@@CRaZyAbOuTYuGi yeah his wife can have a better life in NZ. It's weird why these white people are obsessed by India's poverty. Atleast if they are here they should help the people instead of calling them scammers and then enjoying themselves here
India does not have this concept of 'dual nationality'. So he cannot be a citizen of India and NZ at the same time. That itself is a biggest violation of Indian passport laws.
Well why would you want to immigrate to a western country anyway ? Indians are proud of there culture and country then stay there. We have got to many foreigners here.
@@Ruben355 It's not about why one would. It is about - you get what you give. When they are so rigid about their Visa issues, why do they expect anything different from India?
He participated in CAA protest even as a foreigner He lived in Pakistan for about a year India does not allow dual nationality These may be the reasons
yes he also participated in Election Campaign as his father in law was fighting local election and he took participate in his father in law's rally. Which is against Election Commission rules.
Must have working For another STATE....Hence the Motivation to Discredit India as if those Things do not happen in Western Countries but on secretive scale..... The West and its Exploitative Capitalism are they CHIEF INVENTORS OF CORRUPTION, MAFIA---.AMERICA WAs built UPON IT, SLAVERY AND WHOLE TON OF CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY.... THAT DEFINES ALL EUROPEANS !!!
@@sorryididntnoticedmyname3925 Ofcourse he is, and he is really a good person. I wonder if Indian official's worry of him because he is bringing all the scams to light....
@@sorryididntnoticedmyname3925 bro, we are thankful to him and we adore him. But law remain in its place. No foreigner can participate in domestic politics which he did because his father in law is politician. So
@@sorryididntnoticedmyname3925 It's completely fine to expose Scammers in our country, but being a foreigner and taking part in protests is not (according to our rules). He did that.
@@ducko-chan6285 he is a foreigner. A foreigner is not allowed to participate in India’s internal matters. It doesn’t matter which parties policies he/she is protesting. Be it Congress or bjp.
I feel bad for separation from his wife and family, but in the US, If you misrepresent or overstay your visa, the same thing would happen. Same for Euro countries. Of course there are ways to appeal without being ignored, but this is India and it’s their right. I’m sure there’s more to the story, but break the rules and this is what happens.
The news channel itself gave the conclusion and judgement. It did not even mention the reason that he was involved in anti india govt campaign which is not allowed for foreign citizens to participate in any form of campaign against government in india... So why should he not be blacklisted... Shame on the channel
@@sameerahmad9482 he had to surrender his Indian nationality to do so. But I’m pretty sure he has OCI, which allows him to reside in India while being a Canadian citizen
@@mattiabinnoto8620 i dont think so thats exactly the case....u technically can have dual citizenship if india was the first one ig.....but u cant do stuff like vote etc etc in india the moment u take another citizenship
1) don't run business on tourist visa or marriage visa. 2) freedom of speech & to protest in India is only for Indian citizens. 3) don't play victim card after violation of many.
"Freedom of speech" does NOT exist in India, whenever there is a majority govt in power. If you dare criticize fascist BJP-RSS you'll get slapped with UAPA, NSA etc. And the IT CELL troll army will go after you, make up false stories to discredit you.
@@sultankebab1587 the same many Euro call India a Rape Capital while USA and other developed countries has more Rape cases than India. Don't play Victim Card.
This guy on a tourist visa participated in anti CAA protest. Being a foreign national he is not allowed to have any participation. This goes against the Visa rules. Hence thrown out of the country. As simple as that.
@Abdo Abdo are you on 💊. Like how and why should foreigners have right to participate in Indian protests that to in tourist visa. It's our internal matter they don't have a reason or right to participate in a protest of a foreign country for a bill that doesn't affect them. And in every major Country it's the same. There is nothing related to tolerance here lol. And we didn't made him pay we just stopped him from entering our country again as simple as that.
@@senseigelo195 well he can't have citizenship in India . Because India doesn't offer dual citizenship and. Most other visas give right to protest i guess . So tourist visa is the only visa he can have. But anways even if it wasn't a *tourist* visa it was definitely a case of visa violation.
One side of the story. If you don't abide by the rules you have to face consequences. Why is it that the media will accept this when it's a Western country and not accept when India does the same? Why does New Zealand not grant visa to his wife to visit him there? You can't be a citizen of India and another country (unless you are a Raul Vinci or Antonia Maino)
They banned him for legitimate reasons as India has a right to make and execute immigration rules. Indians abroad have to abide by very strict rules of conduct and it seems foreigners have the privilege of never having to think twice about it. That being said, I don't know how clearly the rules were explained to him that he would have known not to do these things.
Foreigners always want to enter other countries and do as they please and expect no consequences. I know Americans who have complained of the Brazilian fine for over staying their visa. It is a known fact that their is a daily fine for passing the Tourist Visa date, yet they stay, complain (although the dollar is more valuable than the reias) and have to pay.
Non permanent residents can take part in protests in western countries, even tourists but they dont tend to do that. You will only be deported if you participate in a violent protest and are arrested.
@@aasthashubhamsinha1916 Moving the goal posts? did he try to vote? In the USA not only can visa'd people speak against the government and laws but even illegal immigrants can speak against it. The freedom of speech extends to all people in the US borders. If truth is to be a pillar of your culture, you must be willing to listen to words that are painful or uncomfortable.
No wonder I was confused to exactly why they banned him from coming into India. He doesn’t say that it’s his fault because it is. That’s probably why I was so confused watching the video.
Most of people are confused why was he banned . I think that the reasons for him banned form india is that 1 - He visited few area of kashmir which was restricted for any foreign visitors. 2 - you can take part in any protest in india only if you are a citizen of india but he ignored it and took part in CAA protest. You can find him being part of protest and he also once was shown with his report of protest in the news channel . I think the second reason was the exact reason for him getting banned but I think government didn't did right thing it should inform him about the reason of getting banned (Plz ignore grammar mistake )
@@albertoramirez8676 if Indian government banned him because he's showing scammed then government banned all youtuber who shows scammed not only this guy. Think about it.
He is a guest of a country. His involvement in internal politics is unacceptable. A foreign entity in local politics is a violation in most countries. Why he crying?
It's crazy that the comment section is not even supporting him...this guy took down a whole scam call center which made 3 million per year ...we all owe him
Its because the comments are not about his character or his actions are good or bad, it is about the legality of his visa and following the visa norms. I morality it could be fine to kill some one to protect some innocent people but it's not legal. Right .?
Lol are you brain dead...? Just because you do some service for your publicity should all your crimes be forgiven...? Get some life... He has been paid for whatever he did...
He's married to an Indian. In the States, you don't have to become a citizen if married to a citizen BUT you can get a green card and work. Why can't he get a visa change from a tourist visa and have the ability to make money to feed his family? This is bullshit.
@@marvelous_matthew Wake up to the reality! 😀 In the States or any other developed country you don’t get Green Card just because you married a Citizen. There is a separate process through which the Citizen has to sponsor his/her spouse. This application takes long long time and there is good enough chance it can get rejected. So get out of this wrong belief. On the top of that India doesn’t need human resources and talent from outside so India won’t necessarily give work visa to foreigners. Why do you think the US or other developed countries despite having need of talent are stringent in visa policies? Grow up!
I've been a foreign resident of Japan for 15 years, lived in Korea and China and hold an OCI. The rules are the same anywhere; you are also not allowed to partake in protests in the host country as a foreign national. These rules are not India specific, they are everywhere. If India did not disclose reason for blacklisting him they are not obliged to say, the same way as Japan immigration will never tell me the reason if they reject a PR application. This guy is lucky he is white and used that to drum up publicity for his cause. They would have lifted it eventually, he had to be patient and wait and stop painting himself as a victim. White men in Asia are too entitled.
@@Mattdewit You can also do a lot of stupid things in the West. Don't impose your ideology on us. India is surrounded by two hostile neighbours. If our foreigner laws appear draconian, they are so for a reason.
@@nou4605 lol 2? you SURE??? only 2??? maybe 4 maybe 6???? check up on that TWO...none of india's neighbors save for one or two could be 100% trustworthy as allies ....
India doesn't offer dual citizenship. I know it cause i tried to buy British citizenship. and they said in the video that he has both new Zealand and Indian citizenship which can't be true, so there's more to the story.
@@sidhaunt To qualify for settlement and citizenship, one of the following amounts must be invested in the capital of UK-based companies, irrespective of the number of dependants: £2,000,000 to settle in 5 years. £5,000,000 to settle in 3 years. £10,000,000 to settle in 2 years. We tried for temporary shift from India as things aren't going great for our family... but got to know india doesn't offer dual citizenship, once you receive any other countries citizenship, your Indian citizenship will be terminated permanently and to regain it will take 6 years all things considered but not only that... getting American citizenship is a lot easier than getting indian citizenship, trust me on that. 😂 Edit: for complete foreigners it would take 12 years for indian citizenship. Citizenship of India by naturalization can be acquired by a foreigner (not illegal migrant) who is ordinarily resident in India for TWELVE YEARS (throughout the period of twelve months immediately preceding the date of application and for ELEVEN YEARS in the aggregate in the FOURTEEN YEARS preceding the twelve months) and other qualifications as specified in Third Schedule to the Act
I don't think he will give up on his Newzealand Nationality. Her wife will not allow him to do that. 😄 Secondly Newzealand is his Hometown where all his Relatives are living.
He is not a citizen of India as double citizenship is not allowed by virtue of the Indian constitution. Further the right to protest peacefully is under article 19 which is applicable only to Indian nationals.
A foreign national cannot interfere in other country's political affairs. These laws are made to maintain the sovereignity of a country and should be respected He and his wife are pretty well off maybe they should immigrate to NZ and live there.
@@fynamxproduction I have been to Pakistan for 15 days. Every time at immigration they ask about it! Nothing rude but they do ask the purpose of visit.
@@tasneemshaikh4992 To qualify for settlement and citizenship, one of the following amounts must be invested in the capital of UK-based companies, irrespective of the number of dependants: £2,000,000 to settle in 5 years. £5,000,000 to settle in 3 years. £10,000,000 to settle in 2 years.
I am a Zambian RUclipsr and I must say that the kindest people that i have personally have met are Indians, I was very welcomed and treated very well during my 6 month visit there so i don't understand how they can ban this Guy, it means that he did something very very bad to Indians and Indians do not forget
You have to understand that this guy had no ill intent for Indians but was simply pointing out & trying to do something about some massive flaws in their society. You carry on burying your heads in the sand though, Indians seem to be very good at that!
@@pup1008 Stop with ur useless bias talk...He simply broke too many Visa rules & not just one, overstayed despite expiry of visa, visited Nagaland where foreign nationals r not allowed to go without special permit, restricted parts of kashmir, took part in anti-Caa protest despite being foreigner, started his business here, his father-in-law is in politics..so he had biased political agenda too, etc. many more that goes against constitution of India & we can't tolerate that... He even frequently visited pak from india which is alarming to security of india as sovereign nation.
@@trusfratedbunny2215 Yeah you just bury your beautiful head in the sand whilst uploads on Indian scammers hit over 70 million views & the BBC makes primetime documentaries on the problem!
@@pup1008 Talk reasonably here with logic & not blabber whatever s#*t. There were proper reasons to ban him..& he had many. There r tonnes of bloggers in India (both Indian & foreigners) who make vlogs in India..potraying negative sides (smtime even exaggerates) to make others aware or simply for views/attention, but non of them banned by GOI. So, stop blabbering nonsense.
@@trusfratedbunny2215 Regardless of that he was pointing out a flaws in your nation that have made it a near piranha state in the English speaking world + an object of ridicule when these sc*m give themselves Anglo Saxon names scam calling arrogantly not realising that Westerners can pick out their scamming Indian accents within 3 words! I'm telling you this is a *HUGE* deal in the 🇺🇸 & 🇬🇧!
@@aburetik4866 you guys are so hell bent on hating on india. You have freedom of speech there. How do you think politicians are able to tear into each other as much as they want? He’s a tourist so they view it as though he could be trying to interfere with things in a negative way and face no consequences since he doesn’t live there. Imagine if a tourist was trying to influence political opinion in America lmao. It looks weird. You’d definitely react badly if it was a Chinese tourist trying to turn everyone against a party. Like the issue with a tourist protesting is you don’t know what their motives are. You honestly think citizens can’t think for themselves?
Getting a Visa for any country is that country’s prerogative. It is not Karl’s birth right or some human right to demand he be allowed into India. Govt of India owes no explanation to any foreigner about their decision to allow or not allow them into India.
@@ptthunder Before you go on ranting please get familiar with the case in point. He was given a tourist visa but he broke multiple rules of tourist visa despite being warned. Firstly he published a book while being in India, which is a business activity and is forbidden while visiting on a tourist visa. Then he went to POK without permit, then he went to Nagaland without permit. Then he did political campaigning for elections in Haryana which is again forbidden for non-Indian nationals. Then he took part in anti-CAA protests, again violating the rules of a tourist visa. He has broken multiple rules that's why he is being denied a visa. If he wants an Indian citizenship he has to surrender his Newzealand citizenship as India does not allow dual citizenship.
When you're in India, you need to follow the constitution of India. That means you can't protest against the govt. This right is only given to citizen not visa holders.simple as that.
Karl Rock should have gotten his Indian citizenship, before engaging in anti India anti CAA, NRC protests which were organized by foreigners to destabilize India. India just like any other country has the right to refuse foreigners entry if they deem them to be troublemakers or cause problems in the country. If he engaged in an anti US protest organized by foreigners inside the US as a tourist, the US would blacklist him as well. Visiting a foreign country is a privilege and they have the right to refuse anyone they want. Let that be a lesson to all foreigners on a tourist visitor or student visa. Don't cause any problems nor participate in any foreign organized protests if you ever want to come back and revisit the country.
Karl Rock was also misusing his visitor Visa to work and start a business to make money while in India. I know it's a technicality, and the authorities will use it if he pisses them off.
All that attention for 1 Foreign RUclipsr. No Indian Media dared to report on Suffering of 80,000 Hindus that fled Worst Politically sponsored Violence in Decades in West Bengal.
@@lopamudra5398 because violence happens all the time in bengal and bengalis don't want it to stop. Even naxalites originated in bengal. They're called naxalites because they started in a village called naxalbari. Even in small elections, bengalis resort to violence. I've stayed there for 5 years. Political parties are very violent and people very stupid. Let them die. It's what they like to do.
Atleast he's better than most of the Indian content creators. I bet there's no Indian RUclipsr who has enough guts to blow off and make people aware of the scams that go throughout the country that not only foreign tourist but also the Indians themselves who travel to various parts of country.
@@pranavmahajan8458 yeah exactly, his content is so useful not just for foreigners but also for locals. Me and my family were scammed 12k Rupees in Kashmir two months ago by some people running sledges who lied about the distance, skiing and everything else. It's astounding to see the comments who are criticizing Karl content, as if trying to protect the scammers.
Whoever is feeling bad for him if u were in the same position as him ull get kicked out of the country. Pliz revise the Indian constitution once whoever is confused
The news channel itself gave the conclusion and judgement. It did not even mention the reason that he was involved in anti india govt campaign which is not allowed for foreign citizens to participate in any form of campaign against government in india... So why should he not be blacklisted... Shame on the channel
@@noorahmed9947 Like Democracy is doing some good for India? All developed countries in their early days of development were Semi-Dictatorship or Monarchy!
Foreigners can not enter other countries and do as they please and expect to have no consequences. There are rules set in place for a reason. He loves India, it is his passion, so he should have studied and familiarized himself with the laws in India.
@@delmanpronto9374 like the us has gotten better with their laws ? Why didn't the school raids stop in America yet ? Guarantee me the 100% abolishment of racism there , how bout the drive bys that are totally ignored , listen here u hobo , don't judge a country by your cheap and stereotypical mentality and Carl Marks kept criticizing India like he was a part of a bs called BBC ......the problem with Americans is they know how corrupted they are ....they just keep blaming others to cover up their faults ....
@@delmanpronto9374 Not knowing or not understanding the law is not an excuse to disobey the law. I'm not in defence of anyone. I'm just saying. So don't get me wrong.
@@subwaymirdif You're being highly ignorant. India is secular nation. The constitution itself states it. I'm saying this as a Christian who lives in India.
@@venrams India also some good some bad , infact all the country of the world they are good people and bad people . We just have to make the good people win
@@monicarao382 he participated CAA protest, some people are really ignorant if pakistanis or indians do the same in USA or any country, they will get banned
I think karl is at guilty here . He took Indian government for granted . If u are a foreigner according to Indian law u can't take part in any political rally . Also he went to pok without goI permission . Ironically he never showed how serious is the scam in Newzealand but tries to show India in the bad picture by showing scam only on the Indian side .He was inviting trouble . I think its a temporary ban and he should embrace it . India today should get rid of "Gora saab" syndrome
he was covering the protest. his wife was part of the protest who is an indian. Scams in India is terible level. I was in UK and scammers from India would call me as well.If you are worried abt image of India, it doesnt have a good image. Even Indians who live outside India, hate India. Karl loves India. He wants everything good for India. He does point out good and bad things abt India as he sees it. Thats human. Why puish an innocent man like that?
@@arjunkprasad1508 Mr prasad law are equal for everybody it doesn't matter if he is a good person or not he doesn't right to protest in India he should have respected it and stayed away and FYI he tweeted against the CAA lAWS when went for the protests and that proves he or his wife is lying that he tagged along his wife when he had no business to be there
@@Indic_Reactions if law was applied rightly, he should have been given time to rebut all the claims. Instaed he was blacklisted wiwthout telling him what it was for. He comes to know from right wing ppl from twitter. Thats funny isnt it. We, Indians, are the biggest law breakers I have come across. Infact even bigger hypocrites.
He should be eligible for OCI thru marriage after couple of years of continued stay in India, but he shouldn’t be doing business untill he gets OCI. Anyways court is gonna decide on what needs to be done!
Loved this comment :- "Most of people are confused why was he banned . I think that the reasons for him banned form india is that 1 - He visited few area of kashmir which was restricted for any foreign visitors. 2 - you can take part in any protest in india only if you are a citizen of india but he ignored it and took part in farm bill protest. You can find him being part of protest and he also once was shown with his report of protest in the news channel . I think the second reason was the exact reason for him getting banned but I think government didn't did right thing it ghould inform him about the reason of getting banned" Being a fellow Indian it is my appeal :- people should stop spreading unnecessary hate and blind jingoism just because Karl rock's content are appearing negative to their short sightedness and doesn't appeal to blind love . this will only cause damage to democracy instead of making it more appealing to people. and will only reinforce the west's believe in tackling next India's rise to superpower after once China will be kicked out of superpower race because the west is looking for an excuse to make sure they have the monopoly of being a superpower, this is not acceptable to us . Zee News had agreed with Karl rock doing best in his power to keep tourism safe and having a positive vibe in India. and I will blame the tourists instead of Karl for making stereotypes of their own just because they believe they belong to a developed nation or a "morally superior society". I mean westerners will sure hate me if i start to blindly assume them as racists . so we have a moral argument for them, but I don't blame Karl for it ,as if he started this whole out. that being said It is also equally shocking that this news portal told us the half truth and kept other half in Dark. Karl was taking his tour Visa for Granted. exposing Scammers to raise awareness is one thing which we all appreciate . given it has helped me many times in knowing the authenticity of goods and how to deal with traders who practice unethical methods. But Karl was thinking more of himself as a machinery with level equal to that of govt which I don't agree. he advocated himself as a vigilante than exposing merely how it happens and how to keep safe . you don't have to unnecessarily but in Govt functionaries that has got nothing to do with tourist security at all . also he did violate GOI visa rules that clearly state he cannot take participation in India's political protests and most of it , India doesn't allow dual citizenship . and if he had got someone in his reach that had political connections then he is done ,because politics is sick and they can twist any nuts to get you out of race. but Karl rock take this as granted and tried to make himself an upstart in Indian politics and that too being under a foreigner category . dude, you are not Sonia Gandhi . I support getting justice , but not radical vigilantism. and have called on his comments to have him showed that his vigilantism is going too far and he will be facing consequences for it. also he did played a very foul game against some honest passerbys and good traders in our nation, and I disliked and reported his video for that because for his views , he is screwing somebody else's lives. In total, I don't agree with this guy being a saint either and he broke rules , but don't appreciate what happened to him either . but wishing ill wish on someone just because he exposes something, come on fellow Indian brothers and sisters , we can be better than our neighbors and other western countries and uphold our democratic values at all costs . In the end here are four points 1)Please stop being hypocrites. I hate double standards. and I will go any lengths to bring them down 2)Don't paint anything in black and white 3) don't blindly fall in love or hate . 4)do self investigations and keep your moral ground's purity high.
@@VictoryRama Yep unless you had asked the deceitful British🤣 ! But even the British has Changed somewhat.....kicking, screaming and punching along the way. The March of Time.....
He broke many rules . As visitor to india On visa you can’t go to Kashmir, Nagaland , take part in CAA protest which is not allowed for a visitor. Take part in political rally.. of his Father in law and promoted him... think your self can india GUY can have this type of freedom in new zealand that how he has in INDIA..
Yea. Even my relative who was Indian citizen till a few years ago, had to check for permissions when planning to go Andmans. Some areas are restricted and they track foreigner's activities there. And many do come due to political reasons or even espionage.
Who told him to involve in business activities who told him to involve in CAA protest he is on visa he cannot perform such activities then also he is doing,, so actions on him is totally correct
@UCkrvi25VmYB9fESpFLDBMWg he violated his tourist visa conditions, you sh it for brains. What's so hard to understand? He is not allowed to Monetise RUclips videos. He is not allowed to participate in political rallies as a tourist.
@@sujitsharma4346 i agree that he shouldn't have participated in the affairs of the country. But "taking India for granted" is a pretty bold statement. He loves the country and it's culture. He wants others to experience the magnificence of the land with so much to explore. I believe he's doing a great job at that. He helps foreigners by reassuring them that India is not as bad as people think, if you have the knowledge for safe travel and stay. So i don't think he's taking India for granted, i however think he's overdoing it.
@@sujitsharma4346 what about so many Indian travel RUclips making videos in Other countries and channel is monitized? I don't know about attending political events
@@kdouble9618 So Indian government should look at all other countries visa rules now? He clearly went to anti CAA political rallies with his wife and there is a video of that. Ever watched UK border control. Hundreds of Indian students are deported for working more than 20 hours a week.
For me whatever my country is doing for our safety is acceptable and appreciated…Visa issues are big..I am not against New Zealand people but yeah we should respect every country’s rule.
@@stover14 dont give us visas we will not come... Ask your government to do it.... Shameful people... Racist and oppressors... Who newzealanders... U r not even original people.. What have u done to the aboriginals... Where are they now... Where r the original land owners of New Zealand.. Have u cleansed them..... Racist people... We don't need a lecture frm u... Hindus make more than 1 percent of ur population and u dont have one single public holiday for their festivals.... So dont teach us on that...
@@stover14 that’s a stupid fight..if any Indian going against New Zealand law then it will be same for them and why they are coming ask ur government 🙌🏼
@@mandeepsingh-kj6nz You're going to tell me, a maori, what it's like in New Zealand for maori? Your country is still 3rd world bro, humble yourself a little.
Hated him from the first day he entered Nepal. Watched his vlog about drug dealers in Thamel. Why would flocks of hustlers approach a man with a huge camera ? He surely paid those actors .
I feel sorry for him but 'RULES ARE RULES' But I really respect this guy because in one of his videos when he went to Pakistan at a tea shop and thanked the teashop owner by greeting 'JAI HIND' 😂😂😂😂
This is what happen when you support and love India so much as foreigner. See! We should learn this lesson. This guy even hate Pakistan for the sake of India. But still Pakistan accept him roaming the streets while he being evicted. Do not believe snakes
@@cnachopchopnewsagency your comment itself prove you are pak sympthiser ...no need to explain...i can see your love towards a country which enormous amount of t
Well best thing for him to do now is to wait it out, it's a 1 year ban he held on for 280 something days, a few more weeks remaining; it's more like a warning 🙄
Ik man. I get that staying away from your family is very difficult, but let’s be honest, he is exaggerating and also being slightly dishonest. For example, he says that he is not allowed to enter without any explanation even though he violated Indian law by protesting. Also I’m pretty sure he conducted some business activities despite not having a work visa.
that gave him the perfect excuse to vlog in Pakistan and other countries without losing his Indian subscribers. So he is happy. He takes a break from India and the scammers he love so much.
@@eduardochavacano cmon man, have a little empathy. Maybe what you are saying is true, but still staying away from your spouse for extended periods of time is difficult.
Karl Rock thinks that everyone is a scammer if they charge more for a product. Businesses have a right to choose any business model or concept or charge any amount of money for a product. If a company makes mistakes they will disappear from the market. Its plain and simple. That doesnt mean that they are scammers. There is also something called commerical secrets or trade secrets which hinders companies from disclosing certain things. It doesnt mean they are scammers. If tuk-tuk driver charges certain amount of money it his business. Go to some one else or start the same service cheaper. It doesnt mean the tuk-tuk driver is a scammer. He has chosen that business model. The worst thing his done was to go in to hamburgare bar that has a franshise with a Nyzeeland company. Karl Rock without looking for the facts said that the restuarant was illegally coping a business franshise. He also said something stupid about Indian motorcycles that were sold in New Zeeland.
Well he is scamming us when he or his wife claim he had dual citizenship of India and not mentioning how he broke multiple visa rules and thus disrespected law of the land ( visa rules) himself.
@@dixienourmous8156 your right these people wont understand , they speak about thier nation like a god but never try to showcase all the corruption , mob lynching , rape , unemployment , lack of maintenance , malnutrition etc
@@VeritasVortex No it's not. Why should a foriegn national have the right to interfere in internal matters of a country which he may not be fully acquainted with? India's geopolitical circumstances warrant such strict measures or else the country won't be able to develop.
@Mohsin Khan understand the difference everythough i am.not a big fan of bjp , it is clearly mentioned CAA has got nothing to do with Indian Muslims. It is made to help minorities in nearby countries of india like pak and bang and to stop illegal entry of people from neighbouring countries which is a threat to internal security of india.
@Mohsin Khan Read the CAA article first man🤣, to put it simply people who came to India after 2014 residing here will not be considered as citizens.I dont know what this is to do with Indian muslims.
Feeling bad for him and his family. But technically if the violations of visa rules really happened, then it will take time to clear everything. He should be patient. Everything will be fine again.
@@yooloswag1519 A foreign national cannot interfere in other country's political affairs. These laws are made to maintain the sovereignity of a country and should be respected He and his wife are pretty well off maybe they should immigrate to NZ and live there.
I think so, he last time went to pakistan, when we visit pakistan our visa and passport will get expired, So we have to issue new one. Maybe the logic is that
@@MuhammadHamas you people more more afraid of raw , we know which country has less terrorist attack that's show which agency is strong ,,,,,, India has Naxalites and terrorist problems even we are far ahead of you people
People please remember to respect the laws of a country when you visit may it be India or anywhere else. You are a guest when you visit, so its best for everybody if you behave like one. Breaking the law and then putting up a surprise pikachu face wont help you
absolutely. ppl are just stupid when supporting him they treat the laws in india as trash. i think they should surrender their indian citizenship. shameless people are the reason my country is being insulted before the world.
A guy from New Zealand, who visits pakistan, participates in caa protests, marrys an Indian girl with disability(skin disability) says he's trying to expose scammers, I don't think this is something small, he might have something big in his mind.
I get why people are saying that this is fair, but it is such a narrow mentality that if Indians face the same trouble in foreign, foreigners should have to face it too
The fact that media is upholding a case of single person tells you that he is not a common man. More certain sect of media upholds his case, more are chances of him being India's traitor. Otherwise thousands of Visas get rejected accross the world, how many does the media care about? A chief minister of an Indian state was banned entry in the US while no court could prove him guilty. Its unfortunate but thats the way world works.
@@Shrekfan66 LoL!! The joker thinks he is insulting by calling pajeet!! Shows your low level mindset. This guy is already suffering & it seems you are also!! 😂😂😂
India does not allow dual nationality. I am born, raised, and educated in India. When I received German nationality after living and working in Germany for 8 years, I had to surrender Indian passport.
So you can't reapply to get your Indian passport back? For example, my dad was born in Mexico and gave up his passport to become a US citizen. He can reapply to become a Mexican citizen without giving up his US passport since he was born in Mexico.
One of my relatives banned from newzland bec he has done a thing that's against the restriction or rules by the govt when you are in another country you should respect their rules And tell why. You are. Banned in india
☺️ visited Pakistan ( muslim terrorist rogue nation ) ✅ With Pakistani stamp on passport Participated in CAA protest ( which was ment to kick out all jihadi infiltrators from Pakistan and Bengladesh origin ) ✅ And also have two citizenship ✅
It would probably be for the best if he and his wife explain their situation to their family, and just completely forget about India. Then they can start a new life wherever they want
He cannot do all those same things in NZ as he did in India as a foreigner. NZ is very strict with such things they don't expose nor do they alow ppl exposing internal issue's in media opening like this Indian Government has taken a good decision Hum kisise kum nahi👍👍
@@VeritasVortex what I ment is, if he did the same things in NZ he wouldn't be entertained in NZ. Exposing and opposing the activities here in India by making vlogs tat must not be entertained any where in any country
They might have got something fishy coz he stayed in Pakistan about a year, India can't allow as per security purpose, in every country safety comes first
How can you simply exclude one country and deem everyone who lives there "unsafe". You know that if Western countries did that, INDIANs would probably not allowed in...
When you are in a foreign country you should obey that countries law. NZ government would deport any student who works over 20 Hours on their student visa. And that deportation is for life. At least India's ban is only for a year. In my opinion, NZ law should be brought to India.
Scam is every where. Tell me a singel country name where no scam running? Most of you tuber coming India and made money to make video's here and even there subscriber's also most of from India still just for view's they potrate wrong image about country. If India is that much bad and full of scam's then why he been there for so many year's and why still badly want to go. He might not a bad guys but he sould resepect of country constitution and not work against of that. This is not only for India it's for any country.
😂😂😂 so you don't know there is something called immigration laws in every country if you don't follow those you will be thrown out of country. Go and try any country you will be banned there.
He should have thought about all this before joining the protests in Shaheen bagh... The law is the same for everyone!! Besides he used misinformation to gain off of RUclips while defaming our nation!!! He shouldn't be allowed back!!
U sure are not scammers? He never defames your nation. He has proven to show he loved India. He only shows your reality. You scam tourists everywhere. You saying you have the right to charge 5x more because he is white? If you don't want to accept your reality then shut it
@@orpheux8021 it's elementary if you violate the conditions of your visa you're banned! (You cannot plead ignorance of law as a defence in a trial) And there's a considerable portion of people living below the poverty line in India..they try and scam me too...you just have to be wiser! Although They mean well and will never harm you physically, but they would do anything for money!!! I never said that these scammers don't exist...but certainly they don't exist at the level Mr Rock purported them to...it was sensationalism to get more views on his channel...he fails to mention certain facts which clearly show his ulterior motives and clearly he misrepresents facts and has falsified information many a times...I'll give you another example...there are many call centers running "scams" all across the country...many youtubers expose them...however they fail to mention that the source of information to these scammers is usually a person in the very country that the people are being scammed from!!
He loves to be a cry baby when in reality he knows it very well that his actions are not only violative of the law of the land but also in the contravention of its sovereignty and security . You cannot jeopardise the entire nation to protect the civil right of one single individual .
We Indian also have to obey rules and regulations and whatever we do , cry or compliant official doesn't respond easily. So why you need special treatment for you? Jamai ke jese treat kare esa socha tha kya? 🤔
@@sudharshank8256 🤨 what's the logic and sense in your comment? Where I shown "mean mentality"!!! You didn't understand what I said , "everyone treated same according to rules and regulations" we all Indian pay tax , challan , penalty, have to follow government orders , follow constitution so why not a foreigner? He broke the rule of visa and gone against the regulation then why government give him special treatment? USA or any country doesn't give any Indian a special treatment , they as a foreigner must obey the rules set by government otherwise it would be problematic.
I was lucky enough to ride motorcycles with Karl, in Northern Pakistan, and he is one the most genuinely nice people. Everywhere we went he was recognised and he was humble and friendly with everyone
You seem to have have *NO* Idea how India is currently perceived in the West through Indian phone scammers & uploads of the myriad of thefts perpetrated on guests to your land within seconds of walking off a plane & seem to want to shoot the messenger that is giving you a reality check! You are delusional!
He traveled to Dubai and from there to Pakistan. He got banned from India. He broke different visa rules such as doing business on travel visa and visiting parts of Kashmir where foreigners are not allowed. In the name of 26/11, I don't know why he is banned. It's so wrong of Indian govt.
Technically he can’t be a citizen of India, NZ, and the Netherlands. From my understanding, India doesn’t allow dual citizenship.
You are right. Besides, if he was a citizen then he wouldn't need visa to begin with.
Yes
He might bring his wife to NZ better than smelly India
@@CRaZyAbOuTYuGi yeah his wife can have a better life in NZ. It's weird why these white people are obsessed by India's poverty. Atleast if they are here they should help the people instead of calling them scammers and then enjoying themselves here
@@theunderdog690 do agree, he actual can bring his wife family back to NZ and leave there instead stay in
India does not have this concept of 'dual nationality'. So he cannot be a citizen of India and NZ at the same time. That itself is a biggest violation of Indian passport laws.
He has taken part in anti CAA protest
shitty law
@@vd4790 o did he? My respect for him has risen more!🙂
@@kayf_ahmad you should read caa once .
I heard Akshay has Canadian citizenship
Not lying, this is somewhat on the same lines of how Indians are treated while applying for Western Visas.
Well why would you want to immigrate to a western country anyway ? Indians are proud of there culture and country then stay there. We have got to many foreigners here.
@@Ruben355 for a better life maybe? I understand your point but in a globalised world, we can't stop anybody.
@@kalaidoscopez5388 I thought india is the best country in the world? Jay Hind?
@@alecgurney9305 most certainly it is not. But we are trying to improve.
@@Ruben355 It's not about why one would. It is about - you get what you give. When they are so rigid about their Visa issues, why do they expect anything different from India?
He participated in CAA protest even as a foreigner
He lived in Pakistan for about a year
India does not allow dual nationality
These may be the reasons
yes he also participated in Election Campaign as his father in law was fighting local election and he took participate in his father in law's rally. Which is against Election Commission rules.
Must have working For another STATE....Hence the Motivation to Discredit India as if those Things do not happen in Western Countries but on secretive scale.....
The West and its Exploitative Capitalism are they CHIEF INVENTORS OF CORRUPTION, MAFIA---.AMERICA WAs built UPON IT, SLAVERY AND WHOLE TON OF CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY....
THAT DEFINES ALL EUROPEANS !!!
He lived in Pakistan does that make him dodgy??
@@silkygrover2635 yes
@@silkygrover2635 yes nobody should visit terrorist countries
If you violate visa rules, action remains the same in almost all countries
Isn't he is the one who shows scammers in india
@@sorryididntnoticedmyname3925 Ofcourse he is, and he is really a good person. I wonder if Indian official's worry of him because he is bringing all the scams to light....
@@justice410 lol... u brainwashed dammn..
@@sorryididntnoticedmyname3925 bro, we are thankful to him and we adore him.
But law remain in its place.
No foreigner can participate in domestic politics which he did because his father in law is politician.
So
@@sorryididntnoticedmyname3925 It's completely fine to expose Scammers in our country, but being a foreigner and taking part in protests is not (according to our rules). He did that.
Participating in an anti CAA protest was the last nail in the coffin of his stay in India.
yes
how is protesting against the law now ? wtf
This is clear example of no democracy in India,now a person can't even protest in this nation
@@ducko-chan6285 he is a foreigner. A foreigner is not allowed to participate in India’s internal matters. It doesn’t matter which parties policies he/she is protesting. Be it Congress or bjp.
@@deal2683 he deserves it
I feel bad for separation from his wife and family, but in the US, If you misrepresent or overstay your visa, the same thing would happen. Same for Euro countries. Of course there are ways to appeal without being ignored, but this is India and it’s their right. I’m sure there’s more to the story, but break the rules and this is what happens.
The news channel itself gave the conclusion and judgement. It did not even mention the reason that he was involved in anti india govt campaign which is not allowed for foreign citizens to participate in any form of campaign against government in india... So why should he not be blacklisted... Shame on the channel
@@mandeepsingh-kj6nz Aha! Thank you for putting the matter into specific perspective.
Indeed, there is something stinking behind this whining fox.
@@TomTimes5 500, 000!!!?? Give me whatever you're smoking, I want to be delusional too.
@@TomTimes5 any proof or a jingo 🤔🤔🤔
I guess they banned him because they mistook him for PewDiePie
2:09 India never allows anyone to have dual citizenship.Please check before mentioning in the video
If I am not wrong Akshay kumar has canadian citizenship.
Alteast they can give him visa to visit india without citizenship
Then why they dont grant him Visa?
@@sameerahmad9482 he had to surrender his Indian nationality to do so. But I’m pretty sure he has OCI, which allows him to reside in India while being a Canadian citizen
@@mattiabinnoto8620 i dont think so thats exactly the case....u technically can have dual citizenship if india was the first one ig.....but u cant do stuff like vote etc etc in india the moment u take another citizenship
1) don't run business on tourist visa or marriage visa.
2) freedom of speech & to protest in India is only for Indian citizens.
3) don't play victim card after violation of many.
@acooknamed_Rishi he wrote and published a book in India. That's pretty much business.
Yeah but if we did it here in europe everyone would be crying how racist we are, what a joke, and i dont care about your history, iam not british.
"Freedom of speech" does NOT exist in India, whenever there is a majority govt in power. If you dare criticize fascist BJP-RSS you'll get slapped with UAPA, NSA etc. And the IT CELL troll army will go after you, make up false stories to discredit you.
@@bobinpune you just spoke against the government lol. And how did this become an issue of freedom of speech?
@@sultankebab1587 the same many Euro call India a Rape Capital while USA and other developed countries has more Rape cases than India. Don't play Victim Card.
This guy on a tourist visa participated in anti CAA protest. Being a foreign national he is not allowed to have any participation. This goes against the Visa rules. Hence thrown out of the country. As simple as that.
@Abdo Abdo are you on 💊. Like how and why should foreigners have right to participate in Indian protests that to in tourist visa.
It's our internal matter they don't have a reason or right to participate in a protest of a foreign country for a bill that doesn't affect them.
And in every major Country it's the same.
There is nothing related to tolerance here lol.
And we didn't made him pay we just stopped him from entering our country again as simple as that.
tourist visa?you sure about that?
I mean it's a democratic country right? What you are saying doesn't sound democratic at all
@@senseigelo195 well he can't have citizenship in India . Because India doesn't offer dual citizenship and. Most other visas give right to protest i guess . So tourist visa is the only visa he can have. But anways even if it wasn't a *tourist* visa it was definitely a case of visa violation.
@@liambmn Indian Democracy is for freedom of Indians why should we let a foreigner participate in a protest not related to him
it's not party lol
Sorry India, I'm leaving from you. We'll be back when you're better.
One side of the story. If you don't abide by the rules you have to face consequences. Why is it that the media will accept this when it's a Western country and not accept when India does the same?
Why does New Zealand not grant visa to his wife to visit him there?
You can't be a citizen of India and another country (unless you are a Raul Vinci or Antonia Maino)
Exactly, The hue and cry are only when it is India. NOW, WHO IS THE REAL RACIST AND FASCIST?
@@lopamudra5398 on no not ebil waycism :'((( cry about it
@@lopamudra5398 India government is corrupt asf
Has the western media not realized that the colonial period is over?
Because, unlike India, the New Zealand government has issued a travel ban to 1.3 billion Indians due to covid.
They banned him for legitimate reasons as India has a right to make and execute immigration rules. Indians abroad have to abide by very strict rules of conduct and it seems foreigners have the privilege of never having to think twice about it. That being said, I don't know how clearly the rules were explained to him that he would have known not to do these things.
Foreigners always want to enter other countries and do as they please and expect no consequences. I know Americans who have complained of the Brazilian fine for over staying their visa. It is a known fact that their is a daily fine for passing the Tourist Visa date, yet they stay, complain (although the dollar is more valuable than the reias) and have to pay.
He was involved in protest and shouting slogans against India, this is not allowed on tourist visa.
What cos he went to Pakistan u mean?
@@haychkay3590 look at his videos made in porkistan and India, you will understand the propaganda.
@@GajarajKalburgi do you know how many Indians are their in America who does the same thing??
If an Indian cannot speak against USA or UK either with a permanent visa or tourist visa , the same applies to foreigners too.
They can do what they like here in the UK. Foreigners can take part in any protest against the government. Not sure where u got your info from
Non permanent residents can take part in protests in western countries, even tourists but they dont tend to do that. You will only be deported if you participate in a violent protest and are arrested.
@@haychkay3590 do they also vote on tourist visa? Can they influence the the bills passed by the current government of USA on tourist visa?
@@haychkay3590 *vote
@@aasthashubhamsinha1916 Moving the goal posts? did he try to vote? In the USA not only can visa'd people speak against the government and laws but even illegal immigrants can speak against it. The freedom of speech extends to all people in the US borders. If truth is to be a pillar of your culture, you must be willing to listen to words that are painful or uncomfortable.
No wonder I was confused to exactly why they banned him from coming into India. He doesn’t say that it’s his fault because it is. That’s probably why I was so confused watching the video.
nahh you are just a confused person in general lmfao
@@Tdotttttt Actually, I'm not. ROTFLMAO!!
He had both citizenships, i.e., of India and NZ. India doesn't allow dual citizenship.
Exactly ikr!
Most of people are confused why was he banned . I think that the reasons for him banned form india is that
1 - He visited few area of kashmir which was restricted for any foreign visitors.
2 - you can take part in any protest in india only if you are a citizen of india but he ignored it and took part in CAA protest. You can find him being part of protest and he also once was shown with his report of protest in the news channel .
I think the second reason was the exact reason for him getting banned but I think government didn't did right thing it should inform him about the reason of getting banned
(Plz ignore grammar mistake )
Yeah might be this could have been the reason
3- he exposed to the world how scammy 🇮🇳 is
@@albertoramirez8676 no kid....the whole world do same thing...posses same behaviour.....
@@albertoramirez8676 if Indian government banned him because he's showing scammed then government banned all youtuber who shows scammed not only this guy. Think about it.
@@brownboy5229 you are wrong, I don’t get 10 calls a day from other country trying to scam me or my family
He is a guest of a country. His involvement in internal politics is unacceptable. A foreign entity in local politics is a violation in most countries. Why he crying?
yea i mean this usually happens in all countries to some degree. Especially in USA.
lndia is a country without freedom of speech. Why ban this wonderful guy who is only trying to tell truth?
@@aburetik4866 Bro Atleast Do Some Research
@@aburetik4866 he is a foreigner.
@@Aayussh-fl5sz lndia banned TikTok. Is that a violation of freedom of speech?
Donno whether he is right or wrong but he said jai hind in Pakistan that need guts bravo
Not guts in Pakistan we are not extremist like u
He breaked several visa norms not one but many, no one can play with the rule of the land even if you love the nation you have to respect the rules.
@Muhammad Ibrahim bad people are everywhere, in Pakistan too and india too. 😁
Doesnt change anything. He violated Visa rules. You violate visa rules in Other country They will call you Dirty InD**an and kick you out.
He also participated in political programs which also violates the law! A lot of people have been blacklisted for this!
The real reason they blacklisted him is because he made scam safety videos, and according to them it made India “known for its scams”.
the shoeshine scam one comes to mind.
more jokes plzz
@@peak_911 Stop calling my house and sending me emails please.
Hey look this. Some 12 year old made a cliche joke and slept well thinking he was funny 😄
It's crazy that the comment section is not even supporting him...this guy took down a whole scam call center which made 3 million per year ...we all owe him
Its because the comments are not about his character or his actions are good or bad, it is about the legality of his visa and following the visa norms.
I morality it could be fine to kill some one to protect some innocent people but it's not legal. Right .?
yeah but as a tourist he has no rights to do this
@@GP-hr2md its illegal to poo on the streets.
@@quattro4468 if you know law of your country why you doing then. Any way I am sure you don't need a visa for Poo in your country.🤣
Lol are you brain dead...?
Just because you do some service for your publicity should all your crimes be forgiven...?
Get some life... He has been paid for whatever he did...
How the hell can someone have nationality of India and New Zealand together?
Indian constitution doesn’t allow this.
Its allowed
@@HansiNaval Please check Constitution of India Part 2, Article 9.
@@HansiNaval Not allowed. OCI is not citizenship.
He's married to an Indian. In the States, you don't have to become a citizen if married to a citizen BUT you can get a green card and work. Why can't he get a visa change from a tourist visa and have the ability to make money to feed his family? This is bullshit.
@@marvelous_matthew Wake up to the reality! 😀 In the States or any other developed country you don’t get Green Card just because you married a Citizen. There is a separate process through which the Citizen has to sponsor his/her spouse. This application takes long long time and there is good enough chance it can get rejected. So get out of this wrong belief. On the top of that India doesn’t need human resources and talent from outside so India won’t necessarily give work visa to foreigners. Why do you think the US or other developed countries despite having need of talent are stringent in visa policies? Grow up!
I've been a foreign resident of Japan for 15 years, lived in Korea and China and hold an OCI. The rules are the same anywhere; you are also not allowed to partake in protests in the host country as a foreign national. These rules are not India specific, they are everywhere. If India did not disclose reason for blacklisting him they are not obliged to say, the same way as Japan immigration will never tell me the reason if they reject a PR application. This guy is lucky he is white and used that to drum up publicity for his cause. They would have lifted it eventually, he had to be patient and wait and stop painting himself as a victim. White men in Asia are too entitled.
You can take part in protests in many western countries as a foreing national. The ban is not specific to India but its not universal by far.
@@Mattdewit You can also do a lot of stupid things in the West. Don't impose your ideology on us. India is surrounded by two hostile neighbours. If our foreigner laws appear draconian, they are so for a reason.
Well said
@@nou4605 "the laws against protesting are there for a reason" spoken like a true facist
@@nou4605 lol 2? you SURE??? only 2??? maybe 4 maybe 6???? check up on that TWO...none of india's neighbors save for one or two could be 100% trustworthy as allies ....
He was exposing Indian Scammers and got in trouble 😂😂
He is a scammer himself.
Frauds get a lot of money these days to instigate civil war in India
Lol, 😂🤣 the fantasy world you live in must me ammazing...
Absltly
He is a fraud himself. That's why he is good at identifying people of his kind.
If I recall right, he makes anti Indian remarks and that why I stopped viewing his content. You don't get in trouble for exposing scammers, lol.
A subtle warning that rules are to be followed, and not to be taken for granted as its Indian.
One of his video,, being a foreigner he participated in CAA protect.
Sorry, what exactly is this CAA protest?
@NightMare oh ok thanks
He violated the law/ rule by doing so as a tourist.
@@zimmbdo1965 ye let usa ban indian students who also used to protest (InDiAn Forigens)
@@Military_combater He did soo many things not just participated in the protest ,ppl who get blacklisted hv violated many laws not just one .
India doesn't offer dual citizenship. I know it cause i tried to buy British citizenship. and they said in the video that he has both new Zealand and Indian citizenship which can't be true, so there's more to the story.
They're showing what's in his wife's petition at Delhi HC.
You tried to buy British citizenship 😂😂?
@@sidhaunt To qualify for settlement and citizenship, one of the following amounts must be invested in the capital of UK-based companies, irrespective of the number of dependants: £2,000,000 to settle in 5 years. £5,000,000 to settle in 3 years. £10,000,000 to settle in 2 years. We tried for temporary shift from India as things aren't going great for our family... but got to know india doesn't offer dual citizenship, once you receive any other countries citizenship, your Indian citizenship will be terminated permanently and to regain it will take 6 years all things considered but not only that... getting American citizenship is a lot easier than getting indian citizenship, trust me on that. 😂
Edit: for complete foreigners it would take 12 years for indian citizenship. Citizenship of India by naturalization can be acquired by a foreigner (not illegal migrant) who is ordinarily resident in India for TWELVE YEARS (throughout the period of twelve months immediately preceding the date of application and for ELEVEN YEARS in the aggregate in the FOURTEEN YEARS preceding the twelve months) and other qualifications as specified in Third Schedule to the Act
@@Sai_2346 oh thanks for the insight. When you say buy, it sounded more like a backdoor buy out, but yeah got your point.
@@anonymjr2658 well, maybe but they are literally selling their citizenship. 😂🙂
Would he be removed from the blacklist if he was willing to give up his NZ citizenship and attempt to get an Indian one?
I don't think he will give up on his Newzealand Nationality. Her wife will not allow him to do that. 😄 Secondly Newzealand is his Hometown where all his Relatives are living.
He is not a citizen of India as double citizenship is not allowed by virtue of the Indian constitution. Further the right to protest peacefully is under article 19 which is applicable only to Indian nationals.
A foreign national cannot interfere in other country's political affairs. These laws are made to maintain the sovereignity of a country and should be respected He and his wife are pretty well off maybe they should immigrate to NZ and live there.
The fact that he spent an entire YEAR in Pakistan would probably be the reason in of concern
He is been exposing a lot of tourism scams in India is the biggest reason. He was only in Pakistan twice for few days.
@@fynamxproduction what has govt to do with the local scammers? There must be some visa violation issues.
@@fynamxproduction I have been to Pakistan for 15 days. Every time at immigration they ask about it! Nothing rude but they do ask the purpose of visit.
Why should that matter? Can't a foreigner visit Pakistan as well as India?
If tourists can't visit both countries then you're going to limit the number of tourists vising India
2:09 He can't have nationality of both New Zealand and India as stated here. India does not permit dual citizenship.
exactly! I tried buying British citizenship and I was denied stating that I must be prepared to let go of Indian citizenship permanently.
True but I don't like this law of not being able to have dual citizenship
@@Sai_2346 How can you buy British citizenship?
I'm curious..
@@tasneemshaikh4992 To qualify for settlement and citizenship, one of the following amounts must be invested in the capital of UK-based companies, irrespective of the number of dependants: £2,000,000 to settle in 5 years. £5,000,000 to settle in 3 years. £10,000,000 to settle in 2 years.
New Zealand and natherland
I am a Zambian RUclipsr and I must say that the kindest people that i have personally have met are Indians, I was very welcomed and treated very well during my 6 month visit there so i don't understand how they can ban this Guy, it means that he did something very very bad to Indians and Indians do not forget
You have to understand that this guy had no ill intent for Indians but was simply pointing out & trying to do something about some massive flaws in their society.
You carry on burying your heads in the sand though, Indians seem to be very good at that!
@@pup1008 Stop with ur useless bias talk...He simply broke too many Visa rules & not just one, overstayed despite expiry of visa, visited Nagaland where foreign nationals r not allowed to go without special permit, restricted parts of kashmir, took part in anti-Caa protest despite being foreigner, started his business here, his father-in-law is in politics..so he had biased political agenda too, etc. many more that goes against constitution of India & we can't tolerate that...
He even frequently visited pak from india which is alarming to security of india as sovereign nation.
@@trusfratedbunny2215
Yeah you just bury your beautiful head in the sand whilst uploads on Indian scammers hit over 70 million views & the BBC makes primetime documentaries on the problem!
@@pup1008 Talk reasonably here with logic & not blabber whatever s#*t. There were proper reasons to ban him..& he had many. There r tonnes of bloggers in India (both Indian & foreigners) who make vlogs in India..potraying negative sides (smtime even exaggerates) to make others aware or simply for views/attention, but non of them banned by GOI. So, stop blabbering nonsense.
@@trusfratedbunny2215
Regardless of that he was pointing out a flaws in your nation that have made it a near piranha state in the English speaking world + an object of ridicule when these sc*m give themselves Anglo Saxon names scam calling arrogantly not realising that Westerners can pick out their scamming Indian accents within 3 words!
I'm telling you this is a *HUGE* deal in the 🇺🇸 & 🇬🇧!
Many of these youtube guys are treading a very thin line between tourism and journalism or activism. Of course they will ban you eventually.
lndia is a country without freedom of speech.
@@aburetik4866 i see you everywhere You Hate India am i right
@@aburetik4866 tourist can't participate in India's internal politics.
@@aburetik4866 there is Freedom of speech in india 🇮🇳
@@aburetik4866 you guys are so hell bent on hating on india. You have freedom of speech there. How do you think politicians are able to tear into each other as much as they want? He’s a tourist so they view it as though he could be trying to interfere with things in a negative way and face no consequences since he doesn’t live there. Imagine if a tourist was trying to influence political opinion in America lmao. It looks weird. You’d definitely react badly if it was a Chinese tourist trying to turn everyone against a party. Like the issue with a tourist protesting is you don’t know what their motives are. You honestly think citizens can’t think for themselves?
Getting a Visa for any country is that country’s prerogative. It is not Karl’s birth right or some human right to demand he be allowed into India.
Govt of India owes no explanation to any foreigner about their decision to allow or not allow them into India.
Instead of india fit north Korea into your sentence, and see how perfectly it matches
spoken like a true fascist from a country that is not actually democratic or secular.
@@ptthunder yep India is a fascist country I agree
@@ptthunder Before you go on ranting please get familiar with the case in point. He was given a tourist visa but he broke multiple rules of tourist visa despite being warned. Firstly he published a book while being in India, which is a business activity and is forbidden while visiting on a tourist visa. Then he went to POK without permit, then he went to Nagaland without permit. Then he did political campaigning for elections in Haryana which is again forbidden for non-Indian nationals. Then he took part in anti-CAA protests, again violating the rules of a tourist visa. He has broken multiple rules that's why he is being denied a visa. If he wants an Indian citizenship he has to surrender his Newzealand citizenship as India does not allow dual citizenship.
@@jasonjason5821 western education really sucks
When you're in India, you need to follow the constitution of India. That means you can't protest against the govt. This right is only given to citizen not visa holders.simple as that.
Looks like we got us a bootlicker
@@underground_americana bootlicker to the constitution of India? Sure. I think everyone needs to be the bootlicker to constitution.
he did not protest. So why he is stopped.?
@@shankysays when something is wrong, you gotta stand up against it. If protesting against the government is banned, you've got an awful government
Is RSS following the constitution?
Karl Rock should have gotten his Indian citizenship, before engaging in anti India anti CAA, NRC protests which were organized by foreigners to destabilize India.
India just like any other country has the right to refuse foreigners entry if they deem them to be troublemakers or cause problems in the country.
If he engaged in an anti US protest organized by foreigners inside the US as a tourist, the US would blacklist him as well.
Visiting a foreign country is a privilege and they have the right to refuse anyone they want.
Let that be a lesson to all foreigners on a tourist visitor or student visa. Don't cause any problems nor participate in any foreign organized protests if you ever want to come back and revisit the country.
Rule of thumb:
Don't protest in foreign countries and always be grateful if they allow you in.
Karl Rock was also misusing his visitor Visa to work and start a business to make money while in India. I know it's a technicality, and the authorities will use it if he pisses them off.
India shouldn't let him enter in the country. It is right decision.
All that attention for 1 Foreign RUclipsr.
No Indian Media dared to report on Suffering of 80,000 Hindus that fled Worst Politically sponsored Violence in Decades in West Bengal.
ehh what, who fled?
That's bengal, they like violence. Get over it.
@@CosmicValkyrie YOU GET OVER THAT KARL. WHY SHOULD WE GET OVER 80,000 Pople suffering?
@@lopamudra5398 because violence happens all the time in bengal and bengalis don't want it to stop. Even naxalites originated in bengal. They're called naxalites because they started in a village called naxalbari. Even in small elections, bengalis resort to violence. I've stayed there for 5 years. Political parties are very violent and people very stupid. Let them die. It's what they like to do.
@CosmicValkyrie, SHUT UP with your anti bengal propaganda.
No point of playing victim card, he got what he deserves.
Because he showed too much scammers I india
Atleast he's better than most of the Indian content creators. I bet there's no Indian RUclipsr who has enough guts to blow off and make people aware of the scams that go throughout the country that not only foreign tourist but also the Indians themselves who travel to various parts of country.
@@pranavmahajan8458 yeah exactly, his content is so useful not just for foreigners but also for locals. Me and my family were scammed 12k Rupees in Kashmir two months ago by some people running sledges who lied about the distance, skiing and everything else. It's astounding to see the comments who are criticizing Karl content, as if trying to protect the scammers.
Whoever is feeling bad for him if u were in the same position as him ull get kicked out of the country. Pliz revise the Indian constitution once whoever is confused
The news channel itself gave the conclusion and judgement. It did not even mention the reason that he was involved in anti india govt campaign which is not allowed for foreign citizens to participate in any form of campaign against government in india... So why should he not be blacklisted... Shame on the channel
So it means India is under dictatorship
@@noorahmed9947 Like Democracy is doing some good for India? All developed countries in their early days of development were Semi-Dictatorship or Monarchy!
Agree
I think people are more worried that this ban potentially represents the government being complicit with scam call centers.
Foreigners can not enter other countries and do as they please and expect to have no consequences. There are rules set in place for a reason. He loves India, it is his passion, so he should have studied and familiarized himself with the laws in India.
now that's an ordeal. indian laws are notorious for their complexity and poor drafting.
He should hire an attorney that specializes in these matters.
@@delmanpronto9374 like the us has gotten better with their laws ? Why didn't the school raids stop in America yet ? Guarantee me the 100% abolishment of racism there , how bout the drive bys that are totally ignored , listen here u hobo , don't judge a country by your cheap and stereotypical mentality and Carl Marks kept criticizing India like he was a part of a bs called BBC ......the problem with Americans is they know how corrupted they are ....they just keep blaming others to cover up their faults ....
@@delmanpronto9374 Not knowing or not understanding the law is not an excuse to disobey the law. I'm not in defence of anyone. I'm just saying. So don't get me wrong.
@@HypnosisBear i'm not saying it is either. i'm talking about how incomprehensible the laws are in india even to an educated individual.
All sympathies with Karl but it is impossible to hold another citizenship whilst being indian.
And probably belonging to another religion than Hinduism.
@Haung Jo We Indians and Indian Govt Decide that, not any XYZ.
@@subwaymirdif what it has to even do with religion? this isn't any middle east or catholic country.
@@subwaymirdif You're being highly ignorant. India is secular nation. The constitution itself states it. I'm saying this as a Christian who lives in India.
@@subwaymirdif You're either not Indian, or you're ignorant about your own country
He got ban because he went to Pakistan and talk about how friendly and good people they actually are .
Yeah👍😂
I don't think that's the reason though some people would like to believe that.. F.Y.I he still makes Pakistan videos
I think so too
@@venrams India also some good some bad , infact all the country of the world they are good people and bad people .
We just have to make the good people win
@@monicarao382 he participated CAA protest, some people are really ignorant
if pakistanis or indians do the same in USA or any country, they will get banned
I think karl is at guilty here . He took Indian government for granted . If u are a foreigner according to Indian law u can't take part in any political rally . Also he went to pok without goI permission . Ironically he never showed how serious is the scam in Newzealand but tries to show India in the bad picture by showing scam only on the Indian side .He was inviting trouble . I think its a temporary ban and he should embrace it . India today should get rid of "Gora saab" syndrome
he was covering the protest. his wife was part of the protest who is an indian. Scams in India is terible level. I was in UK and scammers from India would call me as well.If you are worried abt image of India, it doesnt have a good image. Even Indians who live outside India, hate India. Karl loves India. He wants everything good for India. He does point out good and bad things abt India as he sees it. Thats human. Why puish an innocent man like that?
@@arjunkprasad1508 Mr prasad law are equal for everybody it doesn't matter if he is a good person or not he doesn't right to protest in India he should have respected it and stayed away and FYI he tweeted against the CAA lAWS when went for the protests and that proves he or his wife is lying that he tagged along his wife when he had no business to be there
@@Indic_Reactions if law was applied rightly, he should have been given time to rebut all the claims. Instaed he was blacklisted wiwthout telling him what it was for. He comes to know from right wing ppl from twitter. Thats funny isnt it. We, Indians, are the biggest law breakers I have come across. Infact even bigger hypocrites.
@@arjunkprasad1508 Time for what??
@@vikashpatel1475 to rebut claims by govt. That's the actual process. You don't simply blacklist a person like that. Against the law to do so.
The actual thing is he is frequent visitor of Pakistan, he was also involved in anti CAA protest... hence he was kicked out..
He should be eligible for OCI thru marriage after couple of years of continued stay in India, but he shouldn’t be doing business untill he gets OCI. Anyways court is gonna decide on what needs to be done!
I have oci
I guess he’s back to India, you can check her channel how he got his visa back and be with his family and friends in India.
Loved this comment :-
"Most of people are confused why was he banned . I think that the reasons for him banned form india is that
1 - He visited few area of kashmir which was restricted for any foreign visitors.
2 - you can take part in any protest in india only if you are a citizen of india but he ignored it and took part in farm bill protest. You can find him being part of protest and he also once was shown with his report of protest in the news channel .
I think the second reason was the exact reason for him getting banned but I think government didn't did right thing it ghould inform him about the reason of getting banned"
Being a fellow Indian it is my appeal :-
people should stop spreading unnecessary hate and blind jingoism just because Karl rock's content are appearing negative to their short sightedness and doesn't appeal to blind love . this will only cause damage to democracy instead of making it more appealing to people. and will only reinforce the west's believe in tackling next India's rise to superpower after once China will be kicked out of superpower race because the west is looking for an excuse to make sure they have the monopoly of being a superpower, this is not acceptable to us . Zee News had agreed with Karl rock doing best in his power to keep tourism safe and having a positive vibe in India. and I will blame the tourists instead of Karl for making stereotypes of their own just because they believe they belong to a developed nation or a "morally superior society". I mean westerners will sure hate me if i start to blindly assume them as racists . so we have a moral argument for them, but I don't blame Karl for it ,as if he started this whole out.
that being said It is also equally shocking that this news portal told us the half truth and kept other half in Dark. Karl was taking his tour Visa for Granted. exposing Scammers to raise awareness is one thing which we all appreciate . given it has helped me many times in knowing the authenticity of goods and how to deal with traders who practice unethical methods. But Karl was thinking more of himself as a machinery with level equal to that of govt which I don't agree. he advocated himself as a vigilante than exposing merely how it happens and how to keep safe . you don't have to unnecessarily but in Govt functionaries that has got nothing to do with tourist security at all . also he did violate GOI visa rules that clearly state he cannot take participation in India's political protests and most of it , India doesn't allow dual citizenship . and if he had got someone in his reach that had political connections then he is done ,because politics is sick and they can twist any nuts to get you out of race. but Karl rock take this as granted and tried to make himself an upstart in Indian politics and that too being under a foreigner category . dude, you are not Sonia Gandhi . I support getting justice , but not radical vigilantism. and have called on his comments to have him showed that his vigilantism is going too far and he will be facing consequences for it. also he did played a very foul game against some honest passerbys and good traders in our nation, and I disliked and reported his video for that because for his views , he is screwing somebody else's lives.
In total, I don't agree with this guy being a saint either and he broke rules , but don't appreciate what happened to him either . but wishing ill wish on someone just because he exposes something, come on fellow Indian brothers and sisters , we can be better than our neighbors and other western countries and uphold our democratic values at all costs .
In the end here are four points
1)Please stop being hypocrites. I hate double standards. and I will go any lengths to bring them down
2)Don't paint anything in black and white
3) don't blindly fall in love or hate .
4)do self investigations and keep your moral ground's purity high.
Please try to explain the HATE PART TO PAKISTAN INSTEAD OF LECTURING 20000+ YEARS OF DEMOCRATIC INDIA !!!!
@@VictoryRama Yep unless you had asked the deceitful British🤣 ! But even the British has Changed somewhat.....kicking, screaming and punching along the way.
The March of Time.....
India don’t allowed dual citizenship
Conversation end here
its time for indians who live in the west and in other countries to go back to india.
@u nd me! You need to learn how to speak English correctly because what you have just said does not make grammatical sense. Try again.
@@mrexpress8002 they are living their as their respective nationality. Kamala harris is American. not Indian.
He broke many rules . As visitor to india
On visa you can’t go to Kashmir, Nagaland , take part in CAA protest which is not allowed for a visitor. Take part in political rally.. of his Father in law and promoted him...
think your self can india GUY can have this type of freedom in new zealand that how he has in INDIA..
Nagaland ka pata nahi, lekin foreigner logo ko Kashmir Jane ke liye special permit lena parta hai...aur wo permit check post me dikhana parta hai
@@truebangladeshi401 wahi tho ab bata wo POK gaya tha aur abhi pakistan me hai..wo kashmir apni biwi ke sath gaya tha.
yes because new zealand is actually free actually secular and actually democratic....not just bullshit fake pretending to be, like india.
As if Indians follow the rules in Thier own country.
Yea. Even my relative who was Indian citizen till a few years ago, had to check for permissions when planning to go Andmans. Some areas are restricted and they track foreigner's activities there. And many do come due to political reasons or even espionage.
I really like the guy I look at him as a brother he made me like India 🇮🇳 ❤
Who told him to involve in business activities who told him to involve in CAA protest he is on visa he cannot perform such activities then also he is doing,, so actions on him is totally correct
@Abdulraheem Badayuni bro , CAA protests .
@Abdulraheem Badayuni India doesn't allows foreigners to protest .
Someone Should Stop Faking It!! It’s a lesson for everyone to Stop Taking India For Granted!!
And explain to me how he's taking India for granted if you don't mind
@UCkrvi25VmYB9fESpFLDBMWg he violated his tourist visa conditions, you sh it for brains. What's so hard to understand? He is not allowed to Monetise RUclips videos. He is not allowed to participate in political rallies as a tourist.
@@sujitsharma4346 i agree that he shouldn't have participated in the affairs of the country. But "taking India for granted" is a pretty bold statement. He loves the country and it's culture. He wants others to experience the magnificence of the land with so much to explore. I believe he's doing a great job at that. He helps foreigners by reassuring them that India is not as bad as people think, if you have the knowledge for safe travel and stay. So i don't think he's taking India for granted, i however think he's overdoing it.
@@sujitsharma4346 what about so many Indian travel RUclips making videos in Other countries and channel is monitized? I don't know about attending political events
@@kdouble9618 So Indian government should look at all other countries visa rules now? He clearly went to anti CAA political rallies with his wife and there is a video of that. Ever watched UK border control. Hundreds of Indian students are deported for working more than 20 hours a week.
For me whatever my country is doing for our safety is acceptable and appreciated…Visa issues are big..I am not against New Zealand people but yeah we should respect every country’s rule.
Then how about you indians stop coming to New Zealand then?
@@stover14 dont give us visas we will not come... Ask your government to do it.... Shameful people... Racist and oppressors... Who newzealanders... U r not even original people.. What have u done to the aboriginals... Where are they now... Where r the original land owners of New Zealand.. Have u cleansed them..... Racist people... We don't need a lecture frm u... Hindus make more than 1 percent of ur population and u dont have one single public holiday for their festivals.... So dont teach us on that...
@@stover14 that’s a stupid fight..if any Indian going against New Zealand law then it will be same for them and why they are coming ask ur government 🙌🏼
@@mandeepsingh-kj6nz Hahaahahhaa I'm Maori you idiot.
@@mandeepsingh-kj6nz You're going to tell me, a maori, what it's like in New Zealand for maori? Your country is still 3rd world bro, humble yourself a little.
You have to give up NZ citizenship in order to get indian citizenship
I never liked this MOFU, great job by Indian government!
His wife lives in India. He has a life and duties to attend there. Whether you like him or not, he has to return.
Hated him from the first day he entered Nepal. Watched his vlog about drug dealers
in Thamel. Why would flocks of hustlers approach a man with a huge camera ? He surely paid those actors .
Your wrong he was trying to make people to not make same mistakes
I feel sorry for him but 'RULES ARE RULES'
But I really respect this guy because in one of his videos when he went to Pakistan at a tea shop and thanked the teashop owner by greeting 'JAI HIND'
😂😂😂😂
This is what happen when you support and love India so much as foreigner. See! We should learn this lesson. This guy even hate Pakistan for the sake of India. But still Pakistan accept him roaming the streets while he being evicted. Do not believe snakes
@@cnachopchopnewsagency thanks for advice a Pakistani... Now f© offf
@@aryan_6969 nah im not pakistani or indian. I am from europe. We have been seeing this too much. Karl Rock is quite famous in my country
@@cnachopchopnewsagency your comment itself prove you are pak sympthiser ...no need to explain...i can see your love towards a country which enormous amount of t
This fellow is a PAID Anti India Journo.
Atleast he exposes scam and show historic culture more than our own media
Scams happen with Tourists everywhere. No Good Person weaponizes Scams to ridicule host Country.
@Uncle James Name your Country, I can bring them to your notice
@Uncle James You reading this random comment and replying to it in as much as random video to a Finnish citizen is a scam on its own. 🤣🤣🤣
@@spd1000 India scammers are next level 😅
he is himself a scam and got exposed.
Well best thing for him to do now is to wait it out, it's a 1 year ban he held on for 280 something days, a few more weeks remaining; it's more like a warning 🙄
Ik man. I get that staying away from your family is very difficult, but let’s be honest, he is exaggerating and also being slightly dishonest. For example, he says that he is not allowed to enter without any explanation even though he violated Indian law by protesting. Also I’m pretty sure he conducted some business activities despite not having a work visa.
that gave him the perfect excuse to vlog in Pakistan and other countries without losing his Indian subscribers. So he is happy. He takes a break from India and the scammers he love so much.
Mattia Binnoto He is just obsessed with views and gaining subscribers. He is not unhappy traveling Dubai and Pakistan.
@@eduardochavacano cmon man, have a little empathy. Maybe what you are saying is true, but still staying away from your spouse for extended periods of time is difficult.
That one year is turning into two years with no end in sight.
Karl Rock thinks that everyone is a scammer if they charge more for a product. Businesses have a right to choose any business model or concept or charge any amount of money for a product. If a company makes mistakes they will disappear from the market. Its plain and simple. That doesnt mean that they are scammers. There is also something called commerical secrets or trade secrets which hinders companies from disclosing certain things. It doesnt mean they are scammers. If tuk-tuk driver charges certain amount of money it his business. Go to some one else or start the same service cheaper. It doesnt mean the tuk-tuk driver is a scammer. He has chosen that business model. The worst thing his done was to go in to hamburgare bar that has a franshise with a Nyzeeland company. Karl Rock without looking for the facts said that the restuarant was illegally coping a business franshise. He also said something stupid about Indian motorcycles that were sold in New Zeeland.
Well he is scamming us when he or his wife claim he had dual citizenship of India and not mentioning how he broke multiple visa rules and thus disrespected law of the land ( visa rules) himself.
Well said.. I used to follow his videos.. One thing I found he is anti national
@@sudarshandesai9160 anti-hindu racist, that karl is.
@@dixienourmous8156 your right these people wont understand , they speak about thier nation like a god but never try to showcase all the corruption , mob lynching , rape , unemployment , lack of maintenance , malnutrition etc
@@sudarshandesai9160 with corrupt govt is india democratic anymore ?
India today learned today
from the comments that
India don’t allow dual citizenship 🙏🏼
As indian citizen i thank him for exposing scams but , he cannot just go and protest.
@Mohsin Khan its in the rule
No foreign entity can indulge in India's internal affairs.
@@abhisheksharma7307 and do you think that rule should exist? It's pretty silly why a foreigner can't protest
@@VeritasVortex No it's not. Why should a foriegn national have the right to interfere in internal matters of a country which he may not be fully acquainted with? India's geopolitical circumstances warrant such strict measures or else the country won't be able to develop.
@Mohsin Khan understand the difference everythough i am.not a big fan of bjp , it is clearly mentioned CAA has got nothing to do with Indian Muslims. It is made to help minorities in nearby countries of india like pak and bang and to stop illegal entry of people from neighbouring countries which is a threat to internal security of india.
@Mohsin Khan Read the CAA article first man🤣, to put it simply people who came to India after 2014 residing here will not be considered as citizens.I dont know what this is to do with Indian muslims.
Good to see . Guys I have seen his some of videos . He Really violating the visa norms .
At least you understand sir he a tourist at the end of day
Feeling bad for him and his family. But technically if the violations of visa rules really happened, then it will take time to clear everything. He should be patient. Everything will be fine again.
lol typical indian response
They banned him for being nice to Pakistan
@@yooloswag1519 A foreign national cannot interfere in other country's political affairs. These laws are made to maintain the sovereignity of a country and should be respected He and his wife are pretty well off maybe they should immigrate to NZ and live there.
I think so, he last time went to pakistan, when we visit pakistan our visa and passport will get expired, So we have to issue new one. Maybe the logic is that
indian government and agencies are afraid that he might be ISI's agent 🤣💪
@@MuhammadHamas Abdool why Allah loved Porkistan so much he took a big fat piss and created a flood in Porkistan 😭
not really, he just broke the law by participating in CAA protests. If youre gonna criticize GOI for following the constitution then be my guest
@@MuhammadHamas you people more more afraid of raw , we know which country has less terrorist attack that's show which agency is strong ,,,,,, India has Naxalites and terrorist problems even we are far ahead of you people
@@MuhammadHamasno hamass femboy he literally say in his twitter to protest against indian government which is national threat
You should of known that before interfering in India's internal affairs, thought you'd get away with it just because you've got a Indian wife? 🤦♂️
Yes It s Stupid Parmy
People please remember to respect the laws of a country when you visit may it be India or anywhere else. You are a guest when you visit, so its best for everybody if you behave like one.
Breaking the law and then putting up a surprise pikachu face wont help you
absolutely. ppl are just stupid when supporting him they treat the laws in india as trash. i think they should surrender their indian citizenship. shameless people are the reason my country is being insulted before the world.
he not a visitor he thet husband of an indian women
@Michelle Sanders as a pakistany livin nin canada for 47 years i agree with u michelle 100 %
@@syedali9095 he was still on tourist visa. And that is why he did not get extended.
@@rkaveti oh now i under stand thank u mr rajesh
A guy from New Zealand, who visits pakistan, participates in caa protests, marrys an Indian girl with disability(skin disability) says he's trying to expose scammers, I don't think this is something small, he might have something big in his mind.
Watching too much Bollywood my dogg lol.
@@redditor2112 just an opinion man😂😂
So? U need to get out of your basement and see the world outside
I get why people are saying that this is fair, but it is such a narrow mentality that if Indians face the same trouble in foreign, foreigners should have to face it too
We face it no one even care for us!
Being passionate about India we didn't expected insulting our krisha from you
yes, Karl rock is banned because his wife was saying our lord Krishna a womanizer and saying that Pakistan is better than India
@@highjoshtech4794 Never said such a thing you need to listen better son
@@MitsukiHashiba he said about krishna u can search
@@MitsukiHashiba you can search
@@PakistanZindabad19828 we didint cut his head for the same
And if someone said anything about islam u would be bombing others
The fact that media is upholding a case of single person tells you that he is not a common man. More certain sect of media upholds his case, more are chances of him being India's traitor. Otherwise thousands of Visas get rejected accross the world, how many does the media care about? A chief minister of an Indian state was banned entry in the US while no court could prove him guilty. Its unfortunate but thats the way world works.
Good point
Which chief minister?
@@comradeleppi2000 Narendra Modi. The current prime minister.
He is another librandu 😑very disappointed
He was part of chota gang(dhurve tatti and jhuta deshbhakt)
True
What is that
@@Stokesy9812 RE Andh Bhakt hai wohi bol raha hai
I grew up rollerblading with Karl in the 90's in Botany Downs, Auckland. Good dude. Great to see how well he's done.
He's a good person?
@@themicroscopeworld5897 No! He actively participated with elements that wants break India.
@@BlackHawkTejas cope paaajeet
@@Shrekfan66 LoL!! The joker thinks he is insulting by calling pajeet!! Shows your low level mindset. This guy is already suffering & it seems you are also!! 😂😂😂
i am very sure he has exploited indian legal system and violated VISA stay norms
India does not allow dual nationality. I am born, raised, and educated in India. When I received German nationality after living and working in Germany for 8 years, I had to surrender Indian passport.
So you can't reapply to get your Indian passport back? For example, my dad was born in Mexico and gave up his passport to become a US citizen. He can reapply to become a Mexican citizen without giving up his US passport since he was born in Mexico.
@@Sajoranirac You can.
One of my relatives banned from newzland bec he has done a thing that's against the restriction or rules by the govt when you are in another country you should respect their rules
And tell why. You are. Banned in india
☺️ visited Pakistan ( muslim terrorist rogue nation ) ✅
With Pakistani stamp on passport Participated in CAA protest ( which was ment to kick out all jihadi infiltrators from Pakistan and Bengladesh origin ) ✅
And also have two citizenship ✅
It would probably be for the best if he and his wife explain their situation to their family, and just completely forget about India. Then they can start a new life wherever they want
Did you support CAA😂
Well you know they ban even Indians so you're .. Just one.
He cannot do all those same things in NZ as he did in India as a foreigner.
NZ is very strict with such things they don't expose nor do they alow ppl exposing internal issue's in media opening like this
Indian Government has taken a good decision
Hum kisise kum nahi👍👍
I don't believe you. Please provide your evidence.
@@VeritasVortex what I ment is, if he did the same things in NZ he wouldn't be entertained in NZ. Exposing and opposing the activities here in India by making vlogs tat must not be entertained any where in any country
They might have got something fishy coz he stayed in Pakistan about a year, India can't allow as per security purpose, in every country safety comes first
How can you simply exclude one country and deem everyone who lives there "unsafe". You know that if Western countries did that, INDIANs would probably not allowed in...
Sorry bro…hope you come back soon
Watched a lot of your videos
Is this guy putting on a show. If he think staying with his family is so important, why not take your family to New Zealand.?
i think he will eventually
@99 so u saying his wife gets a lot of money for him not to leave
@99 what is yt mean
mr 99 who r u where r u from for example eim from canada toronto ontario
@@syedali9095 yt means RUclips
He is a sweet youtuber and a kind person. He shouldn't be banned.
Laws Doesn’t not Apply for your Sweetness !! 💀
When you are in a foreign country you should obey that countries law. NZ government would deport any student who works over 20 Hours on their student visa. And that deportation is for life. At least India's ban is only for a year. In my opinion, NZ law should be brought to India.
@@darkhorseisheartshaker9783 Exactly
Bechare ka Pakistan mein J hind bolna bhi kaam na aaya 😂😂😂
Karl Rock is awesome and has educated Indians about India more than Indians themselves.
He helped exposed the tech support scams in india. Even helped jim browning in one of his crackdown.
Scam is every where. Tell me a singel country name where no scam running? Most of you tuber coming India and made money to make video's here and even there subscriber's also most of from India still just for view's they potrate wrong image about country. If India is that much bad and full of scam's then why he been there for so many year's and why still badly want to go. He might not a bad guys but he sould resepect of country constitution and not work against of that. This is not only for India it's for any country.
Why do you Whites think that you deserve Special privilege anywhere?
Doing a good thing doesn't make all the other wrong things go away. That's not how it works
This guy showed how good are people in pakisthan and there is no hatred among people of India and Pakistan, also he poked many of govt activities.
😂😂😂 so you don't know there is something called immigration laws in every country if you don't follow those you will be thrown out of country. Go and try any country you will be banned there.
@@ravirana2001 go laugh on government but not on him .
@Movieclips I know idiot , but people r more onto hating him for spoiling indias reputation? Like thts absurd
What are your views on osama
He should have thought about all this before joining the protests in Shaheen bagh... The law is the same for everyone!!
Besides he used misinformation to gain off of RUclips while defaming our nation!!! He shouldn't be allowed back!!
If he was blocking roads, then it's only ironic that he's blocked out of country borders, lol.
@@enkidu9298 🤣🤣🤣🤣
U sure are not scammers? He never defames your nation. He has proven to show he loved India. He only shows your reality. You scam tourists everywhere. You saying you have the right to charge 5x more because he is white? If you don't want to accept your reality then shut it
Besides, they never informed him about why he was banned. You think he was going to watch all the rules.
@@orpheux8021 it's elementary if you violate the conditions of your visa you're banned! (You cannot plead ignorance of law as a defence in a trial)
And there's a considerable portion of people living below the poverty line in India..they try and scam me too...you just have to be wiser!
Although They mean well and will never harm you physically, but they would do anything for money!!!
I never said that these scammers don't exist...but certainly they don't exist at the level Mr Rock purported them to...it was sensationalism to get more views on his channel...he fails to mention certain facts which clearly show his ulterior motives and clearly he misrepresents facts and has falsified information many a times...I'll give you another example...there are many call centers running "scams" all across the country...many youtubers expose them...however they fail to mention that the source of information to these scammers is usually a person in the very country that the people are being scammed from!!
It's that Pewds copy. T-series banned him from India. They got the wrong person
A very good step from Indian govt, i am proud of this govt
Is this sarcasm or do you mean this?
@@dharveshreddy6493 whatever pleases you you can think that way , it's all about narrative
He loves to be a cry baby when in reality he knows it very well that his actions are not only violative of the law of the land but also in the contravention of its sovereignty and security . You cannot jeopardise the entire nation to protect the civil right of one single individual .
We Indian also have to obey rules and regulations and whatever we do , cry or compliant official doesn't respond easily. So why you need special treatment for you?
Jamai ke jese treat kare esa socha tha kya? 🤔
@@sudharshank8256 🤨 what's the logic and sense in your comment?
Where I shown "mean mentality"!!!
You didn't understand what I said , "everyone treated same according to rules and regulations"
we all Indian pay tax , challan , penalty, have to follow government orders , follow constitution so why not a foreigner?
He broke the rule of visa and gone against the regulation then why government give him special treatment?
USA or any country doesn't give any Indian a special treatment , they as a foreigner must obey the rules set by government otherwise it would be problematic.
Okey. I wasn't knowing he broke the rules. Apologies.
@@sudharshank8256 ohk then👍😊
I was lucky enough to ride motorcycles with Karl, in Northern Pakistan, and he is one the most genuinely nice people. Everywhere we went he was recognised and he was humble and friendly with everyone
The clear reason is that India fears another potential David Headley and rightly so. He shouldn't have broken the laws in the first place.
Let him stay and what? Protest?
as if he has a right to say what laws India should have?? We are better off without such people.
Thanks we have some sane people like you. We can't allow double standards for western people same as they don't allow for us.
You seem to have have *NO* Idea how India is currently perceived in the West through Indian phone scammers & uploads of the myriad of thefts perpetrated on guests to your land within seconds of walking off a plane & seem to want to shoot the messenger that is giving you a reality check!
You are delusional!
That guy shouldn't enter idea 🤣
Thankyou government you did a great job🙏🙏
He traveled to Dubai and from there to Pakistan.
He got banned from India.
He broke different visa rules such as doing business on travel visa and visiting parts of Kashmir where foreigners are not allowed.
In the name of 26/11, I don't know why he is banned. It's so wrong of Indian govt.