@@17Watman I thought it was the face. Aerion says something about knocking one of his teeth loose with the kick after he has the guards holding Dunk down.
Talentless, classless, and arrogant with the only thing going for him being winning the genetic lottery at birth. Aerion would have had a long career as a politician in the US.
He is also a bit of a badass he killed a blackfire in single combat beat the laughing storm in trial by combat killed black Tom while he was injured beat luthor Long inch after almost drowning and took a lance to the face oh and he lived through one of the only two trials by combat in the entire history of asoiaf
My username is so obnoxiously long and there is absolutely nothing you can do about the matter So am I. I'm thinking the video had to be re-uploaded. I just posted the same comment I did yesterday. 😄
@@91YEHNAH Yeah, in 2016 at Balticon. It's semi-canon. Brienne remembers seeing Dunk's shield when she was little, and had hers repainted as such in Duskendale.
Wait how many Dunc and Egg books are there?? I thought I read them all but Duncan didn’t die :( also I am only 1 minute into this video, so...maybe I should stop?
Yeah, apart from the spin-off books, many want also a spin-off series involving Dunk and Egg... But Martin doesn't want to do it yet, as he wants to finish writting the stories first before adapting them to TV... So maybe 10 years from now we will see it XDD
I think that everything we've read in the books comes from the meeting of Dunk and Egg. The World of Ice and Fire reveals to us that Aegon V Targaryen met his wife, Lady Betha Blackwood, during his travels with Ser Duncan the Tall. So if Dunk and Egg had never met, probably the future king would had married another woman, and none of his descendants, Jaheaerys II and his wife-sister Shaera, Aerys II the Mad King and his sister-queen Rhaella, Rhaegar, Viserys, Daenerys and Jon Snow, would have ever come to the world. Neither the Baratheon brothers, whose paternal grandmother was the daughter of King Aegon V. Furthermore, that book reveals to us that the lady that he helped in the second story, Rohanne Webber, was the future lady of Casterly Rock and grandmother of lord Tywin and of his cousin and wife, lady Johanna Lannister. So, probably, even them, Tyrion, Jaime, Cersei (whoever is their father: Aerys or Tywin) and their children owe their existence to him. The same goes for the young Starks because, without Rhaegar and Aerys, their parents Ned and Catelyn would never have married.
Davide Ferrari Aegon V would never have become King. He was nicknamed Aegon the Unlikely for being the 4th son of the 4th son of the King. But whole branches of the Targaryen house were wiped out by a really bad disease outbreak, others took the Black, and of course one of his older brothers killed the other (during Duncan’s trial) so little Egg ended up king
In A Feast For Crows, Brienne, Brings up that she will her shield repainted.. and that she ran over fingers over the oak tree and shooting star. This is most likely referring to Duncan's Shield. I dont know that Hodor is NOT Ser Duncan's bloodline, but its definitely hinted that Brienne is.
CivilizationEx oh Patreon people get content like this? I was looking forward to more videos like this. I guess I'll have to show you my support so I can.
do you know where did he find the informations from the 7:44 until the end of the video? i mean, the book about Ser Duncan The Tall i read, didnt mention any of these. it stopped after Ser Duncan stopped the Blackfire rebellion before even started in whitewalls.
Prince Aerion wasn’t afraid of Dunk fighting in a trial by combat. Aerion knew that he didn’t actually have to fight Dunk himself and that one of his Kingsguard could act as his champion. However, he was always a madly overblown eccentric that just wanted to make things difficult and try to humiliate Dunk. Aerion thought that by changing it to a Trial of Seven, he could prove that Dunk had no actual friends that would stand with him and that Dunk would be a laughing stock before they took off his hand.
Yeah this is true. And I do agree. BUT, after the asswhooping Dunk put on him, probably also was also a bit nervous of facing him one on one. After all, Dunk is 7 freaking feet tall, and he already felt how strong he was. I have no doubt that Aerion wanted to make a spectacle out of it and humiliate Dunk before chopping his hand off, but it's also pretty obvious that Aerion was a punk and afraid to fight Dunk alone.
Like most GRRM "confirmations" his choice of wording is extremely ambiguous and further confirmation is 3rd party sources / Chinese whispers. I'd put this is the bin of probably, but may never get a confirmation.
I agree exactly with what me from 2 months ago said. This should be Atleast a 4 season series from the start of their adventures to their death at Harrenhaul.
Daaaaaaaaamn this guy is a legend. And damn it this Cercei when she said that he can't be one of the king's guards what a slap in the face of his honor.
A great video! I wish we'll get a film or TV series about Dunk and Egg. The characters and the stories are so compelling. By the way, Daeron, not Aerion, was Maekar's eldest son.
The mountain is the bull, Ser Duncan is the torero If you could kill the mountain using skill alone like oberyn, then i imagine defeating him using swordmanship and strength would be very easy.
Musa Altáriel Duncan relied on his strength a lot. He wasn’t that skilled with a sword during the time of the “knight of seven kingdoms” timeline. So I don’t think Duncan would stand much of a chance with the mountain since he had more skills than just brute strength.
"A knight of the seven kingdoms" ends at whitewalls. Whn ser Duncan leaves for the Wall. Where can i read the later part of his life ?? Can someone tell
Marting hasn't write about that part yet as novels, but you can read that information in the world of ice and fire, and in the books of a song of ice and fire you can find refferences about him
I loved Dunk and Egg's stories. Bitesized and wholesome but still with all the fantasy and political trappings of GRRM's work. Egg is just a hilarious character and the perfect foil for Ser Dunk, he's very witty and incredibly smart for his age. My favourite bits is the catchphrase "get him, he's right there!"
Wait, where did you find the informations from 7:44 until the end of the video? i mean, in the book i only read about all the stuff you said from the begining of the video until 7:44.
It is from what we know about the next Dunk and Egg Book, entitled She Wolves of Winterfell. Then the rest is largely from the history book, World of Ice and Fire.
Honesty trying to remember exactly how Egg became king. I know how Aerion went out. Just trying to remember how the other sons went out. Duncan was a hero and deserves like at least a 20 episode miniseries
Everything is great but for the fact that Aegon wasn't beloved, at least not by the nobility, and the tragedy of Summerhall was caused by his (Aegon's) obsession with hatching dragons to control his vassals with greater ease, but this is a video about Duncan not Aegon, love all your work btw
Angel F. Castillo Aegon wasn't loved by the nobility because Aegon was so generous to the poor. Also it is believed that the tragedy at Summerhall was due to the Maesters at the Citadel fearing a second coming of the dragons.
Aegon The V was like the Bernie Sanders of westeros by trying to help out commoners while the nobles hated him and rejoiced when his policies died with him
Aegon the 5th was now wholly loved during his reign. The common folk loved Aegon for sure. But a lot of nobles hated him due to the reforms Aegon put out that curbed the nobles' power.
I dont get it. The Book ends with bloodraven arresting the blackfyre, but you show dunk and egg going north. Is there another book that shows Dunk becoming kingsguard and fighting the laughing storm
Not that it matters on a 5+ year old video, but just a small error I saw, Prince Aerion isn’t the eldest of Maekar’s sons, but the second oldest. Daeron (the Drunken) was the eldest and original heir, much to Maekar’s disappointment
She was married to Egg's first son, Duncan 1, and she was the reason he gave up his state as crown prince as he knew he couldn't be king if he married her. When Prince Duncan, King Aegon V and See Duncan died at Summerhall, Jenny continued to go there to dance and speak with them.
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
"Striking Aerion down.." has to be the most understated way of describing the beatdown Ser Duncan laid on his ass that day.
Been a while since I read the story but if I remember he knocked him spark out.
Dunk punched his face, causing him to fall to the ground. Aerion reaches for his dagger but Dunk stepped on his hand and kicked him in the chest.
@@17Watman I thought it was the face. Aerion says something about knocking one of his teeth loose with the kick after he has the guards holding Dunk down.
Talentless, classless, and arrogant with the only thing going for him being winning the genetic lottery at birth. Aerion would have had a long career as a politician in the US.
I have one word.
Yield
Dunk the lunk, thick as a castle wall.
The Evil Bassist that phrase was probably repeated a hundred times
A thousand eyes, and one.
c l o u t i n t h e e a r
"slow and stubborn as an aurochs"
*"ARE THERE NO TRUE KNIGHTS AMONG YOU?"*
Dunk is seriously my fucking FAVORITE character in ASOIAF. Hes so freaking honorable and humble. Hes just... god so amazing.
He is also a bit of a badass he killed a blackfire in single combat beat the laughing storm in trial by combat killed black Tom while he was injured beat luthor Long inch after almost drowning and took a lance to the face oh and he lived through one of the only two trials by combat in the entire history of asoiaf
@@knotadoctor1455two trials of seven you think ?
@@niccolorichter1488 I don't think I was clear enough I didn't mean he was in both trials of seven but he was in and I guess won one of the two
Undoubtedly the greatest, and most accomplished knight in the history of the Seven Kingdoms.
Ruben Avalos I'm having deja vu
My username is so obnoxiously long and there is absolutely nothing you can do about the matter So am I. I'm thinking the video had to be re-uploaded. I just posted the same comment I did yesterday. 😄
Ruben Avalos what about barristan or aemon the dragonnight
casey moon Or even Daemon Blackfyre
That's pretty doubtble
If Hodor is a descendant of Duncan the Tall then another sad thing is like Duncan he died protecting the ones he cared for.
Daemon Blackfyre damn, nicely said.
As any one of us could only aspire to do.
Brienne is a descendant of Duncan! R.R Martin has said so apparently :D
@@91YEHNAH Yeah, in 2016 at Balticon. It's semi-canon. Brienne remembers seeing Dunk's shield when she was little, and had hers repainted as such in Duskendale.
Wait how many Dunc and Egg books are there?? I thought I read them all but Duncan didn’t die :( also I am only 1 minute into this video, so...maybe I should stop?
Oak and Iron guard me well, or else I am dead and doomed to hell...
This has spin-off written all over it.
Yeah, apart from the spin-off books, many want also a spin-off series involving Dunk and Egg... But Martin doesn't want to do it yet, as he wants to finish writting the stories first before adapting them to TV... So maybe 10 years from now we will see it XDD
theres also comics
the hedge knight and the sworn sword
Dhorn When George is 78......
What other book about Dunk besides Knight of Seven kingdoms?
Muriel Walker The World of Ice and Fire.
probably one of the most interesting times during the targaryen reign.
I think that everything we've read in the books comes from the meeting of Dunk and Egg. The World of Ice and Fire reveals to us that Aegon V Targaryen met his wife, Lady Betha Blackwood, during his travels with Ser Duncan the Tall. So if Dunk and Egg had never met, probably the future king would had married another woman, and none of his descendants, Jaheaerys II and his wife-sister Shaera, Aerys II the Mad King and his sister-queen Rhaella, Rhaegar, Viserys, Daenerys and Jon Snow, would have ever come to the world. Neither the Baratheon brothers, whose paternal grandmother was the daughter of King Aegon V. Furthermore, that book reveals to us that the lady that he helped in the second story, Rohanne Webber, was the future lady of Casterly Rock and grandmother of lord Tywin and of his cousin and wife, lady Johanna Lannister. So, probably, even them, Tyrion, Jaime, Cersei (whoever is their father: Aerys or Tywin) and their children owe their existence to him. The same goes for the young Starks because, without Rhaegar and Aerys, their parents Ned and Catelyn would never have married.
@@davideferrari1194
Yes but to be fair it's nothing special but just the butterfly effect that always happens.
Davide Ferrari Aegon V would never have become King. He was nicknamed Aegon the Unlikely for being the 4th son of the 4th son of the King. But whole branches of the Targaryen house were wiped out by a really bad disease outbreak, others took the Black, and of course one of his older brothers killed the other (during Duncan’s trial) so little Egg ended up king
In A Feast For Crows, Brienne, Brings up that she will her shield repainted.. and that she ran over fingers over the oak tree and shooting star. This is most likely referring to Duncan's Shield. I dont know that Hodor is NOT Ser Duncan's bloodline, but its definitely hinted that Brienne is.
"Tanselle "Too Tall," they called her...But she wasn't too tall for Me."~Ser Duncan the Tall
Since I used the audio book I thought her name was tamsel lol
C l o u t o n t h e e a r
thats fuckin romantic as hell
But she wasn't too tall for...... uh puppets!
"Tanselle "La Giganta", la llamaban... Pero para mí no era demasiado alta."
100,000 Subscribers! As a thank you I am releasing Episode 1 of the Patreon only series Heroes of Lore and Legend. Happy Holidays!
CivilizationEx oh Patreon people get content like this? I was looking forward to more videos like this. I guess I'll have to show you my support so I can.
CivilizationEx ;
Prequels HBO need to do: Dunk and Egg, Roberts Rebellion, Aegon's conquest and the origin of the faceless men
And don't forget Dance of the Dragons, but the budget will be wow for cgi.
Raphael Raditya How could I have forgotten about that!? That should've been #1. Lets not forget the Night's king/13th Lord Commander
i want The Rise of Karl Tanner
Two of those were already rejected by George R.R. Martin.
What about Benjen Stark in the lands of always winter. Or how the Bloodraven became the 3-eyed raven
Ser Duncan the Tall has one of THE BEST stories I have ever read.
Just finished reading The Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. It definitely is worth a read.
The Tall vs The Laughing Storm , imagine that .
It actually happens lol
I know , I saw that video too .
do you know where did he find the informations from the 7:44 until the end of the video? i mean, the book about Ser Duncan The Tall i read, didnt mention any of these. it stopped after Ser Duncan stopped the Blackfire rebellion before even started in whitewalls.
Ser Duncan The Tall Im guess from A world of ice and fire. A book about the history of Westeros.
That fight is just one reason HBO should do this as a spin-off. The trial of seven would be awesome to see as well.
Prince Aerion wasn’t afraid of Dunk fighting in a trial by combat. Aerion knew that he didn’t actually have to fight Dunk himself and that one of his Kingsguard could act as his champion. However, he was always a madly overblown eccentric that just wanted to make things difficult and try to humiliate Dunk. Aerion thought that by changing it to a Trial of Seven, he could prove that Dunk had no actual friends that would stand with him and that Dunk would be a laughing stock before they took off his hand.
Yeah this is true. And I do agree. BUT, after the asswhooping Dunk put on him, probably also was also a bit nervous of facing him one on one. After all, Dunk is 7 freaking feet tall, and he already felt how strong he was. I have no doubt that Aerion wanted to make a spectacle out of it and humiliate Dunk before chopping his hand off, but it's also pretty obvious that Aerion was a punk and afraid to fight Dunk alone.
Do one about Ser Arthur Dayne
@Eddie LM lel
grrm has confirmed brienes lineage to ser duncan the tall. love your vis!
Like most GRRM "confirmations" his choice of wording is extremely ambiguous and further confirmation is 3rd party sources / Chinese whispers. I'd put this is the bin of probably, but may never get a confirmation.
Yeah, with the amount of vague confirmations GRRM has given, it's pretty much "semi-canon".
The Mystery Knight > The Hedge Knight > The Sworn Sword
All 3 are brilliant though
IMO the tales of Dunk and Egg are better than the main series
Horus the illustrated versions are pretty good too.
Jack Daniels I agree kind of. I don’t think they’d be that special if they weren’t canon to the main series.
From street orphan to Lord Commander of the Kingsguard
Fucking legend
I don't care how skilled Arthur Dayne is, Dunk is the GREATEST KNIGHT in the Seven Kingdoms!
Here after the finale of HOTD s02 and the announcement of the set Duncan spinoff
Oak an iron guard me well or else I'm dead and doomed to hell
No hat for Maester? Scandalous! heheh Love your videos Civ! Thank you.
maybe he held the door for rhealla
You could make a whole season out of this.
A whole series more like.
Season 1: the tourney of ashford meadow
Season 2: Standfast vs Coldmoat
Season 3: butterwell frey wedding
I can see it happening.
Fresh beans That should all be season 1. This is all just a teaser for what Duncan has accomplished.
I agree exactly with what me from 2 months ago said. This should be Atleast a 4 season series from the start of their adventures to their death at Harrenhaul.
@@Kunumbah1 summerhall
So Hodor and Brienne might be siblings. Woah!
No really, only cousins.
Brandon Marroquin Very distant cousins
Who both protect the innocent Stark children like Dunc the Lunk would be proud of.
@@jamiestewart48 You say innocent :D
So Duncan saved Rhaegar, which ensured the events of ASOIAF?
it would be cool to see a 16 year old ser Barristan the bold
Daaaaaaaaamn this guy is a legend.
And damn it this Cercei when she said that he can't be one of the king's guards what a slap in the face of his honor.
A great video! I wish we'll get a film or TV series about Dunk and Egg. The characters and the stories are so compelling.
By the way, Daeron, not Aerion, was Maekar's eldest son.
Wonderful video! Keep up the marvelous work!
dunk the lunk.. i loved this series. so good. and so sad knowing how Dunk and Egg ended :(
ah man i would love for him to be brienne's ancestor
That is already confirmed by GRRM.
Have just listened to the first two D&E books. Dunk is now my favourite character.
Beautiful and brilliant video. Thank you very much!
Oak and iron, guard me well, or else I'm dead, and doomed to hell.
Omg the Hodor bit is fantastic! Never knew that lol
I just finished the mystery knight and i laughed out loud when Daemon blackyre's lover accused Dunk of trying to steal him lmao
How can George RR Martin planned and wrote all these things in his fantasy world. It is so complex
you do great work man.
Ser Duncan The Tall Vs. The Mountain
The mountain is the bull, Ser Duncan is the torero
If you could kill the mountain using skill alone like oberyn, then i imagine defeating him using swordmanship and strength would be very easy.
Mountain would kill him
it's rumored that the Clegane bros are also Duncan's descendants
@@pembomassive1394 Not a chance
Musa Altáriel Duncan relied on his strength a lot. He wasn’t that skilled with a sword during the time of the “knight of seven kingdoms” timeline. So I don’t think Duncan would stand much of a chance with the mountain since he had more skills than just brute strength.
please do one on Barristan Selmy and Arthur Dayne
"Egg.. I dreamed, that I was old"
Duncan' story is more interesting than Season 8
have you ever thought of doing a video on wildfire?
i really want a series about dunk
idk if it's true but i think they're making a spinoff about this. can't wait!
I wish to see a film 🎬 or TV 📺 series on Dunk and Egg.
this will be the only one of theses ill see :(
I'm amazed he accomplished that much with those short arms!
"A knight of the seven kingdoms" ends at whitewalls. Whn ser Duncan leaves for the Wall. Where can i read the later part of his life ??
Can someone tell
Marting hasn't write about that part yet as novels, but you can read that information in the world of ice and fire, and in the books of a song of ice and fire you can find refferences about him
I loved Dunk and Egg's stories. Bitesized and wholesome but still with all the fantasy and political trappings of GRRM's work. Egg is just a hilarious character and the perfect foil for Ser Dunk, he's very witty and incredibly smart for his age. My favourite bits is the catchphrase "get him, he's right there!"
Hodor is like the Chewbacca of game of thrones. Gentill loyal and brave and tall
In addition to the passionate kiss, he took Lady Webber's braid.
AMAZING VIDEO!!!! Thank you!!!
Dunk the lunk, greatest Knight of them all!
so you're telling me that Brienne and Hodor are possibly related
Been doing a stream with these stories. Have 3 left. Lot of fun. I've DEFINITELY had to do my Targaryen research💙💙✌
Love your channel
thank you, great job.💚
The greatest knight who wasn’t officially a knight
I can’t wait for this show
Wait, where did you find the informations from 7:44 until the end of the video? i mean, in the book i only read about all the stuff you said from the begining of the video until 7:44.
It is from what we know about the next Dunk and Egg Book, entitled She Wolves of Winterfell. Then the rest is largely from the history book, World of Ice and Fire.
After readin'the book, and seein'how he died, i teared
Imagine f more lords and kings sent their kids to be around the common man
Dunk really is the best. He isn’t the smartest, or the greatest fighter, but he is humble and just and does what’s right, no matter the cost.
I always suspected Dunk dropped a DONG in Old Nan.
We need a spin off for dunk the lunk!
Honesty trying to remember exactly how Egg became king. I know how Aerion went out. Just trying to remember how the other sons went out. Duncan was a hero and deserves like at least a 20 episode miniseries
My fav asoiaf character.
Thank you!!!!!!
Everything is great but for the fact that Aegon wasn't beloved, at least not by the nobility, and the tragedy of Summerhall was caused by his (Aegon's) obsession with hatching dragons to control his vassals with greater ease, but this is a video about Duncan not Aegon, love all your work btw
Angel F. Castillo Aegon wasn't loved by the nobility because Aegon was so generous to the poor. Also it is believed that the tragedy at Summerhall was due to the Maesters at the Citadel fearing a second coming of the dragons.
Great career for a guy who was defeated and injured almost every time when fought. :) One of my favorite characters.
AHHH NO I haven't finished reading the book, at the second novel. I should've never clicked on this..
He is a legend.
This lore is great. Dunk and egg tv show coming
Can't wait to find out what happens when Dunk and Egg head up too Winterfell.
Am I the only one scaried of how brynden rivers is being drawn??
Two Humfrey’s, one trial.
Aegon The V was like the Bernie Sanders of westeros by trying to help out commoners while the nobles hated him and rejoiced when his policies died with him
Creepy Closet Bernie sanders is an elitist
Love the art
Aegon the 5th was now wholly loved during his reign. The common folk loved Aegon for sure. But a lot of nobles hated him due to the reforms Aegon put out that curbed the nobles' power.
Why was this re-uploaded?
To correct some errors.
Wow! It would be so cool if Brienne and Hodor were his decedents!
probably the baddest dude walking in the stories
that's a trip.
We need a full movie about him, at least three 1st book
Tks for the video
I dont get it. The Book ends with bloodraven arresting the blackfyre, but you show dunk and egg going north. Is there another book that shows Dunk becoming kingsguard and fighting the laughing storm
There are no more Dunk and Egg books but there story is expanded on further in the novels and history book.
CivilizationEx I see. Thanks Civilization, I enjoy your content very much
Where can I read the last story
Not that it matters on a 5+ year old video, but just a small error I saw, Prince Aerion isn’t the eldest of Maekar’s sons, but the second oldest. Daeron (the Drunken) was the eldest and original heir, much to Maekar’s disappointment
Oak and iron guard me well, or else i'm dead and doomed to hell.
Prince Baelor was the best of the Targaryens.
One of the best Targaryens
Can I eat my boots ser, I'll make another out of salt beef it's tougher.
Sad breakspear died, truly a tragedy since his brother didnt even mean to kill him
Reminded me of the hound
So how did Jenny of Oldstones had a song written about her?
She was married to Egg's first son, Duncan 1, and she was the reason he gave up his state as crown prince as he knew he couldn't be king if he married her. When Prince Duncan, King Aegon V and See Duncan died at Summerhall, Jenny continued to go there to dance and speak with them.
You should do brown Ben plumb
Aye Duncans unite or something.
Ser Gorman Peake? Not so subtle Gormanghast reference there