PS5 Pro vs RTX 4070 - The First Descendant
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 дек 2024
- PS5 Pro running in fidelity mode vs RTX 4070 running on Ultra Settings. The RTX 4070 was recorded using obs while playing at the same time so theres a bit drop in frame rate. but it runs smooth at 60fps... next time ill record it using the nvidia app.
#ps5 #ps5pro #thefirstdescendant
Some people keeps saying that PS5 Pro is equivalent to RTX 4070 so i've uploaded a video of The First Descendant running in fidelity mode vs rtx 4070. The fidelity mode on PS5 Pro runs higher than 30fps now but nowhere near 60 and more smoother compared to the base PS5. The RTX 4070 has more stone/grass compared to the pro but overall I think they both look the same.... i do have issues with PS5 Pro though there is some white thingy in 13:50 in the grass. it's also present in the character if you look closely esp. when moving around some watery stuff it's more visible. I hope it's just a software issue and not hardware issue. i think it's the PSSR causing this issue
Show them the framerate from both and resolution...cause there are still many .....that think that they are equal...
@@woofaki5550 yep definitely should do that. but i dont have any other games in the pc atm. im a console guy but i dont argue how good the pc is compared to console.
@@pinoyBrad I have both but i mostly use the console for the exclusive titles...Or for games that release on consoles 1st.
@@pinoyBrad do you have horizon remake?
@@Buccitalksthatish no i dont. i have the horizon forbidden west but i cant play it because it's a disc. i dont have disc in my ps5 pro... =(
4070 has more detail, further draw distance, and shadows aren't doubling up. There seems to be some sort of lighting issue on the PS5 Pro. But if we consider the cost the PS5 Pro is doing just fine.
During movement PS5 Pro looks better, there might be a reason for this though in the capture or something, but look the foliage and everything to the sides. Maybe Motion Blur makes it looks worse during capture? If he toned down motion blur in PC maybe PC would look better at everything. Idk it seems PS5 Pro is running better this game.
I mean, watch around her when she is running, everything looks much sharper and seems to have more occlusion actually. So shadows should be better at PS5 Pro if it seems it has more depth, more ambient occlusion I mean.
Water Reflections in RTX are better because it deals better with lighting and stuff as expected from Nvidia. But I can't see RTX winning over PS5 here other than reflections.
i didn't see none of that.....😋
@@caliginousmoira8565 Yea haha
i see no different, all is cakes what cooks me raise.
the Ass looks good in both 'condition'.. that's sufficient enough to rule them all..! ;)
HAHAHA
PS5 Pro looks better. Maybe it’s the POV angle.😂
ps5 looks smoooother
Yea what's up with that. I can see it without a frame rate analyzer. Maybe the pc clip was captured at 30fps. If so, half of the comparison is useless.
@@PushStart_YT na bro its really run smoother on console
@@gogogjt4975 ok, maybe ultra on everything is too much for the 4070
@@PushStart_YTPS5 Pro looks “thicc-er”! You have to go with the PS5 Pro.😂
@tringuyen7519 No arguing there 😬
Something is too thicc about this video
Alot of folks got no idea what they are talking about in these comments. The ps5 pro version clearly has some things turned down. Raytracing, DOF, blur are the ones that really are noticeable. It's also got worse upscaling. It's just highly tuned with sharpening and other settings to fake some things pretty well.
The 4070 on the other hand is using stock ultra settings, not even the highest quality or raytracing settings, and it still performs better than the ps5 version.
Don't get me wrong, the ps5p version doesn't look bad, but let's call an apple a apple, and a orange a orange.
If you bumped the 4070 to cinematic settings it probably would perform about the same as a ps5 pro and would look considerably better, especially if you set up the sharpening like they did on the Playstation version.
Also thing to note is the video compression. Played it on my pc and my ps5p in the living room and it's just easy to notice it's better on PC. Still I dk how well the 4070 would handle it at cinematic to know how much different it would truly be.
During movement PS5 Pro clearly looks better to me, but this might be for some weird reason in capture or in the Nvidia Control Panel settings or something.
it's in the description =D
The RTX 4070 is much sharper and the colors are more vivid, there is also more detail on the PC as shown on the brown block and explosive gas tank @ 4:07. However it looks like it is running under 60 FPS, but could be the video itself (I been gaming since the early 80's I can see the FPS diffs easily). The PS5 Pro looks like it is less sharp but it looks like it is holding a steadier 60 fps at least. If your recording on pc I suggest using Wondershare Uniconverter Pro. It will give you the best raw image outside of using an external capture card. It's even better than Nvidia's built in screen recorder, with even less resource impact. For recording on consoles I suggest an external capture card
4070 is sharper as it is not using any upscaling, PS5 might deceive many on the sharpness department because it's missing Depth of field and motion blur in the moving scenes which can also be disabled in the PC if preferred. PS5 is using upscaling and can be noticed when looking at the initial scene at 0:36 by looking at the thigh-net, shoulders and hair, it has a sort of shimmering/ghosting that is usually caused by the upscalers. shadows and reflections look superior on PC since it's using maxed out ray tracing as it can be best noticed at 7:20 by looking at the casted shadow-map, the PS5 has baked shadows that for some reason look odd and not placed correctly but nothing that affects the overall experience. as for the framerate smoothness and overall sharpness on the PC, the footage was hindered by the recording software used as stated in the video's description.
overall both are great experiences and i would play both at any time, it's not like you are noticing those super small differences/details while shooting aliens and enjoying your day.
I actually do see that the ps5 pro is more clear a bit but if they werent side by side id probably wouldnt tell the difference
The 4070 is good at drawing individual frames, but the PS5 strikes a better balance between frame rate and drawing quality.
4070 alone cost more than ps5 pro lol
people will still say "the 4090 destroys consoles".......yes, it's also 1500+..........
Joke ? 550€ actually for a 4070 ..
@@gones43 4070 ti super.
the 4070 isnt worth the price it is but it doesnt cost more than a ps5 pro its atleast 600 or so... yall find the most expensive brand of the gpu's and go "oh look its way more"
@@smwfreak1647 so any nvidia gpu then.....
Pro looks to be running at a higher frame rate.
Love it when ppl compare the pc to ps5 pro. Obviously pc is better but just 2 see thousands of vids comparing it everyday gives ppl the mindset "ps5 pro or pc". No switch, no xbox, no steam deck, no rog, no legion air time. This xmas choose pro or pc...nothin else.
Rage, Money Power~ Ultimate Freya 🔥🔥🔥
See better Dept of field on RTX4070, but LOD looks better on PS5 Pro (Less popping up), since no actual fps counter, we can't judge if one of them is smoother, could be impacted by recording quality.
i love it... fr... i mean the ps5 pro is matched th 4070, im not talking about... nope, i love it btw... the review ✌️
Hmm. The ps5 pro looks slightly crisper to me, but it has some ghosting or motion blur going on around the edges of the screen that would drive me mad.
I see what u meant @ 13:50 w/ the bushes having white squiggly evaporation lines. I was about to say it looked the same till I saw that, and no rocks on the dirt as is if the PSPro couldn’t push that many Polys as a 4070 easily can do plus more. I’m Team RTX4070 all day any day, bc #1. I have more capabilities/options to be able adjust & set whatever graphical function I want on the gpu card, than I would have on the PSPro that’s only giving me 3 “Fidelity” Options.
what i really think though is maybe its an unreal engine problem? i saw this issue while playing 4070 although its not really quite visible to the eye but its there. i also saw this in stellar blade too. if stellar blade isnt developed in unreal engine then it really is a pssr issue… im talking about the white thingy… but the shimmering issues thats totally pssr issue
Idk , the pro seems to look better in most cases here. Smoother ,sharper. Pretty Interesting comparison.
The only real difference is that the PS5 Pro has better framerate. That's a HUGE W
No, the 4070 has better framerate and has more details, as mentioned in the description of this video and in the creators pinned comment. The problem is way he recorded this video.
I agree that by just watching the video, you'd think that the PS5 Pro had better performance.
If he lowered the settings on the 4070 to match that of the ps5 it may look different. But the game is also very well optimized on console compared to pc.
Edit: Just saw he was recording his PC with OBS. He was recording AND playing on the same pc so yeah.. no wonder the FPS was much lower than the ps5. Not a proper test
As far as I can see. I almost could not find any significant differences, as if the graphic looks similiar. Then again, if someone ask me, I'd rather build DIY PC than buy PS5 Pro. With PC, I can do some rendering, works, etc., not just gaming.
Thanks for the video
Look at the water looks so garbage on the ps5 pro when she running
If Playstation was smarter, they'd allow the use of mouse and keyboard for their console. IDC if they build their own exclusive set of mouse and keyboard, at least we get the option to play on it. That's the only thing holding Sony back from actually competing with pcs on a full-time basis. They'd make billions selling their own brand input devices.
Ps5 Pro is equivalent to a 3070 but with more ram available. Most likely will be better than a 3070 later on,but it will not come close to a 4070...
TFD is very poorly optimized on PC :/. With an RTX 4070 the PC version should be much better than the console versions. The power is superior.
Pc users coping and seething HARD over how good the ps5 is!
are the tags switched? cause the ps5 pro is sharper
It is sharper because for some reason all kinds of visual effects are enabled for PC here, DoF and a bunch more
It can be seen that the Pro performs better in fps and at certain distances than the 4070 GPU, the Pro is stronger than the 4070 GPU
Lol nope, aint even getting past a 3070
looks like 1080p vs 4k to me but with ps5 pro on the right?
Nope. Its ps5 pro on the right running fidelity on 4K its running quite smoother actually compared to the base ps5. The base only runs fidelity on 30fps this one is higher than 30fps
Its not switched you can see how the water is way better on the left compared than the right at the end of the video. I played the new season now of tfd and it really is sharper playing on 65inch tv and the water physics has changed now in ps5 pro its almost the same as the 4070… ive done recording on the pro so ill upload another video comparison again. I play it in my 65 inch tv and all i can say is it looks really good even in large screen tv i can see the sharpness like everyone was saying in the vireo that i didnt even noticed. I usually play in performance mode and it looks like minecraft before in the base ps5. I have both ps5 and ps5 pro if games are upscaled like this and runs smooth 60fps. The $700 is worth it tbh except for some issues but i think most of issues where from unreal engine i can see it in the 4070 happening too so its definitely not the pro issue. But there is annoying shimmering in the reflections i think that one is a PSSR issue
Is the pro in the left cuz it’s say rtx 4070 and the right say ps5 pro???
The pro side is looking better 😳😳
nahh... it's right. the ps5 pro is in the right left is 4070.
@ so why is the ps5 pro looking better?.. are you playing games? with title placement? Or are you seriously fr
@@Buccitalksthatish does it? the quality yes thats the real quality of PS5 Pro in 4K. it's just that the 4070 was recorded using obs and playing at the same time that's why it is not as smooth as it should be. read description...
@@Buccitalksthatish i can upload another video though if you really want me to but this time a different game. i'll be recording it this time using nvidia app. my pc cant handle both playing and recording the same time using obs studio.
for me they look the same. i dont know... it's just that the 4070 has more grass, stones.etc better shadow, the water stuff is way better. but the image quality they both look the same or i have problem with my eyes?
PS5 Pro looks way sharper, far nicer. Almost makes me want to switch to console.
Yoo is it just me or I’m bugging the start of the video where the chick is sitting down the 4070 is blurry in the background why nobody is seeing this ??? What’s funny people talk about pssr. But let’s run the video back again and turnoff DLss and put on FSR WITH THE 4070 and let’s talk. We know rtx is better when it comes to upscale and rt but wow pssr just now starting and it’s looking like this for 700 is amazing that’s the price of a 4070 alone. A bet the pro looks better then a rx77 and matching g not not beating the rx 7800 in some areas
are you brain damaged? The ps5 pro has aftifacts all over the screen. It's like comparing the ps2 (ps5 pro) to a ps4 (pc).
@@BuccitalksthatishWait till you see the fps on the PS5 Pro I wonder if you hype that again I don't think so 😂😂😂
@ i’m aware of the FPS and again when I see that 4070 set up using a equivalent CPU as the pro then we can have a conversation about other than that 47 alone is the price of the consul plus whatever else you spent on CPU that is way more up-to-date so it’s obvious to have better FPS but the point here is we’re trying to measure the pros performance through GPU and what is equivalent to or closest to. And the 4070 just because digital foundry said what they said in Alan Wake too that’s only special to that game because it’s sponsored by Nvidia, other than that, he expect that car to be a lot slower because it runs out of VRAM the days are still early. Remember, this is what they said about PlayStation five until we found out later what doing and how it’s performing
@Buccitalksthatish Ya'll don't realize it's the capture input is not the same, so of course the ps5 looks better on this capture fidelity wise!
for 20 years, i wondering how ppl actually aim and shoot using PS console controller like using mouse.... in old days, there was CS game on PS if not mistaken.
both have the skin, both win
im playing on the same account so it has skin, i play TFD in both pc and console at the same account.
It’s funny how people think the PS five Pro is equivalent to the RTX 4070 it’s laughable, the 3070 is better than the ps5 pro and if you’d like to know the performance ratio the ps5 pro has 16.5 TFLOPS where the 3070 has 20 TFLOPS/4070 has 29 TFLOPS
Digital Foundry compared those gpus in Alan Wake 2 with ps5 pro, and 4070 is above 40% faster there than ps5 pro. Even 3070 is slightly faster. TheTerk in his video: /watch?v=4umMfrP99sU did great comparison in multiple games. And 3070 is the closest gpu to ps5 pro in most games. So yes, 4070 is obviously faster in most games.
Its really the optimization of games. Its better optimized on console than it is on PC but untrained eyes won't see those details. Thats why so many people are tempted to switch to console for the easy performance boost and price without knowing price adds up as the years go on
@@thecarl1013ofc in a nvidia optimised rt game lmfao. Check in f1 24 it will be other way around
@@k1cs1m3a8 Not only in this game :) check this video: /watch?v=4umMfrP99sU he compared some gpus vs ps5 pro in multiple games, and 3070 is closest gpu to ps5 pro in most cases. Optimized nvidia rt game? Alan Wake 2 runs great on amd gpus as well and dont have issues with memory managment and vram usage. And uses mesh shading and sort of direct storage, so this game is the best example in my opinion.
@@k1cs1m3a8 Nvidia rt optimised game? thats not excuse. 4070 is far better in most cases :) /watch?v=4umMfrP99sU watch this video. this guy compared ps5 pro vs pc gpus in multiple games, and 3070 is closest gpu to ps5 pro in most games.
PS5 is slapping the pc like its nothing
The water on the ps5 pro when she running is so fake looking. Like she running on cardboard floorm
Wow!! Ps5 pro graphic 😮😮
Theres only one thing worth watching here.
ahuhh spill it!!! 🤭
who cares about graphics, we have 400% dungeons to do, we need to see how that impact the console
Fix your PC bro 😂
hahaha
Frame generation sucks in the ps5 pro for first descendent everything looks good but that frame generation keeps fucking up the game.
Wow ps5 wins 😮
What is point of video? Performance? Quality? First is not shown, second is not shown, not shown both together. Pus TFD on cinematic settings, everything maxed out, RT enabled, native resolution, compare it to console, then find exact settings on console - most probably need some "ini" file and apply it to PC version to compare perfromance.
From maby exact comparsions we know that old PS5 was about RTX2060/2060S perfromance. Somewhat like Watchdogs 2, 4k@30FPS on PC with even more details as RT particles which was not drawn on console. PC was 100% time native 4k, console was 1440p-2160p dynamic resolution. 4070 is far faster..
the point of this video was that people was saying the ps5 pro is equivalent to that of 4070. so im showing what the 4070 vs pro looks like
SORRY PRO ALL DAY FRAMERATES ARE VERY SEEABLE...LET CPU's Stay in CPU's place and let consoles stay in Consoles place (PEACEOUT) I SAID WHAT I SAID
u said nothing but ok lol. be good man.
yeah definitely ps5 pro is much smoother!
Intel a sacado una grafica mejor que la del pro a 250 ¿que se siente al ser estafado?
I see pro can't handle DoF.
It’s funny how people think the PS five Pro is equivalent to the RTX 4070 it’s laughable
O ps5 pro está mais nitido.
I don't dude, there has to be something wrong in the capture of RTX 4070, it is looking like it has lower fps or something, it can't really be that bad for a game like this. RTX 4070 is quite a good card. I think PS5 Pro is more equivalent to a 4070 Ti though.
yeah i know. read the description.
There is also no way the ps5 pro is running all the other settings on ultra
ps5 pro is around 3070 and in some games weaker. DF has done video on it.
そもそも、ログイン画面にある、奥のディスプレイの解像度が全然違う
even if i turned off the blur the menu in PC is always blurred for some reason
Oh yeah, & ur right about the water towards the end where u run in circles then shoot at it. The RTX4070 water looks way much better than the PSPro’s water by a huge margin. Thats why I don’t be wasting my $$ buying the latest & “greatest” new console anymore since the Xbox360 & PS3 I got both when they came out. Now PC all the way.(& Nah I don’t meant that Protective Custody for any gangstas out there)lol
yeah by huge margin. the shadow looks better on the 4070 too. at 0:39 if you look at freyna's shoulder i think the pssr dont know what to do with it. probably something to do with reflection. the AI dont know how to resolve some of this stuff, it looks bad on other objects with reflections... its like it's shimmering and not quite good to look at.
QUE QUE BIEN SE VE EN PS5
pro 옵션 졸라 많이 빠졋네 ㅋㅋㅋ.. 그림자, 전역조명, 반사, 사물 옵션은 한단계 아래 옵션이고 물리 옵션과 모션블러 빠짐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ.
동굴안 벽이 다르길래 pc에서 옵션 조정해서 pro랑 같은 벽 만들려면 사물을 건들면됨.
ps pro는 4:48에서 나오는 바닥면 불빛만 봐도 레이트레이싱이 적용안된걸 알수 있음.
왜냐면 pc 레이트레이싱도 저게 중옵에다가 레이컨스트럭션은 키지 않은 옵션임.
피사계심도 역시 pc에만 적용되어 있음.
그나마 좋아 보이는 것이 프레임이 우위인 것 같은데 저 옵션들 다 덜어내면 pc보다 훨씬 느릴거임.
저 옵션들 퍼스트디센던트에서 대부분 많은 리소스 차이가 나는데 ㅋㅋ 멍청이들은 낚일만하다. ㅋㅋ
The PS5 is smoother overall, but the 4070 has much more depth/realism to the environment. I’m sure the 4070 ti will outshine the PS5. Great video!
yep. before i think the fidelity was capped at 30fps now it more than 30fps but i dont think it's 60fps but its smoother now and it's in 4K so i cant argue with that.
Jajajaa😂😂😂 what do you mean with " depht", realism
@@CesarAlbertoRiosNava you have google, use it.
Seguir soñando pobres.....
Ps5 pro-gre