When you are young and immature, you watch this and think, "Go away Raoul!...Christine and the Phantom belong together!" Then when you grow up, you realize that Raoul really was the good guy and the right choice. The Phantom didn't love her, he was just controlling, abusive, and obsessed. He was always "punishing" her for not doing and being what he wanted. Raoul was kind, giving, patient and forgiving.
That's exactly how I was when I was little, I grew up listening to the music and shipping the phantom and Christine lol. But now I totallyyyy ship these two :))
Kristina Cassandra Zaragoza oh no! I don’t recommend Love Never Dies. As much as I love the music, I hate that everyone was out of character. For example, they only made Raoul a drunkard who is in serious debt to have a reason why Christine should pick the Phantom over Raoul. Also, what Meg did was way out of character as well. Yes, I get that it was an accident, but she wouldn’t be jealous of Christine in the first place. It’s just not like her. Also, I don’t like how the events that occurred in LND doesn’t match with what happened in POTO. Why would they make Christine die at a young age in LND, but in POTO she dies of old age? ALW should not have created LND. To me, it seems like he only made it for money and not to keep the story alive. Because if he did want to keep the story alive, he should have made it make sense. However, instead, he made it into a wattpad fanfiction story. Now, if I view LND as a separate story and POTO never existed, then I would like it. But since that’s not the case, I don’t. So, I like to pretend LND doesn’t exist lol. But once again I still love the music in LND, I just don’t like the story overall.
whutzat the thing is, well first I haven’t watched this in a long time so I kinda forgot the movie but I watch the 25h Anniversary everyday since I bought it bcuz I loved it to much😂 but in one of the scenes in the 25th Anniversary Raoul is pushing Christine to sing something she dosent want to only to Laure the phantom and finally kill him, that’s kinda a reason I like phantom and Christine. Erik (the phantom) was hiding in darkeness all these years and he didn’t know how to tell Christine how much he wants her and loves her in a kind loving way so instead he did this, I’m still a teen so imma wait till I’m a little older to see how I feel abt Christine and phantom and Christine and Raoul. But the thing is in the 25th Anniversary to me it’s so hard to choose weather she should stay with Raul or the phantom same with the movie. Idk if you’ve watched LND but the thing that I love is that Christine is kinda with both of them so if u haven’t watch LND to see what I mean. But I just hate the ending I cried from sadness and a hatred for that ending ughhhhhh. WHY ALW WHYYYYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!
Definitely. I love Emma Watson but as opposed to her Emmy Rossum is truly a beautiful singer! Just can't listen to the beauty and the beast songs because of all the autotune...
Patricio Dillon I first heard this song in 2000 in a CD store. It was sung by Cliff Richard and Sarah Brightman. At that time, I didn't know it was from Phantom. Totally fell head over heels in love with it.
“Music of the Night” is the Phantom’s love song to Christine. He sings it all by himself, indicating that he is controlling and possessive towards her, and won’t let her be her own person. “All I Ask of You” is Raoul’s love song to Christine. This is a duet. This indicates that Raoul is encouraging and patient towards Christine, and lets her voice her opinions instead of making her his puppet. No wonder she chose Raoul.
I wish he'd sing more!!! Or do more movie musicals. His voice is SO beautiful, so warm and gentle yet so masculine and powerful. His vocal control is amazing.
@@addicted367 Actually I like Emmy's voice a lot, too! People said it was thin, but I found it clear, sweet, and innocent, and more fitting of Christine than Sarah Brightman's. When I said the rest of the cast weren't so good I guess I mostly meant Gerard ;) I mean he had several sour notes. Emmy never had that.
@@monmothma3358 oh ok gotcha 👍 yeah I have seen comments complaining about how her voice doesn't have enough opera. Well I'm sure if that's what the directors wanted they would have gotten someone else.
I always had a sinking feeling that Christine was betraying the phantom, that she left his deep devotion to her for a petty boy who gave her flowers and was nice to look at, until I realized just recently that Christine's love for Erik is Stockholm syndrome, and Raul is leading her out of a lifelong deception and swirling nightmare geniusly designed by Erik to trap her. I listened to this song for the millionth time once and realized that until she loved Raul she didn't realize what she had wasn't true.
Many today don't understand what love really is Nora, it is about selflessness, not selfishness, one who truly loves is required by that love to desire what will bring health and happiness to the one they love. Even if it means them being with someone else.
I don’t care what everyone else says about him, I love Raoul. He had such good intentions and just wanted Christine to be safe and comfortable. Don’t get me wrong, I LOVE how complex Phantom is. But Raoul is just great. (Especially Patrick Wilson)
Kyrios Same here. Almost every time I watched the film I sided with the Phantom. Watched it at the theatre on the weekend, sided with Raoul straight away.
I believe the Phantom's love was only really true at the end when he let her go. He realized the error of his ways, and let her go on being truly happy the rest of her days. This, of course doesn't take a way from how true Raoul is in his love.
I so strongly agree. In HS they had my choir group watch this movie and I fell in love. I was an aspiring opera singer at the time and I still consider phantom of the opera my absolute favorite broadway ever. I even wanted to audition for a part till reality kicked in lol. I attempted to watch other vocalists/performers perform this and I didn’t like it.., hated it actually. Their voices sounded good no doubt, but their voices just didn’t suit the character and the vibrato was always so cringe...but then, I went to see the live broadway musical (saw it twice when I visited NYC) and I cried throughout the whole thing lol. You can’t go to NYC and NOT see POTO! Nothing can beat the LIVE version or cast from NYC. (The movie doesn’t count of course. They’re both so different but extremely enjoyable to ME.) I wish I could remember the casts name from NYC but I plan to come back to this comment to give credit to the performers in NYC
How far Patrick Wilson has fallen these days. Now, he's just an actor starring in scare-jump horror bland movies and CGI superhero movie with paper thin emotional stakes.
RAOUL No more talk of darkness, Forget these wide-eyed fears. I'm here, nothing can harm you - my words will warm and calm you. Let me be your freedom, let daylight dry -your tears. I'm here, with you, beside you, to guard you and to guide you . . . CHRISTINE Say you love me every waking moment, turn my head with talk of summertime . . . Say you need me with you, now and always . . . promise me that all you say is true - that's all I ask of you . . . RAOUL Let me be your shelter, let me be your light. You're safe: No-one will find you your fears are far behind you . . . CHRISTINE All I want is freedom, a world with no more night . . . and you always beside me to hold me and to hide me . . . RAOUL Then say you'll share with me one love, one lifetime . . . Iet me lead you from your solitude . . . Say you need me with you here, beside you . . . anywhere you go, let me go too - Christine, that's all I ask of you . . . CHRISTINE Say you'll share with me one love, one lifetime . . . say the word and I will follow you . . . BOTH Share each day with me, each night, each morning . . . CHRISTINE Say you love me . . . RAOUL You know I do . . . BOTH Love me - that's all I ask of you . . . (They kiss) Anywhere you go let me go too . . . Love me - that's all I ask of you . .
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤I ❤ Jesus Christ my dreams and plans magkaroon din Ng magandang Buhay at Bahay open door architecture digest Walang mga maiingay na Bata at walang mga kapitbahay don't worryeye be happyeye yes amen thank you 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Lucy Thomas jellieyeye jisoo ninagiradosittijellieyeyenyasia
Lolol I thought of this at school when a teacher was trying to get us to focus and said "Just focus. That's all I ask of you" and I kinda laughed really quietly and this has been stuck in my head ever since.
Why is everyone hating on Raoul so freaking much. I understand that the phantom hypnotized us with his voice and strong appearance but he takes Christine hostage he doesn't have love for Christine. Unless love to u guys is obsession. Honestly they both have points on my board but Raoul can do much more for her.
I love Raouls character, but I just wanted the Phantom to be happy. Like ever since I was a kid and first saw this, I would always cry at the Phantom because he just wants her love.
Eh . . . . I honestly think Erik can do much more for her. Take away his violent ways--and when he is with Christine, they go away unless his mask is TAKEN OFF WITHOUT HIS PERMISSION (but she could get him to accept himself) and he could give her so much just from his talent itself. Raoul acts like he is the "tough vicomte who doesn't need a second opinion." But I still love this song between them.
I truly admire the tender love between Christine and Raoul. Erik is a wonderful character, but I believe he needed first some introspection or a good therapist in order to know how to love himself first, forgive the past and learn to "give" and not just "take" Christine is totally inspiring, since she could "saw" the very essence of the Phantom, as a human, as a living being, she recognised his inherent beauty and potential of goodness. In a way, Christine really "loved" the Erik, which I understood as the epitome of "love your enemy" and "love one another". That's true compassion. That fuels change in the most damaged people. But nobody is obliged to "save" another one. Christine honored herself and choose her freedom and happiness in Raoul. In the end, Erik let her go, because he realized that their love was pure, and he was trying to possess her while Raoul was risking his life to free her. Love is about appreciation. Thanks for reading... I hope you have a beautiful day and find an uplifting love that makes your soul soar!
Oh wow, you captured everything that goes through my head while listening to that song perfectly! Brilliantly said. Thanks a lot for these wise and kind words.
phantom has some of the best orchestral scores, when it first debuted it had the largest orchestra in the west end. its my dream to be able to preform pit for this musical
Coolest thing about the movie adaptation is that they were able to use a complete orchestra while the broadway version couldn’t because of space. So the movie is how you are actually supposed to hear the music that Andrew Lloyd Webber composed. It’s amazing.
I never expected such a wonderful comment section with so much love for the healthy relationship out of the two in this story. I was so sick of hearing people defend Erik.
No more talk of darkness Forget these wide-eyed fears I'm here, nothing can harm you My words will warm and calm you Let me be your freedom Let daylight dry your tears I'm here, with you, beside you To guard you and to guide you Say you love me every waking moment Turn my head with talk of summertime Say you need me with you now and always Promise me that all you say is true That's all I ask of you Let me be your shelter Let me be your light You're safe, no one will find you Your fears are far behind you All I want is freedom A world with no more night And you, always beside me To hold me and to hide me Then say you'll share with me one love, one lifetime Let me lead you from your solitude Say you need me with you here, beside you Anywhere you go, let me go too Love me, that's all I ask of you Say you'll share with me one love, one lifetime Say the word and I will follow you Share each day with me, each night, each morning Say you love me, you know I do Love me, that's all I ask of you Anywhere you go, let me go too Love me, that's all I ask of you So true ♥
Aaahhh! Everyone being so sad for the man who abuses, kidnaps, and murders when he doesn't get what he wants is exactly why so many people end up in abusive relationships and why it's so hard to get out.
you can pity someone but not agree with their actions.. hes a bad person but still had a tragic life. its no wonder that be abuses and murders when you look at his childhood. i dont think he should end up with christine, but its still sad.
no bro, the movie is made throught a lenz that makes us like the Phantom better than Raoul. the Phantom has a story, he has our sympathy. Raoul has a few lines telling something about who he is. of course we would be sad for the phantom, we can't help it a narrative strategy is not the reason people fall into bad relationships!! wth
Although I love this version of the song, my heart couldn't help but ache for poor Erik seeing the love of his life kiss another man. I could feel his heart being ripped in half.
He wants love. But he doesn't know how to express it. His first and only love, Christine was Raul's. I wish Phantom isn't end up alone though. My poor child, we was never loved. His only ounce of love with given to Christine. Yet she "betrayed" him. I actually watched this live in Auckland earlier in the week. I cried at this scene, cuz I could feel their love. And I completely bawled up when The Phantom was left alone in his dungeon, and sang Masquerade to himself. The dancer/performer actually started sobbing while singing, and I cried along with him. It was so moving.
+Alyssa Schwarz I believe that Christine loved the Phantom but she wasn't brave enough to choose him and face his darkness. She chose Raoul because he represented stability and light.
+Alyssa Schwarz no i think that in the end she chose him because she realized that the phantom was not stable and was in many ways very twisted. i think the majority of her feelings were those of pity that were directed towards him
The chemistry between these two is off the charts. Even when the sang on The Today Show or Good Morning America (can't remember which), the ways they looked at one another were beautiful. I hope they do another musical together.
PEOPLE DO YOU UNDERSTAND THERE CHILDHOOD SWEETHEARTS AND THE PHANTOM IS THIS RANDOM DUDE WHO MURDERS PEOPLE JUST POPPED UP IN TO HER LIFE?!?!? OF COURSE SHE CHOOSE RAOUL
Yeah and Raoul casually comes back 10 years after and pretends to be sooo in love but honestly I don't think you really fall in love with someone when you both are still children ..so I never understood how Raoul could be soo in love when he did not even see her 10 fucking years
@@analovatic701 they had a bond and frankly raoul's love for her was pure and out of compassion for her, whereas erik's was manipulative and rash. she was afraid of him, that's not healthy. Also this was the 1800s so... dating didn't exactly exist
@@Bettersucksaul yeah dating did not exist but true love did ...I'm not saying that the way Erik loved Christine was right ..for me it's just more pure because he loved her way longer but he just did not know how to treat people and love people in general because he never experienced something like that.
I'm convinced it was love but he went about it in the wrong way, trying to get rid of everything that got in the way of them. A little like Meg taking Gustave in Love Never Dies...
@@ghjk40404 Patrick Wilson is my Favourite Raoul as well. The only Other Raoul's I genuinely like are Hadley Fraser, John Barrowman and (amusingly enough) Ramin Karimloo. I've never really been a fan of Steve Barton's performance as Raoul. His rendition always felt Foppish and condescending to me...
Savannah Simonton When I first watched it I thought so too. but just recently at my fine arts school we actually did The phantom of the opera and actually being in it opens up ur eyes so much more, because though the phantom deserved love he was decieving her, pretending to be her fathers angle yet also falling in love with her. he wanted to keep her all to himself to a point where she would have no life, in a world full of darkness. and Raoul saved her from it. Its hard not to see the beauty in the phantom but there is a swirling cloud of darkness that also surrounds him. He felt like Christine brought the true angle he was out to the light. though I have to, admit her ending up with the phantom would have been a happily ever after beautiful ending.But thats why I love it so much, it reflects how life can really be and the true faces that love can have. and it connects to so many people
I’ve watched the phantom more times that I can count and all of shameless and it’s only recently I realised Emmy is in this and Gerald butler is the phantom!!!😂
This movie is my introduction to Patrick Wilson I was 16 years old when I saw this and I knew I fell in love with him that day. Still love him now. This movie is one of the most important movies of my life.
Emmy and Pattrick did such a wonderful job capturing the essence of this beautiful scene. The gentleness and warmth in their voices as they serenaded each other complimented the beauty of the lyrics wonderfully. Not only that, but the way they looked at one another with such longing (both), vulnerability (Emmy) and conviction (Pattrick) added another layer of depth to this powerful rendition. I was thoroughly blessed with such an outstanding performance. This is my favourite version of this scene by far. This song reminds me of the passion and delight we find in the Song of Solomon, and, after reading the book over I came straight here to enjoy a similar love displayed so eloquently and purely. Bravo and God bless. ❤
For a long time, I've been enchanted by the Phantom of the Opera, how dark, handsome, and mysterious he is. And to a small degree, I still am. In a fictional setting, it's downright sexy for a tall, dark, handsome stranger to seduce you with his powerful charisma. From the safety of our screens, we can be enchanted by this taboo. But in real life, it's a whole other ballgame. Real life Phantoms really are scary. They produce abusive relationships full of one-sidedness. I just came from watching Music of the Night, and it's an interesting contrast between that one and All I Ask of You. While Music of the Night is the Phantom asking Christine to give her whole life, identity, and willpower over to him, Raul in All I Ask of You is offering her peace, comfort, true love, protection, and joy, and asking her to give him the opportunity to give her all these wonderful things. And Christine wants that, too. With Raul and Christine, it's a mutual exchange of love. I especially love when Raul says, "I'm here," it's so touching and warming. :) I think the reason many people are romantically attracted to the Phantom is not just the tragic character, but also, going back to the taboo, what we may really want is not the one-sided nightmare of an abusive relationship, but maybe a partner who is good but knows how to be "bad", and by that I mean just in the seductive way who knows how to be dashing and alluring, not in the way that wants to dominate, control, imprison, and brainwash. The Phantom may have some degree of caring for Christine, but that is far overshadowed by his possessiveness and seeing her as more of a pretty little doll who can fulfill his darkest wishes. Raul sees her as a human being, whom he wants in his life to love him, but he also wants to love and take care of her. Don't go for the seductive request for one-sidedness, go for the warmth of a loving mutual exchange! :)
I love love LOVE Patrick Wilson's voice. I wish he'd sing more, or do more musicals, or release an album. His voice is beautiful, so gentle yet so masculine. This scene made me firmly Team Raoul.
They are the only ones that sing “Anywhere you go” together in the same note. Everyone else has Raoul’s part doing harmony, which doesn’t sound right. Only Patrick and Emmy do it perfectly.
To anyone who is on Erik’s side, remember that he met Christine as a CHILD. He GROOMED her into thinking she loved him. There was never love. It was curiosity and fascination by Christine, and obsession on Erik’s part. I can’t believe there are people who believe deception, mental and emotional abuse and manipulation, murder, and kidnapping is romantic and considered love.
123bardox “Love Never Dies” was not written by Leroux, so it’s not canon to the original novel. It’s basically fanfiction... Besides, are we seriously going to believe that Christine would be in true love with a man that groomed her since childhood through manipulation, emotional abuse, and kidnapping? He was obsessed with her, not in love with her. He didn’t even know how to love himself, so he could not truly love someone else. That was the whole point of the novel - showing that a person like Raul is the right choice, who actually treats another with love and respect rather than control.
Phantom was also a serial killer it's not very nice really even putting aside his tortured soul bit. he didn't have much in the way of empathy for other people what with him killing them.
As much as I love this movie, it's kind of exactly like James, Lily, and Snape. There is a big difference between love and obsession. James and Lily's patronus's were a stag/doe respectively. They were wonderful compliments to one another. Snape and Lily's patronus's were both doe's. The exact same. Obsession is not the same as love. Complimentary is different from need.
JItterRy PoKERy Nah fam it was definitely obsession. Snape had no concern for how she feels, only how he feels about her. He asked Voldemort to spare Lily but let him kill James and Harry, the people she loves most dearly. Also, he didn’t even bother trying to change for her, he went to practice the Dark Arts because she rejected him, which was because he called her a mudblood anyway.
@@erikaacosta6456 I mean... I wouldn't call it an obsession. Don't get me wrong, James was definitely the right choice, and I do see your point. But at the end of the day, Snape did overall respect Lily's wishes of not wanting anything to do with him, which is a far cry from what the phantom did and what obsession is. Snape's love for Lily was definitely a more selfish kind, but it wasn't an obsession.
I was flipping through the tv channels when I saw this movie playing during this scene. I think it was only less than a year since it came out and I was only around 9 or 10 when I saw this scene. Needless to say I quit flipping the channels because this scene alone made me weep tears.
Patrick Wilson doesn't have the strongest voice, but I find it very pleasant and to me he was the only Raoul I wholeheartedly rooted for. Great job in this movie.
Our high school doing a production of this in February I was lucky enough to get the role of Raoul and this is my absolute favorite song that I get to sing!
Patrick's voice completely embodies Raoul's character in the musical. Raoul represents warmth and light. Hence, his voice is calming soothing and clear. Which directly contrasts the Phantom who represents mystery and darkness, hence the Phantom's voice is powerful and intense. I really love this rendition by Patrick and honestly one of the few times I feel truly rooting for Raoul and Christine..
I am OLD, which means I can’t believe it was 14 years ago that I saw this movie! My friend who saw it with me…we were movie buddies since her hubby didn’t like to go to them…sadly, both he and she have passed away, about 6 months apart.
My English teacher in High School introduced this movie to us for our Historic Play topic and has had me in a chokehold for a long time now. This was my comfort movie tbh and it keeps on letting me get back to watch and be reminded how complicated everyone in the movie was. Acting, emotion, delivery, performance, music, operatic score 1M/10
The movie got bad reviews but I think the box office and the fact you look here and how many people liked this speaks otherwise. I thought this was a great scene which captures the dichotomy of love committed and from another POV love demolished. It is such a bittersweet moment and very complex, something critics couldn't comprehend. The phantom is the background watching this so there is an undertone that comes out after they leave, the hatred and betrayal he feels. If that is good story writing and cinematography, then what is!
as seen in the “sequel”, settling with Raoul was not Christine’s best option. Webber turned Raoul into a drunkard and a gambler who it’s implied beat his wife and son.
@@fulltimehater6250 you'd choose a murderer who lurks in the dark preparing nooses for people he don't like and lives in sewers and pretends to be ur dead father? Really romantic.
The Phantom's love song to Christine is "Music of the Night," but here, Raoul sings _"Let daylight dry your tears"_ and _"Let me be your light."_ Holy crap... Raoul is the Dayman to the Phantom's Nightman!
I feel the phantom's pain on a deeper level than anyone who has never gone through an unrequited love can ever comprehend. It is absolutely painful to love someone that you would be willing to give the entire world to just to watch them fall into the arms of someone else.
It's because Emmy Rossum isn't that great of an operatic singer, but I personally prefer her voice for many of the songs compared to Sierra Bogess. Don't get me wrong, I LOVE Sierra, but sometimes she doesn't know when to make her voice soft like Emmy does. She always goes over-the-top vocally, and I think Emmy's subtlety worked better, especially in this song.
Part of the Phantom's charm is that who he really is, and his actions, are unpredictable. You can tell that Christine feels truly safe with Raoul and that he would never treat her wrongly. The Phantom loves Christine in the way he knows best, and it's very hard to treat people in a healthy way when you've been so mistreated your whole entire life.. he probably thought he treated her correctly.
I have been Team Phantom, but I always very much liked Patrick Wilson as Raoul. 15 years later Patrick Wilson is still an immensely likable screen presence.
Ilike he fact she ends up with Raoul. The book makes it very clear they loved each other and viewed Phantom as his father or "heaven send". Also, Phantom was sort of a murderer. As for LND, it wasn't written by Leroux, so for me, it's not even real (but it has some really nice songs)
I will NEVER get over Patrick Wilson’s voice here… it’s angelic and softly powerful and full of so so much control and beauty. I could listen to him sing forever
Didn't cry during Titanic. Did not weep during Old Yeller or Up. Seen the darkest and greyest movies. None of them made me cry. I wept several time during this one. Deepest movie I ever witnessed. I might not be able to watch it again. The final scenes were the hardest.
Having heard Girard Butler sing and bring the Phantom of the Opera to life in the remarkable film version of Andrew Lloyd Weber's stunning music, it is still the most beautiful and touching performance of all the other performances by every other actor. Girard ButlerBrought his Phantom to life. Thank you so much for th.at film.
I grew up with Phantom. I always thought, 'phffft what love? Who cares about Raoul.' It was all about the phantom and his tortured past (read the book children!!) and feeling sorry for him and like he needed to be saved. The allure was his mysterious nature and the passion. Now that I'm older, even though it is all so familiar, I hear performances like this and think, 'the singers are young and don't get it yet'. And I finally get Raoul and his heart and want to scream at Christine that he is rare and true and to never let him go. Ah youth. It is truly wasted on the young!
I think Hadley's Raoul is kinda meh because he makes Raoul sound arrogant and angry (which Imo isn't how Raoul should sound). Patrick fits the role better imo
Brenna Johnson I think they did intentionally because at the time of Phantom's 25th Anniversary, Love Never Dies was also running in the West End. And Raoul in LND was bitter and verging on abusive. If Hadley did a prince-like Raoul, LND Raoul would've never been comprehensible. :)
+Purppear aj He shouldn't have been shown until the end. Here Christine thinks she and Raoul are safe that the Phantom won't find them. It should have been all about Christine and Raoul and once they went inside the camera should have panned to Phantom's hiding place. It would have been like "OMG here was there the whole time!" Of course if you seen the show its not surprising but it builds tension.
Captain Jakemerica are you stalking these women? Pretending to be their dead father? The phantom was not a nice man. He killed people. She never loved him. He terrified her and basically hypnotized her. And to top it off he tries to kill her lover. That’s not what a good man does. She loves Raoul because he actually cares about her and tries to protect her.
Captain Jakemerica, That happens to me a lot, it's always a Raoul or Christine taking away the person I'm dating. I've only dated 5 people ever!!! And I really liked them, friends I've had for years then some rich looking boy or girl just swoops them off their feet! Can god just let me feel loved for once?! 😧
![[#2024MAMA] ROSÉ (로제), Bruno Mars - APT. | Mnet 241122 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dgGqD28J6aQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Ed Warren. Saving women from ghosts since 2004
couldn't agree more hahaha
jajajajajaja
TheShockinglyEloquentDog woof you just gave my life meaning
i must say this ghost, is quite........ *possessive* - if you know what i mean
TheShockinglyEloquentDog woof Except she belongs with this ghost😭😭
My husband and I had this at our wedding. It was our song. I had it played at his funeral. It will always be our song.
I’m so sorry for your loss.
This comment broke my heart...I am sorry for your loss
That is so very beautiful and I am so sorry, Marianna.
It was our song for my wife walking down the isle
Bless both of you
When you are young and immature, you watch this and think, "Go away Raoul!...Christine and the Phantom belong together!"
Then when you grow up, you realize that Raoul really was the good guy and the right choice. The Phantom didn't love her, he was just controlling, abusive, and obsessed. He was always "punishing" her for not doing and being what he wanted.
Raoul was kind, giving, patient and forgiving.
whutzat 👏👏👏👏👏
Then LND happened
That's exactly how I was when I was little, I grew up listening to the music and shipping the phantom and Christine lol. But now I totallyyyy ship these two :))
Kristina Cassandra Zaragoza oh no! I don’t recommend Love Never Dies. As much as I love the music, I hate that everyone was out of character. For example, they only made Raoul a drunkard who is in serious debt to have a reason why Christine should pick the Phantom over Raoul. Also, what Meg did was way out of character as well. Yes, I get that it was an accident, but she wouldn’t be jealous of Christine in the first place. It’s just not like her. Also, I don’t like how the events that occurred in LND doesn’t match with what happened in POTO. Why would they make Christine die at a young age in LND, but in POTO she dies of old age? ALW should not have created LND. To me, it seems like he only made it for money and not to keep the story alive. Because if he did want to keep the story alive, he should have made it make sense. However, instead, he made it into a wattpad fanfiction story. Now, if I view LND as a separate story and POTO never existed, then I would like it. But since that’s not the case, I don’t. So, I like to pretend LND doesn’t exist lol. But once again I still love the music in LND, I just don’t like the story overall.
whutzat the thing is, well first I haven’t watched this in a long time so I kinda forgot the movie but I watch the 25h Anniversary everyday since I bought it bcuz I loved it to much😂 but in one of the scenes in the 25th Anniversary Raoul is pushing Christine to sing something she dosent want to only to Laure the phantom and finally kill him, that’s kinda a reason I like phantom and Christine. Erik (the phantom) was hiding in darkeness all these years and he didn’t know how to tell Christine how much he wants her and loves her in a kind loving way so instead he did this, I’m still a teen so imma wait till I’m a little older to see how I feel abt Christine and phantom and Christine and Raoul. But the thing is in the 25th Anniversary to me it’s so hard to choose weather she should stay with Raul or the phantom same with the movie. Idk if you’ve watched LND but the thing that I love is that Christine is kinda with both of them so if u haven’t watch LND to see what I mean. But I just hate the ending I cried from sadness and a hatred for that ending ughhhhhh. WHY ALW WHYYYYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!
She would have made a great Belle for beauty and the beast
Victoria Dyer yeah!
Definitely. I love Emma Watson but as opposed to her Emmy Rossum is truly a beautiful singer! Just can't listen to the beauty and the beast songs because of all the autotune...
Yes
I agree.
Anything would be better than Emma Watson in the role.
Probably THE most romantic song I've ever heard.
Ikr my soulmate will sing this to me someday.
Patricio Dillon
I first heard this song in 2000 in a CD store. It was sung by Cliff Richard and Sarah Brightman.
At that time, I didn't know it was from Phantom.
Totally fell head over heels in love with it.
Gosh this might just be on my wedding playlist moves me to tears almost every-time
Angel of Music
Nicholas Lawrence I first heard it from Josh Groban and Kelly Clarkson
Phantom: I want to own you
Raul: I want to stay by your side
Literally.
That comment perfectly sums up why Raoul and Christine are so much better together than the Phantom and Christine
Yay!
Raoul de Chagny We stan 👏👏👏
I really wonder who is going to pick......😂
I love when she says, "Say you love me..." and before she finishes, he says, "You know I do." It's just so freaking romantic!
I read your comment while it was being sang. CHILLS ALL OVER!
@@nathimoon same
I like that part too
HSADJFH YES
Emmy Rossum makes me cry in this song She’s her singing is beautiful
Patrick's voice... is my bias. For me, he has the best voice for a Raoul. It's so comforting and soothing
I prefer Patrick's Raoul than any other Raouls in the musicals, his voice is warm and soothing.
P for Patrick, P for Perfection. Not a coincidence. 😁 He nailed it, but I have yet to see a movie where he didn't. 👌
I agree
Agreed!!
France Magadia AGREED!!
“Music of the Night” is the Phantom’s love song to Christine. He sings it all by himself, indicating that he is controlling and possessive towards her, and won’t let her be her own person.
“All I Ask of You” is Raoul’s love song to Christine. This is a duet. This indicates that Raoul is encouraging and patient towards Christine, and lets her voice her opinions instead of making her his puppet.
No wonder she chose Raoul.
Great analysis.
Yup!!
Eh... plus murder and arson (in the movie) isn't really plus points for the Phantom.
Such a beautiful analogy, good job !!! 👍 👍
Great find!!!
Patrick Wilson is severely underrated as a vocalist. Without a doubt the strongest voice of the entire movie.
Yeah but that's not saying much as the voices of the rest of the cast weren't that good...
I wish he'd sing more!!! Or do more movie musicals. His voice is SO beautiful, so warm and gentle yet so masculine and powerful. His vocal control is amazing.
@@monmothma3358 I like Emmy's voice 👌
@@addicted367 Actually I like Emmy's voice a lot, too! People said it was thin, but I found it clear, sweet, and innocent, and more fitting of Christine than Sarah Brightman's. When I said the rest of the cast weren't so good I guess I mostly meant Gerard ;) I mean he had several sour notes. Emmy never had that.
@@monmothma3358 oh ok gotcha 👍 yeah I have seen comments complaining about how her voice doesn't have enough opera. Well I'm sure if that's what the directors wanted they would have gotten someone else.
I always had a sinking feeling that Christine was betraying the phantom, that she left his deep devotion to her for a petty boy who gave her flowers and was nice to look at, until I realized just recently that Christine's love for Erik is Stockholm syndrome, and Raul is leading her out of a lifelong deception and swirling nightmare geniusly designed by Erik to trap her. I listened to this song for the millionth time once and realized that until she loved Raul she didn't realize what she had wasn't true.
Many today don't understand what love really is Nora, it is about selflessness, not selfishness, one who truly loves is required by that love to desire what will bring health and happiness to the one they love. Even if it means them being with someone else.
Kevin R. Duncil so true, for Eric Christine was something he was entitled to to because he helped her, while Raul truly wants to make her life better
Yes Nora, there are vast differences between love and obsession, or even neurosis brought on by years of abuse.
Nora Eisele It's funny because she's Swedish. 😂😂😂😂😂
Didn’t the phantom let Christine go she practically runs out with raoul with zero problems from the phantom.
“Say you love me...”
“You know I do.”
That’s the cutest shit I’ve ever heard.
I don’t care what everyone else says about him, I love Raoul. He had such good intentions and just wanted Christine to be safe and comfortable. Don’t get me wrong, I LOVE how complex Phantom is. But Raoul is just great. (Especially Patrick Wilson)
Patrick Wilson is great, but Hadley Fraser is the endgame.
Yay!
agreed! raoul was so kind and good to christine. although i feel so sad for the phantom, christine ultimately was safer with raoul.
I agree! Then my friend told me about the sequel and it completely ruins it for Raul😭 but in this one I would have chosen him too
RIGHT, people need to stop hating on him, he was scared about what the phantom could do to her and wanted to help her :)
Used to prefer the phantom over Raoul when I was younger. But now I'd choose Raoul because his love is true.
Kyrios Same here. Almost every time I watched the film I sided with the Phantom. Watched it at the theatre on the weekend, sided with Raoul straight away.
You know I always sided with Raoul... When I was nine. Then I watched it like 4-6 Years later I sided with the phantom. LOL
I think after you've experienced real life relationships with "Phantoms" you realize all you want is something simple and true like the love of Raoul.
I believe the Phantom's love was only really true at the end when he let her go. He realized the error of his ways, and let her go on being truly happy the rest of her days.
This, of course doesn't take a way from how true Raoul is in his love.
Kyrios too bad she ended up with the phantom in the sequel
Patrick Wilson's voice cured my depression
Facts. It cured mine too. I still hear his voice singing to me in my head when I have my bad days.
Patrick Wilson and Emmy Rossum sing this song better than any other duo. I think Wilson in particular is underrated as a singer.
Emmy is underrated also
Holy shit I didn’t even realize that was Patrick until you said so! :0
I so strongly agree. In HS they had my choir group watch this movie and I fell in love. I was an aspiring opera singer at the time and I still consider phantom of the opera my absolute favorite broadway ever. I even wanted to audition for a part till reality kicked in lol. I attempted to watch other vocalists/performers perform this and I didn’t like it.., hated it actually. Their voices sounded good no doubt, but their voices just didn’t suit the character and the vibrato was always so cringe...but then, I went to see the live broadway musical (saw it twice when I visited NYC) and I cried throughout the whole thing lol. You can’t go to NYC and NOT see POTO! Nothing can beat the LIVE version or cast from NYC. (The movie doesn’t count of course. They’re both so different but extremely enjoyable to ME.) I wish I could remember the casts name from NYC but I plan to come back to this comment to give credit to the performers in NYC
I know its so soothing
How far Patrick Wilson has fallen these days. Now, he's just an actor starring in scare-jump horror bland movies and CGI superhero movie with paper thin emotional stakes.
Patrick Wilson was the perfect choice for Raoul. He has that very Prince Charming voice. So sweet, gentle and reassuring.
Patrick really needs to do more musicals. I love his voice.
RAOUL
No more talk
of darkness,
Forget these
wide-eyed fears.
I'm here,
nothing can harm you -
my words will
warm and calm you.
Let me be
your freedom,
let daylight
dry -your tears.
I'm here,
with you, beside you,
to guard you
and to guide you . . .
CHRISTINE
Say you love me
every
waking moment,
turn my head
with talk of summertime . . .
Say you need me
with you,
now and always . . .
promise me that all
you say is true -
that's all I ask
of you . . .
RAOUL
Let me be
your shelter,
let me
be your light.
You're safe:
No-one will find you
your fears are
far behind you . . .
CHRISTINE
All I want
is freedom,
a world with
no more night . . .
and you
always beside me
to hold me
and to hide me . . .
RAOUL
Then say you'll share with
me one
love, one lifetime . . .
Iet me lead you
from your solitude . . .
Say you need me
with you
here, beside you . . .
anywhere you go,
let me go too -
Christine,
that's all I ask
of you . . .
CHRISTINE
Say you'll share with
me one
love, one lifetime . . .
say the word
and I will follow you . . .
BOTH
Share each day with
me, each
night, each morning . . .
CHRISTINE
Say you love me . . .
RAOUL
You know I do . . .
BOTH
Love me -
that's all I ask
of you . . .
(They kiss)
Anywhere you go
let me go too . . .
Love me -
that's all I ask
of you . .
👍🏼
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤I ❤ Jesus Christ my dreams and plans magkaroon din Ng magandang Buhay at Bahay open door architecture digest Walang mga maiingay na Bata at walang mga kapitbahay don't worryeye be happyeye yes amen thank you 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Lucy Thomas jellieyeye jisoo ninagiradosittijellieyeyenyasia
Lolol I thought of this at school when a teacher was trying to get us to focus and said "Just focus. That's all I ask of you" and I kinda laughed really quietly and this has been stuck in my head ever since.
Florence and the machine
Lo is it still stuck in your head
Happened to me too
a wrinkle in time
ephemeralphantasmagoria hahaha
The fact Emmy Rossum was 17 and having a vocal ability is incredible.
18 вроде
Andrew Lloyd Webber: a freaking genius.
agreed gabriel...
Srhndb. Dah when she
I agree too! Also Hans Zimmer and Joe Hisaishi
Don't forget the original author Gaston Leroux :)
agreed
Why is everyone hating on Raoul so freaking much. I understand that the phantom hypnotized us with his voice and strong appearance but he takes Christine hostage he doesn't have love for Christine. Unless love to u guys is obsession. Honestly they both have points on my board but Raoul can do much more for her.
I love Raouls character, but I just wanted the Phantom to be happy. Like ever since I was a kid and first saw this, I would always cry at the Phantom because he just wants her love.
Eh . . . . I honestly think Erik can do much more for her. Take away his violent ways--and when he is with Christine, they go away unless his mask is TAKEN OFF WITHOUT HIS PERMISSION (but she could get him to accept himself) and he could give her so much just from his talent itself. Raoul acts like he is the "tough vicomte who doesn't need a second opinion." But I still love this song between them.
Plus he is not just obsessed with her. He loves her.
He murders,stalks Christine, and kidnaps, and you want us to just ignore his "violent ways"???
Angela Hsiao Yes, because he really wouldn't do it if Christine just loved him. xD
When Raoul whispered “Christine,” I got ~tingles~ because that’s my name too and the way he said it was just ahhhhhh
RIGHT??? It got my heart racing so fast haha
I bet so!
Now I’m listening to that part again.. WOW, I get your meaning. Is anyone here a Raoul simp?
My names Hannah so I can't pretend he's talking to me 😂😂
@@hannahm.9881And you don't need to worry about having a stalker and fiction turning to reality...
I truly admire the tender love between Christine and Raoul. Erik is a wonderful character, but I believe he needed first some introspection or a good therapist in order to know how to love himself first, forgive the past and learn to "give" and not just "take" Christine is totally inspiring, since she could "saw" the very essence of the Phantom, as a human, as a living being, she recognised his inherent beauty and potential of goodness. In a way, Christine really "loved" the Erik, which I understood as the epitome of "love your enemy" and "love one another". That's true compassion. That fuels change in the most damaged people. But nobody is obliged to "save" another one. Christine honored herself and choose her freedom and happiness in Raoul. In the end, Erik let her go, because he realized that their love was pure, and he was trying to possess her while Raoul was risking his life to free her. Love is about appreciation. Thanks for reading... I hope you have a beautiful day and find an uplifting love that makes your soul soar!
Very beautiful and true, thank you for your words
What a beautiful words! Thanks! ❤
Rosario AV he murders at least seven people in the book
Oh wow, you captured everything that goes through my head while listening to that song perfectly! Brilliantly said. Thanks a lot for these wise and kind words.
well said.
Is nobody gonna talk about just how beautiful and powerful the instruments in the background are?!?!
And I still love this in 2024 :)
It's my favorite part haha
phantom has some of the best orchestral scores, when it first debuted it had the largest orchestra in the west end. its my dream to be able to preform pit for this musical
Man, "Nobody" is a weird name. I assume that's your name, since you're talking about it.
Coolest thing about the movie adaptation is that they were able to use a complete orchestra while the broadway version couldn’t because of space. So the movie is how you are actually supposed to hear the music that Andrew Lloyd Webber composed. It’s amazing.
2024 here. Still love it
Patrick Wilson doesn’t get the attn he deserves. I’ve seen him in so many amazing roles👏🏼
I never expected such a wonderful comment section with so much love for the healthy relationship out of the two in this story. I was so sick of hearing people defend Erik.
No more talk of darkness
Forget these wide-eyed fears
I'm here, nothing can harm you
My words will warm and calm you
Let me be your freedom
Let daylight dry your tears
I'm here, with you, beside you
To guard you and to guide you
Say you love me every waking moment
Turn my head with talk of summertime
Say you need me with you now and always
Promise me that all you say is true
That's all I ask of you
Let me be your shelter
Let me be your light
You're safe, no one will find you
Your fears are far behind you
All I want is freedom
A world with no more night
And you, always beside me
To hold me and to hide me
Then say you'll share with me one love, one lifetime
Let me lead you from your solitude
Say you need me with you here, beside you
Anywhere you go, let me go too
Love me, that's all I ask of you
Say you'll share with me one love, one lifetime
Say the word and I will follow you
Share each day with me, each night, each morning
Say you love me, you know I do
Love me, that's all I ask of you
Anywhere you go, let me go too
Love me, that's all I ask of you
So true ♥
Thank you for your cmt
@@tuberosewithlove
Welcome.
Spot on
Love Patrick Wilson. He has the voice of a Disney hero
Aaahhh! Everyone being so sad for the man who abuses, kidnaps, and murders when he doesn't get what he wants is exactly why so many people end up in abusive relationships and why it's so hard to get out.
Phoenix agrees with that statement and will die on that hill
you can pity someone but not agree with their actions.. hes a bad person but still had a tragic life. its no wonder that be abuses and murders when you look at his childhood. i dont think he should end up with christine, but its still sad.
He was a sociopath
no bro, the movie is made throught a lenz that makes us like the Phantom better than Raoul.
the Phantom has a story, he has our sympathy. Raoul has a few lines telling something about who he is. of course we would be sad for the phantom, we can't help it
a narrative strategy is not the reason people fall into bad relationships!! wth
Mic drop
Although I love this version of the song, my heart couldn't help but ache for poor Erik seeing the love of his life kiss another man. I could feel his heart being ripped in half.
He wants love. But he doesn't know how to express it. His first and only love, Christine was Raul's. I wish Phantom isn't end up alone though. My poor child, we was never loved. His only ounce of love with given to Christine. Yet she "betrayed" him. I actually watched this live in Auckland earlier in the week. I cried at this scene, cuz I could feel their love. And I completely bawled up when The Phantom was left alone in his dungeon, and sang Masquerade to himself. The dancer/performer actually started sobbing while singing, and I cried along with him. It was so moving.
+Alyssa Schwarz I believe that Christine loved the Phantom but she wasn't brave enough to choose him and face his darkness. She chose Raoul because he represented stability and light.
same.
+Alyssa Schwarz no i think that in the end she chose him because she realized that the phantom was not stable and was in many ways very twisted. i think the majority of her feelings were those of pity that were directed towards him
This is exactly how I felt
The chemistry between these two is off the charts. Even when the sang on The Today Show or Good Morning America (can't remember which), the ways they looked at one another were beautiful. I hope they do another musical together.
PEOPLE DO YOU UNDERSTAND THERE CHILDHOOD SWEETHEARTS AND THE PHANTOM IS THIS RANDOM DUDE WHO MURDERS PEOPLE JUST POPPED UP IN TO HER LIFE?!?!? OF COURSE SHE CHOOSE RAOUL
Yeah and Raoul casually comes back 10 years after and pretends to be sooo in love but honestly I don't think you really fall in love with someone when you both are still children ..so I never understood how Raoul could be soo in love when he did not even see her 10 fucking years
@@analovatic701 they had a bond and frankly raoul's love for her was pure and out of compassion for her, whereas erik's was manipulative and rash. she was afraid of him, that's not healthy. Also this was the 1800s so... dating didn't exactly exist
@@Bettersucksaul yeah dating did not exist but true love did ...I'm not saying that the way Erik loved Christine was right ..for me it's just more pure because he loved her way longer but he just did not know how to treat people and love people in general because he never experienced something like that.
GOD DAMNIT THANK YOU
Ikr lol
I love the Phantom/Erik, but what he feels for Christine isn't love. It's obsession; it's twisted.
I'm convinced it was love but he went about it in the wrong way, trying to get rid of everything that got in the way of them. A little like Meg taking Gustave in Love Never Dies...
it's love because at the end, he gave her a rose on her grave
koolgirl1235 .. what does giving her a rose have to do with anything lol? yes, he still visits her grave but that doesn't mean he loved her. lmao
He fucked up her mind..... It's abuse...... He's like Killgrave with music.....
It's obsession AND love. Teenage girls (including myself) do it all the time.
patrick wilson is a good singer. they are so good together. ❤❤
Patrick Wilson is hands down the best Raoul.
Hadley fraser??
@@kaceydonnelly4821 He's really good too!
@@ghjk40404 Patrick Wilson is my Favourite Raoul as well.
The only Other Raoul's I genuinely like are Hadley Fraser, John Barrowman and (amusingly enough) Ramin Karimloo.
I've never really been a fan of Steve Barton's performance as Raoul. His rendition always felt Foppish and condescending to me...
Thank you 👏👏👏 He’s the best and most handsome Raoul. People hate on his hair. I think it looks straight out if a L’Oréal hair commercial.
"All I want is freedom. A world with no more """night"""". Ouch
Right in the phantom's heart :'(
Knives to Eriks heart man. So. Sad.
in my opinion...she should've stayed with the phantom....
i think she could have let him go a little more gently and respectfully
Savannah Simonton When I first watched it I thought so too. but just recently at my fine arts school we actually did The phantom of the opera and actually being in it opens up ur eyes so much more, because though the phantom deserved love he was decieving her, pretending to be her fathers angle yet also falling in love with her. he wanted to keep her all to himself to a point where she would have no life, in a world full of darkness. and Raoul saved her from it. Its hard not to see the beauty in the phantom but there is a swirling cloud of darkness that also surrounds him. He felt like Christine brought the true angle he was out to the light. though I have to, admit her ending up with the phantom would have been a happily ever after beautiful ending.But thats why I love it so much, it reflects how life can really be and the true faces that love can have. and it connects to so many people
I watched 8 seasons of "Shameless" and had no idea she could sing like this. Amazing.
I’ve watched the phantom more times that I can count and all of shameless and it’s only recently I realised Emmy is in this and Gerald butler is the phantom!!!😂
How is this movie already 12 years old wtf.
One of my favour Phantom songs ☺️
No, don't say that!! You're making me feel old! XD
DandelionsxFran it's called time flies, STOP IT...I don't want to be a grandma yet
DandelionsxFran I was four when this came out now its my second year of high school like what
Noelle Fritz, same haha. I have always loved this movie though, since i was little.
The movie comes from 2004
Played at my daughter funeral 😭😭😭 brings tears to my eyes each time I watch the film or at the theatre.
May you rest in peace 🙏
I’m so sorry for your loss.
I'm so sorry...may she rest in peace.
This movie is my introduction to Patrick Wilson I was 16 years old when I saw this and I knew I fell in love with him that day. Still love him now. This movie is one of the most important movies of my life.
Ha, I’m playing highway to hell on mine.
The older I get, the more I appreciate Raoul.
And this is exactly why I have been a fan of Patrick Wilson since 😭
Emmy and Pattrick did such a wonderful job capturing the essence of this beautiful scene. The gentleness and warmth in their voices as they serenaded each other complimented the beauty of the lyrics wonderfully. Not only that, but the way they looked at one another with such longing (both), vulnerability (Emmy) and conviction (Pattrick) added another layer of depth to this powerful rendition. I was thoroughly blessed with such an outstanding performance. This is my favourite version of this scene by far.
This song reminds me of the passion and delight we find in the Song of Solomon, and, after reading the book over I came straight here to enjoy a similar love displayed so eloquently and purely. Bravo and God bless. ❤
“Say you love me.”
“You know I do..”
I FELT THAT 💕
Raoul's hair brings me back to the first time I tried to use a curling wand
This song makes me realize how amazing Raoul is and makes me cry...so romantic
Gosh... so I'm not the only one that cried. ;) gosh its so romantic... I couldn't help it.
Who else wishes you and ur partner had these voices and singing a cute duet w eachother like a movie
Valeria Del Rio-Rodriguez meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!
*ME!* ;)
but then you realize you don't have a partner :p
For a long time, I've been enchanted by the Phantom of the Opera, how dark, handsome, and mysterious he is. And to a small degree, I still am. In a fictional setting, it's downright sexy for a tall, dark, handsome stranger to seduce you with his powerful charisma. From the safety of our screens, we can be enchanted by this taboo. But in real life, it's a whole other ballgame. Real life Phantoms really are scary. They produce abusive relationships full of one-sidedness. I just came from watching Music of the Night, and it's an interesting contrast between that one and All I Ask of You. While Music of the Night is the Phantom asking Christine to give her whole life, identity, and willpower over to him, Raul in All I Ask of You is offering her peace, comfort, true love, protection, and joy, and asking her to give him the opportunity to give her all these wonderful things. And Christine wants that, too. With Raul and Christine, it's a mutual exchange of love. I especially love when Raul says, "I'm here," it's so touching and warming. :)
I think the reason many people are romantically attracted to the Phantom is not just the tragic character, but also, going back to the taboo, what we may really want is not the one-sided nightmare of an abusive relationship, but maybe a partner who is good but knows how to be "bad", and by that I mean just in the seductive way who knows how to be dashing and alluring, not in the way that wants to dominate, control, imprison, and brainwash. The Phantom may have some degree of caring for Christine, but that is far overshadowed by his possessiveness and seeing her as more of a pretty little doll who can fulfill his darkest wishes. Raul sees her as a human being, whom he wants in his life to love him, but he also wants to love and take care of her. Don't go for the seductive request for one-sidedness, go for the warmth of a loving mutual exchange! :)
Brilliantly said. Thanks for those wise and beautiful words!
@@avelai9216 Wow, thank you so much. ☺️
Well said!!!
For the love of Mike, it's just a movie. Take it easy
You hit the nail on the head.
There's no musical on earth that can touch phantom..So so sad it's gone ..
Oh how I wish I were a soprano to be able to sing this :-( Beautiful
Jitka Graciasova I'm trying out for a CHIOR concert!
Jitka Graciasova ugh. same
Im thank ful for been a soprano
So glad I'm soprano
As an alto, I sympathize with this comment very, very much
I love love LOVE Patrick Wilson's voice. I wish he'd sing more, or do more musicals, or release an album. His voice is beautiful, so gentle yet so masculine. This scene made me firmly Team Raoul.
They are the only ones that sing “Anywhere you go” together in the same note. Everyone else has Raoul’s part doing harmony, which doesn’t sound right. Only Patrick and Emmy do it perfectly.
To anyone who is on Erik’s side, remember that he met Christine as a CHILD. He GROOMED her into thinking she loved him. There was never love. It was curiosity and fascination by Christine, and obsession on Erik’s part. I can’t believe there are people who believe deception, mental and emotional abuse and manipulation, murder, and kidnapping is romantic and considered love.
Read up on *hybristophilia.*
musicaltheatergeek79 Wait, first I gotta listen to the song. Can’t click on this video without watching lmao
musicaltheatergeek79 Not trying to kink shame but ew
123bardox “Love Never Dies” was not written by Leroux, so it’s not canon to the original novel. It’s basically fanfiction... Besides, are we seriously going to believe that Christine would be in true love with a man that groomed her since childhood through manipulation, emotional abuse, and kidnapping? He was obsessed with her, not in love with her. He didn’t even know how to love himself, so he could not truly love someone else. That was the whole point of the novel - showing that a person like Raul is the right choice, who actually treats another with love and respect rather than control.
Phantom was also a serial killer it's not very nice really even putting aside his tortured soul bit. he didn't have much in the way of empathy for other people what with him killing them.
They played this song at my parents wedding and that’s one of the reasons I like this song
NerdyGamer2001 nice :)
same here!!
I have to say, the amount of people in the comments saying they either used to or still do prefer Christine with the Phantom worry me slightly.....
As much as I like the Phantom I'm glad she chose Raoul he is a better choice really
same
@@snivewus dwn fm Dan sv. Rummn t. Huh hj
As much as I love this movie, it's kind of exactly like James, Lily, and Snape. There is a big difference between love and obsession. James and Lily's patronus's were a stag/doe respectively. They were wonderful compliments to one another. Snape and Lily's patronus's were both doe's. The exact same. Obsession is not the same as love. Complimentary is different from need.
Snape loved lily. He literally gained the same patronus as her and his love for lily was one of the purest. It wasnt a obsession
JItterRy PoKERy Nah fam it was definitely obsession. Snape had no concern for how she feels, only how he feels about her. He asked Voldemort to spare Lily but let him kill James and Harry, the people she loves most dearly. Also, he didn’t even bother trying to change for her, he went to practice the Dark Arts because she rejected him, which was because he called her a mudblood anyway.
this is my favorite interpretation, i 100% agree with you
@@erikaacosta6456 Preach
@@erikaacosta6456 I mean... I wouldn't call it an obsession. Don't get me wrong, James was definitely the right choice, and I do see your point. But at the end of the day, Snape did overall respect Lily's wishes of not wanting anything to do with him, which is a far cry from what the phantom did and what obsession is. Snape's love for Lily was definitely a more selfish kind, but it wasn't an obsession.
Raoul's "you know I do" at 3:17 is so reassuring and calming. Patrick killed it!
Patrick Bateman Pic is dope
Is there anything Emmy Rossum cant do? More talent then all of Hollywood combined
So beautiful...so Romantic...and so Tender......
So *tremulous and tender,* you mean. ;)
I was flipping through the tv channels when I saw this movie playing during this scene. I think it was only less than a year since it came out and I was only around 9 or 10 when I saw this scene. Needless to say I quit flipping the channels because this scene alone made me weep tears.
Patrick Wilson doesn't have the strongest voice, but I find it very pleasant and to me he was the only Raoul I wholeheartedly rooted for. Great job in this movie.
Our high school doing a production of this in February I was lucky enough to get the role of Raoul and this is my absolute favorite song that I get to sing!
Noah Ingold hey hope it was great!
Congrats on the role! =) ;)
Wow! I remember Emmy Rossum from SHAMELESS .... Now, I see her in Phantom Of The Opera... 😸😸😸
Patrick's voice completely embodies Raoul's character in the musical. Raoul represents warmth and light. Hence, his voice is calming soothing and clear. Which directly contrasts the Phantom who represents mystery and darkness, hence the Phantom's voice is powerful and intense.
I really love this rendition by Patrick and honestly one of the few times I feel truly rooting for Raoul and Christine..
I am OLD, which means I can’t believe it was 14 years ago that I saw this movie! My friend who saw it with me…we were movie buddies since her hubby didn’t like to go to them…sadly, both he and she have passed away, about 6 months apart.
My English teacher in High School introduced this movie to us for our Historic Play topic and has had me in a chokehold for a long time now. This was my comfort movie tbh and it keeps on letting me get back to watch and be reminded how complicated everyone in the movie was. Acting, emotion, delivery, performance, music, operatic score 1M/10
The movie got bad reviews but I think the box office and the fact you look here and how many people liked this speaks otherwise. I thought this was a great scene which captures the dichotomy of love committed and from another POV love demolished. It is such a bittersweet moment and very complex, something critics couldn't comprehend. The phantom is the background watching this so there is an undertone that comes out after they leave, the hatred and betrayal he feels. If that is good story writing and cinematography, then what is!
Whether you want to admit it or not, being with a "Phantom" is nice in theory, but we all end up settling down with a "Raoul" eventually.
Kay Lynn17 nah I’d choose phantom because he is better for me and Christine. I’m serious. She ended up with the phantom in the sequel.
honestly i'd choose the phantom just because i wanna live in a basement forever. im tired of responsibilities lolololol
as seen in the “sequel”, settling with Raoul was not Christine’s best option. Webber turned Raoul into a drunkard and a gambler who it’s implied beat his wife and son.
I'd only choose the Phantom because I love the night and darkness.
@@fulltimehater6250 you'd choose a murderer who lurks in the dark preparing nooses for people he don't like and lives in sewers and pretends to be ur dead father? Really romantic.
The Phantom's love song to Christine is "Music of the Night," but here, Raoul sings _"Let daylight dry your tears"_ and _"Let me be your light."_
Holy crap... Raoul is the Dayman to the Phantom's Nightman!
That quick few seconds when Christine said "to hold me and to hide me" and we see the Phantom crying really breaks my heart.
I feel the phantom's pain on a deeper level than anyone who has never gone through an unrequited love can ever comprehend. It is absolutely painful to love someone that you would be willing to give the entire world to just to watch them fall into the arms of someone else.
What is my life coming to, 😂it's 2:30 am and I'm eating a brownie and torturing myself by watching this and thinking how I'm so single 😂😭
why does everyone hate on the film Christine so much? She has an amazing voice :)
I agree
They don't
It's because Emmy Rossum isn't that great of an operatic singer, but I personally prefer her voice for many of the songs compared to Sierra Bogess. Don't get me wrong, I LOVE Sierra, but sometimes she doesn't know when to make her voice soft like Emmy does. She always goes over-the-top vocally, and I think Emmy's subtlety worked better, especially in this song.
+Nexol13 I agree with you
+Kailyn Wynn Well, thank you! :)
Part of the Phantom's charm is that who he really is, and his actions, are unpredictable. You can tell that Christine feels truly safe with Raoul and that he would never treat her wrongly. The Phantom loves Christine in the way he knows best, and it's very hard to treat people in a healthy way when you've been so mistreated your whole entire life.. he probably thought he treated her correctly.
I have been Team Phantom, but I always very much liked Patrick Wilson as Raoul. 15 years later Patrick Wilson is still an immensely likable screen presence.
She is very beautiful and has a great voice.
VitruvianVision I know :)
Crushingly romantic, I never tire of hearing this.
This mans voice is so comforting god bless
Ilike he fact she ends up with Raoul. The book makes it very clear they loved each other and viewed Phantom as his father or "heaven send". Also, Phantom was sort of a murderer. As for LND, it wasn't written by Leroux, so for me, it's not even real (but it has some really nice songs)
I agree.
Um... That's like saying he sorta killed someone with a noose. He IS a murderer.
Think Scar from The Lion King.
can we talk about the fact that when they filmed this movie, emmy was 16, patrick was 30 and gerard was 34..........
Oh... oh... oh dear.
Kaitlyn McCormick she was 18... But anyhoo...still way too young to play Christine
Kaitlyn McCormick l
gorf64:I think they had Christine the same age as Her actress was but I could be wrong
I know! ......the career choices we all should have made! (sigh)
I will NEVER get over Patrick Wilson’s voice here… it’s angelic and softly powerful and full of so so much control and beauty. I could listen to him sing forever
This is one my favourite songs of all the time 💖
But I was wondering that there might be cold 😂
+Kerttu Pänkäläinen 😂
Andrew Lloyd Webber is a songwriting genius.
I love this musical and movie. I memorized the lyrics to about all of the songs
Kerttu Ilona suomalaine army oh man holy shit!
His voice is so sweet sounding. It's so calming.
Didn't cry during Titanic. Did not weep during Old Yeller or Up. Seen the darkest and greyest movies. None of them made me cry. I wept several time during this one. Deepest movie I ever witnessed. I might not be able to watch it again. The final scenes were the hardest.
Having heard Girard Butler sing and bring the Phantom of the Opera to life in the remarkable film version of Andrew Lloyd Weber's stunning music, it is still the most beautiful and touching performance of all the other performances by every other actor. Girard ButlerBrought his Phantom to life. Thank you so much for th.at film.
Arretta Keefer Amen
This the MOST beautiful proposal song 🥰
When you're getting engaged, meanwhile there's a murder going on downstairs
Just like life...
Technically, the murder already happened. The marriage proposal came after.
Phantom catches them kissing and reels back.
"Absolutely disgusting"
That reminds me of the Potc 5 Willabeth kiss scene.
Lmao
😂
no matter what you think about the movie, this is the best Raoul
After watching so much ‘Shameless’ I often forget that Emmy’s capable of this, too! Such a talented actress!
I grew up with Phantom. I always thought, 'phffft what love? Who cares about Raoul.' It was all about the phantom and his tortured past (read the book children!!) and feeling sorry for him and like he needed to be saved. The allure was his mysterious nature and the passion. Now that I'm older, even though it is all so familiar, I hear performances like this and think, 'the singers are young and don't get it yet'. And I finally get Raoul and his heart and want to scream at Christine that he is rare and true and to never let him go. Ah youth. It is truly wasted on the young!
I’m crying, one of the most beautiful love duets
Emmy Rossum here is 18 years old, so damn beautiful, and so damn lucky to have kissed both Raoul and King Leonidas.
Patrick Wilson's voice is perfect for this role. He and Hadley Fraser are tied as my favorite Raouls. =D
YES
Hadley Fraser sounds like an uncle, and Patrick sometimes sings out of tune. My fav Raoul is the one in Assie's Love Never Dies.
+Superfruit Grassi-Hoying Okay. =)
I think Hadley's Raoul is kinda meh because he makes Raoul sound arrogant and angry (which Imo isn't how Raoul should sound). Patrick fits the role better imo
Brenna Johnson I think they did intentionally because at the time of Phantom's 25th Anniversary, Love Never Dies was also running in the West End. And Raoul in LND was bitter and verging on abusive. If Hadley did a prince-like Raoul, LND Raoul would've never been comprehensible. :)
Patrick's multi-talented... he can act & sing too.. underrated celebrity..
I sang this in choir back in high school, and it left the audience in tears.
This song is so romantic.
The phantom was totally third wheeling, that's how it feels
+Purppear aj He shouldn't have been shown until the end. Here Christine thinks she and Raoul are safe that the Phantom won't find them. It should have been all about Christine and Raoul and once they went inside the camera should have panned to Phantom's hiding place. It would have been like "OMG here was there the whole time!" Of course if you seen the show its not surprising but it builds tension.
Gosh I totally can relate to The Phantom on that many women I thought I could get with then a Raul shows up and all my hopes and dreams are done for
Captain Jakemerica are you stalking these women? Pretending to be their dead father? The phantom was not a nice man. He killed people. She never loved him. He terrified her and basically hypnotized her. And to top it off he tries to kill her lover. That’s not what a good man does. She loves Raoul because he actually cares about her and tries to protect her.
Captain Jakemerica, That happens to me a lot, it's always a Raoul or Christine taking away the person I'm dating. I've only dated 5 people ever!!! And I really liked them, friends I've had for years then some rich looking boy or girl just swoops them off their feet! Can god just let me feel loved for once?! 😧
The phantom is absolutely psychotic and probably doesn't relate at all.