We 3D Printed Our Heads To Bypass Facial Recognition Security And It Worked | Forbes
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 дек 2018
- Forbes's Thomas Brewster wanted to know just how secure facial recognition technology is today and how easy it would be to trick the system. With 3D printed head in hand, it's a pretty easy feat.
Subscribe to FORBES: ruclips.net/user/Forbes?s...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
Forbes covers the intersection of entrepreneurship, wealth, technology, business and lifestyle with a focus on people and success.
So this is what EMINEM does when he’s not into music
Looks nothing like him.
It a real shame that after 2 years, many YT commentators still can't tell the difference in the level of security between 3d "IR" data and 2d image "optical" recognition, where both widely uses in fingerprint ID a decade before. This improvement to mobile device because of the development of xbox Kinect and IR camera in general.
Anybody Here From Everythingapplepro?
Yes!
lol he is going to blow up this video
yes
Me
Yeah 🤣
This is straight up dumb. Those androids have basic 2D facial recognition, while the iPhone X has this special 3D sensors that manage to make a better scan and ultimately be more secure. It was obvious that the iPhone was gonna win (because of that 3D system) and the androids were gonna loose (because they have 2D facial recognition). This immediately puts the iPhone at an advantage. But, to all of those saying that that's why iPhones are better, let's make Forbes make the exact same test with Android phones that have 3D facial recognition systems (such as the HUAWEI Mate 20 Pro or the Oppo Find X) and we will most likely see the exact same results. This test is just dumb and senseless, because the iPhone clearly had an advantage from the beginning.
MIXED GAMEPLAYS don’t be salty just because the iPhones are better at this particular feature!
@@jackyarrow9442 WHAT?! dude I'm just saying that this test makes no sense at all because of what I explained you dumbass.
MIXED GAMEPLAYS really ?
Cause when one plus announced their Face ID which is fast, never I read such a comment from android user that apples face if is more secure ..
All comments u see are that how Apple is ripping u off .. one plus has better Face ID for half the price ..
Pay less .. Get less.. Thats what I would say... But sometimes u can get more but still it will be worthless. For example- THE BIG HYPED ONE PLUS 6T MCLAREN EDITION WITH 10GB OF RAM COULDN'T BEAT iPhone XS MAX WITH JUST 4GB RAM IN A SPEED TEST.. So Sad I know... :(
Strongly agree with MIXED GEMPLAYS. This test makes no sense.
@Big Foodie : I personally have a OnePlus 6 and yes, facial recognition is much faster than on the Iphone X but I also know that it is less secure, it is no secret if you are a minimum informed. It is a fully assumed choice.
since it uses infrared rays, you would need to heat it like an human head, and make the eyes a mirror for the iphone.
Thank you for the video. I tried to find the company how made the mask. no luck. Do they have a website? Thank you!
I love that they fail to test intelligent scan (face+iris) on the Samsungs
This printing head thing reminds me about mission impossible
And Seriously, why wouldn't it work...That company does some impressive & amazing 3-D Facial Graphing 👍😉🇨🇦
It takes a few days for making such a fake head, so cost isn't the limiting factor here. You can reset your phone remotely in less than a minute. By the time the head is made, the phone will already be long reset to factory settings.
Yeah, given that you didn't just wrap it in tinfoil. But yeah, on the iPhone I think it disables biometric authentication methods after it wasn't unlocked for 24 hours afaik.
That’s why you make the head first and steal the phone later.
If you had smiled at least once in this video, we also would not have recognized you
I always found it interesting how showing your teeth is considered friendly to humans, when many other creatures do it to show aggression.
Wow ,, LG . Surprising !
Now i will be carefull with my phone if someone brings me to a 3D printing company in UK to scan and print my face.
LMAO
I could make ~25 photos of you and print your face from home with 3d printer.
@@Bata600 photos distort the face, especially the nose, face id is really sensitive even to a slight nose job or filler
@@offgun6466 Well the trick is to manually patch up the parts where software is lacking. All too easy if you have 20+ photos of a person.
@@offgun6466 the fact is that even the dumbest but not really dumb biometric ai system should be able to recognize a photo because by knowing the camera FOV you can try to calculate the depth of the image therefore know how if something is flat or not, i can't do it myself but i know that photogrammetry software do work in this way
I don't expect perfect face recognition in 300$ device , I would buy it for a different reason,while I expect the best form a 1000$ device , simple as that , you get what you pay, and I don't think a face unlock is worth 500$
PEACE OUT I dont either, but Apple sells the brand, not the future. Nevertheless Apple is better than Android
Forbes has led you by the nose. There are many smartphones that cost 500 USD or less that has the SAME face recognition system as the iPhone has. The tested Android-smartphones in this video are special as all of them LACK 3D-face scanning which is present on the iPhone (and pretty much most other 400USD+ Android smartphone, launched mid 2018 and later).
@@kenbaeza lol no it isn't.
PEACE OUT how much is the Note 9?
peace out will probably say that the ultrasonic fingerprint on the s10 is worth 1000 dollars.
You need 3d head to unlock phone........ Remembered the day that expert said, you have to cut a person thumb to access your phone.
Imagine buying a phone off someone and getting a 3d printed model of his head with the phone in the package
Here's our solution: ruclips.net/video/djBNQ5UBz8E/видео.html
We use combination of multiple biometrics including video and audio
And the best security is the one you already had 40 years ago.
How much is 3d printer?
Whatever biometrics you use.
You need to provide a key or a pattern as you reboot.
These biometrics best way to hide your real password
The real test is registering the fake face on the iPhoneX and then using the real face to unlock it.
Wonderful
Should have tried "Intelligent Scan" on the Samsung devices, it does facial recognition + iris recognition and it's probably way harder to bypass with a dummy head
that print time though - would be faster to hire a sculptor if you need to paint the project. More of an entertaining idea to open minds then a serious risk to security on your phone.
What an enthusiastic commentary.
Where is the music from
How much its cost?
Samsung has iris scanner so i pretty sure you can't get through that unless you pull someone eyeball out
Ahsan K go check some videos related bypassing iris scanner with printed eyes and contact lenses. then come here and comment you dumbfuck.
I want you to retest it with android phone that have 3d face unlock..
i want to know how secure their 3d face unlock compared to iphone. Thank you
iPhone has an infrared camera that detect heat pattern. The dummy has no heat.
They should just set it to accept scan after certain number of eye blinks.
I had expected you'd need better eyes on the fake to make this work. I thought a lot of facial recognition relied on finding your eyes (the blacks of the pupil tend to be easy anchorpoints for recognition). That probably wouldn't be too hard to fake either, but I didn't expect matte plaster for the eyes to function...
It’s Face ID not Eyes ID. Although I would say if you want Facial Recognition then the only good choice would be the iPhone as it is extremely secure especially as it is the only phone with 3D Face ID.
What about the huawei mate 20 pro?
ha yes i want to get into your phone so bad i am going to put the effort in to 3D print a head to sign into it!
yall gotta watch Prison Break to know how to bypass this typa shet
There is an iris scanning feature for the samsungs tho
I remembered the video when the identical twins try to open both of their iphones w/ face id.... well, they can trick the phone coz it unlocks! 😂😂😂
Thats nothing, my cousin can unlock her sister's iPhone 11, and she's 10 years younger, but both wear glasses maybe that's why she can unlock it.
My old xperia z3 had facial 2d unlock since 2014
I won't be surprised if Apple paid Forbes!
Now in 2022 Apple Face ID has glitches, it opens to any resemblance!
What a shame!
How much 3d printer machine dear
I use iris security how safe is that
You can do the apple one using a bad picture mask but you have to have similar eyes. It checked the eyes and eye movement.
If I find a phone all I need is a realistic model of the owner’s head and I can unlock their phone. Easy.
Test make no sense. Why forbes does not use Huawei Mate 20 Pro or Xiaomi Mi8? Both using same 3D scan technology like iPhone. That would at least be fair. This is embarrassing. I will test which phones can best write to a memory card and select the iPhone to test as one of devices. Upsss iPhone does not have an SD card slot - So the iPhone lost. Same logic.
Jiří Mrázek because they are testing last year facial recognition tech. it’s obvious that the chinese phones you stated copied apple in that case. so no point comparing those. cz lagdroid fanboys barked that samshit brought facial recognition 3 years ago and apple is late to the game. but dumbasses never understands that apple is late because they bring better reliable version instead of just trying to show off who introduced first because that’s how they attract dumb fanboys like you 🤣
Triggered lol
They are not well known
@@warzonetamilnoobs8063 Obviously you don't understand what Jiri was trying to convey. It wasn't an apple to apple comparison.
Not to mention that Samsung phones have Iris scanner making it more secure but nope for this test they chose not to do it. Why? Well because apple and iphone.
For all Samsung phones tested, their "face-id"equivalent is Iris Scanning, not the standard facial recognition. This is not even a fair comparison, but a commercial for Apple.
And to anyone who think no one uses Iris scanning, at least a dozen of friends of mine uses it on their s8, s9, note8, note9, or even one guy who uses note 7. It unlocks RIGHT AWAY if you look directly at the top portion of the phone, almost as fast as Oneplus's facial scan and definitely faster then FaceID!!! There are independent companies out there testing Iris scan option and found it more reliable!!!
True , and me too i use the Iris Scaner .
I expected the iphone X to not work with the fake because it BARELY even works on my REAL FACE
Galaxies have iris scanner, so its more secure if u use that option
Iris scan on samsung???
We use two-factor authentication with Facial Recognition for added security. Either with PIN or ID Badge.
They should have used glass in the eyes. Like the ones used for prosthetic eyes. And nylon for the hair. Then mount the fake head onto a dummy.
I wonder, had the mask had better painted eyes (the ones on this mask seem almost intentionally unrealistic), if it would fool the iPhones too. They often talk about how much they focus on the eyes with FaceID.
i am artificial intelligence student face recognition also includes eye scans nd its 96 percent accurate more than our thumb impression so i dont know what all they are talking about yup to recognize one have to take the persons eyes too i dont know if its possible to make eyes patterns exactly the same using 3d view however i think its too critical to copy that
You should have used intelligent scan because it cant be fooled at all because of the iris scan.
I hope they can overwhelm the technology constraints!
I really expected more on iPhone x with more advance face I'd tsk tsk didn't see that coming
lol im more interested in getting a 3d printed head of myself for £300, could have a lot of fun with that
I noticed how his finger was anyways close to the finger scanner
Blink of the eye effect with 3D mould would've crack iPhone too.
Tamjeed A you have to look at it not blink
It's all about marketing for Apple
1:39 LinQ?
Now use intelligent scan on the s9 :)
i use a lgg7. didnt know it had a facial recognition security second to Apple.
So whenever you see many dslrs around you. You run away
0:07 : "unknown"
Me: Karen....
Thats why i use iris scanning. Thanks sam s8
lol you can use IR iris pictures to bypass it.
Plus who tf will scan and 3D print your god dam head.
Iris scanner?
I have just tried Huawei mate pro.20 and the OPPO.find X, my 3d printed head cannot fool these 2 phones!
ruclips.net/video/Liu7BgtkquE/видео.html
Is that a paid advertisement of Apple?
Even oneplus will not unlocked when put few centimeters away.
And that's the X- it should be even better with the Xs.
Minority report movie is our future
They should have used phones like oppo or xiaomi with real 3d face detection. The iPhone would still prolly win, but it would just make it more fair.
True just to be fair
even those have been bypassed. look it up
...it worked with the exception for with the iPhone. There, fixed the headline:-)
let's be honest. Unless you are a celebrity and your ex is not a genius trying to get your secret identity with billions of dollars. I doubt would have anough data to collect for the 3d scan, first, then spending the money to print it just to catch with who are you dating now. If you happen to be rich, the best security feature is having a low profile IMO.
How about bypassing the open up photo entirely and feeding the data from your own initial scan into the software? Thus you use the master data instead of trying a physical spoof entirely.
what about Samsung's eris scanner
how about google pixel buddy?
It would work in a world without pictures
Samsung is not facial recognition it is Iris so I'm not a techy but who else thinks that this test wasn't the fairest.
Also sub to my channel
You remind me of Rip Hunter. Am I the only one? This dude looks like he is straight out of the time masters.
Face id opens to twins,iris does not open
Crazy how people think this is crazy news.
All of the android facial recognition versions are a joke. They’re like “well ours is faster” but anyone can hack your phone. #appledoesitbest
android fooled many people and they are still there not able to come out :P haha even in 2020 :P ..
Apple face ID was hacked within days of release
@@mostlymessingabout 🤣🤣🤣 nice joke
Those videos are setting up alternative face u idiot...
That's why they built the Iris scanner...
The Galaxy S9 has intelligent scan that uses the Iris scanner and your face to unlock. Not sure why that wasn't tested in this video...
Two words mission impossible...
Why change in lighting only once getting close to iPhone test.
Wow LG
Why didn't they try the iris scanner?
Esteban Cuarenta Maybe cause NO ONE uses it
What's better 2d face unlock or 3d face unlock
@SP it's true they both do the same thing so I want answers
@SP well they both unlock your phone the only difference is 3d can unlock in lower light
@SP iv tried that and it don't work it won't let a picture of me in and my phone is 2d face unlock
@@SKYELOVER 3D is much better and more secure
Use the iris scanner Forbes!
Can please do this test for Pocophone f1
If the newer iphones will get screen fingerprint scanner, it will be surely great because no one could fool iPhone x
( my opinion okay)
Why dint you enhance the iris scanner in the s9 and note 8
Because he is testing face recognition
Apple wouldn't have paid him if it wasn't the only one with the positive outcome
John Bell Android sheep or Apple hater detected
Believe it or not, objectivity still exists in the fringes.
@@chamarasilva7700 lol, so eye is not part of the face...
It's not 3D stuff. It also takes your attention into consideration.
The intelligent scan of the galaxy is very secure....but now there's no intelligent scan😢
because everyhone has the ability to 3d print such a head...i mean who cant just go to this comepany to print a head so you can unlock own device only, seems really like something everyone would do... of course the android devices will fail because they only use 2d scanning...
Try iris scanning on Samsung!
@Sychrari and how? You can t dublicate the iris or eye
Valentin Face ID sucks but iris scanning is straight up retarted
Valentin well apparently they did by capturing photo of the eye and placed contact lenses on top of it. and it worked. go and make your researches first.
@@RishabhJain-rw1rq how exactly does face id suck?
but can you do this because it’s much slower and inaccurate....
Add a bit more color and shading and it'll beat apple
try intelligent scan on samsung device
Iris ?
*I dare you to repeat this test using a HUAWEI Mate Pro and Oppo Find X with the iPhone X and let's see the results.*
*These other phones shown here have 2D systems for their facial recognition and only the iPhone has a 3D system.*
*So why not bring Androids that also use 3D systems.*
*Is this test paid for by Apple or what?*