iPhone X Review: Testing (and Tricking) FaceID
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
- The number one new feature on the iPhone X is its facial recognition system. WSJ's Joanna Stern put it to the test with masks, costumes and identical triplets. Photo: Drew Evans/The Wall Street Journal
Don’t miss a WSJ video, subscribe here: bit.ly/14Q81Xy
More from the Wall Street Journal:
Visit WSJ.com: www.wsj.com
Visit the WSJ Video Center: wsj.com/video
On Facebook: / videos
On Twitter: / wsj
On Snapchat: on.wsj.com/2ra...
The masks were horrible
Hey! You've inspired me to make a song about cabbage! I've uploaded it to my channel & I'd love to hear what you think :)
ferrari888889 lol ikr, but apple did do the same thing with a lot more realistic and almost exact replicas and the Face ID didn’t unlock as stated in the keynote
ChillyFx lmao yeah I saw him somewhere as well.
ferrari888889 made from porridge.
Actually, they showed a lot more realistic masks and said that they had tested with these masks, but they didn't actually say it didn't work.
Not really tricking it. Apple literally said in their keynote that if you have a twin that looks almost exactly like you it will unlock.
Hey! You've inspired me to make a song about cabbage! I've uploaded it to my channel & I'd love to hear what you think :)
Chrono Cubing then how is it secured then if a twin can hack it?
Tommy Mercy how many identical twins do you see walking around?
Tommy Mercy twins and triplets are too common, aren't they ?
Tommy Mercy android fan boy spotted you know finger print sensor can be fooled by making a mold using hot glue gun? And anyone can open your phone while you are sleeping? Apple pay works with face id this shows how good and secure face id is because banks can't risk the privacy of their customers for apple
1:01 what a fail😂😂
Swipe up then you're in
Swipes up but fails XD
😂👌
She swiped to high lol u guys must not have an iPhone
Yes hahahaha Syzzle Clan
Syzzle Clan you prob don’t even have an iPhone
1:21 anyone else see mickey in the background
Lol
Lool
That ain’t Mickey! That’s someone in road races (With Mickey) 😹
I see a dude who works for college
WOW
That was a horrible mask. Of course it didn't work.
Go make one that works, it will earn you head lines.
Konata Izumi
Give me an iPhone X and I'll get on it.
LIVEFRMNYC
Okey, it will cost you USD2000 bucks.
And I will take 70% of the revenue of the video earn.
Are you in?
Konata Izumi
Cost me? If you want me to do something, you gotta flip the bill.
LIVEFRMNYC
Let me remind you something, nothing is free.
that was not the same face mask as in the mission impossible movies....
How To Make Sushi
It's you...
who the f*ck says that the mask is from mission impossible? Are you dumb or what? OMG and how many likes has this stupid comment...
OMG ITS HOW TO MAKE SUSHI AHHHHHHHHHH
Eton Messy Eton Messy it was a joke, dude. Settle down jeez
This Eton guy really take things literally. Lol
The mask needs to have eyes in order to work, if you have your eyes closed, it doesn’t work.
Luismabou bc everybody’s eyes is like a fingerprint, so it checks that
Sunglasses?
DarwinBlame it can see through your sunglasses, your eyes have to be open so someone can’t unlock your phone while your sleeping
That's a setting that you can turn off
2:40 her eyes wern't closed.
The problem is that it sees the holes in the mask and that is a big red flag.
If they filled in the eyes properly it would have worked.
1:56 the mask didn't work because it was was closing his eyes and to open the phone u must open your eyes
Also they dont look very much like her
still it won't open its most secure biometric security ever in smartphone and work flawlessly.
I have one, I tried it, and, yup. Your right
Why are people supprised? They said in the apple keynote that an evil twin can unlock it. They never made the claim that it was twin proof.
thats why samsung phones are better
girlsdrinkfeck how can samsung phones are better if a picture can trick the facial recognition test
Roblox Flesk Gaming Iris Scanner?
girlsdrinkfeck 😂
Roblox Flesk Gaming because there are other alternatives like iris scanning, fingerprint, facial recognition, and passcode.
1:01 Swipe up, fails, "then you're in"
Melvin Hej 1:02
@@stopplsok1816
💯% necessary
100 like
I am laughing, thanks for the comment to make me laugh
Melvin Hej HAHAHAA😂😂😂
0:57 dude is like " Wtf. Is the the iphone x?"
Red-Haired Shanks no he thought they were taking a pic 🤳 I think so *CHILL!*
VERSI0N I don't think so. He was looking at the iphone.
is that*
Red-Haired Shanks I saw that dude in the back lol
Red-Haired Shanks no he’s like “ooh what’s the password?”
3:37 We hACKeD It!!
Edit: OMG TYSM FOR THE LIKES HOLLY MOLLY!
**tries to hi-five but misses and does a spin**
When ever i play tag with my brother and i keep on tagging him he accuses me of hacking
BISH THIS IS REAL LIFE
Nonspecific Nonsense maybe I saw wrongly but I think they didn’t miss haha
WHO TF IS HOLLY. AND WHO TF IS MOLLY
@@play4keeps77 that would be me. That's my drug dealing name.
0:56 look at the reaction of the guy in the back
aryan kushwaha Lol, this was probably filmed when the X had just been handed out to reviewers.
o mei gud rook is yphone ten i rerry want on
Hey! You've inspired me to make a song about cabbage! I've uploaded it to my channel & I'd love to hear what you think :)
Sgt Brobee ji
LOL i was gonna post the same thing
my twin brother and I have to do this!!
LifeOfTwinz I don't have twin brother 😐
i did it wth my sister and it works HAHAHHA
LifeOfTwinz ..
LifeOfTwinz and you guys still haven't
gonna do it on the new iPhones!
Face ID is pretty amazing technology. I have been through lots of phones and different unlocking methods and the iPhone X is impressive. After you use it for a bit it is hard to disagree that it’s the best all around phone right now.
Right now bro?
@@ShaferHartright now for it's time.
If someone takes the time to make a life-sized, realistic mask of you, you have MUCH bigger problems than phone security.
You'd be literally in mission impossible but you're not Tom Cruise 😢
😂
1:00 then you just swipe right up! *fails to unlock phone*
Are you dumb??
The phone unlocked as shown by the padlock. She didn’t swipe up properly and instead of going to the home screen, she went to the notifications.
she said and you,re in and she was not in that is what he was meaning
Yea lol faceid is the dumbest way of unlocking the phone,iphone 10 is a fail too,fingerprint is far more better than face id
Stupid person learn how to observe properly
Cerus98 How do you know he uses Android? And just cuz he doesnt agree with you doesnt make him a fanboy and this is coming from an apple fan.
3:05 powerpuff boys
yoyo kian u
yoyo kian or ducktales🤷♀️
no chipmunks
Yoooo
My name is kian
Would have been a good video...
If Wall Street Journal didn't upload it!
Tech James Exactly my thought haha. I went to the thumbs up button to click it, then I saw it is wall street journal
ahahahah thats exactly what i thought xD
Tech James try brother sister twins
Hey! You've inspired me to make a song about cabbage! I've uploaded it to my channel & I'd love to hear what you think :)
Explain why? Does it really matter where a story is coming from?
1:02, I’m still triggered how the didn’t fully swipe up
thats because it didnt work
STEAL JUSTIN BEIBER'S IPHONE X AND UNLOCK IT BY GOING TO MADAM TUSSAUD S
lmao
That’s actually a good idea lmao
Or even a picture may work.
Did you even watch the video? *facepalm*
Aaron Bartlett the statues are close to identical, they look practically the same, and the depths and measures are just like the actual person so..
(the guy on the background)0:54 Oh is that the new X ?!!
amgad osama XD🤣
amgad osama lol yea
amgad osama lol
Lmao that was me when the iPhone 5 came out I was like is that the new iphone
did
oh no! I hope someone doesn't secretly mold silicone over my face while I'm sleeping and cakes make up onto it and unlocks my phone and steals it without me knowing.
This isn't really true, you need way more than a photo to make a realistic silicone mask.
TheGamingGecko why don’t they just do it over your face?? 😂😂😂
or just, you know, hope that you did not turn up the "require attention" option for faceID, and unlock your phone with your face while you're sleeping
I will just point the phone at your sleeping face to unlock it
OLDAWESOME0214 whoosh
3:03 Alvin, Simon, and Thedore😂😂
Rey Deleon oh my god i didnt even see that at first
0:56 that guy in the back just saw phone for the first time
He saw a big ass camera focusing on the women using a phone as if it was first one ever . Duh ...
More like he saw the iPhone X for the first time.
Marko Junttil
ψ Ɖǟʀӄηεζζ ψ It could be😄
why will i make a mask that cost more than a iphone to unlock it ! hmm aliens properly laugh at us :/
so a silcon mask costs more than 999$?
a piece of silicon and a carving knife costs about 20$ if your an actual artist? Simple forgery. Facial recognition has been around for 6+ years, and it has been proven almost useless for security.
Yes in terms of useless, it is useless.
You can chop one's head off and unlock the phone, easy.
AbRaHeM BM may be your wife will
Hindi old move song
the mask doesn't look like you
Shhhh she doesnt know
its all about shape not how it looks
0:55 I guess it was that big when it came out...
0:57 that dude is impressed
Alexzius hahaha
Lolololololololol
Alexziu
Lol 😂
You slowmo it
Arya the Faceless Assassin
I was looking for this comment
I Was looking for a comment like this before posting it
what if arya is dead and it was jaqen h'ghar all along
I knew this would be the top comment
Wrong, a girl has no name.
WE HACKED IT~ WE HACKED IT~
Hey! You've inspired me to make a song about cabbage! I've uploaded it to my channel & I'd love to hear what you think :)
Harry Hill haha you made a song about this
except he didn't inspire you to make the song lol, you released it a month ago XD
He/(she?) makes the video then comments on many popular videos to get attention/views. It works, somewhat...but has its limits. Maybe to get started and gain an audience, then switch over to actual good quality content? Basically, its (almost) free advertising.
WOO
The triplets are so cute! Imagine having three kids that look the same, they're just running around duplicates of themselves. lol. I'm still obsessed The Parent Trap.
@@MohammadJ60 😂
Aww duplicates
What if you hit puberty and can’t unlock your phone anymore
Vulpe your most likely to use your phone everyday so when you do, face id learns your face each time. lets say you dont have a mustache and you just put on a fake one, face id might not recognize you. but if you unlock your phone with face id, while your mustache is growing, then it will recognize you. puberty doesnt come over night, soo your phone will still recognize you
Vulpe
If your face ID does not work there is a place you can type in a password that you kept before you registered you face.
Vulpe
Who’s gonna have the newest iPhone at ten yrs old m8
THE XPRT GAMER
A son of a filthy rich person.
Vulpe that would be sad
"Do I look like Angelina Jolie now?"😂😂
No darling...😅
2:20
/ONYX Parker uiii
/ONYX Parker xD when she was making her twin sis xDDD
/ONYX Parker gpp
At 1:35 people will think: Bruh what is she doing😂
NjR legend true omg😂😂
it’s new york city, that’s not even close to weird
Boy Nobody iiii
0:23
*Vsauce theme plays*
XD
Lol
Lol
Finally someone commented my thoughts
Hahahahahahh
Why do we keep forgetting that if someone has the passcode they can still get into your iPhone.
Uday B or any phone for that matter.
Yup but still😒
Ikr, when it can’t unlock just use the passcode, it’s ez af. I often unlock my iP7+ with passcode
Shhhhh don't spoil the shiny new things
Because this thing supposed to replace finger prints that use to work well
"Photos can trick more PRIMITIVE forms of facial recognition... LIKE THE GALAXY NOTE 8 [...]"
I wonder how much Apple paid for that comment, or this review/ad.
^ IRIS scanning on the Note 8 is just as good if not better than face recognition on the iPhone X
If you watched till the end, you would know that Apple definitely didn't pay for that ad. And why would it have to pay for someone to mention something that has no need to be mentioned. It is true...
IRIS scanning isn't even as good as it. Apple haters love to make these statements but don't provide much to back it up. IRIS scanning = 2D. Face ID = 3D.
Hey, ever heard of contact lenses or photos? Yeah, people make a lot of them. and they're all capable of fooling iris scanning.
Why? Because it's 2D...
Iris Scanning isn't as good as Face ID. It's worse. Like a lot worse.
Samsung even said that the face recognition isn't a secure way to lock your phone but a comfortable way. You can't choose face recognition as a way to enter private folder because they know that this future isn't meant for that. So I don't know how I should be offended being a samsung user.
Yes, because my irises are two dimensional. /s
So basically, my doppelganger could come and take over my life - even my phone, lmao
peblezQ A girl has an android!
peblezQ c
peblezQ doppelgängers are actually real you no. idk if we all have one but some people have one for real is on RUclips
peblezQ but u can do the same thing if he even hv the iphone x
peblezQ
“ we had it, we had it “
- the triplets kid
XD
0:55 woah iphone x
lol. got it
havent u seen one before😂😂
Domino Films the guy
orange snipers OJSP dp jr. and more oops lol never mind
FaKi3 haha I noticed it too
SPONSORED
SPONSORED.
Did you even watch it till the end? Haizzz
ruclips.net/video/i4YQRLQVixM/видео.html
Kianaa p
Kianaa
One big True.... With fingerprint twins and identical person dont unlock... So.... Faceid is less secure than fingerprint or íris scanner
To be fair, Touch ID was never as secure because there is a 1 in 50,000 thousand chance that someone elses fingerprint would be close enough to yours to unlock it. By comparison, (unless you have an identical twin) face ID has a 1 in 1,000,000 chance that there is another human being with a face close enough to unlock your phone.
Giacomo yeah but that 1 in 1,000,000 its indicated by Apple. Can you proff that? I dont think in those numbers since we see that isnt so impossible to trick
lkcdlvk yes, it's impossible to trick, unless you have an identical twin. There is no video showing Face ID being tricked by anyone but identical twins.
Giacomo there is.
Giacomo there's two actually, this and another video
"We're brothers, we're triplets, we're identical. "
Their parents :- EXACTLY!!!!!
That mask looks exactly like you 😂
Hey! You've inspired me to make a song about cabbage! I've uploaded it to my channel & I'd love to hear what you think :)
no.
the mask test was a waste of time...... didnt look anything like the reviewer at all
:))) it so f*cking horor
Just out of curiosity.......did any of wsj videos get demonetized???
*NO.*
They're better than average youtubers
We have to respect this.
*totally not sarcasm
Well I mean they were the ones who caused this whole mess anyways but sadly I had an ad during the video so no.
The triplets go to my school
Pineapple Party FR?
Really
Same
Yea right
Reallyy??
Anything would guess that the masked lady wasn't the same person.
Jaime Carvalho LOL
But its technology, sometimes its kind of retarded
This will be in people's recommended in 7 years mark my words
Im just gonna stick to my Nokia.
Ghost Nokia What
Ghost lol I would like to have one
Ghost nokia is legend handphone.....like nokia 3310(legendary phone)
I Remember when my mom had a Nokia flip phone when I was younger and it would have these fading rainbow lights around the phone structure... ahhh the good old times
1:05 hmmm pause it
25 percent charged yet the top is fully charged
My life is a lie....😂
0:56 that's me in background 😂 ooooh look thats an iPhone X 😨😨😵😵
Hey! You've inspired me to make a song about cabbage! I've uploaded it to my channel & I'd love to hear what you think :)
Harry Hill what?
1:01 I THINK SHE FUCKED UP
SAJJAD SSS 333 lol
3:40 even the kids feel the cringe
You forgot 3:36
😁
0:55 that guy tried to look
mask just look like your face 😂😂😂
cuz that's the point no?
Bro she said iPhone 10 hahahaha
yeah cuz is the iPhone of the 10th anniversary it's his name too
HhAHAAH
smart brainz II
I have seen a few of these with twins (first triplets one) and it seems the younger the identicals are the more likely to unlock the device. While the older, they get the more they facially seem to drift apart
that guy saw his ex iphone x 0:55
The reason why it worked in the dark is because a light that we cant see works in the dark and puts a million little dots on your face detecting depth that also why it didnt work for the cardboard cutout and the picture on the phone.
"You know it's unlocked when you see the small pad lock open on the lock screen, then swipe up and you're in"
While still on the lock screen after swiping up at 1:03 hahaha what a fail
FlyingDeathShee
Someone should tell them that it doesn’t work with your eyes closed
lost soul why no? It's a face scanner, not an Iris scanner
Cerus98 yea I also just found out that they even said that they (apple) tested the phone to see if it would get tricked by a realistic mask
Finally a girl is no one
nop
Dulara madushan what?
A girl is Arya Stark from Winterfell.
Those Triplets look so so happy
It’s not going to work if you make mask because the person who wants to put the mask is different eyes then the owner iPhone
Tawfik Adem Help me please my skateboard is 🔧damage please free send skateboard please help me my number 0728099813
Dulara madushan - Yes, that's incredibly convincing and wonderfully executed. I'm sure your phone is exploding with people calling to send you free skateboards.
2:54 they were so happy to get to hold an iPhone X lol
When u buy i phone X on 2018 i phone XI premuim comes out
AeIpZ YT nope there will be no iPhone nine there will be iPhone XI/ iPhone 11
Kittycat Productions what about the Iphone nein
Congrats for being so good at writing Abod
When you having Burger King outside but your mom calls you for a fine dine... So will you vomit it out and dine with your mom immediately? (your statement seems invalid)
And when y buy i phone XI on 2019,i phone XII comes out
Nobody:
The triplets: wE hAcKeD iT
3:37 me when I find out someone’s password and think I’m a pro
You have to have open eyes when u trying unlock your device. Mask won't work here
1:04 erm... it says 25% Charged but on top right it’s fully charged... wut
0:56 I see man being jealous
Should have tried the mask with the sunglasses...i bet it would have unlocked...bam!!
3:05 real-life huey, dewey, and louie!
Facial reconigtion has been out ages ago and its not even ranked the most secured , even twins can open it, but.... the iris scanner is the most secured no ones eyes can be the same even twins!
Chanson Chon you are right, who knows apple May be working on that n through that iris scanner feature in near future! Its a business model. They will definitely do it!
Fraternal twin recognition does occur. Works with my brother mostly if we have the same facial hair
A man has stole a face from the many faced god 😂
What in the world was wrong with the fingerprint sensor this is so unnecessary just move the finger print ON the apple logo not removing the logo but make the logo able to register fingerprints it's really not that confusing
*10 years later* maybe
Golden Joy I have an lg g5 so yeah but he means turn the logo into a sensor
What if you grew a beard and shaved it, would it still let you in?
If you grow a beard over time, it will recognise you. After shaving off, since your face will go through a drastic change, it won't. However, you can just unlock it with your passcode again and change your Face ID. That easy.
Yo thanks for the real answer. Those are pretty rare to get on the Internet. Appreciate it.
Sarah Brooks I think it just didn't work in this case only because I saw another RUclipsr put a fake mustache on and it still worked...
It will still work if you grew a moustache or a beard.. It learns ur face, and dnt worry about shaving ur moustache or beard off, because it will recognize you.
Yes
1:26 its bc it puts around 30k+ infared dots around you
3:03 Theodore Simon Alive XD
you should test this with putting a sunglass on the mask 2:45
Both the picture test and the mask test were really not done great. Picture test why it was done bad. It's call 3d face id because face isn't flat also the picture used in this test is tottaly bigger than the normal face. Also it's outside there's a glare coming from lights. The mask test why was it done bad. because the mask has idk hollow eyeballs maybe? Also the mask wasn't really put on the person correctly. It was just kinda laying on top.
Cerus98 look stop defending the video and look at the facts. Why do the face mold thing if you know it's going to pass. Get my point? And it was a badly done mask too btw.
Also the software would be like gurl why chu got 2 big holes in yo eyes. Daz no u!
VERY TRUE ✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️
1:02 “Then you swipe up” *Fails to swipe up*
Spam replay it. It also says BA BA BA BA BA BA
iPhones are really fun to play with. Truly enjoyed watching this. 🖤
I would be that in the background guy at 0:56 😂
When she said a “Siri’s” who else’s Siri activated 😂
0:25 reminds GOT arya stark slaughtering walder frey🔥😂
The mask just gave iphone X a nightmare.
Such a cool video, it goes to show just how secure Face ID is, and had some interesting tests done😄
Obviously sponsored
Mike Messiah uu
Why would it be sponsored...
If it was it would be shown in the beginning by youtube
It literally showed the Face ID getting fooled...
She called galaxy s8 facial recognition system primitive. Not sponsored at all LOL
Last part was amazing
*The mask needs heat because the infrared on the iphone x detects face heat. The mask has no heat. Heat the mask then maybe it will work.*
Emin Nart shape and heat but apple will not say it detects heat then people will know how to trick it with a mask.
And add a pair of fake eyeballs to it because if you try to put that mask on a different shaped head it will definetly wont work.. -.-"
well... I believe that the dot pattern clearly brings rough 3D shape information mainly to ensure there is a real face put in front of the camera (and not a simple fake printed picture on paper). However, the plain NIR image of the face must be the most interesting one to analyze for Face ID for authentification purpose since NIR light does penetrate 0.3 - 1.0 mm within skin = NIR face image must be most interesting one for features identification purpose. It is more or less confirmed by this video where a printed face on textile t-shirt (or face printed on plastic mask) is used to attempt to trick the Face ID system: however, NIR image of printed face on textile or plastic mask cannot reflect typical skin reflectance in NIR.... since it will rather reveal the raw plastic material base itself, the NIR light penetrating through the printed layer which will be transparent if not thick enough in NIR rnage... Therefore it is for sure not the right approach as is to trick the face ID method. One should study NIR face images as a starting point to understand what the Face ID camera is using as baseline for features identification. Then print this well understood NIR face image on a plastic mask with a material as close as possible to skin reflectance (e.g. some wax or silicon type with well selected pigments?) and as homogeneous and thick (1mm) as possible to ensure the NIR light that penetrate the first layer material's doesn't reach the plastic raw material base of the mask itself. Lot of fun for iFixit and others to explore all these scenarios... and lot of interesting future mask printing services for the ones that will succeed to trick this effectively :)
ggbaroon it works in the dark so it detects face heat using the ir and also face musle movement even the very slightest so it knows it is an alive face not a static object. Also it detects eye ball movement.
bushgreen that could be possible but what I’ve been thinking is that it layers out every part of your face with the sensors by noting how far everything is.
1:02
“swipe up and you’re in!”
*swipes up*
*shows notifications*
BRUH
Nelson you late watcher can you shut up or go back to roblox
Why don’t you go back to being salty
Nelson im salty? *BRUH*
You are tho *BRUH*
Nelson yeah you cant even make a great content like them so i’d stay quiet if i was a no lige kid playing roblox and that late to watch the video.
the mask looks like deli meat
1:00 when she swiped up and it opened notification center had me deaddddddd 🤣🤣🤣
0:57 " mom its iphone x"
these three young lads might be happy now, but let them grow to like 15 and I want to know if theyre happy about their brothers being able to unlock the others devices
Or sh@g each others girlfriends 😂
2:44 i think this test should be nullified, because as mentioned earlier, the Iphone X uses an infrared camera which can see only things with temperature, so it can detect the temperature of your face. Conclusion: i think that it should work if the mask was warmed up at body temperature, or, to be accurate, face temperature 🤓
Faceid not working when u close your eyes. So please paint an eye and check it whether it's working or not.