How a Kick Cost GWS an AFL Premiership

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 авг 2024
  • IG: / jaggerskilbeck
    Thanks to Nick McPhate for writing this piece.
    What If's are fascinating footy topics, especially those that involve long-winded ripple effects. When Nick sent me the concept and script for this video I couldn't say no. Dustin Martin creates some impressive butterfly effects.
    Thanks for watching!
    / jworld110
  • СпортСпорт

Комментарии • 469

  • @timwillcoxfunnyguy
    @timwillcoxfunnyguy 3 года назад +675

    Really enjoy these, not enough AFL content like this out there

    • @baxy219
      @baxy219 3 года назад

      Same

    • @vlillachy1933
      @vlillachy1933 3 года назад +5

      i reckon there’s literally 0 other content out there on footy. so glad i find jagger

    • @liamon1padyt789
      @liamon1padyt789 3 года назад +1

      Look at Aussie Thingz he makes awesome content!

    • @adelaidecrowsrdabest
      @adelaidecrowsrdabest 3 года назад +1

      Hey Tim! Andy Munro here ahah

    • @timwillcoxfunnyguy
      @timwillcoxfunnyguy 3 года назад

      @@adelaidecrowsrdabest Andrew whats goin arrrrn

  • @sauce2383
    @sauce2383 3 года назад +266

    Honestly if the AFL was a global sport your channel would be so huge, all us Australians appreciate you

    • @tsukiyunoda
      @tsukiyunoda 3 года назад

      Do you reckon it should go global ?

    • @HudHudProductions
      @HudHudProductions 3 года назад +3

      @@tsukiyunoda they should at least add a NZ team like the NRL

    • @HudHudProductions
      @HudHudProductions 2 года назад

      @J G yeah I love the part where they score a goal every game

    • @tsukiyunoda
      @tsukiyunoda 2 года назад

      @J G Wikipedia steals your IP address be careful dude

    • @hamishphistopholoes6540
      @hamishphistopholoes6540 2 года назад

      @J G Soccer: beloved by lady boys the world over...

  • @djstorey
    @djstorey 3 года назад +276

    Wow. Almost scary to think how much of an impact one kick has had on a whole decade, elite work mate

    • @Cuzjudd
      @Cuzjudd 2 года назад +2

      2 actually, counting Tamblings

    • @swishprodzz05
      @swishprodzz05 2 года назад +1

      Hi

    • @LeroyRifkin
      @LeroyRifkin 2 года назад +3

      If you wanna believe what you see on youtube

  • @BD-yl5mh
    @BD-yl5mh 3 года назад +121

    Someone needs to track down McMahon and show him this
    This is one of the things I love about footy. It’s a distillation of the butterfly effect. You normally can’t pin it all down to single moments like this but every single thing that happens at a club becomes part of its story, and whenever that club achieves success, all of that stuff was part of that story.

  • @versaarchi
    @versaarchi 3 года назад +481

    As a tiger's fan, this is the scariest alternate reality.

    • @versaarchi
      @versaarchi 3 года назад +1

      @Sasha Taylor Rocky ride indeed

    • @cryptic6917
      @cryptic6917 3 года назад +1

      it'd be a scary alternate reality for the whole league really if Jordy McMahon missed

    • @BlackGateofMordor
      @BlackGateofMordor 3 года назад +11

      I remember watching this moment in the stands, and for whatever reason at the time it felt breathtaking, like something miraculous had occurred. If only I had known at the time just how good it was.

    • @zachmair7299
      @zachmair7299 3 года назад +9

      As a giants fan im pissed

    • @versaarchi
      @versaarchi 3 года назад +1

      @@zachmair7299 Oh I can imagine your pain.

  • @ShezzasVideos
    @ShezzasVideos 3 года назад +237

    Thank you for coming back mate. We love the content

    • @tommy1283
      @tommy1283 3 года назад +1

      Too true👌

    • @DS_2K
      @DS_2K 2 года назад

      Wsg shezza

  • @andrewjameskelly7991
    @andrewjameskelly7991 2 года назад +10

    Can’t believe I was at that game as a Melbourne fan. I remember it so vividly, the crowd going nuts as the ball went through was honestly heart crushing as a 8 year old

  • @brendezen
    @brendezen 2 года назад +11

    Easily the best footy channel out there. Quality over quantity. Appreciate your unique style of storytelling. Your content is timeless and will become classic over time and a legacy you can leave behind.

  • @klokar21
    @klokar21 3 года назад +22

    i would love to see a video on Geelong and their unparralled stay at the top end of the ladder, your content is amazing and there is nothing else like this

  • @the_vortexian
    @the_vortexian 3 года назад +86

    as a Giants fan this hurts a lot, thanks!

    • @darcy399
      @darcy399 3 года назад +2

      on behalf of him no worries hopefully you can get one later this decade

    • @the_vortexian
      @the_vortexian 3 года назад +3

      @@darcy399 should’ve had one in 2016, 2019 maybe if we didn’t shit the bed

    • @TotalDramaOwenandNoah
      @TotalDramaOwenandNoah 3 года назад +1

      @@the_vortexian yeah you should have easily won that preliminary in 2016 and beat the swans in the gf, 2019, maybe not, Richmond were dominating the finals

    • @oldmate6005
      @oldmate6005 3 года назад +1

      @@the_vortexian sneaky chance this year

    • @Adroyo
      @Adroyo 2 года назад

      We've finished 7th now mate, we got this haha.

  • @Spratdragon
    @Spratdragon 3 года назад +10

    I can see the amount of hard work put into this. Just cracked a beer and really enjoyed this. Made my night after Richmonds terrible season. Thank you.

  • @TheAlphaDingo
    @TheAlphaDingo 3 года назад +12

    Great video and an amazing 'what if' scenario to ponder. As a long suffering Tigers fan, this truly was a monumental moment that helped transform the trajectory of the club. Funnily enough, I still remember being upset with some Melbourne supporting mates who gloated that tanking and getting picks 1 and 2 was better than a meaningless win. I remember being sad that a number 1 pick in Scully who was a Tigers fan growing up, and who could have been a messiah type figure to rescue the club from mediocrity would be playing for another team. Funny how things work out. Dusty became that figure. Though on a side note, it's a shame to see highly promising careers never materialise due to injuries and other factors. Would have loved to have seen both Scully and Trengrove fulfill their potential - and Vickery and Tambling for that matter too. Both were, are and have been maligned but their contributions here were vital and at the end of the day, they are people just trying to live their lives who don't deserve abuse and ridicule. Had the pleasure of meeting Tambling once during a preseaon visit to my home town growing up and he was polite, friendly and nothing but a good bloke.

  • @Rapsciddy31
    @Rapsciddy31 3 года назад +4

    Thank you sir for providing content like this for the AFL. As a 2014 RUclips-raised nba fan where I would spend 25 hours a day watching and learning more about the sport of basketball at the highest level. I can commend content like this for the best sport in the world.
    You’ll be reaching people across the globe, heck I’m the only person who know who Giannis is at my Aussie school. And this content can translate that for AFL fans too. Keep grinding my brother, good things are most sure to come.

  • @bronteb8762
    @bronteb8762 3 года назад +11

    You are bloody good at working this butterfly effect mate!
    - as a Crows fan, I say that Richard Tambling kick may have cost us a premiership as well :D

  • @xmjordy332
    @xmjordy332 3 года назад +30

    love this! even as a tigers fan. a unique perspective that no one really has tried for AFL. keep up the great work!

  • @notploper5630
    @notploper5630 2 года назад +5

    You should do a video on Issac smith’s miss after the siren against Geelong in 2016 and how it potentially cost Hawthorn a 4th premiership in a row. Love the videos man

  • @HH-je3sh
    @HH-je3sh 3 года назад +32

    No one:
    Jagger Skillbeck: Dustin Martin doesn’t go to Richmond and this causes WW3

  • @tynanwarren9211
    @tynanwarren9211 3 года назад

    I look forward to these videos they are by far some of my favourite footy content, keep it up man I love it!

  • @RayNoorAly
    @RayNoorAly 3 года назад

    Your analysis is always a joy to watch. Thank you for making these.

  • @samcrispino821
    @samcrispino821 3 года назад +11

    Love your editing and your content in general!

  • @AussieAzure
    @AussieAzure 3 года назад +3

    Found you on my recommended. This is some of the best AFL content out there

  • @zachgratton1488
    @zachgratton1488 3 года назад +2

    Good job. The Sam Mitchell tackle is another one. Saved Clarkos job in 2010 and eventually lead to the three-peat.

  • @zach336
    @zach336 2 года назад

    This is brilliant, love your work! Firstly the concept, and then the research that's gone into this... Can't wait for more

  • @mintotv8395
    @mintotv8395 3 года назад +1

    Glad to see your content finally getting some recognition great stuff

  • @thedarkman4901
    @thedarkman4901 3 года назад +2

    I like these scenarios as they play in facets of life & history.
    A guy on FB put forward a theory about a Hawthorn/Melbourne match late in the 1964 season. Melbourne win a tight match in the last minute at Glenferrie, win the minor premiership by half a game from three other teams with Hawthorn 1 game out of the 4.
    Had Hawthorn won, Melbourne don’t win the premiership, Norm Smith is asked to step aside & Barassi becomes captain/coach. Under Barassi, Melbourne win more premierships & avoid being a joke for 57 years.

  • @litespeed2191
    @litespeed2191 3 года назад +1

    Holy shit, dude. Such a well put together video. On my 3rd watch now, can't believe it...makes me wonder how many other game-changing scenarios on a similar level were so close to happening...this is definitely up there with some of the biggest though, for sure
    Very well done, appreciate this

  • @kingcrom6799
    @kingcrom6799 3 года назад +11

    Great video as always mate. Always after more AFL content on RUclips. Like the way that you didn't bag Melbourne for picking Scully and Trengrove, instead putting us in the position of the recruiters at the time, where there was a clear top 2, even though Dusty has clearly turned out better. Have got a couple of videos over on my channel if you love AFL that you may enjoy, with more videos in the pipeline soon.

    • @1Sleighto1
      @1Sleighto1 2 года назад

      Crazy that they were comparing kane cornea to scully, scully is alot more explosive Kane only had one speed

  • @JBRAI22
    @JBRAI22 10 месяцев назад +1

    0:26 as a Collingwood supporter that sent some bad memories to me, good thing we came back and one in 2023, GO PIES

  • @raph770
    @raph770 3 года назад

    I was behind the goals in that game and was walking out thinking we (Richmond) had lost, when I heard a roar. I realised McMahon was having a shot after the siren and said to my kids "Wait - this doesn't happen often! Let's watch - he'll probably miss..." Of course he didn't, and the rest is history. Fascinating to think what the AFL landscape wouldn't been like if Dusty had not gone to Richmond. Great video!

  • @aussiefinley
    @aussiefinley 2 года назад +1

    this came out on birthday, good YT vids always seems to come out on my birthday!

  • @harryholden795
    @harryholden795 3 года назад

    Another great video. The quality of your content is insanely good, especially with your channel size

  • @GenerationExcrement
    @GenerationExcrement 3 года назад

    I have 100% been talking about this to fellow Richmond fans for YEARS now (add in the fact we gave up pick 21 to get McMahon (Callan Ward - captain of GWS), BUT I could never have put this as eloquently, sequentially and convincingly as you did...WELL DONE!

  • @mitchcricelli4071
    @mitchcricelli4071 3 года назад

    Your videos are literally what I need in life. AFL need to hire you

  • @Josh-xi1qx
    @Josh-xi1qx 3 года назад

    This is an exceptional video mate, I’m not a huge afl fan and I was unaware of your channel before seeing this video in my feed but I really enjoyed watching, keep it up

  • @hazjay4108
    @hazjay4108 2 года назад

    wow, this is simply incredible, i dont ever comment on videos on youtube but this just deserves alot of credit

  • @peterdickerson5653
    @peterdickerson5653 3 года назад

    This is a truly wonderful and amazing story. Thank you for your beautiful presentation, editing, and commentary.

  • @WhyForWhatNow
    @WhyForWhatNow 2 года назад

    That final play narration gave me goosebumps
    This video is superb!

  • @mal1760
    @mal1760 Год назад

    What a great video! I was riveted from start to finish. More please!

  • @sammaniatis7039
    @sammaniatis7039 3 года назад +4

    I was at that Melb v Rich game and I saw Melb leading and switching the players from defence to attack to throw the game.
    The other great tanking game of all time was Rich v StKilda, last game of 2007, Tigers coach Terry Wallace took off Richardson, Brown and Bowden so the Saints could get up to win.
    This enabled the Tigers to get Trent Cotchin in the draft at number 2.

    • @ChannelBlaino
      @ChannelBlaino 2 года назад

      Don't forget the Kreuzer cup between Carlton and Melbourne in 2007, both sides trying too loose.

    • @sentimentalbloke185
      @sentimentalbloke185 2 года назад

      @@ChannelBlaino Kruezer went one, Cotchin two. Richmond finished last & should've had #1 but the league decided to give Carlton #1 as a comp pick.

    • @planetx1595
      @planetx1595 2 года назад +1

      @@ChannelBlaino loose = not firmly or tightly fixed in place
      lose = the opposite of win

  • @NicholasTurnbull96
    @NicholasTurnbull96 3 года назад +1

    Awesome content. Love love love this sort of work for AFL

  • @aamslfc
    @aamslfc 3 года назад

    Fucking brilliant video, mate. I love a good 'What if?' scenario, and this was fantastic to watch.
    Incredible to think how one passage of play in a dead rubber between two then-mediocre sides could dictate the next decade of AFL football.
    And who would have thought that Ben Cousins, of all people, would have such an important role in setting it all up. The ageing genius in a sea of bog-standard footballers, a superstar of the late 90s/early 00s, at the end of his career helping to create the dynasty of the 2010s.

  • @nickbishop4118
    @nickbishop4118 3 года назад +1

    he’s back!! i love your content mate and i’m sure the rest of us do as well keep it up mate!

  • @patrickjamesabade5775
    @patrickjamesabade5775 3 года назад +1

    This was incredible - well done mate!

  • @mobbsey
    @mobbsey 3 года назад +2

    *this bouta be a movie haha.*
    Love your content mate!!

  • @hue4161
    @hue4161 3 года назад

    Your videos are always so entertaining, please do not stop making these videos lol

  • @ashleyharry9067
    @ashleyharry9067 3 года назад +2

    Again. Absolutely brilliant video mate

  • @bishgroundwork3089
    @bishgroundwork3089 2 года назад

    U had me glued... this is like a crime thriller.

  • @sampled611
    @sampled611 3 года назад

    this is hands down the best afl vid i have ever watched

  • @TotalDramaOwenandNoah
    @TotalDramaOwenandNoah 3 года назад +1

    You’re back! Talk about a miracle

  • @philthy4242
    @philthy4242 3 года назад

    Mate I just found this vid in my feed. Forget your other stuff, this content is awesome. Reminds me of the channel Secret Base but for us Aussies. Keep it up.

  • @Medaiyah
    @Medaiyah 3 года назад +1

    This is a scary good analysis. AFL needs more deep dive analysis like this, there are so many stories to be told and picked apart in the game and it's so rare to find someone willing to do it.

    • @chinboy66
      @chinboy66 2 года назад

      Or you could just watch the footy.

  • @FootyA2Z
    @FootyA2Z 3 года назад +1

    Great to see you back mate! good stuff :)

  • @lil_freshaussie6965
    @lil_freshaussie6965 3 года назад

    honestly one of the best videos i’ve watched

  • @themaster7552
    @themaster7552 3 года назад +3

    A legend has returned

  • @felixconboy1156
    @felixconboy1156 2 года назад

    I love these afl doco things. Thet are so interesting. Really great job.

  • @louiedagoatie1640
    @louiedagoatie1640 3 года назад

    He’s backkkk! Love your content bro, the AFL needs to hire you!

  • @Ashley-rx9ew
    @Ashley-rx9ew 3 года назад +3

    This is brilliant. One of the best AFL documentaries I’ve ever seen. Stunning job well done

  • @jaskeeretsingh4583
    @jaskeeretsingh4583 3 года назад

    No words to describe this content. Bloody awesome mate

  • @herbertnosworthy1
    @herbertnosworthy1 Год назад

    This is gold! Masterpiece.

  • @depressedessendonfan5702
    @depressedessendonfan5702 3 года назад

    This needs to be seen by a LOT more people

  • @jasonmarcolin3140
    @jasonmarcolin3140 2 года назад

    jagger your such a fkn legend welcome back mate

  • @anguseverist4178
    @anguseverist4178 2 года назад

    The idea that Tom Lynch is a pillar of anything except worst misses videos is hilarious.

  • @jordanvassallo8452
    @jordanvassallo8452 3 года назад

    that was bloody brilliant mate

  • @clemboston4723
    @clemboston4723 3 года назад +3

    Love your work mate keep it up 👍

  • @vweze4470
    @vweze4470 3 года назад

    always love your videos brother, talented asf x

  • @ST-cp6fn
    @ST-cp6fn 3 года назад

    Love this kinda stuff mate! top notch

  • @leonsteed1243
    @leonsteed1243 3 года назад

    This. Is. Brilliant. Great sliding doors story. Well done man 👍👌

  • @dylanevans8626
    @dylanevans8626 3 года назад

    sic content, love this, good work mate.

  • @Huss_D
    @Huss_D 2 года назад

    Really well made video mate!

  • @DS_2K
    @DS_2K 2 года назад

    Goat amazing content new sub and loyal fan

  • @willhamilton6880
    @willhamilton6880 3 года назад

    You are unreal mate, I absolutely love these videos!!!

  • @markharrison6498
    @markharrison6498 3 года назад

    This is an impressively well thought out what if

  • @jackmcgill7274
    @jackmcgill7274 3 года назад

    Best account on RUclips. Love the content man

  • @ryaneyre5093
    @ryaneyre5093 3 года назад

    Fascinating. Plenty of what ifs but it's interesting to analyse and think about.

  • @trship6274
    @trship6274 3 года назад

    Hindsight’s a beautiful thing. Great vid 😊

  • @joshblackley7024
    @joshblackley7024 3 года назад

    Great vid mate, more AFL ones like this please!

  • @kodmoecoins
    @kodmoecoins 2 года назад

    your so underrated bro. keep up the work.

  • @fhristopher
    @fhristopher 3 года назад +5

    When Dusty was talking to GWS I felt like my wife was leaving me for someone else.

  • @marcusgrosomanidis3396
    @marcusgrosomanidis3396 2 года назад

    I was at this game when I was like 6 years old. Great video

  • @darthwind3048
    @darthwind3048 3 года назад

    Good to see you back

  • @Dale_Doback
    @Dale_Doback 3 года назад +13

    not to mention the Crows might of been 2017 Premiers 😭😭😭

    • @Lady_Gaga95
      @Lady_Gaga95 2 года назад

      I want the alternative reality.

  • @lukeforman7786
    @lukeforman7786 3 года назад

    Excellent video - thank you 🙏

  • @Walshy9494
    @Walshy9494 2 года назад

    Great video dude. Cold shivers and I go for west coast

  • @leeburgers2444
    @leeburgers2444 3 года назад +2

    Canadian here just getting into it. Love this stuff because it helps me become more acquainted. Gotta find a team and join one of the the global packages that let me see every game and that!

    • @umey3445
      @umey3445 2 года назад

      Hope you’ve been watching, it’s gonna be a ripper of a grand final next week

    • @leeburgers2444
      @leeburgers2444 2 года назад

      @@umey3445 I'm gonna have to pay for a membership next year so I don't miss out. It was tough to see some stuff

  • @gusdoes5149
    @gusdoes5149 2 года назад

    love this mate, please do more like this!

  • @joel1365
    @joel1365 3 года назад

    the best video i have ever watched, love the content mate.

  • @user-ee3mw7cy1d
    @user-ee3mw7cy1d 2 года назад

    Mate I’m addicted to your doco’s very sharp stuff...poor old Jordy McMahon give us a 6 minute special on him

  • @Jack-fq2kz
    @Jack-fq2kz 3 года назад

    bro these are fire, crazy to think how it couldve ended up like this

  • @mattm400
    @mattm400 3 года назад

    Fantastic video. I love this type of content.

  • @samuelandreoli5061
    @samuelandreoli5061 3 года назад

    Loving the vids at the moment, keep it up mate!

  • @sevant8855
    @sevant8855 3 года назад +1

    that video literally left me speechless…

  • @camwells9726
    @camwells9726 2 года назад

    I was at that game , Melbourne supporters were celebrating Richmond had won poking fun at Richmond supporters after the siren singing the Richmond song. Pretty funny how it turned out .
    It was similar to Richmond picking Tambling ahead of Franklin.

  • @dmann7004
    @dmann7004 3 года назад +5

    Very impressive research and a great “what if” worthy of some serious discussion. Earned a like and a rare Subscribe from me. Well done 👍

  • @patwhelan3877
    @patwhelan3877 3 года назад +1

    Great video! Best AFL youtuer!

  • @timbojones7066
    @timbojones7066 3 года назад

    What a terrific video. Had me captivated.

  • @lachiekerr2808
    @lachiekerr2808 3 года назад

    incredible. love these vids mate

  • @jamesthompson7623
    @jamesthompson7623 2 года назад

    Love it mate hopefully we can still push for a 4th b4 Dusty retires. What a crazy decade it’s been. Thinking of the challenge by the group who wanted Dimma Peggy etc out. If that happens and a clear out of players occurs we could be looking at no flags and a couple more wooden spoons for good measure. Yet no one would have known what doing that had actually cost the club bloody scary.

  • @hughmungus1183
    @hughmungus1183 2 года назад

    Cracking vid. So nice to watch keeo it up

  • @lucastocks7396
    @lucastocks7396 2 года назад

    great video, well done mate

  • @exxcaliburs6002
    @exxcaliburs6002 2 года назад

    And thus led to Melbourne 2021 season. What a turn up!