Would've def liked to hear more takes. The tribal thing was sick but it was a little too much throughout the whole song.. If he learned the structure a little more he could've done something super sick that was less jammy.
@Globalizmas-Keiksmazodis That's BS. If he didn't like it, he wouldn't have had so much fun playing it, and he totally kept the spirit of the song. You're trippin.
Ive watched several of these now. I've seen drummers do several takes, write out drum charts , even record audio cue tracks for themselves. This guy comes in and does ANOTHER flawless take on first listen that turns out better than the original. Truly living up to that first name
This guys brain is a supercomputer. While other drummers go listening, learning, perfecting the song; he just goes along with the song. Pure feeling and instant reaction.
I would love to see him trying some prog rock or metal, I mean, generally you cant pick up in one listen what is happening because of the time signatures, so it would be fun to watch
Generally, tunes have a standard feel to them, especially these days..this was definitely one of them, a lot of drummers would play along to that in time and sense the feels coming, Chad would see this as nothing.
Best drummer hands down, not because of how complicated his drumming is, but more so because he drums exactly what’s needed for the music he hears, and the result seems to always be better than the original and more fitting
@@TheAluvisify naw it's just an exploitable beat when it doesn't have lots of stuff there's tons of room to improvise, he said he liked the original drum parts and called it good composition.
@@TheAluvisifyI don't think so; Chad himself is a master of "less is more". He often talks about how simple the drums are for the Chili Peppers, even tho he's a goddamn nice drummer, he doesn't need showing off, he plays what the band needs... So I think it would take more to "unimpress" him than simplicity.
@@timothyoreilly6571 I mean that's basically what I was saying. When I say that he's "umimpressed", I don't mean that he dislikes the composition. He probably understands that the drums are simpler because the song is more on the pop side. But the fact that he follows along with the original but then goes off on his own kind of shows that he felt like the drums could've been a little more impactful at that section.
If you are a drummer you understand how crazy this is. Listened to the song for 15 seconds and completely redefined the sound in one take with complicated rhythm patterns. Insane talent of Chad Smith!
i wouldnt call this crazy tbh 😭 his rendition of the kill was very good! This is just playing a random 4/4 tom beat over a 4/4 song that doesnt really fit. i mean the beat is nice but thats just learning to have that in your repertoire so yeee its still chad though so i still like it hehe
I’m not gonna lie out of all the drummers on this channel so far that I’ve seen and I’ve seen over maybe 30 videos Chad Smith is by far the best and most entertaining to watch
Thinking exactly the same thing. I'm not a huge fan of the cymbals (and to some degree the snare) so I loved his fast tom and bass heavy take on this song. aka.. Tribal..
one of the things that makes these so impressive and cause such a positive sound is Chad employs a "I'm not gonna be a background noise" drumming, its so pleasant listening to drums that are driving the song forward rather than supplying a background follow track
It's funny that I saw exactly the opposite comments on Chad's Dua Lipa drumeo video - Chad is so great because of his pauses and silence and letting the track be itself. Haha I agree he's great, but iono about all the breathless analysis. Maybe he's great because he's great and I'm not great enough to exactly know why. I'm ok with that
Ngl, I never listened to this band before but now that I’ve heard the original and this, I prefer this much more…the original lacks balls and chad def made em drop on this one.
I love Chad's facial expressions. He doesn't try to hide when he's missed something or is trying to catch something. It makes the session so much more real.
@@Kennaire Reminds me of another Drumeo video (can't remember which sorry) where the guest drummer was trying hard to fill in gaps.. and at one point when they listened to the original "you mean I could have played NOTHING for this whole part?!" hahaha
@@Kennaire which is funny because in his other videos Chad said more than once about how simple most drumming is, and that you can be a rock star if you can just keep time and do a simple beat (basically)
Doing what you love is the best heroine fam. I train dogs and when I get a chance to work with specific breeds all sounds are muted and I lock in. It's wild. If whatever you're doing doesn't do that to you then idk, find that
It's so cool that he immediately was like "okay... anthemic tribal sound... toms pattern" and went from there. Then you listen to the original with him and it's of course more subdued and heavy especially on the kick, but it does have that same identity. The intuition is so spot on, and in one take too...
It’s so impressive how Chad hears an intro and immediately starts playing. Compared to some other drummers who listen to the song 3 times taking notes. He’s on another level.
Petition for a FULL version with Chad - SIGN BELOW: For real, that was pure GENIUS!! Aways felt that song needed something esle. Now how can i hear the original without thinking about that video... Why @Drumeo, why?! 😭
@@Dirtboy37 He means that is the sound of your heart beat when you have been drug induced sprinting for your life for 5 minutes from those aliens with knives in the film clip.
I think the primary difference with Chad Smith is not only his massive experience of doing studio drumming work with so many different people that aids with the musicianship of improv, it's also that I honestly believe he's not afraid at all to sound 'bad'. He FULL SENDS it every time, with that ultimate zero f--ks given mentality, which in turn usually translates into he kills it. There is no half-assing or tipsy-toeing around it. He's gonna bring it, play it with energy, and it's glorious. Never change, Chad. That energy and philosophy is contagious!
it's actually genius fascinating to watch a man like that figure something out and then not only understand why the initial creative choices were made but pretty much perfectly recreate them by ear. LOVE this
@@Jmack7861 don't be a pedantic asshole. The songs he's been doing are incredibly prevalent in the emo subculture, nobody gives a shit about the "dc emotional hardcore scene" anymore, the word emo does not mean the same thing that it did 30 years ago
@@gabagool_ovahere yeah i definitely wouldnt say its perfect for the song- like i wouldnt replace it with Chad's version, but the rolling toms specifically have a dope vibe, but i admit it was a bit toooo much of it haha.
Now knowing that these two improvised masterpieces are only a few minutes apart of each other, when they were released 10 months apart of each other, just goes to show how legendary Chad Smith really is. Amazing!
@@BodomsScythe Instead of giving you what you want right now, they hold it for a long time so that you dont lose interest in the channel inbetween you seeing your heros, aka this was shot on the same day as the other song, and there was probably a third one, they have cut out most references to other episodes. its manipulative, not saying its bad, but it is manipulative. its on par with every other youtube channel at the moment. everybody is trying to squeeze as much money out of everything as possible, its sad but true.
@@Rasmustheforestit's such mild manipulation I don't think anyone can really act indignant about it. I didn't pay drumeo a cent for this amazing content
@@steinblitz1506 I'm a couple of months away from reaching 50 and bought my first drum-kit. I always have to laugh when I hear younger people speak about age. My mother of 74 drives every week to the other side of our island just to have coffee, buy groceries and even lifts big coolers by herself. Don't focus on the numbers, just stay active and you'll be able to run along just fine :)
My god, I didn't even realize how old I was until you just freakin wrote that! Damn! How time passes so fast. He is incredible at this age. Hell my parents are that age and they just sit around and watch TV. Damn, I think he is beyond the range of the Chilli peppers.
I like Chad's version more, more engaged. It gives the song a more energetic feel. And on that bridge man, he killed it there. Had never heard the song, got into it fast, it fit great, timed it well with the song coming back in, while he couldn't be totally sure that's the way it was going.
@@joserijalkasyasyaf9723 I hard disagree, personally. Drums are what does it for me. If the percussion isn't carrying the energy, I can't feel it. I can't do the original version of this song. It's not enough energy. Shouting isn't energy.
@@joserijalkasyasyaf9723 For me personally, Chad's version was better. And that's just the one take version. Imagine if that was fine-tuned with a few more run throughs. But then again, we all have our own preferences.
Man Chads casual interpretation actually had me completely entranced and sucked into the song on a whole different level, what an insane level of talent and skill this man has.
Im a rap guy through and through, yet somehow stumbled upon this video. I got nothing with songs like these or drumming, yet i got goosebumbs. Its always special to see raw fkcing talent doing what they do best. 👊
admittedly the song is entirely in 4/4 with a pretty basic composition of four bars leading to the next phrase. it's not really that crazy if you've been doing music related shit for a little
a lot of drummers are gifted like this. did you ever go to a football game in high school and hear your school playing the other schools song right then and there and/or vice versa? drummers certainly work hard, but a lot of them are gifted like this.... not saying they don't work hard, but it's not super uncommon bc drummers are just a different breed. it's pretty amazing to be a part of a drumline or band and witness it.
Love the story at the end about the Chili Peppers creative process! It seems like so many legendary creative ideas all start with someone coming up with a tiny piece of the puzzle and then having at least one other cool creative person to validate the idea and even add their own new idea inspired by the original idea until it snowballs into an amazing finished work the world then gets to enjoy and admire. God I love creative people and projects.
A bunch of my old friends used to think that Chad was just another drummer, I tried to tell them for the longest time that he's a beast! This just seals the deal on that!
I always saw him as the guy who looks like Will Farrell and drums for a great band. I had ZERO clue just how phenomenal he is at his craft. He is, BY FAR, the most underrated drummer of this generation.
Hi Brandon, can you make Chad play RHCP's Let's Make Evil one time, I think that song features some of his best and most complex drumming he's ever done -- let's see if he remembers this One Hot Minute B-Side haha
Hope you can get Mat Nicholls in sometime! Would love to hear him go over some of the BMTH catalogue! P.S. you could do a whole album of Chad Smith covers haha
Chad’s Thirty Seconds performance is my most watched RUclips video, and I’m going to watch this on loop too. His talent is almost incomprehensible, I haven’t seen any other drummer be able to just dive into a piece in the way he does, it truly is one of the most incredible things I have ever seen.
I could watch Chad Smith play things that he doesn't know all day. This man is a human metronome and a human drum machine it is absolutely incredible to watch. I hope there is more
It's not a hard song to figure where it's going, but to just jump on the treadmill at 30mph first listen to shows why he's been so successful as a drummer. Master of his craft
Chad Smith might be the best for this series. BMTH is one of my favorite bands and Chad's first try almost made me forget what the original version sounded like.
Same. I know the song (not a super fan or anything) but the way he played it made it feel like it was perfect for the song. (Sure, some things would change ofc seeing that he didn't know when certain changes happened and stuff). He definitely played that well!
@@ShayneMacGregor that also has to do with the way it's mixed for RUclips. Obviously they're bringing the drums to the very front since that's the whole focus of the show. If you imagine this same drum track as a mid-back mix, it makes perfect sense for the song. A lot of OG drummers make good money with newer bands doing exactly this. Consulting and coming up with creative drum licks that goes along with decades of experience
I saw the first part of this video on tiktok and immediately ran to RUclips to see the full version! Absolutely one of my favorite musicians right here!!!!
I love how at 4:00, Chad's face said he knew that something was meant to be there cause of the timing/sound changing. But he was so chill about that, and delayed a drop on que. Amazing and fun video, and his take on BMTH was very colourful!
I don't know anything about drums, but as a complete amateur I just find impressive how he can simply listen to a song for 30 secs and start jamming to it. I checked some other videos on this channel and other drummers tend to analyze/break down the song and make notes, take multiple takes, and Chad here just starts spitting fire after 15s. I just love how he feels the music and how spontaneous he is when creating new beats. Impressive
He was right, the tribal vibe he played goes insanely well with this song. Chad is just unreal when it comes to "feeling" a song and nailing a drum section
Chad's interpretation was great, and it really shows the power of finding an idea and committing to it. Even if it didn't exactly line up with the emotional beats of the song at times, the fact that he never panicked and was able to smoothly transition from one feel to the next completely covers it up. At the same time, what a groove from Matt Nicholls! The hitch in the bass - bass - snare pattern is so effective underneath the rest of the band, and watching Chad try and fail to lock in with it right away (5:59) just shows how much more difficult it is to lay down than it might seem just by listening.
It was pretty amazing to watch....he'd do a big drum fill anticipating the song to change sections, and if he was wrong he adjusted in the blink of an eye like as if he meant for it to happen.
Perfect example of how this music nerd of a magaband from the 90s become a studio drummer is his off hours. No wasted seconds, be fearless, love the process, adjust fast or ya ain’t gonna called back to play around with your friends & oh yeah guest drum on some awesome #1 hits. Really would love to see how much funk he’d put into this one after a few more takes.
@keepitsecret-dl1pr be real. This song is incredibly boring from the perspective of any of the instruments. Chad keeps anticipating that they'll do something different and the song NEVER progresses. His take was considerably better than the original because at least it introduced an interesting dynamic.
@smashin222 Most of the BMTH songs I've heard are driven by the vocals more than anything. The drums support the vocals, guitar fills the holes, everything else brings it home. Repetitive drumming isn't great, but better than busy drumming getting in the way
I know we admire the Portnoys, the Manginis and power drummers of the world, but this guy is a different kind of genius. I have always loved his drumming.
Ehhh, what they asked Portnoy to do was insane. Significantly harder than this song by a factor of multiples, and they asked Portnoy to learn the original part, not make his own, which is way harder in the case of a song like Pneuma imo because now accuracy is a goal, not just playing something functional.
...and who in here is claiming that what Portnoy did was not harder or more complicated? I even said "we" (which includes myself) admire him and monster drummers like him. Is that not giving them proper respect? Saying Chad is a different kind of genius is accurate, his feels and groove cannot be denied and neither his musical understanding. I never said, and never will say, that X drummer is better than Y. I respect them all for what they do.
@WeMissDimebag it's a contrast in approaches and learning styles. One very cerebral and chatty (mostly about how hard it is, which pedagogically speaking only hinders progress -- even when it is really fucking hard! 🤣), the other kinesthetic. I could NOT play TOOL, but I can say with certainty these two drummers could learn a lot from each other. Ooo what if they merged into a single superdrummer?! 🤯
Man, at 3:19, that was just pure amazing talent. It sounded so damn good that I will try to play that riff when I’m playing the song on my drums. Just blew me away.
Pretty standard mic set from what I see, 57 on snare, 451 on hat, U87 outside the kick. The Earthworks DM20s on the toms were pretty cool. Also like the 414 placed next to the shell of the snare, don't recall seeing that before. That said, it's not really the mics. What you're primarily hearing is a good kit, tuned properly, in a great sounding room, mixed well, and played by a pro. All other things being equal, you could probably get just as good of a sound with 2 overheads, a kick and a snare top mic.
I'd imagine since the drums are what we are here to see they probably just made the drums more prominent in the mix. Whereas if this was redone to make it an actual song they'd probably adjust the mix and pull the drums back.
actually insane to me. ofc i know the song (and every lyric of it) but i'm so impressed how he can just improvise to the song on the spot. and while hearing the original, he just knew how to instantly drum and vibe to it even more. i have no idea about drumming and only saw similar stuff of guitar/piano so far but this is more impressive to me. BUT DAMN I WANT MORE.
The song starts with the synth chopped into 1/4 notes with choppy releases so it essentially provides an instant metronome and there’s only so many grooves that sound good to us to choose from while maintaining that quarter note structure.
I’m in awe or watching him just go for it. Not trying to emulate the original, just playing what feels right without a second thought. What a talented individual.
He’s never heard it before, neither had I. He can’t emulate it he can just play something. I was really disappointed to hear the actual song after hearing his drumming.
I know with practice this is possible to be this musical and fluid on a first listen but Smith’s drumming here makes me feel like some people are BORN with a musical spirit.
I would absolutely love to have Chad be a re-occurring guest on this. Between his talent, natural comedic impulses, and overall desire to play on the fly makes these episodes some of the most entertaining content. Much love to you all.
i really liked how the part he was playing remained rather consistent after 3:40 while everything in the song started to break apart ontop of it. very cool effect
The fact it was filmed on the same day and they had this amount of patience to space out this one with there top video, speaks volumes. @Drumeo to the moon
I'm a guitarist. I don't play the drums. Never heard this song but decided to play along and go listen to the drumless track and see if I could come up with some sort of drum part using the "Gregg Bissonnette" method. Kind of worked...just don't know how to translate to an actual drum kit LOL!
man he can't just first take drum everything to perfection without even having heard it a full time first. thats illegal man. it was already incredible the first time and I won't stop being in awe from this level of skill.
Some drummers employ "active listening" on their first listen. Then there's Chad Smith employing "active drumming."
😂 for sure
Would've def liked to hear more takes. The tribal thing was sick but it was a little too much throughout the whole song.. If he learned the structure a little more he could've done something super sick that was less jammy.
he's sick, but they also give him verse / chorus / verse / chorus / breakdown / verse / chorus / ending songs
It's as simple as simple gets really. Not saying he's not a good drummer. Nothing unique
Chad is my spirit drummer - I do the same shit lmao. Jam along, play by ear and figure it out as I go.
Can u do us all a favor and get chad to do like 20 of these. Seriously
and let us buy them on itunes
Lol they definutly have a lot of footage from that session, they drop them by the milliliter tho😂 last one was 30 sec to mars
Yes.
@@mthorpe96 who tf still uses iTunes
❤
Chad Smith listening to the original like "ok but mine was WAY more fun"
Yea and like "what he's doing is cool, but he should do:" *proceeds to make the metal song more heavy than the original
And he DID.
I dont think he had any respect for the original drum track
@Globalizmas-Keiksmazodis That's BS. If he didn't like it, he wouldn't have had so much fun playing it, and he totally kept the spirit of the song. You're trippin.
@@Globalizmas-Keiksmazodis And why should he, its mid af
The simple fact that he MATCHES the song, and then BRINGS OUT MORE from it is actually incredible. Man knows his job and does it well.
I feel like Drumeo needs to start a "Chad Smith Fixes a Song He's Never Heard" series. It's so good that it's almost unbelievable.
But with the same tshirt please 🙏
Your comment really did make me lol IRL
Epic comment
Bro did not “fix” this song
genius idea 💡
I really appreciate how he’s somehow SO serious and SO unserious at the exact same time.
That because he’s actually Will Ferrell. 😂
Seriously not serious
"Life's too important to take seriously" -Oscar Wilde
Idk if just a camera nerd but he had camera cuts on certain parts where he caught the original beat
@@Frank.E.Valley "do you smell gas" some German during WW1 prolly
Drumeo is sure getting their money's worth out of Chad coming to their studio
And we’re all happy about it!!
You have no idea what they paid him!
Pt. 3 coming in another 10 months 😅
That’s usually what happens in a business arrangement
And so are we!!!!!
He’s got lots to share and teach!
Ive watched several of these now. I've seen drummers do several takes, write out drum charts , even record audio cue tracks for themselves. This guy comes in and does ANOTHER flawless take on first listen that turns out better than the original.
Truly living up to that first name
I really want a copy of this version on my Spotify/Apple Music!
This guys brain is a supercomputer. While other drummers go listening, learning, perfecting the song; he just goes along with the song. Pure feeling and instant reaction.
I would love to see him trying some prog rock or metal, I mean, generally you cant pick up in one listen what is happening because of the time signatures, so it would be fun to watch
@@noseqnombreponer7589 "Chad Smith Learns Pneuma" lmao
Generally, tunes have a standard feel to them, especially these days..this was definitely one of them, a lot of drummers would play along to that in time and sense the feels coming, Chad would see this as nothing.
@@noseqnombreponer7589 He did two songs so quick it wouldn't surprise me if they let him do one more.
@@deanristeaird5766 Idk I feel like chad did it better than a lot of people would.
Bro what he did with the bridge was so insane
That was 🔥
can you explain that to me ? Im a dumbass
@@majorlaznthe bridge is the part of the song that begins at 3:04
@@skylaralley2465 thanks
Yeah I totally agree. This part was NAILED. Loved the way it felt so natural.
I think it would be cool to get the drummers who wrote the original parts to react to these videos
Definitely!
thirty seconds to mars saw theirs!
Fr
yes
Brann Dailor saw Eloy's version of Blood & Thunder and his reaction was shown to Eloy afterwards. It's included in the episode too.
Very cool.
Best drummer hands down, not because of how complicated his drumming is, but more so because he drums exactly what’s needed for the music he hears, and the result seems to always be better than the original and more fitting
I love that "listening to the original " essentially means "playing a solo" for Chad
I think he was just unimpressed with how barebones the texture was in places where it could've been busier.
@@TheAluvisify naw it's just an exploitable beat when it doesn't have lots of stuff there's tons of room to improvise, he said he liked the original drum parts and called it good composition.
@@TheAluvisifyI don't think so; Chad himself is a master of "less is more". He often talks about how simple the drums are for the Chili Peppers, even tho he's a goddamn nice drummer, he doesn't need showing off, he plays what the band needs... So I think it would take more to "unimpress" him than simplicity.
@@timothyoreilly6571 I mean that's basically what I was saying. When I say that he's "umimpressed", I don't mean that he dislikes the composition. He probably understands that the drums are simpler because the song is more on the pop side.
But the fact that he follows along with the original but then goes off on his own kind of shows that he felt like the drums could've been a little more impactful at that section.
I was surprised how good he was in this video considering his drumming in the chili peppers is meh to me
@@petrowzz
If you are a drummer you understand how crazy this is. Listened to the song for 15 seconds and completely redefined the sound in one take with complicated rhythm patterns. Insane talent of Chad Smith!
Yeah and ruined the sound. Didn't suit at all. Too fast paced
@@spaghetti5038 oooh we got a Will Ferrell fan over here!
Would completely agree ! Chad Smith’s super dope…
@@spaghetti5038 it's just simply being a tad bit repetitive with Chad's rendition, but in no way it was ruined.
i wouldnt call this crazy tbh 😭 his rendition of the kill was very good!
This is just playing a random 4/4 tom beat over a 4/4 song that doesnt really fit. i mean the beat is nice but thats just learning to have that in your repertoire so yeee
its still chad though so i still like it hehe
The *GIGA CHAD* tune for the Giga Chad himself
two Chads collide, a perfect fitting dedicated to giga Chad meme.
This comment is so underrated
YOU SAID IT!
I think this is the whole point of it all. Hats off to whoever from Drumeo shouted the idea for the double Chad.
😂
I’m not gonna lie out of all the drummers on this channel so far that I’ve seen and I’ve seen over maybe 30 videos Chad Smith is by far the best and most entertaining to watch
man, i could watch Chad do “first listens” forever. love his tribal choice for this track
Thinking exactly the same thing. I'm not a huge fan of the cymbals (and to some degree the snare) so I loved his fast tom and bass heavy take on this song. aka.. Tribal..
Just hit a PR 315 squat to this very youtube vid after being stuck at 225 squat not long ago.. The TUNES are JUICY!
Tribal is a nice way of saying "george of the jungle" style groove. This is the worst one so far. !!!
@@akbarroosevelt2246this part fucks, George of the horizon
@@SuperStruct the grind is paying off brother keep at it!
Chad's waiting for a transition for the entire song, and it never happens.
He found an awesome groove and could just keep playing it throughout.
Haha. Noticed that. He added in the hihat on the second or third time thru outta boredom.
He still had a lot of variations for his build ups. Very talented man.
one of the things that makes these so impressive and cause such a positive sound is Chad employs a "I'm not gonna be a background noise" drumming, its so pleasant listening to drums that are driving the song forward rather than supplying a background follow track
OMg I completely agree with you.
Accurate assessment it’s why I prefer this one over the original even though the original is dope. It’s definitely a different take
That’s why Keith Moon is one of my all-time favorite drummers. That dude refused to live in the pocket.
lmao supplying a backtrack sounds like the metallica thing to do xD
It's funny that I saw exactly the opposite comments on Chad's Dua Lipa drumeo video - Chad is so great because of his pauses and silence and letting the track be itself.
Haha I agree he's great, but iono about all the breathless analysis. Maybe he's great because he's great and I'm not great enough to exactly know why. I'm ok with that
Seriously please bring him back for another session and songs. He’s the absolute best at this bar none.
Chad's ability to rip into a drumless track he's never heard in his life, and make it sound GOOD, has cemented him in my list of favorite drummers
He’s definitely heard them. Dude still rips though
Sound good? Hahahahah
It took you this long for him to be one of your favourite drummers?
Idk, it was very one dimensional, no space to breathe at all
Ngl, I never listened to this band before but now that I’ve heard the original and this, I prefer this much more…the original lacks balls and chad def made em drop on this one.
I love Chad's facial expressions. He doesn't try to hide when he's missed something or is trying to catch something. It makes the session so much more real.
I think he surprised by how simple the original drumming was
@@Kennaire Reminds me of another Drumeo video (can't remember which sorry) where the guest drummer was trying hard to fill in gaps.. and at one point when they listened to the original "you mean I could have played NOTHING for this whole part?!" hahaha
I felt on this one he was trying to be nice. I felt he was "disappointed" with the ideas on this track. Like he heard way more in a more creative way
@@filipeventura2729 1000000000%. that drum part is lifeless and boring and ultra gridded.
@@Kennaire which is funny because in his other videos Chad said more than once about how simple most drumming is, and that you can be a rock star if you can just keep time and do a simple beat (basically)
After 50 years of drumming, Chad still has that "Hears something, wants to play it" impulse. Love it
that´s the best definition i heard. he has that impulse and it´s heartwarming
would you say he... Can't Stop?
@@thejoetandy Bruh...
Doing what you love is the best heroine fam. I train dogs and when I get a chance to work with specific breeds all sounds are muted and I lock in. It's wild. If whatever you're doing doesn't do that to you then idk, find that
I think one of my favorite things about RHCP, is that they have such a diverse track list all while always sounding like RHCP!
His version made me feel like going to war against a thousand with only 4 members. What a nice battle song.
Just like playing L4D
This is so real. The original version is like “if you were the only one left standing” his version is like “we annihilated them to this song”
You sound like…a HELLDIVER
@@xXsravenXx When Democracy calls.
May you fight with the strength of 10 grown men!
You just know that Chad was one of those kids who just never could sit still!
Having a nervous left leg sure does help with drumming
Percussion is awesome for ADHD. You have an excuse to " stick tic" all the time.
@@arimewillow4278that's what I keep telling my kids, but the noise then bothers them, and the muffs only work for a few Minutes
There's plenty of film of him from the early 90s...
Just think if Mom had put him on meds and drowned this huge talent. So scary.
It's so cool that he immediately was like "okay... anthemic tribal sound... toms pattern" and went from there. Then you listen to the original with him and it's of course more subdued and heavy especially on the kick, but it does have that same identity. The intuition is so spot on, and in one take too...
It’s so impressive how Chad hears an intro and immediately starts playing. Compared to some other drummers who listen to the song 3 times taking notes. He’s on another level.
Lol it sounds nothing like the original
@@Mavis709 That's not what I said, your reading comprehension skills need improvement?
It does not have "the same identity", my guy....
Holy shit CLG Lazarus??
Petition for a FULL version with Chad - SIGN BELOW:
For real, that was pure GENIUS!! Aways felt that song needed something esle. Now how can i hear the original without thinking about that video... Why @Drumeo, why?! 😭
using the toms for "Can you feel my heart" like the beat of the toms mimic a heartbeat. Genius
Esté sr es genial
Didn't mean it like that probably but yeah cool
if your heart sounds like those toms you need to go to a doctor
@@Dirtboy37 LOL
@@Dirtboy37 He means that is the sound of your heart beat when you have been drug induced sprinting for your life for 5 minutes from those aliens with knives in the film clip.
I need the chad smith cover on spotify. It would instantly be a gym hype up song
Fr though
Right? I really want a copy of this!
You have the entire song right here....
@peezdoc true but replay and the need to keep my phone in my gym backpack is crying for a loopable version haha
@@war_1104
Revanced, or download and add to your Spotify downloaded library
Unless that last one is just a pc feature
I think the primary difference with Chad Smith is not only his massive experience of doing studio drumming work with so many different people that aids with the musicianship of improv, it's also that I honestly believe he's not afraid at all to sound 'bad'.
He FULL SENDS it every time, with that ultimate zero f--ks given mentality, which in turn usually translates into he kills it. There is no half-assing or tipsy-toeing around it. He's gonna bring it, play it with energy, and it's glorious.
Never change, Chad. That energy and philosophy is contagious!
Yep 💯 -- most valuable skill for any artist is stay open and interested, never be afraid to suck. Chad is a fucking HERO.
Great drummers have enough confidence to try and fail. Rock climbing gets easier after you take your first fall too.
Fearlessness is the key to improvisation
I agree, but I think that Chad is such a chad that he really can't sound bad. Even if he is way off from the original, it is still badass.
Totally agree. This is my favorite drumeo yet. Now I need to see him on hot ones
it's actually genius fascinating to watch a man like that figure something out and then not only understand why the initial creative choices were made but pretty much perfectly recreate them by ear. LOVE this
Every song now needs a Chad Smith drum remix. He's improving emo classics one song at a time.
Agreed
He hasn’t played a single emo song lol
Imagine New Noise .... Oh boy
@@Jmack7861 don't be a pedantic asshole. The songs he's been doing are incredibly prevalent in the emo subculture, nobody gives a shit about the "dc emotional hardcore scene" anymore, the word emo does not mean the same thing that it did 30 years ago
yeah and taylor swift is grindcore
His rolling over the toms for like the whole song is actually such a vibe, It makes the song feel even more like a storm cloud.
I like his drum cover than the original, it feel different and holy shit its awesome
I actually thought the same! Its like a storm clouds coming in
Gives the song something the original is completely lacking, even his fills r killer on this when he eventually hears the song with the drum track
Nah it lost any impact. He overplayed it and as such lost any rise and fall.
@@gabagool_ovahere yeah i definitely wouldnt say its perfect for the song- like i wouldnt replace it with Chad's version, but the rolling toms specifically have a dope vibe, but i admit it was a bit toooo much of it haha.
Now knowing that these two improvised masterpieces are only a few minutes apart of each other, when they were released 10 months apart of each other, just goes to show how legendary Chad Smith really is. Amazing!
and it shows incredible manipulation skills by drumeo.
@@Rasmustheforest hahahahahahaha
@@Rasmustheforest How is it manipulative?
@@BodomsScythe Instead of giving you what you want right now, they hold it for a long time so that you dont lose interest in the channel inbetween you seeing your heros, aka this was shot on the same day as the other song, and there was probably a third one, they have cut out most references to other episodes. its manipulative, not saying its bad, but it is manipulative. its on par with every other youtube channel at the moment. everybody is trying to squeeze as much money out of everything as possible, its sad but true.
@@Rasmustheforestit's such mild manipulation I don't think anyone can really act indignant about it. I didn't pay drumeo a cent for this amazing content
I need this version ASAP. I have never listened to the actual original and I can't have it any other way now. 😢
crazy to think hes now 62 and play with soo much energy
He must be super in shape / good diet and all that. He has the energy of someone my age and I have the energy of someone his age..
@@steinblitz1506 I'm a couple of months away from reaching 50 and bought my first drum-kit. I always have to laugh when I hear younger people speak about age. My mother of 74 drives every week to the other side of our island just to have coffee, buy groceries and even lifts big coolers by herself. Don't focus on the numbers, just stay active and you'll be able to run along just fine :)
My god, I didn't even realize how old I was until you just freakin wrote that! Damn! How time passes so fast. He is incredible at this age. Hell my parents are that age and they just sit around and watch TV. Damn, I think he is beyond the range of the Chilli peppers.
that’s passion for ya
Can't stop moving
I like Chad's version more, more engaged. It gives the song a more energetic feel.
And on that bridge man, he killed it there. Had never heard the song, got into it fast, it fit great, timed it well with the song coming back in, while he couldn't be totally sure that's the way it was going.
Hmm, i think the point of simpler drums is that so the drum didnt dominate the feeling of the song. While its fun its not right for my ears😅
@@joserijalkasyasyaf9723 I hard disagree, personally. Drums are what does it for me. If the percussion isn't carrying the energy, I can't feel it. I can't do the original version of this song. It's not enough energy. Shouting isn't energy.
@@joserijalkasyasyaf9723 For me personally, Chad's version was better. And that's just the one take version. Imagine if that was fine-tuned with a few more run throughs. But then again, we all have our own preferences.
But Can you feel my heart is not supposed to be energetic. It is supposed to be full of emotion and pain.
@@Sodys_eyy I get that, but i still like the sound more.
Man Chads casual interpretation actually had me completely entranced and sucked into the song on a whole different level, what an insane level of talent and skill this man has.
Im a rap guy through and through, yet somehow stumbled upon this video. I got nothing with songs like these or drumming, yet i got goosebumbs. Its always special to see raw fkcing talent doing what they do best. 👊
God. His understanding of the music is so insane, he nails the transitions so effortlessly!
I mean you can hear them about to happen if you're listening to be fair but yea the ability of drummers to get them on the exact count is awesome
Year I don't think this song has. very difficult structure but he's amazing. Tribal version ftw
admittedly the song is entirely in 4/4 with a pretty basic composition of four bars leading to the next phrase. it's not really that crazy if you've been doing music related shit for a little
It's quite easy to guess when verses will transition into a chorus. It's just a simple song in 4/4 with a predictable structure.
I want an hour long video of Chad just jamming to different genres or something. He’s so fun to watch and listen to.
One hour per week section would be perfect.
@@EstevanDrummer
YES YES YES!!!!! A THOUSAND TIMES YES!!
Fr
Muscle memory is crazy. Chad is built to feel it and respond. You can see the music working in his head.
a lot of drummers are gifted like this. did you ever go to a football game in high school and hear your school playing the other schools song right then and there and/or vice versa? drummers certainly work hard, but a lot of them are gifted like this.... not saying they don't work hard, but it's not super uncommon bc drummers are just a different breed. it's pretty amazing to be a part of a drumline or band and witness it.
❤❤❤ I fully back this statement up FACTS
Love the story at the end about the Chili Peppers creative process! It seems like so many legendary creative ideas all start with someone coming up with a tiny piece of the puzzle and then having at least one other cool creative person to validate the idea and even add their own new idea inspired by the original idea until it snowballs into an amazing finished work the world then gets to enjoy and admire. God I love creative people and projects.
Whomever thinks Chad is "just another drummer" needs to watch these videos. Massive respect.
A bunch of my old friends used to think that Chad was just another drummer, I tried to tell them for the longest time that he's a beast! This just seals the deal on that!
I always saw him as the guy who looks like Will Farrell and drums for a great band. I had ZERO clue just how phenomenal he is at his craft. He is, BY FAR, the most underrated drummer of this generation.
Whoever*** dawg. Get it right.
That’s right, Round 2 😈
Hi Brandon, can you make Chad play RHCP's Let's Make Evil one time, I think that song features some of his best and most complex drumming he's ever done -- let's see if he remembers this One Hot Minute B-Side haha
Hope you can get Mat Nicholls in sometime! Would love to hear him go over some of the BMTH catalogue! P.S. you could do a whole album of Chad Smith covers haha
Please make dirk or portnoy play we own the night
I just wish they wouldn’t have went with one of BMTH most simplest songs
Keep bringing him back! These videos are far and ahead your best
Man we need a playlist on Spotify and Apple Music full of “Chad Smith versions”
This!!!!!
Agreed!!!
I have to rip it in mp3 only for listen the "Chad" version
Chad’s Thirty Seconds performance is my most watched RUclips video, and I’m going to watch this on loop too. His talent is almost incomprehensible, I haven’t seen any other drummer be able to just dive into a piece in the way he does, it truly is one of the most incredible things I have ever seen.
I could watch Chad Smith play things that he doesn't know all day. This man is a human metronome and a human drum machine it is absolutely incredible to watch. I hope there is more
This.
Agreed
a human metronome and a human drum machine? So in other words a drummer?
@@chrisharris1522 yup
Holy guacamole, it’s like he just stepped in and grabbed the song by its neck. Chad, never grow old.
He just jumped right in. Wasn’t even through the first verse. It’s insane. He’s a monster. His rendition is sublime 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾
Wasn't even through the intro. 😂😂
Chad Smith is one of the most intuitive drummers of all time.
I've always been a rhcp fan but I honestly didn't know chad was literally the goat until his drumeo arc
Honestly flea and chad are the heart and soul of the band respectively
Haven’t played a video faster in my life, saw the drumeo photo and read Chad Smith and immediately knew this was a banger
Facts. Loaded up RUclips and first thing I saw was Chad and BMTH. Fastest click I've ever done lol
I loaded up RUclips to watch something else and was immediately abducted by this brilliance
It's not a hard song to figure where it's going, but to just jump on the treadmill at 30mph first listen to shows why he's been so successful as a drummer. Master of his craft
That bridge was honestly SO GOOD
Can You Feel My Heart (Chad's Big Bohemian Tribal Remix)
Haaha and im here for it! Pure instinct
This needs its own release. Do it!
Chad Smith might be the best for this series. BMTH is one of my favorite bands and Chad's first try almost made me forget what the original version sounded like.
Doesn’t sound like this. That’s for sure.
Same. I know the song (not a super fan or anything) but the way he played it made it feel like it was perfect for the song. (Sure, some things would change ofc seeing that he didn't know when certain changes happened and stuff). He definitely played that well!
Never heard the original but he killed it
Meh, it was a bit too busy for me. Need to let the song breathe a bit.
@@ShayneMacGregor that also has to do with the way it's mixed for RUclips. Obviously they're bringing the drums to the very front since that's the whole focus of the show. If you imagine this same drum track as a mid-back mix, it makes perfect sense for the song.
A lot of OG drummers make good money with newer bands doing exactly this. Consulting and coming up with creative drum licks that goes along with decades of experience
I saw the first part of this video on tiktok and immediately ran to RUclips to see the full version! Absolutely one of my favorite musicians right here!!!!
@autumnarnold778 same haha ran here quick af lol 😅
Me 2 haha
Bro barely watched the tiktok I came from lol
DRUMEO!!! PLEASE MAKE A SPOTIFY LIST FOR EVERYSONG IN THE "FIRST TAKE" of CHAD SMITH!
I love how at 4:00, Chad's face said he knew that something was meant to be there cause of the timing/sound changing. But he was so chill about that, and delayed a drop on que. Amazing and fun video, and his take on BMTH was very colourful!
that took so much strength. haha be cool and hit the next mark.
I don't know anything about drums, but as a complete amateur I just find impressive how he can simply listen to a song for 30 secs and start jamming to it. I checked some other videos on this channel and other drummers tend to analyze/break down the song and make notes, take multiple takes, and Chad here just starts spitting fire after 15s. I just love how he feels the music and how spontaneous he is when creating new beats. Impressive
It’s even more impressive for drummers who understand how difficult it is. He’s definitely got rhythm in his DNA
He was right, the tribal vibe he played goes insanely well with this song. Chad is just unreal when it comes to "feeling" a song and nailing a drum section
You can tell he knows music. He felt what it should be based on everything around the drums and just played what he felt was right and it worked.
I like Chad's version better
@@ELGF_CKJ Hot take but I think I agree 👀
You're joking, right???
@@niabrightside8893 it sounds better.
please have Chad Smith on more. this is crazy having a legendary drummer being completely candid and demonstrating his artistic prowess
The engeneer deserves an award. The drumms sound is getting better and better
This needs to go on spotify.
I think it'll get there. Some how. Some way.
that would be illegal mayb
Evidently Chad Smith was born for this type of scenario 😂.
I would like one of the drummers to do the same video concept, but use the song Wayward Son by Kansas.
Chad's interpretation was great, and it really shows the power of finding an idea and committing to it. Even if it didn't exactly line up with the emotional beats of the song at times, the fact that he never panicked and was able to smoothly transition from one feel to the next completely covers it up.
At the same time, what a groove from Matt Nicholls! The hitch in the bass - bass - snare pattern is so effective underneath the rest of the band, and watching Chad try and fail to lock in with it right away (5:59) just shows how much more difficult it is to lay down than it might seem just by listening.
doesnt need a listen, he picked up the feel of the song in 20 seconds, and did it in 1 take.
insane.
It was pretty amazing to watch....he'd do a big drum fill anticipating the song to change sections, and if he was wrong he adjusted in the blink of an eye like as if he meant for it to happen.
tbf its all one tempo in 4/4.
Perfect example of how this music nerd of a magaband from the 90s become a studio drummer is his off hours. No wasted seconds, be fearless, love the process, adjust fast or ya ain’t gonna called back to play around with your friends & oh yeah guest drum on some awesome #1 hits. Really would love to see how much funk he’d put into this one after a few more takes.
@keepitsecret-dl1pr be real. This song is incredibly boring from the perspective of any of the instruments. Chad keeps anticipating that they'll do something different and the song NEVER progresses. His take was considerably better than the original because at least it introduced an interesting dynamic.
@smashin222 Most of the BMTH songs I've heard are driven by the vocals more than anything. The drums support the vocals, guitar fills the holes, everything else brings it home. Repetitive drumming isn't great, but better than busy drumming getting in the way
I know we admire the Portnoys, the Manginis and power drummers of the world, but this guy is a different kind of genius. I have always loved his drumming.
Comparing this to Portnoy's TOOL session is a masterclass
Ehhh, what they asked Portnoy to do was insane. Significantly harder than this song by a factor of multiples, and they asked Portnoy to learn the original part, not make his own, which is way harder in the case of a song like Pneuma imo because now accuracy is a goal, not just playing something functional.
...and who in here is claiming that what Portnoy did was not harder or more complicated? I even said "we" (which includes myself) admire him and monster drummers like him. Is that not giving them proper respect?
Saying Chad is a different kind of genius is accurate, his feels and groove cannot be denied and neither his musical understanding. I never said, and never will say, that X drummer is better than Y. I respect them all for what they do.
I thought his piece was awesome. I just really have a hard time believing this is rolling off one drum-less take. His timing on changes is too good.
@WeMissDimebag it's a contrast in approaches and learning styles. One very cerebral and chatty (mostly about how hard it is, which pedagogically speaking only hinders progress -- even when it is really fucking hard! 🤣), the other kinesthetic. I could NOT play TOOL, but I can say with certainty these two drummers could learn a lot from each other. Ooo what if they merged into a single superdrummer?! 🤯
Chad's ability to improvise and play parts that add so much musicality is phenomenal.
I smiled the entire time watching this... I freaking LOVE Chad Smith! Dude is the man
Original Track: Heartfelt desperate plea.
Chad's Take: Focused conviction fighting against the void.
Like the halo reach ending
PLEASE get Chad back in the studio for more of these. He’s the perfect drummer for this series
He turned 15 when he struck that gong. 😂 Absolutely incredible....again!!
Something in my head was anticipating "more cowbell" as soon as he said "needs more"😅
He turned into Will Farrell
@@dshesser 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@dshesser In the flashback Chilis section--yep!
This man's pure talent gives me goosebumps every time
Man, at 3:19, that was just pure amazing talent. It sounded so damn good that I will try to play that riff when I’m playing the song on my drums. Just blew me away.
That part was definitely better than the original
I liked it a lot too sounded tribal almost
How did he even anticipate the vocals coming into this part at 3:09 so perfectly too? Guy is just a monster
the mics they used for this video are insane? best sounding drums ive ever heard
It is "drumeo"
Pretty standard mic set from what I see, 57 on snare, 451 on hat, U87 outside the kick. The Earthworks DM20s on the toms were pretty cool. Also like the 414 placed next to the shell of the snare, don't recall seeing that before. That said, it's not really the mics. What you're primarily hearing is a good kit, tuned properly, in a great sounding room, mixed well, and played by a pro. All other things being equal, you could probably get just as good of a sound with 2 overheads, a kick and a snare top mic.
I'd imagine since the drums are what we are here to see they probably just made the drums more prominent in the mix. Whereas if this was redone to make it an actual song they'd probably adjust the mix and pull the drums back.
I love watching Chad in this format. He just jumps straight in. It's like he listens with his sticks.
actually insane to me. ofc i know the song (and every lyric of it) but i'm so impressed how he can just improvise to the song on the spot. and while hearing the original, he just knew how to instantly drum and vibe to it even more. i have no idea about drumming and only saw similar stuff of guitar/piano so far but this is more impressive to me. BUT DAMN I WANT MORE.
picks up the groove in a matter of seconds, what a legend
Yeah this is someone who has clocked drums
bro eats drum for breakfast, that's why
Can tell he's done a lot of session drumming. What an absolute Gigachad.
The song starts with the synth chopped into 1/4 notes with choppy releases so it essentially provides an instant metronome and there’s only so many grooves that sound good to us to choose from while maintaining that quarter note structure.
Bro if you play drums since a decent amount of time it’s pretty easy to pick up
I wish we could listen to Chad's version on Spotify.
I’m in awe or watching him just go for it. Not trying to emulate the original, just playing what feels right without a second thought. What a talented individual.
He’s never heard it before, neither had I. He can’t emulate it he can just play something. I was really disappointed to hear the actual song after hearing his drumming.
Considering he had never heard the song before, it would be impossible for him to emulate the original percussion
I would pay money for a subscription to solely Chad smith playing covers. Impossible to listen to these and not smile
I like that they got someone named Chad to play the Gigachad song
Underrated comment lmao
I know with practice this is possible to be this musical and fluid on a first listen but Smith’s drumming here makes me feel like some people are BORN with a musical spirit.
THAT SOLO>>>> 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯
I had to scroll way too far to see someone say this.
And just like that, here we are 💪😄
These always make me smile 💜
This is insane. It’s like he’s the lead, it’s so good. The son is like a backing track to his drumming.
I would absolutely love to have Chad be a re-occurring guest on this. Between his talent, natural comedic impulses, and overall desire to play on the fly makes these episodes some of the most entertaining content. Much love to you all.
The energy Smith brings is contagious. Him riffing over the original drum track and going ham was gold.
i really liked how the part he was playing remained rather consistent after 3:40 while everything in the song started to break apart ontop of it. very cool effect
6:16 and following Chad's freestyle is insane, a great demonstration of how technically fantastic he is as a drummer.
Faxx u can tell he just whipped it out heavy cuz the music felt good
The fact it was filmed on the same day and they had this amount of patience to space out this one with there top video, speaks volumes. @Drumeo to the moon
They've got 10 more songs that he did this on and they're going to put out a compilation CD titled Chad does it better
1:11 The transition from black-white to colour and Chad start filling the drum gives me goosebumps. This is unbeatable content.
I'm a guitarist. I don't play the drums. Never heard this song but decided to play along and go listen to the drumless track and see if I could come up with some sort of drum part using the "Gregg Bissonnette" method. Kind of worked...just don't know how to translate to an actual drum kit LOL!
The drumming architecture that Chad built on top of this haunting tune is absoltely insane and yet fitting and appropriate at the same time.
Came for Chad's nuts drumming. Stayed for his sage words of wisdom. Those last 4 minutes are pure gold!
Those werent his nuts drumming. You are thinking of Will Ferrel in Step Brothers
Chad's way added a much deeper and rythmic listen for me.
Sooo much better IMO
man he can't just first take drum everything to perfection without even having heard it a full time first. thats illegal man. it was already incredible the first time and I won't stop being in awe from this level of skill.