Greetings from germany. Literally after decades I dug out the "Colour and the shape" album again. This song is an absolute blast. I didn't remember it at all. Greater than great. Sadly i never saw the "Foo Fighters" live on stage although they had come several times to germany over the years. Greetings from autumn 2024.
I've been a Foo Fighters fan since the beginning and I love the full band with Rami on keys and harmonies from the backup singers, but these old shows have such a cooler energy.
@@SchoolofRockNRoll i think they can afford to lose the 10 minute extended versions, the runways, the storytimes and all the talking and go back to this, but thats just me
@@ab8817I mean they do like putting on a show for the fans, especially a unique one so that each performance is different from the last. Plus, if they just play their songs as they normally do it wouldn’t satisfy everybody as much as it may for you. It’s just about interaction and having fun, they’re also getting old so they can’t bounce around, yell and all that shit like they used to lol.
That someone at 2:44 with the Nirvana In Utero shirt, jumping all 🔥. What an irony to think that the once "Nirvana's drummer" would make it this far. And personally, after all these years, The Colour And The Shape is maybe my favorite from the Foos (At least, part of my Top 3, alongside with their debut album, as well as Wasting Light).
I was there. This was Day 3. I loved their show (first time I saw them), but hate myself for not knowing Pavement at that time and missing them that day.
+Not Brenda so have you noticed that the other guy from foo fighters and the OTHER guy from nirvana look exactly like that one guy from the germs? Weird, I know.
Pat had quit the band at this point, but he agreed to tour until they could get a replacement. That's probably why he was singing weird, he was just so done with touring
@@joshblumer2624 uhh , no ...... he CAN'T sing . The sound city documentary when they're recording with Paul McCartney. Paul asks if pat sings ..and Dave's response was "uhhhhhh.....no" . Go watch the Nirvana Unplugged rehearsal when he was trying to sing harmonies with Kurt on Pennyroyal Tea. It was AWFUL. I know it's so 2021 to come up with a ton of excuses. The dude CAN'T sing ! It's ok ...to just say it .
The reason why Pat Smear was singing horribly was because he was practically done at this point and did not give two flying fucks. It was well known that Pat decided to leave Foo Fighters in September 1997 during their MTV Video Music Awards performance because of exhaustion from touring (Foo's early years were brutal when it came to touring). He was subsequently replaced by Franz Stahl.
Nothing to do with this … sound was shit that day … the night before they had a lit of fun shooting the MTV clip circulating mislabelled as Vienna 1997 …
Pat Smear (nacido como George Albert Ruthenberg el 5 de agosto de 1959) es un guitarrista de rock estadounidense, exmiembro de la banda Germs y actual miembro de Foo Fighters. También es reconocido por haber tocado en vivo con Nirvana como guitarrista rítmico.[1]
I own both of his solo albums. He is not in the closet. More effeminate and got more than you ever will. Why do you want him to be gay? Seriously you got a weird obsession
They should make an album of Pat Smear singing
Pat Smear - So You Fell in Love with a Musician. Check it out.
Pat Smear’s solo albums are pretty good.
😂😂😂😂😂
@@lareeciscomusic2741 Greatest underground album of all-time
Awesome 😂
Pat doesn't give a damn. Off key and loving it.
Greetings from germany. Literally after decades I dug out the "Colour and the shape" album again. This song is an absolute blast. I didn't remember it at all. Greater than great. Sadly i never saw the "Foo Fighters" live on stage although they had come several times to germany over the years. Greetings from autumn 2024.
I've been a Foo Fighters fan since the beginning and I love the full band with Rami on keys and harmonies from the backup singers, but these old shows have such a cooler energy.
Much better energy.
@@garykramermusic do you have the same energy from literally 25 years ago??? lol
@@SchoolofRockNRoll i think they can afford to lose the 10 minute extended versions, the runways, the storytimes and all the talking and go back to this, but thats just me
@@ab8817I mean they do like putting on a show for the fans, especially a unique one so that each performance is different from the last. Plus, if they just play their songs as they normally do it wouldn’t satisfy everybody as much as it may for you. It’s just about interaction and having fun, they’re also getting old so they can’t bounce around, yell and all that shit like they used to lol.
I loved when Pat used to do the harmonies for HJP.
Pat just a little off key..but I can't sing..they so young looks..more mature looks these days
Came to this video for that reason. Pat is pretty punk rock.
@@tracypaech2932 young lol pat is like 39 here
you might say what you want but I found myself singing "johnny park" in Pat's voice couple times today.
That someone at 2:44 with the Nirvana In Utero shirt, jumping all 🔥. What an irony to think that the once "Nirvana's drummer" would make it this far. And personally, after all these years, The Colour And The Shape is maybe my favorite from the Foos (At least, part of my Top 3, alongside with their debut album, as well as Wasting Light).
Damn pat was badass here
I was there. This was Day 3. I loved their show (first time I saw them), but hate myself for not knowing Pavement at that time and missing them that day.
I wish rock music was still valued as much today as it was back then
Pat Forever!!!! ❤
This is the best version of this I’ve found so far love... and Pat’s vocals just kind of make it more memorable.
Personally I think Pat's vocals are great...wish he'd have a chant more often !
Pat is beast man. Check his backing vocals on Pennyroyal Tea and Heart shaped box.
PAT!!!
SMEAR
+Not Brenda so have you noticed that the other guy from foo fighters and the OTHER guy from nirvana look exactly like that one guy from the germs? Weird, I know.
+Jacob James "stranger things have happened"
Awesome performance! One of their best songs!
Pat Smear is the man.
Am i the only one that actually likes the voice of Pat?
I like it more than chris's
I love pats voice!!!
Pat ...LMAO!
almost seems of purpose the off key singing. he sounds good at the end when they sound like they are singing together rather than at each other
SIT ANNDD WAAHCH
Pat had quit the band at this point, but he agreed to tour until they could get a replacement. That's probably why he was singing weird, he was just so done with touring
The end was so good
Now...we know why Pat doesn't sing B.V's anymore...good gawd
Josh Martins 😂😂😂
You need to revisit how F'ing awesome this version of HJP is.
@@BrianMaguireMKE nah, I really don't. If it was so "awesome" Pat would still be singing B.V's ...and he doesnt !
Could see dave smiling? Maybe Pat was deliberately that bad? Lol.
@@joshblumer2624 uhh , no ...... he CAN'T sing . The sound city documentary when they're recording with Paul McCartney. Paul asks if pat sings ..and Dave's response was "uhhhhhh.....no" . Go watch the Nirvana Unplugged rehearsal when he was trying to sing harmonies with Kurt on Pennyroyal Tea. It was AWFUL. I know it's so 2021 to come up with a ton of excuses. The dude CAN'T sing ! It's ok ...to just say it .
Dude at 3:50 is all of us.
Weird people: Dave is so mean to Pat
Dave most of the time: **complimenting Pat**
You know Pat does this shit on purpose to fuck with Dave.😂😂😂
No … the sound was shit that day … the night before shooting for MTV they were great, joking, giving an awesome performance.
@scratchmytail Nice to hear Pat in the background too
The reason why Pat Smear was singing horribly was because he was practically done at this point and did not give two flying fucks. It was well known that Pat decided to leave Foo Fighters in September 1997 during their MTV Video Music Awards performance because of exhaustion from touring (Foo's early years were brutal when it came to touring). He was subsequently replaced by Franz Stahl.
Nothing to do with this … sound was shit that day … the night before they had a lit of fun shooting the MTV clip circulating mislabelled as Vienna 1997 …
"This is a song off our new record"
* blinks *
Covid-19
“siiiiiittttttttt and waaaaaaaaatch” - Pat Smear
Love Pat’s punky back up vocals 😜🤘
Omg not seen since 1997 omg wasn't beck at the same show ? Where he chanted bottles and cans clap ya hands ? Memoirs memories
Pat!!!!!!!
Dave looks like Luis Suárez in this video
Pat Smear (nacido como George Albert Ruthenberg el 5 de agosto de 1959) es un guitarrista de rock estadounidense, exmiembro de la banda Germs y actual miembro de Foo Fighters. También es reconocido por haber tocado en vivo con Nirvana como guitarrista rítmico.[1]
Rip Taylor
Calm down, maybe he was just having trouble listening to himself. Singing in that situation is never easy
Pat sounds like Fred Schneider
Pat…Good lord 🤣
i always wanted to start a band, but that would not have a pat smear in it so whats the use
sounds better wen they play it in their early days then today, apart from smears backing vocals
wtf do you guys mean pat singing is the bomb
Pats vocals arent that bad I think they still harmonize..its live , so its never 100% accurate.
i wish they stay in 1997
Pat's harmonies sounds too punkys
Because he came from a punk band
Yeah pat can't sing rock. He can only sing punk
Pat... Leave the singing to Dave man...
For some reason I read that as "Leave the singing to Deftones man..." and I got really confused lmao
A good sound guy would have "accidentally" turned off Pat's mic.
And that's why you're nothing
bljjl
Pat Smear gay?!?!
No, he's been married for 25 years and has kids
@@Valeo1993 Believe me I know lol. I think he's in the closet. Have you.listened to his solo album So You Fell in Love With A Musician??
I own both of his solo albums. He is not in the closet. More effeminate and got more than you ever will. Why do you want him to be gay? Seriously you got a weird obsession
@@Valeo1993 its an inside joke you will never understand lol
@@Valeo1993 wait ...Pat Smear....is......GAAAAAAY?!?