as a tamilian, there is no problem that we are paying to bihar and jharkhan but when we see that these states are not focusing on development, this really boils my blood. I request all the states to strictly focus on thier development. Jai Bharat
Bihar is a problem but not up , bcs up ppl wants to develop. They are having 74% literacy right now. Soon they will have 90% but bihar has only 45% literacy. Lmao
Exactly. Their leaders are always up in arms in the name of religion and keep themselves occupied with violence. They openly call for violence and rape and no one does anything to arrest them. For some reason, changing the fcking names of stations is more important to UP than actually focusing on development. And yes everyone in UP gets a boner at the sight of the stupid JCB bulldozer destroying houses lol..
I'm from Tamilnadu. Once i attended interview for a private bank (ICICI) in Hyderabad. I cleared 1st round at 2nd round 2 members were there one guy is from South and another lady from North. For that job they don't ask for Hindi mandatory but English mandatory in description. That South Indian selected me but at last he said,"Mam do you have any questions to candidate". She questions me in Hindi and forced me to talk Hindi even I told that i didn't know. If needed, i will learn. But she keep on asking,"Are you from Tamilnadu". Tamil and English languages only known by you. She harshly said you can't speak everyone with your Mother Tongue Tamil. Even that sir in the interview also shocked and rejected me for Hindi. I always see no difference between Indians.North ,East, Central or South all are indians but why North people behave like this.
@praveen0083, then why are they coming to Maharashtra, we maharashtrian don't go to Tamil Nadu. Answer that. In an organisation when you work with a department dominated by Tamilians, what the rest of Indians face is bullying, harassment and hatred.
As a south Indian, I feel very bad when I see that most of the major projects and mega projects are mostly done in north India, even if most of the funding is coming indirectly from south India.
most the road and train infra projects go to north india unfortunately. South India is literally funding those projects. Don't mind overall improvement of India, but South India do need its fair share of money back !
I'm from Tamilnadu. Thank you Mohak. You wouldn't know how grateful I am to you for bringing up this discussion. I'm not saying we (south) are the victims. We (indians) are the victims. The perpetrators being CORRUPT POLITICIANS.
@ahmed why do you try? Are you like a bot pretending to be a Pakistani so that Indians stay united... just know South is not with North as we feel Pakistan is a threat... because we share some culture
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected. why is the Biasedness? WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR? BUT Not NE states? Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected? I dare you to Pin My comment.. And reply me back. I want my answer what's up with Absurd title. Why selective biased?
@@iamsureshourtelugustg1887 it is not Bombay it is Mumbai. Even if you remove Mumbai, Maharashtra will still have bigger GDP and tax returns than any other states.
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
As a resident of Darjeeling , I always respect south indian coz they never make in debeat about religion , hard working for upliftment of india , and still developing faster than north being descriminating by central govt
The "Religion" one is well said. As someone from TamilNadu , I need to address that no one here fights over religion . We all Live in the same street without having any difference .
@@smallcube-zn2mmbecause most of the radical Islamist live in north check the facts what Muslim are doing in north stone pelting conversion is growing but still blame hindus of north 😊😊 in north in one Muslim family there is 6-7 children but blame north terrorist activities happen mostly in north still 😊 I love my india and I cant choose one ovr another north is also very beautiful Himachal pradesh sikkim North East Rajasthan Gujarat etc😊
@@shrutisaha7786unless u treat ur other religions with respect and reduce community clashes, companies won't invest in a place where there is communal unrest, people r not thinking of religion more than education and development and u r not going to grow in north. Grow up guys
The real problem is that most of money which goes to bihar doesn't go to poor but to the bank account of politicians. South generates more revenue but hardly get any help from union government.
Nah, I know that a lot of corruption is there in Bihar, but this money doesn't go to the account of politicians(as their counts is maintained). You can watch a video on it somewhere else on youtube.
What about if we look at per capita tax ??Sikkim give the most about 30,000 2nd is Goa about 25,000. And Isn't it a Well understood fact that Hill states will need more funding for same length of Railways than the plains of South??? And Do ever North Indian states gets funding for Port development or coastal corridors ?... Yes there is problem but you can't be selfish you have geographical advantage of having a coast ....North Doesn't have that Bihar gets flooded every year it isn't the case with Tamil Nadu .... Countering the comments in a positive way just for objective attention over the issue 1 Yes South Indian States are better in management 2 Yes South also have Risks of claimities like Tsunami but North is at greater risk of Earthquakes 3 Telangana doesn't have a coast surely but we all know from where that gdp comes from ( Hyderabad) and how that was developed 4 I am not saying the imbalance is not there but the issue is It's not just a phenomenon that happens in India In United States California the richest state receives the least while Puerto Rico gets the most So does that mean US government is anti Californian ???
If South India becomes a country of its own ,north India will become the next afghanistan. No economic,political or social stability with very less literacy.
@@_kartik_chauhan which fantasy land are you living in? Kerala and Bihar have been victims of flood and a bigger threat called "Tsunami" in the past and are very prone to these two calamities. The reason you don't notice it is because these states are very good in mitigating the threat and taking all safety precautions despites the limited funds they get. They value their people's lives unlike UP,Bihar where people are available in abundance.
I'm also a migrant from bengal living and working in Hyderabad, Telangana state for past 5 years. I've real development (both economic and infra) happening here in front of eyes. States like Bihar don't really deserve to be allocated so much funds as they simply misuse those funds for dirty political gains, while the same could be used in a much better way to fuel India's economic growth here in the South. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
From where do you bring such logics bruhh?? With that logic the two states should be disowned by the country, right?? This is no solution. Instead of this, the central government should launch strict welfare schemes in the field of education and health in these states. They should track the expenditure of every penny given by them. No country can be successful if they ignore and disown any part or region of the country due to various factors.
@@KingsonKeshav lol even in 2023 Bihar government is doing caste based politics and people are electing government on the basis of caste still in Bihar no way Bihar is gonna developed anytime soon...even now UP is doing better than Bihar... So yes Bihar is a burden on India
@@famousd3094 7-8 years ago the condition was almost same in UP also. But later they realised who they should vote. They got a brilliant leadership and today it is one of the most prospering state in our country. Everything takes time and effort both. Moreover the current government of Bihar was not directly elected by their people. BJP made a huge mistake by contesting the election in alliance with JDU. They should have fought it as a single party and without a doubt they could get majority even there. Also, BJP is protesting against this caste based census from the very first day. At last I would say only one thing that each state has its contribution in building this country be it even only 1 percent. We have to grow as a whole. And rectification is the only solution to any problem not leaving it on its own. If we go by your logic gov should have left j&k on its fate due to the terrorism there. But no, we took steps and see the result today. I am as much optimistic about Bihar, west bengal, north-east states as about Delhi, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, Kerala Karnataka, Gujarat or any other sate. Jai Hind 🇮🇳🚩
@Ur father is cry about it 👎 As per the map provided in the start of the video, bengal is getting 90.5 for every 100 rupees while bihar is getting 300+ for the same amount. So it means is getting less money than what they are sending
You are right railway should be divided into zone and according to that profit earned should be used for same zone development. Most of north india don't even buy ticket but move freely in the train.
I am a south Indian. I have no problem with paying more. But states like bihar won't concentrate on development. Instead they are doing caste based census. It just boils my blood.
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
Exactly, that's the point They are wasting money just for politics Central gov denied it, then after making nee alliance they decided to this by money of state gov. When reporter asked that how it will help people, his ans was it will benefit but he didn't explain how?? They are just doing it for votes. After bihar it is going to be UP. Many people in bihar don't care about this census but gov wants it for vote bank politics. Just because of these kind of steps bihar and up are poor states, specially bihar
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected. why is the Biasedness? WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR? BUT Not NE states? Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
Don’t be sorry it’s not your fault Your government is not able to control and develop your state because they don’t want to but if they want than also the people commented from corruption, crime and nepotism don’t have any knowledge to do good stuff You know that UP and Bihar have best fertile soil so it means the god have given them every opportunity but the humans behind them are not able to do any progress If government gives more money to states/areas like Jammu and Kashmir we can understand on that basis Also for Ladakh and Rajasthan also we can understand but for UP and Bihar it’s total waste as they are not developing without having any geographical or geological problems
I'm from North East India, It's true that south Indian states are helping northern India financially and technologically, thanx to people of South Indian states ❤️
@@arnavsharma2635 u know what we all South Indians are same.dravidans means the early indians we are connected to eachother, don't speak if you don't know anything 😂😂
Giving money to underdeveloped states is okay, but there is a limit. I wondered why 59 crore for South India and why 13000 crore for North? It is highly unfair number. The ratio is 1: 220 🙁 how one can be silent on such huge huge difference
@@Rezal_rzl 😂 , haryana Punjab have less population then south state but more GDP like compared to Telangana, only bihar , jharkhand aren't doing good by the way haryana, Punjab give more tax then you people
Bihar gets ₹ 922 Tamilnadu gets ₹ 29 But Maharashtra gets only ₹ 7 😡 Both central and state gov. Ignore backward parts of state, like Marathwada, khandesh, vidarbha
Bihar is poor state and we need to support them otherwise the gap will become huge and there will be too much migration of Bihar and up to South Indian states
@@imawarrior4527 Bihar humesha backward rhega jbtk wha corrupt neta h itna paise kha jta h bhai south India mein itna come investment krte h pr wha log bht educated h
@@imawarrior4527 i am basically from Karnataka i agree with your words but due to the low budget given to us health and education is destroying roads are not properly provided due to lack of funds many offices are closed because of this government employees in Karnataka is not getting pension they only 4000 after this that's why central government want to some less money to Bihar and look towards us
you are doing language politics not northies .. and religion politics is there bcoz parties who actually destroyed u.p and bihar used muslim vote bank foe thier benefits ... For bjp it's is compulsory to polarise otherwise muslims vote in block and hindus vote get divided on many parties ... in kerala you are appeasing certain societies ... that's y even christians started complaining abt appeasement politics of kerala ...
@T Riav In TN, we hate imposition of hindi, not hindi itself. Though, I may not entirely agree with any kinds of divisive politics, be it lang. or faith. In TN, language unites every tamilian, regardless of faith, caste and creed. Somehow, language politics stopped religious politics.
🙄As A Maharashtrian, We Cannot Deny The Fact That Most Central Government Mainly Focus On Up,Bihar due to Their Vote Bank which is mainly Based On Caste Politics, Main Topics like Development, Infrastructure, Education like topics are missing and that's makes A huge Difference 😐.
2 topic . 1 topic = . union of state means - Dr. B.R. Ambedkar said that the Indian was a “Union of States” instead of a “Federation of States” because it was indissoluble, and no State had a right to separate from the Indian Union. The country is one integral unit beside the fact that it consists of different states for the convenience of administration.
2 topic = i have only one request - don't call south India and north India , call them south part of India and north part of India . thank you , jay hind . note - copy pest multiple time to spread awareness and new thinking .
As a Maharashtrian, I can tell you that I'm absolutely baffled by these figures. We're not mad that our tax money is being used to build infra and RRTS trains in U.P, but we're mad about the fact that most of our hard earned tax money goes into the pockets of corrupt politicians. This is the reason why people in my state, both natives and immigrants have started resenting the Centre. But more than that our opinions are not being heard, our voices have been silenced and our political representation has been smothered by the recent political upheaval that occured in the past few months.
@@omnamahshivaya7894 so what he & his fellow state men are indians too. Why don't these financialy back ward states improve they are hindering Indias growth as a whole.
Pardon my comment, but how did you make your English this good. I've seen many comments here, top comments too but yours sound flawlessly good, like a native speaker.
As a tamilian i don't mind our tax money going to underdeveloped states like up, Bihar etc. It has to go to the needeones. But not looting. There should be a monitoring committee inclusive of all states representation. Every two years we have to review how the funds utilized. I strongly believe unity is strength. 🏵️
@@EIGatito in video they explained that if headquarter is located in one state and company is paying tax there it doesn't mean they are getting benifits only from that state
That's what exactly ED is doing. Everyone (thieves) are blaming Central Government for this , i don't know how stupid way of thinking is this . ED and NIA all are on its full form. Unlike those previous governments this Government didn't put any restrictions or any influence on "special" cases. ED and NIA were given their "Rights" to their job. I'm a Keralite , our situation has been changed since communist government got on power , God's own country became terrorist's and burglar's own country. Both red terrorists and green terrorists. No one is allowed to start a business here without "paying" in party fund. Lots of gulf retirees had to stop their ventures and some of them had to do suicide. Our present chief minister from communist party once he didn't have another pair of dress to change , his father was a toddy worker, now he has more than 25000 crores of assets. He is being now chased by ED and other agencies on gold and black money smuggling issues . You search on malayalam news channels. I know Tamilians understand malayalam a little. I've relatives in Palani.
@@EIGatito sorry our Notheast is Naturally developed as well Artificially developed also 🙌 We are giving money to Poor Bihar UP since from 1947 till they are not developed 🤧😂
We, people of North India, should accept our mistake that neither its people nor the governments of North India focused on human capital. There were not enough steps to promote better education and health infrastructure. And also not enough incentives for companies to set up factories and raise employment. South Indian states have done an incredible job, and we should learn from them. And take measures to promote equality and give them taxes and representation they deserve. Jai Hind, Jai Bharat 🇮🇳
Speak for yourself man I who is mixture from Haryana and Uttarakhand can say these BIMARU states do not develop and run to other states and breed like rabbits
@RohanSharmacap Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh are showing rapid development. And I am sure our states will do good in future and for its people. It will be great competition between states to have better growth, infrastructure and human development. This will ultimately lead to growth story of India.
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected. why is the Biasedness? WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR? BUT Not NE states? Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected? I dare you to Pin My comment.. And reply me back. I want my answer what's up with Absurd title. Why selective biased?
I'm from karnataka. I really don't mind if our money goes to lesser developed states. But my only problem is that the money won't go in development but into politician's pockets. We are all one at the end of the day.
@@jioboy2676 lol 😂 i m living in bjp ruled m.p 😂 and bjp has been ruling m.p since 2003 & i can say that bjp made m.p whatever it is today ... best infra ...and continously doing so ... best state for peaceful living ...
@@riav.T i think you are overrating our MP. i am also from jhansi and bjp voter but it have not been so much that you say ya but UP is rapidly developing. only in 5 year up gdp have been double
It's because all major companies' headquarters are located in Mumbai. Revenue is not being generated in Mumbai but is being generated throughout the country and being stocked and taxed out of Mumbai.
but you never cared abt inequality that mumbai has been facing ... 😂 financial city of india has less infra than delhi ... even delhi pays more than it gets ...
@@hyperssb4103 then go and improve your state first then come to Maharashtra... Mumbai is for everyone but if you comment like this then I will proudly say that Mumbai is for Marathi people 🚩🚩🚩🚩
@@hyperssb4103 Mumbai is financially strong because of Marathi manus ⛳. Jagannnath Shankarsheth, this Marathi man made his valuable contribution for what Mumbai today is . And Maharashtra is not rich because of Mumbai. Sugar factories in MH and environment and other factors are also major factors for Maharashtra's economic growth. And politicians here, be it from any party everyone gives contribution to economy.
I am maharastrian. I don't have any issue for getting very less money than what we give. But the issue is the states getting more money don't show development as it should. It's not just injustice against us but also people living in those States Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
You must be living in Mumbai or Pune that's why, go out side of this city and you will see real face , Maharashtra have other regions too to develop but we are not getting enough money
Bro it's not that Bihar is paying 100 and getting 900 or MH paying 100 and getting 7 It's like MH -7 = 10-14- BIHAR BIHAR must be getting more revenue than MH but isn't not like 900 & 7 rupees MH earns more reason why % of return looks small and Bihar earns less reason why % looks more But actual revenue that is received can max. double what MH is getting
As a maharashtrian, i feel that fear of political representation of southern states because of linguistic basis and also economic inequality.... All political parties mainly focus on north india because of large numbers of votes and they are from only one language base ....
Your Suresh kalmadi had already taken 22000 crore rupees to pocket. Abd 2g scam,3 g scam of tamimians ..yiu know that worth is 3 lakh crore rupees. So looters in south india too. Thatvis why most powerful leader of south Chidambaram waS arrested. And your sarad Pawanr,chhgan Bhujbal everyone knows..
South Indians makes lots of noise when they are not benefitted becouse they make sure that they are always being benefitted...up and Bihar needs help from central govt to get developed,rise above of poverty..everybody needs money but govt should provide help to those who needs the help the most...it should not be given basen on tax otherwise some states will become too much rich and will have everything but some states will have nothing to eat
@@annAdafc what you're saying is correct and that is exactly what Gandhi and Nehru have done when they established an equal India. But Bihar and up should improve and contribute even more instead of letting their politicians corrupt all the money. It is the right of Indian tax payers to demand development and only Biharis can demand development in Bihar.
North Indian governments should concentrate in their state developments not in their party devepments , North India more funding no developments and south India less funding more developments then why u people supporting such parties .
Just For example if you look at the budget of Railways it's not evenly distributed to north and south states and surprisingly south indian railway stations are well cleaned and maintained with less allocated budgets when compared to northern states and every south Indian government should step up and fight for fair distribution of funds ... I appreciate you brother ... You're doing an unbiased work 👌🏻👌🏻
@@Abhinay_Singh0 railway transportation is cheaper at every part of India. What he says is... Though the north India gets high budget for development,it has not well developed when being compared to south India
South Indians makes lots of noise when they are not benefitted becouse they make sure that they are always being benefitted...up and Bihar needs help from central govt to get developed,rise above of poverty..everybody needs money but govt should provide help to those who needs the help the most...it should not be given basen on tax otherwise some states will become too much rich and will have everything but some states will have nothing to eat
Being a Maharashtrian, it is disheartening to see how Maharastra is being ignored even after being the most developed both, economically and socially, state in the country. The argument that India is a union of state is only good on paper, it is worthless when I am getting peanuts in return for the value we are adding as the most developed state of the country.
It is important that we make our weak areas strong and if you want to divide go ahead but will be easily captured by Pakistan china or even india 😂 so get ready to spend everything on military
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
so what ?? no country in the world has complete development in all sections of thier geography ?? are every districts of south indian states equally contributing to thier SGDP ?? in USA california alone is paying most of the taxes so what ?? even in china every province is not equally developed
As a north indian living in south India since last 15 years. I must say that south indians are very honest and hard working people. They focus on their education and development. But the sad part is that stats like bihar and UP are just enjoying the money getting from union govt and politician filling their pockets. Nobody even focusing on education and development. So after few years this kind of discrimination with south india will increase. No state will give hard earned money to states like bihar Jharkhand. Poor are getting poor and rich are getting richer day by day in currupt state like bihar.
Yeah ??? Really ??? We are enjoying the money like seriously ??? Gali Dene ka Mann kar Raha ...par dunga nahi ....tax collection dekha h UP ka ??? Tu ek kàaam kar agle 10 baaad compare lena UP ko India k kisi bhi states se !!!! Or sun haramkhori sirf up me nahi pure India me h samjha ...faltu ka Gyan mat Diya kar !!!!
UP and Bihar are enjoying no not.. the North Politicians are enjoying... that's why people from UP and Bihar are coming down to South states for survival
@Kirti Kishore most industries are in Western UP(harit pradesh) not in your purvanchal and bundelkhand area South people are right why do you people go to South or come to Western UP for everything first develop your area and even before industrial development in Western UP(harit pardesh)we had everything we are strong people. See our ratio in Indian Army, forces and farming what did you people did for country paan thukna k elawa bss yaha aa jao bheed bdaa do yaha ki NCR main bss kabhi dekha hain humra yaha ka koi tumhara bihar purvanchal main raah raha ho
@Kirti Kishore 🤣🤣🤣 you don't know anything from history Gurjar Prathihar kingdom is Rajasthan haryana Western Up and we don't need any industries here in NCR why did you people come here first answer this question and we don't migrate anywhere we protect our land there is difference aap log apna waha kuch kar nahi payaa population yaha bad rahi hain problem tho hogi locals ko
Really appreciate you Mohak despite you being a Hindi speaker and come from North India you have narrated this Tax imbalances with Southern states. This is how the social media needs to be without any bias, great work 🙌
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected. why is the Biasedness? WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR? BUT Not NE states? Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected? I dare you to Pin My comment.. And reply me back. I want my answer what's up with Absurd title. Why selective biased?
As a person from UP, I want to thank all our South Indian and West Indian brothers. Even after you people giving so much money there is so much to develop here🥺. We will be grateful to you.
As a Maharashtrian… We suffer this problem the Most. With Due Respect to Everyone, We Contribute the Most in our Country & Receive the least. Thus, we understand this Sentiments better than anyone
You should not think like that.... India is one country and that's how democracy work... Where we take from riche and give it to poor..... Supposed if tomorrow ambani adani tata and all richest man start saying this that you take so much money from us and gave to poors?.. Why would we gave our hard earn money to poors??... What did you say then?
Those who earn more, pay taxes more. There should be no regret for it. Aise to A&N, chhattisgarh etc ka kabhi development nahi ho payga. This will be injustice to tribal people.
This is so bad for Maharashtra because the income disparity between Konkan+Marathwada region with Vidharbha is huge... atleast they should get some of their own money
Yeah if vidharbha and Marathwada is utilised ,Maharashtra economy will reach 1 trillion $ in no time , also some places are exactly in middle of India , gadkari ji is already working on it to make it logistical hub.
I m living in chhatrapati shambaji nagar and I can say our is only city in marthwada which is develop and have industry but if I go to jalna there os nothing we need to focus now or never I want to see jalna and every other district like chhatrapati shambajingar but in this tax amount it's impossible.
Let us declare Bihar as a union territory, caste politics have really impacted the progress of Bihar. Illiterate people are choosing criminals and undeserving politicians and those politicians are again making people dumber and this vicious cycle continues. A union territory for 15-20 years can easily break this cycle. (I would like to know the reaction of people espacially Biharis in the comment section)
as a bihari i can approve this. let bihar be a union territory for 20 years as people are still not mature enough to cast a vote. educate them until they realise there is smthng above caste
As a keralite I feel if we get much more we could have done much more to our people. It's the same for all south Indians and for maharashtra i feel so bad
@@Jungle_boy123 lmao 😂 But plz one request don't produce kids now Maharashtra is 3largest state in India and Bihar is much smaller in Area but still Bihar has overtaken Maharashtra in terms of Population
I am from Beed District in Maharastra and it is really underdeveloped and and poor and highest numbers of farmers die by suicde in this District and same case with the Marathwada region and Vidhraba region in Maha. We also need money and resoucrces to develop but if only north state don't suck up all the money
@Kirti Kishore asking for rights is not crying, Industries come to Maharashtra cuz they provide good working environment, in northern states even tho resources are there due to uneducated people and hooliganism, no industries come there. What Maharashtra is today is because of Marathis hard work and the good work environment they provided. If you really want to see super hard working Marathis go to Marathwada , Vidhraba region, where people work so hard yet they are poor , cuz government did not develop these regions. The only one i see crying is you on many comments.
To say that North Indians had a major contribution in the development of South Indian states is a big mistake. North Indian labourers only started working in Southern states only recently. I am a South Indian and it is only in the last 10 - 15 years we have seen an influx of laborers from the North. Southern states like Kerala have only their people to thank for the development their state has made in social, economic, and infrastructure aspects.
Yes you are absolutely right. Mohak got this view point wrong that it's only the North labourers who contributed to the success of the South. The migration of North labourers to the south started only in last 10yrs or so. Before that, you hardly see them down here. May be 25yrs down the lane, if he makes this comment, it may be right. But not now.
The other way to look at it is, the workers living in their own state didn't have any work or good business. But they heard the cheap quality of life and labour requirement and job opportunities in the south, which were created by the south govts and they migrated. If they had opportunities in their own state, why would they migrate to another state. Leaving everyone and everything behind
Im from Telangana. I have no problem that states like Bihar get more funds in return. But the question is..for how much longer? Its not like these states are using the funds for 'development'. Vande Mataram
I Love how mohak being a north indian himself,but still concerns about our south too.....These issues are lesser explored......Thank you mohak for spitting facts(Unbiasedly) Love From South India❤️
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected. why is the Biasedness? WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR? BUT Not NE states? Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
But it's same for every Country which have many states Including united states California get the least amount it sent to the federal government and Puerto Rico gets the highest.... So it can't be called Discrimination
As a northeastern I prefer south rather than North, these are the reason:- (1) I got called names every day but very rare in the south (2) No discrimination on what I eat in the south (3)People are very welcoming (4) I had to face racism every day in the north but very rare in the south. This are the few reasons why I moved from North to South,
I am from Tamilnadu and I honesly am fine with it. I am an Indian first and I want entire India to develop. But states like Bihar must not enjoy our money just like that and must focus on developing, which unfortunately is not happening. Happy to see UP develop though.
The main reason for the fear among South on loosing the parliament representation is the language. If south looses further seats then there will be forceful imposition of Hindi in South and there will be planned attack to convert the southern states into a Bihar.
Excuse me sir?? I am from south india and here in public or private school hindi language is official *hammko bhi hindi ate hai*.*in south india some state like karnataka, telengana kerala and Andhrapradesh hindi language is important, official in college and school also hindi speaker can use hindi*
Even north Indians don't like Hindi. I'm from West UP and Wikipedia says we speak Hindi, but we don't. When I speak people say I'm Harayanvi. I know the difference between Harayanvi and my language. Hindi is just a crab. Its eating up the variations of North Indian languages.
@@ShivanshuTyagi72981 I see. But I don't understand why hindi language don't like in North india it is unbelievable.... In South india, we don't hate each other bcz south indian language are family so we support each other. The problem in North india is they don't support each other if their language is from one family. There North indian people don't have feeling towards their family of language this is why in North india many incidents happen
As a tamilian settled in Mumbai since birth all states are one it's amazing that South is very developed whereas due to corrupt politicians in North who are interested in lining they have totally ignored their people But the main cause of worry is after 2026 if lok sabha seats of South is reduced it will spell disaster as their political representation will reduce central government has to seriously think about this before finalizing it
Correctly said!. Already in vote politics National parties are concentrating only on UP, Bihar, MP and Rajastan (Hindi Belt). if they win, solidly they will get MP seats more than 200. Wherein if we consider south: Kerala, TN, Karnataka, AP, Telugana < 100 MP seats. Just think. In vote politics 200 seats are more than enough for ruling entire india. hence always politics will be based on hindi belt. This should be changed. if Union govt, plan to decrease MP seats then it will lead to big riot. Union govt should think.. India is not one country. India is made by multiple countries (now we call it as states in independent india). Another think: South developed because of major control in birth ratio. this helped politicians to focus on development and education. but north didn't focus on this. in south: a family will have 1.5 children i.e.) either 1 or 2 in north: a family will have 3.5 children. see the difference. Example: In india Just UP population : ~22 crores But South India population is below UP. South India need to think.
@@sachinraghuwanshi4917 correct! so any PM in union india will not require any support from South or east or west India. Moreover, people from North or south or west or east thought process will be different. but rule or order will be based on North people and it will be imposed on us and will not be fit for others. This should be changed..else in future other than north all people in union india will be looted and face lot of problems.
If south seats decrease in 2026, I expect these states to secede or violent movements to start. No one wants their tax payer $$ going to others who can’t help themselves.
As South Indian states we too like to be a part of overall development of India, but even after 75 years of Independence why are the states of Bihar, UP, MP and Jharkhand still declared as under-developed states and the dependence is raising year on year Dependence from southern states for revenue cannot be continued forever. The respective state governments and center should be held equally liable for these kind of situations
@Kirti Kishore Sorry but North Indian states have more number of seats in loksabha for representation If they wanted it to be removed they would have done it long back.
Don't count m.p dud ... first learn the geography of india ... M.P is the forest state ( we can't destroy our national parks for development ) and its location best in the country ... with low population to its land size ... even infra wise it's more developed than many south indian states ..😂 two cleaniest city of india are in m..p alone .. it's also a home to highest st population in the country ...
As a Telangana person i feel happy that my state is contributing to the growth of the nation. We are 2.5% of population and contributing 5% to the GDP. Proud Telanganaite. Proud Hyderabadi.
As a maharastrian, l always blamed our government for not doing that much. But now l can see, what is happening to us. We gave opportunity to North indians to grow, which their state couldn't gave them. And we still baby sitting North india.
As a person from UP,i feel bad for south indians they are not getting what they deserve in terms of funds, i feel ashamed being north indian for slow progress in development due to huge corruption going on here,i really love south people they r so humble, hardworking, i have some friends from south who always help me and wont expect anything in return🥺🥺😭😭😭.i love south indians
I am from Up sister 😂 And that much u criticise about Up, it is not even that bad 😂 I think u live in dream ..and if u talk about crime rate then Kerala always shown ISIS terrorism and much more but we never talked about that bcz if it's high literacy rate ...so every state has its bad and good things okay
South India not a heaven as you are thinking, they have almost same problem like us, i have been to south and when it comes to social issues hardly South is different from north.
In south India tribals are treated more badly than Dalits in north, Atleast Dalits have political voice in north but in South tribals don't even have political voice.
South indian states have controlled and reduced their population over the years, whereas in northern states the story is opposite. South Indians states always had to carry the burden of BIMARU states, unfortunately north indian states because of their population had got huge representation in parliament and hence dominate national politics, and hence south indians are ignored always preference is given to north indian states, be it highways or other development schemes, south indian states are only a treasure/cash cow to the govt of india, they don't treat south india as a part of india. Period
Uttarakhand HP Ladakh Jammu Punjab disagrees. Up bihar are not the only northern states. Stop using northern resources too and labour as well then improve. We depend on each other that's why it's a country. And above all problem are corrupt politician not people remember people are getting no development the money is for corrupt politicians. 🙏
UP and Bihar are not North Indian states. North Indian states ( j&k, Himachal, uttarakhand, haryana, Punjab) have controlled their population efficiently and have lower fertility rate than national average
@@nitkills7070 all those states are nothing compared in job creation or industries. WE ARE SPECIFICALLY TAKING ABOUT BIMARU ALL FALL IN NORTHERN PART. WEST+SOUTH CREATE SO MUCH REVENUE AND GIVE TAX WHICH ULTIMATELY BIMARU EATS UP
@@krjg9809 we were historically ignored df man, uttarakhand became a state in 1999 before that up was having all the tax so? Why can't we create jobs and industry because central govt has always been the problem and have ignored deep northern states.
I think the problem is not how much cash does north Indian states are getting. but how they are utilizing there money. I am not saying there are no political scandals in south India. but the ration b/w the two can't be ignored. I think every state should improve the quality and both quantity of their education.
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
Maharashtra being the driver of Indian Economy is only getting 7.7 Rs which is the lowest in India but still we are ready to contribute in all the way possible for the future of India but the Indian Govt should focus on Maharashtra and give back atleast 15 Rs in return which Maharashtra deserves. Jai Hind Jai Maharashtra🚩
Yet,south India has more literacy rate and has developed tremendously compared to North. People in North are still obsessed with govt jobs while people of South are changing the world itself
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected. why is the Biasedness? WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR? BUT Not NE states? Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected. why is the Biasedness? WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR? BUT Not NE states? Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected? I dare you to Pin My comment.. And reply me back. I want my answer what's up with Absurd title. Why selective biased?
@@ruby-brawlstars8540 People living in slums gradually progressing day by day & Most of them migrating from Bangladesh, Burma, Nepal and northen part of India. If politicians of Mumbai working well towards society Mumbai will be slum free by 2047.
I am a taxpayer from the Northeast, and it is lovely to see Indians from all parts of India are engaged in creative comments to promote cooperation and brotherhood. I really hope that heard earned tax payer money is put to a good use. Jai Bharat..
Dude, you are a bengali living in one of the northeastern states. Despite this much attention (atleast social media) on them nowadys. Where are they ? They should be interacting with us here. They say that they don't get represented. How will they get represented in the mainstream if they don't put their opinions in the mainstream ? I see that they have made like a separate group of their own in their own youtube channels with heavy social media engagement but where there engagement is necessary they don't engage themselves. Even north and south interacts with each other like a love-hate relationship but where are the NE Indians ?
Atleast this bengali dude is trying to represent on behalf NE Indians here. What are the NE Indians doing when they should be the ones representing themselves here ? Where are they ? Why this much exclusivity from them ?
I guess within the next 100 years, South India will get separated and forms it's own independent nation amd focus all these money to it's own development.
TN finance minister said that - they don't have problem with giving out more money but the real problem is he doesn't see that money being put to good use. That is why he said it is like pouring money in a dump.
lol 😂 same DMK who was involved in corruption 😂 during upa regime ... 😂 right ?? it's DMK who is hand in gloves with parties who actually destroyed u.p and bihar ... ?? could i know why ?? 😂 u.p added more than 50 billion dollars in its SGDP & i think it's highest in india ... so what the hell they are complaining abt ??
@Ak You still believe in tha bullshit propaganda theory proposed by Britishers . Do Aryans look like us . Germans have Aryan ancestry do they look like us 😂😂😂
In a family, it’s normal for a well off brother to look out for his siblings when they are in bad times. So it’s ok that South sometimes subsidises for the North - that’s what families do, even when they may not always agree with each other. But what makes the relationship toxic is when the weaker sibling uses his other strengths to gain control of the household. That’s when problems happen.
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
I'm from Telangana, we don't have any problem to allocate tax amounts in North India but the problem is I can't see the growth in that states why because they are misusing these funds for dirty politics. As a Indian I want see my country has doveloped country hope it will comes true
I thought Telangana will ask for a separate country just like it asked for separate state citing unfair treatment. Thank God you didn't think like that.
@@pokemonitishere202 All telangana people respect India they know they're a part of India and separate state was asked bcoz there were lot of prblms for rural telangana villages 10 yrs ago( water prblm, power cuts, drought, corruption, less connectivity)
As a Bengali when I see states like Tamil Nadu are suffering from not getting enough funds, it's obvious that the state which can do the maximum developement should recieve the max funds , if not it might hinder their developement process. I firmly believe that states like Bihar are a liability to the entire country, we cannot blame the northeast states due to the terrain.
Every state is important. It’s not fair to use the word liability. I am from Chennai. I don’t think Bihar or Up or Bengal as a liability. The whole purpose of taxation is to tax the rich and help the poor. Definitely, the people of Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh doesn’t mind when the government spends on bihar or other states. But there should be proper checks and balances.
Instead of funneling the money into states like Bihar and Jharkhand( as their leaders are not motivated to make the state stable anymore) it is better to use that money for the development of North east because they are educated people and really wanted to progress. Being a Bengali I would vouch for helping North East India to grow further.
In North East there various groups which ask extortion money from people from north south and west india. Even from transport trucks, firms, labours and small engineers. Locals say that it's just like tax u pay to govt. How do u expect development there when they don't want it. Plus if it was so easy then investors would have already done a lot there.
We people from Tamil Nadu are always dealt badly by people in North India especially in UP literally people treats you so badly that one just think to run away they use such Misogynist word to describe people from South such a shame
Yes. I am from UP and I agree with you. South must revolt against the North Indians working there. Drive them away. No representation of North in South without proper tax share. Only then will Delhi listen and treat Biharis how they should be treated.
As a south Indian Its okay if our tax money goes as a part of development to other states but this states like Up ,mp ,bihar are mostly focusing on their hindutva agenda and not focusing on development . Our Ministers are right when they say its like throwing taxpayers money to Well
This scenario between the south Indian states and the northern Indian states reminds me a lot of all the tensions that the former country Yugoslavia had before it broke into several countries. States dominated by linguistic minority groups who are well managed are forced to accommodate the needs of the rest of the nation who are primarily under-achievers.
@@theawesomeman9821 Speaking Hindi or not has nothing to do with having or not having tensions. For example, many freedom fighters spoke and read English. Does that mean there was no tension or conflict between British empire and freedom fighters ?
Though I am from south India (Hyderabad), I am extremely happy to see India recognizing the northeastern states and developing these states in every way, as per UP and Bihar labor worker's contribution, I know they work hard with such low wages and their issues must be addressed at any cost because they are our citizens, and I noticed that you mentioned most south Indians migrating to western countries, yes, I accept that fact, despite the fact that even I'm currently living in the United States, as do most of my friends and relatives, but the reality is that our contribution to India is quite significant since south Indian NRIs spend heavily in India, As an example, in the Hyderabad real estate market, most Andhra and Telangana NRIs purchased at least one housing flat, which easily costs more than one crore, and many more investments in numerous other ways, which contribute to India's economic progress and rise in strong dollar reserves.
As a Kannada speaking Kannadiga myself, we Kannadigas are annoyed with this blatant cheating. Even worse is the lack of sentiments to our Kannada feelings and Kannada people. This is what triggers all Kannadigas. Jai Kannada
I am Marathi who agrees with you. You need to kick out these North Indians and Marwadis. These people already destroyed Mumbai. Now they are trying to destroy Bangalore.
@Mirabas Blabinola You know what any language die when its people left it . It is good to have our regional language but a national language can create more unity and opportunities. So we can carry both a regional language and a national language. People of Bihar have also adopted hindi during indipendent struggles to support unity.
As a haryanvi , we are not getting the equal treatment with our fellow north states 😂😂..Well i don't know about this issue , thanks for the information mohak ..
If I am not wrong, same thing is happening in case of gst too. Southern States created infrastructure, promoted ease of doing business but gst lead to consumption state (High population northern states) receiving IGST instead of production state.
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected. why is the Biasedness? WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR? BUT Not NE states? Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
I as Bihari request Central Government to stop giving hard earned money of other states to Bihar, this state is DEAD due to corruption and politics and it's beyond repair, kindly use that money for other useful purposes.
Alright!!!!! Dead!!!! What do you mean? Bihar is growing at 10.74% for last 10 years, i.e., 3rd fastest in India. I know it is still laggard but still DEAD.. Holy shit!!!!!! Bihar's migrant labor is behind growth of many other states in India.
Why People of North india have remained poor or poorer after pouring so much tax money from South . Politicians/ civil leaders busy looting instead of focusing on development of the states. Why North Indians have to come to the South looking for jobs. Why they have to remain under privileged label. Respect the past contribution & move forward.
To be a developed state: 1. Education 2. Healthcare 3. Skill development 4. Women empowerment 5. Women labour force participation 6. Women free from domestic violence 7. Population control 8. Infrastructure development 9. Industrial development 10. Independence of media 11. Accountability of government 12. Gender equality 13. Corruption free 14. Social inclusion 15. Effective implementation of social welfare schemes 16. Political stability
As a keralite we don't have any issue of investing the money in bihar and up.. But the issue is, the money is going to the hands of corrupted politicians who just play casteism and manipulating common people without making any developments.. Last time when i visited up.. I just cried seeing the conditions of villages
I am not from UP but I can say that infra development in UP is marvelous and their growth is marvelous. It is being said that UP will develop soon if they continue to focus on their Infra but nothing can happen to Bihar because both people and leaders are corrupt.
@@richuraju8123 According to the data, the highest crime rate (1477.2) existed in Kerala and the lowest crime rate (67.2) in Nagaland. In Punjab, the crime rate stood at 242.0 compared to neighbouring states Haryana (697.3), Rajasthan (254.3) and Himachal Pradesh (357.6)., Kerala saw 55% hike in drug cases
@@proudhuman166 know that's common misconception having high crime rates is actually good it says the police forces are much active in Kerala .ie the no of case reporting is high in Kerala ( Finland has the highest in the world and Iran one of the lowest).So if u go by ur logic Bihar ,up etc is much safer ,just give it a thought 🤔🤔
This is not just for Southern States, while checking that map of taxes/investment you will see even Gujurat and Maharashtra are also heavily affected. Just because BiMaRU states can't get their act together, for controlling population,other states are being punished. And any national level political party will support this because the BiMaRU states bring the highest seats in the parliaments so they have to please them.
wait man ....actually gujrat is completely running on rivers of m.p 😂 Is this not the discrimination with farmers of madhya pradesh ?? mumbai is paying more than 70% of the taxes ...in maharastra ?? is it getting equal treatment even within the maharastra ?? dud this the not the way to think ... we can criticize weak performers but we have to understand what's main the problem in thier states ?? bihar was first ruled by communits then lalu chor , then nitish who actually developed alot but people of bihar. don't think anything beyond thier caste ... so there's problem
North Indian states like haryana,Punjab and uttarakhand has higher per capita income than MH. The only states lagging are UP and Bihar, which is due to their overpopulation and mismanagement. Another factor is that north india is a landlocked region and does not get enough economic opportunities as south and west india which gets huge revenues due to sea ports for trading. Many companies also prefer to setup their business close to coastal regions as it is affordable and logistically easier to open business close to sea port. Same was done by British too in the form of calcuta, Madras and bombay
GDP is not a measure of development. In west ambani and adani boosts the gdp but for people? Development can be found by less social inquality, good HDI, gender ratio, women empowerment etc. where you can clearly see which is more developed.
He won't.. Coz if he makes, Then his Concept of MAKING video on NAAARTH INDIA and SOUTH INDIA will go down.. In fact He became Viral through his early Video on WHY SAAAUTH INDIA is Develop, Language video where he showed Entire Rest of India as NAARTH INDIA by his Logic.. But after receiving backlash as WEST INDIA, EAST INDIA, NE INDIA exist other than North India. He quickly Edited out his Videotitleand image.
@@harry_krish lol, ADANI Ambani Gives Job, Makes Road does Social Uplift ment.. Makes new Industries, Port town, Road... List is Long.. When you live like a Frog in a well, Thinks whole world is Only that
i am from Maharashtra we the maharashtrian people work hard and had sacrificed a lot lot to make our state prosperous and developed we pay the most tax our state capita is the most wealthiest city in India but we get only 7.7 rupees on 100 rupees we pay as taxes the over populated and undeveloped states like UP & Bihar get more money from center because they have more population therefor they have more seats in lok sabha so to get more votes and seat in election the party that has a power in center give more money to this states and stole from us who work hard and earned this money and paid tax after getting the lot of free money all this year this states are still backward, poor, corrupt & overpopulated .
I think Maharasthra get enough (OR more) state tax because of city Mumbai and overall state. It about to get 1 trillion economy (1/3rd of India's GDP). Like literally the richest Municipal corporation in Asia is BMC and still living in Mumbai I see poor infrastructure, water fills up in rain, etc. I just feel Maharasthra gov. or BMC is most corrupted gov. I don't know if they want us or not. Just take money from us but please reduce overcrowding in Mumbai. And Real Estate is also the most corrupted too. Maha should focus on policies making or businessman (Micro businessman) will leave Maharasthra. Just remove corruption, half of the problem will get solve and we won't even need central gov. tax money, let central gov. use it for soldiers, R&D, ISRO, poor states, preserving wildlife, etc. (I am not ignoring the fact of UP and Bihar, but I think 1st we should address our own problem than blaming central gov. It's easy to blame others but we shouldn't ignore our problems and I am Maharashtrian too)
@Kirti Kishore ohh really very very thanks, tum up Bihar log ka upkar kidhar vapis karega ham 😂😂 we don't do any type of work, all is just due to up Bihar
@@lol8q no one beaten in Tamil nadu maharashtra is rich because mumbai is rich mumbai is rich because gujrathi and up people Tamilians don't have the power to beat up people if that so then they must try it we'll see 😆
Up bihar should ban product from Maharashtra and Tamil naidu and set up their own industry 😂 Then only tamils and Marathi should know what is discrimination
as a tamilian, there is no problem that we are paying to bihar and jharkhan but when we see that these states are not focusing on development, this really boils my blood. I request all the states to strictly focus on thier development. Jai Bharat
Bihar is a problem but not up , bcs up ppl wants to develop. They are having 74% literacy right now. Soon they will have 90% but bihar has only 45% literacy. Lmao
@@suyashverma2338 corruption khtam karo pehle
Exactly.
Their leaders are always up in arms in the name of religion and keep themselves occupied with violence. They openly call for violence and rape and no one does anything to arrest them.
For some reason, changing the fcking names of stations is more important to UP than actually focusing on development. And yes everyone in UP gets a boner at the sight of the stupid JCB bulldozer destroying houses lol..
Biharis are themselves stressed with development in their state
i totally agree with you
I'm from Tamilnadu. Once i attended interview for a private bank (ICICI) in Hyderabad. I cleared 1st round at 2nd round 2 members were there one guy is from South and another lady from North. For that job they don't ask for Hindi mandatory but English mandatory in description. That South Indian selected me but at last he said,"Mam do you have any questions to candidate". She questions me in Hindi and forced me to talk Hindi even I told that i didn't know. If needed, i will learn. But she keep on asking,"Are you from Tamilnadu". Tamil and English languages only known by you. She harshly said you can't speak everyone with your Mother Tongue Tamil. Even that sir in the interview also shocked and rejected me for Hindi. I always see no difference between Indians.North ,East, Central or South all are indians but why North people behave like this.
No North Indian should ever be recruited in Tamil Nadu in state or central government jobs
But hydrabad is also a south state, how come they ask for hindi?
Hindians will not change their mindset !!! we will have to wait for our chance ......
@@Ronny-Loy yes correct
@praveen0083, then why are they coming to Maharashtra, we maharashtrian don't go to Tamil Nadu. Answer that. In an organisation when you work with a department dominated by Tamilians, what the rest of Indians face is bullying, harassment and hatred.
As a south Indian, I feel very bad when I see that most of the major projects and mega projects are mostly done in north India, even if most of the funding is coming indirectly from south India.
Not indirectly Directly
all companies of south are earning from north.....
@@Dangermonkey1000 lol
Dirty north pan parags
most the road and train infra projects go to north india unfortunately. South India is literally funding those projects. Don't mind overall improvement of India, but South India do need its fair share of money back !
Karnataka getting 13 Rs back for every 100 Rs paid to central govt !
Our Maharashtra leaders are not raising voice for injustice. Shame .
Salute to south Indian leaders
They are servants of northies. They want to become Prime minister.
Why none of them talking about Karnataka 😭top 2nd
I think so haryana is also in North india why no one is seeing that it get 18.6 back only
Delhi and maharashtra pay more taxes Than all south indian states combined !
@@Immense_PAIN Delhi? Yeh kab hua? It's union territory
I'm from Tamilnadu. Thank you Mohak. You wouldn't know how grateful I am to you for bringing up this discussion. I'm not saying we (south) are the victims. We (indians) are the victims. The perpetrators being CORRUPT POLITICIANS.
@@Sagarjk333 they are too. But I can speak only for myself right.
Slumendianz are worst,doesn't matter if South Endian or north Endian
यदि आप तमिल नाडु से हैं तो मेरा आपसे एक प्रश्न है कि क्या तमिल नाडु में देवनागरी लिपि पढ़ाई जाती है?🙏🤔
@ahmed why do you try? Are you like a bot pretending to be a Pakistani so that Indians stay united... just know South is not with North as we feel Pakistan is a threat... because we share some culture
@@SuryadevaraRammurthyNaidu why would I want to see endianz United?It need to break up so we can see 29 new countries
Though I am from south India, It is good to see that the North-Eastern states are being recognised for development.
Remove bihar from india
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected.
why is the Biasedness?
WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR?
BUT Not NE states?
Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
I dare you to Pin My comment..
And reply me back. I want my answer what's up with Absurd title.
Why selective biased?
Bro I am from North East India 🇮🇳
Broo odisha ka bhi south ka jaisa hal hai
@@Hindu428 why can't he express his views...got problem from that too
Even as a south Indian i feel bad for Maharashtra getting only ₹. 7
Thanks to Bombay
Damn even my state Odisha is getting more than 100 but it's no use cuz all of them is soaked up by mines staff. Better the money to be spend on MH
🤣🤣
@@iamsureshourtelugustg1887 it is not Bombay it is Mumbai. Even if you remove Mumbai, Maharashtra will still have bigger GDP and tax returns than any other states.
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
As a resident of Darjeeling , I always respect south indian coz they never make in debeat about religion , hard working for upliftment of india , and still developing faster than north being descriminating by central govt
The "Religion" one is well said.
As someone from TamilNadu , I need to address that no one here fights over religion . We all Live in the same street without having any difference .
So most of the Indian spammers are from North?
@@smallcube-zn2mmyeah 🤣
@@smallcube-zn2mmbecause most of the radical Islamist live in north check the facts what Muslim are doing in north stone pelting conversion is growing but still blame hindus of north 😊😊 in north in one Muslim family there is 6-7 children but blame north terrorist activities happen mostly in north still 😊 I love my india and I cant choose one ovr another north is also very beautiful Himachal pradesh sikkim North East Rajasthan Gujarat etc😊
@@shrutisaha7786unless u treat ur other religions with respect and reduce community clashes, companies won't invest in a place where there is communal unrest, people r not thinking of religion more than education and development and u r not going to grow in north. Grow up guys
The real problem is that most of money which goes to bihar doesn't go to poor but to the bank account of politicians. South generates more revenue but hardly get any help from union government.
Nah, I know that a lot of corruption is there in Bihar, but this money doesn't go to the account of politicians(as their counts is maintained). You can watch a video on it somewhere else on youtube.
What about if we look at per capita tax ??Sikkim give the most about 30,000
2nd is Goa about 25,000.
And Isn't it a Well understood fact that
Hill states will need more funding for same length of Railways than the plains of South???
And Do ever North Indian states gets funding for Port development or coastal corridors ?...
Yes there is problem but you can't be selfish you have geographical advantage of having a coast ....North Doesn't have that Bihar gets flooded every year it isn't the case with Tamil Nadu ....
Countering the comments in a positive way just for objective attention over the issue
1 Yes South Indian States are better in management
2 Yes South also have Risks of claimities like Tsunami but North is at greater risk of Earthquakes
3 Telangana doesn't have a coast surely but we all know from where that gdp comes from ( Hyderabad) and how that was developed
4 I am not saying the imbalance is not there but the issue is
It's not just a phenomenon that happens in India
In United States California the richest state receives the least while Puerto Rico gets the most
So does that mean US government is anti Californian ???
💯
If South India becomes a country of its own ,north India will become the next afghanistan.
No economic,political or social stability with very less literacy.
@@_kartik_chauhan which fantasy land are you living in? Kerala and Bihar have been victims of flood and a bigger threat called "Tsunami" in the past and are very prone to these two calamities.
The reason you don't notice it is because these states are very good in mitigating the threat and taking all safety precautions despites the limited funds they get. They value their people's lives unlike UP,Bihar where people are available in abundance.
I'm also a migrant from bengal living and working in Hyderabad, Telangana state for past 5 years. I've real development (both economic and infra) happening here in front of eyes. States like Bihar don't really deserve to be allocated so much funds as they simply misuse those funds for dirty political gains, while the same could be used in a much better way to fuel India's economic growth here in the South. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
From where do you bring such logics bruhh??
With that logic the two states should be disowned by the country, right??
This is no solution.
Instead of this, the central government should launch strict welfare schemes in the field of education and health in these states.
They should track the expenditure of every penny given by them.
No country can be successful if they ignore and disown any part or region of the country due to various factors.
@@KingsonKeshav lol even in 2023 Bihar government is doing caste based politics and people are electing government on the basis of caste still in Bihar no way Bihar is gonna developed anytime soon...even now UP is doing better than Bihar...
So yes Bihar is a burden on India
@@famousd3094 7-8 years ago the condition was almost same in UP also. But later they realised who they should vote. They got a brilliant leadership and today it is one of the most prospering state in our country.
Everything takes time and effort both. Moreover the current government of Bihar was not directly elected by their people. BJP made a huge mistake by contesting the election in alliance with JDU. They should have fought it as a single party and without a doubt they could get majority even there.
Also, BJP is protesting against this caste based census from the very first day.
At last I would say only one thing that each state has its contribution in building this country be it even only 1 percent. We have to grow as a whole. And rectification is the only solution to any problem not leaving it on its own.
If we go by your logic gov should have left j&k on its fate due to the terrorism there. But no, we took steps and see the result today.
I am as much optimistic about Bihar, west bengal, north-east states as about Delhi, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, Kerala Karnataka, Gujarat or any other sate.
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🚩
@Ur father is cry about it 👎 As per the map provided in the start of the video, bengal is getting 90.5 for every 100 rupees while bihar is getting 300+ for the same amount. So it means is getting less money than what they are sending
@@KingsonKeshav couldn't agree more with you..but the problem is bihari people are getting brain washed very easily by the corrupt politicians
Centre allocates Rs 59 crore for South indians who buy tickets and 39000 crores for North Indians who don't buy tickets...
Modi magic.
Lol😂😂😂
and spits gutka all over trains
All North Indians are not like this
You are right railway should be divided into zone and according to that profit earned should be used for same zone development. Most of north india don't even buy ticket but move freely in the train.
Maharashtra and southern states are paying northern states taxes. sad reality!😢
Give Asam, West Bengal to Bangladesh. Sikkim, Tripura to China. Then India will be smaller and easier to manage.
@@smallcube-zn2mmYes smaller the country stronger the country North Indian States not contribute to central government just exploding with population
@@smallcube-zn2mmwhat a emoji
@@smallcube-zn2mmYou don't even know where Tripura is and you think you are so smart.
@@praneethmashetty591 Isn't tripura bordering bangladesh and mizoram?
I am a south Indian. I have no problem with paying more. But states like bihar won't concentrate on development. Instead they are doing caste based census. It just boils my blood.
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
Exactly, that's the point
They are wasting money just for politics
Central gov denied it, then after making nee alliance they decided to this by money of state gov. When reporter asked that how it will help people, his ans was it will benefit but he didn't explain how??
They are just doing it for votes. After bihar it is going to be UP. Many people in bihar don't care about this census but gov wants it for vote bank politics. Just because of these kind of steps bihar and up are poor states, specially bihar
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected.
why is the Biasedness?
WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR?
BUT Not NE states?
Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
Exactly caste polarization is still high in Up ,bihar evident in many caste based political parties
@@sasmalprasanjit2764 sayd up, Bihar dono ki janskhiya 1,3 aati hai
As a bihari i am really sorry for south Indian and Maharashtra people 🙏🙏
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
Koi nahi bhai kam se kam paise gaye tho development tho ho, Itne paise jaa rahe fir b bihar develop naa hora!!! Itne migrant bichare kya karenge !!!!
As a vlogger, Im sorry too
Don’t be sorry it’s not your fault
Your government is not able to control and develop your state because they don’t want to but if they want than also the people commented from corruption, crime and nepotism don’t have any knowledge to do good stuff
You know that UP and Bihar have best fertile soil so it means the god have given them every opportunity but the humans behind them are not able to do any progress
If government gives more money to states/areas like Jammu and Kashmir we can understand on that basis
Also for Ladakh and Rajasthan also we can understand but for UP and Bihar it’s total waste as they are not developing without having any geographical or geological problems
No need to be sorry as long as the money is spent on development and all states have equitable power in decision making.
I'm from North East India, It's true that south Indian states are helping northern India financially and technologically, thanx to people of South Indian states ❤️
Thank you bro for respecting us Tamil people
@@BennyhinnNadar-wj1yg He said South Indian .... South India is not just Tamil Nadu
@@arnavsharma2635 u know what we all South Indians are same.dravidans means the early indians we are connected to eachother, don't speak if you don't know anything 😂😂
@@arnavsharma2635 Arnav Sharma tumhe sharam aana chahiye 🤣🤣
Khao hindu ka , pa chato Christian ke ..shame North east
As a Gujarati, I thank you sir for bringing this topic up. This is seriously an issue that should be highlighted!
Bro gujrat literally gets 235 rs on 100 rs you are lucky
@@Bh0oshangujrat producing big revenue and 5th highest tax payer and only state which is actually growing
@@kushmaurya373 Bro maharashtra is first taxpayer and what it gets only ₹32
@@Bh0oshan in this way if all gujjus come back home ratantata,ambani,adani desh ki gdp gujrat ki gdp me badal jayegi bhai 😂
@@kushmaurya373 bro no offence but market to maharashtra hai
Giving money to underdeveloped states is okay, but there is a limit. I wondered why 59 crore for South India and why 13000 crore for North? It is highly unfair number. The ratio is 1: 220 🙁 how one can be silent on such huge huge difference
ig they have more rails to build than us?
@@Rezal_rzl 😂 , haryana Punjab have less population then south state but more GDP like compared to Telangana, only bihar , jharkhand aren't doing good by the way haryana, Punjab give more tax then you people
Bro it is a political statement that means that they are cherry picking facts. Also maharashtra contributes more via indirect taxes.
@@proudhuman166those states are not considered North, don't go with geographical locations. See what the center includes in North states.
Don't blame Modi he has to pay to Adani Nirav Modi Amit shah son Etc
Bihar gets ₹ 922
Tamilnadu gets ₹ 29
But Maharashtra gets only ₹ 7
😡 Both central and state gov. Ignore backward parts of state, like Marathwada, khandesh, vidarbha
Bihar is poor state and we need to support them otherwise the gap will become huge and there will be too much migration of Bihar and up to South Indian states
@@imawarrior4527 but is 922 rs really going for development of bihar
Answer is no. Lot of corruption even 50% of money not going for development
@@imawarrior4527 Bihar humesha backward rhega jbtk wha corrupt neta h itna paise kha jta h bhai south India mein itna come investment krte h pr wha log bht educated h
@@imawarrior4527 i am basically from Karnataka i agree with your words but due to the low budget given to us health and education is destroying roads are not properly provided due to lack of funds many offices are closed because of this government employees in Karnataka is not getting pension they only 4000 after this that's why central government want to some less money to Bihar and look towards us
@@imawarrior4527 bhag be
As a Tamil guy, inequality in tax not a big thing.
But politics in the name of religion, caste or language was very harmful for our country.
you are doing language politics not northies .. and religion politics is there bcoz parties who actually destroyed u.p and bihar used muslim vote bank foe thier benefits ... For bjp it's is compulsory to polarise otherwise muslims vote in block and hindus vote get divided on many parties ... in kerala you are appeasing certain societies ... that's y even christians started complaining abt appeasement politics of kerala ...
@@riav.T language politics started because of North because of Hindi imposition
@T Riav
In TN, we hate imposition of hindi, not hindi itself. Though, I may not entirely agree with any kinds of divisive politics, be it lang. or faith.
In TN, language unites every tamilian, regardless of faith, caste and creed. Somehow, language politics stopped religious politics.
As a Tamil Keralite, I won't vote for Brahmin Janata party.
@@scert7329 Aryan invasion is a British theory for dividing Indians.
its surprising that UP and Bihar are getting this much money and still these 2 have the most poverty affected people in the whole country
Sab kuch neta Or beurocrates kha jate hain
@@neetneha8019 Main reason why Sotherners are furious.
🙄As A Maharashtrian, We Cannot Deny The Fact That Most Central Government Mainly Focus On Up,Bihar due to Their Vote Bank which is mainly Based On Caste Politics, Main Topics like Development, Infrastructure, Education like topics are missing and that's makes A huge Difference 😐.
@BIOLOGY i don't see any difference between Bangladesh and west bengal temple destruction or attack on Durga pooja
Up is definitely developing, idk about bihar
2 topic .
1 topic = . union of state means - Dr. B.R. Ambedkar said that the Indian was a “Union of States” instead of a “Federation of States” because it was indissoluble, and no State had a right to separate from the Indian Union. The country is one integral unit beside the fact that it consists of different states for the convenience of administration.
2 topic = i have only one request - don't call south India and north India , call them south part of India and north part of India . thank you , jay hind .
note - copy pest multiple time to spread awareness and new thinking .
@BIOLOGY lol 🤣🤣🤣 Maharashtra is 10,000 TIMES better than waste bengal.
@@sustarokujo1102 good joke
It’s like punishing South Indian states for investing in education and rewarding corrupt North Indian states😢😢
Bhai this is only half truth
@@sankalptiwari2828 reveal the full truth then
LOL LEAVE SOUTH INDIA FOR A SEC AND JUST SEE WHAT THEY ARE DOING WITH MAHA
This means the whole video just gone up through your head😂
Ya true
As a Maharashtrian, I can tell you that I'm absolutely baffled by these figures. We're not mad that our tax money is being used to build infra and RRTS trains in U.P, but we're mad about the fact that most of our hard earned tax money goes into the pockets of corrupt politicians. This is the reason why people in my state, both natives and immigrants have started resenting the Centre.
But more than that our opinions are not being heard, our voices have been silenced and our political representation has been smothered by the recent political upheaval that occured in the past few months.
Bihar is the worst of all
Your tax money??lol
It is indian money because people of india brought your product from your state and pay taxes to your state
@@omnamahshivaya7894 so what he & his fellow state men are indians too. Why don't these financialy back ward states improve they are hindering Indias growth as a whole.
True
Pardon my comment, but how did you make your English this good. I've seen many comments here, top comments too but yours sound flawlessly good, like a native speaker.
As a kannadiga, we are generous helping others out, but do get on the improvement path. Jai Karnataka!
As a tamilian i don't mind our tax money going to underdeveloped states like up, Bihar etc. It has to go to the needeones. But not looting. There should be a monitoring committee inclusive of all states representation. Every two years we have to review how the funds utilized. I strongly believe unity is strength. 🏵️
Your mostly money goes to North east
Ya that is soln not hating each other and saying we all are Indians, these two things never coexisted together
@@EIGatito in video they explained that if headquarter is located in one state and company is paying tax there it doesn't mean they are getting benifits only from that state
That's what exactly ED is doing.
Everyone (thieves) are blaming Central Government for this , i don't know how stupid way of thinking is this .
ED and NIA all are on its full form.
Unlike those previous governments this Government didn't put any restrictions or any influence on "special" cases. ED and NIA were given their "Rights" to their job.
I'm a Keralite , our situation has been changed since communist government got on power , God's own country became terrorist's and burglar's own country.
Both red terrorists and green terrorists.
No one is allowed to start a business here without "paying" in party fund. Lots of gulf retirees had to stop their ventures and some of them had to do suicide.
Our present chief minister from communist party once he didn't have another pair of dress to change , his father was a toddy worker, now he has more than 25000 crores of assets.
He is being now chased by ED and other agencies on gold and black money smuggling issues .
You search on malayalam news channels.
I know Tamilians understand malayalam a little.
I've relatives in Palani.
@@EIGatito sorry our Notheast is Naturally developed as well Artificially developed also 🙌
We are giving money to Poor Bihar UP since from 1947 till they are not developed 🤧😂
We, people of North India, should accept our mistake that neither its people nor the governments of North India focused on human capital. There were not enough steps to promote better education and health infrastructure. And also not enough incentives for companies to set up factories and raise employment.
South Indian states have done an incredible job, and we should learn from them. And take measures to promote equality and give them taxes and representation they deserve.
Jai Hind, Jai Bharat 🇮🇳
Speak for yourself man I who is mixture from Haryana and Uttarakhand can say these BIMARU states do not develop and run to other states and breed like rabbits
@RohanSharmacap Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh are showing rapid development. And I am sure our states will do good in future and for its people. It will be great competition between states to have better growth, infrastructure and human development. This will ultimately lead to growth story of India.
@@sahilkushwaha5864 TBH, I've no hopes for Bihar
@@unbiasedhuman. Agreed . Bihari politicians are the most corrupted politicians in India.
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected.
why is the Biasedness?
WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR?
BUT Not NE states?
Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
I dare you to Pin My comment..
And reply me back. I want my answer what's up with Absurd title.
Why selective biased?
I'm from karnataka. I really don't mind if our money goes to lesser developed states. But my only problem is that the money won't go in development but into politician's pockets. We are all one at the end of the day.
That is the problem...even in the BJP ruled state. They r also very corrupt
Remove bihar from india
@@jioboy2676 lol 😂 i m living in bjp ruled m.p 😂 and bjp has been ruling m.p since 2003 & i can say that bjp made m.p whatever it is today ... best infra ...and continously doing so ... best state for peaceful living ...
@@riav.T i think you are overrating our MP. i am also from jhansi and bjp voter but it have not been so much that you say ya but UP is rapidly developing. only in 5 year up gdp have been double
@@utkarshagrawal2002 Maharashtra and BJP is best bro... Congress puri corrupt ho chuki thi
Bihar past: most civilized
Bihar present: most uncivilized
I am from Gujrat but I must say, people from South India are better educated and well behaved than north. Even visitors also says the same.
Remove bihar from india
Agree brother
Even our Gujarat it also getting very less from central government
@Winter I agree as a south indian living in north.
@Winter well, ig they reside in hilly areas and OP wasn't referring them. Also people of Bihar, up, mp do misbehave a lot
I can't imagine , Maharashtra stands on 7.7 ₹ 😶,,, that's the best example of inequality 🙌💖
( as a Maharashtrian I have no words)
It's because all major companies' headquarters are located in Mumbai. Revenue is not being generated in Mumbai but is being generated throughout the country and being stocked and taxed out of Mumbai.
but you never cared abt inequality that mumbai has been facing ... 😂 financial city of india has less infra than delhi ... even delhi pays more than it gets ...
Puri video dekh le pahle
@@riav.T corruption friend everyone is corrupt here in MH also
@Kirti Kishore Maharashtra= Mumbai, MH. Is a big state and everything is not Mumbai, what about Marathwada we are still facing many problems
I hate people who ignore the fact that MH give Rs.100 as taxes and get Rs. 7 in return. we face most discrimination from central Govt.
Because you are rich only because of Mumbai & Mumbai's economy is not dependend on Marathi but whole Indians
Double engine goes brrrrr
Yes thats what they Dont want to say ! Maharastra is the biggest state as per GDP ! But MH didn’t says anything like TAmils are saying!
@@hyperssb4103 then go and improve your state first then come to Maharashtra... Mumbai is for everyone but if you comment like this then I will proudly say that Mumbai is for Marathi people 🚩🚩🚩🚩
@@hyperssb4103 Mumbai is financially strong because of Marathi manus ⛳. Jagannnath Shankarsheth, this Marathi man made his valuable contribution for what Mumbai today is . And Maharashtra is not rich because of Mumbai. Sugar factories in MH and environment and other factors are also major factors for Maharashtra's economic growth. And politicians here, be it from any party everyone gives contribution to economy.
As a South Indian we won't Accept losing political representation , It's a clear injustice for Us .
No one will do that, you will surely get your political representation
Full support dravidnadu movement....... south indian separate countries...........
A south Indian won't have more power per vote... It has to be equalll...
@@mairajarather9615 full support dravidnadu movement........
@@DADDYG-Ryderlet's see after delimitation,
I am maharastrian.
I don't have any issue for getting very less money than what we give.
But the issue is the states getting more money don't show development as it should.
It's not just injustice against us but also people living in those States
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
they are doing dud bcoz you have not seen thier previous position that's y you are not getting the real picture ..
You must be living in Mumbai or Pune that's why, go out side of this city and you will see real face , Maharashtra have other regions too to develop but we are not getting enough money
The Islamic jihad in North Bihar is the real cause of backwardness.
They are making some areas of Mumbai as Iraq.
@@Hindu428 Hm, quite agreed.. We can utilise our hard earned money for our own necessities
Bro it's not that Bihar is paying 100 and getting 900 or MH paying 100 and getting 7
It's like MH -7 = 10-14- BIHAR
BIHAR must be getting more revenue than MH but isn't not like 900 & 7 rupees
MH earns more reason why % of return looks small and Bihar earns less reason why % looks more
But actual revenue that is received can max. double what MH is getting
As a maharashtrian, i feel that fear of political representation of southern states because of linguistic basis and also economic inequality....
All political parties mainly focus on north india because of large numbers of votes and they are from only one language base ....
north india does religion caste politics i am from odisha
Your Suresh kalmadi had already taken 22000 crore rupees to pocket.
Abd 2g scam,3 g scam of tamimians ..yiu know that worth is 3 lakh crore rupees. So looters in south india too.
Thatvis why most powerful leader of south Chidambaram waS arrested. And your sarad Pawanr,chhgan Bhujbal everyone knows..
South Indians makes lots of noise when they are not benefitted becouse they make sure that they are always being benefitted...up and Bihar needs help from central govt to get developed,rise above of poverty..everybody needs money but govt should provide help to those who needs the help the most...it should not be given basen on tax otherwise some states will become too much rich and will have everything but some states will have nothing to eat
@@annAdafc what you're saying is correct and that is exactly what Gandhi and Nehru have done when they established an equal India. But Bihar and up should improve and contribute even more instead of letting their politicians corrupt all the money. It is the right of Indian tax payers to demand development and only Biharis can demand development in Bihar.
North Indian governments should concentrate in their state developments not in their party devepments , North India more funding no developments and south India less funding more developments then why u people supporting such parties .
Just For example if you look at the budget of Railways it's not evenly distributed to north and south states and surprisingly south indian railway stations are well cleaned and maintained with less allocated budgets when compared to northern states and every south Indian government should step up and fight for fair distribution of funds ... I appreciate you brother ... You're doing an unbiased work 👌🏻👌🏻
Northern india is a plain area and railway is only cheap way for transportation in north india.
@@Abhinay_Singh0 railway transportation is cheaper at every part of India.
What he says is...
Though the north India gets high budget for development,it has not well developed when being compared to south India
@@priyamaddison3073 Priya u speak the truth 💯💯💪🏾
South Indians makes lots of noise when they are not benefitted becouse they make sure that they are always being benefitted...up and Bihar needs help from central govt to get developed,rise above of poverty..everybody needs money but govt should provide help to those who needs the help the most...it should not be given basen on tax otherwise some states will become too much rich and will have everything but some states will have nothing to eat
@@priyamaddison3073 that's what I said 🤷🏻♂️
Being a Maharashtrian, it is disheartening to see how Maharastra is being ignored even after being the most developed both, economically and socially, state in the country. The argument that India is a union of state is only good on paper, it is worthless when I am getting peanuts in return for the value we are adding as the most developed state of the country.
It is important that we make our weak areas strong
and if you want to divide go ahead but will be easily captured by Pakistan china or even india 😂 so get ready to spend everything on military
solution= Maharashtra and south India should need to get more Poltical power in Central government so that they can develop India fast🤗
Yes
Until rss government is there it is not possible.
Lol tamilnadu government don't even more in Central but we are the highest tax payer shame on north india and hindi politician 🤫🤐🤬
@@sureshr5767 Maharashtra also 😢
India hi seperate kardenge south india ke toh
Gujarat gets 31₹
Tamil Nadu 29₹
Maharashtra 7₹🙄
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
Up Bihar and, north east
Northeast can never generate enough gdp as compared to mainland so what's the problem in building infrastructure for them
haan to are they bimaru lol? none are north indian states
so what ?? no country in the world has complete development in all sections of thier geography ?? are every districts of south indian states equally contributing to thier SGDP ?? in USA california alone is paying most of the taxes so what ?? even in china every province is not equally developed
As a north indian living in south India since last 15 years. I must say that south indians are very honest and hard working people. They focus on their education and development. But the sad part is that stats like bihar and UP are just enjoying the money getting from union govt and politician filling their pockets. Nobody even focusing on education and development. So after few years this kind of discrimination with south india will increase. No state will give hard earned money to states like bihar Jharkhand. Poor are getting poor and rich are getting richer day by day in currupt state like bihar.
Yeah ???
Really ???
We are enjoying the money like seriously ???
Gali Dene ka Mann kar Raha ...par dunga nahi ....tax collection dekha h UP ka ???
Tu ek kàaam kar agle 10 baaad compare lena UP ko India k kisi bhi states se !!!!
Or sun haramkhori sirf up me nahi pure India me h samjha ...faltu ka Gyan mat Diya kar !!!!
@Kirti Kishore first blame up waalas who are too communal
UP and Bihar are enjoying no not.. the North Politicians are enjoying... that's why people from UP and Bihar are coming down to South states for survival
@Kirti Kishore most industries are in Western UP(harit pradesh) not in your purvanchal and bundelkhand area South people are right why do you people go to South or come to Western UP for everything first develop your area and even before industrial development in Western UP(harit pardesh)we had everything we are strong people. See our ratio in Indian Army, forces and farming what did you people did for country paan thukna k elawa bss yaha aa jao bheed bdaa do yaha ki NCR main bss kabhi dekha hain humra yaha ka koi tumhara bihar purvanchal main raah raha ho
@Kirti Kishore 🤣🤣🤣 you don't know anything from history Gurjar Prathihar kingdom is Rajasthan haryana Western Up and we don't need any industries here in NCR why did you people come here first answer this question and we don't migrate anywhere we protect our land there is difference aap log apna waha kuch kar nahi payaa population yaha bad rahi hain problem tho hogi locals ko
People fighting North V South what about Maharashtra? 🚩:(
They are the real people of India, contributing the most still being humble
Really appreciate you Mohak despite you being a Hindi speaker and come from North India you have narrated this Tax imbalances with Southern states. This is how the social media needs to be without any bias, great work 🙌
Why would there be an bias ..we r all Indians..we must focus on our country's development
Sadly Now whole the TV news channel controlled by dictator mudi Directly and indirectly.
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected.
why is the Biasedness?
WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR?
BUT Not NE states?
Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
I dare you to Pin My comment..
And reply me back. I want my answer what's up with Absurd title.
Why selective biased?
@@sasmalprasanjit2764 the worst thing: now Indians are dividing India on the basis of geographical north and south 😂
I see divide and rule incoming
He is living outside India and he is targeting India none other case
As a person from UP, I want to thank all our South Indian and West Indian brothers. Even after you people giving so much money there is so much to develop here🥺. We will be grateful to you.
Kick bihar out of india
Remove yogi first. You will develop more
@@ritviksharma572 what a joke 😂 people like tsjaswi yadav should be removed, UP is developing now and bihar isn't
@@ritviksharma572 That Yogi is building Roads and somewhat fixing law and order. Earlier every 10-15 days we're getting news of riots in streets.
@@kirtikousikyogi building gaushalas for old useless cows using Southern states funds
Bihar will never develop untill mindset of people changes
As a Maharashtrian… We suffer this problem the Most. With Due Respect to Everyone, We Contribute the Most in our Country & Receive the least. Thus, we understand this Sentiments better than anyone
Kannada Pride. Kannada Power.
You should not think like that.... India is one country and that's how democracy work... Where we take from riche and give it to poor..... Supposed if tomorrow ambani adani tata and all richest man start saying this that you take so much money from us and gave to poors?.. Why would we gave our hard earn money to poors??... What did you say then?
@@rahulkashiv2299 but it the money really going to the poor?
Those who earn more, pay taxes more. There should be no regret for it.
Aise to A&N, chhattisgarh etc ka kabhi development nahi ho payga. This will be injustice to tribal people.
These North Indians have destroyed Maharashtra
This is so bad for Maharashtra because the income disparity between Konkan+Marathwada region with Vidharbha is huge... atleast they should get some of their own money
Yeah if vidharbha and Marathwada is utilised ,Maharashtra economy will reach 1 trillion $ in no time , also some places are exactly in middle of India , gadkari ji is already working on it to make it logistical hub.
Yes as i am living in Vidharbha i also fill same..
I m living in chhatrapati shambaji nagar and I can say our is only city in marthwada which is develop and have industry but if I go to jalna there os nothing we need to focus now or never I want to see jalna and every other district like chhatrapati shambajingar but in this tax amount it's impossible.
Let us declare Bihar as a union territory, caste politics have really impacted the progress of Bihar. Illiterate people are choosing criminals and undeserving politicians and those politicians are again making people dumber and this vicious cycle continues. A union territory for 15-20 years can easily break this cycle. (I would like to know the reaction of people espacially Biharis in the comment section)
identity politics kills growth especially small identity like caste. Regionalism,nationalism still works
as a bihari i can approve this. let bihar be a union territory for 20 years as people are still not mature enough to cast a vote. educate them until they realise there is smthng above caste
@@samuellajacksoninfi +1
Remove bihar from india
Agreed brother
+1
As a keralite I feel if we get much more we could have done much more to our people. It's the same for all south Indians and for maharashtra i feel so bad
Cry
😲Maharashtra getting only Rs. 7/- for Rs. 100/- and Bihar getting Rs. 922/- WTF😡
Bihar deserves more because they are hardworking people produce more babies😁
@@Jungle_boy123 lol
@@Jungle_boy123 lmao 😂
But plz one request don't produce kids now
Maharashtra is 3largest state in India and Bihar is much smaller in Area but still Bihar has overtaken Maharashtra in terms of Population
In reality bihar corrupts are getting 922 rs 😂 bihar people are still in poverty
@@Jungle_boy123 very hardworking bihar 😂👍
I am from Beed District in Maharastra and it is really underdeveloped and and poor and highest numbers of farmers die by suicde in this District and same case with the Marathwada region and Vidhraba region in Maha. We also need money and resoucrces to develop but if only north state don't suck up all the money
@Kirti Kishore asking for rights is not crying, Industries come to Maharashtra cuz they provide good working environment, in northern states even tho resources are there due to uneducated people and hooliganism, no industries come there. What Maharashtra is today is because of Marathis hard work and the good work environment they provided. If you really want to see super hard working Marathis go to Marathwada , Vidhraba region, where people work so hard yet they are poor , cuz government did not develop these regions. The only one i see crying is you on many comments.
I am also from Beed
Itni saari comments Mai Beedch koni tri bhetl
@Kirti Kishore tum bhaiya log bacche kam peda Karo desh pe boj ho tum northie
@@harshkashid7242 me from Jalna. 🙏
@@Hindu428 🙏
To say that North Indians had a major contribution in the development of South Indian states is a big mistake. North Indian labourers only started working in Southern states only recently. I am a South Indian and it is only in the last 10 - 15 years we have seen an influx of laborers from the North. Southern states like Kerala have only their people to thank for the development their state has made in social, economic, and infrastructure aspects.
Yes you are absolutely right. Mohak got this view point wrong that it's only the North labourers who contributed to the success of the South. The migration of North labourers to the south started only in last 10yrs or so. Before that, you hardly see them down here. May be 25yrs down the lane, if he makes this comment, it may be right. But not now.
The other way to look at it is, the workers living in their own state didn't have any work or good business. But they heard the cheap quality of life and labour requirement and job opportunities in the south, which were created by the south govts and they migrated.
If they had opportunities in their own state, why would they migrate to another state. Leaving everyone and everything behind
Yes you are right 100%
Crct bro....
Not a "MAJOR" contribution 😇.
Im from Telangana. I have no problem that states like Bihar get more funds in return. But the question is..for how much longer? Its not like these states are using the funds for 'development'.
Vande Mataram
I Love how mohak being a north indian himself,but still concerns about our south too.....These issues are lesser explored......Thank you mohak for spitting facts(Unbiasedly)
Love From South India❤️
You are not South Indian. You are Indian from the south.
South Indian states have sea, port while north indian states are landlocked. So southern states are at an advantage anyway.
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected.
why is the Biasedness?
WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR?
BUT Not NE states?
Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
But it's same for every Country which have many states Including united states
California get the least amount it sent to the federal government and Puerto Rico gets the highest....
So it can't be called Discrimination
@@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi Toh kya unki galti wo to naturally hai
As a northeastern I prefer south rather than North, these are the reason:-
(1) I got called names every day but very rare in the south
(2) No discrimination on what I eat in the south
(3)People are very welcoming
(4) I had to face racism every day in the north but very rare in the south.
This are the few reasons why I moved from North to South,
Lemme guess you never went to Himachal pradesh Or delhi
Delhi is much more better than south
@@tharabhai1794 bro Delhi 2 years 😎
Thanks bro … ❤ even South Indian faces discrimination in north basically North Indians are uneducated bullies
@@Poojari02 Look you are proving that
Who is an actual racist
@@tharabhai1794 bro Delhi is better ?😂
Really bro ....
I am from Tamilnadu and I honesly am fine with it. I am an Indian first and I want entire India to develop. But states like Bihar must not enjoy our money just like that and must focus on developing, which unfortunately is not happening. Happy to see UP develop though.
You're not a Tamilian 😂🤣
@@jam-ss2jc why?
But south indians beleive in communism which means the money from rich states should be given to poor states. That is what communism preaches
You are BJP IT Cell Troll....
Up developing? 😂😂😂
North is living on the mercy of South
Loday ki mercy
WHAT ABOUT LOOTING UNITED BIHAR(BIHAR+JHARKHAND) FROM 1952 1993 IN THE NAME OF FREIGHT EQUALISATION POLICY>
@@search_ex_muslim_sahil_yt gutka ki mercy or mere mergi?
From 1993 till now ur begging still @@Createinspiration
The main reason for the fear among South on loosing the parliament representation is the language. If south looses further seats then there will be forceful imposition of Hindi in South and there will be planned attack to convert the southern states into a Bihar.
Nex prime minister should be South Indian . It would solve the problem.
Already we lost so many indigenous languages in North because of this and now it is spreading to South
Excuse me sir?? I am from south india and here in public or private school hindi language is official *hammko bhi hindi ate hai*.*in south india some state like karnataka, telengana kerala and Andhrapradesh hindi language is important, official in college and school also hindi speaker can use hindi*
Even north Indians don't like Hindi. I'm from West UP and Wikipedia says we speak Hindi, but we don't. When I speak people say I'm Harayanvi. I know the difference between Harayanvi and my language. Hindi is just a crab. Its eating up the variations of North Indian languages.
@@ShivanshuTyagi72981 I see. But I don't understand why hindi language don't like in North india it is unbelievable.... In South india, we don't hate each other bcz south indian language are family so we support each other. The problem in North india is they don't support each other if their language is from one family.
There North indian people don't have feeling towards their family of language this is why in North india many incidents happen
As a tamilian settled in Mumbai since birth all states are one it's amazing that South is very developed whereas due to corrupt politicians in North who are interested in lining they have totally ignored their people
But the main cause of worry is after 2026 if lok sabha seats of South is reduced it will spell disaster as their political representation will reduce
central government has to seriously think about this before finalizing it
Correctly said!.
Already in vote politics National parties are concentrating only on UP, Bihar, MP and Rajastan (Hindi Belt). if they win, solidly they will get MP seats more than 200. Wherein if we consider south: Kerala, TN, Karnataka, AP, Telugana < 100 MP seats. Just think. In vote politics 200 seats are more than enough for ruling entire india. hence always politics will be based on hindi belt. This should be changed. if Union govt, plan to decrease MP seats then it will lead to big riot.
Union govt should think.. India is not one country. India is made by multiple countries (now we call it as states in independent india).
Another think: South developed because of major control in birth ratio. this helped politicians to focus on development and education. but north didn't focus on this.
in south: a family will have 1.5 children i.e.) either 1 or 2
in north: a family will have 3.5 children.
see the difference.
Example: In india Just UP population : ~22 crores
But South India population is below UP.
South India need to think.
Are you muttuswami ?
@@johnsonn3479 272 is the magic figure not 200.
@@sachinraghuwanshi4917 correct! so any PM in union india will not require any support from South or east or west India. Moreover, people from North or south or west or east thought process will be different. but rule or order will be based on North people and it will be imposed on us and will not be fit for others. This should be changed..else in future other than north all people in union india will be looted and face lot of problems.
If south seats decrease in 2026, I expect these states to secede or violent movements to start. No one wants their tax payer $$ going to others who can’t help themselves.
As South Indian states we too like to be a part of overall development of India, but even after 75 years of Independence why are the states of Bihar, UP, MP and Jharkhand still declared as under-developed states and the dependence is raising year on year
Dependence from southern states for revenue cannot be continued forever.
The respective state governments and center should be held equally liable for these kind of situations
South Indian state should get Independent from India...if this discrimination continues
@Kirti Kishore
Sorry but North Indian states have more number of seats in loksabha for representation
If they wanted it to be removed they would have done it long back.
Bhai ye same problem America china jese desho me bhi hai, jaha bas coastal states hi jada develop rehte hai...
Don't count m.p dud ... first learn the geography of india ... M.P is the forest state ( we can't destroy our national parks for development ) and its location best in the country ... with low population to its land size ... even infra wise it's more developed than many south indian states ..😂 two cleaniest city of india are in m..p alone .. it's also a home to highest st population in the country ...
@@jioboy2676 Abdul spotted again spamming
0:21 wth? That's just ridiculous.
59cr:13,200cr. Not even 100cr to south??
Yes, and also bjp allocated more than 13k crores for the improvement of sanskrit and not even 10 crore for our language, culture improvement
As a Telangana person i feel happy that my state is contributing to the growth of the nation. We are 2.5% of population and contributing 5% to the GDP. Proud Telanganaite. Proud Hyderabadi.
In Return Telengana Getting Huge No Of Immigrant Workes From North India And Perhaps a Destruction of Telengana's Culture
Yes bro well said
Maddaa guduv
Baaga seppavu
WHAT ABOUT LOOTING UNITED BIHAR(BIHAR+JHARKHAND) FROM 1952 1993 IN THE NAME OF FREIGHT EQUALISATION POLICY _
As a maharastrian, l always blamed our government for not doing that much. But now l can see, what is happening to us. We gave opportunity to North indians to grow, which their state couldn't gave them. And we still baby sitting North india.
We should stop blaming north, even with huge state budget what did our politicians do?
Lol you should ban north indian labour and north should ban you state product 😂
@@millennialmind9507 marathi bol येते काय
@@omnamahshivaya7894 lol we don't want norths products either 🤡🤡
@@Jungle_boy123 ho mala yete, me marathi ch aahe
Meanwhile Maharashtra getting ₹7 for every ₹100 : 😢☹️
Are Mitra आपल्याला bhaiye jast aani paise kami as kahi milt
🥲
As a person from UP,i feel bad for south indians they are not getting what they deserve in terms of funds, i feel ashamed being north indian for slow progress in development due to huge corruption going on here,i really love south people they r so humble, hardworking, i have some friends from south who always help me and wont expect anything in return🥺🥺😭😭😭.i love south indians
I love you Priyanka ji. Love from Kerala
Thank u sister God bless
❤❤ From Tamil Nadu
I am from Up sister 😂
And that much u criticise about Up, it is not even that bad 😂
I think u live in dream ..and if u talk about crime rate then Kerala always shown ISIS terrorism and much more but we never talked about that bcz if it's high literacy rate ...so every state has its bad and good things okay
South India not a heaven as you are thinking, they have almost same problem like us, i have been to south and when it comes to social issues hardly South is different from north.
In south India tribals are treated more badly than Dalits in north, Atleast Dalits have political voice in north but in South tribals don't even have political voice.
South indian states have controlled and reduced their population over the years, whereas in northern states the story is opposite. South Indians states always had to carry the burden of BIMARU states, unfortunately north indian states because of their population had got huge representation in parliament and hence dominate national politics, and hence south indians are ignored always preference is given to north indian states, be it highways or other development schemes, south indian states are only a treasure/cash cow to the govt of india, they don't treat south india as a part of india. Period
Uttarakhand HP Ladakh Jammu Punjab disagrees. Up bihar are not the only northern states. Stop using northern resources too and labour as well then improve. We depend on each other that's why it's a country. And above all problem are corrupt politician not people remember people are getting no development the money is for corrupt politicians. 🙏
UP and Bihar are not North Indian states.
North Indian states ( j&k, Himachal, uttarakhand, haryana, Punjab) have controlled their population efficiently and have lower fertility rate than national average
@@rritiknegi5119 but who will tell these MFS? These people forget us everytime.
@@nitkills7070 all those states are nothing compared in job creation or industries. WE ARE SPECIFICALLY TAKING ABOUT BIMARU ALL FALL IN NORTHERN PART. WEST+SOUTH CREATE SO MUCH REVENUE AND GIVE TAX WHICH ULTIMATELY BIMARU EATS UP
@@krjg9809 we were historically ignored df man, uttarakhand became a state in 1999 before that up was having all the tax so? Why can't we create jobs and industry because central govt has always been the problem and have ignored deep northern states.
I think the problem is not how much cash does north Indian states are getting.
but how they are utilizing there money. I am not saying there are no political scandals in south India.
but the ration b/w the two can't be ignored. I think every state should improve the quality and both quantity of their education.
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
UP is developing at a rapid pace tho, but Bihar can't say anything about that
Mostly bihar
@@yashgupta5192 then people of Bihar need to step up and start questioning and pressurising the govt.
Remove RSS government for good future of india.
SOUTH SHOULD GET INDEPENDENCE FROM NORTH INDIA TO SAVE SOUTH INDIAN PEOPLE.
Maharashtra being the driver of Indian Economy is only getting 7.7 Rs which is the lowest in India but still we are ready to contribute in all the way possible for the future of India but the Indian Govt should focus on Maharashtra and give back atleast 15 Rs in return which Maharashtra deserves.
Jai Hind Jai Maharashtra🚩
Yet,south India has more literacy rate and has developed tremendously compared to North.
People in North are still obsessed with govt jobs while people of South are changing the world itself
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
Ye jhooth hai bas Kerala ki literacy rate jyada hai, andhrapradesh li literacy rate to Bihar se bhi kam
Isiliye bolta hu bhed chal me mat chla kro
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected.
why is the Biasedness?
WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR?
BUT Not NE states?
Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
@@Playerone1287 south India comprises of Karnataka,Tamil Nadu and Telangana apart from Kerala.
Why is literaracy rate of West India, East India, NE INDIA, North Himalayam states is Not Considered?
Why is Only NAAATTH AND SAAAUTHH India is???
As a Maharashtrian i am feeling proud that we are highest contributing to this nation. India First 🇮🇳❤️
हो,तरीही प्यायला पाणी नाही, आदिवासी भाग तर युपी बिहार पेक्षाही मागास आहे
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected.
why is the Biasedness?
WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR?
BUT Not NE states?
Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
I dare you to Pin My comment..
And reply me back. I want my answer what's up with Absurd title.
Why selective biased?
आणि आपल्याला जे भेटतात त्याठी इथे आलेया भैयांसाठी ते वापरावे लागतात आपल्याला
Still has a lot of slums
@@ruby-brawlstars8540 People living in slums gradually progressing day by day & Most of them migrating from Bangladesh, Burma, Nepal and northen part of India. If politicians of Mumbai working well towards society Mumbai will be slum free by 2047.
No one pays attention to Gujarat and Maharashtra
Why only South getting so much attention
SOUTH INDIA FEEDING NORTH INDIANS STATES
@@saukhyawakhale UP AND BIHAR MOST CORRUPTED STATE WHE SHOULD NOT SUPPORT THEM
@@saukhyawakhale IN HOTELS????
@naveenr1938 so what the problem
@@mrk5216 NORTH INDIANS GHUTKA STATES NOT WORKING ONLY ROWDYISM THEY ARE NOT PAYING TAX ALSO
WHAT ABOUT LOOTING UNITED BIHAR(BIHAR+JHARKHAND) FROM 1952 1993 IN THE NAME OF FREIGHT EQUALISATION POLICY _
I am a taxpayer from the Northeast, and it is lovely to see Indians from all parts of India are engaged in creative comments to promote cooperation and brotherhood. I really hope that heard earned tax payer money is put to a good use. Jai Bharat..
Love north eastern India from Maharashtra
Dude, you are a bengali living in one of the northeastern states.
Despite this much attention (atleast social media) on them nowadys. Where are they ?
They should be interacting with us here. They say that they don't get represented. How will they get represented in the mainstream if they don't put their opinions in the mainstream ?
I see that they have made like a separate group of their own in their own youtube channels with heavy social media engagement but where there engagement is necessary they don't engage themselves.
Even north and south interacts with each other like a love-hate relationship but where are the NE Indians ?
How is a Bengali calling himself a North Eastern? 🤣🤣
Atleast this bengali dude is trying to represent on behalf NE Indians here.
What are the NE Indians doing when they should be the ones representing themselves here ? Where are they ? Why this much exclusivity from them ?
How many years will your mother live ?? 1.) Ignore=0 years ❌
2.) 1 subcribe = 100 years✔️..
We need federal laws like in the US where every state earns and pays for its own.
Pl explain briefly.
You should declare independence like Bangladesh from Pakistan.
@@suarasultana8546 lol like Punjab from pak
It will make Northern states more poor.
We south don't worry about North getting more in tax return.
Develop your states that all we want
@@Ausind rajasthan up Bihar underdeveloped
I guess within the next 100 years, South India will get separated and forms it's own independent nation amd focus all these money to it's own development.
Finally someone has raised voice in the topic of freight equalization and labour transfers
TN finance minister said that - they don't have problem with giving out more money but the real problem is he doesn't see that money being put to good use.
That is why he said it is like pouring money in a dump.
lol 😂 same DMK who was involved in corruption 😂 during upa regime ... 😂 right ?? it's DMK who is hand in gloves with parties who actually destroyed u.p and bihar ... ?? could i know why ?? 😂 u.p added more than 50 billion dollars in its SGDP & i think it's highest in india ... so what the hell they are complaining abt ??
As an east Indian ,I can confirm that he was right . The corrupted politicians don't use that money for the betterment of peoples of Bihar.
@Ak Aryans don't look like Yogi adityanath
@Ak your mindset proves why south is overall better
@Ak You still believe in tha bullshit propaganda theory proposed by Britishers . Do Aryans look like us . Germans have Aryan ancestry do they look like us 😂😂😂
In a family, it’s normal for a well off brother to look out for his siblings when they are in bad times. So it’s ok that South sometimes subsidises for the North - that’s what families do, even when they may not always agree with each other.
But what makes the relationship toxic is when the weaker sibling uses his other strengths to gain control of the household.
That’s when problems happen.
that is what happening bro
Bro you explained the video in a paragraph here's the thing you dropped 👑
population is the key used by state like bihar to control nation
South india should break away from the Indian union. We shouldn't have to pay for the mistakes of those hindutva idiots up north who breed like rabbits . Independence for south india from Hindi imperialism. We would be a developed nation already if it we didn't have to serve those idiot illiterate northies
But is the money going to those siblings
Nice explanation 👍
I'm from Telangana, we don't have any problem to allocate tax amounts in North India but the problem is I can't see the growth in that states why because they are misusing these funds for dirty politics. As a Indian I want see my country has doveloped country hope it will comes true
And also about the condescension as well from centre that they are pouring into Telangana even though it gets half of what it pays
I thought Telangana will ask for a separate country just like it asked for separate state citing unfair treatment.
Thank God you didn't think like that.
@@pokemonitishere202 All telangana people respect India they know they're a part of India and separate state was asked bcoz there were lot of prblms for rural telangana villages 10 yrs ago( water prblm, power cuts, drought, corruption, less connectivity)
@@pokemonitishere202you are disrespecting many families who lost their lives just for partition😡😡
Good one sir
As a Bengali when I see states like Tamil Nadu are suffering from not getting enough funds, it's obvious that the state which can do the maximum developement should recieve the max funds , if not it might hinder their developement process. I firmly believe that states like Bihar are a liability to the entire country, we cannot blame the northeast states due to the terrain.
West Bengal gets only 90rs😢
Every state is important. It’s not fair to use the word liability. I am from Chennai. I don’t think Bihar or Up or Bengal as a liability. The whole purpose of taxation is to tax the rich and help the poor. Definitely, the people of Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh doesn’t mind when the government spends on bihar or other states. But there should be proper checks and balances.
@@VIkKNIGHTSTEMPLAR Bengal actually gets less bro...just look up
@@VIkKNIGHTSTEMPLARUP BIHAR is liability not bengal and odisha
@@BhrugurajUP is not anymore
Instead of funneling the money into states like Bihar and Jharkhand( as their leaders are not motivated to make the state stable anymore) it is better to use that money for the development of North east because they are educated people and really wanted to progress. Being a Bengali I would vouch for helping North East India to grow further.
I hope u have seen the full video
Bengal toh jaise bahut developed state h
@@AakashKumar-ry1yu 😂😂
In North East there various groups which ask extortion money from people from north south and west india. Even from transport trucks, firms, labours and small engineers. Locals say that it's just like tax u pay to govt. How do u expect development there when they don't want it. Plus if it was so easy then investors would have already done a lot there.
@@AakashKumar-ry1yu tum north indian states se har figure mein accha hi hai. stats check karlena
We people from Tamil Nadu are always dealt badly by people in North India especially in UP literally people treats you so badly that one just think to run away they use such Misogynist word to describe people from South such a shame
We need a separate country Anna
Karma revolves
@@priyanshuvishwakarma4812 what revolves gutka
Justice for South India. We(AP) people facing so many issue's with this Government. From 4 years there is no Job Calender due to lack of funds.
Yes. I am from UP and I agree with you. South must revolt against the North Indians working there. Drive them away. No representation of North in South without proper tax share. Only then will Delhi listen and treat Biharis how they should be treated.
As a south Indian
Its okay if our tax money goes as a part of development to other states but this states like
Up ,mp ,bihar are mostly focusing on their hindutva agenda and not focusing on development .
Our Ministers are right when they say its like throwing taxpayers money to Well
I mean MP and UP are doing good but Bihar is doing fabulous as a bridge in Bihar got destroyed in 8 seconds 💀💀💀🙏🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻(illegal immigrant moment)
You should declare independence like Bangladesh from Pakistan.
@@suarasultana8546 acha abdul 😂
@@ravishastri5444 same bro like I live in Benaras
@@ravishastri5444 Yoooo Ravi Shastri🗿🗿🗿🗿
നാട്ടിൽ നിന്ന് ആരെങ്കിലും ഉണ്ടോ? Kudos to your efforts, ❤️ from Kerala.
Pinnillah
I understand the pain of southern states but Maharashtra also faces the same problem !
This scenario between the south Indian states and the northern Indian states reminds me a lot of all the tensions that the former country Yugoslavia had before it broke into several countries. States dominated by linguistic minority groups who are well managed are forced to accommodate the needs of the rest of the nation who are primarily under-achievers.
There are no tensions between North and South India, except occasional media hype
@@Insightful_Truth of course there are tensions between the North and South, it just has not evolved into open warfare yet.
@@theawesomeman9821 There are absolutely no tensions.
@@Insightful_Truth if there are no tensions how come most southern Indians refuse to speak Hindi unless they have something mean to say?
@@theawesomeman9821 Speaking Hindi or not has nothing to do with having or not having tensions. For example, many freedom fighters spoke and read English. Does that mean there was no tension or conflict between British empire and freedom fighters ?
Though I am from south India (Hyderabad), I am extremely happy to see India recognizing the northeastern states and developing these states in every way, as per UP and Bihar labor worker's contribution, I know they work hard with such low wages and their issues must be addressed at any cost because they are our citizens, and I noticed that you mentioned most south Indians migrating to western countries, yes, I accept that fact, despite the fact that even I'm currently living in the United States, as do most of my friends and relatives, but the reality is that our contribution to India is quite significant since south Indian NRIs spend heavily in India, As an example, in the Hyderabad real estate market, most Andhra and Telangana NRIs purchased at least one housing flat, which easily costs more than one crore, and many more investments in numerous other ways, which contribute to India's economic progress and rise in strong dollar reserves.
👏👏👏👏
I am from bihar and i am ashamed to see such a situation
100% true...even i am planning to work in abroad for few years, so i can remit that money to india to afford house in bangalore
You went abroad and invested all the money in Hyderabad? So again it's ur States that's getting development.
True soo many hyderabadis take flats and houses in crores after coming back
As a Kannada speaking Kannadiga myself, we Kannadigas are annoyed with this blatant cheating. Even worse is the lack of sentiments to our Kannada feelings and Kannada people. This is what triggers all Kannadigas. Jai Kannada
@Mirabas Blabinola lol wake up kid 🤣
I am Marathi who agrees with you. You need to kick out these North Indians and Marwadis. These people already destroyed Mumbai. Now they are trying to destroy Bangalore.
@@YadavaRahul oh little boi
No one is killing Kannada if you keep speaking it... It's NOT like they're forcing you to speak Hindi... Don't speak if you don't want to....
@Mirabas Blabinola
You know what any language die when its people left it .
It is good to have our regional language but a national language can create more unity and opportunities. So we can carry both a regional language and a national language.
People of Bihar have also adopted hindi during indipendent struggles to support unity.
Fantastic Video!
As a haryanvi , we are not getting the equal treatment with our fellow north states 😂😂..Well i don't know about this issue , thanks for the information mohak ..
The north west states(punjab haryana himachal jammu kashmir) have better livestyles than south indian states. They think only up biĥàŕ is north india
Exactly bro haryana only getting 18rs 🥲
Haryana Punjab do not get tax back to state govt but they receive MSP by farmers. So all in all its same
@@Paaaaaaaaaaal the msp should be stopped in rice
Shi baat
If I am not wrong, same thing is happening in case of gst too. Southern States created infrastructure, promoted ease of doing business but gst lead to consumption state (High population northern states) receiving IGST instead of production state.
Why is MOHAK Targetting North India? Did he Purposely Missed MAH :7 ₹ per 100 but NE is mostly Dependent like AR :4800 MZ :3500, TR :1000, MN :1484₹ per 100 rupees tax collected.
why is the Biasedness?
WHY did You example of UP, BIHAR?
BUT Not NE states?
Why is WEST INDIA is Always Neglected?
@@sasmalprasanjit2764 look at the population of North East vs population of Bihar+UP..how tf can you even compare
@@sasmalprasanjit2764 In absolute terms, the amount spent on UP, Bihar exceeds the amount spent in NW and NE. Maybe that's the reason.
also north eastern states are being developed due to threat from China..earlier they werent getting these funds
This can be addressed by dividing GST among Origin state and destination state
I as Bihari request Central Government to stop giving hard earned money of other states to Bihar, this state is DEAD due to corruption and politics and it's beyond repair, kindly use that money for other useful purposes.
Because that's what Indian government is lacking, Chanakya like you. You are a real joke man.
Alright!!!!! Dead!!!! What do you mean? Bihar is growing at 10.74% for last 10 years, i.e., 3rd fastest in India. I know it is still laggard but still DEAD.. Holy shit!!!!!! Bihar's migrant labor is behind growth of many other states in India.
Just cut the money to half atleast and slowly slow down the money 💸 to Bihar . Bihar need a revolution like up
Jab bjp 39 seat jita tab thk tha
Modi 1.25 lakh crore ru bihar kyun nahi diya ab tak jhootha
Why People of North india have remained poor or poorer after pouring so much tax money from South . Politicians/ civil leaders busy looting instead of focusing on development of the states.
Why North Indians have to come to the South looking for jobs. Why they have to remain under privileged label. Respect the past contribution & move forward.
To be a developed state:
1. Education
2. Healthcare
3. Skill development
4. Women empowerment
5. Women labour force participation
6. Women free from domestic violence
7. Population control
8. Infrastructure development
9. Industrial development
10. Independence of media
11. Accountability of government
12. Gender equality
13. Corruption free
14. Social inclusion
15. Effective implementation of social welfare schemes
16. Political stability
@@Satyauniversegalaxy i didnt get it. Please explain clearly.
My state only has 4,6,7,12 😢
What about suicide control
@@fishyfish6510 bro is living in the feminist land
What about men free from domestic violence
As a keralite we don't have any issue of investing the money in bihar and up.. But the issue is, the money is going to the hands of corrupted politicians who just play casteism and manipulating common people without making any developments.. Last time when i visited up.. I just cried seeing the conditions of villages
I am not from UP but I can say that infra development in UP is marvelous and their growth is marvelous. It is being said that UP will develop soon if they continue to focus on their Infra but nothing can happen to Bihar because both people and leaders are corrupt.
@@subhashishbagchi2569 yeah compared to bihar.. Up is better
@@richuraju8123 According to the data, the highest crime rate (1477.2) existed in Kerala and the lowest crime rate (67.2) in Nagaland. In Punjab, the crime rate stood at 242.0 compared to neighbouring states Haryana (697.3), Rajasthan (254.3) and Himachal Pradesh (357.6)., Kerala saw 55% hike in drug cases
@@proudhuman166 know that's common misconception having high crime rates is actually good it says the police forces are much active in Kerala .ie the no of case reporting is high in Kerala ( Finland has the highest in the world and Iran one of the lowest).So if u go by ur logic Bihar ,up etc is much safer ,just give it a thought 🤔🤔
@@subhashishbagchi2569 j
This is not just for Southern States, while checking that map of taxes/investment you will see even Gujurat and Maharashtra are also heavily affected.
Just because BiMaRU states can't get their act together, for controlling population,other states are being punished.
And any national level political party will support this because the BiMaRU states bring the highest seats in the parliaments so they have to please them.
Lol, Only Maharashtra facing most discrimination, imagine getting 7₹ out of 100₹😭
wait man ....actually gujrat is completely running on rivers of m.p 😂 Is this not the discrimination with farmers of madhya pradesh ?? mumbai is paying more than 70% of the taxes ...in maharastra ?? is it getting equal treatment even within the maharastra ?? dud this the not the way to think ... we can criticize weak performers but we have to understand what's main the problem in thier states ?? bihar was first ruled by communits then lalu chor , then nitish who actually developed alot but people of bihar. don't think anything beyond thier caste ... so there's problem
North Indian states like haryana,Punjab and uttarakhand has higher per capita income than MH. The only states lagging are UP and Bihar, which is due to their overpopulation and mismanagement.
Another factor is that north india is a landlocked region and does not get enough economic opportunities as south and west india which gets huge revenues due to sea ports for trading. Many companies also prefer to setup their business close to coastal regions as it is affordable and logistically easier to open business close to sea port.
Same was done by British too in the form of calcuta, Madras and bombay
@@coldplayfan7357 bcs these places has resources.
@@coldplayfan7357 Punjab, Haryana people gets MSP. Which is artificially inflating food prices.
Someday also make a video on why western states of india (Maharashtra,Gujarat) are more developed than North, south , North east, and center regions.
GDP is not a measure of development. In west ambani and adani boosts the gdp but for people?
Development can be found by less social inquality, good HDI, gender ratio, women empowerment etc. where you can clearly see which is more developed.
@@harry_krish yeah western india is better overall
He won't.. Coz if he makes, Then his Concept of MAKING video on NAAARTH INDIA and SOUTH INDIA will go down..
In fact He became Viral through his early Video on WHY SAAAUTH INDIA is Develop, Language video
where he showed Entire Rest of India as NAARTH INDIA by his Logic..
But after receiving backlash as WEST INDIA, EAST INDIA, NE INDIA exist other than North India.
He quickly Edited out his Videotitleand image.
You should come to eastern maharashtra (Vidharbha,Marathwada) and see how different the situation is compared to pune,bombay and nashik regions
@@harry_krish lol, ADANI Ambani Gives Job, Makes Road does Social Uplift ment.. Makes new Industries, Port town, Road... List is Long.. When you live like a Frog in a well, Thinks whole world is Only that
this video was really a good explanation for the said subject
i am from Maharashtra we the maharashtrian people work hard and had sacrificed a lot lot to make our state prosperous and developed we pay the most tax our state capita is the most wealthiest city in India but we get only 7.7 rupees on 100 rupees we pay as taxes the over populated and undeveloped states like UP & Bihar get more money from center because they have more population therefor they have more seats in lok sabha so to get more votes and seat in election the party that has a power in center give more money to this states and stole from us who work hard and earned this money and paid tax after getting the lot of free money all this year this states are still backward, poor, corrupt & overpopulated .
Remove bihar from india
I think Maharasthra get enough (OR more) state tax because of city Mumbai and overall state. It about to get 1 trillion economy (1/3rd of India's GDP). Like literally the richest Municipal corporation in Asia is BMC and still living in Mumbai I see poor infrastructure, water fills up in rain, etc. I just feel Maharasthra gov. or BMC is most corrupted gov. I don't know if they want us or not. Just take money from us but please reduce overcrowding in Mumbai. And Real Estate is also the most corrupted too. Maha should focus on policies making or businessman (Micro businessman) will leave Maharasthra. Just remove corruption, half of the problem will get solve and we won't even need central gov. tax money, let central gov. use it for soldiers, R&D, ISRO, poor states, preserving wildlife, etc. (I am not ignoring the fact of UP and Bihar, but I think 1st we should address our own problem than blaming central gov. It's easy to blame others but we shouldn't ignore our problems and I am Maharashtrian too)
@Kirti Kishore ohh really very very thanks, tum up Bihar log ka upkar kidhar vapis karega ham 😂😂 we don't do any type of work, all is just due to up Bihar
@@lol8q no one beaten in Tamil nadu maharashtra is rich because mumbai is rich mumbai is rich because gujrathi and up people
Tamilians don't have the power to beat up people if that so then they must try it we'll see 😆
Up bihar should ban product from Maharashtra and Tamil naidu and set up their own industry 😂
Then only tamils and Marathi should know what is discrimination