What is Wrong with Indian Liberals

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 дек 2024

Комментарии •

  • @gauravarya8444
    @gauravarya8444 Год назад +145

    Awesome video man. Literally everyone needs to see this.
    All the people who always take one or the other side very strongly. And not only in politics but in small real life situations as well.

  • @keerthanakalburgivenkatesh8111
    @keerthanakalburgivenkatesh8111 8 месяцев назад +9

    Good work with extensive research.

  • @Mozilla10
    @Mozilla10 Год назад +9375

    Dhruv Rathee be like - Mai toh isse apna samajhta tha!

    • @meghrajdadapatil9148
      @meghrajdadapatil9148 Год назад +162

      🤣🤣🤣

    • @rawntoo4066
      @rawntoo4066 Год назад +189

      @Vishal Autade Agreed

    • @meghrajdadapatil9148
      @meghrajdadapatil9148 Год назад +735

      @Vishal Autade Dhruv Rathi manuplate his audiance

    • @dkjb5756
      @dkjb5756 Год назад +592

      Also I don't like his facial expressions
      He always makes fun and harasses the right wings
      Such biased videos he makes

    • @gitanjalisingh2240
      @gitanjalisingh2240 Год назад +103

      @Vishal Autade ek batt puchu bhai??
      log usse anti national kyon bolte hai.....kafi videos dhekhe maine uske lekin ku v esa nhi lga

  • @adarshsudhakaran3766
    @adarshsudhakaran3766 Год назад +474

    I absolutely agree with you. I also consider myself as a liberal. And I keep telling my fellow liberals the same things you said. But none would listen. Instead they would call me 'Sanghi'. 🤷🏽‍♂️

    • @anupamsatpathi2071
      @anupamsatpathi2071 Год назад +43

      That's mean your friends are not liberal.

    • @sourishmazumdar2107
      @sourishmazumdar2107 Год назад +33

      Yeah, bro, I'm a Liberal, I'd listen to both sides, always ask questions, and only believe in things with a proper fact check, if your friends are just blaming one side, they are not truly Liberal.

    • @Hiraeth1992
      @Hiraeth1992 9 месяцев назад +4

      And the same person cry about democracy

    • @spiderboys
      @spiderboys 9 месяцев назад +4

      Thats absolutely who is "NOT A LIBERAL" by definition 😂

    • @AverageJoe20
      @AverageJoe20 9 месяцев назад +1

      Conservativism/ Libertarian is the way to victory. The Countries in the world are adopting this

  • @henriettahawkins5349
    @henriettahawkins5349 Год назад +3942

    Whether you are Liberal or Conservative just remember one thing "सत्ता का खेल तो चलेगा, सरकारें आएंगी, जाएंगी, पार्टियां बनेगी, बिगड़ेगी; मगर यह देश रहना चाहिए, इसका लोकतंत्र अमर रहना चाहिए।"

    • @mrinalrohilla2654
      @mrinalrohilla2654 Год назад +133

      Ain't that that the universal truth

    • @shubhamjatt02
      @shubhamjatt02 Год назад +361

      Atal Bihari Vajpayee ji 🙏🏻

    • @pratikyadav1378
      @pratikyadav1378 Год назад +65

      Bilkul right ❤️

    • @justice32legends
      @justice32legends Год назад +42

      That's exactly why there's never a dull moment Geopolitics. Well, neither in Republic Media, thanks to a certain news anchor XD.

    • @jeremybrett5076
      @jeremybrett5076 Год назад +13

      W comment

  • @muhammadumer7833
    @muhammadumer7833 Год назад +102

    An important step taken by you by making this EXTRAORDINARY video.
    Hope the society understands this idea's long term benefits for a nation

  • @EnEeJeeEye
    @EnEeJeeEye Год назад +584

    I’m a centrist and I believe problem starts when ppl go extreme.
    (I don’t think it’s left vs right anymore.. it’s between ppl who want to coexist and extremist)

    • @anupamsatpathi2071
      @anupamsatpathi2071 Год назад +8

      In democracy people get that what the deserve.

    • @amusicalinstrument9745
      @amusicalinstrument9745 Год назад +25

      ​@@anupamsatpathi2071in democracy majority wins. so people get what they think they deserve.

    • @amanrawat9741
      @amanrawat9741 10 месяцев назад +2

      I agree

    • @thearunsonishow4482
      @thearunsonishow4482 10 месяцев назад +13

      Yes far right and far left both type of extremisam bad for society

    • @AnshRathore-911
      @AnshRathore-911 10 месяцев назад +7

      i believe its very difficult to be a 100% centrist these days . i myself sometimes tend towards right

  • @shubhammguptaa
    @shubhammguptaa Год назад +326

    I am glad that at least 2 million people are watching a good quality content. I hope that these videos reach out to maximum people around us to develop good interest in politics & policy making because it's important to know all this as a citizen.

  • @maniray3660
    @maniray3660 Год назад +2065

    I support BJP but not bcoz of Modi but bcoz of changes I have seen in my village ...there was no road ppl were tired of using hand pump only few ppl had electricity ..but now most of villagers are using net almost everyone has electricity although I live in city bt I'm happy to see ppl r getting there basic requirements.

    • @utkarsh2279
      @utkarsh2279 Год назад +101

      So?? It is done by modi na 🤣🤣🤣

    • @doggee09
      @doggee09 Год назад +58

      Same

    • @radhakrishn4378
      @radhakrishn4378 Год назад +441

      @@utkarsh2279 To bhai tum ho kya pm abhi?

    • @VitaminProtein4256
      @VitaminProtein4256 Год назад +81

      2₹ added to your account ✌️

    • @doggee09
      @doggee09 Год назад +275

      @@utkarsh2279 Haa toh usse pehle ?? Kyu Nhi aya change !! being hater is easy but not to know more is really hard

  • @siddhantaggarwa2862
    @siddhantaggarwa2862 Год назад +2302

    maturity is when u realize liberals are blindly following opposition , conservatives are blindly following modi thus , both r in andhbhakti ...as a responsible citizen , one should use both ruling govt , and opposition according to the needs and welfare of the society rather than blindly following and favouring either of the two , they both are for us , we are not for them , we need to understand the difference and favour the one who is favouring our interests , never be extreme rightist or leftist , be at the centre ....

    • @vaibhavmadan3542
      @vaibhavmadan3542 Год назад +94

      reading ur comment is the only time i didnt have the feeling of bashing my head against a wall because i was dumb enough to read a poltical comment ( comments under a political video)

    • @dhruvsinghrajput4748
      @dhruvsinghrajput4748 Год назад +139

      Not andhbhakti it's andhnamazipana

    • @narendrasinghrawat5024
      @narendrasinghrawat5024 Год назад +93

      Bro criticising Ruling party doesn't means favoring the Opposition It's our right to ask from Govt to bring more transparency to public.

    • @siddhantaggarwa2862
      @siddhantaggarwa2862 Год назад +69

      @@narendrasinghrawat5024 i did nt mean that , critize the one whom u feel is not ryt and against the needs of society not the one who is against ur personal ideology ....

    • @narendrasinghrawat5024
      @narendrasinghrawat5024 Год назад +13

      @@siddhantaggarwa2862 that's what I was favouring If you have logical Arguments to face your Opposition then You don't need to face them personally

  • @manikantasrao7868
    @manikantasrao7868 Год назад +2084

    Being Secular does not mean being non-religious.
    I am the most religious Hindu-Brahmin who follows my religion and loves being part of it. I am also very secular.
    Don't let either side fool you into thinking that either "religious" or "secular" is bad word and you have to pick one to fit into one side.
    Being secular means you love your religion and believe in the right of others to love theirs.

    • @SahilKewatVlogs
      @SahilKewatVlogs Год назад +31

      Same her

    • @nee23454
      @nee23454 Год назад +88

      Secular literally means non religious
      I think plural should be the better word .

    • @amitkumardeo95
      @amitkumardeo95 Год назад +7

      @@twofacedperson2864 how?

    • @Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi
      @Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi Год назад +32

      ​@Two Faced Person I am indifferent towards interfaith marriages if the union is not harming the concerned party. I won't do it myself because i don't want to associate with people who are from different faiths.

    • @user-xq7jn2tc2i
      @user-xq7jn2tc2i Год назад +32

      Unfortunately most secular people bash the majority with looking at instances where majority are actually victims

  • @sagnikasen2004
    @sagnikasen2004 Год назад +123

    I have now developed a deep sense of respect for Mohak Mangal. Amazing points. And seriously, this video has required so much of in-depth research and thought. Truly commendable work.

    • @Adarshkumar-te8dw
      @Adarshkumar-te8dw Год назад

      West Bengal totally ruined by Mamta begum
      Full of rohingyas 😢

    • @youttt27
      @youttt27 Год назад +1

      No he's dead wrong .The values of Abrahamic faiths are not the values of the Indian .Do to look at conservatism through an Abrahamic lens like LGBTQ rights or contraception, right to choose etc simply does not apply to the Hindu right winger.

    • @bollywoodsongs751
      @bollywoodsongs751 8 месяцев назад

      Don't be manipulate by him,,this is the series to maintain balance otherwise their truth will be revealed

  • @Theo_m64
    @Theo_m64 Год назад +2176

    India is not ready for a video like this, mohak has earned my utmost respect for this video🫡. I used to be an extreme leftist once, and I wish this video had come out then, but even today this video has blown my mind.

    • @motherisape
      @motherisape Год назад +36

      Firstly explain explain what is leftist most politicians use that word for muslim which is not true . muslim can be conservative wright winger .

    • @siddhantrawat1588
      @siddhantrawat1588 Год назад +26

      ​@@motherisape on a very basic level, leftist is a person who wants "change". Kisi bhi tarah ka change, kisi bhi cheez me.

    • @DrMike005
      @DrMike005 Год назад

      @@siddhantrawat1588 no leftists mainly want change in the lives of poor people and there lies the problem, they ignore rich people and dismiss everything advanced as corrupt

    • @motherisape
      @motherisape Год назад +75

      @@siddhantrawat1588 I want to change my old shoes I'm leftist 😔

    • @motherisape
      @motherisape Год назад +1

      @@siddhantrawat1588 I think every person wants to change something . Hindu rastr is itself a change so they all are leftist

  • @anishbhanushali
    @anishbhanushali Год назад +156

    I just want to say that the 2nd last segment of your video ( 16:09 to 18:00) inspired me to join and support your channel. A well researched thought should always be rewarded in a healthy society.

  • @rohit2521
    @rohit2521 Год назад +415

    This is just not a general awareness video, this is the 'bitter truth'. More power to you, Mohak!

  • @nehakamath1449
    @nehakamath1449 Год назад +7

    Thanks

  • @abhimanyadav1037
    @abhimanyadav1037 Год назад +277

    I used to say this to my friends when they keeps fighting on these issues, finally someone with large audience has said it. Great work , keep it up. India desperately needs this kind of information.

    • @thescentofsoil.436
      @thescentofsoil.436 Год назад

      But friends didn't understand.

    • @memehu2910
      @memehu2910 Год назад +2

      मै भी यादव हु
      सपा के अलावा किसी को vote नही दे सकता😢
      Esha मेरे east up ke यादव सोचते है
      Agar मैने कुछ गलत भी बोल दिया सपा के काम के बारे मे तो
      ऐसे देखते है jese मैने unse उधार माँग लिया😮

  • @peteck007
    @peteck007 Год назад +66

    What a content man! Never expected that yours video of today would be opening my mind like this. Well, as a centrist leaning person, I have these things in my mind for a long time, but only had vague idea that all these things could be put into the terms. The terms you explained, now makes it all clear, on how societies work, and runs. And how we should be more frequently opened to the ideas of others, and why they think that way.

    • @QuantumNinja1.9
      @QuantumNinja1.9 Год назад +1

      @@factify07 that's the problem with u guys, don't force anyone and let them think for themselves and even do self introspection 🙏

  • @hiutkarsh
    @hiutkarsh Год назад +219

    writting this after watching the first 3 minutes.
    Secularism and atheism are two different things, one can be secular and follow their own religious practices without harming anyone, I think most of the people, be it liberals or right wing people, they consider atheism and secularism the same and i think this is the main root of all problems.
    Writting this part after watching the whole video.
    I've been watching you since 2019 and I think this video was very well put together and you addressed some important points, would love to see more stuff like this.

    • @spellcheck5393
      @spellcheck5393 Год назад

      Secularism aims for separation of religion and Government, Atheism is rejection of God/religion itself.
      Atheist by defination are Secular but not all secular people are atheists
      India is overall opposite of secularism.

    • @indiankid8601
      @indiankid8601 Год назад +1

      nobody thought that except u

    • @ShubhamMishrabro
      @ShubhamMishrabro Год назад

      Problem is lot of Indians who consider themselves liberals are leftists. They hate anything modi does. Problem is us vs them politics you can't appreciate a person who is in your opposite group. Same thing happens with hindu right wing but problem is so called leftists do same thing what these hindu nationalist do

    • @jishnuchattopadhyay9220
      @jishnuchattopadhyay9220 Год назад +7

      @@indiankid8601 i have that thought too

    • @indiankid8601
      @indiankid8601 Год назад

      @@ShubhamMishrabro Bhos dike liberal has nothing to do with left or right and vice versa. Left means economic communism and right means capitlaism, Kya kichdi paka rha hai? George Soros is liberal right winger. Xi xinping is conservative leftist. antar samjha??

  • @lonewarrior600
    @lonewarrior600 Год назад +12

    Hatts off Mohak bhai.... OUR WORLD NEEDS PEOPLE LIKE YOU WHO USES THEIR BRAINS RATHER THAN USELESS EMOTION!!!!... JUST THANKYOU

  • @shock-t3768
    @shock-t3768 Год назад +807

    This video is such a blessing for people who are 'centrist' and not right or left. I can so relate to you bro. Keep up the good work. There are less people like us but they are there... Comment if you are 'centrist'.

    • @silenceplease2022
      @silenceplease2022 Год назад

      Modi and RSS hates liberty. They are Manusmriti promoters
      How can any liberal promote such enemies of liberty and freedom?

    • @ashwatimenon5481
      @ashwatimenon5481 Год назад

      Meeee 🤚
      Half the idiots on the right question my faithfullness to Hinduism. (Like whyaaaaattt) and say I am trying to destroy tradition when I try to amend questionable practices in our community.
      Half idiots think I hate muslims because I want them to reform. I can expect reform and be a proponent of progress in minority communities. At the same time I can be respectful.

    • @agbdrxj
      @agbdrxj Год назад +5

      👍

    • @prashanttiwari1413
      @prashanttiwari1413 Год назад +45

      😍😍 Ekdm shi kha neutral hone me sbse jyada brain chahiye... Aur maza bhi bhut aata h dono side k drama me😁

    • @hxrsh_x
      @hxrsh_x Год назад +72

      There is no such thing as 'centrist'. Studies have shown that no matter how you try, you are biased in some way or the other.

  • @hawksnest9493
    @hawksnest9493 Год назад +3674

    Hey Mohak, I am a right wing supporter and I request you to make video on what's wrong with Indian right wingers as well because even some right wing supporters take things to extreme and make pointless argument like bhagwa bikini in besharam rang, Hindu rashtra, akhand bharat etc. watching my fellow right wing supporters doing baseless argument rages me.
    Edit: those who are saying what's wrong with hindu rashtra let me tell that it is not at all possible both practically and ethically. Labeling country as hindu rastra won't appease minorities and separatist mindset will dominate among them.

    • @gigabyte1739
      @gigabyte1739 Год назад

      Exactly. Most of the conservatives are so easy to make them do anything and boycott anything.

    • @parasagg932
      @parasagg932 Год назад +229

      ​@@shayanraj7840 same bro, Jai shree krishna🙏

    • @charusharma7927
      @charusharma7927 Год назад +262

      frr bro these people make a bad image of right wing

    • @biswajitbehera6689
      @biswajitbehera6689 Год назад +30

      @@charusharma7927 it doesn't matter because there is no alternative option

    • @patriotenfield3276
      @patriotenfield3276 Год назад +199

      same as a right wing. but don't forget that right wing is not limited to any hindu right wing party like BJP. it also includes muslim right wing party like AIMIM too.

  • @nishu761
    @nishu761 Год назад +594

    This channel presents truly independent and objective sociopolitical content. It’s like gold in the murky river of Indian media. Respect.

  • @ishaansemwal
    @ishaansemwal Год назад +13

    How on earth are you able to articulate these thoughts so well?! Amazing👏

  • @naa.istam.be_549
    @naa.istam.be_549 Год назад +5807

    Nowadays the word liberal became joke in our country 😂😂

    • @srinivasjsd
      @srinivasjsd Год назад +80

      True 🤣🤣

    • @Kakashiffx
      @Kakashiffx Год назад +380

      For your information 🤣🤣 freedom is gone in india already
      India's Hunger index
      2013: 63rd rank
      2022: 107th rank.
      India's Happiness index.
      2013: 111th rank
      2022: 136th rank
      India's press freedom rank.
      2013:79th
      2022: 150th.... the fourth pillar of worlds largest democracy is no more..

    • @VitaminProtein4256
      @VitaminProtein4256 Год назад +120

      @@Kakashiffx you literally copied my comment 😂

    • @Vsk6.0
      @Vsk6.0 Год назад +20

      @@VitaminProtein4256 lol right 😂

    • @Trollge398
      @Trollge398 Год назад +107

      I do agree modern liberalism means nothing anymore

  • @himanshuchoudhary9303
    @himanshuchoudhary9303 Год назад +1011

    Being a centrist and an ex liberal myself, I know really well that no party in India is perfect and no political leader is Saint, even BJP got it's own flaws still the way Modi is governing India no other opposing politician can lead India better than this, Even if all these Liberals rate Modi's performance as (0) then too the other leaders are (-1) in comparison to him

    • @SaysMaverick
      @SaysMaverick Год назад +42

      Please share what exactly is that you like and what exactly is such a good policy that makes you idolize modi

    • @herohub6969
      @herohub6969 Год назад +84

      Yeah I agreed U.
      Modi gives us the reason why we should make a Bharat not a India

    • @kamleshnarayan3286
      @kamleshnarayan3286 Год назад +49

      I don't agree with you completely. Atal Bihari Vajpayee Indira Gandhi Jawaharlal Nehru Lal Bahadur Shashtri. These Prime Ministers were far better than Narendra Modi.

    • @NehaSingh-tj8ng
      @NehaSingh-tj8ng Год назад +36

      Can you please elaborate.... How press freedom index of 150 is better then 140 and petrol of 70 is bad option then 100 rs/L..or LPG of 1150 is an better option then 450.....or milk of 43/L is not good but milk of 60/L is great..

    • @gaganvarshney3287
      @gaganvarshney3287 Год назад +99

      @@NehaSingh-tj8ng That's the whole point of this video... Modi has his flaws. And their is no doubt about it, but he has his strengths which have the helped the country.The problem is that their is no opposition at the moment which I feel is accountable enough to run our central government. All the opposition does is launch a personal attack instead of highlighting these problems which you just stated.

  • @Naayan-jq6dv
    @Naayan-jq6dv Год назад +148

    I have never seen such a professional youtuber who talks about Indian affairs on RUclips
    Hatts of to your way of speaking, confidence and Video Quality. Keep Going and Keep Growing ❤️

    • @silenceplease2022
      @silenceplease2022 Год назад

      Modi and RSS hates liberty. They are Manusmriti promoters
      How can any liberal promote such enemies of liberty and freedom?

    • @ns8976
      @ns8976 Год назад +4

      Then go and see dhruv rathee

    • @maxpayne1670
      @maxpayne1670 Год назад +8

      ​@@ns8976 Okay Libru .

    • @tejastakalkar7924
      @tejastakalkar7924 Год назад +2

      @@ns8976 this video was really a relief from, manipulators like dhruv rathee. I hate the strategy of finding some extrimists from other team and making fun of them and then saying that this is what all of them do. This tactics is used by both godi media and dhruv rathee.

    • @jishnuchattopadhyay9220
      @jishnuchattopadhyay9220 Год назад

      @@tejastakalkar7924 data manipulation is used by him whereas other facts are hidden by godi media its hard to find people like mohak

  • @apoorvshrivastava3688
    @apoorvshrivastava3688 Год назад +12

    What an amazing step for letting people know about the central easiest way to uplift the way of thinking and seeing the other side of the extremism.
    Thank you so much mohak

  • @ShimonAalam
    @ShimonAalam Год назад +228

    The most balanced explaination I have ever seen. Brings us all to a common ground

  • @introvert2023
    @introvert2023 Год назад +76

    I do consider myself liberal (classic) centre-right, secular but i hate neo-liberalism which is just hating the other side because of ideological differences. I am a liberal. I recently turned 19. I will cast my first vote for Modi because i do consider beside bjp there is no better alternative.
    "Don't attack me, attack my arguments" is an awesome statement

    • @Abhi46159
      @Abhi46159 Год назад +14

      I agree with you . I am also centre-right with some liberal and some conservative values (Yes its possible).

    • @preetamyadav7952
      @preetamyadav7952 Год назад +15

      Be a human and do your dharma .
      Stop giving yourself these fake terms like liberal centrist blah blah blah

    • @wingsoffreedom4292
      @wingsoffreedom4292 Год назад +16

      @@preetamyadav7952 dharma is also a term as well. If certain term gives meaning to him let him be chill.

    • @hxrsh_x
      @hxrsh_x Год назад

      Ab kuch log 'dharma' ko hindu ideology se jod ke tumhare comment pe dislike karenge

    • @justchilllll6523
      @justchilllll6523 Год назад

      Actually being liberal or not is not the point......seeing my county been sold by one person and inflation is not ok.....I think "Think 100 times before you take decision and think with brain not with ideologies" is an awesome statement.

  • @Ayush_Thakur16
    @Ayush_Thakur16 Год назад +872

    "Don't attack me, attack my arguments" I guess this is the best quote Mohak had said in his videos.
    I'm definitely going to use this whenever I start a debate with others.

    • @depositgamer4490
      @depositgamer4490 Год назад +5

      True

    • @apurvapatel7781
      @apurvapatel7781 Год назад +40

      Bolna padta hain , Varna comment section main yudh hojata hain.

    • @avi_singhal15december
      @avi_singhal15december Год назад +30

      ​@@apurvapatel7781 ha kuch gawar kattar log kardete hai especially from mainly 2 communities

    • @syedneelofer
      @syedneelofer Год назад +3

      Ad-hominem fallacy is what it is called in the domain of logic.

    • @Vizorfam
      @Vizorfam Год назад +2

      @@avi_singhal15december yeah and one of the community is of sanghi hindutva temple going people

  • @skyloh258
    @skyloh258 Год назад +111

    As a wise person once said:
    “You vote for the person and their people, not their religion or caste”

    • @nevermind2370
      @nevermind2370 Год назад +10

      Then go and vote OWAISI...... 15 minutes.....................

    • @skyloh258
      @skyloh258 9 месяцев назад +6

      @@nevermind2370 and you just made a perfect example of the average modi supporter, read the comment properly

    • @1stRizzMaster
      @1stRizzMaster 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@skyloh258 ye dimag ko jeb me rkh kr dekhte h duniya ko

  • @jhankarmodak1739
    @jhankarmodak1739 Год назад +80

    This is the BEST video on Indian politics on RUclips. One thing we forget is that if we consider ourselves as liberals and do NOT vote a political party because it has an inclination towards a particular religion, we are exactly same as the ones who vote for that party because of religion. We often even forget to see the work and effort a political puts in. Also, politics is a game of choice between candidates standing, yes we should ask questions, but when it comes to vote, we can never have a leader exactly what we want, the only option is to have the better candidate, now the parameter to choose the better is what makes a citizen responsible.

    • @vishalpatkar6819
      @vishalpatkar6819 Год назад

      'Scratch a liberal, fascist bleed' liberals will never stop helping fascists , I don't understand why they portray themselves good because when push comes to shove they always side with fascist.

    • @yochauhan1337
      @yochauhan1337 Год назад

      ​@Z3U5 Bro isliye kehte h video ko dhyan se suna kro..... "Extremism ko oppose krne k liye b keh rha tha Mohak", and if ISIS or any terrorist group supports a good cause or problem of a certain group of people why shouldn't we be listening to them..... Naxalism and terrorism can be fixed by such things.... I'm not saying that you should listen to death threats and jihad shit....but there is sometimes gold in the garbage...

    • @jhankarmodak1739
      @jhankarmodak1739 Год назад

      @Z3U5 Aaj agar taliban education, healthcare, security, infrastructure, jobs ye sab pe actually kaam karte hai, then why not? Taliban, ISIS is just a name, what the people do for the public is what matters, nothing else

    • @abhaysardar2275
      @abhaysardar2275 Год назад

      Inclination towards a particular religion and hating every other religion.

    • @jhankarmodak1739
      @jhankarmodak1739 Год назад +1

      @@abhaysardar2275 True, which is terrible, all I am trying to say is there are hundreds and thousands of traits to judge a political party/politician, but in India people literally forgets everything and just speaks about and make decisions JUST based on religion. The funny thing is the one who totally supports a political party because of religion and the one who opposes a political party because of religion are exactly same, none of them are secular by any means because no matter what the conversation is, in India every one will bring up religion, be it for or against.

  • @ihuman1327
    @ihuman1327 Год назад +1111

    This is one of the most neutral videos I've ever seen in the field of Political Journalism.

    • @akashsinha2880
      @akashsinha2880 Год назад +8

      This is the most purchased comment on RUclips. Now personal attacks in line with all the comment buyers on RUclips.

    • @er7907
      @er7907 Год назад

      @@akashsinha2880 totally agree ... the video is shown to be neutral ... but actually is hatemongers right wing / fake nationalists side taker!

    • @pranavpawar9872
      @pranavpawar9872 Год назад +36

      @@akashsinha2880 😂can't digest reality

    • @gwsaubhagya8220
      @gwsaubhagya8220 Год назад

      Viewers are not always ready to make their own conclusions so a conclusion of this should be provided by the content creator by seeing what is right and what is wrong

    • @mohdsohail8308
      @mohdsohail8308 Год назад +7

      This video is More favourable for andhbhakts 😆
      Fact : Hey Mohan still number of villagers using wood to cook food because of high rate of gas 😂 paid video by Mohan

  • @ratri6110
    @ratri6110 Год назад +874

    Liberal Hypocrisy:
    1. They believe in secularism in India but also want state should run temple.
    2. They support hijab as a personal choice but become active during Mangalsutra, Sindoor, Rakhi and karwachauth.
    Etc

    • @rahulsamant2003
      @rahulsamant2003 Год назад +106

      I agree with you, specially in 2nd point... mangalsutra, sindoor etc should not be banned or forced upon Hindu women....it's a personal choice of individual women. We should respect that.

    • @4cscript743
      @4cscript743 Год назад +77

      State running temple is opposite of secularism, in s truly secular society government has no state religion and does not make laws per religion. India has never been truly secular since there are religious laws

    • @ss_130
      @ss_130 Год назад +8

      ​@@rahulsamant2003 I see many women nowadays who don't wear mangalsutra/sindoor after marriage or only wear them on certain occasions, same goes for the "pallu" system we had in the back.

    • @shubne
      @shubne Год назад +46

      @@ss_130same i see many educated muslim woman not wearing hijab.

    • @mrighald
      @mrighald Год назад +29

      I disagree with this generalization. I'm a liberal Indian, but I feel that:
      1. Religion should not be mixed with government, except when taxes are to be collected.
      2. Hijab, sindoor, rakhi... should be personal choice. Yet in all these, women are judged for choosing one way or the other.
      3. Also believe that bhumi poojan of a government building is OK, but I don't support Modi's presence in the inauguration of the Ram mandir, sine it was mired in so much controversy. I support the SC decision, but I don't support the PMs involvement in such an issue.

  • @indianamerican6362
    @indianamerican6362 Год назад +812

    I used to be a secular, but now became a right winger. Thanks to the hypocricy of left wingers and social media.

    • @ddm1912
      @ddm1912 Год назад +113

      Don't belong to any side, use your own thinking and logic

    • @anshitsrivastava1081
      @anshitsrivastava1081 Год назад

      Except being secular has nothing to do with right or left wing. Being secular means, respecting religious beliefs of others. If you can't do that, you are a bigot, even if you claim to be a leftist.

    • @eevee3168
      @eevee3168 Год назад +32

      People shouldn't really think like "I'm right/left wing", more by what they need to have from politics for them and their family.

    • @GauravKumar-lq7dl
      @GauravKumar-lq7dl Год назад +29

      I think the right path for our nation is somewhere in between liberalism and conservatism

    • @mr.ganguly2624
      @mr.ganguly2624 Год назад +11

      ​@@GauravKumar-lq7dlno the right thing would be like that:- for this I am liberal but for this I am conservative. (Obviously this must not be biased and hypocritical)

  • @vivekpaul8106
    @vivekpaul8106 Год назад +884

    I was also liberal in the past. but it was changed because of their hypocrisy.
    example, they say support freedom of Expression but they want to ban those who don't agree with them.
    they criticize one party for the same issue but defend if the other party does the same.
    they defend one religious extreme and support another.
    they don't want to listen to the problems of another side and label them bhakt if they don't agree with them.

    • @mayankindian3750
      @mayankindian3750 Год назад +62

      Wohi to problem hai na bhai 🤦🏼

    • @gamingwithxan1430
      @gamingwithxan1430 Год назад

      Same toh ulti taraf se bhi hoti hai.
      Jaise anti national, liibrandu etc. VS andhbhakt, it cell etc.
      Ban so called liberals ke tarf se kuch bhi suna hua yaad nhi aa raha, lekin so called andhbhakt ki taraf se lage rehte hai.
      Liberals ko Religious extremism ko support karte nhi dekha, lekin kabhi kabhi sunai nhi padhti, pata nhi news channel ki karan ya nhi sachme ignore krti hai. Lekin andh bhakt ko extremism ke liye boht dekha, example in previous video of this channel.
      So called News channel ke debate mein bhi shanti se baat karne wale boht kamm ho gye, shor machane wale bhar gye.
      Debate ke naam pe off topic quarrel.
      It's better to leave all those & vote good candidates only irrespective of party(including indipendent) or NOTA.

    • @arunv3961
      @arunv3961 Год назад +70

      Every point fits perfectly with the conservaties as well

    • @syhuhjk
      @syhuhjk Год назад +128

      @@arunv3961 no it's same. In my experience 70 percentage of right wingers are more open but only 25 percentage of left wingers are open.

    • @prasannashetty965
      @prasannashetty965 Год назад +31

      Isn't this the same thing what conservatives do?

  • @sanatani_indian_108
    @sanatani_indian_108 Год назад +55

    Ab comments me is bhai ko sab log andhbhakt, bjp supporter goberbhakt etc etc bolenge kyuki
    He is spitting facts
    Much needed video because their hatred for modi is on next level ☠️

  • @raahuldeb
    @raahuldeb Год назад +4

    well researched and presented Mohak!! Congratulations!

  • @sumitsaha1774
    @sumitsaha1774 Год назад +348

    When you are not biased..you get hate from both side that's the fact .. but being a centrist really liked your opinion!! Keep it up man !!

    • @spellcheck5393
      @spellcheck5393 Год назад +6

      What does even being centerist means? Not having opinion at all?

    • @indiankid8601
      @indiankid8601 Год назад +37

      @@spellcheck5393 Having balanced opinions.

    • @Stonersharma8
      @Stonersharma8 Год назад +20

      ​@@spellcheck5393 Not being extremely right or left

    • @someone90000
      @someone90000 Год назад +18

      @@spellcheck5393and pointing out the both sides of stupidity if they done something stupid.

    • @sumitsaha1774
      @sumitsaha1774 Год назад +14

      @@spellcheck5393 that's mean you have the guts to here everyone without hesitation and not simply pointing someone as anti-national or andh bhakts ..respect everybody's viewpoint and then make your own ..only violence is unacceptable..

  • @datta4062
    @datta4062 Год назад +1111

    I'm a centrist. neither liberal not a right winger. but I must say that modi ji brought upon a lot of changes in Indias Infrastructure. I'm not a bjp supporter, but modi ji in itself isn't the worst man out there.

    • @Kathakathan11
      @Kathakathan11 Год назад +141

      Are still you will be labelled, Kuch pro government bolo, toh andhbhakt, kuch criticise karo toh liberal. No I am not liberal at all, this century has lot of fake liberals.

    • @mayankindian3750
      @mayankindian3750 Год назад +23

      ​​​@@Kathakathan11true fake liberals bhi hai 😊

    • @datta4062
      @datta4062 Год назад +6

      @@Kathakathan11 sahi bola yaar

    • @blackmoongaming9542
      @blackmoongaming9542 Год назад +25

      Same but I think bjp was good in infrastructure but bad in economics and religious politics they are spreading hate towards muslim. They don't allow us Indians to be united.

    • @mayankindian3750
      @mayankindian3750 Год назад +53

      @@blackmoongaming9542 indians Kab United the bhaisahab

  • @AdityaSingh-ur3cq
    @AdityaSingh-ur3cq Год назад +272

    As a Indian conservative, this video is way to good , I watch both sides , both have their biases but I can see how much effort you put into having a fair both sided conversation, this is a great start to have people talk to each other of opposite and similar spectrum.

    • @infinix2003
      @infinix2003 Год назад

      Happy to hear this ❤

    • @kaushy
      @kaushy Год назад +1

      May I ask why you are one?

    • @vijaymishra4255
      @vijaymishra4255 Год назад +8

      ​@@kaushy you can watch this video again

    • @kunalsoni3329
      @kunalsoni3329 Год назад +3

      don't divide yourself into groups just because someone said it let it be liberal or conservative or any other, a person is a mix of all kinds of feelings and emotions and it varies over time and the walls between these groups should not be so thick as to one can't switch between them as per requirements, logic should be the only group and people should debate on it in a healthy manner so that everyone can learn

    • @bobfaam5215
      @bobfaam5215 Год назад

      @@kunalsoni3329 ​ Leftist are also patrotic in other countries except India . 😂
      For example , Chinese Communists are Very patriotic towards China .
      USSR Communist were also very patriotic towards USSR .
      Only Indian leftist are Anti India 😂😂

  • @arnabpbhattacharya
    @arnabpbhattacharya Год назад +5

    The depth of research is amazing. Really like how the video gets all the examples right, and gives a framework in the end to stitch things together.

  • @Creativemind7799
    @Creativemind7799 Год назад +458

    India's only youtuber is neutral. All youth should watch this video. Thanks to you people like you can show the right path to our society.

    • @jayantchaudhary6617
      @jayantchaudhary6617 Год назад +41

      Dhruv lathi 😂😂

    • @parth963
      @parth963 Год назад +6

      Bhai jab english nahi aati toh mat likh

    • @parth963
      @parth963 Год назад +2

      @@ripperh8 bhai mai right wing ka hi( jai shree ram) lekin vo english galat bol raha hai toh hindi mai he bol le

    • @HasanUnknown
      @HasanUnknown Год назад +3

      Islam is not 1400+ years old,
      Islam is the Oldest and First Religion,
      Islam means "Submitting our Will to God"
      Islam is their since First human (Prophet Adam)
      And Prophet Muhammad ﷺ is Not the Founder of Islam, Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was just a Last Prophet Of Islam !
      ---------------------
      “God is One and Only without second.”
      [Chandogya Upanishad 6:2:1]
      “He is Allah the One and Only.”
      [Quran 112:1]
      ---------------------
      “There is only One God, not the second”
      [Brahma Sutra]
      “There is only One Allah”
      [Quran 16:51]
      ---------------------
      “There is no image of Him.”
      [Yajurveda 32:3]
      “There is nothing like Him.”
      [Quran 42:11]
      ---------------------
      “There Is No Likeness Of Him”
      [Svetasvatara Upanishad 4:19]
      “And there is none Like unto Him.”
      [Quran 112:4]
      ---------------------
      “of Him there are no Parents"
      [Svetasvatara Upanishad 6:9]
      “He does not Beget nor is He Begotten.”
      [Quran 112:3]
      ---------------------
      “His form is not visible, the eyes cannot see Him.” [Svetasvatara Upanishad 4:20]
      “No vision can see Him, but He see’s all vision.” [Quran 6:103]
      ---------------------
      *[Reminder]*
      *Dear Hindus,*
      *You should worship only One God (Allah) and you must Stop doing Idol worshipping !*

    • @sammybosak10
      @sammybosak10 Год назад

      @@jayantchaudhary6617 Atleast he doesn't hide the fact he's liberal and makes fair point unlike so called centralist influencers who are basically hindutvadi in disguise( no Peepoy or abi and niyuu were harmed)

  • @pro_fessorJD
    @pro_fessorJD Год назад +269

    There is always a major difference between Liberals & Pseudo-Liberals. Be an intellectual not an a**hole. Thank you Mohak bhai for making this video.

    • @nandi7772
      @nandi7772 Год назад +1

      If you were an intellectual, you would have known that intelligence is not something that people can change by themselves.

    • @samprit5620
      @samprit5620 Год назад +7

      ​​@Mr X very easy , koi as a liberal agar very open to listen carefully every opinion and then try to counter opinion as per merit and donot straightaway dismiss other opinion is proper liberal.....
      Like ,mai Bengali Hindu Brahman hu aur nonveg khata hu aur apne aap ko liberal manta hu ....lekin agar mai kisi aur Hindu ko vegetarian hone kliye mazak udata hu ya insult karta hu to mai aur kuch bhi ho ek acha insaan k category me to bilkul nehi ata ....mera jo food, cloth or religious choices hai wo mera personal hai aur isliye mujhe dusre k personal choice ko insult nehi karna chahiye
      * again a Bengali written a paragraph here ,old habits bro😂😂😂

    • @samprit5620
      @samprit5620 Год назад +2

      @Mr X tab kya hi kar sakte hai bhai....waise logo ko aap nehi samjha sakte ,apna hi mood kharab hoga agar behes karne gaye to(waise bhi mera hazirjawabi utna acha nehi, arguments k baad ghar ake yaad ata hai ye kiu nhi bola 😂)

    • @jennyvarshavski3138
      @jennyvarshavski3138 Год назад +1

      @@samprit5620 Bengalis aise bada para likhte hai kya ??

    • @gamingwithxan1430
      @gamingwithxan1430 Год назад +1

      @@jennyvarshavski3138 nhi, zyada tar hote hai, lekin isse koi maine nhi rakhta ki wo dusro ki baat samjhe, kyunki attitude degree se nhi badalti, indirectly thora change aate hai, lekin puri nhi. During study, only sociological understanding se behtar hoti hai.

  • @nadeemafzal2138
    @nadeemafzal2138 Год назад +284

    We're given a thought process since childhood, by our parents, society. But some people always have curious mind, they can't stop themselves from knowing(or seeking). I'm also one of them. When I stopped calling myself as Muslim(at conscious level), people labelled me as an atheist, as I wasn't on the conclusion, I labelled myself as an Agnostic, Seeker etc.
    But when the level of my consciousness rose further, I came to know, all these words can't address me. I also realised that majority of the people who believe in God & people who disbelieve in God, are on the same boat, they are arguing about something which they do not know. If I do not admit that "I do not know, I destroy all the possibilities of knowing."
    And, I never make fun of anyone's knowledge which which they have acquired through self-experience, self-introspection, spiritual practices etc. I've been only against social evils, bigotry, religious fascism etc.

    • @FairozMohammedd
      @FairozMohammedd Год назад +25

      Exactly. I thought I’m alone here with a muslim name.

    • @Myanmartiger921
      @Myanmartiger921 Год назад +6

      Jiadism. Mullahism

    • @vegetal8460
      @vegetal8460 Год назад

      ​@@FairozMohammedd I've heard ur parents may kill u if u believe in rationalism and atheism

    • @FairozMohammedd
      @FairozMohammedd Год назад +11

      @@vegetal8460 Not actually. There could be people with sick mindset or so deep in their belief. But you can find such minds in every religion. I know in Islam and Judaism its high compared others. But hey! the Time will bring change one day. All these religions will vanish.

    • @anujrbx
      @anujrbx Год назад +26

      @@FairozMohammedd the problem is we dont know whether the snakes are from our country or from pakistan and other regions....whenever certain indian muslim wants to express some secular thing or moderate thoughts....10 people from same community come to declare him non muslim......for being a moderate muslim ......or not having extreme thinking....same is happening with hindu community...where u cannot be moderate......

  • @sahithiireddy3561
    @sahithiireddy3561 Месяц назад +2

    bro among other youtubers who are either left or right wing you are a true centrist and a gem whose opinions dont change for the sake of views, keep up the good work and please make more videos regarding politics .
    jai hind

  • @SreeraagMohan
    @SreeraagMohan Год назад +18

    This is such a well made video. Thank you, Mohak & Team Soch!

  • @Joshua_2684
    @Joshua_2684 Год назад +632

    People like him are constantly trying to develop the mindset of people in INDIA 🇮🇳. Respect to SOCH team.

    • @ScrollwithJJ999
      @ScrollwithJJ999 Год назад +16

      The Internet makes people's dumb because whom they follow they made Their Opinion after watching their favourites . They support them without Thinking Right or wrong.
      Mine fav is virat kohli but Virat promotes Royal challengers. Thats my point if we are not fully Perfect how we think that your fav is best opinion his not wrong sometime it's human nature.
      don't believe someone on the internet
      Blindly.think about Something don't be dumb.
      Every Coin has 2 sides you have to choose one by No. Of benefits .
      I am saying that make your own Opinion 🫰. Not everyone's problems are the same so make best self Solution

    • @bhadwamuhammad979
      @bhadwamuhammad979 Год назад

      Modi govt gave more subsidies to chuslims than Congress era.
      Reservation to kill upper caste continues.

    • @mohammadgandhumcbc8478
      @mohammadgandhumcbc8478 Год назад +2

      🙏✝️🕊❤️

    • @tmy3411
      @tmy3411 Год назад

      ​@@ScrollwithJJ999 The bitter truth is people are dumb on average so expecting them to come up with profound opinions is day dreaming. No one would start thinking more because you said so... I think you said that because you want people to be skeptical of SOCH?! If yes, then why not be straight.

    • @a4ya294
      @a4ya294 Год назад +1

      Lol he isn't an indian

  • @prakhyathdb9314
    @prakhyathdb9314 Год назад +82

    I thank you from bottom of my heart for making this video bcz of many extreme political videos i was loosing hope,it gave me headache and i started feeling that i should leave my country
    Then i took a step back and thought myself how to be centrist now i know the most video's on youtube always show the extreme case of both sides (right and left)
    We need this type of video and hope everyone understand what you are trying to say
    Thank you again for making this video 🙏

    • @shock-t3768
      @shock-t3768 Год назад +1

      centrist OP

    • @shubhiupadhyay8349
      @shubhiupadhyay8349 Год назад +3

      Then why don't u leave 🙄
      And please bahar ja kar phir humne gyan Matt dena k humne humari country kaise run karni h

    • @shubhiupadhyay8349
      @shubhiupadhyay8349 Год назад +4

      @@shock-t3768 in real life no one is centrist you just choose that tag because u don't wanna associate with any one
      Rest u always have a libral or conservative ideology
      I am a libral hindu but won't call myself one because I don't wanna associate with so called librandus of my country
      I would like to be associated with conservatives then our librandus

    • @silenceplease2022
      @silenceplease2022 Год назад

      Modi and RSS hates liberty. They are Manusmriti promoters
      How can any liberal promote such enemies of liberty and freedom?

    • @silenceplease2022
      @silenceplease2022 Год назад +3

      @@shubhiupadhyay8349 yes people like you stood by the burning corpse of their grannies during Sati Pratha knowing that it is wrong

  • @ShivamKumar-ww6vh
    @ShivamKumar-ww6vh Год назад +142

    Totally agree with you mohak
    I used to think I am liberal till I realized it depends on issue
    For some issues you can be liberal while for other issues you can have conservative views
    As it's not always black & white
    So ya now I feel myself a centrist
    Thanks for this amazing video

    • @sajidms7976
      @sajidms7976 Год назад +3

      100%

    • @ShubhamMishrabro
      @ShubhamMishrabro Год назад +12

      Most people have mixed ideology. I used to believe in stupid political compass.

  • @khushavarora9347
    @khushavarora9347 Год назад +27

    very well thought video sir. Proud of you! Really needed someone to speak up on this

  • @illusion8340
    @illusion8340 Год назад +1039

    Now liberals:- Modi should be removed to maintain peace, secularism and democracy
    Liberals after YOGI :- we will go for fasting if Modi is not retained.😂😂( Wo to devta Aadmi tha re )😂

    • @gar-
      @gar- Год назад +195

      lol so true, if only yogi becomes pm, ahh it would be a dream to watch all the liberals and leftists crying together, and i am a jain, still yogi to yogi hai baba

    • @gamersgamingz1302
      @gamersgamingz1302 Год назад +8

      Yes ❤️❤️❤️🙏🏽

    • @prathmeshbankar
      @prathmeshbankar Год назад +102

      ​@@gar- if u want Yogi to be elected Only to see leftist and liberals cry then sorry to say but u are actually becoming an extremist 😬😬 if u want to vote someone vote because of their work not because of hatred towards some people.
      (Edited) 👇👇👇
      Arrey thoda dimaag lagao mai ye nahi bol raha hu ki Yogi ne kaam nahi kiya 🤦🤦 mai bol raha hu ki hate shouldn't be the reason to vote for someone. Yogi ne kya kaam kiya aur kya nahi Kiya iske basis pe khud decide karke vote do hate ke vajah se vote mat do

    • @doggee09
      @doggee09 Год назад +1

      😂😂

    • @doggee09
      @doggee09 Год назад +12

      @@gar- liberal meltdown

  • @RudeComedian
    @RudeComedian Год назад +7

    Hell of a good job my friend. You have an Incredible ability to share unbiased information to the masses.
    And I couldn’t agree more with you.
    You got another subscriber 👍

  • @mayulmanav3720
    @mayulmanav3720 Год назад +36

    This is by far, the most value adding video I have ever come across on RUclips. I really wish Departments of Political Sciences across Universities in India include this in their modules & not just fetishize over Western writers. The youth of this country needs more of coverages such as this one, for them to actually be able to relate, resonate & reflect upon. Great, great, great job --- keep this up!

  • @-SimonRiley
    @-SimonRiley Год назад +603

    He's only practicing his own religion, there's nothing wrong with it. Secularism was never about supporting every religion, it was always about viewing all religions as equal.
    I like to eat Chocolate ice cream because that's what my father introduced to me first and I've been loving it ever since, does that mean I hate Strawberry and Vanilla flavors? I believe no

    • @zodiacsama7693
      @zodiacsama7693 Год назад +32

      It's always about keeping state and religion separate.

    • @nknkannadiga9742
      @nknkannadiga9742 Год назад +87

      @@zodiacsama7693 that is French type of secularism. Indian secularism is different

    • @bloodwargaming3662
      @bloodwargaming3662 Год назад +2

      ​@@nknkannadiga9742 no secularism is on that basis only

    • @agastyashrivastava9266
      @agastyashrivastava9266 Год назад +2

      Exactly

    • @avikmandal8578
      @avikmandal8578 Год назад +46

      Exactly, even I don't support BJP, but what's wrong if the PM did Bhumi Pujan? Hey is a Hindu, and an important persons, so he was invited to do it. Just like Nehru was a Hindu hence he performed those said in the beginning of the video. Secularism just means practice your religion without disrespecting any other religion, and do not force your religion on others. Neither Modi nor Nehru violated any of these, so it should not be a problem.

  • @AnandMister
    @AnandMister Год назад +16

    One of the best videos you can find on RUclips for the given context. Really thoroughly thought out and written. Excellent!

  • @namman6190
    @namman6190 7 месяцев назад +1

    Thanks

  • @ShasankShekhar
    @ShasankShekhar Год назад +32

    Such a complex topic explained in so simple words
    Great content
    Highly appreciated

  • @HarshalDev
    @HarshalDev Год назад +100

    Hands down one of the best videos of Mohak Mangal. Absolutely love the "money experiment" example you gave ❤

    • @anuraghegde1
      @anuraghegde1 Год назад

      That's the concept of tax explained in simple terms, in a utopian setting of course

    • @abishekraju4521
      @abishekraju4521 Год назад

      @@anuraghegde1 Before y'all make another financial marketing scam thread here, lemme make this comment so that it messes with the flow.

  • @swetarani8375
    @swetarani8375 Год назад +750

    This is such a mind opening video... Sometimes even we liberals forgot what we were fighting for in the first place... We blindly oppose the right wind ideology without even trying to understand their perspective.. Thankuuu so much for making such intuitive video🤓⚡

    • @TheB657
      @TheB657 Год назад +42

      The issue is not understanding the terms of "liberal" and "secular" . Those who call themselves liberals among politicians are power hungry people and therefore *non - liberals and autocrats* . The word "secular" refers to *non - adherence to any religion or non - attachment to any faith or belief system.* It definitely doesn't mean being 'equal' to all religion whereas it is a term for 'rejection of religion' . Unfortunate that colonial inputs still stay as reserve memory within the Indian academia and common day to day usage. It is a very dangerous weapon Brits. have left behind. This is why there is hardly any patriotism among Indians whom love anything foreign. Our people are such that even if an item is from Uzbekistan they will take it but if it is from India, their heads will hang in shame and disgust. Wah colonials wah ! 👏👏👏 For some things we do have to admire those brutes however we can't keep throwing all blame on them too in regards to the connection of Indians to their roots and culture and civilization since it has been 76 years they left our shores. Great that you are reflecting.

    • @chandrabhushan8597
      @chandrabhushan8597 Год назад

      There is no right wing ideology party in India.

    • @CRuS4D3R88
      @CRuS4D3R88 Год назад

      Indian Liberals are ENTITLED far Left hypocrites/cultural marxists who believe in cancel culture. They want to speak ON BEHALF OF people and they adopt STRATEGIC SILENCE when It comes to criticising M0ozL1Imz and non BJP state government's. Social media has ensured that their hold on information is finished. They r extremely anti Hindu

    • @4cscript743
      @4cscript743 Год назад +4

      ​@@TheB657 you are right governor but then this is a typical thought process in the so-called nationalist circle in new India. Conservatives and Liberals are alike since they can't be flexible today

    • @gk6962
      @gk6962 Год назад

      Hi

  • @akashdubey6650
    @akashdubey6650 5 месяцев назад +2

    An eye opening video Mohak bhai

  • @Rawani201
    @Rawani201 Год назад +488

    Liberal always defend Muslim
    And always criticized hindu, hinduism 🕉️🧐🧐

    • @aayushdalal3771
      @aayushdalal3771 Год назад +2

      They are not liberal , but clowns

    • @Marutheesh_1718
      @Marutheesh_1718 Год назад +77

      wo to joker log hai 😐

    • @deeptanshubhowmik5073
      @deeptanshubhowmik5073 Год назад

      liberals criticize what is wrong and support what is right

    • @tharabhai1794
      @tharabhai1794 Год назад

      They are not real liberals
      And what can you expect from converted people
      Who just wanna copy emmanuel macron(original liberal)

    • @greenkingdom285
      @greenkingdom285 Год назад

      In the Bangladesh - liberal always defend and promote hinduism and Hindu culture and always criticize islam and muslim tradition. 😠🤬

  • @amisaxena4408
    @amisaxena4408 Год назад +244

    I love this guy , I love this channel , it is so hard to find a centrist view in Indian media anywhere and I am grateful that this channel exists.

    • @14debanjan
      @14debanjan Год назад +10

      Does Mohak claim to be a centrist ? I don't think he is. He is a rationalist

    • @ashusaharan5770
      @ashusaharan5770 Год назад

      @@14debanjan no he is leftist

    • @theeducator8574
      @theeducator8574 Год назад +2

      @@14debanjan maybe true
      But he is not an extremist

    • @challenger539
      @challenger539 Год назад

      @@14debanjan every true rationalist is a centrist.

    • @gabbar51ngh
      @gabbar51ngh Год назад +11

      He's centre left not centrist. There's always a soft left bias in his videos.

  • @hanishkaisrani8844
    @hanishkaisrani8844 Год назад +11

    Very well put together! This is one of your best videos in my view. A much needed one as well

  • @vortex659
    @vortex659 10 месяцев назад

    Thanks!

    • @sachinpanwar8649
      @sachinpanwar8649 10 месяцев назад +1

      mujhe vi dede vro ek dollor🙃🤌

  • @MayankCodes
    @MayankCodes Год назад +444

    I try to be a centrist who thinks logically, rationally and then form an opinion on something but the liberals make me support BJP and Modi. This is the case with most of the people who try to form an opinion by using their own mind. When you counter liberals, they have only one argument "Andhbhakt".

    • @xyzguesswho9537
      @xyzguesswho9537 Год назад +55

      Then ur countering pro congress supporters not liberals....Being anti BJP isnt liberal sir !

    • @_Final_Boss
      @_Final_Boss Год назад +2

      Agree

    • @ex.gamer2333
      @ex.gamer2333 Год назад +37

      @@c4pt4ina69 there are stupid people on both side
      just ignore them and debate with a right person

    • @MohanYadav-vc8cq
      @MohanYadav-vc8cq Год назад +14

      @@c4pt4ina69 Dinner ban gaya hoga. Khaana khaalo debate toh hota rahega

    • @mdazeem2114
      @mdazeem2114 Год назад +8

      I think you are a bhakt, I don’t think any fair liberal will call you andhbhakt unnecessarily. I can sense that, you are trying to justify your andhbhakti by defaming liberals. If they are wrong then you are wrong too. It’s like saying, I am not a terrorist but other terrorists are making me terrorist.

  • @khwahish9888
    @khwahish9888 Год назад +211

    We need more youth like him and his whole team in this country

    • @Unknownsscacian
      @Unknownsscacian Год назад +18

      Fun fact:- he doesn't live in india

    • @augu345
      @augu345 Год назад +3

      Why can't you be that youth

    • @khwahish9888
      @khwahish9888 Год назад +1

      @@augu345 I am trying to be

    • @khwahish9888
      @khwahish9888 Год назад +6

      @@Unknownsscacian I never said he lives in India ,and it doesn't matter he live here or somewhere else but we need more people like him who make their opinions based on facts

    • @MusTelOJ
      @MusTelOJ Год назад +1

      @@Unknownsscacian he doesn't lives in india for his studies

  • @Uhbfgjokk
    @Uhbfgjokk Год назад +150

    You've my respect , man!! This video deserves a standing ovation 💜💜

  • @piyushbhatt6882
    @piyushbhatt6882 Год назад +4

    That's what being neutral is like, I appreciate it bro, keep it up we are following you, we need more people like u! Others seems to be politically motivated it gets us off.

  • @Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi
    @Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi Год назад +382

    Never thought the word "Liberal" would be associated with a curse in today's India. Their hatred towards BJP has made them loose all their objectives.

    • @Vizorfam
      @Vizorfam Год назад +16

      If you are not hating bjp it means something is wrong with you can't you see the destruction this party has caused

    • @Abk367
      @Abk367 Год назад +26

      No its actually the other way around .it's BJP that has turned liberal into a curse world .Bjp is afterall an offshoot of the RSS and it has close ties with the Sangh parivar. I would advice you to read what the founders of RSS wanted for india.That will make it very easy for you to understand why liberals have a strong dislike of RSS and its offshoots

    • @Vizorfam
      @Vizorfam Год назад

      @@shayanraj7840 oh yeah how great your religion is please teach me more about it

    • @ubiquitous866
      @ubiquitous866 Год назад

      ​@@shayanraj7840 The only reason liberals hate BJP is becuz they talk about Radical Islam but support radical hindu organizations like Bajrang Dal, hindutva, etc

    • @sayanbose4931
      @sayanbose4931 Год назад +31

      @@Abk367 Ah yes, read 100 year old ideas of an organisation and use that to judge the actions of their current offshoots. RSS chief himself is pretty accepting of muslims nowadays. Judge on merit! Not on you imaginary shades of black and white!

  • @iuhere
    @iuhere Год назад +26

    great explanation, again the topic can be digressed into many other subsets but the way you and your team has compiled it is worth acknowledgement. Great job! Good luck for next one!

  • @beelikepro
    @beelikepro Год назад +134

    I consider myself as a Conservative, but I watch your videos because it gives other side of the place. It opens my mind, but my friends who consider liberal doesn't even consider reading/listening to other side for better understanding of the thought process. It's shame it's happening, but I hope it's happen through your videos.❤

    • @bornconfuced.5403
      @bornconfuced.5403 Год назад

      Your views on Manipur?

    • @beelikepro
      @beelikepro Год назад +12

      @@bornconfuced.5403
      Ethnic violence caused by the unscrupulous Verdict by State High court on reservations in the state. The violence should be condemned by every Indian.
      What about your views on Manipur ?

    • @bornconfuced.5403
      @bornconfuced.5403 Год назад +2

      @@beelikepro my views are simple if the guy who takes credit when anything good happens in his state the cm should also take the blame and resign and there should be a president rule by now the women supporters and his resignation letter was a act like many of the debaters on national tv runs 9pm shows and pm should have been there for atleast a week after 100 days he still talked about it for 5 min don't give me that crap he is doing he don't need to address everything he is we are in democracy he is answerable to us he could have stopped it if he wanted I am not that guy who's gona say ya it was all BJP's fault the roots were planted in congress rule but they are not ruling right now when they ruled we blamed them in 2017 and 2015 the ruler is responsible but bjp be like bangal mai kya ho raha hai ye sab congress ki vajah se hai it won't happen in 2 days it will take 1 or 2 weeks but not 100 days and if he bjp would have done that i would have been on BJP's side on west bangal and rajasthan issue I'm still want these to get sort out but first priority is Manipur for me. And the responsibility should have been taken by pm by now but anyway if you don't have an open mind there is no use of debate. I have the same reservation about the Indira Gandhi era she had the same power as Narendra Modi and I want democracy and people to live in peace and prosperity

    • @beelikepro
      @beelikepro Год назад +2

      @@bornconfuced.5403
      You know what, I agree with most of our points. As most of the state assembly sessions are happening, I bet Manipur's state assembly sessions are also started. The CM should make stance on violence and if opposition doesn't believe him, there's should be no-confidence motion brought to the table by them. I don't believe in using article 356 against any elected government in this country, unless they don't co-operate with courts and union government. As a commission is formed under the leadership of former supreme court judge, the truth will be laid out in state assembly and parliament.

    • @bornconfuced.5403
      @bornconfuced.5403 Год назад

      @beelikepro the reason he is not resigned yet coz he knows he has the numbers that's my point the president rule should be implemented when the state government is unable to sustain governance for more than considerate time and I think 100 days which is fair enough to apply governor rule and if that would have happened in non bjp state it would have been atleast 2 months of governor rule by now and they bjp is busy in Delhi's power struggle and shifting the blame and about court yup they want to control the court too first time cgi started questioning them they don't want him in election commission of India so yup I was supporting them in 2014 wanted them to be in power but after watching them for 9 years they are doing the same thing which Indira Gandhi did killing democracy and divide and rule tactics which many political leaders did in past

  • @NotesOfArun
    @NotesOfArun Год назад +1

    Arguably the best RUclips video I have ever watched. I don't comment on videos but here I was obliged to comment. I watch a lot of RUclips and this is one of the most important videos ever. No rhetoric, fact & science based deduction.

  • @mahipparekh2167
    @mahipparekh2167 Год назад +11

    Understood each and every line you said Mokak. The idea of understanding other's mind or ideology really makes this a great video !

  • @shouryapratapsingh7802
    @shouryapratapsingh7802 Год назад +468

    Brother, I am in class 12 and my classmates have formed groups based on which political parties they support and based on religions.......I find you way of expressing and way of thinking very inspiring.....I've been watching your videos ever since class 10 I guess....and you have taught me a lot thanks for everything ❤️❤️❤️

    • @-__________abhinavtariyal_5999
      @-__________abhinavtariyal_5999 Год назад +13

      अंधभक्ति इन क्लास😱

    • @ackshayshukla
      @ackshayshukla Год назад

      ​@@-__________abhinavtariyal_5999says a lot about you, not the OP.

    • @amsa1076
      @amsa1076 Год назад +14

      That's really sad.

    • @manusharma7487
      @manusharma7487 Год назад +19

      @shouryapratapsingh7802 bro, stay alert and consume good quality content. Stay focused on your personal growth because you meet many who just want to pull you in stupid debates and bad things. Good luck for your future and hope you achieve what you deserve and live a beautiful life.

    • @amsa1076
      @amsa1076 Год назад +28

      @Black White what? I have friends who politically disagree with me. But at the end of the day we are still friends cos we don't let political opinions divide us.

  • @YagamiLight69696
    @YagamiLight69696 Год назад +67

    I rate this video higher then any dhruv rathee political video

    • @anuragnathyal5889
      @anuragnathyal5889 Год назад

      Dhruv Rathee is basically leftist trying to cover himself as liberal.
      I don't call such people liberal.

    • @lonewolfp8802
      @lonewolfp8802 Год назад

      Dhruv Rathee is true liberal and atheist who don't believe in any god except Allah

    • @Lichenroc
      @Lichenroc Год назад

      Because Mohak says what you want to hear.

    • @Lichenroc
      @Lichenroc Год назад

      @Vishal Autade True so there is none who are truly unbiased now is there

  • @livelovelaugh3250
    @livelovelaugh3250 6 месяцев назад +2

    I loved this video and your neutralism towards issues.Loved this

  • @rohsindia
    @rohsindia Год назад +68

    This is probably the first time I am seeing a RUclipsr covering both angles in such detail. Good work mate!

    • @KrishnaVamshi111.
      @KrishnaVamshi111. Год назад

      @Z3U5 according to some people terrorism is a good thing. There are different reasons for them to support terrorism like America is destroying houses for common people in Afghanistan, and another one is people in Jammu and Kashmir are being tortured by Indian government and they think terrorism is fair.

    • @Gen_7979
      @Gen_7979 Год назад

      ​@Z3U5 They are terrorist not conservative... if you comparing isis with BJP, i can compare indian liberal and leftists to Marxist to... But this is not right.

    • @rohsindia
      @rohsindia Год назад

      @Z3U5 you need law and order for those who conduct and preach violence. Politicians are a representation of the people. Get your basic facts right first.

    • @rohsindia
      @rohsindia Год назад

      @@KrishnaVamshi111. terrorism is not good for anyone you fool. It might work for those with poor interpersonal or logical skills. Because they don’t have arguments to prove the other wrong. You missed the point of the whole video. Lol

    • @KrishnaVamshi111.
      @KrishnaVamshi111. Год назад

      @@rohsindia iam not muslim and I don't fuckin support the ideology of terrorism

  • @monalpatel2009
    @monalpatel2009 Год назад +19

    You have my respect Mangal. Your videos are consistently giving unbiased opinions on every topic you decide to talk about. I hope more people can be like you.

  • @sarthakpandey2870
    @sarthakpandey2870 Год назад +17

    I really admire you Mohak. This is top quality content.

  • @rahulsasmal7644
    @rahulsasmal7644 Год назад +704

    This man always states facts and stays neutral in his stance. Love your videos 👍🏼

    • @bbaworld4942
      @bbaworld4942 Год назад +18

      What a joke.

    • @rahulsasmal7644
      @rahulsasmal7644 Год назад +54

      @@bbaworld4942 for andh liberals and andh bhakts it is a joke...

    • @aftabahmed-_-
      @aftabahmed-_- Год назад +4

      Spammer..

    • @deku006
      @deku006 Год назад +41

      He does get biased sometimes but it's not with any intentions (more of a script thing)
      But overall he is one of the most neutral guy farr better than Dhruv 😂

    • @Vizorfam
      @Vizorfam Год назад

      @@deku006 that is the problem with sanghis like you , can't face the truth which dhruv tells?

  • @shrihari6860
    @shrihari6860 5 месяцев назад +4

    Liberal:We want every opinion to exist in this country...
    Also Liberal:We don't want Right wing opinion to exist in this country 😂😂😂

  • @pankajkalra4694
    @pankajkalra4694 Год назад +63

    Loved it
    Gives a totally new perspective to liberals in India🇮🇳

    • @soup_bois
      @soup_bois Год назад +2

      It's the Right that needs a broader perspective. Rahul and Co. are clear. that RSS and company are fascists.

    • @devesh9378
      @devesh9378 Год назад +2

      Brother, now you only tell !! We watched this video ...liberals jinke liye ye video banni hai , wo toh dekhenge hi nahi ... unme comparatively come patience hota hai ...

    • @devesh9378
      @devesh9378 Год назад +2

      ​@@soup_bois can u pls simplify it ?

    • @SShreyas17
      @SShreyas17 Год назад

      @@devesh9378 Kam patience? Let's have a discussion on the core difference between a conservative and a liberal, i.e, religion and see who loses their cool head first. What say?

    • @krisskross6074
      @krisskross6074 Год назад

      @@soup_bois Thanks for proving the point of this video. It talks about people like you.

  • @sarthakdas2365
    @sarthakdas2365 Год назад +17

    Everbody either a left , right or centrist person should share this video in there family/friends group. In my opion this tells how not get polarised and not be opinionated just because one follows a typical mind set be it left or right. Great work Mohak sir. Much need topic to be discussed

  • @Dr.Doodle_exchange
    @Dr.Doodle_exchange Год назад +732

    There is a reason why Mohak makes genuine videos.
    1.He understands the importance of psychology.
    2.Empathy

    • @DevanshMatha
      @DevanshMatha Год назад +8

      bakwaas mt kar kuch funny bol

    • @yo5251
      @yo5251 Год назад

      Nhi isne bhi Libral ka chata hai libarl o ka chat chat ke carrier bna liya 😏

    • @egomaniac1209
      @egomaniac1209 Год назад +14

      People severely underestimate the importance of empathy in today's world

    • @abhishekdarjee7069
      @abhishekdarjee7069 Год назад

      @@egomaniac1209 agree

    • @WizShivam
      @WizShivam Год назад +9

      @@DevanshMatha why are why you here . Jab funny hi dekhna hai to jake comedy video dekh

  • @hritwikchakraborty5602
    @hritwikchakraborty5602 6 месяцев назад +1

    Mohak, this is one of the best videos on this topic. Absolutely superb work. ❤

  • @IdrisHajee
    @IdrisHajee Год назад +11

    This has been one of your best videos so far! Keep up the great work!

  • @Mystic2203
    @Mystic2203 Год назад +85

    Criticizing anyone for following their religion and belief is very wrong
    Modi ji should be allowed to do whatever he wants to do about his belief but nowadays people are abusing liberal mindset people which is also not right
    India is a secular country and politicians will try to divide and rule over us , we need to get over non important issues like religion and caste and focus on real issues like education, infrastructure, Crop prices , jobs and environment
    Fighting over religion and caste is the only thing that is stopping our proud India from reaching it's full potential

    • @fenrir834
      @fenrir834 Год назад +7

      critisizising Hindus for discriminating against dalits is wrong? Critisizing muslims for killing blsphemers is wrong? they all are just following there religion

    • @SresthaChakraborty
      @SresthaChakraborty Год назад +19

      ​@@fenrir834 these things are not mentioned in any religious books ..

    • @Mystic2203
      @Mystic2203 Год назад +10

      ​​@@fenrir834 Those things are unacceptable but I don't see that happening in mass population nowadays and if it's an issue of a particular area then it should be solved immediately but fighting over such issues throughout the year is not good for development
      The most important thing for the development of our country is education and jobs
      Uneducated people or Jobless people are the easiest to manipulate for communal violence
      People with jobs will never care about such issues
      Mature people with jobs understand what is important for the development of our country
      Please try to understand that I don't hate anyone and discrimination should not be allowed ,I just want my country to focus on important issues , develop and become the real greatest nation in the world

    • @zodiacsama7693
      @zodiacsama7693 Год назад +1

      @@Mystic2203 Your faith is good unless it start interfering with the values of democracy and constitution.

    • @fenrir834
      @fenrir834 Год назад +2

      @@Mystic2203 i agree whith you moslty, but i feel religion is just a set of beliefs, and if you can have the freedom to have those beliefs and preach them, others who hold the belief that those religious beliefs are wrong ought to have the right to critisize

  • @CreativitySimplicity
    @CreativitySimplicity Год назад +43

    This was a much needed video. People are not differentiating between anti-govt and liberalism.

  • @ashutosh3206
    @ashutosh3206 Год назад

    Perfect Video. I never expected from any youtube channel. Thanks for taking it up.

  • @nikhilraj6277
    @nikhilraj6277 Год назад +63

    We really need people like you who can criticise both BJP and Congress
    Our Country should be our priority not any party or leader

  • @bhuvangaur
    @bhuvangaur Год назад +17

    Hey Mohak, this was really insightful and in perspective can help provide viewers with a different approach to current Indian society. Thank you for creating this.

  • @awesome9k
    @awesome9k Год назад +1

    Methinks you should run my man. Loving your content.

  • @ravs3788
    @ravs3788 Год назад +174

    THANKS FOR PUTTING THIS VIDEO OUT for PEOPLE LIKE ME!
    DON'T NEED TO EXPLAIN MY STAND FOR INDIA WHEN I SUPPORT A DECISION OR WHEN I'M AGAINST IT.
    AS A CITIZEN OF MY BELOVED COUNTRY I WILL ALWAYS CHOOSE TO FAVOUR ANY POLICY/DECISION WHICH IS IMPORTANT FOR ITS LONG TERM DEVELOPMENT PLAN!
    PERIOD. 🙏🏼

    • @CrikYash
      @CrikYash Год назад +3

      Liberal how ?
      :- how listen carefully Right vig & Left vig and give Neutral opinion 😎

    • @june3775
      @june3775 Год назад +1

      bhai shaant hoja

    • @shock-t3768
      @shock-t3768 Год назад +3

      I am with you bro. We are very few who have a brain.

    • @silenceplease2022
      @silenceplease2022 Год назад

      Modi is a RSS commander
      He will never be my PM. Congrats to those andhbhakts who think he is Indian PM.

    • @gurjotsingh838
      @gurjotsingh838 Год назад

      WHY ARE YOU TYPING THIS IN ALL CAPITALS?! ARE YOU YELLING WHILE TYPING THIS?!

  • @flyeagle320
    @flyeagle320 Год назад +10

    Most balanced video ever seen on your channel . Thank you Mohak 😀

  • @bhushanborse4256
    @bhushanborse4256 Год назад +16

    I was subscriber mohak mangal since 2020, his video qualities increasing day by day, sound effects giving more enhanced experience to watch video. Most important thing is that many things are very critical to think & present infront of people, without harassing someone's belief & without manipulating the message what need to deliver to peoples. I think this is big achievement of this channel. Congrants for all team. We are eager to see more content like this in upcoming videos.

  • @kindofanmol
    @kindofanmol Год назад +12

    *EXCELLENT* video. Hats off to you for being so objective with your opinions. Takes real guts to be this unbiased.

  • @kaustabhmishra938
    @kaustabhmishra938 Год назад +71

    You don't know how happy and satisfied after watching this video, it's truly the most related mindset and a big problem in India, love this video 💙✨

  • @tejas50909
    @tejas50909 9 месяцев назад +1

    What an explaination... One of the best video ever watched on YT