Why Switch From Java To Bedrock?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
- Just explaining that bedrock vs java is not a one sided issue, and bedrock does have a lot of advantages - that you should know about
Minecraft Bedrock is the same as Minecraft Windows 10, Minecraft Pocket Edition; or Minecraft Xbox / Minecraft Switch
- Think you've missed something? You might have, and you can check my most recent uploads here: / ibxtoycat
Update Adventures (My Let's Play):
• Update Adventures Let’...
- My Twitter: / ibxtoycat
- Follow for video updates and Early News!
You can become a channel member by clicking here:
/ @toycat
Looking forward to the hordes of comments based on the title and not the video.
More seriously, I think debate about which platform you prefer and why is interesting and useful, but if you insist anything is objectively worse than anything else that is enjoyed by millions of people, maybe you haven't thought your point out enough
I agree
Btw i like mods so it's a no for me
Even after watching the video still didn’t make me want to switch.
Java just has a lot more things that I like about it.
Some things objectively worse than other things
jAvA iS bEtTeR aNd Im NoT gOiNg To LiStEn To ReAsOnEd ArGuMeNtS.
Imagine you being a java player playing bedwars on a bedrock server and see someone bridging at sprinting speed to your base
"OMG HAXXXX REPORT!!!!!" lol
HAÀAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAX
OMG SCAFFOLD HAX!!
"HACKINGGGGGGGGG"
And jumped to XD
Are we just gonna ignore the fact that you have built a massive stone wall for no foreseeable reason?
Yep
It’s not as good as world edit but it works
Yes.
We don’t question it
To keep the Illagers out
I’m seeing points from both sides. Never thought I would see the day
Only 3 like
5 is enough
E
I have both of em
Disabafating, I'm sick of you! You only comment on as many videos as you can because you know you're going to get likes from it, because you've been verified!
I love how in bedrock it looks like the world curves so it looks like an earth.
@King Caravan Yes its a cool feature in a superflat world.
"an earth"
It does that in Java too
@@mcmobactivist4624 ?
@@that_swiftie13 it's a spelling mistake, there is no such thing as another earth, it's just "the earth" no "an earth". The world only have 1 earth.
The answer for most people is "yeah, my friend has bedrock."
Lil Squidward litterally the only reason i play bedrock
@@samhemmen7012 same and because the old console version isnt being Supported anymore
Nasa531 Blöb yeah fr
Same lol that's why I have both versions
would like but cant because *nice*
Like a wise Mumbo Jumbo once said:
2 + 2 = 4... or sometimes 5 on Bedrock Edition.
Adipose a quote I’ll never forget
True. I tried making some contraptions on Bedrock that work on Java and when you press the button, the game will decide if it works or not. Do you know the famous secret piston door that is flush with the walls? Well, it doesn't work on Bedrock. At least when I first tried it.
@@gigaphoton376 theres a few modifications u need to make bcuz some java redstone only works because of bugs
@@drakeweddner Yes, but it is a fact that when you send a direct redstone signal to a piston, a piston underneath it should also activate. That either doesn't work on Bedrock, or doesn't work on the Nintendo Switch. If it's a problem of the Nintendo Switch version, then crossplay shouldn't be possible since it means the game works differently on different versions. If it's a Bedrock problem, then it means a mechanic existing since the existance of redstone is STILL to be added onto this version. There is also the fact that the pistons' texture is glitched. Sure, most of the redstone components work fine, but many times what happens is inconsistent, and redstone isn't supposed to be unpredictable, besides what items go out of dispensers and droppers. You can see what I mean in the video Mumbo Jumbo made about his Love Hate relationship with the Bedrock edition of the game. I still enjoy the Bedrock edition of the game and know that redstone is an optional part of the game, but there is a huge community revolving around redstone and people every day wishing to learn redstone and being limited by this kind of bugs, since they can't get Java or currently play it, and pistons are by far one of the most important redstone components in the game. I don't care about quasi connectivity, but people that want to do something more complex than a hidden crafting table, or something, deserve to have CONSISTENT redstone. That is a problem.
@@gigaphoton376 ehhh idk about that let's say you had a bedrock version that was 1.12.10 beta you could still play with other people with the regular version of just 1.12 so uh the versions thing is kinda weird in bedrock
5:13 calling Java a "very archaic" language, ignoring the fact that C++ is 10 years older than Java
But not for gaming
Just opinion, every one has different opinions
@@CruzeeStar it's not really an opinion though, it's just fact that C++ is older than Java and saying otherwise is just incorrect???
Yes but the way Java operates is very archaic compared to C++. C++ translates in machine code which can be read directly by the processor, leading to much high performance. On the other hand, Java translates into a language which must be read by the JRE during runtime, leading to decrease in performance. C++ has been extremely optimised. Direct, optimised machine code will always be less archaic than Java.
To add onto this, C++ handles large arrays and array iteration better than Java. This is because Java has safety measures to check whether an accessed location is safe. Those two factors are very important when graphics are involved, which is why C++ is better than Java for games.
Why I prefer Java:
- Better off-hand (torches, blocks, food, etc.)
- Better Mods (both Forge and Fabric)
- Optifine and Shaders (Bedrock may have RTX now, but not everyone can use that, plus Optifine massively improves performance to levels higher than Bedrock (I'm talking 300+fps on a 7-year-old graphics card))
- No MTs (everything is free- maps, skins, mods, etc.)
- Total skin customization (less of an issue on the Win10 version of Bedrock, but a major issue on console/mobile versions).
- Better Redstone (Things like quasi-connectivity, plus the more simple nature meaning some cross-compatable machines between Java and Bedrock have vastly different sizes (Java machines always tend to be smaller than bedrock ones, or just unable to be made at all in Bedrock))
- Hardcore. Mode.
- There are shaders on bedrock
- maps, mods can be downloaded for free the same way as java, and its way easier
- Win10 has more customizable skins with 4d skins and stuff
I do think that java is a better game and I respect your opinion. Just stating my points
@@UnstablePotato he literally said that in his comment
And Java has a paused function. :D
optifine dont give you 300+ fps, thats sodium
@@y3flamex250 well on older java versions it does xD But that doesn't really count
Ok, as a software developer, Java as a language being called archaic in comparison to C++ kinda left me hanging.
That statement hurt me, Toycat has demonstrated some level of understanding in basic cs in previous videos but now i wonder if he just took 1 class so now he believes he can make false statements as such
java is a really good language, and even has the plus of being the easiest to learn. after you learn javascript, it's much easier to learn other languages. but i really disagree with it being called "archaic"
@@SoməøneXD but.. Java and Javascript are completely different?.. I would hardly call Java the easiest to learn. Easier than c++ probably, but eh.
@@SoməøneXD The statement is just plain false. Yeah Java can be, ahem, *quirky* to code with but at the end of the day, it's easy, efficient, simple and versatile. Technically C++, is a full ten years more "archaic" as Java is. It's a good language too, but has limitations that Java does not.
@@SoməøneXD Javascript is definitely different from java seeing as how javascript is a combination of java, c and c++ but if we're talking about easiest its definitely html or even python since its dynamic and built to be userfriendly
I perfer Java because Command Blocks on Java are so much more robust than on Bedrock; you could probably build Minecraft Bedrock on Minecraft Java with command blocks, but not vice versa.
That's just me; you do you.
Thanks for the idea brb
Cross platforming is bettwr
@@notabot3518 no
@@notabot3518 yeah, but java in overhaul is better
@@memejutsu I can build a bridge faster and play with friends on different consoles. To each their own
Me who has java and bedrock: *unlimited power*
Same
This people are so rich
@@landerpatriarca1546 some people like me got it for free.
PlatinumThief how?
@@landerpatriarca1546 Bedrock was free for Java players for quite some time. Only reason I own bedrock lol, maybe played it 5 times since it came out
The reason why I have Bedrock: I cant get java, because I have no pc
lmao same
Same, i only have my switch and my crappy kindle that wouldn't be able to run Minecraft
Yeah I play on ps4
I don't hace Java for the cooldown and my PC is a toaster
@@Dan0zBan0z there's this mod called sodium that improves your fps by about 100 fps for me, you should try it
Why I prefer Java:
I can put torches in my left hand.
WillVirus86 and you can actaully do redstone in java
Facts
You can actually still do red stone in bedrock
I made a couple of tnt cannons with comparators,repeaters,and redstone and plus on bedrock you can place redstone despensers
jeanrenando isaac ima tell you something that makes java 10x better
You have mods that can do more than addons in bedrock
Pretty much everything you mention here is also available in the Java edition via mods. Also, it's much easier to get a custom skin in Java edition - you simply upload your character to Mojang and there you go -- instant character. No paid crap, no microtransactions.
the same works for Bedrock as well. import your custom skin. done
@@BakuhatsuFoxy You are right. Thats why i also hate some Java players that think they are superior. which they arent
BakuhatsuFoxy bro what are you on about? this ain't some political stuff, i play both versions but Java is so much better trust me. Especially with mods that can actually add real furniture blocks and stuff that aren't just entities
@@cheesecakebeast5052 not all java mods are available on bedrock but most ones. also you dont need furniture. play mc the normal way and soon mining through the nether finding ancient debris. its fun to play the normal way as well and java and bedrock can do both things but bedrock is better in terms of performance
@@zzahkaboom24 except for the fact that we are
I actually switched from bedrock to java mainly because of all of the customization options and the multiplayer benefits but its really down to personal preference.
Don't forget about the bigger variety of mods, texture packs, shaders, etc.
I can't stand the fact that you have to pay for textures and skins which are all limited, I also can't build an intercontinental ballistic missile and launch it at my m8.
Same
@@mryellow6918 on windows 10 edition you can download mods
@@TheGreatTalia that is how lan works, also you can set up your own server easily using free server hosters or using your own computer, but that is harder to set up
Why do people get mad if someone prefers bedrock , Let the man have an opnion .
No
@@benmartin432 then go away
@@benmartin432 yes
Why switch from java to bedrock?
WILL SMITH TEXTUREPACK
The only good texture pack is Nic Cage
That texture also exists in java
@@ExtremeGuyOne ^
Ahhhhhh, its minecraft time!
bless jura
Minecraft render distance: * makes curve *
Me: *wait, that is illegal*
Fr like duh the earth is flat
So on a round earth you can't see a curve but on a flat one you can.
But the earth doesn't exist
@BlueCube067 ohhhh
Can't be an less illegal than curved swords...curved...swords.
Ever since I got a computer and switched to Java i never looked back java edition just feels more like minecraft to me.
I wish I could switch to java but my parents think having a switch for games is enough
Well it feels like Minecraft because it is the original version of Minecraft
That's because it literally is lol, it's real Minecraft
thats the same thing that happened to me with playing on java
@@flockstep oooooof
8:25 it literally looks like earth-
@Caleb Farlow it LOOKS round not IS round
“Try to do a 1 tick pulse”
-Mumbo
Try to connect Redstone on the side of a piston
-Mumbo
Boom observer!
@@ispentthenightin7721 try and have a piston spit out its block
try and do quasi connectivity
try and make a 3x3 door
try and use the 2, 4, 0 pattern for a double piston extender
@@theforge129 it's too much to give away just for better performance...
@@ispentthenightin7721 exactly
Reasons i love java:
-Redstone isn’t weird
-Mods
-Can play older versions
-Hypixel
-I can put torches on my left hand (that + optifine = heaven)
-nostalgia, i guess
Things i dont like about java:
-Awful performance on a weaker pc
-Hard to play with friends (in a normal world without realms)
Reasons i like bedrock:
-better performance
-easier to play with friends
-cross platform multiplayer
Things i dont like about bedrock:
-redstone behaves differently
-microtransactions
-why no torch on left hand tho
no torch on left hand is because it is hard to make the player able to controll the other hand if playing on a phone
Masked Redstoner Pro Z ok that makes sense
I have an old Windows 7 PC currently running the 1.16 snapshots and oh my god, the lag is so bad that I easily get bored. However, it's not that bad when I run Alpha and Beta versions and early release versions.
Gianina L my good pc stopped working recently so i was forced to switch to a very old one, it barely runs java and runs bedrock at 10-15 fps
@@Goobtoob6 install 1.15.2 optifine
There are Still features in the console edition that bedrock doesn’t have. One being
*Custom Superflats*
Stick101 Gaming With Melissa D I’m not switching from Java because the entity spawn system in bedrock is messed up, and bookmarks on maps aren’t a thing on there either.
Legacy edition had that😢
I miss it...
@@flamics Java edition mob system is crappy and annoying,Mobs don't have a set spawn limit like bedrock on java 10 to 15 god damn zombies can spawn all at once,That's not balanced at all,No hate to the java players I just prefer bedrock cause java has annoying flaws espically performance optimization
The Player yeah I agree with the performance being bad, but I’ve had bad experience with monsters spawning on bedrock. Every time I’d go in water there would be 2+ drowned coming to get me wether it was day or night, no matter what water I was in... even a little river. In java, drowned are much more infrequent and their spawning makes more sense to me.
This hordes of zombies spawning a lot as well is a feature, I believe. There is a chance that they’ll spawn in groups
I don't really care about custom superflats I usually just do survival and when I do a creative it's usually just for testing add-ons or trolling my friends
I doesn't even matter if a game is og the thing matters that you enjoyed the game😊
Big brain
Yeah bedrock and Java is are both cool
Og is always better.
@@sleepingeye7314 fake gamer
@@Lobotomyyyyy bruh if im a fake gamer for preferring og things, your probably a 2 day old gamer, so you wouldnt even know the og things from new p2w copies.
I think for most people they play bedrock because that’s what they have available. If I had a gaming pc I would be all over java
Lamp Shade I am in that exact position
@@nigelchambers484 or just download optifine....
Yes
Yup, i cant afford a gaming pc
Why are people always throwing around the term gaming pc, most people run java perfectly with optifine on old macs and school desktops.
My first version of Minecraft was Minecraft Lite.
Anyone else remember that?
Only true gamers will remember
But it wasnt the first version
@@loafofbread9400 No. No it wasn't.
Edit: Just read your username. F me.
@@echelon5162 i like anne frank and loaf of bread is the name i use when a clerk asks for my name
This isnt a joke account
@@loafofbread9400 Double ouch.
came to see if I could be convinced to switch to Bedrock
left even more convinced to stay in Java
lol i have java i use windows 8.1 but i can get bedrock for free i only got it to play with my sis when shes on the ps4 but
imma use java when im alone
the only reason i play on bedrock is because it can acually run shaders without crashing and it runs WAY faster
I play bedrock cause I didn’t know the difference with java until I grew older. Now I feel like a fool after this video :/
@@xenovy7865 optifine on java makes it run good so ye
i play bedrock because i don't have a pc and also hack free dupes
Finally a bedrock youtuber who doesn't say that java sucks
He should
@@ducbruh no he shouldn't
When did a bedrock RUclipsr insulted java? It's on reverse lmao
@@roshikantcm9913 Actually, it's pretty often
@@hanka. Hard disagree on that
The way I see it, if you play with a low end pc or have friends that play bedrock, choose bedrock. If you have a good computer and don’t care about cross play I’d go with Java. My experience with java has been a lot better.
You’ve summed it up perfectly.
And if you are already used to a version and dont want to get used to a new one
Roborbiettino is gone Neither of those are even cards you can buy. I think you mean 1650 Ti... but the other one I don’t even know. Maybe a 1080 Ti??
Connor Knight So.... You don’t need anything to special processor wise. I would go with AMD Athlon 3000G, which is a processor and has an integrated graphics processor, which means you could take a video output straight from your motherboard. It would run Minecraft, but not a whole lot of other games. It might struggle just a bit on high settings, and shaders wouldn’t be possible, but it would be good enough for just plain and simple java Minecraft.
I have an awful computer and it's really laggy but I still like it more.
My man literally said that bedrock has more settings than java
I'm a bedrock player and even I can agree that java has more settings
I mean bedrock does offer a few more video settings, but most bedrock settings are related to bedrock, as a bedrock player, I too, will admit there is a fuckton more settings in java lol
NekoBit well if you add mods you can get a lot of video options and etc
zen 420 why would you need optifine in bed rock if it already runs really damn good
Toasteddd Toast we just explaining that java can have a lot more settings
Redstone on Bedrock is like rolling a 20 sided dice and hoping you get a particular number
Matt I play java, can you explain?
Zahven certain features in java that you can use like powering pistons through other pistons and bud powering and that kind of stuff is very very VERY unpredictable and unreliable
@@zahven sometimes in bedrock the redstone just doesnt work plain and simple. You can set up something that should work and sometimes it will but sometimes it just wont work as intended for no apparent reason and no changes were made
@@zahven redstone on bedrock is so random
Bedrock redstone is different on bedrock, and thats a fact!
Here's what it is, java for single player and modding and servers, bedrock for playing with friends who don't have a pc
GeyserMC : Im gonna show you what is the real Cross Playing!
Best comment I’ve seen 🙌
you can still modding on bedrock
@@Shape1425 yes, but this is add-ons, modding is different, and it is also a lot easier and more versatile to mod Java than bedrock
@@Shape1425 add-ons add custom looks and behaviors to existing mechanics and objects in the game. A lot can be done with this, But it is a lot more difficult and there are not many people who do it other than those on the marketplace. Modding. However, is altering the games code, or adding NEW things, not just changing existing ones. Many many mods can be found for Java and 99.99% of them are free. This is why I said Java is the Version for modding and bedrock for crossplay
Java has more features but not having them in bedrock doesn’t take away from the experience of playing Minecraft. Java is better for mods and addons but both versions still provide the vanilla Minecraft experience.
If you use Linux or Mac Java is your only option.
my vanilla experience involves _dust of stone that's shade is red_ so Java is still better for me
@@karlisulmanis3810 I switched to java for the same reason. On bedrock you cant get 0tick speeds so java is better
I may be wrong but aren’t 0 tick and quasy connectivity just bugs?
Always Wright i dont think so, they have been in the game for many versions and still haven’t been removed
Theres only 2 things i like about bedrock
-Preformance
-Crossplay
Other than that java is better
If you use optifine om Java the differences on that become smaller.
There is no better version of Minecraft, both editions are great and equal.
lately feels like java has better performance, it takes so long to start up bedrock nowadays
@@imnoobgamer_2915 you have great common sense you are definitely right.
Killing mobs systems?
Exclusive features?
The fact that bedrock gets like 8 times as many updates java does?
I will only switch to Bedrock if redstone will work the same as in java edition, also all the farming stuff. Oh, and if they change the title screen, it is just bad, it works for MCPE, but not Windows 10 or XBOX.
Yeah they should change it for windows 10 edition
@@iforst1639 lol ur wrong haha
You could download a resource pack and change the title screen
@@dubl33_27 it's just their opinion, calm down
Agree on red stone part.
When people ask me which version I prefer I physically cannot answer that question.
Java has hardcore mode
Bedrock can swap skins in game
Java has more advanced mods
Bedrock has easy to install mods that really have everything I want anyway
Java has f3
Bedrock has coordinates on screen at all times
Java has customizable super flat
Bedrock has high performance
Java has bigger servers
Bedrock has easier to use multiplayer
Java has anything in your off hand
Bedrock has paper doll (which I actually like)
And the list goes on
On your first point, isn't hardcore just hard mode with one life? because technically on bedrock you could just play hard mode and call it hardcore and delete the world when you die once, just you don't have the ability to spectate your world after which I guess could put you off doing it
There are good behavior packs on mcpedl to simulate a hardcore mode that puts you in spectator mode after you die
@@dirtyshinobii what's your point
@@RZ302 there are good data pack on Java edition
1:09 Yeah, Minecraft bedrock was sold more often than Minecraft Java. But you have to consider: I bought Minecraft bedrock 4 times: on my iPod, on my Android phone, on Windows and on my tablet (different account than on Android phone). My cousin bought it at least 3 times because he lost some Google accounts and therefore the game. The same goes for my brother who bought it 3 times. My girlfriend bought it 2 times.
All of these persons also own Minecraft Java. But all only bought that version once. I think the main reason for bedrock having more sales is that you have to buy it again on different platforms and that many people are somehow more likely to loose their Google account than their Minecraft Java account. Because we all can still access our Java we bought that one time.
I had to buy it 3 times
i’ve bought it 6 times ( Xbox One, PS4 x2, IPad, IPhone x2)
matz alkema i got a new phone and got a new itunes :(
This comment section is like iOS vs Android all over again
Android is better
@@YourLocalYter true though
@@YoshMonsterGaming Yeah
Yosh Monster I like iOS more but I won’t argue
@@hydraball So many limitations on IOS. IOS is ok if your rich but also nust need to use the phone function part of it.
I just wanted to play the game I played 9 years ago
That’s why I play java edition
@@honecm44 its literally the exact same my guy
gormna kickXD bedrock uses 1.8 pvp
I just wanted to play the version I've played 6 years ago
That's why I play bedrock
bedrock and Java 1.8 combat are identical, @@honecm44
@@honecm44 nothing of what you just said makes any sense please go to english class for once
3:27 ibxtoycat calling iballisticsquid just a squid
iballisticsquid: 👁👄👁
you could just say
Reasons to switch to Bedrock:
1.- Will Smith HD Textures
@tixonium 3000%
Does bedrock pc have 128x128 skins?
@@lpsamyrose i think so cos bedrock mobile has 128x128
And also ray tracing
@@crispinotechgaming pay for ray tracing or just install it like java edition
The biggest reason why I haven't changed to Bedrock are the microtransactions. It's just stupid to make kids ask their parents for money every time they see something cool. The Java edition is sort of Community Made. Mojang gave us the tools and we made the game. But Bedrock is almost completely run by Microsoft and even the servers have this "Partnership".
dont like it dont buy it
I totally agree I feel like it’s a kids version like Microsoft is holding my hand 😂
Robert you can mod bedrock and get free skins too... I did it all the time when I was 8 on my tablet. All you have to do on PC is find a client that’ll run mods on bedrock. And for Xbox you can upload the client by hooking your PC up to the xbox and downloading it.
I play bedrock and I’ve never even opened the marketplace it’s a really small feature
@@Michael-hu2fb well that is exactly what he doesn't want to do
Jokes on you, I have both
Nice👌
Puppy_ Gam333r Same.
Yea me too
Me too lol
Best of both worlds
2 of my friends are java lovers
7 are bedrock lovers
2 are both (including me)
So
I have both Java and Bedrock, but I still play Bedrock instead of Java. It just feels smoother than Java because of the differences in the coding.
How slow is your pc? I haven’t noticed anything tbh with mods.
If i have a good computer i would rather play on Java edition
@𖣘GamerX𖣘 "DonAtE It" ah yes my 800 dollar pc is soooo expensive... Don't tell people what to do
@𖣘GamerX𖣘 4gb ram is so low dude get 12gb at least.
@GamerX "GOOD PC"
4GB ram
so what you're telling me, is that Minecraft bedrock is secretly a paid version of Minecraft Lite?
edit: why did my "comedy" get so many likes lmao
Yes
Omg wait. I think you opened a spot in my brain that Minecraft was free at one point-
No bedrock is better than java
Yes
@@whitneyknipe6066 let me guess, you're a windows10 player?
No mods, no control, a micro transaction store... eh no thanks, the performance isn’t that bad you just have to tell it to use more ram
Redtstone on Java is just better too
Yea java is made in a way so you need to tell it to use more ram for better performance but thats fine
Josh I can get mods easily on Xbox.
@@ragingcombust7304 He meant good mods
XV Cold Xbox has addons
@@mmsweatyballs1449 which absolutely suck compared to java. They just added custom armor in 1.13. i do have hope for addons though. Maybe it will catch up in a year or two
to the people out there that are like "bEdRoCk iS tRaSh, bUy jAvaaaAaaA" some of us don't want to or physically cant because we don't have a PC
well, buy a pc then XD
@@100rm They really are like that though XD
Or we're broke
"jUst bUy a pC brUuhH"
Or our pc is trash
I like bed rock, but my girlfriend insists on getting a memory foam mattress so it won’t make any noise.
69 likes...nice
Talentless Cult Member ok
Talentless Cult Member you’re the people who starts arguments on RUclips comments
@@raskall7571 they are inevitable whatsoever
Talentless Cult Member one comment can start a war and a person can comment more than one
Why i love java edition
*Mods(java mods better than bedrock)
*Can choose every versions
*I hate color water
*I can play on windows 7
*And of course F3
*Optifine for life!
*I can put anything in my left hand
Linux and mac
@@tiagosales3373 yeah but I haven't got Linux or mac
@@creepquest raspberry pi
F3? Well there is a MCpack for that
@@_-_--_ Windows 10 is simply not good...
Updates breaking the system, microsoft permanently spying on you, and so on.
This video's is gonna be a gold mine for triggered minecraft bedrock and java players
A degenerate True. I think both are good, and if one likes to play Java more or vice versa it doesn’t matter. So many people fight but again, it doesn’t matter. I don’t get why people have to argue.
@Dima Kabbout Also the fact our version is OJBECTIVELY better, but alright.
Oh god here we go
@@sexhaver32_31 tries to correct spelling, uses the wrong you're AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH YOU'RE BRAINDEAD YOU'RE NEVER GONNA LIVE THIS DOWN.
I play Minecraft Java and bedrock, but I by far prefer Java. I still like both for different reasons, but my favourite things to do in Minecraft are the things Java is better at. (Minigames, mods etc)
I think we can all agree both are great. I’m a bedrock user but I respect Java heavily
No, we can't all agree on that. Bedrock edition is garbage.
@@spoderrr it’s much better for playing with friends as you don’t have to become a programmer just to invite someone to your world
@@spoderrr least salty Java player
@@massivecringe4989 Not salty. Bedrock just sucks.
And then there’s me in the corner liking both equally
Thank you for the love of Jesus
These Java boomers constantly bickering is getting tiresome
@@masterofpasta95 Java boomers lol
yes
Bedrock edition + Java edition = The perfect Minecraft
@@enriogjoni8583 and I mean legacy too if ya wanna feel nostalgic
My main reason for sticking to Java is the absolute quality of the mods available and being able to set up servers around these huge mods that will just never happen to Bedrock.
True. Heck, Pixelmon might possibly be better than Pokémon in the future, since it has all the Pokémon and the same features of Pokémon combined with the ones of Minecraft, except mobs. You could even make your own Pokémon game with this (which is pretty much what Pixelmon servers are)! And that is just a single mod. Bedrock has some neat features, but when you have mods like those it is hard to compete. And don't get me started with people that actually made Pokémon Red inside Minecraft. Or *MINECRAFT INSIDE A MINECRAFT CHEST!* It's just ridiculous.
Addons are getting powerful every update so just wait and see
@@ajsabum Have you ever heard of Orespawn's complete insanity?
Tomás Andrade
just wait for the Modding API to be fleshed out
@@ajsabum Still, even after that, modders are more than used to 1.7.10 as the mod update of Minecraft. If only a few of them went to a more recent version, I doubt that they will change to Bedrock anytime soon.
I’ll never get you for playing Bedrock, I can’t stand it. Respect though.
My experience is the exact opposite in terms of preformance. I first played java and almost never lagged unless I went nuts on the tnt(a bad habit of mine) but when I tried switching to bedrock, I found just walking in bedrock caused more lag than detonating a few dozen cubes of TNT.... 3×3 cubes of it.... in java. Maybe my computer didnt agree with the different language(my computer may or may not be xenophobic or something XD)
Nowadays I just use a ps4 which idk which it is or if it's some combination or something
@@dbooth3975 current PS4 edition is Console Edition. It started out as a console port of the PC version and is now adding bedrock features, too, so it's a bit of a mix of the 2. it has some features Java doesn't, some features only bedrock doesn't have, but also lacks some features from both.
however it's getting replaced by bedrock in a few months anyway.
He just want a tail
@@pout6038 which in my opinion sucks. Rip console edition :((
@@dbooth3975 Some bedrock versions have a hard time trying to let you play. In my Nintendo Switch, I have a similar performance to Java, having trouble rendering chunks and stuff like that. That could be the reason, but I still prefer Java.
i dont like the monetization and how animated it is (makes it hard to move quickly), and i think everything feels more "mainstream" and a bit cash-grabby. the bridging thing is okay but then you realise how much it takes away from the skill of playing the game. you might say "the animated-ness makes it look better though," and it sort of does, but you simply can't move fast on it.
just turn the setting under paper doll off to fix lag
why toycat uses bedrock: bedrock is found in caves, cave update
@tayy well you would have to go through a cave to find bedrock, its at the very bottom
@@FungiCaptain or you can go to the nether roof!
@@felobatirmoheb4884 Or the ender dragon's pit in the end
@@FungiCaptain or... You can mine without any need of going through a cave!
I LIVE THUS DEBATE HAHAHHAAHAHA YALL ARE IDIOTS ENJOY THE STUPID CONVERSATIONS PLZ
Imagine having to pay for texture packs and behavior packs.
This post was made by Java gang
Just use mcdl lol
Imagine not doing your research on the version you don’t like to make a meme out of it ._.
@@Sup3r87 Imagine talking about not doing research and then forgetting about consoles!
Reeno kopli ok good point, it’s quite harder on consoles but still possible. Not impossible, just very hard lol. I still don’t know why I keep getting ignorant memes like this that resend the marketplace is the only source of content availible ._.
@@Sup3r87 it kinda is on consoles + the marketplace is more limited and since java has better commands ,the content itself isn't AS good! It's still fine but java just has it better ,just like almost everything else!
I ain’t paying my skins or textures
You dont have to pay for them and they are optional, you can get free contents through the internet on bedrock too.
its optional
There are apps and websites that let you customize your skin for free for bedrock.
@@imnoobgamer_2915 Are there allso free mods (addons) available for bedrock anywhere?
@@M4ggy98 what do you mean?
I have both but I use java for multiplayer servers and mods and I use bedrock for playing regular creative or survival since it's easy to setup a world to play with friends (and all my friends play on consoles)
i would have both tbh but i dont have the laptop for it so im stuck on my ps4 lol
I prefer Java because:
- Can jump between updates
- 1 tick pulses on pistons
- quasiconnectivity
- no confusing multiplayer settings stuff
Luniz is Glacey I thought 1 tick pulses on pistons were not working after 1.16 but please correct if I’m wrong. And the multiplayer isn’t that confusing, it’s quite simple. I use bedrock because I don’t have a pc or money for it.
@@jimym__ 0 tick farm not working in 1.16, he meant that when you send 1 tick pulse into a sticky piston it will "shoot" out the block
@NoName98 No, only 0-ticking a plant to trick it to grow was patched. 1-ticks are still here, and so are 0-ticks, but you can no longer trick a plant to grow.
I could never figure out multiplayer on bedrock, but I guess that was a few years ago so maybe it's changed.
@Dylan Jones but does it work right? No.
I’ve always found multiplayer more confusing on Java, but I still prefer it.
Toycat: the render distance is done circly
Me: isnt this game about cubes and squares?
Edit: also half the video is toycat like saying he likes the ui
I want my realistic cube world
Imagine everything rendering in cubes
DialingComa 66 it does though...
milk Then Minecraft would look terrible. Voxels and Pixels are not squares and cubes.
FBI OPEN UP
I'm a Java player, have a good pc. and have my render distance at 10. I don't need it any further.
Same, I still don't get why would you need to see the whole world.
I keep my render distance at 16. Feels just right for me.
I remember in Alpha 1.2.6 I could play at 16 smoothly but every 3 hours the game would crash. The crash was so predictable I could close the game 5 minutes before it happens, open it again and keep playing. Good old days.
@@gabbie07 finding end cities
I allways liked fps over everything so even when i had a good cellphone i keep the render distance at 5 to play it at 60fps
Why i prefer bedrock: *speed briding is much more faster*
I'm a redstone Guy and Bedrock redstone is pure crap for me.
Bedrock redstone is basically useless
yea its unpredictable and im pretty sure there is quasi connectivity
@@t4ky0n there is no qc in bedrock
@@johannessilvennoinen3327 I think he meant there is no qc but forgot the no
@@popeval6654 Yes
"Java, a *very* archaic language"
Java release date: 1995
C++ release date: 1985
Fortran release date: 1957
Java is not a great language for performance but the idea that it's archaic is laughable.
Java is sandboxed in almost every possible way, C++ is very much not. That's great for some things, but bad for performance.
Java 8 is old, I'll give you that. It's end of life, and Minecraft should update to 11 ASAP.
They can't upgrade to Java 11 because LWJGL hasn't been released for Java 11.
GamingCraft_hd when do you think it'll be out?
@@zimmeisdead1373 I hope soon.
Let's make Minecraft's in Java FX
I thought Java was for beginner programmers who want to make a game before they have enough skill to code properly.
There are a lot more mods for java and dont even make me start talking about redstone.
And the Marketplace
@@justrez2571 for money
@@Wombattlr locking things that are free on the Java edition behind a paywall
*Big Brain*
@@justrez2571 ik
@@justrez2571 The marketplace is literally exclusively high quality content lol there's countless mods, addons etc for free our there but without a price tag or the dedicated modders java has you won't be guaranteed to get that quality.
To me java is the definitive edition of the game. Bedrock is a remake which only has crossplay going for it.
True
@@JFK19637 I started playing java edition on a £100 laptop...granted it was in alpha but at best you only really need £200 or £300 to spend on a laptop to play the game.
@@JFK19637 I suppose but that's more of a Java edition having bad performance problem than anything else.
@@JFK19637 sodium or optifine = 60+ fps
you: "... switch from java, a very archaic language, to C++ ..."
me, a software engineer: *dies*
He doesn't mean archaic as in older, he mainly means obsolete. Java is mostly used in jobs, but java is extremely slow because of JRE, while C++ is much faster and generally considered more modern as C++ compiles into machine code. Java just isn't a good language for games and stuff.
@@nek0bit why would C++ be considered more modern? you said it yourself C++ is much much older than java so why would it be more modern at all?
creeperchaos57 because C++ is faster
@@spaghetti_man3807 C++ takes more modern approaches to problems then Java does. Sure, java might be a bit easier to read, but C++ gives the developer total control over their program, memory management, compilation, lots of safety, etc. C++ also has a lot more optimizations that are considered amazing by most people. Like I said he doesn't mean archiac, for example, take the language javascript, it is adopted in a modern manner, and is used in the web, yet lots of people hate it due to being slow and jank. C++ still gets new versions and rarely ever starts a controversy, while java has been controversial for years to come.
@@miniature9079 are you kidding me do you see bedrock now there is a bug glitch that so lag that crash your game automatically i prefer java
I prefer Java cause:
-better updates
-easyer online
-F3
-mods (better than add-ons)
The console is the worst only has 5 servers like are you actually serious
Sadly true, since Bedrock got the central name Minecraft
Redstone
@@polskistalker New religion I guess
Sadly Console lags easier
YOU CAN SEE THE CURVATURE OF THE EARTH
ok I'm sold
So on a round earth you can't see a curve but on a flat one you can.
Enderdragonpig Prime and I oop- sksksksksksksk
That’s not the curvature of the earth, it’s the render distance being a radius
no.
Laughs in German technology
java: ewwwwwwwwwwww
bedrock:ewwwwwwwwww
education:nice
@gamingwith din well then its potato just download the both and my job is done
>"The performance is bad"
>VSync is on
Really? Turning that off will make the game so much smoother
Doctorj1 yea but tearing tho. Ima leave it on.
@@ftr0sty31 get a Gsync or Freesync display. Vsync is obsolete
@@ftr0sty31 if you have amd fressync monitors are priced at normal range and dont cost more than one without it, not true for gsync on nvidia side but still not terrible price to pay. I know it involves getting a new monitor but if screen tearing is an issue than it might be worth it since it works on almost all games and you dont need vsync which can hurt performance in some ways. It can make even 30fps look much better than it usually does if that's what you are forced to run a game at. It can provide a much smoother experience without actually upgrading internal PC hardware as long as you can already hit a playable frame rate consistently. I can run games at 1440p that while not being able to sustain fps at my 144hz refresh rate still look smooth since I do hit over 60fps and can simply enable free sync and set my monitor at 60hz. Otherwise I'd need a better card to get similar smooth graphics at the 144hz refresh rate without vsync.
If you have a bad processor, no
@@ftr0sty31 youll get no to very little tearing if you set the fps cap 10 or 20 fps above your refresh rate
I personally prefer java because of how expansive the mods are. You can play a whole new game with java edition.
@@NuruddinPlays
He didn't mean to say expensive lol, expansive is a word that means "large". He's saying that Java mods have a lot of content available.
NuruddinPlays do bedrock addons have an addon that adds a nuclear fusion or a mod that adds portal guns? Does it have an addon that changes the mechanics of each and every mob or animal? I didn’t think so
NuruddinPlays exactly
HydraIsGone no, but why would I? At that point I might as well play a different game.
@@Slender_Man_186 That's kind of the point, it still feels like minecraft, but at the same time its a whole new experience. What's wrong with wanting to play something a little more refreshing? And no it really doesn't feel that different, it still looks the same, sounds the same, mine the same, craft the same, etc.
I don’t think you fully understand the capabilities of Minecraft java
He doesnt, I am sure
I am a Bedrock pleb. Why don’t you Inform me?
@@zachrobinson8357 as someone with experience playing both, here's how i view the two versions. Bedrock feels absolutely clunky and slower paced than java, much of the content is driven by mtx, the servers are kind of a joke for anyone looking to play semi-seriously/competitively, and the lack of fully controllable off-hand mechanics is just depressing when you know java players have full range of use with the off-hand. Java on the other hand has very competitive servers (UHC, kit pvp, anarchy, actual tournaments such as MC Saturdays, etc..), java's redstone mechanics are actually usable, custom skins, mods, optifine, schematica, ability to go back to even the alpha and classic versions of the game, getting snapshots/new updates first, being able to access the unused game data (Illusioners, giant zombies for example), and even something as simple as having the F3 screen to look at makes a huge difference. As much as toycat sees bedrock as the future of the game, theres a reason the developers still focus on the java version first. it will always be better maintained than bedrock.
That was pretty one sided there xD your point was that java is better than bedrock in every way by completley roasting it wow you dont even say what bedrock has to offer do me a favour stop tryna act formal because your really not and yes i know im not speaking formal
@Alien Ants i didnt want to say that to make it sound less one sided, but literally everything bedrock has that they charge for, java has for free (or cheaper in terms of dedicated servers). there are no real benefits of bedrock over java. yeah you can play with your console friends, but in terms of the actual game it is a downgrade
Java: a torture for my pc
Bedrock: very fluid and not even a little lag
Why?
because bedrock loads the chunks you're looking at and not the chunks around you
@@chloeburbank_ ok thanks 👍👍👍
Use optifine or sodium
(12:39) why was he so specific when describing this “friend” 👀👀
dude he playing with bart baker
Bedrock Devs: Hmm, Java has no ingame purchases... I've got a plan
Me, watching this video with no intention to ever switch
i play pocket edition on computer
Faubi edition*
@@christina9902 oh no.....
Kittria Leviana me wondering if I should switch to java...
@@aquatax24 do it
Vanilla = Bedrock / Java = Mods
Me: plays bedrock edition
The 30 million creepers in my house because of a dark corner: hi
How about a torch?
Or playing with cheats? Then there is a light block availible by using /give. It just makes the air glow without any seeable light source.
@@delucxsglobal8616 Then just make a torch using charcoal, it doesn't take that long to get a furnace, a log, sticks, and some planks.
@@delucxsglobal8616 who can’t get coal and wood? If they have a whole house why wouldn’t they have torches? Are u ok
@@DizzyMapping its a joke smartass
@@librahz how in the world is that a joke? U saying it is a joke is more of a joke
3:00 Those are add-ons, not mods. Add-ons are far more limited than mods, add-ons can only change some behaviours and add some new mobs/blocks, while mods can revamp the whole game. There hasn't been an Aether add-on, there hasn't been an Aquatism add-on that is as good as the mod, there hasn't been a worldedit add-on, there hasn't been a RLCraft add-on pack, not as good as the Java counterparts at least. On the other hand, there have been Java mods and modpacks for all of that. Also, Forge and mods are becoming increasingly easier to install and use.
If you didnt post this just 2 weeks ago then i would 100% believe this, since addons now can add mobs since really long ago, do some research. Tho, they are still limited compared to mods.
i found a rlcraft addon that doesnt replace anything on the addons for minecraft app, mind if you remove the “there hasnt been a rlcraft addon-craft”?
addons can add mobs blocks and items, i know bc ive made them before. u can also do scripting with javascript
@yo lo ?
@yo lo oooh i get the point now
You cannot get add-ons though marketplace, only though the internet (who cares marketplace lul, MCPEDL forever)
And i dont care about 2b2t, there is a Minecraft pe version of it too
Wait, this wasn't uploaded on April 1st...
OK you little Java fanboy
@@irdor1318 Java is way better cause it supports forge-optifine
@@xupperkx Java fanboy
@@irdor1318 that is all you know?
@@xupperkx I don't wanna waste mental resources with a Java fanboy arguing. That's why I say no more, I already did it before
Why I prefer Java:
Java Edition is what I grew up with.
OG
Alpha 1.2.6
Well i first started playing in 1.12 i think because i remember seing the version name and a 1.2 but i started late so 1.12.
But i really grew up with beta 1.8 because i used to watch videos everyday back in the day that were on that version.
i ain't switching to bedrock until redstone will work the same.
So you want a broken version with red Stone? Because bedrock's redstone is the accurate way
@@jcsuarezjc4571 yes i want it because the bedrock redstone breaks a lot of contraptions, it's buggy and you kinda need to learn it all from the ground up again
@@gregtechnewhorizons then you gotta get good
@@jcsuarezjc4571 what even is this argument lol
@@jcsuarezjc4571 java
My thoughts on this video:
-Performance is definitely better on bedrock ( 72 chunks? Jesus), However, The game still does run smoothly on java to the point where it is still playable so there is no real reason to switch for just a visual improvement.
-Multiplayer is a bit weird since both have their advantages but I think java has superior multiplayer. Sure bedrock has crossplatform, but in my experience, anyone I've ever wanted to play Minecraft with seriously usually has it on their PC. Bedrock multiplayer is inferior imo compared to Realms/making your own server in multiplayer or joining big servers on java
As for the feature differences, at the end of the day, they both are minecraft: the mining and crafting game. Both versions have identical updates at the same time(now that bedrock has caught up to 1.14) which means that they are basically the same game, however if you are on pc, The good original minecraft is probably the better option
Java is unplayable on low end pcs
@@friedgage3288 very true
Servers on bedrock work better in my experience in terms of ping and stuff. But there are way more choices and resource packs on java.
i wouldn't say its unplayable as long as you use optifine. i used to have a very low end pc, installed optifine on it and the game wasn't amazing but it was certainly playable and i enjoyed it
My experience with realms in java involved server lag because of going too far
"We can show coordinates inside the game"
F3: am I a joke to you?
F3 was better tbh
Yes, but F3 takes up a lot of space, what if you just want coordinates and not all the other stuff
@@ArmandoTheCatholic thats true, but it does bother me also that I cant just open and close it with the hit of a button. Rather then just having to have it on or off. But i guess both have their pros and cons
Armando Cabrera-Ontiveros Then you press F3 again 😐
Armando Cabrera-Ontiveros but then use mods on lunar or blc or labymod then u can choose coordinates
Every other game community: This update was empty
Minecraft community: WAAAAAAAAAAAAAA I CANT GET JAVA EDITION
Why do I see you everywhere
Xbox 360 edition will always have the most nostalgic memories of my lifetime
I also played xbox 360 edition before and I must say it was a legend!
Mine is ps3
I first played minecraft on my ipod touch when it only had glass and brick blocks. Then I upgraded to 360 and that was my main platform for years until I switched to ps4.
Helloooo this is stampy..!!
And welcome back to anover episode on stampy's lovely world..!
Xbox 360 is the best console of all time no cappuccino
I prefer java, because in my opinion it has better graphics, better redstone, more control (I mean key to switch item between hands, ability to transfer lots of items from inventory to container, and not having to go to settings to see coordinates and switch your view), and obviously nostalgia
Akai well, on bedrock, you have the chance of having the coordinates being permanent or not. On Java, would you play with the debug screen always on? Also, there is a huge nostalgia factor in bedrock for PE players, such as myself. The Stonecutter is quite nostalgic. With every other point, I agree with you.
@@draketurcotte4760 well, i turn on debug screen only when I need to see where I am, for example to match my nether portal, or when I need to go Back to my base after long adventures
Drake` Turcotte There's always 5zig, which (don't quote me on this) can, iirc, be installed clientside to work on servers. But yeah, Java needs a vanilla non-intrusive coordinate system.
Drake` Turcotte i play with my debug screen on 24/7. it feels un natural for me to play with it off. also why would you switch to bedrock because of coordinates? the very fact that you have to go into your settings just to turn them on is a downside for bedrock. lul
Hazer eh, I didn’t switch from any platforms yet. I’ve always been a mobile player. I have tried Java before, haven’t given it a full test. Anyway, I originally started playing PE back in the alpha days. Back before Microsoft took over and put in their Marketplace. I bought PE around the 0.7.0 update. Those were the days, back during the time of the Nether Reactor and Stonecutter. I always watched Java RUclipsrs, though, until the 0.9 update. Also, you can set the showcoordinates gamerule by using a command.
I like java more because it’s the more “technical” version
a smart I have both but I use bedrock more because I am too stupid to figure out how to use the setting and I like playing eggwars on bedrock
@@tegan1027 I like both Java and Bedrock but I feel the controls on Bedrock at least on Windows 10 is a lot clunker than Java. Also if you like eggwars maybe try playing the Hypixel server's bedwars on Java, it has more features to it and controls are easier on there
Good luck getting tridents
Golden_Red_Panda I find it hard to sprint on java I have no clue why
@Yo Tengo Master just use lan
"But then he gets a phone made in China with a camera and microphone attached" omg I am dieing
Imagine forgetting about the fact that Redstone in Bedrock can be unpredictable
(Per a redstoner, the same contraption can produce multiple different outputs randomly)
Which is such a big problem I'm surprised it got into the full release.
That’s actually a problem with the tick speed, java has a faster tick speed than bedrock so it causes that behavior.
Really depends tho.. but Java is better I guess, I just don’t play it CASUE I don’t have a comp... :)
Yes that is a problem, though many people have adapted to the quirky redstone that bedrock provides. Now we have many working and efficient farms like obisidon farms, slime farms, ender enders etc. We also have some unique things like the ability to make trident killers which are used to kill mobs part of a mob farm. We also can make drowned farms, and there is a technique to get bedrock off the center of the main end island.
Classic eyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
I've played Bedrock edition since it was released. I quit playing recently after Bedrock update 1.13 after months of playing mostly Java. Java is just so much better and more fun. Bedrock feels like a money grab to me.
Bedrock's microtransactions are 100% optional and you dont have to pay for them
@@imnoobgamer_2915 As I said, I've been playing Bedrock edition since release. I don't know why I wouldn't know that the microtransactions are optional.
@@imnoobgamer_2915 All crimes are 100% optional, it doesn't mean that it's justified. We know that it is optional to buy them, but the act of making micro-transactions a reality in Minecraft is bad. People who cannot afford paid content and want to use it can't, because they don't have the money. Optional and bad can coexist.
ChickenGamerITA Well you can use FREE apps with FREE Addons and FREE maps and FREE EVERYTHING!
@@imnoobgamer_2915 paid skins are a sin.
Things have changed in Java a bit now, a lot easier to add texture packs and shaders. pretty much download, move file to location, folder opened from in game now so no need to go rummaging, and click on done.
Just thought I needed to share that here ;)
MadmanMac that’s how it works on bedrock console , pe is as easy as download an app and clicking a few things on the screen , pc just as easy pe
vasa di pc is better but bedrock is on pc
@vasa di java has microtransaction too, Minecraft realms.
on bedrock you download a .mcpack file and directly open it with mc lol
@@ismailqeis jokes on you our datapacks and mods can be modified
easily
Friend 1 :- MC Java Is better
Friend 2 :- MC Bedrock is better
Me who plays both and loves both :- Minecraft is minecraft !!
Okay, so here's my perspective as someone that has both versions of the game. I think that if you're looking to play cross platform with other people then Bedrock is definitely the way to go, but other than that my experience with Java has just been better. Sure, Bedrock may perform better, but due to the fact that it has to cater to the lowest common denominator (mobile), it has to make a lot of concessions in order to be compatible across such a wide spectrum of hardware.
For me, one of the biggest issues is that Bedrock edition has a maximum simulation distance, meaning that activity beyond a certain distance from the player simply stops. What this means is that say you have some iron ore cooking in a furnace, if you stray too far it simply pauses until you get back within distance (I think the max distance you can set in the options menu is 12 chunks). Another thing I've noticed with this, is that if you have a mine cart rail that is too long, if you want to send a cart you will have to follow it in order to make sure it reaches its destination or it will be stuck on the track unmoving until you get close enough, at which point it will start moving again. In Java edition, you can put your iron in the furnace and go mining as deep as you like, and your ore will be done when you get back. You can send your mine carts as far as you like, and as long as your track is well constructed they will reach their destination rather you are there or not.
Another major difference I've noticed is that Bedrock edition seems to have a much lower spawn rate for mobs. The main reason I got bedrock in the first place was so that I could play on the cross platform server my younger brother set up on his pc so that we could play with our Dad, who has an X-box, and our youngest brother, who has a Ps4. On that server, I've done a fair bit of exploring, having filled up two level 4 maps worth of territory. During all of that exploring, I spent a significant amount of time without running into any enemy mobs whatsoever, and this is despite the difficulty setting for that server being set to high. At the same time, On my single player Java world with a difficulty setting of normal, it seems like whenever I go cave exploring I have to fight tooth and nail for every little bit of forward progress I make. I also have a single player bedrock world on normal setting, and despite the fact that I have both worlds set on the same difficulty setting I have yet to die even once on my Bedrock world vs. multiple deaths on Java, despite having played a similar amount of time on both worlds. It's like Bedrock edition is a schoolyard bully that wants to harass you every once in a while to make your day bad, while Java is a brutal murderer that wants you dead at all costs (I prefer Java's difficulty to Bedrock's ease).
This one is more of a nitpick, but I don't like how blocking with your shield is tied to ducking in Bedrock. In Java version it's bound to the same button that you use to place blocks, which to me just makes for better combat. I'm fairly certain this was a concession made for players using a touch screen, i.e mobile.
the shields are a pet peeve for me too, it even makes you walk slower while holding a shield up than you do in bedrock, and you cant hit while holding down a button, you have to uncrouch, hit, uncrouch. also on xbox pressing down on left stick quickly is hard to do compared to just tapping right click
The simulation distance is not infinite in java actually. You can not send a Minecraft through unloaded chunks though any chunk that is being loaded with 2 chunks around in any direction will be entity processing. But you do have spawn chunks which are always loaded. Totally agree on the mobspawning thing though. It’s literally impossible to build mob farms and that’s an absolute dealbreaker to me. And the second dealbreaker for me is bedrock redstone which is completely useless and unpredictable
The bedrock Redstone becomes more consistent (not perfect but like 99.9percent consistent.) when you add longer delays. But I understand that some of the bugs like quasi are so useful that it makes bedrock redstone look really bad. Im a bedrock player and I always get annoyed with how simpler contraptions could be if a sticky piston could spit out it's block. But I do enjoy some benefits of bedrock like moving containers. Maybe one day Java and bedrock parity comes to redstone.
Vidit Tiwari even 99.999 percent is still inconsistent. Leave a farm running and eventually it’ll break
@@feschber Now that you mention it, I think I do remember that minecraft Java does prevent things from running in unloaded chunks. I think that was one of the issues that the people who made redstone computers had to work around. I do get the impression however, that bedrock is much more limited in range, though admittedly it could simply be that I never noticed for some reason.
After watching - I have to say:
1) Minecoin is a joke
2) Java has much more content compared to bedrock (add ons)
3) Personally, the inventory management looks and feels better in Java
4) LAN servers are just as easy to set up in Java, but external connecting is easier in bedrock
5) Platforms like Twitch make creating and/or installing modpacks so much easier
6) Switching versions and creating custom profiles is easier in Java
7) Commands are made to be easy to use anyway
8) some things like redstone are broken on Bedrock
Honestly - Bedrock just feels like the version you get first to get the feel of the game, before moving onto the more complex Java
Mate using touch controls for me is the extreme challenge!
I agree
@@Ben-cb8ue It does - there is a mod tab on twitch which used to be Curseforge but is a part of Twitch now
0) Bedrock is not the same, old-school Minecraft we know. The "nostalgia" aspect.
9) Bedrock isn't for Linux.
Bedrock literally has mod support built in. All you need to do is download the mod and open up the file which will prompt the game to automatically install it.
Inventory management feels better, imo, for bedrock. Mainly because I always play in creative.
How is redstone broken? Do people not realise you could just add delays to pistons?
Commands are easy to use.
Creating custom profiles: I don't know why you'd need a more difficult process than signing in and playing but sure. Why not?
But these are just my opinions. Feel free to play any version you want.
I’m gonna say it, Java is the real and original Minecraft.
He ain't lying.
even the guy says it in the video.......
so your comment isjust... useless?
I mean, it literally is the original Minecraft. That’s not too nuts.
Original, yes, better, debatable
@@11Denis11 its really not debatable. our servers are superior on java, the customization options are more in depth, we have shaders and optifine etc..., you can change your version to play legacy versions of the game on servers for niche types of gameplay, meta is defined by the java community. it may be outdated, but it still outclasses the bedrock community in more aspects than the bedrock community does vs java
Why do people think one version is better than the other why can’t we settle the Java/bedrock war
Because people have rights to an opinion
@@Towells. but sometimes they don’t respect the other persons opinion
@@chinchice2733 They don't have to.
@@Towells. I know but it’s best to
@@chinchice2733 never said it wasn’t.