Actually i can tell different. Astro is more sensitive and more louder than blue ice pop. Blue ice pop is more quiet and sound more natural voice if you know what i mean. So Ice pop is more better quality sound. This is my option.
Thanks for this! I will stick to the stock Astro mic. I immediately thought microphone 1 sounded better. Watched again and still believe it sounds better.
I could tell there were less plosives on the blue icepop mic in this video. I'm sure that's because of the built in pop filter on it. However, last year I had bought some little foam mic covers for the ASTRO A40 standard mic and did the exact same thing. And it sounds awesome. They cost me less than $10 on Amazon, I've only lost one so far and I have 9 left.
it would have been nice if you matched the volume levels of the 2 mics so we could really tell the difference in quality, having to adjust the volume adds difficulty towards objective listening
Yeah honestly the difference is not much. Sound wise the Astro sounds better. I have the a40. I bought the blue ice pop simply for how it’s more flexible build but sound wise I don’t think it’s much better
The blue mic does sound better imo but thats probably because of the built in pop filter, you can just save a lot of money by buying a foam cap for the original mic to act as a pop filter.
For sure could tell with the plosives the ice pop is better but aside from that specific thing there is extremely little difference in the sound profiles.
I could tell by the pop filter, quality wise was pretty equal. Now I’m no way are they the same. I could tell they were different mics just wouldn’t call one better. If you have the money get the blue and only if you’re using that mic while you’re also on twitch or RUclips or whatever. If it’s just for chat then save your money lol
I heard mic 1 and thought it was a lot clearer, I have the astro headset and listned through that, I was shocked as I was just about to buy the Blue mic for my headset.
unfortunately my device does not work. I connect icepop to my G PRO headset and there is no option on the G HUB to activate blue voice. I already performed all the procedures I saw on the internet but nothing appears on the G HUB, even logitech sent me a new icepop but it still doesn't work.
Wow, I did not expect this ... the stock Astro mic definitely has more robust sound and clarity overall. The Blue Icepop unfortunately has this dull flatness to the voice reproduction. A bit disappointed since I've been running it for awhile. Back to the stock mic!
@@sebastianrosenbach7873 To each his own; no need to personally attack me. We're having a discussion here. After watching this video, I actually performed my own test and recorded an identical voice sample on both mics. Then I played those back on a blind test to several people I game with. 90% of them actually preferred the stock mic. I'm not saying it's a bad mic, I'm just saying that there's no compelling difference in the quality of the sound reproduction. If there was, we wouldn't be having this discussion.
if your headset can take a mic like this one and you need an upgrade, sounds like people should get the $14.99 astro A40 mic instead of the $49.99 blue icepop mic for A40 lol
Wait people actually had trouble telling them apart, the ice pop has it so your voice is somewhat clear and not so "loud" and didn't seem to cut you off prematurely as much. Like yes there is clipping at the start and end of both but mic one had it significantly worse
@@phototristan it can’t, what’s weird is since I’ve moved over to editing on my iPad Pro with luma fusion it appears to upscale it or something.. still trying to figure out how that is possible.
![OsamaSon - ik what you did last summer [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4DIQDnu3mr4/mqdefault.jpg)
Actually i can tell different. Astro is more sensitive and more louder than blue ice pop. Blue ice pop is more quiet and sound more natural voice if you know what i mean. So Ice pop is more better quality sound. This is my option.
Thanks for this! I will stick to the stock Astro mic. I immediately thought microphone 1 sounded better. Watched again and still believe it sounds better.
I could tell there were less plosives on the blue icepop mic in this video. I'm sure that's because of the built in pop filter on it. However, last year I had bought some little foam mic covers for the ASTRO A40 standard mic and did the exact same thing. And it sounds awesome. They cost me less than $10 on Amazon, I've only lost one so far and I have 9 left.
Thanks this comment just saved me £45.
@@tammurney3053same here this comment saved me 45$
Just going to say it for everyone. If you have to replace your mic. Probably not a bad idea to have a pop filter.
it would have been nice if you matched the volume levels of the 2 mics so we could really tell the difference in quality, having to adjust the volume adds difficulty towards objective listening
Yeah honestly the difference is not much. Sound wise the Astro sounds better. I have the a40. I bought the blue ice pop simply for how it’s more flexible build but sound wise I don’t think it’s much better
The blue mic does sound better imo but thats probably because of the built in pop filter, you can just save a lot of money by buying a foam cap for the original mic to act as a pop filter.
For sure could tell with the plosives the ice pop is better but aside from that specific thing there is extremely little difference in the sound profiles.
I'd pay 20 for it. They want a lil much though in my opinion.
I could tell by the pop filter, quality wise was pretty equal. Now I’m no way are they the same. I could tell they were different mics just wouldn’t call one better. If you have the money get the blue and only if you’re using that mic while you’re also on twitch or RUclips or whatever. If it’s just for chat then save your money lol
me watching it with my astro a40 😂
I heard mic 1 and thought it was a lot clearer, I have the astro headset and listned through that, I was shocked as I was just about to buy the Blue mic for my headset.
I can hear the difference for sure and the blue icepop to me sounds better. Not by alot, but definitely alittle better
sounds like you recorded this with a gopro
I like to Gucci everything glad I decided to just check reviews before purchasing lol
These should work with HyperX headset then right?
i mean my mic went out so whateves
unfortunately my device does not work.
I connect icepop to my G PRO headset and there is no option on the G HUB to activate blue voice.
I already performed all the procedures I saw on the internet but nothing appears on the G HUB, even logitech sent me a new icepop but it still doesn't work.
Do you have: G pro? Or G Pro X? G Pro does not have Blue Voice!
Wow, I did not expect this ... the stock Astro mic definitely has more robust sound and clarity overall. The Blue Icepop unfortunately has this dull flatness to the voice reproduction. A bit disappointed since I've been running it for awhile. Back to the stock mic!
and you seem to have no idead what a good mic should sound like
@@sebastianrosenbach7873 To each his own; no need to personally attack me. We're having a discussion here. After watching this video, I actually performed my own test and recorded an identical voice sample on both mics. Then I played those back on a blind test to several people I game with. 90% of them actually preferred the stock mic. I'm not saying it's a bad mic, I'm just saying that there's no compelling difference in the quality of the sound reproduction. If there was, we wouldn't be having this discussion.
stock astro sounded better 🤣
I think so too!
astro sounds better
if your headset can take a mic like this one and you need an upgrade, sounds like people should get the $14.99 astro A40 mic instead of the $49.99 blue icepop mic for A40 lol
Wait people actually had trouble telling them apart, the ice pop has it so your voice is somewhat clear and not so "loud" and didn't seem to cut you off prematurely as much. Like yes there is clipping at the start and end of both but mic one had it significantly worse
What video camera are you using these days?
For this video it’s the Sony a6600 with Sigma lens
@@metagamers I didn't think that camera could do 4K 60
@@phototristan it can’t, what’s weird is since I’ve moved over to editing on my iPad Pro with luma fusion it appears to upscale it or something.. still trying to figure out how that is possible.
I could tell the Noise Floor was Higher on the Blue Icepop and the audio was slightly muddy. Compared to the OG Astro A40.
100% you can tell the diffrence I knew stright away mic 2 was the blue
This mic is also for logitech g pro headsets keep that in mind.
Ooof lol the astro mic sounded WAAAAY better lol, it sounded louder and more crisp, im disappointed in Blue
has anyone tried this on a non Logitech headset that can confirm it works? Im leaning towards buying this for my razer blackshark v2
Jesus Christ love you