Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
GIMBAL vs HANDHELD - What wins?!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 янв 2019
- FOLLOW KITTY ☞ bit.ly/2CUt32O
CLIENT HORROR STORIES ☞ • HOW TO AVOID SH*TTY CL...
Kitty and I have a face off! We both shoot the same location but she shoots with a Gimbal, and I shoot entirely handheld! Who win's? You'll have to watch to find out. Stick around and we talk about what we liked/didn't like about each and when you should or shouldn't choose each shooting style!
LET'S BE FRIENDS! :)
✔ SUBSCRIBE: / lizziepeirce
✔ FOLLOW ME ON INSTA: / lizziepeirce
✔ FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: / lizziepeirce
GET MY LIGHTROOM PRESETS HERE ☞www.lizziepeirce.com/shop/thestarterpack
GET MY GO-TO LUT HERE ☞ www.lizziepeirce.com/shop/solsticelut
GET THE VINTAGE preset & DUST filter pack HERE: ☞ www.lizziepeirce.com/shop/vintagepack
FREE BUDGET TEMPLATE ☞ bit.ly/3uWcFbE
FREE PRESET FOR NEON PHOTOS ☞ www.lizziepeirce.com/shop/neonheaven
FREE RUclips HEADER TEMPLATE ☞ www.lizziepeirce.com/shop/channelart
MUSIC ☞ share.mscbd.fm/...
GEAR I USE:
◇ SONY A7 III: (Amazon) geni.us/5ceQ5z
◇ SONY FE 24-70mm f/2.8 GM Lens: (Amazon) geni.us/nRQx1Un
◇ SONY FE 16-35mm f/2.8 GM Lens: (Amazon) geni.us/QoFx
◇ SONY FE 85mm f/1.4 GM Lens: (Amazon) geni.us/HuvHS
◇ GOBE UV, Polarizing & ND FILTERS : bit.ly/2P82iiX
◇ VIDEO MIC PRO PLUS: (Amazon) geni.us/7iONdN
◇ DEADCAT WINDCOVER: (Amazon) geni.us/LLIBT
◇ 5 IN 1 DIFFUSION/BOUNCE: (Amazon) geni.us/OliRJ
◇ JOBY GORILLAPOD: (Amazon) geni.us/6dBBhh
◇ VIEWSONIC VP3881 HERE ☞ smarturl.it/Liz...
◇ VELCRO HACK ☞ (Amazon) geni.us/uvBQeK
Which do you prefer?! Gimbal or handheld?!
Lizzie Peirce handheld was way better... i think its more creative... you can move te camera wherever you want... without any adjustment
I loved the both of them but I think you get more Creative handheld but the gimbal is more easy to make smoooooth shoots ☺️ thanks for a great video 🙏🏻💕
Totally joking here but are you a fan or Sara Dietchy?also just wanted to swing by and say whats up! I like if I had one would use a gimbal but have learned how to shoot handheld pretty decently too
Handheld
Handheld
This was such an amazing collaboration! Great to see you both team up and create this GIMBAL VS HANDHELD shootout. Your content is fun, informative and keeps me hooked to the end, excellent work 👌
I feel like the gimbal makes a ton of sense to get smoother longer motions. I have to say though I really like the handheld most, but I think it was purely the editing... great video!!
They are both really good, but I feel like you cannot really compare them because they have a completely different vibe and music
Yea good point not just the vibe and music but the look handheld gives you that realism look to it. What do ch plays a big role and gimble gives you better and longer extended shots when needed it just comes down to the look your trying to create
same tought
the reality is that you cannot really compare it, just because both the systems give you 2 completely different way to film in hand held you need to do short clips and found a way to attach them, with gimbal is all more controlled but you have the downside of gear and portability.
I agree and the point of having a gimbal is to walk with it to see if it works or not. Both clips are mostly static, so no need a gimbal in my opinion. Ladies have failed ( :D ) show us more difficult tasks a gimbal can/not handle the topic.
Handheld forever!
Ok fine handheld until someday when I can actually buy a decent gimbal that I don't mind lugging around!
Ayyye whats up Jesse!! Love your dope IG story vlogs
Or, you could use that money to buy a plane ticket to visit me. After this visit that you're about to visit.
Ronin S maybe??
JesseDriftwood hey Jesse!!! Got any content for handheld? Help yah brother out here :)
@@jezreelcolangoy3290 I've been working on a video on this very topic!
I like gimbals cause they give us the option to let shots breath more during editing. Going hand held, you have to cut when it starts to shake or warp stabilization starts looking warpy.
But it's nice not having to carry all that equipment too. 🤷🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
Handheld looks like you need to make your edits with shorter clips, do more speed ramping and SloMo to pull it off but it works. Nice job though!
The gimbal shots felt like I was watching a story that was being told. The handheld shots felt like I watching a commercial due to the shorter clips and trendy transitions.
Yay! Been handheld for 2 years now and made me appreciate it even more because I've had gimbal envy for awhile. Handheld forces you to think about your shots more and challenges the creative process. Perfect collab once again! 🙏
Love this! Footage really breaks it down and the differences, but it's your back and forth conversation that I really like! As a solo videographer, we often don't get many opportunities to virtually or personally sit in on these kinds of conversations. Also, I like how you show that both techniques have their place. Thanks for this, Lizzie and Kitty!
Kitty and Lizzie collab? Best day ever!
Yayy!!!
কতো যে বাঞ্ছদ Best Day, আমিই জানি 😏
Eee! Kitty Lizzie collabs are out into the world! I miss you already come back for another shoot out in another location 😄 I loved watching them turn out so different. Mm done!
😂😂 thx for hanging out with me! Mm done! Best outro!
[Whoa why did i reply to so many people?...]
The gimble was super smooth and the hand help was moving with its music well making nothing noticeable. Different music's that made them look dope, keep up the enthusiasm
even if i hold my camera close to my body's centre of mass, very firmly but not too rigidly and allow my elbows to convert kinetic energy to heat by dampening the oscillation, my clips still come out like i have parkinson's disease. so i think gimbal is a must for me.
haha best comment and very accurate for someone like me as well!!!
Haha very scientific there.
depends one the lens and if ur using a crop sensor camera trust me on a 16mm it wont be as shaky handheld
That’s why their shots were stabilized! If you have IBIS and IS on your lens , done!
It's an old OLD secret. What she did is shoot in 60FPS, interpreted footage to 30fps, then slowed it down again and used Optical Flow Frame Blending. That gives you silky smooth...I mean SUPER SMOOTH footage. Trust me...she isn't holding the camera any better than you. The title is BS.
I’m gonna watch this when I have WiFi but I’m pumped 👏👏👏
Lucy Martin whoa! Lucys here!
Awesome video, Lizzie! I literally just bought a DJI Ronin S today so it was a funny coincidence to see this video from you today. There are definitely pros and cons to both, and it was great to see yours and Kitty's footage side by side!
I LOVE a varied mix of both, balancing it depending on what is happening and where the story is going.
gosh it’s so reassuring to see more female videographers! I’ve been watching gimbal reviews all day and finally to find a female review was a breath of fresh air. Regardless of gender, y’all are so good at what you do. I subscribed SO FAST
O yaaa..!! Women empowerment kind of girl...
Agreeeed!
Yes!
first time seeing kitty footage i thought there is no way lizzie would win. but lizzie footage are awesome too! both of you are the best
I think the hand held forces you to be a tad more creative and hard working which could lead to cooler shots... but both are dope :)
I think the combination of gimbal and handheld is perfect, you can have the camera in your hand and its fun and you can use the gimbal and make sick videos!
Been watching Kitty for awhile, pumped to find Lizzie!
The Greatest Crossover of 2019.
Lol Jason
Jason Vong hey jason! U know what?! Were little pickles!!!!!!
In realtime speed motion on the move, gimbal wins out 99%, but in slow mo hand held can look good too, as the imperfections don't show as readily obvious to the eye.
It's what ever you want the finished effect to be,....and that counts!
Either way, have fun🙂👍
I think both have their use.. Loved this duo!
It’s so nice to see women in the filmmaking world ! I’m the only girl the works in the filmmaking world in the place that a live!
Loved this video! Super interesting and inspiring getting to see both your visual styles, framing/composition for the same location - just goes to show it's not about what gear you have to make great videos, it's always about how you use that gear!
I'm really inspired by videos like these that show that you can achieve some really awesome results without super expensive equipment. It's really nice knowing that I can learn a lot with handheld footage
Both are gorgeous! But lizzie’s handheld shot is da bomb!
Lizzie I definitely like your style way more. I believe a mix of handheld and gimbal shots are needed. but your edit killed it! but i feel your pain shooting entirely hand held . EXCELLENT JOB!
Handheld 🙌🙌
Fernando Valon 😉
Great subject!I 👍 used my Ronin-S gimbal so much when I first got it in August but lately I've found myself shooting like 90% handheld cause it's faster in run and gun situations. But certain shots, like the low to the ground follow shot, I obviously need to shoot with a gimbal!
Handheld video is the winner for me.👍🏻
A lot of people totally forget about the basics of composing a cinematic shot, as soon as they're holding a gimbal. You both did a great job. I personally love the handheld clip more. Although the shots are shorter in the handheld clip, the gimbal clip felt more restless because of the constant movement.
The rotating shot of the birds is still super badass! You ladies are both so dope!
Thanks so much guys. Love this segment.
I'm handheld but the Lizzie video is far superior, I mean is cinema.
Handheld wins only for the fact that the story line and sequence of clips makes way more sense. I like mixing up gimbal and handheld in a video.
Wow preety cool RUclips channel. Finally new creators in the areahh! Can't wait to join the crew!
I'm choosing some gear for upcoming project. Definitely try to do it handheld.
Fairly new to shooting with a gimbal here - i feel like there's a new "language" to learn when using the gimbal.
One thing i noticed when i saw your videos side-by-side, handheld tends to move "from behind" the camera. The gimbal move moves a bit behind behind the camera (if that makes any sense?). The gimbal tends to make me do the same shots over and over. Pans, tilts up/down, etc. at the same speed, the same move, and so on.
Would be interesting to see this challenge again but none of you guys can shoot more than 24fps.
Personally I prefer handheld and it's strictly because most of the things I film are run and gun/spur of the moment type things and staying handheld allows to me be the most nimble with my camera. For example, I could be snapping pics of a spot and then something happens I want to film. I imagine that transition would be significantly easier without a gimbal. That being said, I would love a chance one day with a gimbal on a whole storyboarded video. Awesome job both of you. The Palace of Fine Art is such a beautiful spot
machajohn totally agree! That’s why I use it most often but I still find myself needing a few gimbal shots for the perfect edit
The handheld shots with the quick change edit was more interesting
A gimbal has the mentioned advantages. I'm amazed at how good both videos look. I like both of them equally. Great work, ladies.
Gimbal all the way🤙🏽
The gimbal is more work, but it really comes down to a persons shooting style.
You two gave a great pro and cons list for both handheld and gimbal shooting 🙏🏼🙏🏼🤙🏽☀️
For me Lizzie smashed it!
I like the gimbal shots, seems easier to use but the handheld is cool too. I need a gimbal 😭
Both clips came out amazing but I’m honestly Impressed how hand held came out!!
I felt both were exceptional clips and equally stable. However, what took my focus was how creative the two of you are and educational it was looking at the variation of two different clips for the same area. Great vlog
I'm rooting for Kitty just because I love kittyyyyyyyy!
I absolutely love the music in Kitty's clip
I like each of your B roll sequences individually. They both had their own unique feel. If I picked a personal favorite I would say Handheld because it feels like you are put more INTO the scene. I do still appreciate to solid quality of a gimbal shot though! You both are b roll Queens!
Handheld killed it with the music
If both combined will be unstoppable :)
Wow. You both are great photographers. Excellent job
I love your way of shooting
I love Kitty's work. But Lizzie nailed the transitions 😍
Surely using a camera that shoots 120fps helps massively in having super steady b-roll when handheld, it ends up looking as smooth as with a gimble. It'd be cool to see a vid like this on a cheaper camera that doesn't support 120.
Loved the smooth gimbal shots but that handheld final edit was amazing. Great comparison!
I think you should be able to do both. I feel that the gimbal is hands down my go to for any job or paying work. Road trips and little adventures with the friends hand held is nice when you’re not having to lug around the gimbal.
Prefer Handheld a lot but a couple of shots with gimbal add some dynamics in the edit. Its like drone shots.. too much is not good but a few shots here and there is really cool !
I really loved the handheld portion. But also the edit was faster. But as you mentioned, that was sort of a result of the fact that you couldn’t use longer shots in the edit because of the shake - so maybe handheld actually forces people to make faster paced videos, which I like - like it informs the whole feel of the vid. As I am sure you are going to mention, likely the best effect is gonna be mixing the two.
Lizzie smashed it!!!
Such a true video on this gimbal hype, it's all about how creative you are! The less gear you have, the more creative you will be! Thanks girls, keep on rolling those clips! :-)
I think this shot turned out perfect! Looks like you're tracking that bird! 5:38
Its like: "Tele or wideangle? Which lens is better?" First you decide what you want to shoot and what you want it to look like, then you figure out how to get there. Gimbals are clearly very usefull with smooth movements, but its getting really annoying if overused. Also there are stabilized cameras like the GH5, which allow you to do a lot without a gimbal.
Lizzie, you think you can do a video on how to create a creative spot for let's say a kitchen or bathroom Reno effectively (30 secs)? In other words, not Real Estate, but design of a room...the details of a cabinet, hardware, etc. I would love to see how you would do it (female perspective).
Lizzie your sequence was 🔥 buttery smooth handheld!
Would have never known your shots are handheld! Impressive.! 'm going to work on my handheld stuff!
I love the moza! But I feel like it lacks a little bit on the z-axis
Both of these sequences are awesome! Really inspired by what you came up with just shooting handheld! Love the idea of using your body as your own steadicam. I've always just tried to crouch or walk slow but those tips really help!
Both look great, I use the gimbal when tracking people but I prefer handheld for just moving around and getting different angles.
Both. If you own a gimbal, you can choose which way to shoot a scene
I guess it is how you use it, not what you use. I like both.
Both videos looked awesome.
handheld (not confused with shoulder support or rig) without good ibis is not done in much situation for professional production with lighter camera's. Only if u are master and have a stable hand. Handheld (not confused with shoulder support or rig) can be used in reality tv or some fast action scenes/sports and amateur looks.
Great shots for my 2 idols
Well, like you said; they each have their character, so it's more what you want to tell with the shot. Great video, that was some stunning looking material!
*I use both when filming my history vlogs* I guess it’s like:
What’s quick that looks cool to shoot!
I’ve got time to shoot this shot, let’s gimbal it!
I need to be up in the Sky for this. Let’s get the drone out.
Each device to fulfil each artistic need within the time frame or physical restriction to each shoot.
I own a tabby cat btw. He’s called George and is a legend.
Great tips ladies. I like the gimbal when I’m trying to get clean shots without shaking but sometimes the shaking gets the audience in the action. Just depends!
Gimbal all the way! Love the smooth movement. Also have a quick release plate on the gimbal in case I need to capture those quick handheld moments.
Nice double collab day!
Lizzie your handheld is awesome, buttery smooth, looks almost gimba-ish! 😁
Weeeeee!
The Gimbal one is more like simple smooth video but .. the handheld has more advanced editing ..transitions, speed ramping ect.
I would combine the gimbal with more advanced editing and would looks amazing! Both great videos. I would have use the same music for both of u to actually see the difference.
the shots i really liked the gimbal was the tracking shot of the swan (goose?) and then the running follow shot of lizzie. but overall i much prefer the handheld shots. I'm very sensitive to the footstep movement that i feel like i see in most gimbal shots these days and totally takes me out of the moment.
Both clips are really nice. It really comes down to great editing ! Each method seems to be best suited for different things.
Videos are in slow motion - that reduce visible shakes, try to compare straight of camera sample. Gimbal always wins but who want to take big chunky gimbal always whith him. The best solution for everyday use is IBIS (but good IBIS).
slow motion and steady arm movements still look really nice. wish i knew i could do this before i bought a gimbal lol
Love kitty! So happy to see her here and this collaboration! Great video!!
Dam!! The gimbal shot was good but the handheld shots were awesome! How u get to shoot that circle roof patterns when it was turning. Anyway well done to both of you. Worth the visit to your channel. Great Work!
Both are so good
Great stuff ladies! Lizzies edit was better in my opinion but the dynamics of using a stabilizer are hard to match :) love y'all!
l feel like the gimbal had a lot more movement to it. Curious if she used it in FPV mode. Both great! just prefer the gimbal look
the power of editing makes the video flawless
try make it longer moving video than gimbal will take place
I will say, I definitely preferred the handheld edit, not just for the handheld...ness? but I'm more of a fan of the upbeat flow of it. I feel a filmmaker should have great handheld skills, but a gimbal is great for getting some really, buttery, silky gold and some shots that you sometimes just can't get (Or its just difficult doing) with handheld.
i love the hand held
I prefer the gimbal!! But handheld has other areas its better at!
I like to shoot with a gimbal mostly because it's easier, but I also notice a tendency to go for longer takes and sometimes the shots end up looking too languid to a point sometimes where there is a feeling of unreality to the shots already. Which makes me miss the somewhat shakiness of handheld that gives a feeling of nowness and of intruding on a hard reality. On analysis, it's the French New Wave style of handheld camerawork aesthetic fighting the Hollywood slickness in me.
It's so hard to compare because the style is so different. I liked the Gimbal footage better personally but I wonder if I would feel differently if you both shot the same stuff. I can't use a gimbal because I don't have the strength and then my arms are super shakey. Got to do more push-ups I guess!
Loved the throw away comment about a metal music vid, normally a music stills photographer but have a possible music video project coming up (as well as a general interest in getting into video more as well) so have been thinking of gimbals and what not.
Loved both clips and can see how a combination of the two could also work together for their own qualities. Even in a metal music vid I could see a gimbal being useful for certain times of shots, even if chaotically cut with madness interspersed...