I made a mistake, Naevys may not be JWK, aeboards utilize their own molds but there is no confirmation on who manufactures the switches. My bad! Also, there was a mistake in the description of Zykos, it's PANDA tops, not Boba. Sorry about that!
Btw Shoobs, you don’t take things “as” a grain of salt, you take things “with” a grain of salt ;) I figured you were just saying it wrong, but it’s written like that in your intro disclaimer as well.
@@boiledicetea no it isn't. it literally doesn't have a membrane. rubber domes don't necessarily have to use membranes and membranes don't necessarily use rubber domes. its a capacitive design, therefore it has a pcb and no membrane.
Pls help my eyes are swollen and feel like exploding so this is last video for tonight Edit: we shall also wait for glarses due to the inclusion of Mx browns in tha tactile category
You mean the time it takes to switch a single key switch and keycap and the then tap it consistently till it comes. And repeat? He only gets credit if he had done each board entirely filled with a switch with a real typing test. Then went back and lubed them. Then filmed and lube. That’s work son. This is just jerking off the z key.
You can actually compare tactility by pressing two switches with the same spring against each other. Holy pandas are a lot less tactile than all franken variants with zealios and boba bottoms and even zealios and u4t themselves in my testing.
So lubed my favorite are Okomochi's, but they still sound a bit too scratchy. Is there a switch with a similar, deep and soft sound with less scratchyness?
@@metrogrinch9316 ive looked all over for good tactiles, most of then are either unavailable or sound pretty bad. No idea why pandas are so popular. U4S is probably the 2nd closest switch that i found thats pretty decent, but its so hard to find in stock
Thank you so much for this fantastic comparison - the video is really informative and I love how you scored the switches according to different parameters and visually ranked them, easy to follow and visualise! One suggestion: working a bit on your audio (recording and post) would be a great way to boost your videos. You have a very calm voice and smooth humour, both things you should capitalise on on the audio department :)
Excuse my ignorance but I want to assemble my Bykos Switches and I have the doubt if the top can be from the boba U4 instead of the boba U4T, or if they are very different and would not feel the same. Thanks, I really liked the video
So I've heard some pretty mixed results from Kailh Box Royals. I've heard that they are very tactile (some even say they are more tactile than Zealios), but they also turn slightly clicky after a couple of weeks of use. What are your thoughts?
I'm not him but I've used royals for half a year now and yes, they get noticeably clicky, although you can allegedly fix it by lubing the leaf of the switch. I really like their tactility because they're very sharp and not drawn out like zealios or most other modern tactiles are
Thanks for tbe video! Great overview and really interesting getting other people's take on tactiles. Since you have the parts for it, could you try putting a Dark Jade stem and spring into a Kiwi housing (bottom and top?) I really want to know if I'm the only person who finds this frankenswitche really appealing. To me it feels even than Bykos. Thanks dude!
Most to least tactile: zykos (panda invyr top halo stem zealios bottom) / bykos (boba top halo stem zealios bottom) zealios moyu black holy boba/holy panda boba u4t glorious panda blueberries/holy t1 t1/okomochi paco kiwi ergo clear outemu sky/lilac/navies dragonfruit pewter mx glarses (brown)
Quick question, I hope I just didn't notice you mention this in the video but were all their spring weights the same? Because I've heard that you made rules for the sound test but I don't think there were some for the feel/tactility test. Thank you Shoobs! Great video as always!!
For the tests, I just used the stock springs for each switch. I got the lowest offered weight for each switch but yeah I did not spring swap for the tests.
Tactiles are super hard to cover honestly, I prefer to speak on linears haha. Just gotta put disclaimers to let people know that my information may not be 100% accurate
Genuine and probably ignorant question: during the wobble test visually I notice way less wobble in the "wobbly boys" and much more in the "nice" ones. Am I missing something? I assume wobble is just clearance between the stem and top housing, Sky Blues for example seem to have A TON of wiggle room judging by the video
Yo Shoobs, with your Moyu Blacks what films did you use? I've seen people saying you need to use TX Thin 0.125mm but I wanted to know if there is any truth to that. I normally use Deskeys but they are fairly thick in comparisons.
I know that I will be unpleasant but force curve graphs should be the first and main way to learn about switch behavior. Subjective comments do not allow an informed purchase. The very definition of tactility is extremely uncertain and subjective. For example a 50g pump with no pre-travel feels "more tactile" then a 65g pump with a little pre-travel.
We need a silent switch comparison now, sir. I'm desperate because It practically does not exist on RUclips and there are so many good factory and frankenswitch options now. halp
I made a mistake, Naevys may not be JWK, aeboards utilize their own molds but there is no confirmation on who manufactures the switches. My bad! Also, there was a mistake in the description of Zykos, it's PANDA tops, not Boba. Sorry about that!
Rest easy soldier
A man of culture o7
F
what are those keycaps looks minimalistic and clean
@@koyonari1843 the mode is GMK 8008, the BoW one is GMK metaverse
you actual madman, thank you for this
Shoobs is the scuffed god we didn’t know we needed
Oh! Hello there Hamaji
I am waiting for Glarses comment on 18:12
no, thank you for giving me the push to sleep at 4am instead of 5am
hamini neo
Funny how i went from watching your videos about tf2 and then becoming intrested about mech keyboards
No one wants to get shit talked about one's hololove addiction
judgment free zone
Bruh the voice that shoobs uses When he does the stem wobble test sounds like the optician s giving me and eyetest, number one or number two
shoobs is the best keyboard youtuber hands down he is 🤌🤌🤌
Silent tactile next
Btw Shoobs, you don’t take things “as” a grain of salt, you take things “with” a grain of salt ;) I figured you were just saying it wrong, but it’s written like that in your intro disclaimer as well.
this comment just changed my life.... I've been saying "as" for my whole life lmao. no one stopped me.
@@ShoobsTube [as]
lol, didn't notice he wrote that
I want to see you suffer, where's the Big Bad Clicky Switch review and the Big Bad Membrane Keyboard Review peepoSmile
topre is technically membrane so it wont be full pain
@@boiledicetea no it isn't. it literally doesn't have a membrane. rubber domes don't necessarily have to use membranes and membranes don't necessarily use rubber domes. its a capacitive design, therefore it has a pcb and no membrane.
@@NautsuJJR sorry i forgot it had a pcb
@@NautsuJJR A Model M would be a membrane board which is clicky tho :D Of course, no domes(usually), but still
Big bad clickies but only alps clickies
Intro: *zooming into MX Browns*
Glarses: And I took that personally.
I didn't realize we got another marvel movie #lineargang
Shut up nerd
#lineargang
Y
X
#lineargang
Shoobs finally came out of his editing dungeon
Now I sleep... or not
@@ShoobsTube 6am gang amirite
@@chunkymilk1288 basically my schedule nowadays lmao
i went to sleep at like 3pm last night, i mean day
@@ShoobsTube you re not weak?
You forgot to rank by empirically the most important metric: housing and stem color
This can't be legit, he's not wearing any ring
my fingers were too tired from hitting the one key
Glause should like this one. Team Tactile! 💥
Tactile Gang rise up
Pls help my eyes are swollen and feel like exploding so this is last video for tonight
Edit: we shall also wait for glarses due to the inclusion of Mx browns in tha tactile category
Some say he's still tapping the Z key
@Caleb Danis wut
Do silent switches next, I am having fun with this series.
yes please, Silents of any kind are better than both linears and tactiles imo
@@StaticNebula26 um... silents are either linear or tactile lmao
@@amathine440 I was saying that I like both silent linears and silent tactiles together more than the others
And I like silent tactiles the most
@@StaticNebula26 ah that makes a lot more sense
@@StaticNebula26 kinda late but what silent tactiles would u recommend
holy shit that's a lot of switches
YOOOOOOOO NEW SHOOBS UPLOAD
hopefully this one isn’t a mistake
Edit: it wasn’t a mistake
every video I make is a mistake
@@ShoobsTube can’t tell if your videos are a mistake with good moments or mechanical keyboards as a whole are a mistake with good moments
I'm a mistake
>*wobble tests Outemu Skyblues*
What he said: "nice"
What he meant: "I... don't even want to comment on this"
Gazzew so good
Goated
so lit
Changed the game, got me into frankenswitches
damn shoobs really blew up in just a few months. Congrats man!
wait. didnt you already have a big linear switch comparison video?
oh wait jk. its tactile.
bro i love the wobble tests he does for these videos, its always so scuffed and he's just rambling to himself... love this guy
Again i will say you are doing gods work
it must be done
I wasn’t a tactile guy until I tried the U4T. That’s a game changing switch.
lube or stock? :)
Holy! I can't even imagine the time that took to make this! Thanks for putting this together for everyone brother!
You mean the time it takes to switch a single key switch and keycap and the then tap it consistently till it comes. And repeat? He only gets credit if he had done each board entirely filled with a switch with a real typing test. Then went back and lubed them. Then filmed and lube. That’s work son. This is just jerking off the z key.
another degen hours upload, thanks shoobs
You can actually compare tactility by pressing two switches with the same spring against each other. Holy pandas are a lot less tactile than all franken variants with zealios and boba bottoms and even zealios and u4t themselves in my testing.
About time you did this. THANK YOU SHOOBS
So lubed my favorite are Okomochi's, but they still sound a bit too scratchy. Is there a switch with a similar, deep and soft sound with less scratchyness?
Yh same the sound was really inconsistant
@@metrogrinch9316 ive looked all over for good tactiles, most of then are either unavailable or sound pretty bad. No idea why pandas are so popular. U4S is probably the 2nd closest switch that i found thats pretty decent, but its so hard to find in stock
This video feels like a radical candy shop. But in reality, candies are disguised drugs, and you entered a drug cartel.
Thank you for the video.
@Shoobs can you overlay the price of each switch when you do the scales of tactility and sound? Adding the switch name could also be helpful
I can only imagine all the random switch parts you have lying around your room 😂
What a banger of a video! Truly a memer of culture taking the hit o7
thank you engy
DADDY SHOOBS I WAITED ALL DAY
sorry it took so long, it was a long one
@@ShoobsTube no problem man great video keep up the great content
Wow! Such a great collection of tactiles! :D
f
Thank you so much for this fantastic comparison - the video is really informative and I love how you scored the switches according to different parameters and visually ranked them, easy to follow and visualise!
One suggestion: working a bit on your audio (recording and post) would be a great way to boost your videos. You have a very calm voice and smooth humour, both things you should capitalise on on the audio department :)
based outro choice and helpful vid overall
u4t is the new king under 1$ switch
Excuse my ignorance but I want to assemble my Bykos Switches and I have the doubt if the top can be from the boba U4 instead of the boba U4T, or if they are very different and would not feel the same. Thanks, I really liked the video
I have exactly the same doubt
So I've heard some pretty mixed results from Kailh Box Royals. I've heard that they are very tactile (some even say they are more tactile than Zealios), but they also turn slightly clicky after a couple of weeks of use. What are your thoughts?
I'm not him but I've used royals for half a year now and yes, they get noticeably clicky, although you can allegedly fix it by lubing the leaf of the switch. I really like their tactility because they're very sharp and not drawn out like zealios or most other modern tactiles are
SO CLOSE TO 10K!!!! wooooo
shoobs time.... let's fuckin goooooo 😏
Great video! I like the part where you demonstrated each switch one after another by spam clicking consistently. Very helpful.
i dont think anyone can beat boba u4ts for the price to performance that it delivers
Yeah the bobas are the thockiest, it’s just what he heard
Browns are endgame switches
one of my favorite linears for sure
reject tactility, return to mx browns
Based on sound alone, I like the Browns, the naevys and the bykos (unlubed)
Just got boba u4t switches after watching your review
they are so good man
@@ShoobsTube Thanks for the review :)
whered u get yours???
@@D1G17ALH3X from aliexpress - store owner is MKzealots
Thanks for tbe video! Great overview and really interesting getting other people's take on tactiles.
Since you have the parts for it, could you try putting a Dark Jade stem and spring into a Kiwi housing (bottom and top?) I really want to know if I'm the only person who finds this frankenswitche really appealing. To me it feels even than Bykos. Thanks dude!
Most to least tactile:
zykos (panda invyr top halo stem zealios bottom) / bykos (boba top halo stem zealios bottom)
zealios
moyu black
holy boba/holy panda
boba u4t
glorious panda
blueberries/holy t1
t1/okomochi
paco
kiwi
ergo clear
outemu sky/lilac/navies
dragonfruit
pewter
mx glarses (brown)
Clicky switches next?👀👀
What are the bykos made of ?
Quick question, I hope I just didn't notice you mention this in the video but were all their spring weights the same? Because I've heard that you made rules for the sound test but I don't think there were some for the feel/tactility test. Thank you Shoobs! Great video as always!!
For the tests, I just used the stock springs for each switch. I got the lowest offered weight for each switch but yeah I did not spring swap for the tests.
@@ShoobsTube then again, this is obviously such a hard and painstaking topic to do 😂 Kudos to you man!
Good on you for making a disclaimer that there’s different tactilities for different people. Great video, I appreciate the lack of filter too.
Tactiles are super hard to cover honestly, I prefer to speak on linears haha. Just gotta put disclaimers to let people know that my information may not be 100% accurate
@@ShoobsTube I do the same thing. I’m sure you’re aware :p
Congrats on 9k
every video has so much "shoobs essence" its so special and I just had the best dish washing session of my life to this video thanks shoobs 👍👍
What is your daily driver
When the Dragon Fruits first came out I asked TKC directly on IG what the housing material is and they told me "the same as Kiwis"
AND kiwi's housing material are described multiple times online as "the same as Tangerines"
why cant they just write "UHMWPE" for all three 🥲
Gotta respect the effort that went into this. Righteous work, man.
thank man, it took a while to get everything together.
Thanks Shoobs. Nice vid. Ever sense I got a buckling spring ⌨️ no MX switch can compete.
My favorite ones and the ones I want are the Okomochi. Seems they have been discontinued though. RIP
Genuine and probably ignorant question: during the wobble test visually I notice way less wobble in the "wobbly boys" and much more in the "nice" ones. Am I missing something?
I assume wobble is just clearance between the stem and top housing, Sky Blues for example seem to have A TON of wiggle room judging by the video
Yo Shoobs, with your Moyu Blacks what films did you use? I've seen people saying you need to use TX Thin 0.125mm but I wanted to know if there is any truth to that. I normally use Deskeys but they are fairly thick in comparisons.
8:05 u4t
8:55 glorious panda
6:35 kiwi
lubed
11:47 u4t
12:38 glorious panda
10:15 kiwi
I'm looking for that just angry sounding tactile, I already have anubis, what might be fake holy panda any suggestions? is u4t any good in 2023?
TRY EM ALL BABY i just got arctos naevys and aliaz its finna get WEIRD
Someone, please help! I LOVE the feel of tactile switches… but LOVE the sound of thocky poppy linear switches. 😭
I really like your vids man :) Keep it going!
btw #clickygang here :D
much wow! next KANGAROO switches! great video comparison! much in-depth ! very nice!!!
yes
I know that I will be unpleasant but force curve graphs should be the first and main way to learn about switch behavior. Subjective comments do not allow an informed purchase.
The very definition of tactility is extremely uncertain and subjective. For example a 50g pump with no pre-travel feels "more tactile" then a 65g pump with a little pre-travel.
dont boba u4ts have long pole?
they do
This is such a thorough list. Well made. +1 sub
6:35
10:15
We need a silent switch comparison now, sir. I'm desperate because It practically does not exist on RUclips and there are so many good factory and frankenswitch options now. halp
Love your intro
keyboard + watame. I think I found my favorite keyboard youtuber lol
Im just getting into the keyboard stuff, learning there are Red Brown Blue, green black silver and other switches
Wat de hell is dis
Thanks, I have decided they all suck and I will go with Khailh blues for my endgame
You put a linear in the thumbnail.
Cherry MX Browns aren’t tactile
999th like 😈
Your my favorite keyboard youtubers, I am so glad I found your 100-250 keeb video
Why no Big Bad Clicky Switch Comparison :(
next time when you make those comparisons you should add text on the screen to differentiate them beyond describing them verbally
The holy pandas are obviously the highest pitch of them all lol... Have you listened to your own video?
are these including clicky switches too?
im sorry if this is too much but can you make a video of a Big Bad Tactile/Linear switch and Plate comparison in one video?
What keycap set is on that keyboard Shoobs? The one you used for the wobble test.... reminds me of the red and blue samurai sets from gmmk.
Hi
hi
one day you should add ajazz kiwi switches compared to the c3 kiwis
U should hv tried out the Soju switches as well cuz I think they r more tactile than Zykos.
Why are kiwis the best and people who say otherwise have wrong preference ( ^_- )
Your just bloody weird. Chill with the anime mate!
I think it would've been better if you didn't spam the keys like a madman
he said juul whilst talking in the switches info, you vape kid?
Im thinking snag sum kiwis instead of tangerines for my next switch.
plsssss someone tell me what those keycaps are called and if they are available somewhere OMG
Not first
Can you please press the key slower on the sound test cause most people don’t hit the key like they’re having a seizure