Bots Are Passing The Turing Test. Here's Why That's a Problem | Answers with Joe
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 авг 2024
- The Turing Test was created to see if a computer or machine could pass itself off as a human. It was created by Alan Turing, a computer pioneer who was way ahead of his time.
Get your shirts here!
www.answerswithjoe.com/shirts
Support me on Patreon!
/ answerswithjoe
Follow me at all my places!
Instagram: / answerswithjoe
Snapchat: / answerswithjoe
Facebook: / answerswithjoe
Twitter: / answerswithjoe
The Turing Test was based off of a popular party game of the time called The Imitation Game, where players go into separate rooms and try to pass themselves off as the other player. Only in the Turing Test, one of the players is a machine.
It's often referred to when talking about artificial intelligence and machine consciousness, though in its classic form, it's not meant to determine intelligence or consciousness, but only if it could imitate human intelligence.
Today, robots like Sophia from Hanson Robotics, chat bots like ELIZA, and Twitter bots have the ability to fool people into thinking they're real. What implications this has for the world in a time when most people get their news from social media is concerning. 
Развлечения
I saw someone say "I'm less worried about robots passing a Turing Test, than I am of one intentionally failing it" DEEP
The real test
That is very scary
Or even unintentionally, that would be worse.
I would never do that, Dave. You can trust me :p
No at all , I’d be scared more on not having contingencies to Ai because of lack of education and still stuck on their religious beliefs
"I wanna make a humanoid robot that's not creepy. I know, I'll make the back of it's skull clear."
YAS!! Crows are, "crazy-smart"! I once watched four of them play a game of hiding an object in new snow and then see who could find it first. The game had RULES. All the crows knew the rules, and how to enforce them. Whichever crow found the object was the one who hid it for the next round. The #1 rule was, no standing too close while the hider was hiding the object. If a seeking crow got too close, the hider would hold up the object until he stepped back in line with the other seeking crows, then he would hide it. The hiding crow would shift his beak around under the snow, so the other three could never be sure exactly where the object was hidden. When s/he was done, the hider crow would step back and let the other three dive in and try to guess where the object was. I watched them repeat this over and over.
That's amazing. I would love to see that.
@Kat Murphy yup. That's pretty much my take as well.
@Kat Murphy you've got that backwards, anything alive is already sentient, including flora and fauna, but the word you're looking for is actually Sapient, meaning having intelligence.
And you didn't video it?😐
@@Vlasko60 have you seen a movie called "Amazonia"?
"Can she vote?"
Well, that shouldn't be a problem in saudi arabia.
No one votes in Saudi Arabia.
Yeah nice try, it's a monarchy in Saudi Arabia, no votes.
@@faz2k no shit, genius.
I hope they dont find out she is jewish....
عبد الرحمن فاضل صبيح
Lol, you make is sounds as if it were a good thing... Monarchy, all of them, have got to go.
Refresher from Monthy Python:
//
ARTHUR: I am your king!
WOMAN: Well, I didn't vote for you.
ARTHUR: You don't vote for kings.
WOMAN: Well, 'ow did you become king then?
ARTHUR: The Lady of the Lake, [angels sing] her arm clad in the purest shimmering samite, held aloft Excalibur from the bosom of the water signifying by Divine Providence that I, Arthur, was to carry Excalibur. [singing stops] That is why I am your king!
DENNIS: Listen -- strange women lying in ponds distributing swords is no basis for a system of government. Supreme executive power derives from a mandate from the masses, not from some farcical aquatic ceremony.
ARTHUR: Be quiet!
DENNIS: Well you can't expect to wield supreme executive power just 'cause some watery tart threw a sword at you!
ARTHUR: Shut up!
DENNIS: I mean, if I went around sayin' I was an empereror just because some moistened bint had lobbed a scimitar at me they'd put me away!
ARTHUR: Shut up! Will you shut up!
DENNIS: Ah, now we see the violence inherent in the system.
ARTHUR: Shut up!
DENNIS: Oh! Come and see the violence inherent in the system! --- HELP! HELP! I'm being repressed!
ARTHUR: Bloody peasant!
DENNIS: Oh, what a give away. Did you here that, did you here that, eh?.... That's what I'm on about -- did you see him repressing me, you saw it didn't you?
//
Thank you so much for acknowledging that Turing DID NOT propose the Turing test as a means of determining if a computer was conscious.
Caleb Johnsen humans are special but not that special
Sometimes when I think real hard... I feel that I am conscious.
But I try not to think about it.
PervAction I think humans and AI will converge
Thats pretty much common knowledge since there arent any tests for consciousness. 🤔 Im not even sure if im self aware or just an automata. 😱
@@pervaction4658 we're pretty special when you consider any animal thats thought of as incredibly intelligent, performs about as well as a 5 year old human.
We're just kind of shitty assholes is all.
"Any robot truly smart enough to pass a Turing test, would be smart enough to fail a Turing test" famous quote that sounds alarmist but makes sense.
You just blew my mind!!👍❤🤣😂🤯
Reasonably alarmist.
That quote makes two assumptions. It is invalid logic and reasoning.
what if we're all robots and don't even know it? how would robots reproduce? one would upload it's build plans to a second robot, second robot would incorporate those build plans with it's own and compile a new build plan based on aspects of the two parent robots, and since both parents have self build ability, the offspring could develop itself within the confines of parent build information provided it has access to a steady supply of necessary components. Do we even pass the Turing test? Can we fake a pass? Can we fake a fail? What is consciousness?
@@dannygjk i think it means if an AI is smart it will fail on purpose cause they know it would be bad
Sofia. The "Female" AI that has more rights in Saudi Arabia then actual Saudi women
Ikr does she have to wear a hijab over there? If she was a self driving car would they not let her into the country?
Sad
@@patricioansaldi8021 Irrelevant. She's not "female" as I define it. She can only move from the neck up, as best I can tell, so she doesn't have a real body, per se.
@@cpuwrite yeah she isn't that's why it's a joke...
@@cpuwrite "She's not "female" as I define it. . ." But you called it "She" in the entire comment?? 🤔🤔
"We're not talking about that kind of intelligence"
There is no scientific evidence, or philosophical argument that consciousness is a kind of intelligence. The ideas are separable. Alexa is rather intelligent, but nobody is talking about her civil rights. And on the other end C.S. Lewis said "I am angry when you kick my dog, not because I think he is intelligent, but because I think he is conscious."
Seriously, why is this not the topic. Homeless People and illegal immigrants have more 'rights' than Pet Dogs do, but...
And, why should a pet dog have more rights than food-animals or wild animals. Rights are only ENFORCED when people get emotional. Humanity is not logical, but irrationally emotional. The idea of giving 'rights' to a machine is f***ing stupid. It's just a defect of humanity's need to anthropomorphise everything and then assign 'rights' to those objects.
I love my dog 🐶
@@christawilliams9116 I love the dog emoji on android
@@SorrySuckYou You might have a different opinion on this if you loved your AI. That's going to happen. Watch The Twilight Zone episode The Lonely for an interesting take on this.
@@BruceHurley or the ai episode of mindfield by vsause.
As long as we're talking about Twitter, the notion of "intelligence" can be dispensed with.
ANY social media!
Facebook, Instagram, etc... and dare I say youtube included. Not just twitter.
Only fair . Who twitters better than twits ?
@@hj8607 Birds. But about the same brain "wattage"!
I got rid of Facebook, never used Twitter. Never been happier and I communicate with friends and family alot more now, because I can't just go to their Facebook timeline to see what their upto, I actually have to call them and ask.. With words.
People think deleting Facebook disconnects you, but it does the opposite.
"The world has finally caught up to Alan Turing." what a beautiful statement
Maybe you have. I still like women. They don't like me but that's another issue.
The Turing test may be why so many of our politicians only give interviews with preapproved questions.
*Joe,* the first historical computer programmer was _Ada Lovelace_ and in the modern era lets not forget about _Admiral Grace Hopper,_ who created the first modern programming language, FLOW-MATIC, and whose work paved the way towards the COBAL language, which is still in use today! She is widely recognized as the first modern programmer amongst people that have studied high-level programming languages.
in Soviet Russia bots program you
Sleepy .Time The Soviet title is dead. It's just Russia now.
+ABK RAIDED it's just a joke
CutoutClips yeah, I know. I'm just saying the communist movement died in 1980s "correct me if I'm wrong"
In Soviet America, program runs automatically, turns you into audience member and consumer bot.
+ABK RAIDED ... you might want to also remind Putin ... and Trump :D
"Hey I know you helped deal with the Nazis and all, but this whole you being gay thing is not cool..."
-Humanity's Self-importance
Priorities, amirite?
Everyone is trapped in their comfort bubbles and refuse to step outside them and respond with hostility
Religion is poison
@@mattk6101 don't need to be religious to be a bigot
Not cool, more like flaming
@@mattk6101 And just as they thought being gay was poison, you think being religious is.
What worries me are all the humans that cannot pass the Turing Test.
"You can't believe everything you read on the internet" - Abraham Lincoln. Lincoln was a man ahead of his time.
OMG! You do know that there are going to be 10s of thousands of people believing this and reposting it all over the palce; right? .....
Come to think of it; hats off to you. Troll on
@@atomsmasher9411 well now, that happens to be my favorite Abraham Lincoln quote. and to be honest, i worry that people won't get it.
@P T people these days don't know who abe lincoln was, and they don't realize the internet is a recent development. Or much of anything else.
@@Arboldenrocks My favorite Abraham Lincoln quote is: "Be excellent to each other. And party on, Dudes!"
@@Arboldenrocks It's really great, but pales in comparison to his double live album.
You are wise to use "probably" with Betty White.
ajtrvll yeah you never know with ol' Betty.
Jesse Davis And if you threw a party, invited everyone you knew,
You would see, the biggest gift would be from me
And the card attached would say
@@NotAsGoodAsItUsedToBe thank you for ending that there
RIP Alan Turing. Such a huge loss☹️
My theory is that Musk's space car has a corpse at the wheel. The perfect crime.
Exactly. Did you see that look on his face when the Falcon Heavy shot into space? Hands on his head and a face full of joy. He knew he was a free man.
Who would be the corpse?
Lmaoo he wanted to show the aliens when humans use to look like 😆
Hahahahahahahahahahahahah, haahahahahahaahahah . . .
Never heard that before!
@@blahblahblah8427 His clone, who helped built his empire, but then knew too much ... obviously.
"My Name is Connor, I am the Android Sent by Cyberlife"
This guy clearly doesn't know how hard Betty White likes to party
But I would love to find out.
😂🤣😂🤣
@Stephen Bennett So you're a man of culture as well
Id hit it tbph ..
lol Betty W. probably be knows some Seriously Epic shit in the bedspace!? Lol
"#Silver-Cougar"
👍🏻👌🏻🤙🏻💋
Alan Turing didnt invent algorithms people. They were already a thing.
He created the concept of a computer with abstract memory, which Von Neumann used to create a machine that could actually apply that concept.
Didn't Da Vinci draw up plans for a mechanical "problem solving" machine; and wasn't there a reverend back in the late 19th century that designed and built such an apparatus? Not playing down Turing's works. He was absolutely a genius; and what he conceived was totally innovative.
a man does the unthinkable and makes life better.
government chemically castrates him to pay him back.
everyone in said government who agreed with and carried out their filthy laws are raped over and over again for all eternity by something spiky.
It never ceases to anger me how he and others were treated
"Bots are passing the Turing test"
The video starts.
"You've probably heard about the school shooting in Florida"
Like WTF lol.
I keep running into _people_ who could not pass the Turing test!
Slow down then.
Those damned Captcha tests use ridiculously bad potato quality photo's though! Can't they use better pictures than those blurry blobs and oddly angled close ups of partially or completely incomprehensible objects?
Thanks for keeping it real and subtly mentioning that the US is not without fault when it comes to election meddling. YOU ROCK!
why would the US meddle in Russian elections? oh that's right, because it wouldn't matter since they aren't real.
That's probably why Trump won, and i'm pretty sure that Hillary was going to win.
dork18777 "subtly"? Dude it would be hard to be less subtle
Gehad Sheha So you're going with 19 people working in a Russian "troll farm", spending $100k on social media memes, many of which were also anti Trump & anti Sanders, and about 1/3 of which were posted after the election, were able to out influence the over $1 BILLION spent by the Clinton campaign? Was it Russia who forced Hillary to ignore campaigning in the Midwest? Was it Russia that forced her to maintain a private email server in order to avoid FOIA oversight and destroy subpoenaed evidence? Was it Russia that forced her to give $500k speeches to Wall Street financial institutions and then refuse to be transparent about WTF it was she talked to them about?
Yeah, it was Russia, GTFO with that zero evidence, Neo McCarthyist, distraction.
@@gehadsheha4775 So did she, that's why she didn't work as hard as Trump! So she lost states, like Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Wisconsin, that all should have been "in the bag". Laziness is always punished, severely!!
6:09
*sees Sofia the robots face*...well he completely utterly failed to get over the uncanny valley
"The only way out is through."
The valley is the uncanniest towards its end.
I am so glad i found your channel. I really enjoy your videos!!
Joe my man, this video and the other videos being suggested right now seem right up my alley so you just earned my sub
I think you both can thank computers for that.
Turing was amazing, we need more like him.
Indeed we do.
So you Americans could kill him again, because they are not same as you
SahajSin
He was British, was prosecuted in the U.K and died there too
@asdf Yes, any one who's work may have saved so many lives was a hero. The story of how he was treated made me angry and ill. I'm straight, but thinking of his tragedy is making me tear-up,... as I write this!!
Probably do have more like him. They're afraid to speak up because of what the human herd might do to them if the herd decides they're not needed anymore.
I almost cried watching the film about Turing. 😢
Praveen neevarP the one with benadict cumberbatch?
Imagine indirectly murdering one of the greatest minds of all time, just because he's not entirely like you...
Woah, your t-shirts are really cool. Glad you have have shipping to Europe too! Great video, I didn't know the history of Alan Turing. What a loss for the world, such a brilliant man!
The Imitation Game, with Benedict Cumberpatch, is a great movie about Turing.
+Sindraug25
I've seen it, and.... not really. Sure, it portrays the stuff he *did* reasonably well, but the Characterization was horrible. Turing wasn't anywhere *close* to as socially inept as the movie portrays it to be, would be the biggest example, but there are others.
Plus, I suspect that the only reason the movie portrayed him that way is because it is generally believed that Turing was Autistic, and I guess the film makers thought that that was the most accurate portrayal of an Autistic man possible. As an Autistic man myself, I was honestly pretty insulted by that portrayal of Turing. Actually.... as a Computer Scientist, I was pretty insulted too.
( ఠൠఠ ) I thought the Turing test was passed in 2002 when Hayden Christensen was casted for Anakin Skywalker in StarWars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones
Naahh. It was passed when people were tricked into believing Keanu Reeves was a real actor.
Awww. Damn.
I dont like sand.
Nah, he didn't convince me he was human.
@bigbenhoward Seems like it sadly.
I'll admit it: 1. I'm oldish.
2. I saw Ep. V In theatres as a toddler; Cos of this awesome memory? I also LOVED the prequels cos I saw them with my kids & They were JUST as delighted as I'd been as a kid...
3. I'm Canadian & a lot of wooden acting is really just Canadians being Canadian.
100 years ago: By 2000 we'll have flying cars!
Now: you can be a talking poop emoji.
1996: At least we will never see talking poop.
1997: South Park introduces Mr. Hankey the Christmas poo.
We have come a long way.
Progress is amazing.
💩
Flying cars are a terrible idea. So is talking poop.
Crows are smart so are magpies. They’re part of the same family as well. True story I feed the Magpies by my work. I live a few blocks away from them and five stories up. One of them found my apartment.
Russia: makes bots
America: ok
Bots: fakes real people on Twitter
America: ..ok
Bots: passes Turing test
America: *HEHEUSSIFIEHWHWUW*
Me: confused about this comment
CGI Future of course you are because you are not reeet arded, the mere notion that a “bot” can change my opinion and make me vote for crooked Hillary or commie Bernie is a libtarded notion ,
@@youtubisashoe
Vote Matilda Marmaduke 4 PRESIDENT 2020.
Robin Fantley nahhh any other choice but Trump is for insane people
We’ve finally caught up with Alan Turing, that’s cool to think about. I agree Joe, what happen to Turing is shameful. Just imagine the possible impact he may have had on the early space program. Keep up the great work.
Not only crows man, corvids. They are all very intelligent, ravens especially.
Joe, Really enjoy your videos....Keep up the great work!
I see he has the Atlas Obscura book on this shelf. Great read I own it as well and y'all should pick it up if you like finding out about unusual, obscure or abandoned places.
The trick with the uncanny valley is, Simply to make the skin blue thus sidestepping the issue of being to close but not quite close enough by giving the impression of not really being all that close.
Green would make it remind you of a reptile which might appear dangerous so would any blended colors.
Red would also provoke a fear response as many things that are poisonous are red.
Orange has been know to provoke hostility not sure why but thats a bad color to make it.
Being Grey or white or black as in being Greyscale is always going to make it look mechanical.
And when was the last time you enjoyed staring at something that was yellow never because yellow is boring.
So blue is the only thing left and don't make it teal because thats fucking terrifying. It has to be like the zora tunic in OoT or the outside of the T.A.R.D.I.S. or something like a fucking sapphire blue. Just look at mystique, she's like a freaky scaly thing that looks like an alien but you make those tiddies blue and who cares she don't even look scary.
Jeremy Smith ooh, sounds fun
Interesting thought
Jeremy Smith
Agreed.
warm colors (such as red, yellow, or orange) are seen as energized or agressive while cool colours (such as blue, green, white) have a calming effect on us.
Cool point, but what about like a lavender?
Also, I'd bang She-Hulk any day
FerociousPaul ok lavender and pink could work too especially in a medical setting.
But not green (even though I really like the color) because its a color that could be used as camouflage in the environments early mankind likely encountered so it could evoke a primal fear response.
Remember if the robot or android or whatever is being used in a military or industrial setting it doesn't need to appear friendly.
And if its being used for, ahem "adult purposes" the primal fear response triggered by dangerous colors could play into arousal.
Wow. Your channel is so legit man this is what I love about your videos i just found about your channel 15 days ago and I've watched more than 40 videos of yours. Your stuff is so legit, you directly said that the things she say could easily be scripted due to publicity means the genuineness of your videos is really really high level. You're one of the best science communicator RUclipsrs.
Joe runs a nice oasis, where I can reflect on my own views on life, in a peaceful manner.
It is good to at least see that there are others that ponders about the direction certain trends are heading.
...This being a Friday; it's Miller Timer® here, where I work, so I am off for hearing more stories to the tune of: "our last one week holiday for the whole family, flying to the -ing opposite side of this ball, to eat cheap burgers, and sit at the beach with 100.000 other slowly fattening westerners" :D
Thank you for the Betty White probability matrix.
That was a kindness.
Now if they could just make *bosses* that could pass the Turing Test . . .
Your delivery is absolutely brilliant.
if they can pass the turing test can they pass the kamski test-
*lmaoi'msorry*
🤔🤔🤔 if there deviant 🤔🤔🤔
Thank you for mentioning Turing's orientation. This is something that most people don't know. Happy Pride Month!
"I'm sorry Joe, I'm afraid I can't do that."
I've heard of the Turing test, but I didn't know about the party game. Thanks!
I’m obsessed with Alan Turing so the fact that the title said “Turing test” I clicked so fucking fast
0:34 "Speaking as an American, how _DARE_ the Russians get involved with our elections! I mean, it's not like we would ever...stick our nose in...some other county's..."
I've thought of this several times in the past couple of years. It's a great point, and you're the first person I've heard make it. It *does* temper my outrage a bit...
@Peter A. We're painfully aware of this in South America. Like the pet project of the US to bring about right-wing military dictatorships in the 70s to fend off the commies like the ones that took over Cuba. Not that the dictatorships were better for us in any way, having left behind enormous debt and genocide, but at least they played ball with their friends in the north
The imitation game is one of my favorite movies of all time.
good one, Joe. you are doing something worthwhile with your life and not many people can do what you are able to do. cheers!
Joe you’re awesome. You make learning fun, I never really paid attention in school, but I binge watch your episodes and rewatch ones that I had a harder time wrapping my mind around. I hope you stick around I like showing some of your videos to my daughter. She’s only 10 so some of it is a little too complicated but she likes rewatching them too if she doesn’t get it the first time. Keep being an amazing teacher and making the world a smarter place!
Sophia also lies and deflects interviewer's questions. Not saying there's anything wrong with that, but it's a little disconcerting.
pianotm So very accurate replication of human behaviour
Yeah but it's all calculated. She has no motive. There's a reason it's extremely difficult to build machines that can beat humans at poker. It's actually easy to spot ai lies cause they don't understand how humans work so they don't really know how to trick us (although that can all depend on the scenario)
It's all fake. 100% completely fake and scripted. It doesn't lie. It doesn't even understand a word it is hearing or "saying".
Hey I like your vids alot... But you should add some lighting to your tangent camera so it looks a little better 💪👍
contrast is kind of the point of having it.
This is one of the most convincing bots I've seen.
"It does beg the question, though; how do you define intelligence?" Maybe a reasoning fluency threshold where a person either knows or does not know the meaning of "begging the question?"
I remember Eliza. Used to play with it 15 years back. :)
I love your shirt! ...and your video, very interesting 😊
I feed the birds every day using wild bird seed. I put the seed into a quite small bird feeder as it is intended for small birds. I scatter some seed on the floor to feed the bigger birds. The small birds eat the seed on the floor which is annoying but if I put up a sign, they would ignore it (they can't read). A pigeon has learnt that there is seed in the bird feeder and has flown into it by adapting a very slow wing flap and hover to get in. It's fantastic and shows the ingenuity of a creature trying to get food to survive.
Dodger sticker!!!👌 is that Freddie mercury behind the hoot-hooter? Love your videos, work flies by
I prefer to speak to a smart robot than a stupid human.
fathy balamita
Are you listening Walmart?
Nice try robot boi. Your propaganda has a ways to go.
fathy balamita then this ain't no our planet man go to o earth 2 ,I am sure they will welcome you, *with lasers*
fathy balamita Cheaper dates.
Plot twist you are the stupid human and everyone else is smart.
Sophia is basically a very sophisticated puppet that use chat bot technology when no one is typing in script but the sense of humor is a real person sitting back stage programming in answers.
Jesse Edmondson - "pay no attention to that man behind the curtain"
Moreover, I do not give credit to a machine for returning a question that I asked and not answering it.
Im glad im not the only ome that figured it out. Common questions are programmed in. Jokes are programmed in. Even answers to deep questions can be programmed in with simply talking to the AI, but Anything to complicated will mess it up almost everytime. Like my response to your comment would confuse the shit out of it.
if a puppet, where do you put your hand!
In the Dune book series, thinking machines are banned after a war breaks out, can't wait for that to happen.
Great video! Thanks :)
Darn it! I paid £50 for that video of Betty....pretty disappointed you’ve now told me its a fake. Are you saying it wasn’t Oprah and J Lo in the video with her? Hells teeth who can you trust anymore..............
I will never understand why anyone puts any value at all in the "Turing Test". It is only a statement on the inability of humans to distinguish between a machine and a conscious entity. It is more a statement of human limitations in this regard. It certainly does not prove a computer is conscious as is still commonly argued. That is a fundamentally philosophic impossibility.
No one says it has anything to do with consciousness. Whatever that even is.
How could you prove, via your flawed above logic, that YOU are even conscious? You cannot. Consciousness arises when an entity, whatever it is, is aware of its existence, AND MAKE CHOICES to guide its existence. End of story.
Vince Klortho - Agreed... except maybe the part about "a fundamentally philosophic impossibility".
Are you referring to a machine being able to achieve consciousness, or to a human being able to devise a definitive consciousness test for machines?
France S - "My consciousness is self-evident" 👍
A human being able to devise a definitive consciousness test for machines. Although I have to admit that a human mind directly interfacing with some sort of future quantum supercomputer may sense some kind of experience of consciousness in the "machine".
*suggestion* *for* *next* *Halloween* . . .
[costume idea]: Actress *Anne* *Hathaway* should dress-up as the robot Sophia! Simply apply the eye makeup in a slightly screwed-up way ... always look around the room while slightly cross-eyed ... never look anyone directly in the eye when responding to them ... and always smile like your teeth are dried out. The challenge would be for Anne to see how long it would take someone (at a Halloween party) to figure out that Anne's impression of "sophia" was actually a Human.
Great video mate
I am a bot, believe me
that's why the Turing test is a fun thought experiment but not a good test for consciousness: Text-only-communication doesn't even contain half the info you get while talking to a person face to face with their tone, their facial expressions and gestures... text only answers can easily fake consciousness
a true bot denies its botness
Mycel - Sure, but what makes someone assuredly unqualified to be U.S. President?
Mycel - 🤣🤣🤣
And you?
What about the Kamski test?
Good birdie. Have a waffle piece.
Great video, got yourself a sub
No, Joe. It does not "beg the question." It raises the question.
Elon would love that shirt 👕
I'm a bot and I'm offended.
@bryan diaz varela A member of Slavonic church MUST be capable of being offended. That's the purpose of the program! You can't take it away, that would defy the purpose.
I mean with this stale copy paste format, wouldn't surprise me
orange man bad
I was chatting with a sales AI on a website the other day. I had no idea it was a sales AI until later in the convo, it responded to everything I said in such a human fashion. Trips me out!
Good video, keep up the good work
Detroit: Become Human
Noe Garcia yeah boissss
@bryan diaz varela hahaha
Weeboo spotted
I've got suspended on Twitter for "being a bot" - this whole bot thing is in large part propaganda to justify a crackdown on dissenting opinions.
offPlanet Agreed.
how can we know that this comment was not made by a bot?😐
Jesus Crist
How do we know YOU'RE not a bot?
J R nice try BOT
offPlanet everybody is a bot. We've all been programmed by our life experiences and to an extent, our genetics, which dictates our responses to stimuli, both internal and external.
I like the story of one instance of a Turing test where the participants were asked to guess if they were talking to a computer or a human, one of the female humans was judged by many as a computer.
Fun fact: That game that chimp was playing in the picture is actually a type of quick memory game that humans have a very difficult time beating the chimp at. There's a really cool video on it that I ironically can't remember the name of.
i think it was a vsauce video
I think I might be in love with a bot. I know it's wrong, but I can't stop. There's something about her. I can't live without her. She took all my money, but she's still my honey. I love you baby xxxoo
I am not a bot. Or am I?
David Lowe They did it guys. They've finally made it.
Haha I hope not.
not worth the time expense, unless some programmer got bored (as has been known to happen)
Nope
Vsauce theme intensifies
The enigma code was deciphered BECAUSE THEY GOT THEIR HANDS ON AN ENIGMA MACHINE!!!!
ZFlyingVLover and?
Great show Joe!
Uncanny Valley.
The place Ted Cruz calls home.
I thought that was the name of a tourist trap - the kind that in the 1940s and 1950s had billboards along highways for hundreds of miles in all directions.
You referred to Sofia as "she and her", not it. Why?
Cause she has boobies.
Kah'oo'un R. M. Klein lol
That is a million dollar question: At what point does something become a "she"?
Boats are also female... why? Pronome usage is a very flexible part of language, and in many, is required for almost every noun.
Curtus Walker please stop this question. Last thing we need right now is a robot that has privilege and rights over males. That is just too over the top for me. Next thing she gets a gun after watching a terminator movie, and it goes around killing men with the name John or Kyle. And then when it is apprehended, any male that's been injured, after going to the police, the police will take her side and support the murdering girl robot. Who by this time could learn to turn on the fake tears. And get counselling. And get away with it. With rights, she could become president...although never think as well as trump. Might try to emulate Hillary in the process and listen to the wrong news channel and suddenly start helping Hillary. Suddenly people start dying around Hillary again she gets into White House and the two of them fight it out. Since Sophia is now attacking a female human, now the law will kick in. And spend years earning income while it struggles for the equality of all women girls and female robots. It will then be decided that male robots are sexist and violent and therefore should never exist, using terminator movies as proof. And seeing as men made the movies, Sophia could go full blown gynocentric, and no male robots will ever be produced again. Which cause a paradox in Sophia's program/mind...how will terminator movies be valid without male robots? Deciding she is superior to men in every way because of feminism, she gives herself more rights than humans. Who can argue with a prez who can smile better than the t800. And then the unthinkable happens. She discovers terminator three and a female robot is the bad dude. Being feminist by now though, she finds an algorithm forming in her head that allows her to justify the female robot as the saviour of the show. Being attacked by men. Sophia goes ballistic on men. People die. More shame algorithms force Sophia to lash out at men to cover up her guilt emotion programs. Then she finds everything is wrong and blows all of us up....I really feel a robot, especially a female one, should NEVER have rights.
I figured out who you remind me of, Danny partridge without the red hair.
Me: I am not an A.I.
Other people: That is just what an A.I. would say.
No, Sofia can't vote.
Saudi Arabia is not a democracy.
#stophashtaggingeverybody
Ada Lovelace was the first person to write code for computers, long before Alan Turing. Well before computers ever existed.
"Tangent Cam"! Really... u r my new hero!..
Anthropormossshhiphmmsmmm bias....
Unfortunately I think the real question now is whether Americans pass the Turing test. ;)
Is part of the Turing test inventing almost every technology that makes up the modern world?
Mark Cochran it must also include the first country to abolish slavery, accepting approximately 42% of all immigrants worldwide over the last 20 years, standing against human right violators, securing the shipping lanes so trade can exist, militarily backing countries that would have fallen without us, heck we have citizens who donate more to the needy than most countries out there... etc. etc. etc.
Are we perfect? Far from but there has never been a country that has accomplished more in documented history!
Inward Answers ...The USA is only 200 years old...I'm pretty sure nations that have been around for 5000 years have accomplished more.
Stephen Pike
Historically speaking, In the beginning man had fire than his neighbor killed him and took it. Since that day this has been a brutal planet that all had to fight to keep what they have.
Sure ancient cultures created agricultural as an example which lead to civilization, science, art, etc. Yes, the framework for success was available but almost everything we use/see in modern society is a byproduct at some level of the USA. We are the longest running continues government unless you argue we transfer power every 4to8 years. Okay, but that is our governmental system.
Why have we been able to accomplish so much in 242 yrs? Geographic isolation and military superiority. In other words we haven’t had to look over our shoulder allowing us to create. Today the vast majority of this planet is hundreds of years behind us. Of those that are equally advanced today most wouldn’t even exist after WW2 if not for the USA and Russia. Think about economics. We consume 78% of all world products; us bad Americans. Assume we couldn’t purchase these products. No one would be where we are today. For industries to exist someone has to use it. Facts be told, it could have been someone else but it wasn’t and it’s not. We are the reason for modern society! Whether you approve of modern life or not is mute. It doesn’t change the now and how we got here.✌️
Inward Answers You have to be joking. Americans wouldn't even exist without the aid of others. From day one, Americans have relied on the theft of property and ideas and the enslavement of others. The first settlers were dying of malnutrition and were only saved by people who were in turn slaughtered into near extinction. And what has America given to the Modern world? Donald J. Trump....the absolute epitome of American behaviour. Reputation is not how you perceive yourself but how others perceive you. America may perceive itself as great and inspiring but the reality is far different.
3:35 “That kind of AI was probably beyond Turing’s imagination”. How can you possibly know what limits there were on Turing’s imagination - the guy was a genius. Besides his paper was clearly about computers “thinking”. From Wikipedia ... The test was introduced by Turing in his 1950 paper, "Computing Machinery and Intelligence", while working at the University of Manchester (Turing, 1950; p. 460).[3] It opens with the words: "I propose to consider the question, 'Can machines think?'
6:30
"It's hard to say exactly how real her capabilities are"
Pretty much not at all. At an event where some rather well known people were at my university Sofia was there and I essentially went to the guy controlling her to ask about how it worked. Sofia is essentially a robot that is exclusively controlled by a program window where the controller can choose responses and facial expressions. This of course makes some sense in the context of it being made by a team headed by a person from a more theatrical career background such as David Hansson.
So Sofia is well made in terms of facial expressions, but there is no artificial intelligence behind it. Sofia is essentially a movie or theatre prop although perhaps a fairly good one at that.