I feel like part of her weight gain was also her growing into her body. We all know Lisa has long limbs. She was 19 years old when Blackpink debuted. I don't think it's too outlandish of a thought that her body developed and filled out more as a result of maturing.
I agree. And I think it also works the other way around. Theres probably many idols that lost weight because they were so young when they debuted and they just lost the baby fat/hormonal fat from their teens, especially in the face.
and her body will keep changing and growing in her 20s if she keeps the healthy diet and lifestyle she's been doing all this time. people forget bodies do change and mature as you grow up in your 20s too
yes, many are insisting that the gained weight is only muscle, as if anything else would be bad. change is normal anyway, and it makes sense to 'fill up' with muscle or fat as you grow up if you have been very slim when you were younger, especially if you have been very active as a kid. your metabolism usually slows down as you age, so simply growing up can explain everything.
One of the things I notice alot is also that she never lacks energy, she always gives her best and is full of energy. You can see alot of times when idols lose weight bc of harsh diets that they suddenly lack energy in their dancing or look really tired on stage and that has never been the case wit lisa. I dont think she could have this kind of energy on stage constantly if she starved herself
That’s bc dancing in her studio 24/7 is how she maintains the weight. Doesn’t necessarily mean she doesn’t starve at all. The dancing balances the starving. Not saying she starves all the time. Cmon u really believe she never starved during her career as a KPOP IDOL
@@khia797 i'm not saying she never starved or that she never had an unhealthy diet before, probably all idols have, especially when they were trainees or in the beginnng of their career but I was focusing more on now or the last year, where she also gained some weight. Also you can't dance/practice 24/7 in a studio if you are truly constantly starving or you'll break down at some point. I'm just saying that there's a huge difference in her energy when dancing on stage/performing than when you compare it to idols where its KNOWN they have an unhealthy diet bc they keep talking about it.
@@khia797 lmao u just cant admit that naturally skinny ppl exist. lisa is clearly one of them. it doesn’t matter how much she dances, she will get exhausted every time, that’s how the body works???
@@annis749 actually you can many idols mentioned they’ve gotten used to the starving by balancing it out with dancing or doing yoga something athletic.. to distract them.. though she may not be starving now she prob went back & forth with the starving throughout the years but since she is naturally skinny she has it easier & prob does it less versus other idols (Edit) my comment was meant for the last thing u said in ur original comment. I just stated my opinion too that I think she has starved herself throughout years going back n forth.
Lisa is one of those people who have a naturally healthy slim body frame, even when it seems like she "gained weight" you can tell it's mostly pure muscle. She works hard and it shows, much love to Lisa and all of Blackpink ~♡
The only member that truly fluctuates in weight is Jisoo. Of course not that that is a bad thing but Lisa isn’t the only member of blackpink to remain consistent in weight and not lose weight for comebacks. Everyone just makes blind incorrect assumptions especially about rosé that they’ve lost weight every single time.
Lisa does her best to maintain her body looking good. People need to know the difference between being healthy and unhealthy without labeling someone with some kind of disorder or health issue.
There's a difference between being thin by starving yourself and being toned. Lisa is toned. Look at her arm muscles 13:09! You don't build muscle by starving yourself. You need to work out AND eat enough (especially protein) in order to build muscle. So her arms and legs are enough proof that she's doing that. She has so much energy as well! She's a beautiful, talented, confident young woman. People are intimidated by that.
I think her legs are toned since she's a professional dancer. However if you wanna have toned muscles you need to do weight lifting, I don't know if she does, but if she did since she has a low fat percentage her muscles would pop out completely
it’s actually more insane that people will automatically think skinny = diet in kpop, like lisa and all the blackpink members have said numerous times that they dont diet, and it actually shows because when you don’t starve yourself or diet in an extreme way, there are less chances that your body bounces back and makes you gain more weight that you’ve lost, hence why their body never changed extremely. they’ve always had the same figure since debut because they have the same eating habits as before
I feel like these days people are so quick to throw out the words “eating disorder” or “starvation” at anyone who is on the thinner side, wants to get healthy or wants to lose some weight and it’s so frustrating! They think that the only way to lose weight is by starving and that’s very concerning. There is something called a balanced diet, calorie deficit and exercise! I also notice that when those words are thrown around carelessly they start to get taken less seriously, just like the word “anxiety” There’s now people thinking they have anxiety disorders just because they once felt a little nervous before a test. It’s much deeper than that, every human experiences anxiety every now and then but anxiety disorders completely take over and ruin lives just like eating disorders!
I know a lot of people asked for an update but I don't really see a difference from 2020 haha. Lisa always seems super confident and happy in her own skin no matter what show she's performing on.
your videos always point out proper hypocrisy and i love that. i think everyone who criticize idols’ bodies should watch your video. what you said about lisa in comparison to idols who are praised for being on the thicker side for idols yet theyre the ones who struggle the most with dieting, i had never even thought of.
She gets SO much hate it’s crazy...she’s always gotten hate since debut, for being thai, being too skinny, people saying she ‘can’t sing’ it never ends....I’m glad she’s never late the hate affect her stage presence. She never gives it anything less than 100% Queen !
I really dislike it when people think they can tell if someone is healthy or not just based on how their body looks, some people are born skinny and have trouble gaining weight even though they have a balanced diet, being skinny doesn’t mean unhealthy. Same goes for when someone gains a little bit of weight or is not naturally skinny but is not diagnosed with obesity :/
Exactly my bestie tried to eat a LOT and lift heavy at the gym and so many things ( medicaments etc .. ) but nothing worked for her she is still SOOOO thin ( HOW DO U FEEL LIVING MY DREAAAAM AHHHHH ) like her old sister too it's GENETICS
@@rymasiuuu6312 U can't avoid me 😏 Those ppl gain wieght yrs later. But not the desirable kind... Uk what I mean. My dream of being a bone will never come true...
As a naturally thin-framed/ taller than average girl I can confirm the hate is very real. Even more so when you are a teenager when everyone's more focused on body image. I have always been thin, but ever since I started to gain weight, I am getting backhanded compliments and rude comments. Please keep going Lisa, we love you.
Im sorry for hearing that. Ik that since im a male that it isnt in the sam light but i also am very skinny barely being at 60 kg and ive even tried to starve myself and start eating again so i could get the yoyo affect and it didnt even work . Im 180 cm tall ( 5 11) and my mom constantly thin shames me as well as other guys since i sont have any muscle . I hope you're doing better now 4 months later queen.
100% relate. For me gaining weight is a loooootttttt harder than just to lost weight. When I'm sick, 3 days is enough for me to lost 5kg. And it needs months to gain those back 🥲
FINALLY SOMEONE WITH COMMON SENSE 😩 I’m so tired of the ‘but she’s under the normal BMI and she looks anorexic’ argument, and the fact that people will always try to support this bs of an ‘argument’ by saying ‘It’s fine to admit that the company and the entertainment forces her to be skinny 🥺’. They literally go around stating this with no objective proofs, and It makes me nervous, because I’m the same as Lisa and somehow someone always has to point out the things they call Lisa.
people say those things as if they never saw a skinny person in their lives, as if skinny people are just like that bc they starve when it's a completely normal and natural body type in many people
The reason why we're below BMI is because we have a tinier bone density and frame than average, add that to a fast metabolism and you'll literally have to overeat to just have a normal BMI. I have an ample amount of fat in my body but I look tiny and I weigh less because my bones are so thin.
i feel like for bp its the opposite of losing weight when it comes to comeback season. they're always a bit more leaner and muscular during promos. they make sure to eat well and exercise to mantain stamina in order to sing & dance constantly. i still remember during their 2018-2019 world tour and coachella, they were all very toned. they need to be physically good shape in order to fulfil all of their hectic schedules! and i thank their team for keeping their health a priority before any unnecessary diet!
women can never win when it comes to body standards & blackpink is one of the many examples - like there are actually people who call jisoo & jennie "fat" and say that their legs & arms look too "meaty" while in the same breath rosé & lisa get called "skeleton", "anorexic", "sick" etc.?? skinny doesn't automatically equal unhealthy! stop judging someone's health only based on how YOU see their bodies. you don't know them personally, their eating pattern, their health history or anything else. the comments that were shown in this video were disgusting, just cause someone is skinny doesn't mean they don't have feelings or you get a free pass to insult or degrade them for their bodies. skinny shaming hurts the affected persons as well cause at the end of the day we're all human beings who all get affected in a negative way by mean comments.
Haters: lose weight. Idol: loses weight Haters: ew gain weight. See it makes no sense! Why try to control idols and when the haters get their way they still aren’t satisfied?? As long as Lisa is a healthy weight, I’m happy. I’m happy when my idols are happy and it hurts to see people bringing the happy vibes down. Harassing others cause they are skinny is just as bad as fat shaming.
I really hate the mentality of these people honestly, they think idols are their play dolls or sims 🤷🏻♀️ it’s actually very sad and concerning, these are the same people who’ll grow up to be parents someday and body shame their children 🙁
Exactly I still remember when they called idols like Jennie and Somi fat LIKE WHat ?!,!????!!! and now Somi lost weight OMGGG U ARE SOOOO THIIIN DON'T SKIP MEALS GAIN WEIGHT at least she TOASTED THEM
I think a lot of the hate stems from jealousy, I mean I’m jealous of her just look at her she’s like an absolute goddess haha! It’s great to see her have a more athletic ‘healthier’ looking weight now compared to debut, but she still has the same lovely slim body proportions and women naturally just get curvier as they get older too. She seems like a really happy driven young woman!
She's just born skinny. At her ages with her exercise routines plus her works, her shape just goes naturally with that. I really can tell if that time she works hard. Her weight seems up and down so easily. Anyway, i love yr video. Can't agree more that Lisa's strongest point is to ignore the haters and just be positive. Years by years, they already prove it.
Conclusion: people don't know what they want when it comes to weight. Idols should stop worrying about that and focus on their talents... oh, but I'm forgetting this industry revolves heavily on outer beauty over talent. Maybe companies should promote a healthier message for everyone, and not tell people inner beauty is what matters, making songs about that topic, when they clearly don't think that way.
It's so sad that people shame Lisa for something she can't control. Shes a dancer and dancers usually have the body type Lisa has, She's strong and muscular. Lisa also has a fast metabolism and that makes it hard to gain weight. People need to stop shaming her
The same people who bash Lisa’s body are the same people who would kill to have a body like hers. Lisa has amazing proportions, healthy, talented, humble, sweet, and beautiful. Leave her alone!!!
Most woman outside korea don't desire Body like Lisa.they want some thick legs,thick hibs and boobs and some fat in ribcage area so that they don't look like skeleton
This video just showed me that you can never please everyone. People will always find something to criticize. Why can't people just let her be seriously? Just focus on yourself. Lisa is a queen and I know those body shaming comments can't bring her down, it just makes her stronger.
Out of all Blackpink members, Lisa is by far the most stable one, and to me she seems the healthiest one. I hate that in Western culture, everyone's quick to criticize anyone who's on the thinner side, even if it's completely natural, and are quick to assume they have an ED, which is absolutely not always the case
@@rosieposie1504 Jennie and Jisoo's weight fluctuates a lot more than Lisa's. You can see it in their faces and legs. But don't get me wrong, they're all amazing and I hope they're all healthy. It's just that to me, Lisa seems to be the healthiest one
@@ispeakonlyfacts.3228 What nonsense are you saying now? She is literally looking gorgeous now, lean muscled and looking so healthy. Might consider changing your @ cause you’re speaking straigh trash
Actually the statement at the end when you said Lisa's weight wasnt put in a negative light is false. People were fat shaming her and complaining that she gained weight. Which is really weird considering all they did was scream and cry about how Lisa was to thin and needed to gain weight and when she did they proceeded to complain about it
Exactly, they complained she gained lot of weight, i was shocked, when it was just muscles, they really body-shamed her and called her lot of names, i can vouch i saw this one, if not i don't comment
@@mae_ri Yes! I saw some tweets saying things about her weight gain like "we lost another one" (what do they even mean by that?) And "Lisa is getting fat" (or something similar to that) I was really shocked and disgusted when I saw these
I have been watching your channel for a long time,and I gotta say, I really appreciate the the amount of research and facts you put in your vedios. After watching all the blackpink videos along with the other idols videos,it's clear that the girls themselves are totally fine and don't really seem to put much thought on their diet. From what we see they have three meals a day and often even have midnight snack. They don't have any kind to eating disorders and have never encouraged any kind of unhealthy eating habits or diets. They seem content and happy in terms of their eating habits. Even when asked in interviews about their diet they have said they like having a balanced proportioned meals three times a day so why do people always seem to say something about their body and eating habits. I have seen this kind of comment saying they are worried about their weight or how they look underweight,my question to you is why,just why are you worried. Did they say anywhere they are unhealthy and weak. It is not our job as fans to dictate what an idols eats or do. Also before people come and comment about how they are worried about influencing the young fans, as a young fan let me say they haven't done any bad influencing on my eating habits. They have in all their interviews only encouraged people people eat healthy and exercise regularly to keep our bodies fit. So as a blink it never occurred for me to compare my bodies with these girls or even worry about their weight which seems to be the excuse and worry of all the netz or knetz when it comes to an idols diet influence on the fans. Also before people come here and comment on how they might not say the full truth of their diet or what they really do behind the camera, really do we need to scrutinize and doubt everything they say. If these girls are really lying about their eating habits I think the opposite should happen. Because both Lisa and Rosé are being thinshamed . If they are dieting for the sake of the fans then it doesn't make sense. As all the so called fans are actually telling them to put on weight or should I say forcing them to have curves on their body. And I am sure they have heard these so called worriness of the fans. And from what we see they are consistent and don't really do any kind of extreme eating, diet or exercise for the sake of these people. Which means they are content with their present body and are also confident and aren't shaken by these comments. I have also seen people just hate on them for how their bodies are and then hide behind these indirect hate comments by saying they are worried for the girls. Please don't do that.They really don't need your worries. It's fine if you don't like their music or style. We all have our own opinions. Don't watch vedios related to blackpink if you don't like them. As a multifan even I have some groups I like and dislike and I just avoid the groups I dislike. No need to spread any hate on any groups. And for people who say they have eating disorders pls go and learn the definition of eating disorder. It's a mental disorder where they have distorted body image which leads to them seeing as overweight or underweight. I have seen people saying that Lisa and rosé have eating disorder because they are thin . If they do have it ,then it would be anorexia nervosa where idols with this disorder would refuse to eat in front of other and lose large amount of weight in a week and starve themselves to death. Its clear these girls never shy away from saying that they have good proportioned meals and also have eaten food and asked for food if they are hungry. Rosé also said that she eats rice before any important event and we also see her eating in all the shows and etc(like in the present vogue interviews for both met gala and Paris fashion week). During their netflix swoon interview when asked who always eats, jisoo pointed out on Lisa saying she always had some packs of chocolate if she gets Hungry, and rosé pointed out how jisoo kept on drinking milk because she wants to grow tall🤣😆😁. They have no problem with having some amount of carbs and also have timely food. I recommend people to see the other idols videos here to know who really do have Ed and how idols with ED behave. I hope these idols don't get hate for their body and people will stop commenting on it. Also stop saying blackpink aren't real women because two members are thin.They are real confident women who don't need someone's approval of how their body should look. All 4 girls have been having a consistent weight for 6 years even when they got bodyshed so thats enough confirmation for all the fans and netz to stop worrying about their weight. And stop hating on the girls on how their bodies look,if someone says Rosé, Lisa , Jennie and Jisoo look beautiful,let them appreciate them. Because none of the girls made the fans feel like they have to have any particular food or diet to look a certain way. When the girls themselves encourage everyone to eat healthy balanced diet and also not shy away from trying out different cuisines then why do the knetz and netz still want to say these girls have a disorder and they are a bad influence when in reality these girls are a good influence for people who follow unhealthy diets. Stop creating a problem just to hate on the girls or just to make yourself look better. Sorry for the rant,I got a bit carried away. Pls don't fight in the comment section. Sorry for my grammar as eng is my second language.Again pls don't comment on their bodies , we as fans need not worry about what they eat or how they look when they have never encouraged any kind of unhealthy diets. Ps. I have seen in RUclips where in blinks channels when the youtuber uploads a pic of the blackpink girls saying their outfits are good or their performance are good or if they say these girls look elegant ,the comments section is filled with the so called "worried" fans who keep on saying Rosé and Lisa look underweight and they are worried for them.Pls don't comment if you really don't know what is happening behind the scenes.To just throw on words like weak and Eating disorder isn't something simple. Actually fans like these people are the ones who turn a normal healthy idol into having an eating disorder when these idols themselves never had one before. Lisa and Rosé might look underweight but we have no rights,no rights to say what they should eat and do. If you feel like they look thin then just don't shame them for it. Appreciate the other girls , say they all look nice and leave it at that. No need to hate on idols who is naturally thin. How would you feel of people said you look underweight you need to eat a lot when you are eating and exercising just fine or how would you feel if people said you rae overweight and you need to lose it when you are eating and exercising just fine. How would you feel if someone commented on your natural body by saying it's not desirable or you look bad or say you are doing a diet when in reality you just eat normally(balanced diet) and do exercise regularly.So don't comment on their body and shame on their body without knowing anything. It can really do lot of damage to these idols mental health. The blackpink girls are healthy and don't seem to want their fans to constantly talk about something as insignificant as their body type and weight. In pretty savage song Lisa literally said she is a skinny b*tch or skinny chick which means these girls do read those horrible comments and Rosé during her Solo premiere interview had said she loves eating and her sister Alice said her nickname in school was porky pig because she eats a lot. A foodie like her won't be able to live without food.Leave the girls alone. They are fine,of they do have something they will open up,we don't need to unnecessarily worry about them and comment on how they look.
0:58 this is SUCH a true point that needs to be addressed more often. not every slim idol is unhealthy. sure they’re underweight, but just like being slightly overweight doesnt make you unhealthy, being underweight doesnt if you’re eating and exercising well
It’s easy to see she’s just built this way. But imagine dreaming to be a performer, having that dream come true and no one asking you about the creative process, your motivations, your inspirations but rather.. about your diet 🥴
I love the fact that all Blackpink members maintain their body right from the time they first debut and truly happy that they feel confident on themselves and ignoring the haters for body shame them fighting 😘😘
its always body positivity unless its ppl who are naturally underweight or thin (i know that plus size suffer much more) as a 5'10 girl whose only like 108 i relate to lisa alot bc i cant gain weight for shit and was bodyshamed too and trust me those type of naturally thin girls try to gain weight rlly hard
I’m glad that you added in plus size people suffer more cause it’s true but there is a double standard skinny shaming is real but when it’s talked about people think that it’s tone deaf when that’s not the case
Honestly, i think that Lisa is so gorgeous just the way she is. She is so talented and that is something really important that need to be mentioned. She is a real queen just like the other members of Blackpink. We need to support her and understand that all bodies are different and react in a different way depending on every situation.
this video is great people need to grow up and know that skinny shaming is as harsh and hurtful as fat shaming it's really mean what some people would say fr
I feel like Lisa and Rosé just have the body types that don’t gain weight easily. One of my best friends is very thin but that girl can EAT. it’s just in her genetics!
As someone that's always been on the skinnier side naturally, I'm so pissed for Lisa. No one deserves to be shamed for being healthy. Some of us are naturally this skinny. I was especially thin when I was still growing. My legs were very thin and my rib cage was visible even if my arms were down. Because of my thin, curveless body, I experienced lots of bullying. I was told I was ugly because my bones were more visible. Because my backside didn't grow in until later, people shamed me for having no curves. I was only 11 when this was really bad. Even my best friends called me ugly. So when I see others being shamed for their appearance, my heart aches and I get pissed off. It makes me want to smack some of these audacious and disrespectful people with a 2X4. Keep eating healthy foods that make you happy and maintain a balance of exercise. If consistent, you'll be at your healthiest. This is what Lisa has been doing. The amount of fat and muscle on your bones will never determine how beautiful you are. What's beautiful is someone that does their best to be healthy both physically and mentally. :)
13:50 guuuuurl you finally said it. The West has a skewed af view on healthy now due to seeing everyone fat all the time! Being fat is now normal and it's terrifying. I'm still losing the weight I need but now when I mention I have about 25-30 more lbs to lose everyone goes "omg noooo you'll disappear!" like no, no I won't. I'm still on the bigger side.
I just want to put out there my experience. I have always been very thin, my dad is too, i eat regularly and i even eat very high-calory foods on a daily basis. Lisa inspired me to get a bit of muscular mass, for the body type i have it is attainable for me to get a body like hers. I wasn't very happy with my body before Lisa because i have been skinny shamed my whole life. I am not saying that lisa's body is the ideal type, and i strongly believe some people might get sick trying to get it because it's not for everyone. Don't compare yourselves with someone who has very different metabolism and bone structure from you. The best is to be HEALTHYLY inspired by your fav/Idol/actor whatever that looks like to you, if you feel like that could help with your body image. And stop harrassing people for the way they look. But that's just my opinion, nobody is going to read this anyways lol
Thank you for making this video! Basically i love Lisa and am so happy to see evidence of her healthy habits so i’m really grateful for the effort you put in compiling all the pictures. Basically I got to enjoy a whole video of beautiful pics of best girl! I hope she is healthy and happy for the rest of her life!!
Let's refrain from bodyshaming thin people in the comments. Everyone's bodies are different, and we aren't all supposed to be at a bigger size. Some of our weights naturally stay on the low end and that's fine. One weight isn't better than another so don't put them down. Skinny shaming is the same as fat shaming and can be hurtful. Look at Rose for example
I honestly don't understand how people think she's lost weight since its debut. If you compare pictures between the two it's obvious that even if she hasn't gained 'fat' her hips have gotten larger through puberty and muscle development. And like muscles literally require calories and fat to grow and even remain so like science literally renders the argument of not eating void???????? like if you're going to hate at least know your facts
For me Lisa’s body is such a bodygoal I really like her tight arms and her abs her thighs everything is just perfect I truly can see how healthy n fit lisa is ❤️ actually her body everytime amazed me her body makes her dance even more clean n attractive Nd tbh she has the best body I’ve ever seen in my life I mean she is just my type😘😘😘❤️
Exactly, people should realize people have different taste if they hate Lisa body, they should remember that lots of people love Lisa body & Lisa opinion & happiness is the most important
It's fine to have a body goal, but just remember you never can get the EXACT same body, as everyone has a different body type! The most common body type is the Pear shape for example, and you can't magically go from a pear shape to a real hourglass, though you can try to build muscle to replicate it a little :) Just wanted to mention this, as sometimes people don't seem to realize body goals are nice but also can't be fully 100% the same haha!
@@yulana990 I like your concern:) and tbh I didn’t intend to give any negative impacts on someone🙂 Also I didn’t mean it I just love lisa and for lilis she is just perfect the way she is that’s what I mean😊
As an naturally skinny(38kg /150cm), I always get body shamed and being told not eating properly, meanwhile I eat everything in the kitchen, our body just burn more calories than others, or we have short intestine so we don't absorb all calories like other people. I have skull sticking out of my skin but that just my natural body frame, I'm not fatigue or anything or starving myself. Is it wrong to have skinny figure?? I think people really want adjusting every person weight with their standart, but reality everyone has their different body type :( please open your eyes, not every skinny person starve themselve!! It's just their body!!
Sorry to hear this :( I'm 149cm myself and struggle to lose weight instead no matter how little I eat, and my friend also is naturally skinny and can eat so many cals and not gain anything to the point it stresses him out. People really should stop acting like BMI is everything, especially when the same people who call others too skinny and "anorexic" say that the BMI is inaccurate for obesity and is flawed! It's also been shown that the BMI is very inaccurate for people udner 155cm and above 190cm or something, and for people at our height the BMI's should be higher, so you being 38kgs is actually fine! Some people just think anyone who's skinny HAS to have an ED or is starving which is ridiculous, and they should be ignored as they are very ignorant. You aren't even underweight BMI wise (using the BMI for shorter people), and with the normal BMI would be 3kgs underweight which is not severe and won't kill someone. Stay healthy like you are right now and try to not take those comments to heart. :)!
One thing i like in BP they never starved themselves. They just maintained their own body. They don't need to pressure themselves to be "skinny" as a Kpop idols. And that's a relief for me as a fan of them. They bash BP for being too skinny when infact they eat a lot,they always bash them but BP always makes money a lot,so thanks to the bashers of BP.
I am so proud of her that she is one of those people who observe and think wisely and fairly...not just to protect them from all the hate they get, but also she is very fair and she researches well...I am very happy I got to meet someone this wonderful! Hwaiting! You got a new subscriber!!🥺
A true fan is accepts fully and wholeheartedly an idol who he/she idolized. Lisa unnie, we, the BLINKS accept who you are both inside and outside of yourself. You have the good physic and beautiful face. Keep fighting #LISA unnie!😘 The #BLACKPINK members as well as true BLINKS will protect you. Thank you for making this vvide.😊❤
Honestly love her i never thought of her anything tbh like she is happy real blinks know lisa and won’t ever question lisa weightloss or weightgain we love her either way its the antis who attack
She even said it herself on a show, she doesn't have a diet. She just dances a lot and she loves it. Dancing keeps her fit and she even has muscles from it
My American kpop friends still diss Lisa's body even in her thickest eras, especially one who is overweight and has a habit of thin shaming. They don't believe there is such a thing as skinny-shaming, but I always shut them down immediately and say I won't talk about them that way and won't stay around them if they do. So many Americans still have that skinny-shaming mindset it's so sad.
I find it crazy that so many people think she is too thin. I think she looks amazing. Most, literally most, people over here in america are overweight, and yet they think they should comment on her being thin. The absolute irony 🥴
Definitely think people are overreacting. The majority of kpop idols are as skinny as she is. Shes healthy and happy. That’s all that matters. She’d probably get hate if she put weight on too
There are actually people who are born skinny, it hurts when they calling you some names about being skinny. it's not our fault if we are built like this
tbh people thinking that only really thin bodies are associated with ED's actually make things worse and put a stigma around them in reality anyone can have anorexia regardless of their body type when I had an ED I definitely did not look like what media makes girls with eds to look like which honestly tarnished my mental health even more thinking I wasn't "sick" enough so ppl think they are doing something by calling naturally thin bodies someone with ed's actually make things worse and feed more into stereotypes and miseducation about them.
If people see how she twerks during her concert in Amsterdam and other places on a fancam. Then yeah, she’s not too skinny she’s just muscular and knows how to keep a physique.
Lisa is just naturally slim and she absolutely looks healthy. I wish I was lucky enough to be blessed with her metabolism and natural frame. All 4 of them look completely healthy to me. And you can tell they've filled out since 2016 because they are grown women now, not teenagers. They didn't gain a huge amount of weight but they definitely have a more grown up fullness to them than when they when they first started.
It's not a crime to be super skinny and it's not a crime to be thick. The only crime is body shaming others because they don't fit into your idea of a perfect body...
My body is very similar to Lisa's (only with a big butt and cellulite), and let me tell you, some of the rude things people have told me are out of this world. I have been told "I was worried while you were dancing that you would collapse", I was an "unfair skinny bitch" when I lost my pregnancy weight after my son was born (with daily exercise), I was told my bones are unattractive, I should put on weight, and that I have an ED. It's literally just my body type and exercise, but people are jealous so they say mean shit like this. I am very happy Lisa ignores all of it.
Lisa seems to simply have superfast metabolism. Her body actually digests her food too fast, making it difficult for her to actually gain a lot of weight. I actually was in class with someone at high school who had the same problem. It was like she had the stomach of 4 horses. She ate like 3 times as much as everyone else, yet never gained a pound. Some people simply are like that
You can just tell with Lisa that she's naturally tall and thin, and very healthy and and fit. There's just a big difference between someone who is malnourished and someone like Lisa who just happens to be thin
Her weight is no issue, i have a friend that is like her, skinny since childhood even if she eats a Ton of food and up till now she still is but developed some muscles. It seems they loose weight fast when stressed but slow at gaining it back. How I wish to be like Lisa who have a fast metabolism so i can eat so much food without worrying to get obese like the 60% Americans. Those people who body shame Idols are ignorant and insecure and at the end of the day they would be searching other Idols diets to extreme weight loss.
It's clear to anyone with common sense she's naturally slim. That is a natural body type for millions of people. People need to stop commenting on other people's bodies. Being a fan doesn't make it your business.
NATURAL its all natural she was literally born with a really thin frame and doesnt gain weight easily despite this she's gained a ton of muscle and looks so healthy toned and beautiful none of black pink have to diet intensely because theyre built like thst
With as much Lisa dances and how much energy she always puts in, she'd be in and out of the hospital if she were starving herself to maintain her slim frame. She would've probably broken down on stage already, or it would've been apparent in her face. No one can tell me that this girl isn't healthy. Being quite slim, especially over a long period of time like hers doesn't always equal to drastic diets or E.Ds.
she always have been critized for being "an*rex1c" and "trying" to make people starve to be skinny. Then when she gain a little more weight afters years mainting her body really skinny, ppl saying she was FAT and was ugly. Honestly, i don't have any comments about how disgusting this are.
Literally people are so stupid I have an Ed and when i was at my lowest i was really skinny but i had no energy i looked as white as a zombie because of malnutrion and i was really tired, i could barely even walk Lisa has very strong muscles and is very energetic abd strong which a peron with ED is not, Skinny shaming is as hurthul and fatshaming so people should think before they say something to others
I always found it offensive how a lot of people would use Lisa as one of the faces of “Kpop dieting” or “Kpop weight loss” when she’s one of the few idols who never has seemed to go through weight loss like other idols have, she started off skinny yes but skinny doesn’t always attribute to Ed’s or diets.
i don't think people understand how the human body works. if you're doing vigorous workout (in her case, dancing) and have stress upon your body, you will lose weight. that's your body responding. you could lose body fat and gain muscles, and as a dancer and performer, you have to stay healthy to do the moves. which means eating, as well as exercising, which she does. Lisa is a smart girl and starving herself is not something she wishes to do. she understands the industry and the stress and pressure it can put on idols, especially female idols. so she takes care of her health and eats. and some people are just naturally skinny.
im so proud of her! im already hard on myself with my body and i cant imagine what itd be like having the entire world shame me for it as well. she's very strong and i love that she ignores it because she does know whats best for her. plus if youre moving around that much during the days etc like dancing, working out, even just walking for a bit you are naturally going to lose weight. especially if youre on an extreme tour like she was when blackpink wasnt able to see their home for a long time. i think a lot of people just associate kpop/kpop idols with being too thin or eds because that is a pattern with a lot of groups. i also think americans are maybe a bit too used to seeing slightly overweight or obese people mostly everywhere so they think any thin person is starving themselves, especially if they dont have hips the size of kylie jenner's (not literally)
Lisa has a high metabolism. There is also a possibility of having an overactive thyroid. In order for Lisa to gain muscle, she has to do less cardio and eat a high-protein diet. Combine this with weight training, different forms of yoga, or calisthenics. If you watch the MONEY video you see a clear example of gaining weight due to muscle.
It's because western teens are starting to try and starve themselves to be at Lisa's weight even tho most westerners have a larger frame and are taller. It's not some "agenda". It's a cultural thing. Now that media isn't constantly hating fat ppl in the west, regular ppl are turning to kpop idols to get their fix of who they want as a reason to starve themselves and diet. Westerners are obsessed with new trends in dieting, which ultimately leads to not being happy no matter what, and many just start binge eating. Either that, or they listen to quack dietitians who tell them to eat a certain way that just ends up being bad. If you are taller than Lisa and have a different frame size, you will not look like Lisa at her weight! Quit obsessing over numbers in weight and measurements based on outside appearance, only a doc can tell you if you're at a healthy weight and dieting right. Focus on proportion and eating gut healthy foods and balancing macros and micros, and avoiding foods that will bloat you and make you look bigger than you are. If anything, just cut out sugar and too many bready/pasta dishes. Balance is key
Haters gonna hate, hate, hate Lisa's gonna shake, shake, shake if you slim, skinny, fat, healthy . It's your body not theirs. No matter what people say........ Every body is beautiful just love yourself 💜
Its so sad that things like bodyshaming actually exists. Too fat, too skinny - imagine: people are different, no one is perfect. Wondering what bodyshamers would do if people would say nasty stuff about their looks, clothing, etc. They would probably be the first ones to cry.
It's so difficult being naturally skinny. My height is 164cm and I'm about 42 Kg and all my Life I've been body shamed because of my skinny body. People always compare me with an anorexic, a stick, rachitic, and also telling me things like: do you even eat? You look sick. I've tried almost everything. I eat a lot, I do excercises, tried to do hypercaloric diet but I'm tired of forcing myself to eat more than I can stand. Sometimes my intestine hurts and I can't poop for like days. I just gave up. Sorry for the text, I needed to vent because I'm so angry with people bullying other bodies just because how they look.
I agree with you on most points but I still dislike the concept of body goals in general. People are different and it can get you in a really bad mindset if you obsess over trying to achieve someone else's body
Genetics play a big role especially in her 20s. I’m Thai when I was her age and seriously ate like a cow 😂 hardly exercise. I was XXS size. We even have XXXS size for young adults clothes. Lisa is tall, slim build and work out hard. If she doesn’t eat too much junk, pizza, Korean fried chicken. I’m not surprised if she’s that slim.
I have a godmother who used to be a professional ballet and she has the same body as Lisa. It’s because they started dancing when they were young. My godmother had to diet when she had shows bc it was required for huge performances, but even when she doesn’t diet her body looks the same. They are just long and muscular and toned bc they have been dancing since they were rly young.
I feel like part of her weight gain was also her growing into her body. We all know Lisa has long limbs. She was 19 years old when Blackpink debuted. I don't think it's too outlandish of a thought that her body developed and filled out more as a result of maturing.
This. Finally someone talking sense.
I agree. And I think it also works the other way around. Theres probably many idols that lost weight because they were so young when they debuted and they just lost the baby fat/hormonal fat from their teens, especially in the face.
and her body will keep changing and growing in her 20s if she keeps the healthy diet and lifestyle she's been doing all this time. people forget bodies do change and mature as you grow up in your 20s too
yes, many are insisting that the gained weight is only muscle, as if anything else would be bad. change is normal anyway, and it makes sense to 'fill up' with muscle or fat as you grow up if you have been very slim when you were younger, especially if you have been very active as a kid. your metabolism usually slows down as you age, so simply growing up can explain everything.
Exactly! My body at 19 and 21 even was so different... Less gangly and more curvy.
One of the things I notice alot is also that she never lacks energy, she always gives her best and is full of energy. You can see alot of times when idols lose weight bc of harsh diets that they suddenly lack energy in their dancing or look really tired on stage and that has never been the case wit lisa. I dont think she could have this kind of energy on stage constantly if she starved herself
Strong Will Power?
That’s bc dancing in her studio 24/7 is how she maintains the weight. Doesn’t necessarily mean she doesn’t starve at all. The dancing balances the starving. Not saying she starves all the time. Cmon u really believe she never starved during her career as a KPOP IDOL
@@khia797 i'm not saying she never starved or that she never had an unhealthy diet before, probably all idols have, especially when they were trainees or in the beginnng of their career but I was focusing more on now or the last year, where she also gained some weight. Also you can't dance/practice 24/7 in a studio if you are truly constantly starving or you'll break down at some point. I'm just saying that there's a huge difference in her energy when dancing on stage/performing than when you compare it to idols where its KNOWN they have an unhealthy diet bc they keep talking about it.
@@khia797 lmao u just cant admit that naturally skinny ppl exist. lisa is clearly one of them. it doesn’t matter how much she dances, she will get exhausted every time, that’s how the body works???
@@annis749 actually you can many idols mentioned they’ve gotten used to the starving by balancing it out with dancing or doing yoga something athletic.. to distract them.. though she may not be starving now she prob went back & forth with the starving throughout the years but since she is naturally skinny she has it easier & prob does it less versus other idols
(Edit) my comment was meant for the last thing u said in ur original comment. I just stated my opinion too that I think she has starved herself throughout years going back n forth.
Lisa is one of those people who have a naturally healthy slim body frame, even when it seems like she "gained weight" you can tell it's mostly pure muscle. She works hard and it shows, much love to Lisa and all of Blackpink ~♡
True
yes
Agreed🤝
Yes I love the muscle look on her, she looks super strong. But I love her no matter what
Healthy?
Honestly Lisa's the only blackpink member that has continued to gain weight (muscle) each comeback without any weight losses
The only member that truly fluctuates in weight is Jisoo. Of course not that that is a bad thing but Lisa isn’t the only member of blackpink to remain consistent in weight and not lose weight for comebacks. Everyone just makes blind incorrect assumptions especially about rosé that they’ve lost weight every single time.
G DRAGON IS THE KING
@@StanChunghaOrGoHome rosie lost a lot of weight during her solo and jennie’s weight fluctuates a lottt not as drastic as jisoo’s tho
Not trying to be mean but there’s hardly any muscle when you’re that skinny.
@@himaririku9254 doesn't relate
Lisa does her best to maintain her body looking good. People need to know the difference between being healthy and unhealthy without labeling someone with some kind of disorder or health issue.
G DRAGON
KING G DRAGON
There's a difference between being thin by starving yourself and being toned. Lisa is toned. Look at her arm muscles 13:09! You don't build muscle by starving yourself. You need to work out AND eat enough (especially protein) in order to build muscle. So her arms and legs are enough proof that she's doing that. She has so much energy as well!
She's a beautiful, talented, confident young woman. People are intimidated by that.
I think her legs are toned since she's a professional dancer. However if you wanna have toned muscles you need to do weight lifting, I don't know if she does, but if she did since she has a low fat percentage her muscles would pop out completely
You can still gain muscle even if you starve
What arm muscles?
@@swag428 💀
@@oopssenpai8208 I’m just curious cuz I can’t c them
it’s actually more insane that people will automatically think skinny = diet in kpop, like lisa and all the blackpink members have said numerous times that they dont diet, and it actually shows because when you don’t starve yourself or diet in an extreme way, there are less chances that your body bounces back and makes you gain more weight that you’ve lost, hence why their body never changed extremely.
they’ve always had the same figure since debut because they have the same eating habits as before
Exactly. I don't know why people don't understand that naturally skinny people DO exist
I feel like these days people are so quick to throw out the words “eating disorder” or “starvation” at anyone who is on the thinner side, wants to get healthy or wants to lose some weight and it’s so frustrating! They think that the only way to lose weight is by starving and that’s very concerning. There is something called a balanced diet, calorie deficit and exercise! I also notice that when those words are thrown around carelessly they start to get taken less seriously, just like the word “anxiety” There’s now people thinking they have anxiety disorders just because they once felt a little nervous before a test. It’s much deeper than that, every human experiences anxiety every now and then but anxiety disorders completely take over and ruin lives just like eating disorders!
Perfectly said👍
because the antis are doing the same to maintain their weight so they are just themselves by teasing idols
@@kurumbix4029 Teasing?? Don't you mean bullying & shaming cause teasing can be said as a joke but what they trolls do to idols is horrendous.
Thank you!
@@florencembah2626 ya sry
I know a lot of people asked for an update but I don't really see a difference from 2020 haha. Lisa always seems super confident and happy in her own skin no matter what show she's performing on.
your videos always point out proper hypocrisy and i love that. i think everyone who criticize idols’ bodies should watch your video. what you said about lisa in comparison to idols who are praised for being on the thicker side for idols yet theyre the ones who struggle the most with dieting, i had never even thought of.
I personally wouldn't say that Lisa she really gained weight per se. I think she just got really toned in her lower body portion.
I been waiting for this one ^0^
i was curious if you were going to do an update on Jimin?
I really love how spesific your videos
She gets SO much hate it’s crazy...she’s always gotten hate since debut, for being thai, being too skinny, people saying she ‘can’t sing’ it never ends....I’m glad she’s never late the hate affect her stage presence. She never gives it anything less than 100% Queen !
Same exactly with Minzy after her debut when she was 14.
I really dislike it when people think they can tell if someone is healthy or not just based on how their body looks, some people are born skinny and have trouble gaining weight even though they have a balanced diet, being skinny doesn’t mean unhealthy.
Same goes for when someone gains a little bit of weight or is not naturally skinny but is not diagnosed with obesity :/
exactly! I have a friend who eats 6 full meals a day and still cannot gain any weight.
Exactly my bestie tried to eat a LOT and lift heavy at the gym and so many things ( medicaments etc .. ) but nothing worked for her she is still SOOOO thin ( HOW DO U FEEL LIVING MY DREAAAAM AHHHHH ) like her old sister too it's GENETICS
@@rymasiuuu6312 U can't avoid me 😏
Those ppl gain wieght yrs later. But not the desirable kind... Uk what I mean. My dream of being a bone will never come true...
As a naturally thin-framed/ taller than average girl I can confirm the hate is very real. Even more so when you are a teenager when everyone's more focused on body image. I have always been thin, but ever since I started to gain weight, I am getting backhanded compliments and rude comments. Please keep going Lisa, we love you.
Im sorry for hearing that. Ik that since im a male that it isnt in the sam light but i also am very skinny barely being at 60 kg and ive even tried to starve myself and start eating again so i could get the yoyo affect and it didnt even work . Im 180 cm tall ( 5 11) and my mom constantly thin shames me as well as other guys since i sont have any muscle . I hope you're doing better now 4 months later queen.
I can 100% relate to this. I was always naturally thin and it seems that everyone had a lot to say about it
100% relate. For me gaining weight is a loooootttttt harder than just to lost weight. When I'm sick, 3 days is enough for me to lost 5kg. And it needs months to gain those back 🥲
FINALLY SOMEONE WITH COMMON SENSE 😩 I’m so tired of the ‘but she’s under the normal BMI and she looks anorexic’ argument, and the fact that people will always try to support this bs of an ‘argument’ by saying ‘It’s fine to admit that the company and the entertainment forces her to be skinny 🥺’. They literally go around stating this with no objective proofs, and It makes me nervous, because I’m the same as Lisa and somehow someone always has to point out the things they call Lisa.
people say those things as if they never saw a skinny person in their lives, as if skinny people are just like that bc they starve when it's a completely normal and natural body type in many people
Lisa literally said that herself that she gains Weight pretty quick and even loses weight pretty quick.
@@stanshvts1997 lmao no she didn’t, source??
The reason why we're below BMI is because we have a tinier bone density and frame than average, add that to a fast metabolism and you'll literally have to overeat to just have a normal BMI. I have an ample amount of fat in my body but I look tiny and I weigh less because my bones are so thin.
Will she was on that tv (forget what it was called) the guy said she was underweight but it’s clear she eats well and she’s always been that tiny
i feel like for bp its the opposite of losing weight when it comes to comeback season. they're always a bit more leaner and muscular during promos. they make sure to eat well and exercise to mantain stamina in order to sing & dance constantly.
i still remember during their 2018-2019 world tour and coachella, they were all very toned. they need to be physically good shape in order to fulfil all of their hectic schedules! and i thank their team for keeping their health a priority before any unnecessary diet!
women can never win when it comes to body standards & blackpink is one of the many examples - like there are actually people who call jisoo & jennie "fat" and say that their legs & arms look too "meaty" while in the same breath rosé & lisa get called "skeleton", "anorexic", "sick" etc.?? skinny doesn't automatically equal unhealthy! stop judging someone's health only based on how YOU see their bodies. you don't know them personally, their eating pattern, their health history or anything else. the comments that were shown in this video were disgusting, just cause someone is skinny doesn't mean they don't have feelings or you get a free pass to insult or degrade them for their bodies. skinny shaming hurts the affected persons as well cause at the end of the day we're all human beings who all get affected in a negative way by mean comments.
All that dancing gained her lean muscles ! She never looks malnourished just naturally petite and over time gain muscle and getting older.
Haters: lose weight.
Idol: loses weight
Haters: ew gain weight.
See it makes no sense! Why try to control idols and when the haters get their way they still aren’t satisfied?? As long as Lisa is a healthy weight, I’m happy. I’m happy when my idols are happy and it hurts to see people bringing the happy vibes down. Harassing others cause they are skinny is just as bad as fat shaming.
I really hate the mentality of these people honestly, they think idols are their play dolls or sims 🤷🏻♀️ it’s actually very sad and concerning, these are the same people who’ll grow up to be parents someday and body shame their children 🙁
Exactly I still remember when they called idols like Jennie and Somi fat LIKE WHat ?!,!????!!! and now Somi lost weight OMGGG U ARE SOOOO THIIIN DON'T SKIP MEALS GAIN WEIGHT at least she TOASTED THEM
I think a lot of the hate stems from jealousy, I mean I’m jealous of her just look at her she’s like an absolute goddess haha! It’s great to see her have a more athletic ‘healthier’ looking weight now compared to debut, but she still has the same lovely slim body proportions and women naturally just get curvier as they get older too. She seems like a really happy driven young woman!
Me 2. I'm jelus 2...
She's just born skinny. At her ages with her exercise routines plus her works, her shape just goes naturally with that. I really can tell if that time she works hard. Her weight seems up and down so easily. Anyway, i love yr video. Can't agree more that Lisa's strongest point is to ignore the haters and just be positive. Years by years, they already prove it.
I’m loving the little bits of humour in these more recent videos
she is so healthy and strong, fr. like really one of the healgjiersy body in kpop, and im proud of her for being happy and have healthy minfdet
Conclusion: people don't know what they want when it comes to weight. Idols should stop worrying about that and focus on their talents...
oh, but I'm forgetting this industry revolves heavily on outer beauty over talent. Maybe companies should promote a healthier message for everyone, and not tell people inner beauty is what matters, making songs about that topic, when they clearly don't think that way.
It's so sad that people shame Lisa for something she can't control. Shes a dancer and dancers usually have the body type Lisa has, She's strong and muscular. Lisa also has a fast metabolism and that makes it hard to gain weight. People need to stop shaming her
Being dancer has nothing to do with skinny body.stop this shit
@@cianchim9034 it sometimes does lol. as a dancer you burn more calories than the average person. go look at a ballerina and see how muscular she is
@@cheeseburgercake7193 Ballerinas hold strict Diets
"Born skinny bitch
No matter how much weight I gain, I’m slim"
Lisa stays winning. She doesn't give a shit about what haters say.
The same people who bash Lisa’s body are the same people who would kill to have a body like hers. Lisa has amazing proportions, healthy, talented, humble, sweet, and beautiful. Leave her alone!!!
Most woman outside korea don't desire Body like Lisa.they want some thick legs,thick hibs and boobs and some fat in ribcage area so that they don't look like skeleton
This video just showed me that you can never please everyone. People will always find something to criticize. Why can't people just let her be seriously? Just focus on yourself. Lisa is a queen and I know those body shaming comments can't bring her down, it just makes her stronger.
Out of all Blackpink members, Lisa is by far the most stable one, and to me she seems the healthiest one. I hate that in Western culture, everyone's quick to criticize anyone who's on the thinner side, even if it's completely natural, and are quick to assume they have an ED, which is absolutely not always the case
@@rosieposie1504 Jennie and Jisoo's weight fluctuates a lot more than Lisa's. You can see it in their faces and legs. But don't get me wrong, they're all amazing and I hope they're all healthy. It's just that to me, Lisa seems to be the healthiest one
@@pa.o she is not the healthiest. She is back to her skinny frame now.
@@ispeakonlyfacts.3228 What nonsense are you saying now? She is literally looking gorgeous now, lean muscled and looking so healthy. Might consider changing your @ cause you’re speaking straigh trash
@@rosieposie1504 she did but obviously people like to think she is starving herself rather than to believe that that’s her actual body type
@@ispeakonlyfacts.3228 She's thin but have a toned legs and arms right now. So she's healthy.
Actually the statement at the end when you said Lisa's weight wasnt put in a negative light is false. People were fat shaming her and complaining that she gained weight. Which is really weird considering all they did was scream and cry about how Lisa was to thin and needed to gain weight and when she did they proceeded to complain about it
Exactly, they complained she gained lot of weight, i was shocked, when it was just muscles, they really body-shamed her and called her lot of names, i can vouch i saw this one, if not i don't comment
@@mae_ri Yes! I saw some tweets saying things about her weight gain like "we lost another one" (what do they even mean by that?) And "Lisa is getting fat" (or something similar to that) I was really shocked and disgusted when I saw these
@@tothekosmos4042 yeah disgusting set of humans
The thing is they just wanna hate, haters gonna hate
Most people dont know the difference between gaining muscle and gaining fat which is actually sad. People are never happy I swear
I have been watching your channel for a long time,and I gotta say, I really appreciate the the amount of research and facts you put in your vedios. After watching all the blackpink videos along with the other idols videos,it's clear that the girls themselves are totally fine and don't really seem to put much thought on their diet. From what we see they have three meals a day and often even have midnight snack. They don't have any kind to eating disorders and have never encouraged any kind of unhealthy eating habits or diets. They seem content and happy in terms of their eating habits.
Even when asked in interviews about their diet they have said they like having a balanced proportioned meals three times a day so why do people always seem to say something about their body and eating habits. I have seen this kind of comment saying they are worried about their weight or how they look underweight,my question to you is why,just why are you worried. Did they say anywhere they are unhealthy and weak. It is not our job as fans to dictate what an idols eats or do. Also before people come and comment about how they are worried about influencing the young fans, as a young fan let me say they haven't done any bad influencing on my eating habits. They have in all their interviews only encouraged people people eat healthy and exercise regularly to keep our bodies fit. So as a blink it never occurred for me to compare my bodies with these girls or even worry about their weight which seems to be the excuse and worry of all the netz or knetz when it comes to an idols diet influence on the fans.
Also before people come here and comment on how they might not say the full truth of their diet or what they really do behind the camera, really do we need to scrutinize and doubt everything they say.
If these girls are really lying about their eating habits I think the opposite should happen. Because both Lisa and Rosé are being thinshamed . If they are dieting for the sake of the fans then it doesn't make sense. As all the so called fans are actually telling them to put on weight or should I say forcing them to have curves on their body. And I am sure they have heard these so called worriness of the fans. And from what we see they are consistent and don't really do any kind of extreme eating, diet or exercise for the sake of these people. Which means they are content with their present body and are also confident and aren't shaken by these comments.
I have also seen people just hate on them for how their bodies are and then hide behind these indirect hate comments by saying they are worried for the girls. Please don't do that.They really don't need your worries. It's fine if you don't like their music or style. We all have our own opinions. Don't watch vedios related to blackpink if you don't like them. As a multifan even I have some groups I like and dislike and I just avoid the groups I dislike. No need to spread any hate on any groups.
And for people who say they have eating disorders pls go and learn the definition of eating disorder. It's a mental disorder where they have distorted body image which leads to them seeing as overweight or underweight. I have seen people saying that Lisa and rosé have eating disorder because they are thin . If they do have it ,then it would be anorexia nervosa where idols with this disorder would refuse to eat in front of other and lose large amount of weight in a week and starve themselves to death. Its clear these girls never shy away from saying that they have good proportioned meals and also have eaten food and asked for food if they are hungry. Rosé also said that she eats rice before any important event and we also see her eating in all the shows and etc(like in the present vogue interviews for both met gala and Paris fashion week). During their netflix swoon interview when asked who always eats, jisoo pointed out on Lisa saying she always had some packs of chocolate if she gets Hungry, and rosé pointed out how jisoo kept on drinking milk because she wants to grow tall🤣😆😁. They have no problem with having some amount of carbs and also have timely food.
I recommend people to see the other idols videos here to know who really do have Ed and how idols with ED behave. I hope these idols don't get hate for their body and people will stop commenting on it.
Also stop saying blackpink aren't real women because two members are thin.They are real confident women who don't need someone's approval of how their body should look. All 4 girls have been having a consistent weight for 6 years even when they got bodyshed so thats enough confirmation for all the fans and netz to stop worrying about their weight. And stop hating on the girls on how their bodies look,if someone says Rosé, Lisa , Jennie and Jisoo look beautiful,let them appreciate them. Because none of the girls made the fans feel like they have to have any particular food or diet to look a certain way. When the girls themselves encourage everyone to eat healthy balanced diet and also not shy away from trying out different cuisines then why do the knetz and netz still want to say these girls have a disorder and they are a bad influence when in reality these girls are a good influence for people who follow unhealthy diets.
Stop creating a problem just to hate on the girls or just to make yourself look better. Sorry for the rant,I got a bit carried away. Pls don't fight in the comment section. Sorry for my grammar as eng is my second language.Again pls don't comment on their bodies , we as fans need not worry about what they eat or how they look when they have never encouraged any kind of unhealthy diets.
Ps. I have seen in RUclips where in blinks channels when the youtuber uploads a pic of the blackpink girls saying their outfits are good or their performance are good or if they say these girls look elegant ,the comments section is filled with the so called "worried" fans who keep on saying Rosé and Lisa look underweight and they are worried for them.Pls don't comment if you really don't know what is happening behind the scenes.To just throw on words like weak and Eating disorder isn't something simple. Actually fans like these people are the ones who turn a normal healthy idol into having an eating disorder when these idols themselves never had one before. Lisa and Rosé might look underweight but we have no rights,no rights to say what they should eat and do. If you feel like they look thin then just don't shame them for it. Appreciate the other girls , say they all look nice and leave it at that. No need to hate on idols who is naturally thin. How would you feel of people said you look underweight you need to eat a lot when you are eating and exercising just fine or how would you feel if people said you rae overweight and you need to lose it when you are eating and exercising just fine. How would you feel if someone commented on your natural body by saying it's not desirable or you look bad or say you are doing a diet when in reality you just eat normally(balanced diet) and do exercise regularly.So don't comment on their body and shame on their body without knowing anything. It can really do lot of damage to these idols mental health.
The blackpink girls are healthy and don't seem to want their fans to constantly talk about something as insignificant as their body type and weight. In pretty savage song Lisa literally said she is a skinny b*tch or skinny chick which means these girls do read those horrible comments and Rosé during her Solo premiere interview had said she loves eating and her sister Alice said her nickname in school was porky pig because she eats a lot. A foodie like her won't be able to live without food.Leave the girls alone. They are fine,of they do have something they will open up,we don't need to unnecessarily worry about them and comment on how they look.
0:58 this is SUCH a true point that needs to be addressed more often. not every slim idol is unhealthy. sure they’re underweight, but just like being slightly overweight doesnt make you unhealthy, being underweight doesnt if you’re eating and exercising well
It’s easy to see she’s just built this way.
But imagine dreaming to be a performer, having that dream come true and no one asking you about the creative process, your motivations, your inspirations but rather.. about your diet 🥴
I love the fact that all Blackpink members maintain their body right from the time they first debut and truly happy that they feel confident on themselves and ignoring the haters for body shame them fighting 😘😘
She's gorgeous! Although common, bodyshaming is never healthy and nice. Glad Lisa is doing better! 💟💕💞💖💖💓
If anything Rosé and Lisa have the healthiest bodies since they carried consistent weight throughout the years. Jennie and Jisoo changed a lot more
its always body positivity unless its ppl who are naturally underweight or thin (i know that plus size suffer much more) as a 5'10 girl whose only like 108 i relate to lisa alot bc i cant gain weight for shit and was bodyshamed too and trust me those type of naturally thin girls try to gain weight rlly hard
I’m glad that you added in plus size people suffer more cause it’s true but there is a double standard skinny shaming is real but when it’s talked about people think that it’s tone deaf when that’s not the case
Crazy how people hate her for being slim
Honestly, i think that Lisa is so gorgeous just the way she is. She is so talented and that is something really important that need to be mentioned. She is a real queen just like the other members of Blackpink. We need to support her and understand that all bodies are different and react in a different way depending on every situation.
this video is great people need to grow up and know that skinny shaming is as harsh and hurtful as fat shaming it's really mean what some people would say fr
I feel like Lisa and Rosé just have the body types that don’t gain weight easily. One of my best friends is very thin but that girl can EAT. it’s just in her genetics!
What you said in the 14:00 minute mark is pretty true, people seem to dislike natural slim women is jealousy and bitterness
As someone that's always been on the skinnier side naturally, I'm so pissed for Lisa. No one deserves to be shamed for being healthy. Some of us are naturally this skinny. I was especially thin when I was still growing. My legs were very thin and my rib cage was visible even if my arms were down. Because of my thin, curveless body, I experienced lots of bullying. I was told I was ugly because my bones were more visible. Because my backside didn't grow in until later, people shamed me for having no curves. I was only 11 when this was really bad. Even my best friends called me ugly. So when I see others being shamed for their appearance, my heart aches and I get pissed off. It makes me want to smack some of these audacious and disrespectful people with a 2X4. Keep eating healthy foods that make you happy and maintain a balance of exercise. If consistent, you'll be at your healthiest. This is what Lisa has been doing. The amount of fat and muscle on your bones will never determine how beautiful you are. What's beautiful is someone that does their best to be healthy both physically and mentally. :)
13:50 guuuuurl you finally said it. The West has a skewed af view on healthy now due to seeing everyone fat all the time! Being fat is now normal and it's terrifying. I'm still losing the weight I need but now when I mention I have about 25-30 more lbs to lose everyone goes "omg noooo you'll disappear!" like no, no I won't. I'm still on the bigger side.
I just want to put out there my experience. I have always been very thin, my dad is too, i eat regularly and i even eat very high-calory foods on a daily basis. Lisa inspired me to get a bit of muscular mass, for the body type i have it is attainable for me to get a body like hers. I wasn't very happy with my body before Lisa because i have been skinny shamed my whole life. I am not saying that lisa's body is the ideal type, and i strongly believe some people might get sick trying to get it because it's not for everyone. Don't compare yourselves with someone who has very different metabolism and bone structure from you. The best is to be HEALTHYLY inspired by your fav/Idol/actor whatever that looks like to you, if you feel like that could help with your body image. And stop harrassing people for the way they look. But that's just my opinion, nobody is going to read this anyways lol
Thank you for making this video! Basically i love Lisa and am so happy to see evidence of her healthy habits so i’m really grateful for the effort you put in compiling all the pictures. Basically I got to enjoy a whole video of beautiful pics of best girl! I hope she is healthy and happy for the rest of her life!!
Let's refrain from bodyshaming thin people in the comments. Everyone's bodies are different, and we aren't all supposed to be at a bigger size. Some of our weights naturally stay on the low end and that's fine. One weight isn't better than another so don't put them down. Skinny shaming is the same as fat shaming and can be hurtful. Look at Rose for example
I honestly don't understand how people think she's lost weight since its debut. If you compare pictures between the two it's obvious that even if she hasn't gained 'fat' her hips have gotten larger through puberty and muscle development. And like muscles literally require calories and fat to grow and even remain so like science literally renders the argument of not eating void???????? like if you're going to hate at least know your facts
For me Lisa’s body is such a bodygoal
I really like her tight arms and her abs her thighs everything is just perfect I truly can see how healthy n fit lisa is ❤️ actually her body everytime amazed me her body makes her dance even more clean n attractive
Nd tbh she has the best body I’ve ever seen in my life I mean she is just my type😘😘😘❤️
sameeee, Lisa's body is literally the ideal body to me
Exactly, people should realize people have different taste if they hate Lisa body, they should remember that lots of people love Lisa body & Lisa opinion & happiness is the most important
It's fine to have a body goal, but just remember you never can get the EXACT same body, as everyone has a different body type! The most common body type is the Pear shape for example, and you can't magically go from a pear shape to a real hourglass, though you can try to build muscle to replicate it a little :) Just wanted to mention this, as sometimes people don't seem to realize body goals are nice but also can't be fully 100% the same haha!
@@yulana990 I like your concern:) and tbh I didn’t intend to give any negative impacts on someone🙂
Also I didn’t mean it
I just love lisa and for lilis she is just perfect the way she is that’s what I mean😊
Do people find it shocking that there are idols with fast metabolism or do they just live under a rock ??
As an naturally skinny(38kg /150cm), I always get body shamed and being told not eating properly, meanwhile I eat everything in the kitchen, our body just burn more calories than others, or we have short intestine so we don't absorb all calories like other people.
I have skull sticking out of my skin but that just my natural body frame, I'm not fatigue or anything or starving myself. Is it wrong to have skinny figure??
I think people really want adjusting every person weight with their standart, but reality everyone has their different body type :( please open your eyes, not every skinny person starve themselve!! It's just their body!!
Sorry to hear this :( I'm 149cm myself and struggle to lose weight instead no matter how little I eat, and my friend also is naturally skinny and can eat so many cals and not gain anything to the point it stresses him out. People really should stop acting like BMI is everything, especially when the same people who call others too skinny and "anorexic" say that the BMI is inaccurate for obesity and is flawed! It's also been shown that the BMI is very inaccurate for people udner 155cm and above 190cm or something, and for people at our height the BMI's should be higher, so you being 38kgs is actually fine!
Some people just think anyone who's skinny HAS to have an ED or is starving which is ridiculous, and they should be ignored as they are very ignorant. You aren't even underweight BMI wise (using the BMI for shorter people), and with the normal BMI would be 3kgs underweight which is not severe and won't kill someone. Stay healthy like you are right now and try to not take those comments to heart. :)!
One thing i like in BP they never starved themselves. They just maintained their own body. They don't need to pressure themselves to be "skinny" as a Kpop idols. And that's a relief for me as a fan of them. They bash BP for being too skinny when infact they eat a lot,they always bash them but BP always makes money a lot,so thanks to the bashers of BP.
I am so proud of her that she is one of those people who observe and think wisely and fairly...not just to protect them from all the hate they get, but also she is very fair and she researches well...I am very happy I got to meet someone this wonderful! Hwaiting! You got a new subscriber!!🥺
A true fan is accepts fully and wholeheartedly an idol who he/she idolized. Lisa unnie, we, the BLINKS accept who you are both inside and outside of yourself. You have the good physic and beautiful face. Keep fighting #LISA unnie!😘 The #BLACKPINK members as well as true BLINKS will protect you. Thank you for making this vvide.😊❤
She never deserved to be skinny shamed, nobody does. But I’m glad she gained weight. She looks healthier and more energetic
Honestly love her i never thought of her anything tbh like she is happy real blinks know lisa and won’t ever question lisa weightloss or weightgain we love her either way its the antis who attack
She even said it herself on a show, she doesn't have a diet. She just dances a lot and she loves it. Dancing keeps her fit and she even has muscles from it
My American kpop friends still diss Lisa's body even in her thickest eras, especially one who is overweight and has a habit of thin shaming. They don't believe there is such a thing as skinny-shaming, but I always shut them down immediately and say I won't talk about them that way and won't stay around them if they do. So many Americans still have that skinny-shaming mindset it's so sad.
I find it crazy that so many people think she is too thin. I think she looks amazing. Most, literally most, people over here in america are overweight, and yet they think they should comment on her being thin. The absolute irony 🥴
Definitely think people are overreacting. The majority of kpop idols are as skinny as she is. Shes healthy and happy. That’s all that matters. She’d probably get hate if she put weight on too
She should come to USA, we have whales as idols atm, she will be a breath of fresh air.
9:37 The real yo-yo here is not Lisa’s weight but the netizens. Lisa is clearly healthy and so energetic since forever
There are actually people who are born skinny, it hurts when they calling you some names about being skinny. it's not our fault if we are built like this
tbh people thinking that only really thin bodies are associated with ED's actually make things worse and put a stigma around them in reality anyone can have anorexia regardless of their body type when I had an ED I definitely did not look like what media makes girls with eds to look like which honestly tarnished my mental health even more thinking I wasn't "sick" enough so ppl think they are doing something by calling naturally thin bodies someone with ed's actually make things worse and feed more into stereotypes and miseducation about them.
If people see how she twerks during her concert in Amsterdam and other places on a fancam.
Then yeah, she’s not too skinny she’s just muscular and knows how to keep a physique.
Lisa is just naturally slim and she absolutely looks healthy. I wish I was lucky enough to be blessed with her metabolism and natural frame. All 4 of them look completely healthy to me. And you can tell they've filled out since 2016 because they are grown women now, not teenagers. They didn't gain a huge amount of weight but they definitely have a more grown up fullness to them than when they when they first started.
It's not a crime to be super skinny and it's not a crime to be thick. The only crime is body shaming others because they don't fit into your idea of a perfect body...
My body is very similar to Lisa's (only with a big butt and cellulite), and let me tell you, some of the rude things people have told me are out of this world. I have been told "I was worried while you were dancing that you would collapse", I was an "unfair skinny bitch" when I lost my pregnancy weight after my son was born (with daily exercise), I was told my bones are unattractive, I should put on weight, and that I have an ED.
It's literally just my body type and exercise, but people are jealous so they say mean shit like this. I am very happy Lisa ignores all of it.
8:20 is the first time I heard Lisa speaking Thai, it felt like coming home
Lisa’s legs are perfect , I love so much 💖
Lisa seems to simply have superfast metabolism. Her body actually digests her food too fast, making it difficult for her to actually gain a lot of weight. I actually was in class with someone at high school who had the same problem. It was like she had the stomach of 4 horses. She ate like 3 times as much as everyone else, yet never gained a pound. Some people simply are like that
You can just tell with Lisa that she's naturally tall and thin, and very healthy and and fit. There's just a big difference between someone who is malnourished and someone like Lisa who just happens to be thin
People are just jealous to a person that naturally skinny .
Her weight is no issue, i have a friend that is like her, skinny since childhood even if she eats a Ton of food and up till now she still is but developed some muscles. It seems they loose weight fast when stressed but slow at gaining it back. How I wish to be like Lisa who have a fast metabolism so i can eat so much food without worrying to get obese like the 60% Americans. Those people who body shame Idols are ignorant and insecure and at the end of the day they would be searching other Idols diets to extreme weight loss.
I have exactly your wish, to have a fast metabolism & muscle build which burns calories fast then I can eat all I want cause I soo love food.
It's clear to anyone with common sense she's naturally slim. That is a natural body type for millions of people. People need to stop commenting on other people's bodies. Being a fan doesn't make it your business.
the only video i was waiting for actually
NATURAL its all natural she was literally born with a really thin frame and doesnt gain weight easily despite this she's gained a ton of muscle and looks so healthy toned and beautiful none of black pink have to diet intensely because theyre built like thst
she looks so good in her comeback like Im so much more in love with her🤤
And that's why she sang "born skinny, bitch" 🤷♀️
With as much Lisa dances and how much energy she always puts in, she'd be in and out of the hospital if she were starving herself to maintain her slim frame. She would've probably broken down on stage already, or it would've been apparent in her face. No one can tell me that this girl isn't healthy. Being quite slim, especially over a long period of time like hers doesn't always equal to drastic diets or E.Ds.
she always have been critized for being "an*rex1c" and "trying" to make people starve to be skinny. Then when she gain a little more weight afters years mainting her body really skinny, ppl saying she was FAT and was ugly. Honestly, i don't have any comments about how disgusting this are.
Literally people are so stupid
I have an Ed and when i was at my lowest i was really skinny but i had no energy i looked as white as a zombie because of malnutrion and i was really tired, i could barely even walk
Lisa has very strong muscles and is very energetic abd strong which a peron with ED is not,
Skinny shaming is as hurthul and fatshaming so people should think before they say something to others
I used to be worried about Lisa when they debuted, but she very obviously has been gaining healthy weight
I always found it offensive how a lot of people would use Lisa as one of the faces of “Kpop dieting” or “Kpop weight loss” when she’s one of the few idols who never has seemed to go through weight loss like other idols have, she started off skinny yes but skinny doesn’t always attribute to Ed’s or diets.
i don't think people understand how the human body works. if you're doing vigorous workout (in her case, dancing) and have stress upon your body, you will lose weight. that's your body responding. you could lose body fat and gain muscles, and as a dancer and performer, you have to stay healthy to do the moves. which means eating, as well as exercising, which she does. Lisa is a smart girl and starving herself is not something she wishes to do. she understands the industry and the stress and pressure it can put on idols, especially female idols. so she takes care of her health and eats. and some people are just naturally skinny.
She is a dancer.They burn lots of calories.
im so proud of her! im already hard on myself with my body and i cant imagine what itd be like having the entire world shame me for it as well. she's very strong and i love that she ignores it because she does know whats best for her. plus if youre moving around that much during the days etc like dancing, working out, even just walking for a bit you are naturally going to lose weight. especially if youre on an extreme tour like she was when blackpink wasnt able to see their home for a long time. i think a lot of people just associate kpop/kpop idols with being too thin or eds because that is a pattern with a lot of groups. i also think americans are maybe a bit too used to seeing slightly overweight or obese people mostly everywhere so they think any thin person is starving themselves, especially if they dont have hips the size of kylie jenner's (not literally)
She’s too gorgeous, I don’t understand people who bodyshame. Just because somebody is thin doesn’t make it ok to body shame them!
Lisa has a high metabolism. There is also a possibility of having an overactive thyroid. In order for Lisa to gain muscle, she has to do less cardio and eat a high-protein diet. Combine this with weight training, different forms of yoga, or calisthenics. If you watch the MONEY video you see a clear example of gaining weight due to muscle.
Honestly, Lisa has the most perfect body and proportion among BLACKPINK.
It's because western teens are starting to try and starve themselves to be at Lisa's weight even tho most westerners have a larger frame and are taller. It's not some "agenda". It's a cultural thing. Now that media isn't constantly hating fat ppl in the west, regular ppl are turning to kpop idols to get their fix of who they want as a reason to starve themselves and diet. Westerners are obsessed with new trends in dieting, which ultimately leads to not being happy no matter what, and many just start binge eating. Either that, or they listen to quack dietitians who tell them to eat a certain way that just ends up being bad.
If you are taller than Lisa and have a different frame size, you will not look like Lisa at her weight! Quit obsessing over numbers in weight and measurements based on outside appearance, only a doc can tell you if you're at a healthy weight and dieting right. Focus on proportion and eating gut healthy foods and balancing macros and micros, and avoiding foods that will bloat you and make you look bigger than you are. If anything, just cut out sugar and too many bready/pasta dishes. Balance is key
Haters gonna hate, hate, hate
Lisa's gonna shake, shake, shake
if you slim, skinny, fat, healthy . It's your body not theirs. No matter what people say........ Every body is beautiful just love yourself 💜
and the lyrics from you never know really goes well with this video. " its easier to judge me then to believe".
She's is beautiful ❤️ LALISA
I don't understand why people are more concern about somebody's weight
Lisa looks healthy and normal 🥰
Yes they’re skiny but not too skiny! It makes me mad when people say that idols are too skiny! Bc that’s how they’re body is Built like shutup
Its so sad that things like bodyshaming actually exists. Too fat, too skinny - imagine: people are different, no one is perfect. Wondering what bodyshamers would do if people would say nasty stuff about their looks, clothing, etc. They would probably be the first ones to cry.
It's so difficult being naturally skinny. My height is 164cm and I'm about 42 Kg and all my Life I've been body shamed because of my skinny body. People always compare me with an anorexic, a stick, rachitic, and also telling me things like: do you even eat? You look sick. I've tried almost everything. I eat a lot, I do excercises, tried to do hypercaloric diet but I'm tired of forcing myself to eat more than I can stand. Sometimes my intestine hurts and I can't poop for like days. I just gave up. Sorry for the text, I needed to vent because I'm so angry with people bullying other bodies just because how they look.
I agree with you on most points but I still dislike the concept of body goals in general. People are different and it can get you in a really bad mindset if you obsess over trying to achieve someone else's body
Genetics play a big role especially in her 20s. I’m Thai when I was her age and seriously ate like a cow 😂 hardly exercise. I was XXS size. We even have XXXS size for young adults clothes. Lisa is tall, slim build and work out hard. If she doesn’t eat too much junk, pizza, Korean fried chicken. I’m not surprised if she’s that slim.
She is looking more pretty and healthy seriously 🌸💞
I have a godmother who used to be a professional ballet and she has the same body as Lisa. It’s because they started dancing when they were young. My godmother had to diet when she had shows bc it was required for huge performances, but even when she doesn’t diet her body looks the same. They are just long and muscular and toned bc they have been dancing since they were rly young.