@@StyxxOfDidymos why do you assume they didn't read the books? And now that the show is out, the "recruitment tool" and "not looking for roommate" bits are definitely spoilers
Watched 5 minutes of this review and it's mostly just highlighting plot points and spoiling things. Less than 3 minutes left and it's barely spoken to the quality of dialogue, cinematography, or really anything. It's more of a show summary than a review.
Thats always how IGN review movies or shows. They just say what happened and drop a score at the end. But thats why you should watch actual dedicated reviewers, not a Video game site.
Guys you can watch this review the comment section is full of children who have never read the book or watched the show . Please ignore this uneducated person's comment.
Which means you watched much of all of the review right!? So why complain if you chose to watch the whole review if you were already hearing plot reveals??
No . There isn't you are just repeating the comments you've read cause your desprate for attention and likes. It spoiled nothing . Watch the show or read the book you dumb child
IGN has terrible journalism ethics! Your reviews have become spoiler filled “buzzword” editorials that are the equivalent of verbal masterbation. A review for a pre-release is supposed to be an objective analysis of what viewers should look forward to. Not a spoiler filled self-indulgent diatribe about plot twists and character motivations. Once upon a time IGN was an organization trusted for entertainment journalism at the forefront of genre culture. Now it’s a algorithm driven joke desperately grasping at whatever it thinks is “trending.” SHAME!
there never was a point. you can summarize the premise of the trilogy on one page. the rest is just poorly written sci-magic (its not hard science at all, we today know better than what the author assumes, he makes fundamental mistakes.)
No they didn't. You've never watched the show or read the book . Try forming your own opnion instead of just repeating what you read in a RUclips comment section . How childish. Lmfao .
Episodes 1-5 really built intrigue. 6-8 absolutely ruined the whole thing for me. It gets so silly and impossible. And no, not because it leans into the Fi of Sci-Fi, but because actions are taken (or not taken) make little-to-no sense. It becomes a comedy for how laughable every scene is once the story FINALLY picks up pace again after 2 hours of drudging through ep 6 and 7
I’m sorry, but as a fan of the book series, your review didn’t highlight if people in my camp would like the changes being done, and it’s quite obvious there are many changes that Make this a fundamentally different story.
Don't watch this until you read all 3 books, it's a more condensed spoiled version of it that takes a lot of the nuance and mistery from the novels (based on his full of spoiler review..)
The police character played by Benedict Wong’s name is not Da. In the book, his nickname is Da Shi. In Chinese context, this nickname means his Last name is Shi(史). The “Da” means big. Basically it can be interpreted as big bro Shi.
IGN: take this video down. As noted in the review, this project is meant to introduce the story TO PEOPLE WHO AREN’T FAMILIAR WITH IT. It’s cool and all that the reviewer is familiar with the entire franchise in its assorted incarnations, but this vid is written for people who know the twists and ruins them for the people this show is made for. I’m annoyed.
You know all those times in every other science fiction production that makes you roll eyes... like where the supposed biologist goes to prod the clearly provoked alien, or characters make some other equally idiotic decision that no one with a high school diploma would make? Well this show manages to avoid 95% of those. The decisions actually make sense. The characters ask the right questions. What plot holes you do see, are mostly explained by the fact that the show simply couldn't cover everything. Its a really refreshing experience for anyone with an interest in sci-fi and science.
@@HobiAIBook 2...the one with the dream woman...has strongest narrative? TF did you read... the only worthwhile book is 1, you get some Chinese history, some character study of a women doing something terrible out of "reasons" (not spoiling), and even if the science in the book is flat out wrong it can inspire some ppl.
They can tell people if the show is worth watching, WITHOUT giving away the entire f*cking plot of the whole season ffs. 🤦🏻♀️🙄 This was effing ridiculous. I've already read all of the books anyway, but for people who know nothing about the story at all... they literally give away everything that happens in the f*cking show! And they released this "review" 12 days before it even dropped for people on Netflix. That's INSANE... and that's why people are pissed. A proper review can discuss & rate stuff like the acting, the cinematography, or source material faithfulness... without giving away key plot points & surprise twists. This was awful.
Ign has always been one my primary review channels. But this “review”was more of synopsis, a spoiler fest. Thanks for telling the whole story, disliking the video. 👎🏼
1. Spoiler warning needed. 2. Who cares if some politician liked the story? Review the thing yourself. No one cares that ________ celebrity or politician thought it was "neat".
Well, among the executive producers are *Dumb & Dumber* and *Rian O'Roundhead* (though _his_ involvement is probably minimal compared to D&D, who are the _actual_ writers, directors & showrunners, with Alexander Woo, who was a writer on *_True Blood_* on HBO) .
How do you know there are spoilers? Because you already now the plot, why are watching a review of something you already know? Why everybody is so mad at this video if you clearly know all the plot?
Here’s the review Chinese best selling novel turned in a European who “dumbit” that is solved within 4 episodes - half the episodes are essentially the “beginning” the second book. The characters are atrocious (not the actors) - all expcept the dying one and Jon are complete “the world is to blame” narcissists. The plot is truncated to be almost unrecognizable, the CGI is laughable, the “subplots” asinine, the character arcs non-existent (much like the novels) It’s candy - so enjoy. A solid 5/10
It blows my mind that IGN thinks reviews are summering the entire plot of the thing (with no spoiler warning) instead of focusing on the quality of the writing, directing, acting, editing, etc. They have such a shallow level of understanding in how to review or cover entertainment. No wonder they love the MCU. It’s perfect for their type of brains.
This review is completely backwards. The VR portions of the show were the best parts (hence why 90% of the trailer are scenes from the VR sections). The human drama was boring a sin, and everything was contrived and convenient. The Santi could have easily found any planet in the galaxy that DOESN'T have 3 suns and it would be more habitable than their own.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
This review needs a spoiler warning. They reveal key elements of the plot you aren't supposed to get when you watch the show or read the book.
Thank you for the wroning
Thanks for the warning as well as most of my excitement for this show is seeing what the hell is happening
WTAF. This moron "reviewer" just killed the experience of watching this show. Absolutely disgusted with this spoiler video. Not a single warning.
Read the book there so much details the show won't/can't show
Thank you sir
A lot of spoilers in this review
thank you for this comment, looks interesting so ill just stop the video and try it lol
Plenty left out from this magnificent trilogy.
Correct, way too plots and twists to cover here, or even in the series.@@sarfaraz.hosseini
left out "many"
Honestly IGN always does this
WTF is with the spoilers in this review?!
Hahhahaaaa
he casually gave away at least two big reveals.
You mean the lack of spoilers.
You've never read the books. , and when you made this comment the show wasn't out. Spoilers? How could you know ? You are just saying what you heard .
@@StyxxOfDidymos why do you assume they didn't read the books?
And now that the show is out, the "recruitment tool" and "not looking for roommate" bits are definitely spoilers
Why is IGN releasing a spoiler ridden review before anyone else can even watch it? You're spoiling it for every single person watching. Shame on you.
^ exactly this
For everithing spoilers, stick whith IGN.
It’s called a review…
@@TalkinKush A review doesn't have to be full of spoilers? tf? theres a reason why everyone is complaining here
It’s IGN! Full of a bunch of know it alls that do no wrong!
Watched 5 minutes of this review and it's mostly just highlighting plot points and spoiling things. Less than 3 minutes left and it's barely spoken to the quality of dialogue, cinematography, or really anything. It's more of a show summary than a review.
Thats always how IGN review movies or shows. They just say what happened and drop a score at the end. But thats why you should watch actual dedicated reviewers, not a Video game site.
The quality of the dialogue and cinematography are both awful. There, fixed it.
yeah nice „review“…
@@albanier8426that’s how how they always do reviews, but it happens often enough to lose them credibility
Spoilers
Don't watch it if you're new to three body
Yall should mark this review for heavy spoilers wtf lol
it's more like a recap of the plot rather than a review lol
Agree
This is one of those stories where you’re probably going to need spoilers to keep up.
MASSIVE SPOILER WARNING! If you want to watch this series, don't watch this so called review. It ruins the entire experience. Downvote and move on
Guys you can watch this review the comment section is full of children who have never read the book or watched the show . Please ignore this uneducated person's comment.
Guys is this a mis timed release of the vid ? You guys are aware that the show releases on 21st right ? Too many spoilers for an early review guys.
A spoiler alert would be nice.
The series has a bad screenplay. Benioff and Weiss should stick to fantasy like GOT.
A spoiler alert for a review? LMAO.
This isn't a review, it's a recap. The mystery of the first book/season and you've spoiled it all. Why?
Lmfao comming from someome who's never watched the show or read the book . Dude stop hoping on to the hate train . Get a personality.
@@StyxxOfDidymosI think you might be projecting a little bit, stranger! 😊
SPOILERS. This isn’t a review.
No spoilers. Cry about it you big baby 😂
What kind of freaking review is this? You listed the majority of plot twists and reveals.
Which means you watched much of all of the review right!? So why complain if you chose to watch the whole review if you were already hearing plot reveals??
@@michaeldeierhoi4096 because we wanted an actual review. not a play by play of the plot points. but im not surprised you don't know the difference
Since they spoiled the plot. I'll spoil the review.
Its a solid 8/10. Thanks.
They didn't.
It’s an 8 if you wanna avoid spoilers
its a 1, its better you watching the chinesse version its more deep.
Bad spoilers in this review
No . There isn't you are just repeating the comments you've read cause your desprate for attention and likes. It spoiled nothing . Watch the show or read the book you dumb child
This isn't even a review. It's just a plot summary laden with major spoilers. WTF, IGN?
SHADDUP
IGN has terrible journalism ethics! Your reviews have become spoiler filled “buzzword” editorials that are the equivalent of verbal masterbation. A review for a pre-release is supposed to be an objective analysis of what viewers should look forward to. Not a spoiler filled self-indulgent diatribe about plot twists and character motivations. Once upon a time IGN was an organization trusted for entertainment journalism at the forefront of genre culture. Now it’s a algorithm driven joke desperately grasping at whatever it thinks is “trending.” SHAME!
Why does IGN always mess up there reviews 😂😂
I've read the books so whatever but this is just a plot summary. IGN, do better. And probably terminate whoever made this.
No you haven't clearly
This is not a plot summary at all . Stop lying .
Why would he spoil so much? How’s this a review
Thumbs down. It's not necessary to spoil major plot points in reviews.
My mans gave away the entire plot before I've even seen it or read it. What's the point of watching it at this point??
there never was a point. you can summarize the premise of the trilogy on one page. the rest is just poorly written sci-magic (its not hard science at all, we today know better than what the author assumes, he makes fundamental mistakes.)
No they didn't. You've never watched the show or read the book . Try forming your own opnion instead of just repeating what you read in a RUclips comment section . How childish. Lmfao .
@@StyxxOfDidymosbet? how much? lets go kiddo...i'm ready.
also, i'm in a bit of a mood...so you better come prepared.
this is not a review it's a spoiler laden monologue ..terrible stuff... don't watch if you have any interest ij actually watching the programme
What?? Is this a tv review or a summary?
Thanks for the spoiler warning people, immediately stopped the video
Episodes 1-5 really built intrigue. 6-8 absolutely ruined the whole thing for me. It gets so silly and impossible. And no, not because it leans into the Fi of Sci-Fi, but because actions are taken (or not taken) make little-to-no sense. It becomes a comedy for how laughable every scene is once the story FINALLY picks up pace again after 2 hours of drudging through ep 6 and 7
The Comment section saved me. gonna be disliking for the sole purpose of no spoiler warning
Wow. You are throwing spoilers right into the reviews! Please consider adding "spoilers included" in the description.
I’m sorry, but as a fan of the book series, your review didn’t highlight if people in my camp would like the changes being done, and it’s quite obvious there are many changes that Make this a fundamentally different story.
Obviously... it's for western audiences
its not even a review. it's just plot points, i.e. spoilers
How are reviews coming out so early? Do TV shows also get early copies like games?
Yes. Big reviewers and sites get to watch the show earlier than the rest of the world.
Are you new to reviews?
Watch the tencent version people
Is this a review or synopsis of the book??? come onnnnnnn
It's this level of no-spoiler warning, and smug reviewing that we've come to expect from IGN
Whoever wrote this review obviously read the books and has very high expectation for Netflix.
As they should
The show is awful, in my opinion.
They rated it an 8! Looking forward to it!
Spoiler alert! 😂
@@MrTimHamilton Not nearly as spoiler filled as the review ;)
Saving people from having to learn about the story before
why look forward when they gave she hulk and dune an 8
@@Caboos55 lol yeah those are all the same quality, totally
@@mistressfreezepeach that's the problem
Does it cover the wallfacer program in the show?
Don't want to spoil it but it sets it up for the next season.
They're introduced at the end of the season. Same idea, but gender/race swaps abound. They don't even have the same names or countries of origin.
thanks for the comment section for warning about spoilers in the review
Ign you guys' have to edit this review too many spoilers
Thanks for the spoilers... had to dry myself off in the shower as fast as possible to stop this video 🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️😡
Don't watch this until you read all 3 books, it's a more condensed spoiled version of it that takes a lot of the nuance and mistery from the novels (based on his full of spoiler review..)
What is the point of releasing this review before release date other than to spoil everything?
That is called the 🔊 _"First!" Problem_ 😐.
WTF No Spoiler Warning ⚠️⚠️?
The police character played by Benedict Wong’s name is not Da. In the book, his nickname is Da Shi. In Chinese context, this nickname means his Last name is Shi(史). The “Da” means big. Basically it can be interpreted as big bro Shi.
And he's a fantastic character in Tencent's show. This one seems more "inspired by".
All 8 episodes air date: March 21, 2024
Does IGN know the difference between a summary and a review?
Its a 10 don’t continue without spoilers
The chinese version is amazing 😊
best opening series for this year
You mean it will get worse from here? How much worse can it get? A Netflix remake of the Rocky Horror Picture Show in eight episodes? ;-)
This is less of a 'review' and more of a plot summary with a slurry of SPOILERS. Avoid.
The music really bothered me at the beginning
Of this video? Or the show?
Reading the books feels like the first time you watched a foreign film. It's not paint by numbers like the American story telling we're used to
IGN: take this video down. As noted in the review, this project is meant to introduce the story TO PEOPLE WHO AREN’T FAMILIAR WITH IT.
It’s cool and all that the reviewer is familiar with the entire franchise in its assorted incarnations, but this vid is written for people who know the twists and ruins them for the people this show is made for.
I’m annoyed.
What a Bad Review massive spoilers
This review is awful, filled with spoilers
You know all those times in every other science fiction production that makes you roll eyes... like where the supposed biologist goes to prod the clearly provoked alien, or characters make some other equally idiotic decision that no one with a high school diploma would make? Well this show manages to avoid 95% of those. The decisions actually make sense. The characters ask the right questions. What plot holes you do see, are mostly explained by the fact that the show simply couldn't cover everything. Its a really refreshing experience for anyone with an interest in sci-fi and science.
This review straight up spoils major parts of the story
A quick correction; Keiko was never warm. She's was always kind of a "if looks could kill" ballbuster.
Prepare to be confused and disappointed, book readers?
Book 1 has great scifi topics
Book 2 has strongest narative
Book 3 err didn't finish...too sleepy to understand the book.
@@HobiAIBook 2...the one with the dream woman...has strongest narrative? TF did you read...
the only worthwhile book is 1, you get some Chinese history, some character study of a women doing something terrible out of "reasons" (not spoiling), and even if the science in the book is flat out wrong it can inspire some ppl.
Where are the spoilers?? I’ve finished the show and didn’t see any spoilers.
Don't study these other comments about spoilers, some of us come to youtube to find out if its worth spending the time to watch some of these shows.
They can tell people if the show is worth watching, WITHOUT giving away the entire f*cking plot of the whole season ffs. 🤦🏻♀️🙄 This was effing ridiculous. I've already read all of the books anyway, but for people who know nothing about the story at all... they literally give away everything that happens in the f*cking show! And they released this "review" 12 days before it even dropped for people on Netflix. That's INSANE... and that's why people are pissed. A proper review can discuss & rate stuff like the acting, the cinematography, or source material faithfulness... without giving away key plot points & surprise twists. This was awful.
i'll just stick with the chinese version if whatever this review told are true
Lies. You will watch.
Ign has always been one my primary review channels. But this “review”was more of synopsis, a spoiler fest. Thanks for telling the whole story, disliking the video. 👎🏼
This thing is a 6 if you're being generous. Better over the first 4 episodes but the final 4 episode story quality drops off like a rock.
9 for me
1. Spoiler warning needed. 2. Who cares if some politician liked the story? Review the thing yourself. No one cares that ________ celebrity or politician thought it was "neat".
U mad
2:43 That's a neutrino detector, not a particle accelerator
*!!!GIANT SPOILER WARNING!!!*
Dear lord...IGN has gone completely down the drain the last ten years.
Yal might want to edit this a little. There are definitely spoilers in this video.
Obviously they had to dump down the sorry in the books for US audience.
dumb down MORE than in the books? how?
This isn't a review, it's a story breakdown. Avoid if you haven't watched yet.
still, the Chinese series is way better. or just read the damn books.
It's not a review, it's plot synopsis, duh.
Make sure to thumbs down this video if you don't like IGN spoiling shows without warning
***Review States Major Plot Spoilers.***
I'm always fascinated by how consistently and casually IGN media reviews spoil major plot revelations.
Since when did reviews give most of the plot away? I've read the books. But others won't have. You can do better than this.
Whyd they change the story around?
Well, among the executive producers are *Dumb & Dumber* and *Rian O'Roundhead* (though _his_ involvement is probably minimal compared to D&D, who are the _actual_ writers, directors & showrunners, with Alexander Woo, who was a writer on *_True Blood_* on HBO) .
Because the Chinese rights holders specifically asked for a more western version on Netlfix
watch the chinese version, its much better. it is also free on youtube
Just the first 2 episodes
想看汪淼和章北海的部份
Casually dropped multiple MAJOR SPOILERS for a show that no one has yet.. W T F IGN ! 👎
SPOILERS!!!! WHY INJECT SPOILERS FOR THE WHOLE SERIES IN A REVIEW FOR SEASON 1 THAT ISN’T EVEN OUT YET????? Take this garbage down.
How do you know there are spoilers? Because you already now the plot, why are watching a review of something you already know? Why everybody is so mad at this video if you clearly know all the plot?
Here’s the review
Chinese best selling novel turned in a European who “dumbit” that is solved within 4 episodes - half the episodes are essentially the “beginning” the second book.
The characters are atrocious (not the actors) - all expcept the dying one and Jon are complete “the world is to blame” narcissists.
The plot is truncated to be almost unrecognizable, the CGI is laughable, the “subplots” asinine, the character arcs non-existent (much like the novels)
It’s candy - so enjoy.
A solid 5/10
Terrible review, lack of passion, and can you not at least spend some effort to make sure you pronounce the author’s name correctly?
Watch quinns ideas on 3 body peoblem and his review of the show
It blows my mind that IGN thinks reviews are summering the entire plot of the thing (with no spoiler warning) instead of focusing on the quality of the writing, directing, acting, editing, etc. They have such a shallow level of understanding in how to review or cover entertainment. No wonder they love the MCU. It’s perfect for their type of brains.
So are they gonna rush through the last season and abandon it so they can go work on something else again?
This review is completely backwards. The VR portions of the show were the best parts (hence why 90% of the trailer are scenes from the VR sections). The human drama was boring a sin, and everything was contrived and convenient. The Santi could have easily found any planet in the galaxy that DOESN'T have 3 suns and it would be more habitable than their own.
IGN being IGN, releasing a review full of spoilers because you journalism is non existent
whoever wrote this review needs a counseling. They go through major plot points and spoils them.
My man really out here mispronouncing Da Shi 😭
The score is 11. You’re a welcome.
I thought the writing was extremely juvenile. It should’ve been three epic movies directed by Dennis Villanueve or Christopher Nolan.
GoT alumni in 3BP
1. David Bradley
2. Liam Cunningham
3. Anthony Pryce
4. Conleth Hill
Thanks for the spoilers 🙃
For everithing spoilers, stick whith IGN.
Guys, don't watch a review of a TV show you haven't watched yet, not rocket science
Well, definitely don't waste your time on this show. It's pure garbage.
Space is fake. Also this isn't a review... It's a plot run thru.
This comment section is a W
IGN - shame on you. You have turned garbage over the decades
Job Opening!
EDIT:
Job Openings! FULL BRANCH REHIRE.
hey ign! won't you just tell us what else happens? just point by point. then you don't have to watch the series anymore. thanks.
What is the idea with telling so many plot points , this is no review! Its a almost a spolier talk