How did Palestine get its Name? (Documentary)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 ноя 2023
- Palestine is a region that has been inhabited for thousands of years due to it being a nexus point between multiple major empires. It is a region that was home to different tribes, cultures, and religions in the past, which today is contested over. But what is the true origins of Palestine? Where did it's name come from? And why is it used today?
Развлечения
The Romans called the place Palestine to erase the Jewish connection to the place, and the British continued to call it that, and in the 1960s the Arabs adopted the name while rejecting it all the time in the past
It was called Palestine actually way before Roman’s .. also so called Arabs are related to Bronze Age people .. most of European Jews have no relation
Also the Roman’s calling it that because Jews is also been debunked many times now
The Greeks called the place Palestine, not after the people, but after the region, and the Romans adopted the name to cut off the Jews and their connection to the Kingdom of Judah at that time. The Philistines came from the area of Crete, and were one of the great enemies of the people of Israel. When the Romans arrived in Israel in 63 BC and with the invasion of the army led by Pompey, the Jews rebelled against the Romans (by the way, to this day there are finds of charcoal, arrows and stones that were used for fighting) The great rebellion in the Kingdom of Judah happened in 70 AD, when the Romans captured Jerusalem and murdered many, and they fought the Jews in Jerusalem, in the Galilee and they murdered many there. the Romans took many Jews captive and as slaves and exiled them to Rome. Since then, the Jews fast on Tisha B'Av every year, and mourn. By the way, it is recommended to read the book of the historian Yosef ben Matityahu, a Jew who lived at that time and after the revolt lived in Rome and he wrote about what happened. The Jews from Europe are descendants of Jews who were exiled to Rome and Jews who immigrated to Rome from the first and second centuries AD.
Derived from Philistines who were there before the Jews
The documentary did not tell how long jewish state at that time ruled ? Why? Is it because it ruled 80 years only . Why not mentioned the othmany ommeran,ubasien,egyption,mamluke .....etc whom are arab or muslim ruled over 5 thousand years total ? Why the hide this ? Is it because uf isreli time ruled is 80 years but Othmany ruled 400 years based on time Othmany has more claim ????
Philistines didn't have anything to do with so-called Palestinians. The Philistines were of Greek origin and settled in today's Gaza. Palestine was a name first given by the Roman Imperator Hadrian. He wanted to erase the Jewish people identity with their land. The Canaanites were the descendents of Canaan, son of Ham and grandson of Noah.
100% right, the Romans did try to disassociate the Jews from the province of Judea. The Canaanite’s are a bit more mysterious in my opinion, and quite loosely defined, as they were not just one solid empire but many tribes and groups who had a similar language, grouped together as Canaanites.
So who was in aqsa when The Jews were in Egypt?
@@yusufhissein1292Arabs
@@HistoryLeaksGenetics has proven the Canaanites were one people, not different peoples. They have genetically sequenced many different Canaanite sites throughout Israel/Palestine and Lebanon. The people were one people!!
@@yusufhissein1292 What aqsa???? Aqsa means farthest in Arabic.
Hadrian changed the name of the Roman province of Judea to Syria Palaestina and renamed Jerusalem, the region's capital, Aelia Capitolina.
Yes so "palestine" is the embodiment of foreign occupation
And to make it worse, philistines themselves were foreign european invaders!
A 2021 study by the New York Genome Center found that the predominant component of the DNA of modern Palestinians matches that of Bronze Age Palestinians (Canaanites) from around 2500-1700 BCE.[17]The original jews are the palestinian people, who were ethnically cleansed by invading zionists alien to the land. The third temple, Alaqsa, was built by the people of jerusalem, many jews who converted to islam during its construction upon the liberation of jerusalem from roman rule and the return of palestinian jews to jerusalem in 632-634 ad. The invading zionists, according to Israeli author Shlomo Sand in his book "The invention of the Jewish people are jewish converts alien to palestine. In the 8th century ad the Khazar kingdom in ukraine converted to judaism and would go on to make the ashkenazi jewish population in europe. Yemenis converted to judaism during the yemeni kindom o Himyar in the 5th century ad during the rule of Dul Nawas. There were jewish kingdoms in iraq and north africa as well. The palestinians are the eternal natives of the land. Free Palestine.
It was called palestina before Roman’s
@@goldmo2427 no it wasn't. Philistines were part of egypt and conquered the area of gaza.
The rest was cnaan and then israel for 2000 years
My grandparents who lived there during the British mandate, had Palestinian passports, where it showed they were Jews.
The Palestine post was a Hebrew newspaper. Don't fall for narratives. Just look at facts.
That’s really interesting that you can attest to what Golda Meir was saying, and wow didn’t know that was a Jewish newspaper 🤔
@@HistoryLeaks these things are pretty much on public record, it's too bad more of it isn't being shown, mostly because the narrative is just that arrogant in its closedminded self righteousness
They are Judah the Palestinian
You are so right!!!
Eu tenho os documentos dos meus avós e do meu pai até hoje são dos arredores de Jerusalém o registro do meu pai está escrito em hebraico embaixo um pouco árabe são de origem judaico ele tem o nome hebraico
de Jerusalém
There has never been an Arab Palestinian authority that ruled Palestine.
British took over from Ottamans
Excellent historic
documentary.
Thank you, glad you enjoyed
Did you use FCP? well done.👍🏻 I mean the video production.👍🏻
Thank you 🙏 I appreciate it - and no what’s FCP?
@@HistoryLeaks Final Cut Pro
Abram came from the Summerian city of Ur and migrated to the promised land. Known later as Abraham, he became the father of the Jews and Arabs, through his sons Issac and Ishmael.
Abram wasnt exist
Its mitology not more then this
Arabs and jewish have nothing together
Jewish is Canaanites tribe
While arabs is arabs
Abraham has another 6 children from his Ethiopian wife. Read more.
@@greenpulseeducation5002
If you k ow the history of the fertile crescent you know that abraham story dpnt fit with the culture,time,period,area,
And if you know the ancient Hebrew language you know that this name wasnt exist,
And if you know the story you and you know Canaanites culture so you know that this story fit with nothing in this area,
Because jewish and israelites was Canaanites tribes, like Amonites Moabites,adomites, phinician, and Aramaic
They all Semitic,
Speaking same language,
Abraham its a story of someone who come from Mesopotamia,
While jewish genetic is same as Canaanites,
The story of abraham is not real and today we know who creat this story
Abraham didn't came from any place, there's no such man in History, just in the bias imagination of the Biblical Fairy Tale. The Conqueror always had written the so called History for his own convinience.
In 1406 BC, the Amorite Pentapolis of five cities controlled that area that would become the Philistine Pentapolis, but with different cities.
The Amorites were one of the tribes of Canaan, with a name meaning "Westerner". They were not the Philistines, who were from Crete.
there are hundreds of maps from before 1948 with the region named as Palestine
Yeah absolutely it has been called that since the time of the Romans
@@HistoryLeaks theres archeology from 1150bce in Egypt referring to the land as P'lsht
@@rama_lama_ding_dong yeah that’s right, related to the Phillistines - who were a group of Aegean settlers that came to the region.
@@HistoryLeaks PALESTINE HAS A HISTORY OF 10.000 YEARS! The term "AMURRU" in Babylonian inscriptions refers to the area of "Syria-Palestine" in the time of Hammurabi.
Yeah the Romans renamed Judea to Palestine. Can you link a source where the maps call it a country? Lol
The Philistines are also called “the Caphtorim”, meaning the people from Caphtor (Island of Crete). "And the Avvim, who lived in villages as far as Gaza, the Caphtorim who came from Caphtor, destroyed them and lived in their place.)" (Deuteronomy 2:23)
BS
COMPLETE BS, and utter lies! Keep spreading your hasbara BS, the people of the land know their own history
That’s funny because the Bible says that it was casluhim that the philistines came.
Dan took Crete in bronze age
Apearantly they were related to the kasluhim who were descendants of cham.
So they werent europeans or semites
But weren't cretian europeans?
the Minoans were engaged in maritime trade throughout the Levant in the Middle Bronze period (ca. 2000-1500 BC). Some of this evidence suggests that they established trading colonies in Syria, Canaan and Egypt. A small, but growing, number of finds in Palestine provide tangible evidence for contacts between Canaan and Crete long before the 12th-11th century Philistines.” (The Genesis Philistines, Bryant Wood, May 31, 2006)
And ?The SeaPeople moved around the Mediterranean.
This video just proves that people are fighting since the beginning of time. It will never end. There will never be peace.
When Arabs love their children more than they hate Jews there will be peace. Golda Meir
Peace comes when worshiping the one true G-D and living according to His commandments and ordinances. G-D is One for all. His blessings are meant for all that breathe.
The Philistines still owe a servitude to the Jews from the promise of Golieth to David.
Its really a nice documentary
Herodotus called it Syrian Palestine so yes, it did exist before the Romans
not as a kingdom though but as a geographical place. no Kingdom of Palestine, King etc.
@@anthonypalo8191 irrelevant
Israel” has been the name of an ethnic group in the Levant going back at least 3200 years, based on the first known mention of the name in the written record, which was in ancient Egypt. That is a hieroglyphic inscription on the Merneptah Stele (also known as the "Israel Stele"
The term "Palestine" first appeared in the 5th century BCE when the ancient Greek historian Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" between Phoenicia and Egypt in The Histories.
👉After Herodotus, the term `Palestine' came to be used for the entire region which was formerly known as Canaan. The Canaanites are to be destroyed “that they may not teach you to do according to all their abominable practices that they have done for their gods, and so you sin against the Lord your God” (Deut. 20.18).
Israel as the Promised Land comes from Genesis 17, where God's covenant with Abraham and his offspring is affirmed, and God promises to be the God of Abraham's offspring and gift them the land of Canaan for “a perpetual holding".👈
@@nocomments4777 that is incorrect. Jewish people's OWN texts prove you wrong: The Pelest/Philistines are mentioned in the Bible as a group indigenous to the land of Canaan before the Israelites even existed as a people. They were there even before Abraham was there according to the Bible. They are also mentioned in Bronze Age Egyptian sources. So Philistines or Palestine is older than Israel
@@ayo9715 🤔....I think that's what I said.
"Palestina" is a Greek name. For the Philistines, of course. Hadrian was so mad on the Jews that he wanted to disperse people and their culture. But actually he named the province "Syria", since there was already Syria, he got an old Greek name to designate it. Since the province seems to have been a satellite to the province of Syria, which was very important for the empire. So he named Syria Palestina.
I called it Palestine because the Greeks called the region alrady - Παλαιστίνῃ Συρίᾳ - in the 5th century BC
Wrong and wrong again the philistines settled in the same region, where modern day Gaza is located. And the philistines are not the same people of Palestine today.
@@flexgado249 "modern Gaza"? Gaza, Gat, Aschdod, Aschkelon and Ekron (Pentapolis) were Greek cities. The Palestinians are indigenous Palestinians. However, the majority of Israelis are native Europeans. They are Germans, Austro-Germans and post-Soviet migrants who have nothing to do with any Semitic tripe of the Hebrew Bible. The Blacks and Whites in the USA are not Native either. You can ask all the Sioux people.
What about earlier? Please let me know the migration pattern for the Prodo-Indo Europeans @@Hadrianus_Olympius
@@joesheppard8831 They came from the depths of the oceans millions of years ago and almost became extinct with the dinosaurs.
The last Indo-Europeans perished with Atlantis.
Egyptian records of the Late Bronze Age speak clearly of four localities on Crete or "Keftiu" (Kftyw), which could also be translated "Caphtor" in the Egyptian language (T. Dothan 1982a, 13, 21, and footnotes; Stiebing 1989, 175). There is almost universal agreement that the Egyptian "Kftyw" refers to Crete
which Egyptian records are you talking about?
Hi: I really enjoy your videos. Where can we find more about you? You seem very well educated, what is your background. Can we know your name and what country that you are in too? I appreciate it! Tim in California.
Thank you Tim, I appreciate the kind words and I'm glad you enjoy my videos! I will definitely think about sharing more about myself and my background in the future, keep an eye out!
Just change the flag in the name of the country, and for all countries to agree that the country belongs to three different groups of people, and that will make it fair for everyone
Excellent video! I couldn’t have said any of this better myself
Thank you sir, I'm glad you enjoyed 🙏💯
some of the Philistines had their origins in Caphtor/Crete. However, remember that in our examination of the Egyptian records for the Sea People invaders, during the reigns of Merneptah (ca. 1215 B.C.) and Ramesses III (ca. 1185 B.C.), we noted an Aegean -- and especially a western Anatolian -- origin for the invaders
What we call the "Holy Land" has a very long history. In very remote times it was populated by Philistines and referred to as Philistine. The ancient Hebrews emigrated from Sheba into the land of Egypt near what was then the Philistine border. After a number of years, the Hebrews invaded and began to conquer the land, which retained the ancient name of Philistine. Each Hebrew tribe settled into own area of occupation. Perhaps the largest tribe, Juda settled in the area around Jerusalem. Being at the nexus of the ancient world mint there were frequent wars and the Hebrew kingdoms were occasionally occupied by foreign armies. Nebuchadnezzar, King of Babylon, smashed the Hebrew kingdom in 587 BC and depopulated it, forcing the Hebrews into exile where most disappeared. Some years later, Cyrus the Great of Persia (now Iran) conquered Babylon and allowed what Hebrews that remained, to return to return to Philistine and form a vassal kingdom centered around Jerusalem. Then came Alexander the Great who conquered the Persian empire and Philistine became a Greek vassal kingdom. Then mighty Rome began to conquer the Greeks in the second century BC and by 27 BC, had total control of the Greek empire and appointed Herrod the Great to be king of Judea, in what the Romans referred to as Palestine. Predictably, the Hebrews revolted and, predictably, the Romans quickly smashed the rebellion. In 130 AD, a false "messiah", Simon Bar Kokhba, lead the THIRD revolt against Rome. Hadrian, the no nonsense Roman emperor, ordered his mighty Legions to "Kill them all", as per the Carthage Rule and fulfilling a prophecy of Jesus (Matthew 23:27). After "killing them all", Hadrian opened Palestine for resettlement and Christians, both Greek and ex-Hebrews, which had taken no part in Bar Kokhba's revolt, settled in Palestine. They were quickly joined by Semite descendants of Ishmael, Galileans and Samaritans. There has ALWAYS been a Philistine/Palestine, from the most ancient times. Modern "Jews" are "Jews" by CONVERSION. They are not "Semites" and have NO DNA connection to the ancient Hebrews.
Nice video, the narrator is so slow he makes me feel sleepy 😅 but still enjoyed watching
Maybe the narrator needs some extra coffee next time! Glad you enjoyed it though. Thank you 🙏
Golda Meir and a lot of other Jews called themselves Palestinians in the British Empire’s Mandate of Palestine (1920-1948). Arabs shunned the name, Palestinians. They wanted to be Arabs like their cousins that Arabian people, Egyptians, Syrians, Iraqis. In fact, Pan-Arabic movement was rampant in the ended of 19th Century and 20th Century.
Inaccurate, this documentary is revisioning the history of Palestine.
You can't blame them after 400 years of Turkish domination.
@@ashervinuya2780 no no it isn't sorry abdul
so? All the Northern Arab nations were made with the fall of the ottomans, it could have gone very differently for sure... no excuse for genocide
@@barryirlandi4217 There's NO genocide in Gaza
Excellent video!
Thank you my friend 💯💯❤❤🙏🙏
@@HistoryLeaks Just the facts, one of the best videos I have seen on the subject
Crete was their home sea port base for this sea-oriented people who were likely traders and raiders (pirates).
THAT`S BS
They had Established a fishing community around Gaza. Jews had issues with them over land.
Invading Romans used this fude to Change Judea and Samaria's name to Philistia. Only to take Jews identity from their land.
Because Jews had rebelled Against them. Jews fought two major Battles Against them .
Jews had a thriving civilization and Kingdoms in Judea.
Occupation is other way round.
V
Every war that is fought comes about becos of the greed of land/territory acquisation. This will always change the map of the world.
History will repeat itself & the world map will have new features.
Just take note: The original Arabic Alphabet does NOT have an equivalent letter to Letter P! In The Middle East they use "B" in Bebsi Softdrink, Bediasure Baby Milk, etc.. How can there be Palestine when they dont use Letter P
That is very true, hence why it’s called Falestine in Arabic. I will have to order a Bebsi next time I go out though 😂
You are Very correct about the non existence of the alphabet 'P'.
Samek ayin pey phey
😂😂Yes true 😂😂they should name it balestine😂
@@HistoryLeaks
When you makes history people don't Lough in comments
This is gonna be confusing for the arabs ,the bible doesnt mention palestine but philistines which were greeks, the koran doesnt mention palestine but children of Israel,and the arabic langauge doesnt have a letter P but only have F. Which means there is no arab Palestinians.
It might be confusing for you so hold on, but Palestine is the anglicized version of the name Filisteen, current day Arab name of the region in question. It’s ok, google is free.
and?
The populating in Palestine in 1800 was 250,000 people. Arab, Christian, Jewish, Turk, Circassian and more. At the year 1915 the population raised to 450,000. It too the population 110 years to double itself from 250,000 to 450,000. Then from 1915 to 1945 the population again doubled it self in 30 years. So what do you think. One morning everyone derided to make babies from morning till eve? I got a feeling it wasn't natural growth.
50% of all Arabs in Palestine in 1948 came after 1917. To work under the British mandate.
50% is around 450,000 people maybe a bit more. From the other 50% also not all natives.
Its not surprising that to be considered by the UN to be a Palestinian refugee. You only need to prove you lived in Palestine between 1946 to 1948, You don't need to prove 1 generational connection.
You can be a Syrian who was born in Syria. Who came to British Mandate Palestine in 1925 for work. left after the war of 1948. Came to the US. Got citizenship. Made a family in the US. And all of his children's and grandchildren are Palestinian refuges forever??? F this $h!t.
Enough with the Palestinian lies.
@@shaziaali6020It truly kills me how skulls want to see the name and spelling as Palestine in antiquity. Mere English ignoramus'. Simple lesson...it's Roma, NOT Rome.
The philistines were not Greeks. They were hammitic in origin. Greeks are japhetic people from javal.
@@shaziaali6020 as in Roma, not Rome.
Golda Meir who was an Israeli prime minister identifies herself as a Palistinian. There is a clip of her saying this or is it a fake?
When Abraham arrived in Israel, God made him a promise. He said, “ I will give you this land for your descendants. I will make you a great nation, and I will bless you. I will make your descendants as numerous as the stars in the sky.”
Jews and Arabs are Palestinian.
Don't confuse yourself
Palestinians
@@ianbarr5110 do you understand why she said she was palestian and where she was coming from her speech?
The Philistines were the naval power in these stories.
The Iliad even identifies the Philistine trademark feathered/horsehair-plumed helmets: “On the bright ridges of the helmets, horsehair plumes touched when warriors moved their heads. That's how close they were to one another.” (Iliad 16:213-17)
the Philistines were Greek seafarers lost to history. The "Palestinians" are Arabs.
Origin of the Philistines (Caphtorim): Crete (Caphtor)
Gen 10:14 Island of Crete in Aegean Sea area
If only the British had just called it Israel....
I think what matters most is who was there first
@@treybanks1068 well that question has no meaningful answer in reality and 'who' and 'there' and 'first' have no meaningful definition. Everyone that thinks they were 'first' are already 'there'.
@@treybanks1068Jews-Jewnanistani-SeaPeople are not a pastoral,tribal...alliance called Israelites that where in Egypt 3500+ years ago just a later SeaPeople cult from Mediterranean.
@@brigitpimm8488@treybanks1068 Jews-Jewnanistani-SeaPeople are not a pastoral,tribal...alliance called Israelites that where in Egypt 3500+ years ago just a later SeaPeople cult from Mediterranean.
Why don’t they ask the Palestinians how long they’ve been there?
What do you mean?
And the Avvim, who lived in villages as far as Gaza, the Caphtorim who came from Caphtor, destroyed them and lived in their place." (Deuteronomy 2:23)
I Enjoy your historical videos. Keep up the good work.
Thank you my friend I really appreciate you ❤️❤️🙏🙏💯💯
Arabs motherland is Saudi Arabia. In 700ad they colonized all land right up to south France. Arab Colonization is never talked about. Why
Coz it’s inconvenient to Islam’s narrative.
Palestinians are not ethically or racially Arab, but culturally Arabized. You make no sense. Then white Jews motherland are in Europe. White people from US or Austria, for example, should go back to their motherland in Europe.
Compare classic colonization with Islam. Grow up. Their spread is literally miraculous to say the least. To this day historians scratch their heads on how that’s possible. Everyone joined cuz Muslims stuck to their moral code and people joined them even if they didn’t convert, they saw them as much much better than their European masters and actual colonizers.
Palestinians aren't actually Arab. They just adopted the Arab language. They descend from the ancient Canaanites and biblical Philistines.
@@OmaliMedia-zv1bs biblical philistines?🤣
What's the origin of Bangladeshi people and why they are different from eachother even though they shares the same religion language and traditions
I’m not sure I would have to look into it. It would be an interesting topic though ! 🤔
@@HistoryLeaks you must have to go through the historical conqueror of Indian subcontinent The Britishers point of view on this matter while their time of service for the monarchy in the British Raj of Bengal. This is my advice for you because I'm eagerly awaiting to hear from you about my people on your RUclips video. It would be an excellent analysis of Bangladeshis origin because explaining the history the way you do is amazing.
@@commodusmeridius4718 okay I promise I will look into and have a video on Bangladesh coming very soon 🇧🇩 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🙏🙏🙏 thanks for your comment sir
Palestine the Name come from the Sea Peoples, this was various tribes like Shardana, Sekelesh, Tursa, Peleset etc. The Peleset attack 2 times Egypt one time under the rule of Oharao Merenptah and second time under Ramses lll well like in the papyrus Harrys described Ramses lll give the Peleset after tje battle 1177 B.C. Land in Cananaan and the new owners give the land the name Palestine like the Sea People did everywhere they settled like the Shardana did in Sardinia, the Sekelesh in Sicily or the Tursha in Etruria in Italian Peninsula
Sorry to inform you about where the name Palestine comes from.
Humans first came from Alkebulan ( Africa )
Alkebu - Mother
Lan - Mankind
From there Mankind migrated to the rest of the world.
It was the very beginning when humans stayed on a land and begun agriculture.
Then started to make weapons from sticks and stones for hunting.
Palaios - Era / Period
Stine - Stand
Lithos - Stone
Palestine is the first land in history where humankind stayed instead of being nomadic.
Mankind built the first villages and cities in Palestine.
I think you are rong -The local Jews gave those "Sea peoples" the name "Polshim" Or "Plishtim"in Hebrew it means simply -"Invadors"-The local Arabs have nothing to do with them-They a r e Arabs invadors that grew from some thusends to milions and now claming Judea-End of story
That was 1200 bc,you tell me you think they had no sex outside their tribe? Seriously? You find out with dna.its already been done.
@@talchapoton2402
The Phillistines was named the Phillistines because it was where the first towns were built.
Phillistines means Son of the Stone Age
The peleshet were Greeks. They invaded Israel and established a small five city state. It didnt last very long and it's only really known today because the Jews recorded this people in English the Pilistines as Israel's traditional enemies.
And idol worshipers.. they worshiped Baal and other deities. God gave the Israelites the land. After the Israelites disobedience they were casted to the four corners of the earth. But, given a date of yrs to return. That land is Jesus Christ stomping ground and the jews are his chosen ppl. He will fight for them.. sit bk and watch..
why? when jews dont even recognize Jesus as the messiah
Where in the Bible does it say God gave them the land? Where are the co- ordinates of it? According to the Ultra Orthodox Jews they cannot return until the messiah returns. Guess what, that hasn’t happened. If they actually followed the Bible they wouldn’t be murdering Palestinians and stealing their land. Also get those Jewish people to take DNA tests you will see they are Askenazi Jewish. Which means they’re European see how far that goes. Now try with Palestinians.
God did not give them any Moses lead them to that land you are saying when they reached their they disobeid and said they can't enter the land that contains other people there is nothing like a promised land
They are no longer God's chosen as the covenant ended. God's chosen are not based on a DNA.
Have you read the new testament.
One should be careful not to misquote issues just to satisfy one's ego
So very true.
1:50 so my prior knowledge is that the kanaan society developed since 10.000 BC. Okay now ill critically watch your video
I hated the background music of this marvelous historical information.
Thanks for the feedback I’ll try to reduce it next time around 🙏💯
The British Empire's decline was marked by a series of defeats against less technologically advanced but highly motivated local armed forces. The failure stemmed from a disconnect between imperial aspirations and the realities of managing diverse territories. The struggle for independence, fueled by a desire for self-determination, became a formidable force that overshadowed military disparities. The lesson lies in recognizing the aspirations of local populations and adapting strategies accordingly, emphasizing diplomacy alongside military might to navigate complex geopolitical landscapes.
🎉❤🎉 In both the Vietnam War and the Afghanistan War, the strategic miscalculations were evident. The failure to understand the cultural and historical dynamics, coupled with an underestimation of local resilience, played a pivotal role. Nationalists, driven by a deep-seated determination to defend their homeland, perceived sacrifice as a triumph against foreign forces. Victory in unconventional conflicts demands a nuanced approach, acknowledging the significance of ideological motivations and the resilience of local populations.🎉
15:30 the romans did not invade the holy land they invaded a country and nation called Judea
You're actually right, the idea of the holy land probably came much later. I just used it as a different sounding name, but it was officially the kingdom of Judea.
The arabs invaded Jerusalem in 636 AD.
@@HistoryLeaks You can always take it back to PANGEA. Game over.
Thanks for the correction @@averageGoat_meh_eh_eh_eh
PALESTINE HAS A HISTORY OF 10.000 YEARS! The term "AMURRU" in Babylonian inscriptions refers to the area of "Syria-Palestine" in the time of Hammurabi.
The word Palestinian was invented by PLO in 1968 when the PLO amended its charter to rename "Arabs of Palestine" to "Palestinians". The Arabs used to call themselves Southern Syrians. Most Arabs immigrated to the then occupied Israel seeking jobs created by the returning Jews.
Golda Meir said she was a Palestinian.
This is good information about Palestine and Israel the Jews and these people's lives together for thousands of years .
Thank you for the references and detailed information of 4,000 year history. How can we learn about the 9,000 years before this?
I am sure there is evidence going back even further but that would be a whole another story my friend
@@HistoryLeaks Much appreciated. I look forward to it and many more of your documentaries.
I'm alway keen to learn and adapt and question.
See you say that 9000 was entirely different but that seems to be the point.
I’m looking at a book that shows Palestine at 9000BC
If you are so sure that "Palestine, the country, goes back through most of recorded history," I expect you to be able to answer a few basic questions about that country of Palestine:
1. When was it founded and by whom?
2. What were its borders?
3. What was its capital?
4. What were its major cities?
5. What constituted the basis of its economy?
6. What was its form of government?
7. Can you name at least one Palestinian leader before Arafat?
8. Was Palestine ever recognized by a country whose existence, at that time or now, leaves no room for interpretation?
9. What was the language of the country of Palestine?
10. What was the prevalent religion of the country of Palestine?
11. What was the name of its currency?
Choose any date in history and tell what was the approximate exchange rate of the Palestinian monetary unit against the US dollar, German mark, GB pound, Japanese yen, or Chinese yuan on that date.
12. And, finally, since there is no such country today, what caused its demise and when did it occur?
You are lamenting the "low sinking" of a "once proud" nation. Please tell me, when exactly was that "nation" proud and what was it so proud of?
Why do you use the word "probably" when it comes to Palestine??
ruclips.net/video/QUCeQt8zg5o/видео.htmlsi=UH6RPML-1-pqe6kb
The Palestinians lived as a vibrant sub-nation of Arabs until the forced UN Partition of Palestine 1948, without consulting the Palestinian political representatives.
Their fate changed with the defeat of the Ottoman Empire in World War I, and the winner Allied Power of UK and France had already planned in 1913 to divide the Arab lands under the Ottoman Empire (a year before the World War I was started in 1914).
Another independent documentary is posted after this one, so you can have the picture of history as unbiased as possible.
there is no palestine nation pelistine refers to people or tribe that live in canaan .syria palestine came from romans emperor hydrain .in arabic there is no letter P so they not recognize it or read it
The descendant of Ishmael israelite exit of ancient egypt. From now on the modern day Palestine
can you name a Palestinian king or currency?
Who built and lived in Jericho
From ChatGPT:
Human and chimpanzee DNA are remarkably similar. It's estimated that human DNA and chimpanzee DNA share about 98-99% similarity, meaning that the genetic makeup of humans and chimpanzees is very close. Despite this high similarity, the differences in DNA are significant enough to result in the distinct physical and behavioral differences between humans and chimpanzees. This close genetic relationship underscores the evolutionary relatedness between humans and chimpanzees, as both species share a common ancestor that lived millions of years ago.
..... so does that mean that the ancient Canaanites were aliens? 90% similar to Modern Lebanese seems mighty distantly related.
Abraham was a iraq and Sarah and moved from iraq to Canaanite
It was put to a vote on November 29th 1947.
All supporting Arab countries at the time voted at the UN against partition of the contested region between the Arabs and Jews.
The final vote tally was 33 to 13 in favour of partition. The Jews accepted the outcome and declared independence on May 14, 1948.
The Arabs rejected the outcome and declared war the day after independence declaration by the Jews.
If anyone is yet confused or appalled or fighting over Palestine in support of the Arabs, you only have to reason that it's both morally and logically unfair by now to accuse the Jews of stealing any land after all the unprovoked wars.
Jews at that time is only a third of the population yet get 60% of the land and most of the infrastructure. So yeah, i wonder why the Arab population didn't agree
How Palestine passport? Who is the first Palestinian president/prime minister/government????
The passports were created by Britain.
@@anthonymorris5084 exactly there was no independent Palestine because it was never a country
@@thealbertvoices Correct. Not ever. Cheers.
@@thealbertvoicesbecause their rights were denied
@@warh1story563 because they have refused the offered statehood 5 times.
Question Which of the ff invading Empires did the Arab Palestinians fight?
1.Assyrians
2.Chaldeans/Babylonians
3.Medes/Persians
4.Greeks/Seleucids
5.Romans.
6. None of the Above.
I’m gonna take a wild guess here, 6.? 🤔
@HistoryLeaks Precisely. Now I ask you. Where were they during all these invasions. Surely thered be some record of Cananite descendants fighting these invading armies? My conclusion is either there's bn a big cover up or They Didn't exist. Palestinian Arabs didn't set foot in *Judea* until the 7th Century and the Claims They Make to that heritage, and by extension the idea that Their Prophet travelled to Jerusalem on a winged Chimera and then ascended into heaven from the Temple mount (the only reason they starved Latin Christian Jerusalem into submission in the first place) is all contrived nonsense.
All of them. Their ancestors were proven to go all the way back to the natufians. The Arab identity is what came later and has nothing to do with whether or not they are indigenous
@@HistoryLeaksyou seemed pretty non biased in your video but in the comments you go out of your way to deny Palestinian nativity despite historical evidence? Disappointing
@@toasted_donut2308 I actually agree with what you said about Natufians etc. in that way I can see your point. But it is a loaded question mentioning Arab Palestinians deliberately, and given those answers above, Arab Palestinians were not a group yet, during Roman times, or Seleucid, Babylonian, Assyrian, etc it is a fact and I’m not denying anyone’s existence, it’s civilisations from completely different eras.
Roman Emporor Hadrian renamed Israel Palestine after Philistines from Greece after Bar Kochba rebellion against Rome by Jews was lost in 135CE.
Quran says Israel 🇮🇱 43 times no Palestine in Quran.
No Palestine in Hebrew scripture or Christian bibles.
Quote it please if you are not lier
@@asiyaasaeed8437 Quran Sura 5:20-21 Allah gave LAND of Israel to Musa Moses and his people Yehudi Jews.
Quran Sura 2.40,2.47,2.83,2 .122,3.49,5.78..
You can Google " Quran says Israel" .
No Palestine in Quran.
Long story short: Modern israelis are not the Israelites that received the scripture of Moses, Not the the ones mentioned in the bible, not the one mentioned in the Quran
It’s just a name
The land was never empty
And no country in the Middle East and North Africa are Arab
They adopted the religion and the language
The people are the same
All countries in the Middle East are Arab (except Israel). And there is no connection between them, at no point in their history did they claim to be the Philistines (who are also considered extinct), moreover, the reason they called themselves Arabs is because they came from the Arabian Peninsula, and DNA tests of the Philistine remains revealed that they were from Europe, and not from the Middle East. And even if they do, they are no longer the same nationality because there is no custom and even the name did not survive so the connection no longer exists.
@@eldadmarbach2288 the only reason you think they extinct is because David lied about it it’s not true because ofter the Jews were kicked out of the land the remaining people joined the Persian Empire
And in Alexander river you can find a philistinines village that is 1800 years old
Plus the name is not relevant because the land was still full of Canaanite and Bedouins
@@adamm2909 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philistines
"In 604 BC, the Philistine polity, after having already been subjugated for centuries by the Neo-Assyrian Empire (911-605 BC), was finally destroyed by King Nebuchadnezzar II of the Neo-Babylonian Empire.[2] Subsequently, the Philistines were compelled into exile in Babylonia, where over time, they lost their unique ethnic identity. By the late fifth century BC, they vanished from both historical and archaeological records as a distinct group.[3][4]"
Just because David didn't eradicate them doesn't mean they haven't been extinct.
Where did you get the idea that we would find a 1800-year-old settlement of theirs? This is nonsense.
In addition, the tradition and name of the group are important, because that is what means that they are really related to them, the second possibility is DNA that has already been tested, and found to be a mixture of different nationalities.
(Among the Jews there are also differences, but there is our tradition and our name and language that prove that there is a connection, and DNA does not have such a big change either.)
In addition, it is recommended to be careful with what you find on the Internet in terms of reliability on all kinds of strange websites (and yes, I know I brought up Wikipedia) because even if the person claims to be a professor, it does not mean that what he says is the truth.
For example, brewminate.com/philistia-a-history-of-palestine-since-the-stone-age/
this website belongs to a person who claims to be a professor of history and explains about the "history" of the Palestinians since the Stone Age, but there is a mistake there that shows that it is nonsense, he claims that the remains of a "Palestinian person" were found in the oldest city in the world located in the Isreal,
which dates to the year 600,000 BC, the most ancient Homo Spines skeleton known is 300,000 BC, in addition the city dates to the region of 10,000 BC
So this shows that it is nonsense, plus the Philistines are from Europe at all and not from the Middle East.
Exactly !!!!
The land where Jesus was born
Yeah originally it was the kingdom of Judah before it was renamed “Palestine” by the Romans
Thank you for video, that’s the way I know it.
I appreciate your comment 🙏 I’m glad it resonated with you. I will say this is a very complex history, with many moving parts it’s often difficult to articulate and fully understand. There are aspects which I couldn’t cover due to the complexity of this topic, but I did my best to summarise what I found in historical evidence and from recent studies. I’m glad you enjoyed and I hope you have an amazing weekend my friend 🤙🏼
@@HistoryLeaks thank you very much appreciated, fully understand how difficult it can be sometimes. ❤️
Abram went on through the land as far as the site of Shechem near the big trees of Moreb and at that time the Canaanite was in the land. Jehovah now appeared to Abram and said to your seed I am going to give this land. After that, he built an altar to Jehovah who appeared to him. Genesis 12:6,7 then READ Genesis 31:17.18
The criminals in Israel today have nothing to do with that land.
Ibraham was the father of both the Jews and the Arabs.
@@yusufhissein1292abraham was a hebrew
@@dayasubramaniam2929 Abraham was born in Ur Iraq and then went to Canaan. The name Isreal comes after Abraham from his grandson Jacob his other name is Isreal, and one of Isreal son is Yahudah hence the term Yahudi, latinised Judah to Jew. So Abraham was not a Jew or a Christian but a strict monotheists.
@@joyridesham yes but he worshipped YHWH not allah. allah is pagan moon god
Goliath was Hamitic. How did arabs (Ishmael), a semitic people become Hamitic?
The origin of the philistines is the island of Crete and the Aegean sea area bounded by Athens, Corinth and Ephesus.
Indeed, Philistine existed. But Palestine is from the time when Samaria was changed to Syrian Palestine until Angelo Saxons changed the name to British Palestine, very recently. However, this is the Land of Israel.
This place called Palestine can be a tinder box for the world, because the history is not understood correctly!
PALESTINE HAS A HISTORY OF 10.000 YEARS! The term "AMURRU" in Babylonian inscriptions refers to the area of "Syria-Palestine" in the time of Hammurabi.
Rome used the Latinized translation of Philistia which is Palestine - the land of the Philistines....
They are the citizens of Syria, Persia and Babylon, all citizens of so called Westbank
Canaanites are descendants of Canaan.
Palestinians are Arabs from different Arab nations settled in the place.
Israelites are descendants of Jacob, who's name changed to Israel, God promised the land to the Israelites and ordered to conquer the Canaanites.
False prophets, preaching evil. Racial superiority, moral degradation
My DNA test says am 89% Canaanite and 5% arab , stop this shit
The modern world, isn't buying into it. Just because people CLAIM to be chosen, and say their God gave them the land, it wouldn't hold up in court. Religion doesn't give anyone the right to be a douchebag. You all blasphemy the Quran and expect everyone, whether religious or not, to abide by the primitive and repugnant theosophy of the Zionist. God promised me a billion dollars, 5 million acres in Siberia and 90 supermodels as wives and concubines. You going to help God fulfill the promise? If not, you will be cursed. Reject
what about Ishmael....son of Abraham
The people in Israel now who emigrated to Palestine/Israel in the 1940's from Eastern European countries are not descendants of the ANCIENT ISRAELITES.
They just emigrated there and laid claim to the land.
We don't actually know who those people are.
Some call them Khazars and people who converted to Judaism.
No one today can prove that they are a descendant of the Ancient Israelites neither in the 1940's.
Now what qualified them to be Israelites coming from Europe and not anyone else from Africa or Asia or Middle Eastern countries?
I believe Theodur Herzl said let's go to Palestine/Israel and Europeanize it.
He wanted to take a white culture to a Indigenous semitic culture.
Netanyahu's family are descendants of Poland so how does he trace himself to be of the Ancient Israelites?
Israel was whitewashed when those European Jews emigrated to Israel.
The ANCIENT ISRAELITES were not white people. They had olive to dark skin.
The European Jews brought their culture to Israel like their clothing, Top Hats and Black Ling overcoats and other things. The Israelites wore Middle Eastern garments.
The people who emigrated from Eastern European countries just said they were Jews, Zionist Jews, who moved to the Holy Land in the Zionist nationalist political movement ideology. They wanted a homeland because of antisemitism. Most of them were secular and not spiritual.
Zionism is a man-made nationalist political ideology and not from God. It was not a return from God. They thought about moving to Argentina and Uganda in Africa. Just go to another country or land and take up residency irregardless of the people already living there.
This goes to saying that had they not gone to Palestine/Israel they would have made somewhere else their HOMELAND.
They emigrated to Israel and some bought land and the rest took it aggressively and gained more land by winning a war with the Palestinians.
The British, and others gave the Jews military training and weapons so they had the upper hand in fighting the Palestinians and winning the wars between each other.
The Palestinians were tricked regarding the Balfour Declaration and the Palestinians didn't have a good chance to defend their land because the Jews had help.
ROMANS NAMES IT PHILLISTINE ???? ANCIENT KING SOLOMONS TEMPLE BELOW NEW AL AQSA ???????
They named it this way after having colonized it.
It wasn't PALESTINE but(The land of Shaam) which includes(Lebanon Syria Jordan Palestine, Iraq)
Three Pentapolis empires in Canaan in 1406 BC at the time of the conquest of Joshua:
a. Philistine Pentapolis in coastal plain: Gaza, Ashdod, the Ashkelon, Gath, Ekron: Ex 13:17-18; Deut 2:23; Josh 11:22; 13:2-3; Judges 1:18-19; 3:1-3
your tellling the truth but in my country a big country in asean a lot of people did't know and don't wanna to know for this history
There is no Palestinians. Only refugees
THERE WERE PHILIZTINE
Want to know what the roman term for Palestine means? Dig deep , you will be surprised it was a derogatory term for the Hebrews.
Can you say that there are no descendants of Ancient Egypt, hence no Ancient Philistines, no Ancient Canaanites, because they now look like Arabs?
Then how come that the present Jews are the descendants of the Ancient Jews - whereas that they don't look anything like them, infact they are more of Europeans than the original people from the region!!!
So who amongst the Jews and Palestinians still share the cultures of the Ancient People???
What I am saying is that THE PALESTINIANS LOOK AND BEHAVE MORE LIKE THE ORIGINAL PEOPLE, THAN THE EUROPEANS POSING AS JEWS!.
As of 2005, 61% of Israeli Jews were of full or partial Mizrahi ancestry. Mizrahi are jews who remained in israel, or lived in other parts of the middle east e.g north Africa, Iran etc. So the majority of jews in Israel are actually from the middle east. So it is a misconception when people say all Israeli's are European.
there are plenty Sephardic and Mizrahi Jews. Almost 1 million of them expelled after 1948 from Muslim countries.
👏 say it louder for the deaf, dumb, and blind 🤷♂️
It wasn't Hadrian it was vespian who sent his son titius who was sent to collect tax for the collisium ...the arch showing the plunder of the temple is titius s arch
Caananites explains why I hear the Israelites and Palestinians are cousins. They share a similar history and have only recently been the target of nationalistic fanaticism that harms innocence to be known. I agree you cannot clump all ethic identities as either good or bad because of their activities but you can say -- "The best requires responsibility and not a dependence on others to subsist." They are not alone in this.
Philistines are not the same as Palestinian, it is not a linear descent. Palestinian=Jordanian=Ismail, brother of Isaac. Islam is the latecomer!
No matter how many tacos I eat, or gallons of horchata I drink- it doesn’t increase my heritage make me indigenous to Mexico- much like the “diaspora “Jews”, many of whom are non religious, yet lay claim to a religious aspect
...and many of whom have zero Semitic blood/claim to the land whatsoever
@@kalimjabari3397 Islam lays claim to Jerusalem though Ishmael's children did not build it, and no longer worship the God of Abraham. Jerusalem built by Judea. Yahweh gave the city, and the land to the 12. If you want to fight with God, he will defend his people. Good luck with that. As you state, even non practicing Jews know better. Yahweh gave the Riches of Arabia to Ismail, and still they covet what belongs to others. The "Palestinians" are fools to thing God will not keep his promises.
Basically the lands have been conqured many times over by leaders of multiple religions for the last 3000 years? But 1 religion beleives they have all the rights to the lands? A religion that came 600 years after Jesus because they knew more about Jesus than the men who walked and talked with Jesus? How about all 3 big religions just allow every man have tje freedoms to worship who they choose? Alot of questions sorry
Abt Philistines they didn’t disappear bec of Babylonians but they survived till the Greek period as Philisto-Arabs and they minted their coins as such. Arabs after the Mineans.
Philistines has been their in the times of Canaanite?
Way any country don't want Palestinians refuge because i know their real history
and history means roots
Israeli is an ethnic cleansing state it has made many Palestinian refugees who are now in Jordan Lebanon etc.
Since 1964? What utter nonsense is this? Even Shakespeare referred to them in Othello 400 years ago. But it didn’t matter what they called themselves. There were people on that land, it wasn’t empty.
I agree, the land has never been empty and has been inhabited for thousands of years. That is interesting about Shakespeare mentioning it, I never knew that 🤔 What I am referring to there is the national identity as we know it today. Palestine officially declared independence in 1988. They began referring to themselves as Palestinian rather than Arab in the 60's that is what I was talking about. It was a shift in the national identity. Before that Palestine was the region, where jews and arabs both lived, both could be Palestinian, as Golda Meir explained in the clip. It doesn't mean they never existed, of course they did, it was just a shift in their national identity.
@@HistoryLeaksIs that why many scholars have agreed, that the name Palestine was given by the Roman Emperor Hadrian, during Jesus’s time. Even the meaning of Palestine in Hebrew means “land of the Phillistines”. You’re either spreading lies on purpose, because you have an agenda, or you’re getting mixed up with Israhell, which was given birth to, in 1948, by the British, due to the rise of the Zionist movement.
This is true. And “Palestine” was the regional ((exonym)) of the area. Not the endonym. Shakespeare was English, who would have learned this exonym as an Englishmen from British’s conqueror Rome, who referred to the area “Syria Palaestina” at some point, who loved Greek everything. And the Greek sea peoples had territory on the coast called Philistia. Within this area was the Roman province called Judea, which was the territory of the Judahites, amongst many other ethnic groups/states/kingdoms. The Egyptians didn’t call themselves Egyptians and the people in India don’t call themselves Indian. These are exonyms used by outside peoples. “Germany” = exonym. Real name “Deutschland” = endonym. We tend to refer to places by the conquerer/colonial power. The endonym of that area was never Palestine. We pretty much piggy back our names for places off the exonyms used by Rome and Greece. There is an interesting connection though, between the word Israel and Palestine as well. Israel meaning wrestles with God and Palaistís meaning wrestler in Greek.
Elijah also referred may be 3000 years ago about Israel... Saul their First King and King David their Second King... The same David the Prophet was the King of Israel... Then why would your brain trick you into believing otherwise 🤔 May be Long Hair and Long Nail guy told you that they are enemies 🤔 but if all of them are enemies and they think you are enemies 🤔 may be someone is making both of you fight 🤔 who could be that... May the one who said you are Slaves of Allah not Children of God.... Hope your father does not treat you as slaves... Because God the Father Abba Father is Father of Creation and Treats all Humans As His Children whosoever Believeth in Him...
But there was a Fallen One who wanted to enslave people. Hence, He taught you slaves of Allah and to west. He taught Alien 👽 FOR the King of East Dragon 🐉 FOR Lucifer is a Shape Shifter Dragon a Fallen Angel or aka Alien who will enslave the planet for 7 years the same years that AlMahdi and Dajjals reincarnated version will do...
He just deceived humanity to kill each other... do you think killing will stop ✋️ by killing others he injected the pison to kill each other. The division is not only in yours but worldwide...
At the time you should look after each other you go out to kill disregards to what will be the repercussions of all that .... only because someone wrote killing is good and it is the reason you are alive...
My friend, a dead father to your son and dead son to your father, is of no good... if you take life, how could someone else remain silent as they could be some ones Father and someone's sons??
Think about it weapons do not give peace bit pain, and suffering ... with a never-ending cycle of deaths... You killed some of them they came and killed more of you... who won??? FALLEN ONES ... TRY TO SEEK GOD HE WILL INFORM ABOUT THE SOULS HE SECRETLY COLLECTS TO HELL...
WHEN KILLING IS WRONG FOR YOU IT SHOULD BE WRONG FOR ALL.. BUT FALLEN ONE MADE IT NORMALIZED..
IN HEAVEN HE GRIEVED GOD BY WAGING WAR AND WAS CAST DOWN... HERE AS WELL SHE DID THE SAME THING AND YOU ARE PUPPETS OR SLAVE OF ALLAH WHO WANTS YOU TO KILL OTHERS BUT OTHERS SHOULD NOT KILL YOU...
WAKE UP YOU ARE DECEIVED IN TO KILLING YOUR SELF.. AT LEAST FORGIVE FOR THE SAKE OF YOUR OWN FAMILIES..
What does it matter what outsiders called Israel? The Jews have been calling themselves "Israel" for 3700 years. For instances the Americans call my people Hispanics but that's a word I never heard until I came to Canada. We don't call ourselves by that name.
Palestenians were originally pagan Hindus / Aryans. They seem to be the descendants of Great Vedic sage 'Rishi Pulastya', the grand father of Ravana.
Yàsarel should occupy promise land its the land of shem
We can clearly trace the movement of the Jews dating back to 12 century and follow them throughout history, unfortunately even if the name Palistine was used to describe the area there is still no record of any people called palistinian, no record of commerce, no ancient text or pottery, Jews, Romans, Greeks all up and down history but never a palistinian.
The surrounding Arab nations formed some council and they are the ones who voted no to the deal. They saw it as a great way to strengthen the Arab/ Muslim presence in the area so call all the people who came to work around the turn of the century. The term PAlistinian first used in the early 60's.
No "p" in Arbic..pa-lies-tine ...
They are Arabs who arrived during the conquest of Salah Eddin and the Abyssinian dynasty.. They are not related to Shertel or the Jews
lmao, Palestine is the latin name. It's true name is Filistine.
Philstine is the name, not Palestine, English didn't exist back then, Also, the dud literally said that most Palestinians, Jordanians, iraqis, lebanese and Syrians are 90% Canaanites in DNA, and probably didnt mention that only 30-45% of modern israelis are of Canaanite/Arab origins, meaning that israelis are mostly europeans and have nothing to do with canaan or judea.
@@abdullahhodhod3779
Arab friend... decide... are the Palestinians Canaanites? "Philistines" from Greece? Or Arabs from the Arabian Peninsula?
You can't be all three.
In any case, we the Jews, the nation of Israel.. know who we are and where we are from.. it is written in the Bible, the New Testament and the Koran
@@medalaeeladlani5683
Arab friend... decide... are the Palestinians Canaanites? "Philistines" from Greece? Or Arabs from the Arabian Peninsula? You can't be all three. In any case, we the Jews, the nation of Israel.. know who we are and where we are from.. it is written in the Bible, the New Testament and the Koran
Share the whole video of Golda...
The list of travellers and pilgrims throughout the XVI to the XIX centuries c.e. that give a similar description of the Holy Land is quite longer, including Alphonse de Lamartine, Sir George Gawler, Sir George Adam Smith, Siebald Rieter, priest Michael Nuad, Martin Kabatnik, Arnold Van Harff, Johann Tucker, Felix Fabri, Edward Robinson and others. All of them found the land almost empty, except for Jewish communities in Jerusalem, Shechem, Hevron, Haifa, Safed, Irsuf, Cæsarea, Gaza, Ramleh, Acre, Sidon, Tzur, El Arish, and some towns in Galilee: Ein Zeitim, Pekiin, Biria, Kfar Alma, Kfar Hanania, Kfar Kana and Kfar Yassif. Even Napoleon I Bonaparte, having seen the need that the Holy Land would be populated, had in mind to enable a mass return of Jews from Europe to settle in the country that he recognized as theirs' - evidently, he did not see any "Palestinian" claiming historical rights over the Holy Land, whose few inhabitants were mainly Jews.
Just curious. If they were Jewish people living in Palestine, why would the Israeli Jews fight the Palestine Jews ?
Incomplete to the point of plain false. The name Palestine comes from Philistines, which comes from the Hebrew word פולשים (pronounced polshim) which means invaders, pillagers. The Jews called these (Greek) invaders פלשתים pronounced plishtim . Incidentally from Philistines comes the English derogatory adjective philistine, with similar pronunciation and meaning in French, Italian, Romanian, Portuguese.
Shouldn’t those who call themselves Palestinians, who have nothing to do with Palestine, find a better name than a insulting Hebrew word and a derogatory adjective in many languages?
Interesting how do you know that, are you a Hebrew speaker?
If you are Hebrew speaker, then you know Israel government teaching you the wrong propaganda history. The Jewish history teacher just got arrested for telling the truth of actual Palestinian history. Israel government jailed him for telling the truth. He still going through court cases. They detained him but no charges.
Shouldn't those who call themselves the "original Palestinians" but have nothing do with Palestine have themselves a different HOME. Preferably one they didn't steel.
The Pelishtim were Greeks. They invaded Israel and established a small five city state. It didnt last very long and it's only really known today because the Jews recorded this people in English the Pilistines as Israel's traditional enemies.
Judaea was named Syria Palaestina (Palestine) which was based from the area Philistia and Ohilistines were known to be Greeks. Palestinian-Arabs of today came from the Ottoman occupation and were branded Palestinians because of the name of the region, not the people. Reason why the Jews who were born in Israel before 1948 like the Jew Gokda Meir were also Palestinians. Therefore technically, there is no such thing as Palestine.
Lmao did you make this up with your own little brain? Have you ever seen an ancestry test of a Palestinian? They have genetic origins to the ancient remains found ( the canaanites). Arab jews also are related however christian palestinians are the closest to the canaanites. This is proven by science. Ashkenazi jews are less related to Palestine than even muslim "arabs". If you are going to talk do your research so you dont look stupid.
Totally correct.Besides them, many Arab sources confirm the fact that the Holy Land was still Jewish by population and culture in spite of the Diaspora:
·In 985 c.e. the Arab writer Muqaddasi complained that in Jerusalem the large majority of the population were Jewish, and said that "the mosque is empty of worshippers..." .
·Ibn Khaldun, one of the most creditable Arab historians, in 1377 c.e. wrote:
"Jewish sovereignty in the Land of Israel extended over 1400 years... It was the Jews who implanted the culture and customs of the permanent settlement".
After 300 years of Arab rule in the Holy Land, Ibn Khaldun attested that Jewish culture and traditions were still dominant. By that time there was still no evidence of "Palestinian" roots or culture .
·The historian James Parker wrote: "During the first century after the Arab conquest [670-740 c.e.], the caliph and governors of Syria and the [Holy] Land ruled entirely over Christian and Jewish subjects. Apart from the Bedouin in the earliest days, the only Arabs west of the Jordan were the garrisons".
Even though the Arabs ruled the Land from 640 c.e. to 1099 c.e., they never became the majority of the population. Most of the inhabitants were Christians (Assyrian and Armenian) and Jews.
That's a myth. Archeologists like Norman Finkelstein have shown that the Bible's history does not match the history of modern Israel/Palestine Syria. So they make up crazy interpretations to force it to fit, including Philistines being Greek. The Bible clearly states the Philistines are cousins of the Israelites and the same people as they intermingled and mixed genetically often. Minor point: The Ekron inscription shows the Philistines were a Semitic speaking people also
so who are the Palestinian people Then?
@@peter-df6wl jews.
sigh
@historyleaks
@3:04 ... Abraham's first offspring (that have been recorded) were Ishmael and Isaac. When Abraham's youngest, and favorite son was put in a pit, is was Ishmaelites who bought him. 'Israelites' as you call them, were Hebrews. Israelis and 'Arabs' are step-brothers.
3:54 Arab influx, or conversion?
Bronze age Levant people used Aramaic (Syrian writing, Aram being Syria), that was far earlier than Hebrew.
4:43 and Christians - to this day. Deir Yassin was just one mostly Christian town that was evacuated of it's citizens in 1948, they were told it was only for a short time. After the expulsion, the survivors of the winter started to return t the village to care for what animals remained, and to plant their crops. Soon more and more residents began coming back to their homes. That's when the Deir Massacre happened. Then the town was obliterated, then pennies from the US helped pay for 'trees to be planted', all to obscure the foundations and rock wall property outlines from prying eyes, especially from the sky. Then the hill town was turned into a national park, then a settlement began, now it's a densely populated city (large town). None of the telltale signs that there was once a thriving town are evident.
That is just one story. Stop ignoring the fact that many Christians never left the area, that Lebanon was almost exclusively Christian.
5:20 the name Filistin, Falastin or Palestine is old, but Gaza alone is ancient. :)
Thank you.
phlistines ,were beside the sea,but these were already vanished. 'Syria Palaestina' was named by Romans in first century to shamed the Jews which they vanished by gen Titus in 70CE and emperor Hadrian in 106CE, Ottomans coined the place as Palistines,and British in WW1.thats all
No need to go in such depths or details...simple question....under what law one can reclaim a land after 2000+ years? If thats the case then no one in this world has the right to live where he/she is living...bcz USA belonhs to the native americans (red Indians) who were massacred n butchered by the colonizers..tomorrow the decendants of tge vikings would emerge n would start fighting to reclaim their ancestral lands...would the civilized world allow that to happen?
There is a constant presence of Jews in the land. Anthropologists find Jewish DNA consistently in the land. Palestinians people came from Crete and sea bordering land ro the north. They didn't form a nation, nor had a leader. There was a sprinkling of families. There is no history of a state of Palestine.
OK. If that's what you want. So the Jews conquered and now it's theirs. Is that better for you?
😂liar