1:48- you can definitely hear the scriabin sonata no 4 come through in that inner voicing; written 23 years before the andantino You can also hear it come through in lyrica nova- interesting to see the inspiration the piece had on him
11:47 the last piece. I almost thought Mahler's Titan was about to make his grand entry (symphony 1, mvt 4, around 18 mins depends on the conductor) but it was Rachmaninoff who came out indeed. It was very fun to listen to this and to read the comments here. Thanks for posting.
There is a beautiful waltz in the fantasy pieces Op. 61 set, its called Sie tanzt, maybe you will like beacuse you used a lot of F#sharp major pieces quite a bit in the video hehe. Also, no 3rd concerto moments? The theme in the Andandrte (part 8) is just too good and addictive
1. For Pf con no.1, best part is from start until 6.04 min 2. 2nd mov of Pf sonata no.1 very very expensive 3. 1st & 2nd symphonies are very good, almost perfect. 4. Lyrical intermezzo for vln and orchestra 100% better than debussy prelude to the afternoon of a faun
@@karrotkake Yes. Quoting so many great composers is the beginning of being original ? I don’t know… A few pieces are very good too great, but a lot of his works are too derivative.
@@mathieuberquet3988 His works are at the level of the composers he's inspired by. Yes, Scriabin is to be more respected for his ingenuity, but you wouldn't complain if you took an uber instead of a taxi. It's a derivative, but one that gets the job done imo. I still prefer Scriabin and Chopin btw
Nice list, but I would like to suggest other performances for 33 / 7 and Piano Concerto No. 1 - Kyoungsun Park and Chihiro Ishioka respectively - which are on my channel. Especially for PC 1 it is much better than the most viewed version on RUclips that has a lot of wrong notes so you should definitely check these out. I've also made a lot of videos on Bortkiewicz's Etudes and Preludes.
I just wanna say that there's a much better concerto nr.1 recording. It's title says "analysis" but it's the full concerto with the subtitles bellow analyzing it.
Only agree with the 2nd concerto that can stand before the greatest....But you missed the Caprice op 3 n 1, the Prelude op 6 n 1, the Ballade op 10 n 1, the Etude op 15 n 6 and many more 😐😐
Yes, I'll do Rach soon. Scriabin later, I need to listen to more of his work (never heard his symphonies, and I need to dig even deeper into his etudes, preludes and sonatas)
@@PianoConcerto-wn2udScriabin first symphony is one of the most monumental, universal, etheral pieces ever. It needs a few shots to appreciate all its grandeur!
1:48- you can definitely hear the scriabin sonata no 4 come through in that inner voicing; written 23 years before the andantino
You can also hear it come through in lyrica nova- interesting to see the inspiration the piece had on him
11:47 the last piece. I almost thought Mahler's Titan was about to make his grand entry (symphony 1, mvt 4, around 18 mins depends on the conductor) but it was Rachmaninoff who came out indeed. It was very fun to listen to this and to read the comments here. Thanks for posting.
Thanks for spreading the work of this deeply underrated composer!
underrated composer, underrated vid
Bortkiewicz ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
wow nice to see my performance here! :)
3:17 scriabin sonata no.4 first mvmt
What's your favorite ?
00:00 Piano Concerto No. 2, Op. 28 (1st mvt)
01:33 Prelude Op. 33, No. 7 - Andantino
02:45 Lyrica Nova, Op. 59, No. 3 - Andantino
03:55 Etude Op. 15, No. 9, Allegro di molto
04:29 Waltz No. 3 "La Viennoise", 3 Waltzes, Op. 27
05:28 Nocturne (Diana), Op. 24/1
06:30 Esquisses de Crimée, Op. 8, No. 1
07:30 Consolation, Op. 17, No. 2
09:13 Piano Sonata No. 2 in C-sharp minor, Op. 60 (1st exerpt)
10:59 Piano Sonata No. 2 in C-sharp minor, Op. 60 (2nd exerpt)
11:47 Piano Concerto No.1, Op. 16 (1st mvt)
Etude op 15 no 8 is one of my favourites
concerto 3 first movemetn second theme, last movement
There is a beautiful waltz in the fantasy pieces Op. 61 set, its called Sie tanzt, maybe you will like beacuse you used a lot of F#sharp major pieces quite a bit in the video hehe. Also, no 3rd concerto moments? The theme in the Andandrte (part 8) is just too good and addictive
That prelude is literally Scriabin 4 and then Chopin ballade 4 right after that.
Quotes Rach 2 at 10:26.
1. For Pf con no.1, best part is from start until 6.04 min
2. 2nd mov of Pf sonata no.1 very very expensive
3. 1st & 2nd symphonies are very good, almost perfect.
4. Lyrical intermezzo for vln and orchestra 100% better than debussy prelude to the afternoon of a faun
Lol I want to make a video of all the times Bortkiewicz sounds like he's directly quoting Chopin and Scriabin
at least 8 out of these 11 do hahahaha
So you can do another video of all the times Chopin quote Field…
it seems he also quoted liszt and rachmaninoff in a few pieces if im not mistaken
@@karrotkake Yes. Quoting so many great composers is the beginning of being original ? I don’t know… A few pieces are very good too great, but a lot of his works are too derivative.
@@mathieuberquet3988 His works are at the level of the composers he's inspired by. Yes, Scriabin is to be more respected for his ingenuity, but you wouldn't complain if you took an uber instead of a taxi. It's a derivative, but one that gets the job done imo. I still prefer Scriabin and Chopin btw
Nice list, but I would like to suggest other performances for 33 / 7 and Piano Concerto No. 1 - Kyoungsun Park and Chihiro Ishioka respectively - which are on my channel. Especially for PC 1 it is much better than the most viewed version on RUclips that has a lot of wrong notes so you should definitely check these out. I've also made a lot of videos on Bortkiewicz's Etudes and Preludes.
07:30 For I second I thought I heard Brahms intermezzo
I just wanna say that there's a much better concerto nr.1 recording. It's title says "analysis" but it's the full concerto with the subtitles bellow analyzing it.
you could have included op 33 nos 8 and 10 too!
Only agree with the 2nd concerto that can stand before the greatest....But you missed the Caprice op 3 n 1, the Prelude op 6 n 1, the Ballade op 10 n 1, the Etude op 15 n 6 and many more 😐😐
C'est un choix, donc subjectif. Vous avez raison, il y a d'autres joyaux.
music is a subjective area.
Interesting. Can you also do rach and scriabin
Yes, I'll do Rach soon. Scriabin later, I need to listen to more of his work (never heard his symphonies, and I need to dig even deeper into his etudes, preludes and sonatas)
especially at 10:26
@@PianoConcerto-wn2udScriabin first symphony is one of the most monumental, universal, etheral pieces ever. It needs a few shots to appreciate all its grandeur!
Очень напоминает 2 концерт Рахманинова
I don’t like this composer. No individuality, just impersonation.