In india, there were so many social workers and reformers before Independence, 1 Dr. Babasheb Ambedkar 2 Mahamrma Jotiba Fule 3. Dr. Rajaram mohan roy 4 Abdul kalam 5 Periyar 6 Karmveer patil.... ..... so on. They believe in humanity and science with modern education . The foundation of modern education was put in 1950at ground level.
Disappointing to see the ignorance of even educated Pakistani intellectuals about most things related India. Caste based discriminations are our dark past which we put behind our current prime minister is from lower cast and our President is a 'Adivasi' women. And the audicity of Pakistanis to talk about Muslims getting discriminated in India is nothing but sick joke, Guys we already had a Muslim president - probably the most loved President so far btw it's in your Pakistani law that only Muslims could become PM, Prime minister etc. Here in India Muslims are well represented in all walks of life here and the can become whoever they wants if they have talent & meanwhile minorities of your Pakistan cannot live their life without the fear of Islamists. Your economy might start to do well when you leave your hypocrisy, hatred, lies & propaganda.
It would be good if you gave the entire lecture in English. So that all people who do not understand Urdu and Punjubi but are interested in issues affecting Pakistan could follow the lecture.
Endless discussion on problems does not bring useful results. Observation on that small industrialist who spoke positive. Encourage such people for positivity. Best of regards.
It is incorrect that Raj Rammohan Roy began " Hindu" reforms. Reforms began as early as 5 th century. Again in 8 th and 15 th centuries by different reformers all very well known respected, documented and their writings in Sanskrit and various other Indian languages including straight texts, poems, hymns, etc. It is shameful and laughable that Pakistan's " elites" deliberately avoid 90% of India's factual history and focus only on recent ( 18 th or 19 th century,) to suit their made up thesis. Also comparing " gurukuls" with madrasas is idiotic. Don't forget the oldest University, Nalanda that existed for so long until destroyed by a " don't like education" Muslim tyrant. Neither speakers would want to go there, obviously. Another aspect Roy's well needed reform was more cultural, not religious and was confined to a specific region and practices. Caste exists in India mostly in pockets of rural areas. It still plays a role in elections and is kept alive by losing parties like Congress. IT HAS Minimal impact in day to day life. But if you see a group of friends male or females anywhere in India you will finds that all castes are represented and this is evident right from primary schools through adult hood. In towns and cities nobody cares what caste you are. Regarding muslims of the sub continent, yes they are all seen as converts from the lowest castes either through coercive means or other. But in present day India Muslims are getting more inclined and inspired by c-grade Muslim countries, sharia, and other stuff ignoring the vast opportunities. Just look at the burquas in any city or town. They were occasional sights even 15-20 years ago, but now they are everywhere and more defiant. MUSLIMS think it is their right to have multiple wives and children instead of common laws for all. So the crocodile years shed by the two speakers about " poor Indian Muslims" is both pathetic and laughable.
When ALL Pakistanis start believing that they are Humans first, that they are of Bharthiya Origin, that they converted to Islam, their priorities should be - Better Education, Equal rights to ALL, establish good relations with Bharath, NO Support to Any Islamic Terror groups - They will see an improvement.
None of that matters. They will always be a 7th century displaced Turks or Arabs. It’s none of our problem. Just know it that they busy they are amongst themselves the better it is for us. This is not an ideology that lets people improve.
Real advice begins after "their priorities". Jews are more zealots than Muslims. Israel is a Jewish state and a security state with a narrative that is overwhelmingly rejected by the majority in UN. Yet they are one of the best economies in the world. The only thing that differentiates Israel from Pakistan is the focus on modern STEM education. For that to happen, regressive mullahs would have to be made an agonizing example out of.
Since 1985 (when FEBC and Dollar Bearer Certificates were issued) Pakistan is exporting $s. Even while carrying on Exports and Imports the people are laundering money by 'under invoicing and over invoicing'.
aga5 percent obsolete crriculum tha aur us ne us ko 5% newer curriculum ke level per la khara kia . kia khami hai is may. kabhi parha hai ki kia changes hui curriculum may?
The root cause of all issues is obsession with Kashmir cause. Pakistani establishment and puppet government took position as a security state rather than adopting socio development model.
solution is very simple and is already happening in SA and UAE become MODERATE or better do GHAR WAPSI then everything will be sorted out in your present mindset you are doomed
Unfortunately there is big void towards east of Pakistan before Bangladesh border starts. Now how they would become part of global supply chain. Theory is OK. There is no country in the world who have such a big void around their borders and that void is also being created towards their west also. Baki sab baten hai. Mind is close.
Economy platform are fundamentally changed , with new platform rules of game is changed, You do not need Row manpower likes for mfg Economy, you need educated man power that required time and institution of repute. Managerial man power that can guide boat in right direction. Industry and education institutions with right govt. Policy in tandem moving forward promote ideas and opportunities. Domestic market as well ax foreign market , now to understand without domestic market ,you have hardwire to conquered export market. Stability of government, policy and peaceful cooperative neighborhoods promotes business that is like fertilizer for soil , Pakistani economist is building Castel in the air without understanding ground realities.
Not the economy, it's the mindset of jihadi culture that to b improved first, accept the science in its original form,b compitative,thrive for excellence, the economy will take care of its own.
Our biggest failure and India’s biggest success is population control. As of 1972 our population increased four fold whereas India was able to control it to 2.5 folds. Our fertility rate id 3.3% against 2% in case of India. 8 million children are born every year and we do not have resources to educate and train the properly. Our planners do not seem to understand this crisis.
When you talk about doing business with India, you forget that India is in no mood to accommodate Pakistan due to state supported terrorism from your country. Why your discussion does not mention that ? Terrorists operate with impunity in Pakistan.
Mhgayi q ber rahe Hy y jtnay be Gig Trees Hy os sy fruits ly aur SB by bs logo ma tkseem Ker ly aur y ju sirkari trees Hy moft Ka Mal y SB reshta daro yateemo meskeno aur musafer aur SB ma tkseem Ker ly aur y foj ju buto ke abadat kerti Hy Allah ke abadat Nahe Ker ty in SB Ku duty per laga do y SB chezay na serf Pakistan k le y BL k reshta dar counties k le y be hy
![Megan Thee Stallion - Bigger In Texas [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QxTkZTLWdo4/mqdefault.jpg)
Dr.Hoodbhy, India's software export in FY 23 is 320 billion dollar, not 120 billion.
In india, there were so many social workers and reformers before Independence,
1 Dr. Babasheb Ambedkar
2 Mahamrma Jotiba Fule
3. Dr. Rajaram mohan roy 4 Abdul kalam 5 Periyar 6 Karmveer patil....
..... so on.
They believe in humanity and science with modern education .
The foundation of modern education was put in 1950at ground level.
After Listening to this discussion it seems there is no one interested in making any hard changes in Pakistan. Definitely not the ruling elites.
Mujhe ye program bahut accha lagta hai । From India ।
Hatred is consuming Pakistani minds. No solution is possible without moving away from religious beliefs whose purpose is conflict
Disappointing to see the ignorance of even educated Pakistani intellectuals about most things related India.
Caste based discriminations are our dark past which we put behind our current prime minister is from lower cast and our President is a 'Adivasi' women. And the audicity of Pakistanis to talk about Muslims getting discriminated in India is nothing but sick joke, Guys we already had a Muslim president - probably the most loved President so far btw it's in your Pakistani law that only Muslims could become PM, Prime minister etc. Here in India Muslims are well represented in all walks of life here and the can become whoever they wants if they have talent & meanwhile minorities of your Pakistan cannot live their life without the fear of Islamists.
Your economy might start to do well when you leave your hypocrisy, hatred, lies & propaganda.
Nice to see Shakil sir in audience.
Power packed session. Well-done
It would be good if you gave the entire lecture in English. So that all people who do not understand Urdu and Punjubi but are interested in issues affecting Pakistan could follow the lecture.
Endless discussion on problems does not bring useful results. Observation on that small industrialist who spoke positive. Encourage such people for positivity. Best of regards.
It is incorrect that Raj Rammohan Roy began " Hindu" reforms. Reforms began as early as 5 th century. Again in 8 th and 15 th centuries by different reformers all very well known respected, documented and their writings in Sanskrit and various other Indian languages including straight texts, poems, hymns, etc. It is shameful and laughable that Pakistan's " elites" deliberately avoid 90% of India's factual history and focus only on recent ( 18 th or 19 th century,) to suit their made up thesis. Also comparing " gurukuls" with madrasas is idiotic. Don't forget the oldest University, Nalanda that existed for so long until destroyed by a " don't like education" Muslim tyrant. Neither speakers would want to go there, obviously. Another aspect Roy's well needed reform was more cultural, not religious and was confined to a specific region and practices.
Caste exists in India mostly in pockets of rural areas. It still plays a role in elections and is kept alive by losing parties like Congress. IT HAS Minimal impact in day to day life. But if you see a group of friends male or females anywhere in India you will finds that all castes are represented and this is evident right from primary schools through adult hood. In towns and cities nobody cares what caste you are.
Regarding muslims of the sub continent, yes they are all seen as converts from the lowest castes either through coercive means or other. But in present day India Muslims are getting more inclined and inspired by c-grade Muslim countries, sharia, and other stuff ignoring the vast opportunities. Just look at the burquas in any city or town. They were occasional sights even 15-20 years ago, but now they are everywhere and more defiant. MUSLIMS think it is their right to have multiple wives and children instead of common laws for all. So the crocodile years shed by the two speakers about " poor Indian Muslims" is both pathetic and laughable.
I am proud of Black Hole which is beneficial forum.
When ALL Pakistanis start believing that they are Humans first, that they are of Bharthiya Origin, that they converted to Islam, their priorities should be - Better Education, Equal rights to ALL, establish good relations with Bharath, NO Support to Any Islamic Terror groups - They will see an improvement.
even something as simple as this is controversial there
All correct except your grandiose toughs about india. India is just another shitty country.
Inn k paas itna dimag nahi hai. Agar hota toh ye todina islam kabul karte😂😂😂 ye log kabi b sudar nahi sakte😂😂😂
None of that matters. They will always be a 7th century displaced Turks or Arabs. It’s none of our problem. Just know it that they busy they are amongst themselves the better it is for us. This is not an ideology that lets people improve.
Real advice begins after "their priorities". Jews are more zealots than Muslims. Israel is a Jewish state and a security state with a narrative that is overwhelmingly rejected by the majority in UN. Yet they are one of the best economies in the world. The only thing that differentiates Israel from Pakistan is the focus on modern STEM education. For that to happen, regressive mullahs would have to be made an agonizing example out of.
Capital flow can be digested only if you have strong domestic market.fundamentals of economy.
Provision of quality education to all and sundry can improve the situation considerably....
What does Pakistan make which is worth exporting?
Very productive
Boooorrrriiing lecture!
Sir I want to Join the session Live. How can I? Please
Keep the camera on the display not un the speakers face. You can still hear the Doctor.
Since 1985 (when FEBC and Dollar Bearer Certificates were issued) Pakistan is exporting $s. Even while carrying on Exports and Imports the people are laundering money by 'under invoicing and over invoicing'.
جب تک کرپشن ختم نہیں ہو گی تب تک معیشت ٹھیک نہیں ہو سکتی ہے۔
ایکسپورٹ کلیرنس اور ویلیوایشن بغیر رشوت نہیں ہوتی۔
aga5 percent obsolete crriculum tha aur us ne us ko 5% newer curriculum ke level per la khara kia . kia khami hai is may. kabhi parha hai ki kia changes hui curriculum may?
The root cause of all issues is obsession with Kashmir cause. Pakistani establishment and puppet government took position as a security state rather than adopting socio development model.
Uppal seems like a Hindu Sir name
❤
solution is very simple and is already happening in SA and UAE
become MODERATE or better do GHAR WAPSI then everything will be sorted out in your present mindset you are doomed
Unfortunately there is big void towards east of Pakistan before Bangladesh border starts. Now how they would become part of global supply chain. Theory is OK. There is no country in the world who have such a big void around their borders and that void is also being created towards their west also. Baki sab baten hai. Mind is close.
انڈسٹری بند ہو رہی ہے۔ نئی انڈسٹریز لگائی ہی نہیں جارہی اور نا ہی نئے انڈسٹری اسٹیٹ بنائے گئے انوسٹر کو کوئی تحفظ نہیں ہے۔
Sorry to say that the whole discussion sounds hallowed and superficial.
گھریلوں انڈسٹری کو پروموٹ کیا جائے۔
بزنس کرنے والوں کو عزت دو۔
Economy platform are fundamentally changed , with new platform rules of game is changed,
You do not need Row manpower likes for mfg Economy, you need educated man power that required time and institution of repute. Managerial man power that can guide boat in right direction. Industry and education institutions with right govt. Policy in tandem moving forward promote ideas and opportunities.
Domestic market as well ax foreign market , now to understand without domestic market ,you have hardwire to conquered export market.
Stability of government, policy and peaceful cooperative neighborhoods promotes business that is like fertilizer for soil ,
Pakistani economist is building Castel in the air without understanding ground realities.
GHQ asim munir will manage economy😂😂
cpec ki kia zaroorat hai, really, paisa establishment kha chuki ho tu road ki liey paisa kahan se ayega
Not the economy, it's the mindset of jihadi culture that to b improved first, accept the science in its original form,b compitative,thrive for excellence, the economy will take care of its own.
Tum Allah, alllah hi karte raho yaar
Our biggest failure and India’s biggest success is population control.
As of 1972 our population increased four fold whereas India was able to control it to 2.5 folds.
Our fertility rate id 3.3% against 2% in case of India.
8 million children are born every year and we do not have resources to educate and train the properly.
Our planners do not seem to understand this crisis.
سمال انڈسٹری کو پروموٹ کیا جائے۔
Y funny Andaz ma batay karay ta k zayada log os Ku son ly y keya Hy boring Andaz Hu a Hu a y keya hy
Pakistan compare there country with all the non muslim countries again and again 😁😁
When you talk about doing business with India, you forget that India is in no mood to accommodate Pakistan due to state supported terrorism from your country.
Why your discussion does not mention that ? Terrorists operate with impunity in Pakistan.
I don’t see any hope.
Mhgayi q ber rahe Hy y jtnay be Gig Trees Hy os sy fruits ly aur SB by bs logo ma tkseem Ker ly aur y ju sirkari trees Hy moft Ka Mal y SB reshta daro yateemo meskeno aur musafer aur SB ma tkseem Ker ly aur y foj ju buto ke abadat kerti Hy Allah ke abadat Nahe Ker ty in SB Ku duty per laga do y SB chezay na serf Pakistan k le y BL k reshta dar counties k le y be hy
These guys can't think beyond India..