You know what would have been hilarious in this duel? If the destruction of Makyura caused Marik to forget the Pharoh. Just, his entire motivation, gone.
Not so sure, Pharaoh was Marik's objective. But unless they changed it in the anime, Yami Marik just wanted to destroy everything around himself for no greater reason than he wanted to. Yea, Pharaoh may have been higher on the list of "things that I most want to destroy" but if he was gone Marik would just destroy everything else.
I have to say that I've always liked that this Duel's Shadow Game rules are different from Joey's, because it makes Yami Marik seem like he puts more thought into how his games harm his victims and makes each of them unique. Mai: Talks about not needing anybody and being able to be on her own, so Yami Marik attempts to isolate her completely. Yami Bakura and Less Evil Marik: Two spirits inhabiting a body, so Yami Marik takes it away from them. Joey: Wants to be a tough guy, so Yami Marik makes the Duel as physically painful as possible. Yami Yugi: Wants to save Less Evil Marik, so Yami Marik sets it up so that Less Evil Marik dies if Yami Yugi wins. He also fixes it where he can kill both Yugi and Yami Yugi together. While this one superficially resembles the Bakura match, the two key twists are Yugi being painfully eroded away as they lose life points, while Yami remains whole, and that Less Evil Marik is acting as a hostage because Yami promised Ishizu that he'd save the guy who led a terrorist cell, enslaved people, kidnapped his friends, and tried to kill Yugi and his friends on multiple occasions. Come to think of it, is that one actually a "Less Evil Marik" at all?
I do dislike how the rules play out though in this. Oh, Mai loses memories of two people who taught her important lessons about needing support, Marik loses memories of two mooks he had probably already forgotten. I know Yami Marik really doesn't have anyone close to him, but it would probably be more impactful if it was Ishizu and Odeon he lost memories of.
Mai vs Marik is one of those frustrating yugioh moments where “Only the main character can beat the big bad guy no matter what.” Behind the king of examples, Joey vs Marik.
If it wasn't for how Marik was framed in these duels, I'd think they were trying to make a point that he's actually a terrible duelist being carried by Ra's power.
Honestly I think that's part of the point. Pegasus didn't play fair either, literally reading minds to get the upper hand. It's meant to feel unfair, such that their eventual downfall feels like karmic punishment, instead of "just" being outskilled by the MC. I mean Takahashi could have written these duels to have Marik win fair and just be a dick about it, but he chose to do it this way, and I definitely think it's intentional In the Joey duel, also, it's made explicit that Marik isn't really playing optimally, he's forgoing opportunities so that he can cause Joey more pain through the mechanics of the shadow game. It's his cockiness that almost costs him, and it's the beginning of his villainous breakdown that leads to Marik Prime being able to take over, at least in my reading I definitely feel similarly, he's a great big cheating bastard, I just don't think it's bad writing, necessarily
That's more like a common trope that a lot of common animes do. In the latest season of SAO, Asuna (the female lead) almost beats 1 of the main villains of the season, but she lets him regain his power back, only for Kirito to beat him in the next episode.
@@TayGlass92 That's because he's the reincarnation of the Millennium Rod's original user, Kaiba could only read it because of his own past life, Mai doesn't have that benefit
Odion would have won but listened to Marik about summoning fake Ra and thus he got knocked out by Ra allowing Marik's living dark side to break free from the confinement Odion held him in.
Ehh it's decent but not my favorite. Yeah I get that they wanted to show that making fake egyptian god cards was not a good idea. But it resulted in making Joey look weaker than he actually was at that point, and it is not lost on me that this happens while Kaiba is present too. And the writers seemed to have had a habit of nerfing Joey whenever Kaiba was around to keep the status quo, it's the reason I don't like their first duel at all. The only real exceptions were his duels with Johnson and Marik. Kaiba was watching but Joey was performing how he should've at both duels. Point is the duel with Odion is a bit sloppy in how it got to where it wanted to by the end, it would've been much better for him to put up a fight the whole way through and push Odion to the point of using Ra ontop of his accusation that Odion was'nt really Marik.
@@Cloud-dt6xb I feel that it misses the point. The English dub has Joey more rude and dismissive even towards the end, but the original Japanese and the English manga establish that Joey really came to respect Odion during their duel. THAT'S how he knew it wasn't Marik, not just the vague feeling he had in English. Even after he briefly wakes up after being knocked out by Ra he tells Joey it was an honor to duel him, and Joey returns the sentiment. Unlike all the cheaters using underhanded tactics to win, Roba, Weevil, Marik, Pegasus, etc. Odion faced his opponents head on honestly. Plot armor made Joey win, but I feel it really fits with the theme of the show that the one who came closest to winning against the heroes is one who played fair the whole time. In that regard it's not showing Joey as weak. It's showing that playing with honor is a strength and that he's basically a better duelist than his boss even without the magic and God cards.
I think the reason why Mai didn’t attack with her Harpies is because the anime/manga effect of Elegant Egotist makes the monsters summoned by it not able to attack the turn they’re summoned. The same applied when she used it back in Duelist Kingdom if you recall and I think she said so.
I thought I saw something about that, thanks for the info! Luckily though Marik only had 1050lp left. So Mai could have won had she chosen not to use it and just attacked with the one Harpie Lady she already had on the field.
Even if that were the case she had 3 monsters, Marik could only summon one monster at a time so he'd have to pull some serious BS out in order to survive and still win.
@@SuperSayianWarrior Right...in her VERY last duel, she used the card and immediately attacked with all three resultant monsters. That filler episode only further undermined her plays here. They just needed to establish the damn shackles as untargetable...it would have been so damn simple...
@@TGSAnime She had a one epsiode duel versus a guy in love with her using ninja deck during this tournament, and she used "Élegant egotist". No restrictions on the first turn for harpie sister, she didn't attack because of plot 😉
14:00 Marik is not attacking because he knows Mai is gonna summon Ra, so he plans to take it back to inflict maximum pain. Also interesting how all memories lost are people who appear in the series. It would have been very funny if some random people were forgotten.
Would have been interesting to have Ishizu vs Marik and Kaiba vs Mai over what we got. Yes the idea for Ishizu was for her to reclaim obelisk and use that as her sword, but it would have given her a bit more prominence than a Kaiba stepping stone. Plus you could introduce Yami Marik’s whole “Immortal god Phoenix” plan earlier with Ishizu choosing to destroy his deck to only find out that helps him as Marik wouldn’t use Ra that way
@@if7723i mean I understand that, she saw that if she plays these certain cards, she has a guaranteed win, her fault for over relying on ancient powers but also not her fault that Kaiba had mind armour
It's funny how in this duel Marik lost his memories of Strings, however in dub when he summoned Revival Jam against Yugi, he reminds him that Yugi already encountered Revival Jam against Strings, although Marik should've forgotten that
@@live22morrow Well that and Marik's kind of known to rig the shadow games so they're far less harsh on him. Probably got the memories back when he won
20:23 Here's an interesting hypothetical to defend Mai's decision. Assuming Holding Arms' invincibility was actually three of Marik's turns, and thus Mai wouldn't be able to attack it with her Harpies, maybe she thought summoning Ra would bypass the invincibility? The God cards effects are infamously vague in the anime, so I don't think it'd be unreasonable for Mai to think Ra would be able to attack and destroy Holding Arms.
I doubt it. Recall how Atem used the Slime Monster to block against Osiris/Slifer. Given the set-up with the Slime, even the Egyptian God card couldn't penetrate it. Going back to your case, the same thing applies. The only difference is that the only thing keeping Holding Arms alive is its own effect. Not even Ra will penetrate it.
@@7swordquanta459 but it acted to the effect, it doesn't have piercing it just attacks your opponents monsters to reduce unless it destroys. That's what Slifer did. Ra should just obliterate.
Ah yes. The Duel that, while painful to watch, the original manga had an even darker alternative where duelists actually had the same damage that the monsters had (Basically the meant when say, Mai's Amazoness monster cuts the head off a monster with how the Duel Disk projected it, Marik's head actually falls off his body because he also took that damage. Yes, he lived, but he actually held his head Dullahan Style for a moment and it was metal as hell)
I actually do like that the anime chose not to repeat any of the shadow game rules. With Mai every time a monster is destroyed their memories of someone is erased. With Bakura each time they lose life points a portion of their bodies disappear. With Joey each time a monster is destroyed or weakened the owner feels its pain. With Atem each time they lose life points a portion of their soul partner is erased. Also note that Marik’s duel with Bakura and Joey were the only duels where they were on an even playing field. With Mai and Atem Marik gave himself the advantage as he doesn’t care about any of his henchmen or his partner soul.
@@sonicgen20 Perhaps, but I feel like it does split things differently to tell the story. Marik in the manga was about physical harm the most and actively causing bodily damage, which stays consistent with his backstory when he chose to not just stab his Dad, but actively carve the Runes off his back and drop them onto Rishid's back, as well as in his Duels with Mai, Jounouchi and Atem, alongside the Penalty Game being not just sand that erases the memory, but actual parasites that eat your Soul while you watch your friends live on without you in Mai's Case, while the anime was more about causing psychological pain with Mai and Atem. Weirdly enough Bakura was most tame out of both types, and the Dub's use of the Shadow Realm works better with how much of his focus in the anime is on psychological torment of his opponents before sending them to the Shadow Realm.
Also, the punishment Mai received from Marik was slightly different. Instead of an hourglass of sand that takes away Mai's memories... It's an hourglass of carnivorous insects. Likely Scarabs. *Edit* I just saw the above reply after commenting this.
I think, Mai summoning Ra isn't really a bad thing. It's a story point. She wants to prove herself to the others. If I remember correctly, Yugi even tries to give her advice when Marik plays his slime combo and she refuses it. So what better way to prove yourself than using an egyptian god card? Therefore, I think, it's fine, especially since there was no mention of ancient egyptian texts in the duel before (between Odion and Joey). Mai even references that duel when Marik asks her if she wants to play Ra with that rescue card and she says she understands that Ra would have 0 ATK then. So I think, overall, it shows her to be a good duelist while also giving you enough reason to understand why she did it. Of course, you could add a few rules that just make it even more logical. Like for example, that Holding Arms is still invincible, but God Cards would be able to destroy it, to just name the easiest fix. But then again, I would also say it would make the story worse as Mai would have to use Ra. And the reason why Joey feels responsible for her being trapped is that he wasn't honest with her and therefore, Mai felt she had to prove herself in the first place.
I feel like for Joey to be erased I think maybe the winged dragon of Ra should’ve instead destroyed her ace which would be harpie lady, it would’ve hit that much harder imo, like for him to be erased with one of her monsters we never see again just feels insulting
This is really 1 of those duels that suffered from being brought from the manga to the anime. The purpose behind the Holding Arms play was that it would torture Amazoness Chain Master each turn, therefore torturing Mai, but that's completely lost when the whole Shadow Game has been changed (the duel itself was identical, except it started with The Unfriendly Amazon and Makyura, skipping the part where Marik uses the cards of his henchmen). Similarly, Grave Arm just painlessly pulls a monster down, so to keep its secondary purpose of avoiding the Shadow Game's rule they invented this rule of this not wiping out a memory (ironic how this only became inconsistent because they added the Dunames Dark Witch vs Unfriendly Amazon part to the duel). 1 more interesting thing to mention is that Harpie cards were lvl 5 in the manga, so Mai was waiting for something that would spring her Dramatic Rescue trap so she could bring out Cyber Harpie without tribute. Also, I think the 3 turns invincibility counts Marik's Standby Phases just like how Viser Des does, and that The Winged Dragon of Ra bypasses this invincibility because of god card deus ex machina. Also, I think the talk about destroying Amazoness Chain Master within 3 turns is an inaccurate translation and he's actually talking about how Amazoness Fighter will be dying in 3 turns (in the context of being tortured by Holding Arms).
@@danieltodorov7753 No they're not. Just take the ceremonial duel for example. In the manga Yugi was outplaying Atem at every point, showing just how much he'd grown, and how he deserved to be the king of games. In the manga Yugi and Atem both make a ton of stupid plays just so old ass monsters could be brought back because nostalgia, and Atem even had to encourage Yugi to keep going when Yugi became sad and dejected.
What I love about this duel is how Marik uses the same strategy that nearly broke Yugi (revival jam defender) only for Mai to defeat it with a simple Harpies Feather Duster. This is why you play backrow removal.
One thing I found most interesting with this duel and Joey’s duel against Odion: Joey manages to counter the Powers of the Shadow Realm. Combine that with Joey managing to fully throw off the Millenium Rod’s mind control effect, and you have a recipe for a great power within Joey. I do a bit more Headcanon in a fanfic I’m writing, but suffice it to say, Joey overcoming the Millenium Rod’s Power over erasing memories to have Mai actually remember him is something no one else has ever been able to do. Not even Yami. Yami managed to keep Mai in the duel after she lost her memory of Joey, but he couldn’t restore her memories. In season 1, the Puzzle managed to reverse the Ring’s effect and swapped Bakura with Yami Bakura, but not even Yami could undo Marik’s memory manipulation. Joey is amazing in all sorts of ways, but he has the favor of the luck god to the point he can override a Millenium Item’s Power. That is a level of Awesome Kaiba can’t comprehend.
That's why I'd say Joey could have gained Ra's respect if he beat Marik. His deck is centered quite a bit on luck to get out strong monsters or to make some fights more in his favor. Ra's effects all require luck to get the most out of them especially when it comes to what monsters you use to summon it. Joey would have had the strongest version of Ra in BC
Man, this duel has a lot of personality and life in the animation. Mai's movements have a lot of personality, like her activating Grave Hand, or Amazoness Spellcaster. Even the Monster battle animations are great, like The Unfriendly Amazon doing a back flip through the air, and then swinging her blade to the side to kill Makyura.
It's a shadow game. If the memories are lost in shadows, then you can't see them. ... Yeah, I know it's stupid. I can't think of a better explanation for why they showed it that way.
Considering if I remember correctly this is the first time anyone has seen Marik duel I think it would make sense for her to not play her traps on her first turn so she doesn’t know how he’ll play and doesn’t want to potentially lose the traps, or potentially take up trap or slots that she might need.
I mean, by this point in the series we've already seen a card that destroys cards in hand, so that's not playing cautiously at all, it's choosing a different gamble and hoping it pays off.
God card tunnel vision was Mai's detriment upon getting it since she had some knowledge of how Ra works from Joey/Jounouchi's duel with Odion/Reshid when he summoned the fake Ra card. Throughout the duel she was in control before the Game of darkness/Yami no Game/Shadow game which did off set her a bit but then she had a small reprieve thanks to Yugi and the Millennium Puzzle then she made a move that she shouldn't have made and its the very card Marik had that was a trap her taking Ra was the biggest misplay because its even shown in the Manga and anime when Mai stole Ra using her Chain Masters effect Marik was unfazed which is a red flag. Her summoning it was a mistake thinking it was her end game but its not because of the Hieratic Text which only appears when Ra is played. Had she just attacked with her Cyber Harpies or regular Harpie lady in the manga she would have won and Ra would have been hers and even if she stole through the chain masters effect and didn't summon it she would have it reguardless. Sadly she doesn't and the play she made ultimately is her own demise
If I remember correctly, in older rules, turn count used to be based per player, not in total. By that, I mean “turn 1” was both the first turn and the second turn, because it was turn 1 for each player, then turn 2 was third and fourth, etc. That’s at least what I remember from older yugioh games because it changed how Final Countdown worked.
I want to see one of these where you say "Was {character} about to defeat {other character}? ... No, of course not." and then the Full House ending theme and credits roll.
I think it is worth noting that when Mai lost her memories of Tea from destroying Diane’s Dark Witch, she destroyed it by battle. But when she destroyed Amazon Chain Master it was via Grave Arm’s effect. That could explain why she kept her memories, since she was willing sacrificing her monster via a card effect. Same reason she didn’t lose any memories from tributing her Harpies to summon Ra.
Its really sad that this was the last time Mai does something relevant in-canon Also, Marik did missplay with Mirror Wall since its established that, if set, spells in Battle City can be used as Quick Plays. And since he set it early on, he could have used Trap Removal and attacked sooner. It wouldn't have changed the end result but he would have secured his victory more confidently
Mai's strategy of going into this with Chain Master was such a good idea. imagine her dueling like this in Battle City and stealing Obelisk or Blue-Eyes or Dark Magician for the win; but, no. She unlucky ran into a card that was theft-proof. Shame, really.
However, Gods can be controlled by worthy people with relations to Ancient Egypt, which Mai isn't. So it's safe to assume that stealing Slifer and Obelisk to use is like firing a jammed gun. And as we saw with Joey, stealing a BEWD against Kaiba won't do much against him.
@roncerjani9063 hey, stealing one of Kaiba's Blue Eyes and using it against him does plenty! Specifically, it majorly pisses him off like very little else can lmao
@@gothicbutterfly013 I'd pay good money to see an animated duel between Mai and Kaiba in which at one point, perhaps as her winning play, she uses the same trick she used on Marik to steal his Winged Dragon of Ra and steals one of Kaiba's Blue Eyes White Dragon and uses it to either gain a massive advantage over Kaiba, backing him into a corner, or perhaps even straight up winning the duel because of it. In the latter outcome, nothing would piss him off more than a move like that lmao. His pride would be beaten down.
I like to imagine this duel ending in Marik's disqualification. "Ref! Marik's card isn't in Japanese!" "Marik Ishtar! Please provide a translation reference!" "I don't have a translation reference." "Well, you're disqualified then." "Shadow Games dont have disquali-!" *Shadows start slowly dragging Marik away.*
Marik really is the king of "Could X have won", isn't he? so many dubious fights. Could we have shun vs sora? They have two complete duels, with pretty complex plays that can be entertaining to analyze
This is not even a question, from a normal dueling rules perspective Mai should have had Ra and win BUT the fact that not only she couldn't use Ra but MARIK was allowed to despite Mai summoning it made her lose. How could have she know such a bullshit would happen ?
If we go by normal dueling rules, ra is actually the one god card whos text, as it was translated by Kaiba, was most closely followed. Yes the effect had not appeared before that duel but it was followed through the manga - and the parts of the anime adapted from it - quite closely. Saint Dragon - The God of Osiris, I'm reading their manga versions to get the effects and that includes the names, however stated only that X is the number of cards in the players hand. And: When the opponent summons a creature , the point of the player's card is cut by 2000 points. - Nothing about destroying it if it goes down to or below 0. The God of Obelisk has probably the most space for misunderstanding: "The player shall sacrifice two bodies to the God of Obelisk" is so far so clear, though it does not specify if those "bodies" must be on their field or if they can discard monsters from their hand or I mean with how the characters act especially in shadow games just murder 2 bystanders, and "The opponent shall be damaged" has similar concerns and additionally even when assuming it only applies to ingame damage it does not specify any amount (It is appearantly 4000 wich is equal to a direct attack by Obelisk), "And the monsters on the field shall be destroyed" at least specify that it does mean the field, and only in game objects finally, but whos monsters and how many and no part of that includes gaining infinite ATK for a Turn. The Sun of God Dragon in its first line does mention "[...] However God shall only follow those who offer the ancient incantation to the heavens." so saying that the first player who says the text in their turn gets control of it sounds like a comparatively reasonable conclusion. And Kaiba had translated and spoiled the other 2 effects in the original before they were used, he just didn't feel like sharing with the rest of the class.
Well if you consider that it didn't have stats and wasn't going to stop a direct attack it was apparently not treated as a monster on her field. So it would either be considered a non monster card like a backrow crystal beast or not on either players SIDE of the field, in either case it would cause a rules nightmare if after its summon a player got to 5 on field monsters and then read its effect.
19:03 I think in defense to Marik here, Pegasus wasn’t able to finish translating all 3 Egyptian god cards because his people kept vanishing. Therefore I assume he simply had to leave the card text in its original script and created the effect over it? That or the Winged Dragon of Ra itself did that. Either way, there exists no translation for it because it’s the only copy
The duplicate draw at 6:01 could be intentional for a commercial break. Cut after Marik gets the monster and reestablish Mais turn with her Draw step. Just a hunch though, any thoughts?
I think the whole “lose memories when monster is destroyed” is meant for if the monster is destroyed in battle. Given Mai destroyed her dark witch in battle vs using a card effect for her chain master.
@@dogboyton3166 that’s where I think I heard it from. But it’s been a long time since I watched Yugioh and if that’s the case. Point for the dub for fixing a mistake the sub did.
This duel was the start of Marik’s reign of terror and where things got way out of hand. Just when Yugi and the gang thought they had Marik figured out he goes and becomes twenty times more evil than he was before. Like I said in a previous video the last quarter final pairings should’ve been Ishizu vs Marik and Mai vs Kaiba. Not only would the former be the first sibling battle we’d get instead of Chazz vs Slade in GX but even if Mai lost to rich boy at least she would be able to watch the rest of the finals from the sidelines instead of being trapped in the Shadow Realm. Plus even if Ishizu lost to her brother’s dark side she would be safe from his wrath thanks to her Millennium Necklace.
I would have loved it if this duel played out as such: Mai wouldn't have particularly cared much about losing her memories of her friends at first because she doesn't believe she has any close bonds with them. Destroying Dunames Dark Witch would have made her lose her memories of Téa, which she would notice but not take too seriously at first. She would however make a note that there's no way she could forget about Teá because she dueled her in Duelist Kingdom to get Yugi out of his slump after his duel with Kaiba, but she'd be unable to properly recall the moment. After Marik destroys Unfriendly Amazon with Makyura, it'd be here where she'd lose her memories of Yugi instead of Joey. She'd begin denying it because the two of them dueled in the Duelist Kingdon finals and promised to duel again afterwards, but she'd be unable to remember that moment as well. It would be at this point that she'd become a bit scared and would understand the gravity of the situation. It would then only be after Mai's Grave Arm destroys Chain Master that she'd lose her memories of Joey, the only person she genuinely cares about. She'd then go into a panic mode, which Marik would notice and decide to capitalize upon. He would then use the Millennium Rod to manifest a fake memory of Joey in Mai's mind and convince her to use Chain Master's effect to steal Ra from Marik. The duel would then continue as normal until Mai uses Elegant Egotist to get her three Harpie Lady cards out. Mai would then realize that she would win if she attacked Marik now, but would be hesitant because of Marik's face-down cards and the fear of losing all three of her Harpie Lady cards and in turn her memories of three other people (it would also be a nice reference to her duel with Yugi in Duelist Kingdom where she surrendered before her Harpies could be destroyed). In her moment of hesitation, Marik would use the fake memory of Joey again to tell Mai to summon Ra to the field, because it would allow her to protect her monsters from being destroyed and win her the game. Mai would summon the disobedient Ra and Marik would reveal that he tricked Mai into doing this, steal Ra and win the game. I feel like this ending to the duel would help justify Mai's actions a bit and would be a sad, if poetic, end to her time in Battle City.
Marik doesn't go for the early win when he has the chance because he is not interested in that he wants to play with his food, slowly tormenting people with both the shadow game and the actual game and wear them down before he summons ra for the big finisher. He often has chances he could go for early wins and that is just never something he's interested in. It's not exactly the most meta play style, but it fits his role as a big bad very nicely.
Canonically, Yami Marik isn't much of a duelist. He's a sadist spirit first and foremost, and it influences his play. A common trend in his duels is him having game on board without finishing the job, because he wants the shadow game to take it's toll. He realizes his own stupidity in dragging it out during the semi-finals vs Joey (who severely outplayed him), but his *strategy* ends up working out in the end due to the fact that he essentially gives Joey a near heart-attack from all the mental and bodily stress the shadow game inflicts on him. It's a neat touch that both the sub and dub manage to translate well.
Pretty sure Holding Arms attaches itself to an opponent's monster and prevents them from attacking as well as prevents Holding Arms from being attacked as long as the monster being trapped by Holding Arms is on the field.
If Holding Arms and Holding Legs are both real cards, then if you play duel monsters with someone and you put them in play, what are they supposed to do?
Fun fact about the Wing Dragon of Ra he does have visible card text. The card text is shown to only those who have connection to the ancient scriptures for example Yami, Kabia, and Marik can see the “invisible ancient scriptures” on Ra. Mai has no connection to the the ancient scriptures so therefore she can’t see or read the text to summon Ra
Fun fact, Card of Last Will is an actual trap in real life, came out in I believe a Legendary Collection set, it though has the Match Winner YCS clause of cannot be use in a duel written on it
Card of last will would be broken, given that the print card mention when the attack of one of your monster become 0, meaning you Can activate it after you reduce the attack yourself.
19:36 This would only matter if these weren't the only versions of the cards in-universe, and that there are implications that the card game is played worldwide and there's no requirement for language to match. On top of this, Pegaus owns the IP in-universe, and if he says the cards are officially part of the game, they're part of the game. _Even further on top of this, Seto Kaiba is the person running the tournament, and he personally legalized the God Cards for its use._
Would be funny if Kaiba came up and was like "woah woah woah, that card has a SECRET effect? Yeah it's banned from my tournament." Save the world via DQ.
7:19 nice parrallel between Panter Warrior and Unfriendly Amazon, both 2000 ATK the former requires 1 tribute to attack the latter requires 1 tribute as maintainence it is fitting Joey's memory is within that card
May I suggest a bunch of duels that I would love to see analyzed? - Odion vs Joey - Yubel/Jesse vs Adrian Gecko - Yusei vs Kalin Kessler (rematch during Dark Signers arc and crash town duel) - Any duel the protagonist lost, especially Yuya vs Jack Atlas - Maybe some more Yu-boys and bracelet girls?
This always botherd me about mai, she was always put in situations where she had to lose otherwise the show would be over, the fact that her only on screen wins were the one filler episode against that actor and joey in the orichalcos arc where the latter could barely stand says something, at least she won against tea (yes I consider that a win for her if only on a moral level) she deserved better
Mai had a pretty good deck by DM standards. I dunno if she could beat Odion, but I'd still rank her ahead of everyone else in the finals except Yugi and Kaiba.
I remember watching this episode so many times and saying please don’t sacrifice the harpy lady sisters all you have to do is attack directly and you win
I like this duel because of the character growth for Mai and Ra. She’s committed to playing fairly and has shown she has thrown away her old cheating playstyle. We saw a bit of that in DK but that could be explained that because Pegasus was watching, she decided not to cheat. However, she still has a major flaw, Pride. She deliberately summoned Ra to flex on Marik for making her suffer throughout the duel. But that was the point. Marik knew as soon as she stole the card, she would use it. It’s also why he punishes her by having Arms and Legs attack directly before Ra does. Later on in the Waking the Dragons arc, this duel is the whole reason she joined up with Dartz.
I thought that too, but then that idea of the rare hunters came to my mind when was rewatching one day years ago, and I was like “Oh right. They copy and print cards, so he might have been the one to give them such monsters”
This is one of those times in Yu-Gi-Oh when the cards being magic means they sometimes don't or won't do anything, like the time Yami Yugi/Atem couldn't use his Legendary Dragon card against Weevil because it was mad about him using the Seal of Orichalcos. On a separate note, it would've been very funny if the referee had shouted "Hold it! According to tournament rules, you need to provide an accurate translation when using foreign langue cards!", even if it would prevent Marik from dueling Yugi because he would be forced to give Mai complete control of Ra and cause him to lose either by attacking into Holding Arms or by one of Ra's 15 effects.
Funny enough, when a real world version of The Winged Dragon of Ra Sphere mode was released, your able to summon it to your opponents field by tributing three monsters and during the end phase, changes controller of the card.
I THINK Egotist prevents the monsters attacking that turn in the manga, which is why she did what she did. (It's hard to tell if it did that beyond Duelist Kingdom since the text never mentioned it.) It definitely didn't prevent them from attacking in the anime (we see that against Jean-Claude), but that could just be manga meddling, which happens on occasion. Viser Des was also still immune in the manga I believe. So yeah, this is all probably because of how things worked in the manga, regardless of if they would have in the anime.
Marik really should have lost every duel he was in but because he made them all shadow games and was more focused on torturing his opponents then winning the duel he was able to make it to the finals. I have him as a B class duelist that could have been an A or S if he was more focused on his dueling
Also he was allowed to use banned cards. Ever notice how no one used cards like raigeki? Effect damage cards and board wipes aren't allowed, but Marik used them and Kaiba allowed it due to Marik having Ra
I’m so happy to see this one! I actually requested this one a while back but thought it wouldn’t since someone reminded me of certain parts I forgot about, but man it feels good knowing that I was right that Mai could’ve won without Ra. Thanks for looking into this duel. 😁 As for another duel I’d like to see you look at, could you possibly take a look at Yuma & Astral vs Nash (Shark)? It’s where Nash used CXyz Barian Hope, and I noticed that he never used his own Barian Number monster’s effect while Hope was out (it used all the other Barian Numbers’ effects but not Silent Honor Dark), and Silent Honor lets him turn one opponent’s monster into an overlay unit. Should he have won, or was there some effect preventing him from doing this play?
Very interesting analysis in this one, TGS. It does kind of feel like Mai got a little screwed here because of Ra’s unique summoning condition she knew nothing about. But really, she should’ve just sent her Harpie’s in to shred Marik’s life points. Not sure what duel you have planned for analysis next, but I think Alexis versus Jayden in the two-parter Heart of Ice from season 2 of GX could be worth a look. Alexis had Jayden in some really bad spots in that duel. Could she have won or was Jayden always destined for victory?
@@roninwarriorsfan Assuming elegant egotist wasn't played, sure. It wouldn't have done any good though. TGS is wrong. It still had its invincibility on that turn, and for one more as well.
All that I learned from this was that it would have been smarter to keep Marik away from his God card. Either keep it in your hand or remove it from play. Just don't use it or send it to the graveyard.
This guy is my favorite Yugioh content creator, hands down. His analysis of duels especially the og Duels, are so fun to watch. Especially since I love "what if" scenario's. But there is 1 duel he needs to do... Yugi and Kaiba vs Lumis and Umbra, The 1st time they dueled. 😂 I'd love to see his genuine thoughts and reactions to how bs that opening turn was. Plus, it'd be a quick one for him to do!
i find it funny, Marik basicly coulda lost in like every single duel he was in if his opponants where not A) Scared AF of him and play passively or B) Where not egotisticol and just gone for game when they coulda done it
A few things to observe: 1)The memory loss was not permanent, otherwise it's a total plothole that Mai remembered Tea and Joey 2)I knew Mai could have won this duel if she had just attacked with the haripes, but didn't expect she needed only one 3)In the manga, the duel is a bit diferent, Marik had 3600 LP, and Mai summoned regular harpy with 1300. On Marik's field, he had Viser Des, with 500 atack points and the same invencibility effect , but still on going. Summoning the 3 harpies make her have 3 monster with 1300 attack points, even if she had attacked, she would have caused 1300-500=800 x 3 = 2400 an Marik would still be in the game. She would still not have won if she had summoned Ra, but still it's a matter of weighting quantity against power 4)Basically, both Mai and Joey could have won their duels against Marik, which means he basicaly won because he had villain plot armor
Really wish Yugioh had a “What If” style mini show with different potential ideas for how mainline events could’ve gone. Such as; Kaiba beats Pegasus S1 and gets the Eye but is corrupted by it, create a new monster in a Millenium aesthetic Blue Eyes. Of course Joey beating Marik and we get Ra versions of Red Eyes, Gearfried and Time Wizard. Mai beating marik, same principle as Joey. And on and on. Additionally a concept i think would’ve been cool to explore is that, without mind control bullshit, marik is kinda bad a dueling. So the powers of Ra and the Rod go to Mai, then Joey, then Kaiba, then back to marik for the final duel with yugi/Yami but it’s a multi duel with Atem and Yugi plus Joey and Kaiba vs Marik and Bakura.
9:41 "However, looking closer at what Marik says, it also seems to imply that this monster can't be attacked for next three turns." Teeeeechnically he just says that it possesses an effect which for three turns makes it unaffected by opponents' attacks. Whether it's merely indestructible or is also untargetable isn't really relevant, but it's best not to treat whichever subtitles are available as gospel and to keep in mind that they may not be totally reliable for this kind of precise nuance, either because they have errors or simply because the editor decided, quite understandably imo, to have Marik declare the effective outcome in a way that might be unintentionally confused for an exact description of the monster's ability.
Someone should make an edit version of the duel where Mai does somehow know the Egyptian language, recite the chant, summon Ra and attack for game. It would be hilarious.
The "Holding Arms" shenanigans comes from adapting the manga: in the original, Marik summons Viser Des instead, which can't be destroyed for three of the turns of whoever the player was when it was summoned and, like Rocket Warrior, the monsters it attacks lose 500 ATK and cannot be tributed, but in this case Viser Des can also attack during the opponent's Battle Phase (Marik uses Viser and not Plasma Eel against Joey too); in addition, manga rules imply that prevention from destruction in battle also prevents any battle damage, but if Viser Des is already targetting a monster and the controller doesn't have other monsters on the field, it cannot protect him from a direct attack.
I believe for certain Mai overextended. There was no need to summon Ra. She would have won by simply keeping it in her hand and away from Marik. But of course, plot.
I love this duel, great coverage, I always watch and love this series. I must say that I totally disagree with the Holding Arms take though. 3 Turns of "invincibility" comes across like with Swords of Revealing Light, so I don't think she could attack so soon. If that's the case, then Summoning Ra would be the superior play, ending your turn with Ra as apposed to the 3 Harpies. She probably felt that Summoning Ra would be a game winning move, and that Ra may have an ability to take out the Holding Arms card as a bonus, guaranteeing a victory that turn. That's how I interpreted it anyways, much love, great video 🤠
Honestly I used to think Marik was a great villain. However after watching this video, it’s clear that the only reason he survived as long as he did, was because the plot needed him to. Both Mai and Joey outdueled him and I really don’t like it when an antagonist is saved only so that there could be a story. Excellent video as always! For future suggestions here’s a few: Atem and Kaiba vs Lumis and Umbra Aster Phoenix vs Adrian Gecko Aster Phoenix vs Jaden (round 2) Jaden vs Darkness (Season 4) Yuma and Nash vs Don Thousand 10000 out of 10 😇😇😇
Nah, it was because the anime made Mai and Joey performed better. In the manga, Marik completely stomped Mai and Joey only had a chance because he pulled Gilford out of nowhere.
@@Ramona122003 I’ll be honest when it comes to the Manga I’ve only read the Dawn of the Duel Arc so thanks for the heads up. Was completely unaware of that. 😇
Never mind that The Winged Dragon of Ra has 3 forms, with 1 that DEFINITELY does not match the card Mai used The text on the Winged Dragon of Ra - Sphere Mode (which is what Mai has and is MILES different from the Winged Dragon of Ra's monster card) reads: "Cannot be Special Summoned. Requires 3 Tributes from either side of the field to Normal Summon to that side of the field (cannot be Normal Set), then shift control to this card's owner during the End Phase of the next turn. "Cannot attack. Your opponent cannot target this card for attacks or by card effects. You can Tribute this card; Special Summon 1 "The Winged Dragon of Ra" from your hand or Deck, ignoring its Summoning conditions, and if you do, its ATK/DEF become 4000." Yes, Marik could be right and Mai could have a brick, BUT it CAN'T be targeted for attacks or destroyed by card effects, meaning Marik could throw a top-tier monster at it and Ra, even in its Sphere Mode, would've been "bruh, NO." Shenanigans, YES.
Honestly Marik should've lost to joey. But honestly if Mai won here that would've been hilarious. Just imagine the shit talk Kaiba would've came up with.
One thing to point out is that Yami Marik's memory loss trick was only temporary. In his duel against Yami Yugi, he summons Revival Jam and flashbacks to the moment when Yami Yugi first faced that monster against Strings.
![Was Weevil About To Defeat Yugi? [On The Wrong Track]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/q7deAXLJV4E/mqdefault.jpg)
![Was Weevil About To Defeat Yugi? [On The Wrong Track]](/img/tr.png)
![Was Yugi About To Defeat Yami? [Self Destruction]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4ujE023tTWY/mqdefault.jpg)
![Stromae, Pomme - “Ma Meilleure Ennemie” (from Arcane Season 2) [Official Visualizer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1F3OGIFnW1k/mqdefault.jpg)
You know what would have been hilarious in this duel? If the destruction of Makyura caused Marik to forget the Pharoh. Just, his entire motivation, gone.
"What am I doing here again? Oh yea playing this girl I guess"
This should've been a funny scene in the abridged series haha!
@@rhamztajarros4335 To be fair I didn't expect Mister Tweetums.
Not so sure, Pharaoh was Marik's objective. But unless they changed it in the anime, Yami Marik just wanted to destroy everything around himself for no greater reason than he wanted to. Yea, Pharaoh may have been higher on the list of "things that I most want to destroy" but if he was gone Marik would just destroy everything else.
He’d go full Brick from Anchorman.
“I DON’T KNOW WHAT WE’RE YELLING ABOUT!!!”
I have to say that I've always liked that this Duel's Shadow Game rules are different from Joey's, because it makes Yami Marik seem like he puts more thought into how his games harm his victims and makes each of them unique.
Mai: Talks about not needing anybody and being able to be on her own, so Yami Marik attempts to isolate her completely.
Yami Bakura and Less Evil Marik: Two spirits inhabiting a body, so Yami Marik takes it away from them.
Joey: Wants to be a tough guy, so Yami Marik makes the Duel as physically painful as possible.
Yami Yugi: Wants to save Less Evil Marik, so Yami Marik sets it up so that Less Evil Marik dies if Yami Yugi wins. He also fixes it where he can kill both Yugi and Yami Yugi together.
While this one superficially resembles the Bakura match, the two key twists are Yugi being painfully eroded away as they lose life points, while Yami remains whole, and that Less Evil Marik is acting as a hostage because Yami promised Ishizu that he'd save the guy who led a terrorist cell, enslaved people, kidnapped his friends, and tried to kill Yugi and his friends on multiple occasions.
Come to think of it, is that one actually a "Less Evil Marik" at all?
There's Marik and then there's a Psychopath 🗿
I do dislike how the rules play out though in this. Oh, Mai loses memories of two people who taught her important lessons about needing support, Marik loses memories of two mooks he had probably already forgotten. I know Yami Marik really doesn't have anyone close to him, but it would probably be more impactful if it was Ishizu and Odeon he lost memories of.
Makes me wonder what he would have done if were to face Seto instead of Yugi
@@igorlopes8463 maybe forget how to play the game? Lol
Either that or it could be about Mokuba again, but that's repeating Mai's duel, kind of.
You should(n't) find out what she suffers through in the manga...
Mai vs Marik is one of those frustrating yugioh moments where “Only the main character can beat the big bad guy no matter what.” Behind the king of examples, Joey vs Marik.
Well it makes sense for the main character to be the one to beat the final boss.
Plot armor
If it wasn't for how Marik was framed in these duels, I'd think they were trying to make a point that he's actually a terrible duelist being carried by Ra's power.
Honestly I think that's part of the point. Pegasus didn't play fair either, literally reading minds to get the upper hand. It's meant to feel unfair, such that their eventual downfall feels like karmic punishment, instead of "just" being outskilled by the MC. I mean Takahashi could have written these duels to have Marik win fair and just be a dick about it, but he chose to do it this way, and I definitely think it's intentional
In the Joey duel, also, it's made explicit that Marik isn't really playing optimally, he's forgoing opportunities so that he can cause Joey more pain through the mechanics of the shadow game. It's his cockiness that almost costs him, and it's the beginning of his villainous breakdown that leads to Marik Prime being able to take over, at least in my reading
I definitely feel similarly, he's a great big cheating bastard, I just don't think it's bad writing, necessarily
That's more like a common trope that a lot of common animes do.
In the latest season of SAO, Asuna (the female lead) almost beats 1 of the main villains of the season, but she lets him regain his power back, only for Kirito to beat him in the next episode.
Clearly mai should have taken more ancient Egyptian language classes. She could have won the duel
Yeah, probably should've brushed up on her Egyptian language before the duel.
@@years-ti7xlor ask Tristan to take one for the team and duel marik so he can use ra on him. Record the duel and boom just repeat the phrase. Ra
I mean you’re not wrong
Kaiba never took any Egyptian language class, and he could read it as if it were in English. Even he was surprised by it
@@TayGlass92 That's because he's the reincarnation of the Millennium Rod's original user, Kaiba could only read it because of his own past life, Mai doesn't have that benefit
There is now only one battle city finals duel to cover, Joey vs Odion
Odion would have won but listened to Marik about summoning fake Ra and thus he got knocked out by Ra allowing Marik's living dark side to break free from the confinement Odion held him in.
Ehh it's decent but not my favorite. Yeah I get that they wanted to show that making fake egyptian god cards was not a good idea. But it resulted in making Joey look weaker than he actually was at that point, and it is not lost on me that this happens while Kaiba is present too. And the writers seemed to have had a habit of nerfing Joey whenever Kaiba was around to keep the status quo, it's the reason I don't like their first duel at all. The only real exceptions were his duels with Johnson and Marik. Kaiba was watching but Joey was performing how he should've at both duels. Point is the duel with Odion is a bit sloppy in how it got to where it wanted to by the end, it would've been much better for him to put up a fight the whole way through and push Odion to the point of using Ra ontop of his accusation that Odion was'nt really Marik.
Joey could've won if he played better with what he had.
@@Cloud-dt6xb I feel that it misses the point. The English dub has Joey more rude and dismissive even towards the end, but the original Japanese and the English manga establish that Joey really came to respect Odion during their duel. THAT'S how he knew it wasn't Marik, not just the vague feeling he had in English.
Even after he briefly wakes up after being knocked out by Ra he tells Joey it was an honor to duel him, and Joey returns the sentiment.
Unlike all the cheaters using underhanded tactics to win, Roba, Weevil, Marik, Pegasus, etc. Odion faced his opponents head on honestly.
Plot armor made Joey win, but I feel it really fits with the theme of the show that the one who came closest to winning against the heroes is one who played fair the whole time. In that regard it's not showing Joey as weak. It's showing that playing with honor is a strength and that he's basically a better duelist than his boss even without the magic and God cards.
there is also the marik vs bakura duel as i don't think he has done that one yet
I think the reason why Mai didn’t attack with her Harpies is because the anime/manga effect of Elegant Egotist makes the monsters summoned by it not able to attack the turn they’re summoned. The same applied when she used it back in Duelist Kingdom if you recall and I think she said so.
I thought I saw something about that, thanks for the info!
Luckily though Marik only had 1050lp left. So Mai could have won had she chosen not to use it and just attacked with the one Harpie Lady she already had on the field.
It actually doesn't have that negative effect. Maybe in DK it did but not for BC
Even if that were the case she had 3 monsters, Marik could only summon one monster at a time so he'd have to pull some serious BS out in order to survive and still win.
@@SuperSayianWarrior Right...in her VERY last duel, she used the card and immediately attacked with all three resultant monsters. That filler episode only further undermined her plays here.
They just needed to establish the damn shackles as untargetable...it would have been so damn simple...
@@TGSAnime She had a one epsiode duel versus a guy in love with her using ninja deck during this tournament, and she used "Élegant egotist". No restrictions on the first turn for harpie sister, she didn't attack because of plot 😉
14:00 Marik is not attacking because he knows Mai is gonna summon Ra, so he plans to take it back to inflict maximum pain.
Also interesting how all memories lost are people who appear in the series. It would have been very funny if some random people were forgotten.
Like the random bird Marik forgot in the abridged series
Or Miho from Season 0
@@emreekinci4258wait, no! Mr. Tweetums!
That’s what I think happens when she attacked her own monster it was just like a cashier somewhere she forgot
Also I'd just like to point out: after Mai's Joey memories were wiped, Yugi used the puzzle to help Mai overcome Marik's mental attacks
Which always made me mad why he didn’t do that earlier
@@kenganmmvs8615 don't forget it was "tension" between her and the group
Technically Odion, Mai, and Ishizu should’ve all won their duels. Imagine that battle city finals
Ishizu defeating Marik would have been a better story for sure.
@@danieltodorov7753agreed
Ishizu lost because she flat couldn't do anything outside of her gameplan.
Would have been interesting to have Ishizu vs Marik and Kaiba vs Mai over what we got. Yes the idea for Ishizu was for her to reclaim obelisk and use that as her sword, but it would have given her a bit more prominence than a Kaiba stepping stone. Plus you could introduce Yami Marik’s whole “Immortal god Phoenix” plan earlier with Ishizu choosing to destroy his deck to only find out that helps him as Marik wouldn’t use Ra that way
@@if7723i mean I understand that, she saw that if she plays these certain cards, she has a guaranteed win, her fault for over relying on ancient powers but also not her fault that Kaiba had mind armour
To be fair, if someone _had_ called Marik out regarding the language on the card, Kaiba would have just gone "I'll allow it".
It's funny how in this duel Marik lost his memories of Strings, however in dub when he summoned Revival Jam against Yugi, he reminds him that Yugi already encountered Revival Jam against Strings, although Marik should've forgotten that
Maybe since he won he got them back...? ...or it was always temporary and just intended to fu** with his opponent in the moment?
"Strings" was just a puppet body that Marik was using. Even if he forgot the specific person, he would still remember his own deck and duel moves.
@@live22morrow Well that and Marik's kind of known to rig the shadow games so they're far less harsh on him. Probably got the memories back when he won
@@live22morrow yeah, he could remember that duel, but Marik shouldn't have mentioned String's name in that sentence
Or maybe because he won the shadow game, all his memories are back? not sure haha!
20:23
Here's an interesting hypothetical to defend Mai's decision. Assuming Holding Arms' invincibility was actually three of Marik's turns, and thus Mai wouldn't be able to attack it with her Harpies, maybe she thought summoning Ra would bypass the invincibility? The God cards effects are infamously vague in the anime, so I don't think it'd be unreasonable for Mai to think Ra would be able to attack and destroy Holding Arms.
I doubt it.
Recall how Atem used the Slime Monster to block against Osiris/Slifer. Given the set-up with the Slime, even the Egyptian God card couldn't penetrate it.
Going back to your case, the same thing applies. The only difference is that the only thing keeping Holding Arms alive is its own effect. Not even Ra will penetrate it.
@@7swordquanta459 but it acted to the effect, it doesn't have piercing it just attacks your opponents monsters to reduce unless it destroys. That's what Slifer did. Ra should just obliterate.
@@7swordquanta459 thats because yugi took advantage of Slifers effect
Sadly Mai forgot to take the Ancient Egyptian Language Class so that she could summon Mega Ultra Chicken 😂
Shhh, he is legend.
@@Vile-MKII I'd love to see Megan Hollingshead react to this video!
@@Vile-MKII Who?
@@rainbowdragon168 The Voice Actor (I think?)
@@jay-stag Oh ok
Ah yes. The Duel that, while painful to watch, the original manga had an even darker alternative where duelists actually had the same damage that the monsters had (Basically the meant when say, Mai's Amazoness monster cuts the head off a monster with how the Duel Disk projected it, Marik's head actually falls off his body because he also took that damage. Yes, he lived, but he actually held his head Dullahan Style for a moment and it was metal as hell)
Gotta love how dark Yugioh was back when its original writer was doing it.
I actually do like that the anime chose not to repeat any of the shadow game rules. With Mai every time a monster is destroyed their memories of someone is erased. With Bakura each time they lose life points a portion of their bodies disappear. With Joey each time a monster is destroyed or weakened the owner feels its pain. With Atem each time they lose life points a portion of their soul partner is erased.
Also note that Marik’s duel with Bakura and Joey were the only duels where they were on an even playing field. With Mai and Atem Marik gave himself the advantage as he doesn’t care about any of his henchmen or his partner soul.
@@sonicgen20 Perhaps, but I feel like it does split things differently to tell the story. Marik in the manga was about physical harm the most and actively causing bodily damage, which stays consistent with his backstory when he chose to not just stab his Dad, but actively carve the Runes off his back and drop them onto Rishid's back, as well as in his Duels with Mai, Jounouchi and Atem, alongside the Penalty Game being not just sand that erases the memory, but actual parasites that eat your Soul while you watch your friends live on without you in Mai's Case, while the anime was more about causing psychological pain with Mai and Atem.
Weirdly enough Bakura was most tame out of both types, and the Dub's use of the Shadow Realm works better with how much of his focus in the anime is on psychological torment of his opponents before sending them to the Shadow Realm.
Also, the punishment Mai received from Marik was slightly different. Instead of an hourglass of sand that takes away Mai's memories... It's an hourglass of carnivorous insects. Likely Scarabs. *Edit* I just saw the above reply after commenting this.
I think, Mai summoning Ra isn't really a bad thing. It's a story point. She wants to prove herself to the others. If I remember correctly, Yugi even tries to give her advice when Marik plays his slime combo and she refuses it. So what better way to prove yourself than using an egyptian god card? Therefore, I think, it's fine, especially since there was no mention of ancient egyptian texts in the duel before (between Odion and Joey). Mai even references that duel when Marik asks her if she wants to play Ra with that rescue card and she says she understands that Ra would have 0 ATK then. So I think, overall, it shows her to be a good duelist while also giving you enough reason to understand why she did it.
Of course, you could add a few rules that just make it even more logical. Like for example, that Holding Arms is still invincible, but God Cards would be able to destroy it, to just name the easiest fix. But then again, I would also say it would make the story worse as Mai would have to use Ra. And the reason why Joey feels responsible for her being trapped is that he wasn't honest with her and therefore, Mai felt she had to prove herself in the first place.
I feel like for Joey to be erased I think maybe the winged dragon of Ra should’ve instead destroyed her ace which would be harpie lady, it would’ve hit that much harder imo, like for him to be erased with one of her monsters we never see again just feels insulting
but her ace is harpy drago
And this duel actually has one of my favorite scenes in the whole series, and that’s when Atem shielded Joey and Mai from Raw’s attack.
Dammit, Joey! What did I just tell you about being careful?
@@renatoramos8834 "Yes! Burn, Pharao! BURN!"
And apparently their school uniforms are fireproof!
AGREED 🤝
@@dockkid or it's just a virtual augmented reality instead of real fire
I no longer watch Yugioh but can’t describe the joy I get when I see videos in this series come out
This is really 1 of those duels that suffered from being brought from the manga to the anime. The purpose behind the Holding Arms play was that it would torture Amazoness Chain Master each turn, therefore torturing Mai, but that's completely lost when the whole Shadow Game has been changed (the duel itself was identical, except it started with The Unfriendly Amazon and Makyura, skipping the part where Marik uses the cards of his henchmen). Similarly, Grave Arm just painlessly pulls a monster down, so to keep its secondary purpose of avoiding the Shadow Game's rule they invented this rule of this not wiping out a memory (ironic how this only became inconsistent because they added the Dunames Dark Witch vs Unfriendly Amazon part to the duel). 1 more interesting thing to mention is that Harpie cards were lvl 5 in the manga, so Mai was waiting for something that would spring her Dramatic Rescue trap so she could bring out Cyber Harpie without tribute.
Also, I think the 3 turns invincibility counts Marik's Standby Phases just like how Viser Des does, and that The Winged Dragon of Ra bypasses this invincibility because of god card deus ex machina. Also, I think the talk about destroying Amazoness Chain Master within 3 turns is an inaccurate translation and he's actually talking about how Amazoness Fighter will be dying in 3 turns (in the context of being tortured by Holding Arms).
Nope, anime duels are always better.
@@danieltodorov7753 No they're not. Just take the ceremonial duel for example. In the manga Yugi was outplaying Atem at every point, showing just how much he'd grown, and how he deserved to be the king of games. In the manga Yugi and Atem both make a ton of stupid plays just so old ass monsters could be brought back because nostalgia, and Atem even had to encourage Yugi to keep going when Yugi became sad and dejected.
"1 more interesting thing to mention is that Harpie cards were lvl 5 in the manga"
This is so crazy to me, btw lol
They were on crack
You forget Yami Marik also lost the memories of Mr.Tweetums, his only Best Friend
Right? The worst mistake Mai has done. Probably things would be different if she didn't erased Mr. Tweetums
@@aksonnolasco4763
Marik lieklt would’ve showed Mercy if Mr.Tweetums wasn’t erased. He was just the cutest little guy!
Abridged
What I love about this duel is how Marik uses the same strategy that nearly broke Yugi (revival jam defender) only for Mai to defeat it with a simple Harpies Feather Duster. This is why you play backrow removal.
If Joey had some backrow wipers, he'd be much more of a threat
To be fair, Yugi has Mystical Space Typhoon and Dust Tornado. It’s just the plot didn’t allow him to draw them.
One thing I found most interesting with this duel and Joey’s duel against Odion: Joey manages to counter the Powers of the Shadow Realm. Combine that with Joey managing to fully throw off the Millenium Rod’s mind control effect, and you have a recipe for a great power within Joey. I do a bit more Headcanon in a fanfic I’m writing, but suffice it to say, Joey overcoming the Millenium Rod’s Power over erasing memories to have Mai actually remember him is something no one else has ever been able to do. Not even Yami. Yami managed to keep Mai in the duel after she lost her memory of Joey, but he couldn’t restore her memories. In season 1, the Puzzle managed to reverse the Ring’s effect and swapped Bakura with Yami Bakura, but not even Yami could undo Marik’s memory manipulation.
Joey is amazing in all sorts of ways, but he has the favor of the luck god to the point he can override a Millenium Item’s Power. That is a level of Awesome Kaiba can’t comprehend.
That's why I'd say Joey could have gained Ra's respect if he beat Marik. His deck is centered quite a bit on luck to get out strong monsters or to make some fights more in his favor. Ra's effects all require luck to get the most out of them especially when it comes to what monsters you use to summon it. Joey would have had the strongest version of Ra in BC
@@caiusdrakegaming8087 he does still need to read the ancient text. But since Jono exists in Forbidden Memories… that might be enough.
@@RedDragonForce2 Yugi would be able to help him with that, so not a big problem.
@@RedDragonForce2 I could see Jono just making it up on the spot, but because it's close enough to the text, Ra allows it. XD
@@caiusdrakegaming8087 true. Best friends and all that.
The thing I liked best about this duel is how in the beginning Mai destroys strategies previously used by marik’s minions so easily
With basic backrow destruction and trap countering
Marik’s goal wasn’t only to win, but to torture. The idea of prolonging the duel is to make his opponents suffer.
Pot of Greeds effect is so complex the even had to have the duel disk simplify it
Man, this duel has a lot of personality and life in the animation. Mai's movements have a lot of personality, like her activating Grave Hand, or Amazoness Spellcaster.
Even the Monster battle animations are great, like The Unfriendly Amazon doing a back flip through the air, and then swinging her blade to the side to kill Makyura.
Desgardus attaching to Dark witch and moving her to Marik’s side of the field. Fighter getting trapped by nightmare wheel..
Lot of posing and action moves yes.
Mai's movements, or her cards' effects?
@@Steveman27both, really. That graceful charity draw had some unique flair.
The episode is animated by Kagami, basically the best animator of Yugioh series.
Why does losing memories of someone = unable to see them?
Wouldn't it be like "who the hell is that?"
It's a shadow game. If the memories are lost in shadows, then you can't see them.
...
Yeah, I know it's stupid. I can't think of a better explanation for why they showed it that way.
Considering if I remember correctly this is the first time anyone has seen Marik duel I think it would make sense for her to not play her traps on her first turn so she doesn’t know how he’ll play and doesn’t want to potentially lose the traps, or potentially take up trap or slots that she might need.
I mean, by this point in the series we've already seen a card that destroys cards in hand, so that's not playing cautiously at all, it's choosing a different gamble and hoping it pays off.
@@dontmisunderstand6041 either way it’s a gamble
@@steampunkfox4932 Yeah, that's what strategy is. There's no strategy in any situation with a correct answer.
God card tunnel vision was Mai's detriment upon getting it since she had some knowledge of how Ra works from Joey/Jounouchi's duel with Odion/Reshid when he summoned the fake Ra card. Throughout the duel she was in control before the Game of darkness/Yami no Game/Shadow game which did off set her a bit but then she had a small reprieve thanks to Yugi and the Millennium Puzzle then she made a move that she shouldn't have made and its the very card Marik had that was a trap her taking Ra was the biggest misplay because its even shown in the Manga and anime when Mai stole Ra using her Chain Masters effect Marik was unfazed which is a red flag. Her summoning it was a mistake thinking it was her end game but its not because of the Hieratic Text which only appears when Ra is played. Had she just attacked with her Cyber Harpies or regular Harpie lady in the manga she would have won and Ra would have been hers and even if she stole through the chain masters effect and didn't summon it she would have it reguardless. Sadly she doesn't and the play she made ultimately is her own demise
If I remember correctly, in older rules, turn count used to be based per player, not in total. By that, I mean “turn 1” was both the first turn and the second turn, because it was turn 1 for each player, then turn 2 was third and fourth, etc. That’s at least what I remember from older yugioh games because it changed how Final Countdown worked.
also, it might work like how swords of revealing light works, except based on your turns over the opponent's
I want to see one of these where you say "Was {character} about to defeat {other character}? ... No, of course not." and then the Full House ending theme and credits roll.
Well, he did do “Was Weevil about to defeat Yugi?”
@@blazep629 YES!
I think it is worth noting that when Mai lost her memories of Tea from destroying Diane’s Dark Witch, she destroyed it by battle. But when she destroyed Amazon Chain Master it was via Grave Arm’s effect. That could explain why she kept her memories, since she was willing sacrificing her monster via a card effect. Same reason she didn’t lose any memories from tributing her Harpies to summon Ra.
Its really sad that this was the last time Mai does something relevant in-canon
Also, Marik did missplay with Mirror Wall since its established that, if set, spells in Battle City can be used as Quick Plays. And since he set it early on, he could have used Trap Removal and attacked sooner. It wouldn't have changed the end result but he would have secured his victory more confidently
Thats what happens when an anime writer writes an insert turn
He didn't set Tramp Removal.
To be fair, marik did infact give mai an accurate translation of the chant, but that's what gave ra back to him =P
Lesson of the day: You should be scared when TGS Anime wears the glasses. He is smarter than we can comprehened.
I love that despite all of these shenanigans, the Ref only stepped in and commented on Yugi setting a card without looking at it.
Well this is because Kaiba's in charge and any obejctions will be met with "But I want the god cards soo I don't care"
@@Cloud-dt6xbyes the law of being a petty dick.
Mai's strategy of going into this with Chain Master was such a good idea. imagine her dueling like this in Battle City and stealing Obelisk or Blue-Eyes or Dark Magician for the win; but, no. She unlucky ran into a card that was theft-proof. Shame, really.
However, Gods can be controlled by worthy people with relations to Ancient Egypt, which Mai isn't. So it's safe to assume that stealing Slifer and Obelisk to use is like firing a jammed gun. And as we saw with Joey, stealing a BEWD against Kaiba won't do much against him.
@roncerjani9063 hey, stealing one of Kaiba's Blue Eyes and using it against him does plenty!
Specifically, it majorly pisses him off like very little else can lmao
@@gothicbutterfly013 I'd pay good money to see an animated duel between Mai and Kaiba in which at one point, perhaps as her winning play, she uses the same trick she used on Marik to steal his Winged Dragon of Ra and steals one of Kaiba's Blue Eyes White Dragon and uses it to either gain a massive advantage over Kaiba, backing him into a corner, or perhaps even straight up winning the duel because of it.
In the latter outcome, nothing would piss him off more than a move like that lmao. His pride would be beaten down.
I like to imagine this duel ending in Marik's disqualification.
"Ref! Marik's card isn't in Japanese!"
"Marik Ishtar! Please provide a translation reference!"
"I don't have a translation reference."
"Well, you're disqualified then."
"Shadow Games dont have disquali-!"
*Shadows start slowly dragging Marik away.*
What the F - Abridged Marik
Can we admit that Joey and Yugi are great people considering they took an attack from a GOD! And they did it with no hesistation.
Marik really is the king of "Could X have won", isn't he? so many dubious fights.
Could we have shun vs sora? They have two complete duels, with pretty complex plays that can be entertaining to analyze
This is not even a question, from a normal dueling rules perspective Mai should have had Ra and win BUT the fact that not only she couldn't use Ra but MARIK was allowed to despite Mai summoning it made her lose. How could have she know such a bullshit would happen ?
It's called plot armor...
Plot armor
If we go by normal dueling rules, ra is actually the one god card whos text, as it was translated by Kaiba, was most closely followed. Yes the effect had not appeared before that duel but it was followed through the manga - and the parts of the anime adapted from it - quite closely.
Saint Dragon - The God of Osiris, I'm reading their manga versions to get the effects and that includes the names, however stated only that X is the number of cards in the players hand. And: When the opponent summons a creature , the point of the player's card is cut by 2000 points. - Nothing about destroying it if it goes down to or below 0.
The God of Obelisk has probably the most space for misunderstanding: "The player shall sacrifice two bodies to the God of Obelisk" is so far so clear, though it does not specify if those "bodies" must be on their field or if they can discard monsters from their hand or I mean with how the characters act especially in shadow games just murder 2 bystanders, and "The opponent shall be damaged" has similar concerns and additionally even when assuming it only applies to ingame damage it does not specify any amount (It is appearantly 4000 wich is equal to a direct attack by Obelisk), "And the monsters on the field shall be destroyed" at least specify that it does mean the field, and only in game objects finally, but whos monsters and how many and no part of that includes gaining infinite ATK for a Turn.
The Sun of God Dragon in its first line does mention "[...] However God shall only follow those who offer the ancient incantation to the heavens." so saying that the first player who says the text in their turn gets control of it sounds like a comparatively reasonable conclusion.
And Kaiba had translated and spoiled the other 2 effects in the original before they were used, he just didn't feel like sharing with the rest of the class.
It's also worth noting that even though Ra doesn't respond to Mai, it should still be considered "summoned to her field".
Well if you consider that it didn't have stats and wasn't going to stop a direct attack it was apparently not treated as a monster on her field.
So it would either be considered a non monster card like a backrow crystal beast or not on either players SIDE of the field, in either case it would cause a rules nightmare if after its summon a player got to 5 on field monsters and then read its effect.
knowing Kaiba with the foreign language thing he'd put the responsibility on the duellist to know the language 😂
19:03 I think in defense to Marik here, Pegasus wasn’t able to finish translating all 3 Egyptian god cards because his people kept vanishing. Therefore I assume he simply had to leave the card text in its original script and created the effect over it? That or the Winged Dragon of Ra itself did that. Either way, there exists no translation for it because it’s the only copy
No, they straight up say Pegasus couldn't decypher the text and copied whatever was written there
@@igorlopes8463 yeah, that’s what I said? The effect of it not being visible was what I was saying may have been done by Ra
The duplicate draw at 6:01 could be intentional for a commercial break. Cut after Marik gets the monster and reestablish Mais turn with her Draw step.
Just a hunch though, any thoughts?
I think the whole “lose memories when monster is destroyed” is meant for if the monster is destroyed in battle. Given Mai destroyed her dark witch in battle vs using a card effect for her chain master.
I swear that was actually addressed in the dub, but it’s been a while so it might just be a phantom memory
@@dogboyton3166 that’s where I think I heard it from. But it’s been a long time since I watched Yugioh and if that’s the case. Point for the dub for fixing a mistake the sub did.
This duel was the start of Marik’s reign of terror and where things got way out of hand. Just when Yugi and the gang thought they had Marik figured out he goes and becomes twenty times more evil than he was before. Like I said in a previous video the last quarter final pairings should’ve been Ishizu vs Marik and Mai vs Kaiba. Not only would the former be the first sibling battle we’d get instead of Chazz vs Slade in GX but even if Mai lost to rich boy at least she would be able to watch the rest of the finals from the sidelines instead of being trapped in the Shadow Realm. Plus even if Ishizu lost to her brother’s dark side she would be safe from his wrath thanks to her Millennium Necklace.
Mai flew too close to the sun, and her wings were destroyed.
I would have loved it if this duel played out as such:
Mai wouldn't have particularly cared much about losing her memories of her friends at first because she doesn't believe she has any close bonds with them. Destroying Dunames Dark Witch would have made her lose her memories of Téa, which she would notice but not take too seriously at first. She would however make a note that there's no way she could forget about Teá because she dueled her in Duelist Kingdom to get Yugi out of his slump after his duel with Kaiba, but she'd be unable to properly recall the moment.
After Marik destroys Unfriendly Amazon with Makyura, it'd be here where she'd lose her memories of Yugi instead of Joey. She'd begin denying it because the two of them dueled in the Duelist Kingdon finals and promised to duel again afterwards, but she'd be unable to remember that moment as well. It would be at this point that she'd become a bit scared and would understand the gravity of the situation.
It would then only be after Mai's Grave Arm destroys Chain Master that she'd lose her memories of Joey, the only person she genuinely cares about. She'd then go into a panic mode, which Marik would notice and decide to capitalize upon. He would then use the Millennium Rod to manifest a fake memory of Joey in Mai's mind and convince her to use Chain Master's effect to steal Ra from Marik.
The duel would then continue as normal until Mai uses Elegant Egotist to get her three Harpie Lady cards out. Mai would then realize that she would win if she attacked Marik now, but would be hesitant because of Marik's face-down cards and the fear of losing all three of her Harpie Lady cards and in turn her memories of three other people (it would also be a nice reference to her duel with Yugi in Duelist Kingdom where she surrendered before her Harpies could be destroyed). In her moment of hesitation, Marik would use the fake memory of Joey again to tell Mai to summon Ra to the field, because it would allow her to protect her monsters from being destroyed and win her the game.
Mai would summon the disobedient Ra and Marik would reveal that he tricked Mai into doing this, steal Ra and win the game. I feel like this ending to the duel would help justify Mai's actions a bit and would be a sad, if poetic, end to her time in Battle City.
Marik doesn't go for the early win when he has the chance because he is not interested in that he wants to play with his food, slowly tormenting people with both the shadow game and the actual game and wear them down before he summons ra for the big finisher.
He often has chances he could go for early wins and that is just never something he's interested in.
It's not exactly the most meta play style, but it fits his role as a big bad very nicely.
Canonically, Yami Marik isn't much of a duelist. He's a sadist spirit first and foremost, and it influences his play. A common trend in his duels is him having game on board without finishing the job, because he wants the shadow game to take it's toll. He realizes his own stupidity in dragging it out during the semi-finals vs Joey (who severely outplayed him), but his *strategy* ends up working out in the end due to the fact that he essentially gives Joey a near heart-attack from all the mental and bodily stress the shadow game inflicts on him. It's a neat touch that both the sub and dub manage to translate well.
Forget Pot of Greed, who knows what Holding Arms does!
Nah. The real mystery is Negate Attack
And Holding Legs 🦵 🦵
Pretty sure Holding Arms attaches itself to an opponent's monster and prevents them from attacking as well as prevents Holding Arms from being attacked as long as the monster being trapped by Holding Arms is on the field.
If Holding Arms and Holding Legs are both real cards, then if you play duel monsters with someone and you put them in play, what are they supposed to do?
@@Steveman27 get chained to the tablet if udjat. Didn't you see those secret effects?
Fun fact about the Wing Dragon of Ra he does have visible card text. The card text is shown to only those who have connection to the ancient scriptures for example Yami, Kabia, and Marik can see the “invisible ancient scriptures” on Ra. Mai has no connection to the the ancient scriptures so therefore she can’t see or read the text to summon Ra
15:40
Gotta love those situational traps that would never work in real life lol
Fun fact, Card of Last Will is an actual trap in real life, came out in I believe a Legendary Collection set, it though has the Match Winner YCS clause of cannot be use in a duel written on it
Card of last will would be broken, given that the print card mention when the attack of one of your monster become 0, meaning you Can activate it after you reduce the attack yourself.
I find it funny that Marik like....Loses every duel but only wins because of shenanigans
19:36 This would only matter if these weren't the only versions of the cards in-universe, and that there are implications that the card game is played worldwide and there's no requirement for language to match. On top of this, Pegaus owns the IP in-universe, and if he says the cards are officially part of the game, they're part of the game.
_Even further on top of this, Seto Kaiba is the person running the tournament, and he personally legalized the God Cards for its use._
Would be funny if Kaiba came up and was like "woah woah woah, that card has a SECRET effect? Yeah it's banned from my tournament."
Save the world via DQ.
Do note that we do know that Kaiba banned/limited many cards, like Raigeki, so this is canonically how the tournament is set up.
7:19 nice parrallel between Panter Warrior and Unfriendly Amazon, both 2000 ATK
the former requires 1 tribute to attack
the latter requires 1 tribute as maintainence
it is fitting Joey's memory is within that card
i love how you left out the part where yugi took a blast from RA and survived
May I suggest a bunch of duels that I would love to see analyzed?
- Odion vs Joey
- Yubel/Jesse vs Adrian Gecko
- Yusei vs Kalin Kessler (rematch during Dark Signers arc and crash town duel)
- Any duel the protagonist lost, especially Yuya vs Jack Atlas
- Maybe some more Yu-boys and bracelet girls?
Is it just me or do they really need to do another series with the original cast members like I’d love to see yugi and joey battleing todays cards
Wow. The depth, detail and little tidbits here and there. Thank you for doing this. Nostalgia galore. Very much earned 👍🏻 & sub
This always botherd me about mai, she was always put in situations where she had to lose otherwise the show would be over, the fact that her only on screen wins were the one filler episode against that actor and joey in the orichalcos arc where the latter could barely stand says something, at least she won against tea (yes I consider that a win for her if only on a moral level) she deserved better
against tea/anzu mai lost on purpose. I feel it's similar to yugi surrendering to Rebecca in the filler episode
@@alexandercharizard3617 I know, some people just say those wins are actuall wins, it just depends on you look at it
Aoi Zaizen knows her pain.
Mai had a pretty good deck by DM standards. I dunno if she could beat Odion, but I'd still rank her ahead of everyone else in the finals except Yugi and Kaiba.
Didn't she also Beat Rex while on the boat?no wait..that was due to perfume cheating
0:46 those zoommies were totally necessary to captivate the insensitivity of the battle ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
I remember watching this episode so many times and saying please don’t sacrifice the harpy lady sisters all you have to do is attack directly and you win
Saaaaame 😂😂😂 Used to not even finish the duel, and stop at that iconic invocation of harpie sisters.
"End your turn Jean!"
I love tbe fact that holding harm effect was so confusing they just trow away the "3 turns" clause when the card was made real
I want you to analyse more recent duels again, like Yuya vs Declen/Reiji or Soulburner vs Revolver
I like this duel because of the character growth for Mai and Ra. She’s committed to playing fairly and has shown she has thrown away her old cheating playstyle. We saw a bit of that in DK but that could be explained that because Pegasus was watching, she decided not to cheat. However, she still has a major flaw, Pride. She deliberately summoned Ra to flex on Marik for making her suffer throughout the duel. But that was the point. Marik knew as soon as she stole the card, she would use it. It’s also why he punishes her by having Arms and Legs attack directly before Ra does. Later on in the Waking the Dragons arc, this duel is the whole reason she joined up with Dartz.
I like how Marik plays some cards from duelists that were on his side.
The slime monster are originally his and masked beast is probably just a side ace for him
I thought that too, but then that idea of the rare hunters came to my mind when was rewatching one day years ago, and I was like “Oh right. They copy and print cards, so he might have been the one to give them such monsters”
This is one of those times in Yu-Gi-Oh when the cards being magic means they sometimes don't or won't do anything, like the time Yami Yugi/Atem couldn't use his Legendary Dragon card against Weevil because it was mad about him using the Seal of Orichalcos. On a separate note, it would've been very funny if the referee had shouted "Hold it! According to tournament rules, you need to provide an accurate translation when using foreign langue cards!", even if it would prevent Marik from dueling Yugi because he would be forced to give Mai complete control of Ra and cause him to lose either by attacking into Holding Arms or by one of Ra's 15 effects.
plot twist: mai pull's out her phone and uses google translate
Smart phones weren’t created yet
Funny enough, when a real world version of The Winged Dragon of Ra Sphere mode was released, your able to summon it to your opponents field by tributing three monsters and during the end phase, changes controller of the card.
So if Mai didn't try and flex on Marik and everyone else, she could have won. Damn.
I THINK Egotist prevents the monsters attacking that turn in the manga, which is why she did what she did. (It's hard to tell if it did that beyond Duelist Kingdom since the text never mentioned it.) It definitely didn't prevent them from attacking in the anime (we see that against Jean-Claude), but that could just be manga meddling, which happens on occasion. Viser Des was also still immune in the manga I believe. So yeah, this is all probably because of how things worked in the manga, regardless of if they would have in the anime.
Marik really should have lost every duel he was in but because he made them all shadow games and was more focused on torturing his opponents then winning the duel he was able to make it to the finals. I have him as a B class duelist that could have been an A or S if he was more focused on his dueling
Also he was allowed to use banned cards. Ever notice how no one used cards like raigeki? Effect damage cards and board wipes aren't allowed, but Marik used them and Kaiba allowed it due to Marik having Ra
@@Mavuika_Gyaru what cards did he use that are considered banned? I know monster reborn is limited or is it banned again?
@@kevinreilly7924 cards like Lava Golem are banned by battle city rules
@@Mavuika_Gyaru ah okay I was going by actual cards in real life. Didn’t know that he actually said it was banned
I’m so happy to see this one! I actually requested this one a while back but thought it wouldn’t since someone reminded me of certain parts I forgot about, but man it feels good knowing that I was right that Mai could’ve won without Ra. Thanks for looking into this duel. 😁
As for another duel I’d like to see you look at, could you possibly take a look at Yuma & Astral vs Nash (Shark)? It’s where Nash used CXyz Barian Hope, and I noticed that he never used his own Barian Number monster’s effect while Hope was out (it used all the other Barian Numbers’ effects but not Silent Honor Dark), and Silent Honor lets him turn one opponent’s monster into an overlay unit. Should he have won, or was there some effect preventing him from doing this play?
I wanna see Playmaker vs Revolver next
Revolver has violins on his side.
Very interesting analysis in this one, TGS. It does kind of feel like Mai got a little screwed here because of Ra’s unique summoning condition she knew nothing about. But really, she should’ve just sent her Harpie’s in to shred Marik’s life points.
Not sure what duel you have planned for analysis next, but I think Alexis versus Jayden in the two-parter Heart of Ice from season 2 of GX could be worth a look. Alexis had Jayden in some really bad spots in that duel. Could she have won or was Jayden always destined for victory?
If Mai just used 3 of her Harpie Ladies without using Ra, she would have won that duel against Marik
That’s what I said
No, because of the restriction of Elegant egotist. The harpies could not attack on the same turn elegant egotist is played.
@@a.jperez202Cyber Harpie could still attack Holding Arms
@@roninwarriorsfan Assuming elegant egotist wasn't played, sure. It wouldn't have done any good though. TGS is wrong. It still had its invincibility on that turn, and for one more as well.
@@a.jperez202 the literal duel earlier vs Zean Claude Magnum she does Egotist into attacking
A huge plot twist would be if the Pharaoh started chanting in the background
Mai could’ve just attacked marik directly with her 3 cyber harpies and she would’ve won the duel, so stupid 😤
Marik should have lost to Mai and Joey both but didn't because of bs plot armor
It's not her being stupid, it's the show having her lose for the sake of plot.
@@hadrianhexe9603 you’re right, plus NO one would miss the chance to use an Egyptian god card, wish she could’ve finished marik with it
Apparently in the manga, marik had a lot more life points than mai. That’s why she stole Ra and tried to summon it
please make more of these! i would watch a breakdown of any battle city duel tbh
All that I learned from this was that it would have been smarter to keep Marik away from his God card. Either keep it in your hand or remove it from play. Just don't use it or send it to the graveyard.
This guy is my favorite Yugioh content creator, hands down. His analysis of duels especially the og Duels, are so fun to watch. Especially since I love "what if" scenario's. But there is 1 duel he needs to do...
Yugi and Kaiba vs Lumis and Umbra, The 1st time they dueled. 😂 I'd love to see his genuine thoughts and reactions to how bs that opening turn was. Plus, it'd be a quick one for him to do!
i find it funny, Marik basicly coulda lost in like every single duel he was in if his opponants where not A) Scared AF of him and play passively or B) Where not egotisticol and just gone for game when they coulda done it
That second one is marik’s biggest flaw
15:35
Bro literally peeked at his deck 😅
A few things to observe:
1)The memory loss was not permanent, otherwise it's a total plothole that Mai remembered Tea and Joey
2)I knew Mai could have won this duel if she had just attacked with the haripes, but didn't expect she needed only one
3)In the manga, the duel is a bit diferent, Marik had 3600 LP, and Mai summoned regular harpy with 1300. On Marik's field, he had Viser Des, with 500 atack points and the same invencibility effect , but still on going. Summoning the 3 harpies make her have 3 monster with 1300 attack points, even if she had attacked, she would have caused 1300-500=800 x 3 = 2400 an Marik would still be in the game. She would still not have won if she had summoned Ra, but still it's a matter of weighting quantity against power
4)Basically, both Mai and Joey could have won their duels against Marik, which means he basicaly won because he had villain plot armor
Really wish Yugioh had a “What If” style mini show with different potential ideas for how mainline events could’ve gone.
Such as;
Kaiba beats Pegasus S1 and gets the Eye but is corrupted by it, create a new monster in a Millenium aesthetic Blue Eyes.
Of course Joey beating Marik and we get Ra versions of Red Eyes, Gearfried and Time Wizard.
Mai beating marik, same principle as Joey.
And on and on.
Additionally a concept i think would’ve been cool to explore is that, without mind control bullshit, marik is kinda bad a dueling. So the powers of Ra and the Rod go to Mai, then Joey, then Kaiba, then back to marik for the final duel with yugi/Yami but it’s a multi duel with Atem and Yugi plus Joey and Kaiba vs Marik and Bakura.
Feels good to see you drop something, you're a must see to me now !
I do love how Sphere Mode was born from this into a card.
Brightened my day with anither dual analysis. Thanks
9:41 "However, looking closer at what Marik says, it also seems to imply that this monster can't be attacked for next three turns."
Teeeeechnically he just says that it possesses an effect which for three turns makes it unaffected by opponents' attacks. Whether it's merely indestructible or is also untargetable isn't really relevant, but it's best not to treat whichever subtitles are available as gospel and to keep in mind that they may not be totally reliable for this kind of precise nuance, either because they have errors or simply because the editor decided, quite understandably imo, to have Marik declare the effective outcome in a way that might be unintentionally confused for an exact description of the monster's ability.
Someone should make an edit version of the duel where Mai does somehow know the Egyptian language, recite the chant, summon Ra and attack for game. It would be hilarious.
I think it can be done through AI imitation of voices
The "Holding Arms" shenanigans comes from adapting the manga: in the original, Marik summons Viser Des instead, which can't be destroyed for three of the turns of whoever the player was when it was summoned and, like Rocket Warrior, the monsters it attacks lose 500 ATK and cannot be tributed, but in this case Viser Des can also attack during the opponent's Battle Phase (Marik uses Viser and not Plasma Eel against Joey too); in addition, manga rules imply that prevention from destruction in battle also prevents any battle damage, but if Viser Des is already targetting a monster and the controller doesn't have other monsters on the field, it cannot protect him from a direct attack.
I believe for certain Mai overextended. There was no need to summon Ra. She would have won by simply keeping it in her hand and away from Marik. But of course, plot.
Not just in yugioh, many anime girls can't catch a break!
@@tarikkash4282The Inner Senshi in Sailor Moon Crystal/Eternal/Cosmos...
@@minicle426I don't watch Sailor moon!
@@minicle426 That's a quite bad example though, cause Sailor Moon is still full of anime girls who succeed.
I love this duel, great coverage, I always watch and love this series.
I must say that I totally disagree with the Holding Arms take though.
3 Turns of "invincibility" comes across like with Swords of Revealing Light, so I don't think she could attack so soon.
If that's the case, then Summoning Ra would be the superior play, ending your turn with Ra as apposed to the 3 Harpies.
She probably felt that Summoning Ra would be a game winning move, and that Ra may have an ability to take out the Holding Arms card as a bonus, guaranteeing a victory that turn.
That's how I interpreted it anyways, much love, great video 🤠
Honestly I used to think Marik was a great villain. However after watching this video, it’s clear that the only reason he survived as long as he did, was because the plot needed him to. Both Mai and Joey outdueled him and I really don’t like it when an antagonist is saved only so that there could be a story. Excellent video as always! For future suggestions here’s a few:
Atem and Kaiba vs Lumis and Umbra
Aster Phoenix vs Adrian Gecko
Aster Phoenix vs Jaden (round 2)
Jaden vs Darkness (Season 4)
Yuma and Nash vs Don Thousand
10000 out of 10 😇😇😇
Nah, it was because the anime made Mai and Joey performed better. In the manga, Marik completely stomped Mai and Joey only had a chance because he pulled Gilford out of nowhere.
@@Ramona122003 I’ll be honest when it comes to the Manga I’ve only read the Dawn of the Duel Arc so thanks for the heads up. Was completely unaware of that. 😇
@@Ramona122003 That doesn't make Anime Marik any better bro, and they've done Mai dirty enough in the anime anyway.
Never mind that The Winged Dragon of Ra has 3 forms, with 1 that DEFINITELY does not match the card Mai used
The text on the Winged Dragon of Ra - Sphere Mode (which is what Mai has and is MILES different from the Winged Dragon of Ra's monster card) reads:
"Cannot be Special Summoned. Requires 3 Tributes from either side of the field to Normal Summon to that side of the field (cannot be Normal Set), then shift control to this card's owner during the End Phase of the next turn. "Cannot attack. Your opponent cannot target this card for attacks or by card effects. You can Tribute this card; Special Summon 1 "The Winged Dragon of Ra" from your hand or Deck, ignoring its Summoning conditions, and if you do, its ATK/DEF become 4000."
Yes, Marik could be right and Mai could have a brick, BUT it CAN'T be targeted for attacks or destroyed by card effects, meaning Marik could throw a top-tier monster at it and Ra, even in its Sphere Mode, would've been "bruh, NO."
Shenanigans, YES.
Honestly Marik should've lost to joey. But honestly if Mai won here that would've been hilarious. Just imagine the shit talk Kaiba would've came up with.
One thing to point out is that Yami Marik's memory loss trick was only temporary.
In his duel against Yami Yugi, he summons Revival Jam and flashbacks to the moment when Yami Yugi first faced that monster against Strings.
Please Do Joey Vs Weavel and Joey Vs Mako next time
@ 13:45
Card effect destruction compared to battle destruction. That may be the nuance here.