Why Ta-Nehisi Coates's "The Message" Is So Wrong on Palestine | ARI Bookshelf

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 47

  • @Mr.Witness
    @Mr.Witness 18 дней назад +7

    First, on another awesome addition to this series. I standby it being ARI’s best content idea in a while! Excited to see more episodes.

  • @zardozcys2912
    @zardozcys2912 18 дней назад +2

    This is great application of Objectivism to real life and shows how important philosophy is to living a good life. Thanks for this.

  • @Luke-lb2cv
    @Luke-lb2cv 18 дней назад +4

    I love this ARI bookshelf series! Great new video!

  • @GeorgeMlll
    @GeorgeMlll 17 дней назад +1

    Was he wrong too?...Ta- Nehisi is in good company

  • @GeorgeMlll
    @GeorgeMlll 17 дней назад

    Father of cultral Zionism Ahad Ha'am in 1910" They treat the Arabs with hostility and cruelty, deprive them of their rights, offend them without cause..boast of these deeds;

  • @greenvelvet
    @greenvelvet 11 дней назад +1

    Ideologues like coats? 🤣🤣 Apartheid is a part-time. You either think it's wrong or you don't.
    There is no middle ground for a ethnic state where people are kept on a tier system based on their ethnicity

    • @t-townfoxtrot5181
      @t-townfoxtrot5181 10 дней назад

      Who is Mansour Abbas?

    • @jmagaram
      @jmagaram 7 дней назад

      Go to Israel. It’s not apartheid in any way. 20% Muslim, Christian, Druze with equal rights. The Palestinians in the West Bank have their own government. Gaza had Hamas. Anyway all these Israel haters can’t answer a basic question. Where should the Jews have gone to find safety after persecution throughout Europe and up to the Holocaust? Have you noticed that all the Arab countries and Iran pushed out the Jews since 1948? Jews need self determination in their own country because antisemitism is a real thing.

  • @edbonz2
    @edbonz2 18 дней назад +5

    Excellent analysis and podcast. Nihilism is evil. So glad we expose this evil. May our brave police surveil this hater and his colluders. Reason matters in America. TY ARI

    • @greenvelvet
      @greenvelvet 11 дней назад +2

      😂😂 people who expose the truth are always called haters and "terrorists" and every word in the book..
      Run coward your lies have been exposed to the world

    • @greenvelvet
      @greenvelvet 11 дней назад

      Have you ever wondered why the international court of justice is issuing arrest warrants for Netanyahu?
      How the international criminal court has deemed as a genocide plain and simple.
      How can you justify the MURDER of UN workers, ambulance drivers, nurses, doctors,

  • @alexjohnson9630
    @alexjohnson9630 16 дней назад +1

    Thank you for your insight.

    • @greenvelvet
      @greenvelvet 11 дней назад

      Pure propaganda. Israel is just a proxy State for the military-industrial complex in the Middle East.
      Anybody can see that with their own eyes

  • @cristianflorin5970
    @cristianflorin5970 18 дней назад +4

    I think the CBS interview is enough to know what type of person this guy is.

    • @greenvelvet
      @greenvelvet 11 дней назад

      Kamala Harris lost 15 million Democratic voters, partly because of the genocide they are arming and funding. Nobody thinks this cause is righteous in any way whatsoever except the unhinged barbaric zios.
      AMERICANS DON'T WANT THEIR TAX DOLLARS BEING SENT TO ISRAEL

  • @rfwilliams9
    @rfwilliams9 9 дней назад +1

    It is true that US media does not give a Palestinian of view point..What is the difference between the Zionist and Hamas. You guys are unbelievable.The American Jews I know are nationalist too. It is not unusual, all cultures, promote their own group, nationality. Mr. Coates, I think did a great thing. We are having discussions and disagreements and hopeful we will come to some solutions---a peaceful one.

  • @rfwilliams9
    @rfwilliams9 9 дней назад

    Israel does exist. They are militarily equiped to defend themselves.

  • @fate91583
    @fate91583 9 дней назад

    Very interested on the opinion of the cranky think tank of the worst philosopher of the previous century.

  • @user-tk1lf5hi6f
    @user-tk1lf5hi6f 3 дня назад

    Quislings

  • @skylinerj3
    @skylinerj3 17 дней назад +5

    Morally egregious???😂😂😂. How many Palestinian voices have we heard in the last 20 years? Voices like yours are all over the media? But Palestinian voices are constantly silenced. We overlook what the impact of what Israel does but constantly inflate the impact of Hamas and the PLO and conflating that with the Palestinians. Are all Palestinians guilty?

    • @thevillageyid
      @thevillageyid 17 дней назад +6

      Name 3 Palestinians peace movements and their leaders. And I mean actual peace with Israel still present.

    • @jmagaram
      @jmagaram 17 дней назад +4

      About conflating Hamas and the Palestinians, a week ago the PLO issued a statement mourning the death of their "great leader Sinwar". Among the worldwide protests you just won't find pro-Palestinian anti-Hamas voices, although that is the moral and practical position.

    • @talihershkovitz689
      @talihershkovitz689 16 дней назад +8

      Unlike Iranians and Israelis (like myself) who constantly and vocally object their governments, Palestinians supports theirs. I am not for collective punishment and I also think Israel doesn’t always have the higher moral ground. However, Israeli society does allow different voices. You have academics who openly criticize the government and write different kinds of histories. Gaza had 12 universities, which Israel sadly destroyed but ask yourself, how come no voice that criticizes Hamas came out of those institutions . I am sorry but it’s weird…
      Now, I can concede that Palestinians are living under an oppressive government and are not free, but it’s not Israel preventing them from voicing dissent so then why not support Israel in its mission to destroy Hamas? You can criticize the approach, the means Israel is using to do so, but why not support the overall goal? And if you think it’s an impossible mission (which I do) why not offer a better solution? I cannot but I am not going to tell fellow Israelis to live next to a genocidal regime. Especially since I myself am living in the safety of the U.S. (however temporary it may be).

    • @RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla
      @RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla 16 дней назад +1

      Palestine, a dream that the "invaders" gave up themsleves 5 times but blame others for their failure

    • @adv_jaco7883
      @adv_jaco7883 15 дней назад +1

      The common Palestinian voice on the streets in the West Bank is against Israel. They say it's their land. Jews have to go back to Europe they say. There's a Canadian in RUclips that does interviews in the West Bank and Israel to capture people's voices. Check it out

  • @patharvard
    @patharvard 17 дней назад +2

    Coates provides an accurate picture of Palestine and is deeply committed to the truth.

    • @lostcauselancer333
      @lostcauselancer333 13 дней назад +2

      And other hilarious jokes to tell yourself

    • @greenvelvet
      @greenvelvet 11 дней назад

      ​@@lostcauselancer333the world can see for itself with the monstrosity and barbarism the Israelis are doing to the palestinians. People like you don't have a leg to stand on

    • @t-townfoxtrot5181
      @t-townfoxtrot5181 10 дней назад

      @@greenvelvet45k Palestinians killed since Oct 23. 60k born. Hamas wanted more martyrs than that. The population increase was slower this year though. I guess if you really want you can call that genocide. But clearly you don’t know the origins of the word. And if you do, you’re bad at math and English.