Salaryman Reincarnated As A Cruel Tiny Girl In An Alternate WWI
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 апр 2022
- A girl with blond hair, blue eyes, and porcelain skin fights on the front lines of a brutal war and climbs the ranks of the imperial army.
Anime Name: Saga of Tanya the Evil 
Развлечения
The fact that she does all that just to spite god is amazing.
Shes reaching DOOMGUY levels of spite here
True lolz
No she doesn't.
Is English your second language, or did you just not pay attention.
There are no gods, that is mere superstition, and the salary-man ASSERTS THIS TRUTH, and does what he does because he is aware some malevolent being, being X, has done something to him.
And he is doing what he can to resist that beings malevolent machinations.
"God." No. God wouldn't incarnate you.
@@uncletiggermclaren7592 In anime? I wouldn't doubt that it's probably some alien pulling the strings. Real life is a different story, however.
Sorry.
The manga is better in some ways; the fired worker is actually a drug addict refusing rehab on the company's dime. Further Tanya is less 'brutal rational efficiency' and more 'traumatised from brutality of war and desperately trying to Do This Right so they get shifted to a rear echelon desk job'. The anime definitely makes Tanya more of an unrepentant psycho.
The funny thing is that the manga was not liked by the author for its artwork and it got lukewarm reception among the Japanese fandom, with a common review saying the animal art seemed suspiciously like attempts to be lazy. Both the author and much of the Japanese LN fans prefer both the LN and the anime to the manga. The author warmed up the manga not because he felt it got better, but because he saw the English sales and he gets a royalty.
Ironically as the previous comment said. It's true but If you see the Light novel version of the art It's amazing but in the manga is okay, there are same panel that is amazing and there's some that.... Yeah, It's cluster, But It is different on scans doe. Scene I don't have the physical copy I can't really comment the actual quality. so take it as a grain of salt.
@@alex_zetsu I mean, I guess extra royalties would make me find some appreciation for the redheaded step child of my work as well.
@@sylonogwailou Yeah, think of the positives!
The manga art is still better than the anime, despite the reasoning for the anime looking like that which didn't even work
I cant get over how Tanya's future rival is named "Mary Sue". It's great! A character written in such a way that the story is twisted just to glorify them. What better way to write such a character in a way that fits into the narrative than to have "god" assert his influence to do exactly that?
1 mol is still tier 0 entity relative to fiction. looks down at all.
@@1mol831 what?
That Mary Sue is a literal idiot. Yet thanks to being X she becomes nearly unkillable and overpowered to be a hardcounter to Tanya. Resulting in more deaths among her allies then enemies. Yet she is treated well and liked, almost by everyone. In the end i think she is going to be called a Hero.
Mary Sue is not a Mary Sue tho... She is blessed and therefor possesses very high magical capabilities but is also quite naive and everything but a "good soldier" almost driving her superior insane (especially in the LN) as she lacks the ability to understand her allies or why it is important to follow orders
Ngl i shocked god did 't just give mary sue the best aim bot
“Sir! They can fly!”
“You mean they’re using zero cover?”
“Yes…..”
“Get the anti-air cannons.” 🔥
Fr tho, forget about flak gun, even heavy mg should swat them out of sky clean
@@aimanasyraf5657 Idk, nobody goes hunting with a machine guns because it’s harder to hit a target like that than you’d expect. Flak guns make crowds of shrapnel, and at low altitudes a shotgun works great too.
@@FurryEskimo flak cant really catch up with tiny sized flying human. Mg is portable enough and can be carried in 3 man squad
@@aimanasyraf5657 You don’t need to catch them, you just need to be in range of one another. You’d playing defense, so you have the advantage or having permanent defensive structures, so those should be a lot more powerful than the Handheld weapons a human can cry while Flying.
@Aluzky Airplanes can fire far faster than a human, and would be more agile, but we still manage to hit them. Armor is also a thing, but a human really shouldn’t have the kind of power on hand as the ground forces usually. Going Higher also isn’t always better, as the air would be thinner (requiring heavy equipment to maintain consciousness) and the friction of the air on your projectile would likely reduce their speed dramatically, causing the targets to hit with low velocity rounds, or be harder to hit due to your limited range. Accuracy would also be next to impossible for a human at greater ranges, especially due to the numerous factors that impair a human at range (limited vision, hands shaking slightly, inability to fire at the same point twice, inability to do the math required to predict the bullet’s trajectory, difficulty accounting improving accuracy when an attack misses and calculations are needed to adjust aim, basically all the wind factors between them and the targets, etc..)
6:30 I've always found it most interesting that whenever everyone comments on Tanya using a childlike voice to convince the factory workers that it was a prank, she gets increasingly angry with them, which implies she literally didn't think of doing that at all and accidentally slipped into a more natural speaking voice for the announcement, probably seeing it more as a boring activity like filing paperwork then a chance for legitimate manipulation and strategy.
She's angry because it's her REAL voice and she hates it.
Not only that, but she's the one insisting on giving them fair warning (and in the manga, they wait a while half an hour before destroying the factory, just to allow for the offered evacuation).
Her troops were the ones who wanted to simply attack without warning, as they saw issuing a warning to be a poor tactic, even if it's technically required by international law.
She trained them like modern day Navy SEALs, even if most of her info was obtained through video games and movies. Such arduous training partnered with the "war is glorious" mindset of early WW1 means her soldiers _think_ they've been purpose-built for "screw the rules, we're gonna win!" tactics.
The anime is honestly really good the protagonist is ruthless, but hates being on the front line yet puts out info and actions that keep her there. She is 100% by the book and generally doesn’t do anything you’d consider wrong yet she’s hated by a lot of people because their mindset is small compared to hers. To me the being X isn’t even a needed part of the story but adds some entertainment to the whole thing.
Like the sc
Yeah he can be kinda irritating
@@thedrunkengreybeareddwarf8431 exactly story would be good with or without him.
Being X is central to the story, the whole context is modern secularism against God played out in a WWI/II world with magic thrown in order to allow for the little girl protagonist to actually participate in the war. Without out that conflict the story never happens.
@@jacksongunner7122 yeah I get that part just think the story would be cool even if changed up a bit. Honestly the anime is good but the story is better if you read it.
its creepy how this anime could easily be the origin story for violet evergarden
I don’t like that thought
I like that thought.
@@ls200076 I agree with you, I wanna be traumatized because living in a 3rd world nation is too easy, idk, maybe luck?
But violet evergarden doesn't have magic
Dang that’s creepy-
Tanya Literally Taught The Empire Stormtooper Tactics but with Mages lmfao
insert sabaton here.
@@sluggaboyzWC3 *STRIKE AT ZERO HOUR, WITH OVERWHELMING FIREPOWER, THEY'RE FUELED BY THE FEARS OF THEIR ENEMIES EYES!*
yep
@@sluggaboyzWC3 EXACLTY MY FRIEND
"A glimpse of the future, new tactics of war!"
It's like the creators wrote down a list of every unrelated thing they were currently interested in or thinking about and then crammed it all together:
1. WW1 is an underused setting with a cool style, let's use that.
2. The VFX artists want to flex so let's have magic.
3. Tiptoeing and gamesmanship around laws of war is an interesting topic so let's explore that a bit.
4. Let's also briefly touch on the brutality of salaryman culture.
5. Isekais are still pretty popular so we'll make this one of those.
6. We're making an anime so naturally the antagonist should be God.
7. And of course, we gotta have lolis.
Just sounds like they cram out ideas after downing 60 bottles of vodka
@@yuki97kira It's one of the most intelligently written stories in all of the manga/anime space, exploring real philosophical ideas and how they interact and conflict, and the anime itself is a masterpiece of cinematography and the use of symmetry, repeated shots and perspective make it a technical marvel
From the video, the technology does not seem to be WW1 era, but WW2 era. Which means that the protagonists are all Nazi-Era Germany rather than Imperial Germany, which is certainly an interesting choice to make protagonists.
@@glenbe4026 it’s actually pre-World War Two tech. They have tank tech from the early 1930s, with ideologies and strategies from the Great War, the borders similar to the Great War. So it’s more like there was no Great War in the late 1910s, but instead it wasn’t triggered until late 1920s, by which point the communists in their version of Russia have already revolted, the USA is still isolationist, France is still trying to spread its republic ideas, Germany having their monarchy and Britain being Britain in the background. It’s a very interesting and fascinating choice because you can have freedoms to show certain tactical decisions from Tanya making her seem like a military genius when all she is doing is regurgitating the info from real world history
@@glenbe4026 it's an "alternative" WW1 where things developed differently especially with the existence of magic.
Trenches and stalemates on the front lines are WWI, Fast moving action packed fronts are WWII
And dont forget that one time they used essentially modified V1s
Oh and the time with the WW2 era tanks
It is both, just like Iron Harvest.
I feel like it’s a 1930s ongoing WW1 with slow advances with military tech due to magic
Trenches and stalemates is _Western_ front
Eastern was a lot more dynamic
Yeah if you look at the progression of this war it's much more similar to ww2. France gets knocked out, north Africa campaign, fighting communist Russia in the east. It's magical ww1.5 but it's more similar to ww2
It still feels strange to see a litteral Mary "Sue" (Sioux) with actual personality and tragedy XD
All in all, the most frightful part of the anime is that the evilness of the protagonist comes from his/her, well... modern, rational, efficience-seeking mindset (thanks corporation career) in a world still governed, even inside the empire's army, by various, old-fashioned (for us) beliefs. And yet, that alternate world doesn't look much better itself XD
the Mary Sue is still a b**** though lol
tbf these people back then were capable of incredible cruelty and brutality. Factories beating children and women, protestors being hung, military troops routinely shooting their own countrymen. Even the weapons of war were being designed to chew up people, tanks killed their operators more than they did the enemy, battleships were chocked full of people outside the armor, being shredded by massive guns. their command structure seeing men more as numbers and toy soldiers to be moved, consumed, and replaced.
Indeed the reality behind efficient thinking and how truly ruthless it can be is incredibly portrayed in saga of Tanya the evil the lack of emotion and caring for other humans
@@gaelurquiz5755 Well, I don't know how it's depicted in the manga, but stopping a mission with predictable heavy loss and a chance of dooming the empire seems rational enough. The risk would just be too great, it would need quite a huge benefit to justify such a mission :)
That, or Tanya may be starting to change her vision. That's the role of a protagonist, after all XD
Tanya isn't evil tho.
the title says WW2 , its WW1 , but awesome you covered Youjo Senki
It's kinda a mix of both.
@@VioletPistols
The "great war"(ww1) never Happens
And canonically the time is preatymuch right between when both wars happend in Out world.
Both wars get merged into a great-great-war. Some aspects are more WW2 and some more WW1 (Im preaty Sure "the Fatherland" is a monarchy Here?)
It's a mix see the panzer 3s firing on the French, that was from ww2. What the Germans had in ww1 is more of a slow fortress with a main gun and the appearance of s metal box
It had panzer 3,s and 4’s
@@willanderson3044 not to mention the dates being for the 1920's instead of the 1910's
I always love the self-righteousness of those kind of characters "Oh my father failed to kill this little girl he hunted down with his unit and instead she killed him during a battle during a war, so now I'm going to swear revenge on this little girl for daring to kill my father who wanted to kill her."
At least Mary Sioux has more emotion than actual Mary Sues.
Like, fair that she’s angry about it, but getting angry at the enemy soldier for killing a soldier in a war is basically getting mad at someone for doing their job. Couldn’t she have been mad at the war in general? Unless Tanya tortured her dad I don’t see why she gotta swear vengeance.
@@sugarkane1571 That is LITERALLY the entire point. Tanya is driven by logic and reason, Mary is driven by emotion and faith. They are polar opposites
@@karlthorsten9118 Her name is MARY SiOUx mary sue.....
From bad salaryman, to being nearly as good as Erwin Rommel.
Who? Lol
@@michaelbecket4901 the desert fox
@@ghostdiaries369 im lost here
@@michaelbecket4901 why?
@@michaelbecket4901 a German strategist and Field Marshall during WWII. I forgot his rank, but that's the closest I got. He was very well known for his tactics and commander skills
Me: oh so Tanya is a British officer *Sees the 1939-1942 german flag and Panzer IVs*
also me: GHOST DIVISION
*PANZER ELITE BORN TO COMPLETE NEVER RETREAT!*
Living or dead always ahead fed by your dread
HANS BRING THE ANTI TANK RIFLE
12- and 24-pounder rifled breech-loading field guns
Y?
This anime is good but the LN is a masterpiece. In the end you have the feeling that Tanya and her unit (the Salamanders) are fighting the world alone and win. But the war is lost in the end and Tanya becomes a legend without face. Her nickaname evolved from Silver wings to Mad dog to Devil of the Reihne.
I feel like she had more in common with the red Baron than anyone else in German WW1 or WW2 history
What's the light novel called?
@@bryangallows657 Saga of Tanya the Evil.
Rusty silver...
Isn't it Devil of the Rhine?
In manga and LN Tanya is not nearly as ruthless and psychotic as she is anime. She is still an hardass and the comedy of misunderstandings is there, but she is way more humane and have actual friends and care about her men. They simplified her character in anime (and made her and Visha ugly as well). Of and BTW I usually do not read fanfiction but there is an masterpiece called 'A Young Woman's Political Record' about Tanya fate after the lost war and how she tried her hand in politics and unwillingly become a beloved Fuhrer.
it is ww1.5
Thanks for the recommendation. I'm glad I'm not the only one's brain drifted in this direction.
I remember when I first heard of the series, I naturally just assumed the reason she was a child was so that she could be drawn young like the average high school aged anime protag when she becomes Kanzlerin and leads Not-Germany into pseudo-WWII. Moreso when I heard the manga reveals really early on what the outcome of the war was. I was surprised as hell to learn that wasn't where the story goes.
Watch as Tanya fails her way into success, choosing a "reals over feels" build for her character in a world where a balanced build is the meta, all the while thinking she's playing 5D chess when actually, everyone else is playing blackjack, leaving everyone confused about the goals of the others.
I always loved tanya the evil, its just really cool looking to see a "cute girl" being just a total psycho + strategist without any shitty anime stereotypes
this anime was really good for a history buff, they stretched out things but it is accurate to a lot of smoke a mirror missions in WW1-2 that were used to gain footholds
The coolest part of this series is when Tanya is snapped out of her isekai possession and the personality of the girl she occupies shines through.
"Tanya" is a zealot animated by unhinged religious fervor.
Isekai isn't about possession, it's about BEING that person. The only soul in the body being the reincarnated's.
Actually, there are different types of Isekai. Like being transported directly. Or being reborn. Or possessing the body of someone who should have died. There are those were the original memories of the body are lost. There are those where they are merged. There's reverse isekai like Devil is a part-timer. Or a mix of normal and reverse like Arata Kangatari.
Isekai is about a person (or group of people) from one world and goes to another world. Some people even consider Sword Art Online as Isekai, because they consider the VR world as another world.
When did her normal little girl side ever come out?
Tanya follows whatever that's in power and does everything to succeed in any society. That's the point of the story since chapter 1.
It's not about what she believes. She doesn't believe in anything. That's why Being X punished her in the first place
@@zigrakudo4092
The only reason it was considered an Isekai is because they were stuck in that world for some time.
But animes like Paprika or Belle are not considered Isekai just because they sometimes enter another world.
This video misses out on the most important parts of the anime, the character's personality. Tanya is a ruthless strategist type character, that just so happens to agree with the efficiency of a certain austrian. Although Tanya may seem to be incredibly ruthless and opportunistic, she does care about those around her and perfectly gives them a perfect solution to their issues. She acts kind, only when there is enough leeway to do so. The anime portrays Tanya to be a strict but pure evil character at the start, and slowly spins the narrative around to make the Higher authorities (in every sense) to be the most absolute evil one could be. From Military executives being complacent and drunk off the victory of their men, thus allowing a world war to occur, to the unrelenting evil that is being X, which goes to any length in order to put Tanya through true hell. Mary Sue, is a term for characters who are ridiculously perfect, to the point of being able to destroy an entire story and make it far too unrealistic. That being said, the character in A little girl's war, Mary Sue, is an incredibly perfect character to be the antagonist. Born with everything, and obtaining everything needed, she became a true 'mary sue' to fulfill being X's goal. She is portrayed exactly like a 'mary sue', yet she was driven by revenge. A perfect character, unfit for storytelling, became imperfect through the meddling of being X, and became a character fit for storytelling, not as a protagonist, but as an antagonist fueled by revenge.
Man this channel has been on a roll recently, first DTF and now this? My two favorite anime within a week, impressive timing
Whats DTF?
@@robloxnubnub3771 darling in the franxx
Imagine dying and reincarnated as ruthless cute anime girl 😆
I love Tanya with her evil laugh, it's just perfection
*"History is Written by Victors."*
She might be evil. But evil is different from each people. Also she wants to stop the war, maybe she's noble like Lelouch, who knows? 😂
I would say first, but I`m not
@@NatetheGreat-gf7un you did
Hmmm,i wonder if she is Hitler's grandchildren "Just my thoughts"
Aoi yuuki did a banger job on voicing her
She never intended to stop the war, she simply intended to stop being the one on the front lines every time, but we know how being X feels about that
Tanya to being X: Respect is not given it is earned
Cpt. Kirk: "...why does god need a starship?"
me after watching this anime: "Why does god care if one person doesn't believe in them?"
Gods are petty and cruel.
Achievement.
He wishes to save Tanya.
Happy to see you cover this one, Tanya is one of my favorite anime characters!
This was surprisingly a very good anime, love her attitude toward fool
Tanya sounds like a prime example of why you don't try forcing beliefs as that's just going to get a bad response.
I mean what else you gonna believe in when there's evidence Infront of you?
@@marcxworld5708 Except it's not evidence there is a god or that Being X even created them. He could very well be a fraud. And why would a supposed god so obsessively need and seek the validation of a mere being they created? If anything, that's evidence that what's in front of me is in fact NOT god.
@@spookystyle7058 so why TF is the real god just letting some nobody slander his image
@@marcxworld5708 Because he has more important matters to attend to than playing games with such pestilent beings.
@@spookystyle7058 you act like this isn't the same god that caused Sodom and Gommorah or something like that
This anime does some advancements to the plot, but the manga says it best: What gives us the choice to believe?
Being X is an interesting character whom I theorize may be a shard of the Abrahamic God or one of the Thol-Buddhist deities, another perspective has Tanya see a very powerful parasite that wants to eat her "faith" and move onto another victim.
I'm tired of people saying manga is good when it's worst version of all three of them. Just read the light please.
It is interesting how real WWII factions can be renamed into an amazing anime.
WW1*
@Why 01 it's a mix. The war starts in the interwar period with ww1 never happening. The empire is the ww1 era central powers but Russia is comunist and you have explicitly fantasy versions of Churchill, Charles degaul, stalin and the Russian NKVD head whose name escapes me all ww2 era figures plus Romel is present as the imperial general in charge of the African campaign that gets glossed over in 40 seconds during the movie.
Well the early light novels are clearly ww1 era trench warfare and ww1 era tanks and weapons (in the light novel the anime just uses the later tanks from the start) duirng the later books you see the more modren weapons with Tanya commenting how due to advances in tech mages can no longer reliably punch past tank armor or match planes like they used to. You also see the V series of weapons, which are WW2, even though they both got changed extensively.
The Author is clearly drawing on both world wars, saying it's one or two specifically or is wrong
@@vonfaustien3957 yeah i completely forget about the russy federation
It's ww1, not ww2
I love your analysis
Kami: I exist and you, the protagonist will acknowledge this and worship me!
Tanya: I'm about to go full atheist on this deity's existence.
My personal favorite aspect of this anime-is the ideological dichotomy between her "past" life as a supervisor & Tanya. The former is a fervent and pragmatic, Rightist Libertarian type who applies his free market principles to the neoliberal economic framework accordingly to maximize on the success of his company whereas, the latter appears slightly different on the surface level via, not only engaging in offensive warfare, but: also fighting alongside a past, centralised and totalitarianist governing body (two facets that contradict libertarianism) although her competency as a war strategist aligns with the aforementioned pragmatism of her previous identity.
Although, the behaviors, beliefs and actions of both are purely attributed to environment, the supervisor either grew up in an authoritarian and overly religious household or has a negative past experience with the state infringing on one of his earlier startups as a businessman hence his right libertarian, and atheist views. Tanya's actions are majorly attributed to her lack of a parental role model or authoritative figure plus her lack of financial self-reliance or employment, thus resulting in her lacking any guidance or meaning and her being groomed by a fāscist regime with the promise of attaining the aforementioned validation, the show also explores a social difference between men and women, our supervisor seeks personal self reliance, Tanya seeks a social/financial "safety net".
8:07 what made you think they where being influenced by being X? A 2 front war is way harder to fight than a single front war so sending support to the entrance alience would make it an easier fight for the Republic even if only slightly.
That would make sense but Being X was the reason the war was started in the first place. This world is a sandbox for him to test and play in while he tortures a salaryman in the body of a little girl. Everything done; in the grand scheme of things... Is done to kill or convert Tanya.
Having not seen the anime, I am going to go out on a limb and assume there is an explicit audio or visual indicator of X's influence in the anime that wasn't explicitly shown in this recap.
@@generaluser8291 There wasn't I've also read the book it's based off of and it wasn't in there either
A lot of things are influenced by being X but they almost all are designed to target Tanya and not the empire. For instance they magic she uses only works when she prays and another thing later on when the General staff is organizing the mage assault battalion her profile has the words Deus Vult on it which helps her get noticed.
@@generaluser8291 I have actually watched the whole thing, it isn't there.
I still can't get over the artstyle of this really great anime🤣
I think it’s hilarious that ‘Being X’ technically looses, and doesn’t even realize it.
By influencing the scientist the creat an unstable magic drive, then Forcing Tanya to pray or die. X, effectively looses, as it wanted her to break down and accept his authority as God. He exercised his control, but failed his ultimate goal.
It’s like people with authority who Demand respect and Will abuse that authority to punish those who do not. They are Shown respect, but they are Not Respected.
Have you done "So i'm a spider? So what?"? If not, Please do it, i've never actually seen a recap about the anime unless im living under a rock
@@expertoflizardcorrugation3967 Unless something was animated in 2006 I would never notice. The animation seemed average enough for me to not notice anything, but I guess others noticed something.
@@expertoflizardcorrugation3967 true, I don’t think it’s ever getting another season.
@@expertoflizardcorrugation3967 Thinking back to their delay on an episode being released, I suppose I now know what happened.
One of my favorite animes. From the story to the beautiful artwork, seriously check out the backgrounds especially in the buildings. All around a well done show.
My absolute favorite anime, thanks for the recap!
man thank you for posting these vids it help me find a lot more good anime to whach.
Tanya's entire anime is the "GOD PLEASE, ANYWHERE BUT GERMANY" meme.
My favorite anime by far. Season 2 being confirmed makes me super happy.
Being X has the personality and temperament of a CSGO xbox message
never thought id see saga of tanya the evil on this channel, however it is a present surprise, love the videos and keep it up!
6:26 what she did is still a war crime
In the show, her subordinates try to joke, and it is inferenced that it was a slip up of her using her actual voice because it was a more boring task.
I don't think it is. They announced their intention to bomb the factory and told them to evacuate.
@@victorvonsteuben1728 intentionally trying to blur the lines is generally frowned down upon. When trying to get enemy to surrender there should no confusion about the legitimacy of the offer. I doubt any independent court will take a technically I did give them warning, is either your clearly warned them or you didn't.
@@TheFuri0uswc Well, AniRecaps interpreted this scene (like many others) only partly correct.
In the LightNovel its a completely normal warning, its just performed by a child instead of an adult.
If you now include the fact that child-mage-soldiers were rare, but not thaaat uncommon then you should 100% heed the warning.
I agree with you, in an earth like environment that would be illegal, but not in the Tanya-Universe.
Technically not a war crime.
the VA for Tanya is fantastic, people should definately watch this one, its fantastic
This was by far my favourite anime, glad you Covered it :))
This anime sounds equal parts incredible and terrifying. Incredible because of its gorgeous art style and enthralling story based on actual history, terrifying because the protagonist is the vessel for committing all of the worst acts in military history in the name of victory. It's the sort of thing where I'd love to watch it someday, but only if I know for a fact that the main character will get what's coming for her in the end.
Horrific war strategies written by Tanya are hypotheticals based off of efficiency and real world parallels. They were never meant to be implemented but are under orders of her incompetent superiors and through her due to her being the most qualified and only battalion able to carry it out.
In fact in the series, it is not above other nations to try to replicate her plays and ultimately failing because they do not understand the intricacies and flaws of the strategy and why they succeeded in the first place. You can only use a tactic successfully once because afterwards countermeasures will start to be implemented.
In this specific case, the other nations are not entirely guiltless either. With the Empire just wanting to maintain its borders and expanding only in retaliation to invasions. While other nations plotting to instigate the war in hopes of dividing the empire’s vast territories.
In terms of you wanting the villainous pseudo nazi protagonist getting its comeuppance. It is revealed in the manga and in turn the original light novel. That despite the many victories and horrific war crimes(not war crimes because no prior laws were ever preestablished and this is the first of its kind) that the Empire will eventually lose this war with all records of the protagonist’s existence redacted. Tanya even knows despite the Empire’s superior military, that if the war is to escalate into a real world war, that her nation is doomed to fall just due to pure quantity of enemy nations. But again this is the story of a overly competent subordinate who wants a peaceful life and her overly incompetent superiors that puts her into the frontlines and mistaken her rational and logical mind for malice and evil.
@Vurrunna I wouldn't say she is an evil character. She states many times her hatred of war, her hatred of the loss of human life, and her strong desire to be ANYWHERE save for the front lines.
The 'get what's coming to her' comment is intresting because that's exatly what Mary Sue (the daughter shown at the end) believes. That Tanya is a devil who killed her father, and The Entire empire is Evil. She chooses to ignore the fact that her own country started the war, and Tanya was only doing her job.
@@waxerwaer9700 The thing is, "only doing her job" involves her committing bona fide war crimes (yes I know they're technically not illegal in-world, the point is we _made_ them war crimes for a reason). Stuff like purposefully masking her voice when she warns the factory of their attack in order to ensure that civilian workers don't evacuate the premises, allowing them to deal a harder blow to their enemy's production capabilities. Cold and tactical, and also _incredibly_ amoral.
Essentially, going off of this video's representation of her, she's evil in everything but name. She's only seeking the most efficient means to wage warfare, sure, but in the process, she abandons all morality and basic human empathy. Keep in mind, just because her empire is under attack doesn't absolve her all wrongdoing.
As a sidenote, while I don't know the specifics from the show itself, it seems clear that the reason the Entente even attacked the Empire in the first place was not from a desire to conquer territory, but more a reaction to the Empire's unparalleled growth, as they now control vast swathes of Europe--this would suggest that, while the Entente technically started the war, it comes across more as a preventative war to stop the Empire expanding and conquering everything.
The Empire's pursuant use of unethical tactics would only serve to cement the Entente's perception of the Empire as evil, meaning that, in a twisted way, Tanya's probably done more to ensure the war's continuance than anyone else, since she's proven them to be not only a military threat, but a moral threat. Her relentless war tactics are also likely to result in the enemy feeling no compunction whatsoever in releasing the same tactics upon the Empire, once they figure it out on their own rather than clumsily copying the Empire.
Basically, Tanya may not perform her duties with any malice, but that doesn't excuse her actions, nor does it justify the Empire that's so willing to put her tactics into practice. The Empire are undoubtedly the bad guys here, displayed by their ruthless desire to conquer more and do whatever it takes to attain victory.
Like I said though, I think this kind of story can be truly fascinating, so long as it doesn't end in some unequivocal victory for the Empire. Tanya's a war criminal, no doubt about it, and a world where the Empire wins is a world where the rules of war are left much more horrifying than what we already have. I'm not even saying she has to die or suffer or anything, I just think it'd be great to see her go to trial and try to justify her actions to a court that doesn't give a damn how logical her actions were given how unethical they were.
It would also make for a good resolution on a narrative level, showing that no, you _can't_ get by being that cold and heartless. Just like a disgruntled employee threw him in front of a bus, this world will also punish him if he doesn't learn from his mistakes. Otherwise, if Tanya gets away scot free, it essentially validates the idea of "Yes, screw everyone else, do things the cold and efficient way with zero regard for human life."
Anywho, that turned into a bit of a rant. I think I'll leave it at that before I write another few paragraphs. Cheers.
@@vurrunna But the thing is, she didn't blow up that factory in Dacia because she loves the smell of blood and death, because that would be the evil thing to do. She did it for a multiple of factors. Number one, was to not ruin her surprise advantage, if she gave a 'real' warning, then not only would they evacuate the factory, but the city would also mount a defense. Which would not only mean they might miss their chance to hit the factory, but she's also put in danger the lives of herself and the 47 soilders and comrades she's in charge of keeping alive. And further along that, hitting that factory ENDED the war. On the scale she killed perhaps 300 to save 300,000 in a long drawn out conflict. That doesn't make it a 'good' thing by any means, but its not an evil one. You called her out for being 'amoral' but that is exactly what she is, amoral. True netural. Not moral, or immoral.
Nothing in this video, or in the show, or in the mange, or in the LN show her as being evil. They show her as someone forced into a job she does not want, but as someone who does their job well whatever it may be. She bombed a factory of workers? Well see above. She helped destroy the city of Arene? She tried to wiggle out of her orders by instead saving the Empire soilders captured, but said prisoners were killed by the occupants of the city. And the empire destroyed the city because they were wrecking havoc on supply lines. You could also blame the republic themselves for the massacre. They were using the people of the city as human shield, thinking that the Empire wouldnt attack the people in the city. That bluff was called.
No you are wrong. The attack from the Entente alliance was purely politics, nationalism, and perhaps the work of being X. In the light novel there is even a section from Anson Sue (the guy Tanya has the bos battle with at the end) cursing their leaders for doing this mentally, but being forced to follow orders. Further on in the story, even the Entente's own allies and the people fighting 'with' them in the war, despise them for the attack that started the world war. As for the other nations, some are influenced by Being X, some are due to The empire's shitty diplomatic skills, but yes some are for the very reason you describe. Fear of the Empire's growth, Tanya even remarks on this at the very end. The Empire, never ONCE declares war on ANY other nation, yet because the whole declares war on them, in the name of peace, they must fight. And the whole world fears The Empire from becoming a new great power in the world and taking the world over, so in the name of peace, they wage war.
Just saying 'oh the empire and Tanya are the bad guys, end of story' is just so.. ugh. I'm sorry you are just so close to the way of thinking of one of the stories main antagonists (mary sue, yes that's her real name) makes quick snap judgments based on emotions, not facts, and refuses to accept anything save the Empire is evil. I'm not trying to insult you, but the only real argument against your points is for you to sit down and watch/read the story yourself.
If Tanya goes to trial, she will not be punished. Ever. She goes to GREAT lengths to ensure every little thing she does is legal. There is no arguements or questions here. Yes she states she has to attitude anything that is in a 'gray' zone I consider white. But she has never put a single pinky toe in the realm of black, there is nothing she's done that can be called illeagal. Even the attack on the city full of people, it's legal.
@@vurrunna Historically speaking, brutal efficiency of a military is what ends wars, not "pussyfooting around ethics". The rules against "human atrocities" basically exist to prolong war as much as possible for the greed of companies that make their money off of it.
That's the immoral thing here.
"You can't use X in war, it's immoral!" But... wouldn't it end the war VERY QUICKLY? Sure, it sucks for the victims... but there will be LESS victims and LESS strife if it is used, correct?
Historically, "honor" in a fight gets you killed. It's a stupid thing to be beholden to. If you adhere to it, you are at a disadvantage.
You win wars by destroying the enemy's ability to wage war. You do this as quickly as possible by targeting civilians (supply lines... which also puts pressure on the government to surrender if the civilians are targeted and can't be defended), targeting military bases, using tactics to MAIM soldiers rather than KILL them (drains the coffers!), and taking as many strategic points as possible with as few losses as possible.
War is a terrible, brutal, horrible thing. This is why it must be ended as quickly as possible. Prolonged wars in which the enemy gets to maintain their ideologies, ability to wage war, and their malice of their population against you are stupid things. You do not let these stand. You invite further war and conflict and action against you if you let ANY of these stand.
The only reason "war crimes" even truly exist is so that profiteering can be done by businesses invested in prolonging that war as long as possible.
If the duo from Fantasy Bishoujo get added to Isekai Quartet, I could see Tachibana and Tanya hitting it off due to one or two major things they have in common.
One of my top 10 animes of all time, and top 5 Isekai.
Thank you for all your hard work. So much easier to get my friends into stuff
anime name?
8:17 I never really noticed that she was named because her whole character was really just being a Mary sue
This anime has a few popular themes rolled into one. The reincarnation into another world, the one where the main character is over powered, the one with alternate history with an anime spin, and finally the obligatory beach episode.
"Onsen episode" is an acceptable alternative
Being German I watched it with the German dub and that just really adds to the experience
This anime was sick
This is sad! Dude! Wtf??
This is an AWESOME anime!
Where's the spirit of story telling??
You're making me cry with this!
Thanks for these I’m gonna start to pick anime’s using your vids
Much as I love this Anime, the way that they skipped over half of what happened in the Manga to a degree that Tanya's personality in the Manga is radically diffrent from that in the Anime (alongside with the fact that they decided to have The Main Character [Tanya] and the main supporting Character [Victorya] be the only characters IN THE ENTIRE SHOW to have that weird facial animation), along with other issues like the fact that we never really see Tanya apply her 21st century knowledge to her advantage, is something I hope that they will do better in Season 2.
Tanya and Victoria were deliberately made "less attractive" at the authors' request because he wanted the focus to be on the story and concepts, not Rule 34. Whelp, better luck next time, fella
Still wish this show could get a 2nd and 3rd season going through the rest of the war
i mean a season 2 is coming, now a third... maybe in the future
@Andrew Acácia really? Its about time this show got some more stuff.
@@Dr.Mcstaby do you know about the Movie? there is a movie wich continues the story but it skipped most of the desert arc
@@zunis7896 i seen the movie but its ends on a cliff hanger, i want to see the empire win and tanya piss of being X some more.
this show is worthy of 4 seasons unlike most who actually get 4 or more.
@@zunis7896 to many really good anime only continue in the manga form.
thank you for recapping one of my favorite anime's ever
Deus Lo vult
What’s is called
I discovered this anime by seeing pictures of Tanya and hearing the show's theme song - Jingo Jungle - and falling in love with the beat. I'm all for psychotic characters, and it being set in a fantasy-like WWI? I understand nothing about war but heck yeah, I'm into it! It's one of my top favorite anime and for good reason.
2:28 so basically your telling me that being x is actually just a pissy dungeon master that thinks your messing up their "master crafted" story
I never love but hate a girl MC at same time.
Good job
Technically she had a man's mind.
It's also interesting that for once the Isekai MC was actually a villian and not a God like hero..like Rimiru for example.
@@jasonalbran376 She's actually more neutral than a villain
Honestly i think this is a better way to learn about an anime im not entirely wanting to watch. i’ll watch the ones i want when i have time but this is a good substitute for the rest
Thanks to you I found on of my favorite animes because of you
This will forever be my favorite anime im so excited to season 2 to come out
Adult Tanya would be top tier waifu. Don't worry about the war crimes and genocide.
why are you sexualising a child character...
@@joyscd she's like a 30yo man in a childs body dont worry about it
@@nono4273 you said in a child's body and still saw no problem. Yall tone deaf 💀
He said adult not child
@@nono4273 yo I may be degenerate but I can confirm, some of us have limits, the ones that go beyond are as braindead as a blobfish and have the sex drive of a rabbit
Nice always wanted to see it and know about it. But didn’t had the time on my overtime shifts. Many thanks !
If I had a nickel for every time I enjoyed an reincarnated mc that becomes a sociopathic child soldier war criminal I’d have 2 nickels which isn’t a lot but it’s weird it happened twice.
what series is the 2nd nickel?
To be fair, (in the anime at least), Tanya was a sociopath _before_ she was reincarnated.
@@ragaboi4103
I’m curious too. I’d love to find another series like this one.
And which would that be?
Bro, please, what’s the other one?
When you see the V1s in a WW1 anime...
And then theres that scene with the tanks...
Still loved the show tho
I mean light novel wise ww2 tanks do show up later in the war causing Tanya to bitch because her mages can't punch through the armor like they used to be able.
But that was well after the Rhine stuff
WE NEED a part 2 of this
deym this anime is amazing.. i want more of this war + isekai +psychopath genre
One of the best I've ever watched 👏
Animerecaps, it is Alternative WW1 not ww2
There's panzers and V1 flying bombs so who knows
@@user-mx1fq6qm6i Because it’s in another world. But there is a Royal German family, plane tests and Communists in Russia. because it is set in 1925 or something. So the logical answer would be ww1
@@user-mx1fq6qm6i it's both early light novels are ww1 than post Rhine arch after not technically France is beaten it goes full ww2 complete with not Stalin, not Churchill, litterly just Romel and Charles Degaul. They still keep the empire more in line with the ww1 era central powers
“When a Salaryman is Reincarnated as a Girl who failed Art School”
Ey dude i just wanted to tell you that this recap inspired me to watch some more anime. I ended up binge watching the entirety of the series in one sitting, no breaks no nothing, just pure, unfiltered GOOD SHIT.
To anyone and everyone reading this that hasn't watched anime in a while, pick it up again, it's great ^^
Literally just did that tonight. Saw the first few seconds of this video and decided to watch it instead of spoiling myself. Glad I did. Can't wait for S2.
anime name?
@@king_isaiahcee8349 Saga of Tanya the Evil
Yes! This is one my favorite animes!
Too bad, they will:
a) Wont continue it properly.
b) Stay historically accurate, thus making Tanya Lose.
what do you mean historical accurate? lol Tanya's world is different compare to our history.. its just similiar.
It's not the same world
@@january0057 the world is like ours and will go down a similar path as ours
@Jellyjared L. she may or may not befriend Romel and decide to kill some high ranking empire officials to force the empire into a truce after the politicians go batshit insane like a certian real life event Romel tried to pull on everyone's favorite mustachioed art student.
What do you mean by a?
Remember friends. If they don't leave the combat zone, they're not civilians
Yay! I love this anime so much, its so cool
Hope there is more to this anime, I am invested into WW2 or WW1 stuff
Season 2 is coming. There is also a movie (with an airshow over Moscow), and the OVA Operation Desert Pasta.
GOD I CAN'T WAIT UNTIL THERE IS A NEW SEASON!!!
I can't wait to see season 2 ❤❤❤
I watched this at lot of times but i will watch it again
Seems like one of those animes where they unnecessarily had to make the protagonist a literal child for no reason. She looks so unrealistic and out of place when she could have easily been written as a normal adult. Gotta wonder what the author was thinking.
She was born during the war. If she were to join the army as an adult, the war would've been over.
There was a reason actually. God reincarnated her in this world and changed his gender because God thinks it will help him uhh become religious, well that's the gist of it.
The loli form is actually genius. The incongruity of a loli acting cold blooded who prioritizes efficiency and the reactions of those around her is hilarious.
what's the deal with lonely salary man, neets and middle aged men being always the protagonists of most Isekai manga and animes? I find it weird and peculiar tbh, also this one cause he got reincarnated as a loli girl. Anyway nice recap of this anime AniRecaps, I'll try to watch this one. It would be nice if you recapped Texhnoloyze it's such an underrated seinen sci-fi anime that it deserves more attention.
Because most viewers are older now and they're trying for that sweet, succulent "relatability."
If i remember correctly old isekai's were kids being reincarnated, so now that everyone's older now they wanna keep it up
You gotta be a loser to be in a Isekai obviously 👀👀👀
Most isekais I can't stand. But this one was good. "God" basicaly said "so you lack Faith cuz you are an adult man with a stable job in a modern world? Ok, now you're a kid in an orphanage with no money... Oh, also now you're a girl, and... I* hope you like war. Now give me your Faith mothertrucker!".
It's amazing.
@@AlexSander-jr9et I believe the protagonist made this point before, but I can't remember. The basic idea is that an actual god would not need our faith to exist. So because the being demands faith, it is not god, but some otherworldly being. So I'm totally on board with this one because I really want this being to be proven false, but I'm still open to it really being god and messing with him to teach him the error of his personality and the power of humans.
We need more shows like this!!!
I love this channel
The fact that being x might actually be God is horrifing.
9:03 bruh you didn't 'say the part plan is accually a top secret plan
ONE OF MY FAVORITES
i loved this series
Day 10 of telling anirecaps to make a recap about the anime "i've been killing slimes for 300 years and maxed out my level."
well goodluck,bestie
He said soon last time you asked
@@trolly7985 ik but its not released yet soooo im gonna keep doing this
I agree with Tanya that being-X isn't God, but some entity that desperately desires to adored as a supreme being, seems like what Lucifer aka satan wants. God only wants of our worship because he always wants to interact closely with man, who is the masterpiece of a sovereign God.
i love you your vids kieep it up
This new history channel documentary looking good
I love how there's a character literally named Mary Sue!
Correct your title, is an alternate World War One, not only starts with trench war, is stated in the series that is the forst World War of that errr world
WWI attracts more eyes with less of an explination which is the point of a title.
@@NianJKL i know liying and missinforming get you up in the youtube algorithm, but that's for those who don't really have good content, this channel has really good content, good edition and a narrator who is both fun and easy to unnderstand, so don't need to lie, altought, yeah, algorithm is algorithm
He corrected it.
Thanks
Love the opening