Testing 4 Common Engine Building Myths: Which Ones Are True? - Engine Power S8, E6

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 июл 2024
  • Back to Basics episode 2. Want to build your best powerplant? It starts with understanding the fundamentals of engine building. We bust 4 common engine misconceptions. #horsepower #engine
    Myth #1: Valve Lash Settings - Cold v. Hot
    Myth #2: Air Cleaner Effects
    Myth #3: Accessories Rob Excessive Power
    Myth #4: Effects of Header Sizing
    Part 1: How To Achieve Power Gains Without Taking Apart Your Engine
    • How To Achieve Power G...
    Check out the PowerNation store for shirts, hats, and more: bit.ly/39LkvsF
    Want to watch POWERNATION completely ad-free? Subscribe at the link below and receive the first month for just 99 cents: bit.ly/2DuRILC
    Follow POWERNATION Everywhere:
    www.powernationtv.com​​​​​​​​​
    / powernationtv
    / powernationtv
    PARTS USED IN THIS EPISODE
    MouseBlocker
    Plug-In MouseBlocker PRO
    pntv.us/pn_pt_16947_60240ca7d...
    Summit Racing
    Summit NHRA Driver Tim Wilkerson
    pntv.us/pn_pt_16946_60240c66a...
    Matco Tools
    MATCO Tools are the Official Tool Supplier to PowerNation
    The Industrial Depot
    Tools, Hardware, Shop Supplies
  • Авто/МотоАвто/Мото

Комментарии • 968

  • @unicornsteaks6769
    @unicornsteaks6769 3 года назад +152

    Engine building myth #5: The budget rebuild...with aluminum heads, roller cam, lifters, roller rockers, headers, distributor and carb we had lying around the shop, not to mention the $20K worth of machines we have at our fingertips.

    • @stevesalkas9128
      @stevesalkas9128 11 месяцев назад +6

      Budget means under 5k

    • @stevesalkas9128
      @stevesalkas9128 11 месяцев назад +17

      Budget mean old heads from 60s 70s not 5k heads from 2000s

    • @HioSSilver1999
      @HioSSilver1999 11 месяцев назад +4

      ​@@stevesalkas9128 i agree to a certain extent on that....except it's probably less expensive to buy the new heads than refurbish the old ones.

    • @zztop7306
      @zztop7306 11 месяцев назад +6

      Poors "why are decent parts and equipment expensive"
      Just keep running those clapped out 350s and keep it moving.

    • @thatguyoverthere9634
      @thatguyoverthere9634 11 месяцев назад +6

      ​@@zztop7306shoot man, you mention 350s. I'm building 351 clevelands for my stuff and the price for just a pair of decent heads would just about cover a whole sbc overhaul including machine work and a decent stroker kit.
      I'm only a poor because I'm not rebuilding a clapped out 350.

  • @Orygunner67
    @Orygunner67 2 года назад +42

    I love how Pat gets this seriousl yet maniacal look on his face when he's pushing that throttle lever forward on the dyno! 🤠

  • @BatJordo
    @BatJordo 3 года назад +99

    I’ve been watching “PowerBlock” since it first aired on TNN. These guys have done such awesome work over the years, hope they can keep going for another 22 years.

    • @MrTheHillfolk
      @MrTheHillfolk 3 года назад +4

      Haha yup, I'd chill on the weekend mornings watching all the wrenching shows back then before going to play in the garage.
      I guess it was like a grown-up version of sitting around the tube watching Warner Bros as a kid😁

    • @karlsmith2570
      @karlsmith2570 3 года назад

      I've been watching these shows for about the same length of time as well

    • @scottyV1000
      @scottyV1000 3 года назад +1

      I started watching these shows when Joe Elmore and another guy I can't remember were on - he sort of looked Hawaiian. Before that I watched Shade Tree Mechanic on Saturday and Sunday mornings. I'm glade they are on RUclips because since they aren't on Spike / Paramount anymore they are hard to find on TV.

    • @karlsmith2570
      @karlsmith2570 3 года назад +1

      @@scottyV1000 the other guy who cohosted with Joe Elmore was Chuck Hansen

    • @scottyV1000
      @scottyV1000 3 года назад +2

      @@karlsmith2570 yup, that’s him. He was the “Chevy” guy and liked station wagon grocery getters.

  • @myturkishlife1777
    @myturkishlife1777 3 года назад +57

    You get more pens in your top pocket as you get promoted :-)
    Great Video Guys .....

    • @zero-by6ib
      @zero-by6ib 2 года назад

      😅😂🤣

    • @davelowets
      @davelowets 29 дней назад

      Maybe it's a compromise for other areas??.... 🤷🏻

  • @Nick-cz7co
    @Nick-cz7co Год назад +12

    Thanks for doing these comparisons! I would have liked to see a air fuel ratio with the different air cleaners.

  • @mickysmith8851
    @mickysmith8851 3 года назад +193

    They should do the old flipping the top of the stock air cleaner upside down

    • @hodr1000
      @hodr1000 3 года назад +12

      I agree. I ran my 78 Camaro like that.

    • @hualni
      @hualni 3 года назад +27

      I'm honestly surprised they didn't. Engine Masters did.

    • @genwatie2191
      @genwatie2191 3 года назад +4

      @@hualni you must be watching engine masters on something other then RUclips.

    • @hualni
      @hualni 3 года назад +3

      @@genwatie2191 It was on RUclips back a while. But now I watch it on the Motortrend app. It cost me less than $1/ month.

    • @genwatie2191
      @genwatie2191 3 года назад +5

      @@hualni this one is free so...

  • @stargasm1000
    @stargasm1000 3 года назад +40

    What I'd love to have seen for the air filter test would be a manifold vacuum graph. That tells how much restriction is really happening.

    • @ts302
      @ts302 3 года назад +6

      Also, if any change with the A/F ratio.

    • @pranays
      @pranays 3 года назад

      I think they did an air filter test on an old episode with mike and pat

    • @donziperk
      @donziperk 3 года назад +3

      I took an air cleaner lid and put a fitting in it and ran a vacuum line to a gauge in the car. Tried a bunch of different filter elements including foam and oil, dry paper and KN. Amazingly there really wasn’t of a difference.

    • @Orygunner67
      @Orygunner67 2 года назад +1

      I always added a vacuum gauge hooked to the intake manifold under my dash in my hot rods. Used one under the hood for tuning too! They can tell you a lot about how your engine is running

  • @jsflagstad
    @jsflagstad 3 года назад +8

    I'd like to see all of these myths compared on this high HP engine and a lower HP engine expressed in "Percent Gain" terms.

  • @sean7857
    @sean7857 3 года назад +7

    I didn't read through all of the comments but the air cleaner test is interesting. Would like to see results of power changes from pulling outside air vs under hood air - 100 degrees vs 70 degrees outside vs under hood.

    • @pranays
      @pranays 10 месяцев назад

      I think engine masters does that test.

  • @jimkillen1065
    @jimkillen1065 2 года назад +4

    I use to change the lash on my solid roller on my small block chev to see how it responded . I was surprised of the results. That was a long time ago but I not forget... as far as lifters I run limiters in my hydraulic lifters in my Harleys. I prefer limited travel lifters in them

  • @stevohmelike
    @stevohmelike 3 года назад +21

    Everyone I ever told that the lash opens up when warmer, thought I was dropped on my head. Which was besides the point.

    • @dukecraig2402
      @dukecraig2402 3 года назад

      Not true with every type of engine, I've seen some that tighten up when it's brought up to temp and some that loosen, pushrod material comes into play there.

    • @K4TORG412
      @K4TORG412 3 года назад

      @@dukecraig2402 exactly, and the pushrod becomes nearly the same temp as the block so it depends on the material. but the exhaust valve gets really hot so it expands extremly more then the rest and normaly gets tighter

    • @dukecraig2402
      @dukecraig2402 3 года назад

      @@K4TORG412
      Yep, I've seen some tighten up and some get looser in the same engine all depending on the pushrod material.

    • @yarpos
      @yarpos 2 года назад

      @@dukecraig2402 ahh pushrods, how quaint :-)

    • @charlesvan13
      @charlesvan13 2 года назад

      It depends on which expands more, the block and head, or the pushrod.

  • @zaccivy2061
    @zaccivy2061 3 года назад +5

    I learn so much from these shows. Now I'm convinced that I need to upgrade my 1.5" long tubes on my 408w.

  • @bradkeeney5236
    @bradkeeney5236 3 года назад +11

    Thank you for the summary at the end. It would’ve been nice to see it comparing runs with each test also.

  • @chipgilley6203
    @chipgilley6203 3 года назад +23

    This is one of the most useful and interesting videos I’ve ever seen! Settles so many things. Had NO IDEA air cleaners could make 80hp diff at max pull!!! Do more controlled testing of performance products!!! I LOVE IT!!!!

    • @gregg7761
      @gregg7761 2 года назад +3

      How could you possibly have “no idea”? You honestly thought that a ridiculously small air filter wouldn’t kill horsepower?? Get ready to have your mind blown again… An undersized fuel filter also hurts horsepower!

    • @andreyangere3076
      @andreyangere3076 2 года назад +4

      @@gregg7761 well I don't think anyone expected it to have a 80hp impact

    • @tryhardfinessedyou
      @tryhardfinessedyou Год назад

      @@gregg7761 No need to be a sarcastic ass clown Gregg. Not everyone is a master mechanic like you.

    • @pranays
      @pranays 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@gregg7761then why are you even here? You know it all clown.

    • @pranays
      @pranays 10 месяцев назад +1

      Just remember an engine is just an Air pump and anything that improves it's ability to move more air gives it more horsepower and torque.

  • @descargaelbano
    @descargaelbano 3 года назад +19

    I always check my valve lash setting while the engine is running. You just have to be quick about putting the feeler gauge in there.

    • @factoryminis3437
      @factoryminis3437 3 года назад +4

      Lol

    • @freedom1439
      @freedom1439 3 года назад

      That’s the way I was taught….

    • @wsfwsf1497
      @wsfwsf1497 3 года назад +2

      My buddy Superman does my adjustments--in fact he can do a couple engines at the same time.

    • @billcat1840
      @billcat1840 3 года назад +2

      I Kno what you mean...I changed my fan belt and I tell ya it's like some kind of machine in there all them parts moving around in there 😂

  • @malamri424
    @malamri424 3 года назад +24

    thanks for testing the air cleaners! great content as always

  • @okjd159
    @okjd159 3 года назад +6

    My dad's master thesis was all about air flow in an engine in 1952. Which agrees with your tests.

  • @robertwest3093
    @robertwest3093 2 года назад +3

    Those 2 inch primary headers surprised the heck out of me! So much for the theory I was taught!

  • @postwar46
    @postwar46 Год назад +1

    Thanks for the undisputable evidence regarding valve lash. I've been in a quandary about this for some time : it's all clear now........ many thanks.

  • @scoutdogfsr
    @scoutdogfsr 3 года назад +3

    I like these guys the best out of all of the "big" shows. They never tell me I can build a 700 hp motor with parts I have laying around. No BS with some solid tech thrown in to every episode.

    • @starcloakstarside9719
      @starcloakstarside9719 2 года назад +1

      Sarcastic. Stock motors and parts can make just as much power and torque as white motors.
      - Joe Biden, probably.

    • @scoutdogfsr
      @scoutdogfsr 2 года назад +1

      @@starcloakstarside9719 you know it brother! My Magpul, comp cams, and let's go Brandon stickers are worth at least 5hp each too!

  • @lukehanlon9965
    @lukehanlon9965 2 года назад +5

    Another awesome episode guys, I'd love to see the effects of those snake oil fule-saver gadgets too. Cheers!

  • @GregSr
    @GregSr 3 года назад +3

    I'm one of those guys that likes to see data backing up the theory. Well done! Thank-you. Subscribed.

  • @greggoett
    @greggoett 3 года назад +19

    Now do a 14" flow thru top.. in hot engine bay.. vs a Spectre dual 3" inlets to tubes out thru the radiator core support or high beam headlight buckets.

    • @trillrifaxegrindor4411
      @trillrifaxegrindor4411 3 года назад +1

      easy,cool air works,flow through lids in an enclosed engine compartment do not.open element air cleaners don't work well in an enclosed,hot engine compartment either........good enclosed air cleaner housing,free flow air filter and dual inlets sucking cold air #1.....theres a reason ram air works

    • @greggoett
      @greggoett 3 года назад +1

      @Derek Young yeah.. but 13 hp increase on stock heads.. that's great. 65F drop.. that's a good deal

    • @greggoett
      @greggoett 3 года назад

      If this was more of a build show.. maybe team up with one of the other shows.. team up and build a real cold air / ram air intake. Weld together a sheet metal filter housing, ducts off that, tubing to firewall.. etc.

    • @roymcdre9180
      @roymcdre9180 2 года назад

      Agreed. That ram air should be nearly same as the open filters sucking in air super heated by cheap ass non coated headers lol

  • @crw3673
    @crw3673 2 года назад +3

    This was very informative! Kind of like myths buster. But like you point out, these changes become relevant the larger the engine.

  • @johnclary729
    @johnclary729 3 года назад +11

    This tracks with the Engine Masters episode from a couple of years ago on the same subject, almost exactly.

  • @farqend
    @farqend 3 года назад +9

    Great video, guys. Back in the eighties I tried disconnecting my alternator at the strip and running just on the battery. To my surprise I had better times with the alternator connected. More stable and slightly higher voltage.
    Keep up the good work.

    • @muimasmacho
      @muimasmacho 3 года назад +2

      Positive rotational mass, with the kinetic energy working to help the engine recover after gear changes.
      Not all rotation mass is your enemy.

    • @jediknight129
      @jediknight129 2 года назад

      it depends on the build you have and precisely what accessories you have on there. it gets real complex real quick.

  • @PFLEONARDI0906
    @PFLEONARDI0906 2 года назад +1

    Great video, and the summary of the stats was icing on the cake!

  • @garryhatchett775
    @garryhatchett775 3 года назад +25

    How about testing in real world street rpm ranges like 2500-5500?

    • @trillrifaxegrindor4411
      @trillrifaxegrindor4411 3 года назад

      i agree,sadly this isnt exciting on the dyno

    • @stanleykendziorski7964
      @stanleykendziorski7964 3 года назад +1

      My question is why they're pulling it 500rpms past peak horsepower.. just making noise and wear and tear at that point.. and the way it rolls over so fast, I would say its valve train isn't happy

  • @karlsmith2570
    @karlsmith2570 3 года назад +4

    Overall, this was definitely very helpful for what to consider when building an engine for your next project vehicle

  • @cemeteryhill
    @cemeteryhill 3 года назад +56

    "I literally have hunting boots that are older than you."
    Now that's a flex if I ever heard one.

    • @Larcona_
      @Larcona_ 3 года назад +1

      Why?

    • @MrTheHillfolk
      @MrTheHillfolk 3 года назад +6

      @@Larcona_ he's just a kid , he might be pretty savvy but only time will bring the speed that comes with experience.
      I've trained a few new guys at my job , and I can do a typical service in an hour , maybe 1:15.
      After a week of them being on their own ,they come up and say holy crap it's taking me 1:30 or more you're good !!
      Settle down little fella, the speed will come with time.
      Don't go for speed , ask yourself if the olady likes when you finish fast 😝

    • @ChachoGSX
      @ChachoGSX 3 года назад

      I was looking for this.

    • @Larcona_
      @Larcona_ 3 года назад +2

      @@MrTheHillfolk So after one week they're around 15 minutes off your time, not a huge difference. Also age and experience aren't necessarily correlative. Oh and your example is just being accustomed to a specific routine, which isn't all that important when it comes to building custom engines.

    • @scottyV1000
      @scottyV1000 3 года назад

      I like the little quizzes Pat gives the kid most weeks. He's doing pretty good too.

  • @hagen8745
    @hagen8745 2 года назад +5

    I'd love to see if any of this makes a difference on say a stock 5.3 or 5.7. I am guessing the higher HP shows a more dramatic increase HP increase with better flow from headers and air cleaners.

  • @reverend099
    @reverend099 3 года назад +2

    Lash setting, that depends on the engine series. My Cobrajet FE I tested more than once to make sure it was not a fluke. Iron head Iron block. .0015 smaller cold.

  • @bmxrider71
    @bmxrider71 3 года назад +8

    I'd love to see how much HP is lost due to AC units. A LOT of us older guys want our hot rods but like the comfort of an AC

    • @jediknight129
      @jediknight129 2 года назад +1

      it can get crazy that's one of the scary ones.

    • @kevinfloyd808
      @kevinfloyd808 11 месяцев назад +1

      Would be good test, but main question is what does the weight and the drag of the pulley cost you. Cause in the 5 % of the time your going hard, full throttle, wrapping the tach to top of power curve..id assume air is off both for power and because the compressor is coming apart if not.

  • @jlfastride1
    @jlfastride1 3 года назад +5

    Would've be interesting to see the effects of running and outerwears pre filter on them last 2 tests...

  • @mikestewart7338
    @mikestewart7338 3 года назад

    Very important information. Great job!

  • @70_Torino_Guy
    @70_Torino_Guy 3 года назад +2

    Keep the lessons coming. Love that 408w! 🍻

  • @ricepony33
    @ricepony33 3 года назад +16

    How about some catalytic converter testing, standard vs high flow.

    • @crimsonstang
      @crimsonstang 3 года назад +4

      Power Nation? Cats? HAHA

    • @aleklukacs6170
      @aleklukacs6170 3 года назад

      No cats

    • @ryanroberts1104
      @ryanroberts1104 3 года назад +2

      People who build motors like that do not use cats. Ever.

    • @josephschaefer9163
      @josephschaefer9163 3 года назад

      I melted the front of a cheap cat a little bit. Too much exhaust heat from running rich

    • @snowcrest7863
      @snowcrest7863 3 года назад

      High quality CAT has little effect on H.P. numbers. Mufflers and full exhaust pipe have much, much larger effect.

  • @toddperry9860
    @toddperry9860 3 года назад +55

    Does Pat really need the entire staple store of writing instruments in his top pocket?

    • @JSCB-365
      @JSCB-365 3 года назад +4

      Pat used to teach at an engine building school, students there were horrible about not having the correct writing utensils with them.

    • @TwoAMBlacktop
      @TwoAMBlacktop 3 года назад +2

      He's got a couple pens and a pencil, maybe a marker in there, everything else are pocket tools

    • @CathodeRayNipplez
      @CathodeRayNipplez 3 года назад +1

      @YOYO MA Bwahahahahah!

    • @ragman069
      @ragman069 3 года назад +2

      PPP
      Pocket Protector Pat
      BOOM

    • @rustychevy2087
      @rustychevy2087 3 года назад +8

      That's his mechanic ranking system. He's basically a five star general LOL

  • @mikecurtis2585
    @mikecurtis2585 3 года назад +1

    Good information. Thanks 😊!!

  • @mwaynem
    @mwaynem 3 года назад

    Good work guys. Thanks for the info.

  • @socalltd
    @socalltd 3 года назад +3

    would like to see the A/F numbers with all these pulls on the headers and air filters.

  • @adhithyasodhi3203
    @adhithyasodhi3203 3 года назад +3

    Thanks, this sort of stuff is always interesting to see on different engine combos. Need a piece on the effects of Pat's pocket pens / tools combos as well :)

  • @ronjon4010
    @ronjon4010 3 года назад +1

    Great info ! Thanks !

  • @crabbyfrog
    @crabbyfrog 3 года назад

    Love this, do more of these!

  • @hunterjones9822
    @hunterjones9822 3 года назад +5

    Pat has those shirt pockets at max capacity

    • @bmstylee
      @bmstylee 3 года назад

      High capacity pockets.

  • @tomhamilton9140
    @tomhamilton9140 3 года назад +3

    Would like to see 1 3/4 header in this test. Nice test for the Ford 408 thank you.

  • @danw.8180
    @danw.8180 3 года назад

    Very good, I like this kind of testing. Thanks...

  • @dereckhernandez5945
    @dereckhernandez5945 3 года назад +1

    Love the video thanks for the tips but I was wondering if y’all can do a Tahoe upgrade to the max like a sleeper truck

  • @timgresdal3617
    @timgresdal3617 3 года назад +6

    The amount of load produced by an alternator on an engine is related more the the current than the voltage.
    P=V x A
    Being that V is a regulated value ( ~14.4V). It would have been nice to know the current value during the alternator run on the dyno. But don't get me wrong. I love your show.

    • @bobroberts2371
      @bobroberts2371 3 года назад

      It is pretty straightforward to estimate alternator losses. Measure current draw of all accessories needed to run the engine, measure voltage and multiply to get Watts. Add 20% in order to account for electrical losses, some small amount for alt fan windage and belt / bearing losses then divide by 745 to get HP ( One hp is 745 Watts ) Now, there are intermittent loads like recharging the battery after cranking but this can go away after the engine has run for a while.

    • @mattquarles7029
      @mattquarles7029 2 года назад

      Alternator draw on engine power will be different on smaller engines. In my experience a good high performance alternator made for racing usually takes less than 1hp draw in V8 engines. Too much displacement for that little pulley to make a difference even with full accessories.

    • @JamieBainbridge
      @JamieBainbridge 2 года назад

      @@bobroberts2371 or in other words, 51A @ 14.4V takes 1hp to drive

  • @johnnymula2305
    @johnnymula2305 3 года назад +6

    Everyones always building for Horsepower. I would love to see a 5.0 Torque build. I’m searching the web and have yet to see any quality content out there.
    Those of us that have Full Sized Broncos with 5.0’s (and dont want to buy a new bigger cube motor) would love to get low to mid range numbers up. We’re not interested in high RPM.

    • @albertgaspar627
      @albertgaspar627 3 года назад +1

      you're halfway there--the Ford ran smaller valves and ports than a Chevy. The 351 W will do better because in theory, its taller deck makes for longer intake runners, and that helps over a 347 stroker. Go check your local boneyard for the last year Explorer to get a 302 pushrod--it has the GT40P heads, best things to ever come on a Windsor. The spark plug angles will require their own headers, a Fox Body Mustang stock equipment won't fit.
      don't bother with the Mustang EFI intake either--its a nice design, but its size means it soaks up heat with all that surface area. If you REALLY wanna get crazy, know that the Boss 302 ran longer connecting rods--from the 289. But not everyone jumps on the "long connecting rod" bandwagon.
      pick a header length you can live with (depending upon body lift, etc) and call the cam companies for what they recommend. If accessories robbing power bothers you, the ford contour had a great set of electric fans--you can look online anywhere for the swap of these junkyard (ie, cheaper than aftermarket) parts.

    • @ryanroberts1104
      @ryanroberts1104 3 года назад +1

      They aren't interested in old outdated non performance vehicles that few people own anymore. Broncos have all but disappeared from the roads. If you can't swap a larger junkyard engine for almost nothing chances are you can't do much else...

    • @bradnimbus4836
      @bradnimbus4836 3 года назад +1

      Jesus, don't listen to either of these dopes. Start with gears and then work your way down from the top of the carburetor. 4.10's will wake that ol' girl up!

    • @ineffable1129
      @ineffable1129 3 года назад +1

      That about runner length and cam, it's never going to be great with 5.0 Ford because of the 3" stroke. With your limitation a procharger would give you the simplest big results any form of boost really would give you what you are after and then some.

    • @johnnymula2305
      @johnnymula2305 3 года назад +2

      @@ryanroberts1104 you do realize that theres tens of thousands of 80’s to late 90’s Ford trucks on the road, right? And the Torque would also work for any truck. Weather 2 or 4 wheel drive. So my question is extremely relevant to whats currently on the road. And trails.

  • @MrTrueshoe
    @MrTrueshoe Год назад

    Very cool to watch and learn some from this

  • @STREETFIGHTER50
    @STREETFIGHTER50 8 месяцев назад

    Nice tests! Good to see the air filter I like making good HP!

  • @KYMarty
    @KYMarty 3 года назад +6

    Good test but you left out having the fan on when testing the accessories. I would think that would be the biggest drag of the accessories you tested.

    • @maddog9659
      @maddog9659 3 года назад

      Yep and with a shroud drawing air through radiator = death to horsepower

    • @stanleykendziorski7964
      @stanleykendziorski7964 3 года назад +1

      Worth 30hp with a fixed, factory style 6 blade fan

  • @brucehirsch5437
    @brucehirsch5437 3 года назад +6

    I'd like to see dyno results on cold air intakes.

    • @starcloakstarside9719
      @starcloakstarside9719 2 года назад

      Contrary. With the exception of the stock air cleaner, these are all “cold-air intakes.” I recon you’re talking about an autoparts store universal off-the-shelf part designed for a modern MAFS EFI motor, and to that I’d say don’t bother. It will throw off your Mass Air Flow Sensor and mess with your Air:Fuel ratio due to the lower restriction.
      Elaboration. Might even be enough to lean out your motor and contribute to lower fuel economy and lower power. Even if you’re talking about a carbureted motor, an open element filter is probably going to be cheaper. I think I’ve got a Mr. Gasket open element filter that cost me $14 compared to the $40-$60 that the EFI-style ones will run you.
      Conclusive. So unless you want to spend that plus $500 for a shop to reprogram your car or $1,500 for the equipment to do it yourself, it’s not going to be worth it. And even if Power Nation did do an episode on those things, it would probably do more harm than good over all.

    • @tylhunt
      @tylhunt 2 года назад

      @@starcloakstarside9719 Unless the car is being run without a hood, those are not cold air intakes.

  • @mrelectron6220
    @mrelectron6220 3 года назад +2

    Was interesting to watch I've seen other dyno videos showing only a net gain of maybe 4 HP with electric water pump and could not justify the $$ to HP gains for that mod.
    Every thing else fell into place with what I expected.

  • @THROTTLEPOWER
    @THROTTLEPOWER 3 года назад +2

    Great vid, really enjoyed!!!!!!!! 👌 👍 👌

  • @Henry-fx4yk
    @Henry-fx4yk 3 года назад +5

    It would be helpful to have a summary chart for all the runs at the end of the video.

  • @michaelglenn2106
    @michaelglenn2106 3 года назад +3

    I want to see a similarity sized turbo vs supercharger on the the same engine and see which really makes more power

    • @TeamGeezer
      @TeamGeezer 2 года назад

      The Turbo should win every time. A Supercharger requires a bunch of HP just to drive it. The Turbo with the exception of some exhaust restriction is basically free HP.

  • @ModernBeastx1
    @ModernBeastx1 2 года назад

    Just broke a million subs gratsss!!! @POWERNATION

  • @cmsracing
    @cmsracing 3 года назад

    I learned some stuff, thanks for posting!

  • @nicolascreech6367
    @nicolascreech6367 3 года назад +8

    Yall forgot the fans in the accessory test...

    • @BobbyOfEarth
      @BobbyOfEarth 3 года назад

      ..then add a power steering pump.

    • @albertgaspar627
      @albertgaspar627 3 года назад +2

      The accessory test alone could have been a mini show....use oversized pullies, run an electric fan draw on that battery, a serpentine belt with idler pulley adding drag, et cetera.

  • @thomasbrown7728
    @thomasbrown7728 3 года назад +85

    I guess I’m just a grumpy old man, but I can’t stand all of the background music when someone is talking. Too much Hollywood

    • @illililililillli
      @illililililillli 3 года назад +9

      Boomer

    • @muimasmacho
      @muimasmacho 3 года назад +5

      I agree.
      That narrator sumbitch keeps breaking through in spots. Annoying as a rod-knock.
      *We're only here for the robo-cheesy adrenyline junkie moosic, right?*
      Drama queens in shop aprons. 😶

    • @frenchenstein
      @frenchenstein 3 года назад

      @@illililililillli ' cough

    • @donaldfrazier5244
      @donaldfrazier5244 3 года назад +7

      We don’t want a show we are trying to obtain information not go to a concert you’re making enough money for these pods so keep it simple for us knuckle draggers ! Too bad you don’t do the actual work to these engines otherwise you’d have some grease under your manicured fingernails! Hollywood Boys

    • @jimcooper5392
      @jimcooper5392 3 года назад +3

      @@donaldfrazier5244 I guess I'm a Boomer geezer too. I don't need all that damn drum beating to pound information into my head.

  • @peter455sd
    @peter455sd 3 года назад

    Very nice guys,very thorough

  • @merc-ni7hy
    @merc-ni7hy 3 года назад +2

    that would be a nice little motor for something like a first gen camaro ...and i like the cleveland style valve covers

  • @aidanrussell-smith4619
    @aidanrussell-smith4619 3 года назад +7

    love this shit

  • @TheVoice010
    @TheVoice010 3 года назад +12

    I wonder how Engine Masters feels about this Episode🤔

    • @yarpos
      @yarpos 2 года назад

      are they still around?

    • @carbonfiber492
      @carbonfiber492 2 года назад +1

      The fact they seemed to ether not know or pretend to not know how pre throttle vacuum effects power I’d say engine masters aren’t to worried

    • @justinvowels2284
      @justinvowels2284 2 года назад +1

      I knew if I scrolled thru the comments I would find a comment about ripping off engine masters lol.

    • @TheVoice010
      @TheVoice010 2 года назад

      @Satchel McQueen Video yeah...its all about the Money now..used to be free

    • @TheVoice010
      @TheVoice010 2 года назад

      @@carbonfiber492 lol

  • @Wrenchen-with-Darren
    @Wrenchen-with-Darren 2 года назад

    Great video, thanks👍

  • @durtmotors9782
    @durtmotors9782 3 года назад

    Awesome show guys!! And both of the guys are perfect for the show.

  • @robertsnyder1330
    @robertsnyder1330 3 года назад +3

    Great tutorial, but increasing air flow changes air/fuel ratios...can we get this test with keeping a/f ratio consistent ?(carb jet change to keep ratio at about 13.7-14.2)

    • @timothydillon6421
      @timothydillon6421 3 года назад

      Changing the air flow also changes the pressure differential in the venturini. More air is faster air and lower pressure and more suck and more fuel.

    • @nerd1000ify
      @nerd1000ify 3 года назад

      Just stop messing about and use fuel injection.

  • @darkwolfshadowv1
    @darkwolfshadowv1 3 года назад +3

    Throwing shade on engine masters. Clapped out 305. 😂

    • @JSCB-365
      @JSCB-365 3 года назад +1

      But they didn't try the salad bowl Engine masters found a few ponies hidden in that trick

    • @billgates1682
      @billgates1682 3 года назад

      I guess they thought it was best, for some odd reason, to make fun of them since they essentially (poorly) copied some of EM's past episodes. These dudes will never compete with EM, lol 🤣

  • @371francis
    @371francis 3 года назад

    Awesome video guys!!

  • @Leethal1
    @Leethal1 3 года назад

    Great tests guys!

  • @tonkatoytruck
    @tonkatoytruck 3 года назад +5

    what about power steering and A/C?

    • @bmstylee
      @bmstylee 3 года назад +2

      A/C only drags when the compressor is engaged. Otherwise it's an idler pulley. On modern cars power steering is moot given its generally not hydraulic. But I can see it drawing a good chunk to push the fluid on a pump style system. Hydraulic fluid ain't water that's for sure.

  • @davidpryor4742
    @davidpryor4742 3 года назад +3

    The drag/load from the Alternator would increase with a increase in demand from many of today's needs - ex: fuel pump, ECU's, ignition systems, etc.

    • @dukecraig2402
      @dukecraig2402 3 года назад +1

      Exactly, in the days of V belts on car engines you could get in a car on a frosty morning and after you start it up turn on the rear window defogger and listen to the belt start squealing, shut it off and it quits.
      Just charging a battery isn't proof on that test, they needed to load the system like it would be with the headlights, rear defogger and wipers on, then see what happens.

    • @timothydillon6421
      @timothydillon6421 3 года назад

      @@dukecraig2402 I am now dumber from reading this.

    • @dukecraig2402
      @dukecraig2402 3 года назад

      @@timothydillon6421
      Why exactly is that? What part don't you get?

    • @timothydillon6421
      @timothydillon6421 3 года назад

      @@dukecraig2402 you can draw hundreds of amps from a battery or even 1000 but the alternator only charges it at 75 to 100. A dead battery will certainly max out the draw on an alternator.

    • @dukecraig2402
      @dukecraig2402 3 года назад

      @@timothydillon6421
      What makes you think the battle is dead?

  • @Tk-ou9ec
    @Tk-ou9ec 3 года назад +1

    One thing I do know is that with my old Datsun I fell victim to the washable,more breathable air filter. So I bought a 2.5 by 10 inch to go into the factory air cleaner housing. I noticed immediately upon driving it that the initial take off or acceleration was down( a lack of torque). I drove it like this for about a week as I thought, naaaaah can’t be,but it was. I changed it back to its normal paper filter and voila,torque came back,much better take off. I’m guessing that the extra air flow created to much turbulence which in turn affected performance?!
    Either way. I won’t buy washable again!

    • @e-curb
      @e-curb 2 года назад +1

      Or that high-flow was more restrictive.

  • @ArjanBeudeker
    @ArjanBeudeker 2 года назад

    Very interesting, thanks!

  • @chrisbouchard4719
    @chrisbouchard4719 3 года назад +3

    I'd ike to see how much an ac compressor does. I've always heard accessories listed as robbing a % of hp, I'd like to see that tested. It seems more logical that the same accessory drive on different hp engines would rob the same horsepower, regardless of hp level

    • @markg7030
      @markg7030 3 года назад

      I agree.

    • @NBSV1
      @NBSV1 3 года назад

      If it spins the accessory at the same rpm and the accessory has the same load it will pull the same power.

  • @evi1dav3
    @evi1dav3 3 года назад +3

    8:21 just left of the water pump I thought I saw something fall off. Loose bolt?

    • @thelol1759
      @thelol1759 3 года назад +1

      I saw that too

    • @evi1dav3
      @evi1dav3 3 года назад +1

      @@thelol1759 at least I'm not the only one.

    • @realdeathpony
      @realdeathpony 3 года назад

      washer

  • @bafigueroa21
    @bafigueroa21 3 года назад

    Awesome episode!

  • @eddieb4227
    @eddieb4227 2 года назад +2

    Vizard the wizard wrote a really good in depth book on the air cleaner issue. It's worth getting a copy. I gave mine to a younger guy at the shop getting into drag racing.
    One thing that really increased hp was the carb coffin.

    • @chrislore2681
      @chrislore2681 10 месяцев назад +1

      He's a smart......smart guy

  • @betthat313
    @betthat313 3 года назад +4

    You missed the 1 3/4 headers ..

  • @lawrencefoster2120
    @lawrencefoster2120 3 года назад +5

    I mean you wouldn't even put that ugly thing on if it increased hp but wow 80hp loss.

  • @mattyallwood
    @mattyallwood 3 года назад

    Great episode guys keep it up

  • @kevinclancy.
    @kevinclancy. 2 года назад

    great video, never knew that about the lash, wow I've been wrong for decades!

  • @chrismorton9736
    @chrismorton9736 3 года назад +8

    Your alternator test was flawed. When testing the alternator you should have loaded the alternator to its maximum rated current and then completely removed the alternator from the engine as was done with the water pump test. The alternator has other parasitic loads other than the eKw load such as windage from the fan/rotor . This comment is about the way the test was conducted only!!

    • @mpugne
      @mpugne 3 года назад

      still pretty easy to figure out a solid approx number. lets say the alt outputs 100A at 14.4 so 1440 watts/745=1.93hp. just an approx peak number but close enough.

    • @chrismorton9736
      @chrismorton9736 3 года назад

      @@mpugne its not about the result its about the test condition

    • @mpugne
      @mpugne 3 года назад

      @@chrismorton9736 which max current rating should they have used? idle, 2000rpm (what most stock replacements use for rating), or red line which will be the highest. in the end you are still going to be within the error factor of the dyno its self.

    • @eddieb4227
      @eddieb4227 2 года назад

      Exactly what I thought. No parasitic load. Cummins on all of their electronic engine control the charging system. It has to see oil pressure before it will energize the field circuit.
      I have seen mechanical diesel engine stall out when starting in cold temperatures. They go to full field until the regulator can pull back. On a 300 Amp alternator that's a lot of umph!
      At one time a 65 Amp alternator was huge. Then the Asian market came out with 120 amp.

    • @tylhunt
      @tylhunt 2 года назад

      @@mpugne Standard alternator is only about 55-60% efficient.

  • @Stone177
    @Stone177 3 года назад +3

    What happen to the other guy?

    • @Carlos.Rivera
      @Carlos.Rivera 3 года назад +1

      Mike?

    • @Stone177
      @Stone177 3 года назад

      @@Carlos.Rivera that's his name. I thought it was Gilbert.

    • @kriscarter5440
      @kriscarter5440 3 года назад +1

      Mike Galley. No clue. But LT (Lawrence Tollman) has also left but has a growing following on his RUclips channel.

    • @bmstylee
      @bmstylee 3 года назад +1

      Once Tommy leaves it will become completely unwatchable.

  • @samhicks97
    @samhicks97 Год назад +2

    Would have been cool to see tests also with standard/flat/humped/ velocity stack air cleaner base and see if there is a temperature/HP change.
    No matter still a great video.

  • @iancook7315
    @iancook7315 Год назад +1

    Hey POWERNATION I would love to see a test using forced air ... more over like the scoop, every dyne test I have seen with a scoop is done in static conditions (no moving air). Granted the other test you did in this video the engine is likely under a hood, however when those "T-Bucket" hot rudders put that scoop on, it is usually catching air at speed, forcing air into the engine. A lot of modern hot rodders that have their engine under and enclosed hood are using ducting from a removed headlight, ducted to the engine, forcing air at speed much the same. I would love to see the difference that forced air makes. I am sure the air would need to be gradually increased to simulate different speeds.

  • @spoogethat
    @spoogethat 3 года назад +6

    so pretty much ripping off of engine masters, they covered all of this

    • @genwatie2191
      @genwatie2191 3 года назад +5

      Yep except you don't have to pay to watch the full episodes

    • @johnmonroe961
      @johnmonroe961 3 года назад +2

      Well I won’t say they ripped them off. Maybe a different check. I mean I m not go of one resource.

    • @genwatie2191
      @genwatie2191 3 года назад +2

      Oh and engine masters is basically a rip off of engine power. Engine Power has been on a lot longer then engine masters.

    • @TwoAMBlacktop
      @TwoAMBlacktop 3 года назад

      @@genwatie2191 Not really. Engine Masters is full dyno testing. Really if you want to get into it, Engine Power is a rip off of Hot Rod.

    • @spoogethat
      @spoogethat 3 года назад

      @@genwatie2191 not accurate, engine masters has been around for a long time, it was a magazine as well as a builders challenge long before the motor trend show, as well as saying these guys dont rip off of motor trend is a joke. I mean the show carcuss is a direct rip off of roadkill, then all their little "extras" didnt start until roadkill extra, dirt everyday extra, etc.

  • @jeffpelletier5186
    @jeffpelletier5186 3 года назад +8

    This formula of show is so dated. It’s like watching an accountant and a banker trying to be car guys.

  • @GonzoDonzo
    @GonzoDonzo 3 года назад +2

    I wish I had overlayed the belt driven pump vs the electric pump. It looked like the torque stayed up significantly higher in the higher rpm range. Not surprised by the alternator outcome. 1hp can produce around 1kw of power.

  • @kenswitzer4133
    @kenswitzer4133 3 года назад

    The filter demonstration is great.

  • @BeauAmoureux
    @BeauAmoureux 3 года назад +3

    Great video. However, “Engine Masters” tested all these myths years ago. 🤷🏿‍♂️

    • @karlx-1
      @karlx-1 3 года назад +2

      But you have to pay to watch EM.

    • @johnnikollaj496
      @johnnikollaj496 3 года назад +1

      @@karlx-1 Exactly

  • @jessemurray1757
    @jessemurray1757 3 года назад +3

    this show is too scripted, which i fear is its Achilles Heel .

  • @zenriderx
    @zenriderx 10 месяцев назад

    3:18 I was taught the "Go/No Go" method. It is much more reliable. Use the feeler size bigger than the spec, it shouldn't slide in, and the size smaller than spec should fall through. Then if preferred yoy can slide the spec gauge through for a "feel". Different parts will have different textures (new and worn) and will have radically different drag feedback. Use the go/no go method and eliminate that variable and move on to the next project 😁👍

  • @jeremybggs
    @jeremybggs 3 года назад

    Thanks for the test pat

  • @chrisgabbert658
    @chrisgabbert658 3 года назад

    This was good seeing the results 👍

  • @GTStuning-
    @GTStuning- 3 года назад +1

    It made 2 more ft lbs of torque with the filtered lid combo (518) versus no filter at all (516) on the test with accessories being ran.

  • @TheIrishPhantom
    @TheIrishPhantom 2 года назад

    So hot metal expands and you would think that would tighten up the valve clearances but in fact does the opposite. Learn something every day. Pullet the tappet off my bike today and sure enough... You guys know your stuff.

  • @srinivasvaranasi1645
    @srinivasvaranasi1645 3 года назад

    Great learning!