NOT TRUE! Krystian Zimerman so over-rated pianist! Krystian Zimerman his Brahms piano concerto no 1 with Bernstein is The most dull stiff Mechanical Boring playing ever! Zimerman The first movement coda Brahms piano concerto no 1 with Bernstein is The most Mechanical stiff machine playing ever! The Best greatest Chopin piano concerto no 2 players Are really=1: Grigory Sokolov ( The Best beutiful piano sound! Sokolov The most rhythmic vital beat! Unbeatable vitalness! Sokolov The most Titanic Chopin piano concerto no 2 ever! 2: Artur Rubinstein ( The GOD of Chopin piano concerto no 2 player! Rubinstein The Golden piano tone sound for Chopin piano concerto no 2) 3: Vladimir Ashkenazy ( The most colorful volcanic piano sound Ever for Chopin piano concerto no 2! Ashkenazy a class of his own playing Chopin piano concerto no 2)
Raed Al-Sabbab No, the best version is Zimerman's 1999 recording (together with the frist piano concerto) with the Polnish Festival Orchestra and Zimerman himself conducting!
Zimerman is a dull Robot with colorless piano sound! The Best Chopin piano concerto no 2 players are Really=Artur Rubinstein Vladimir Ashkenazy Grigory Sokolov! Rubinstein the golden tone! Ashkenazy had volcano colorful sound! Sokolov had the Best piano sound! Sokolov his rhythmic vitalness is unbeatable! Sokolov the most Titanic Chopin no 2!!
I am surprised DG never issued this when Karajan died as he never recorded it commercially and he conducts it very well; Zimerman is superb; so fresh...
For sure Karajan conduct these concert, took place in Lucerne in 1980. If you have a look at the Karajan-Institut, you could see, the they repeat it in Salzburg at the same year. They made no recording because Zimerman redcorded it with Giulini.
The Best Chopin piano concerto no 2 players really Are Artur Rubinstein Grigory Sokolov ( The Best piano sound The most Titanic version Ever) Vladimir Ashkenazy recording from 1963 Ashkenazy his piano sound Second to none The Best! The greatest pianists of All Time Are really Artur Rubinstein Grigory Sokolov Emil Gilels Radu Lupu Mikhail Pletnev Sviatoslav Richter Maurizio Pollini Vladimir Ashkenazy Alexei Lubimov Stanislav Igolinsky ( better than Lipatti) Solomon Cutner Maria Grinberg Natalia Trull! Zimerman his Brahms piano concerto no 1 with Bernstein is The most dullard dull Boring stiff machine playing ever! The first mvt coda is so mechanical Boring stiff dull machine playing ever!!
I mean, even if you have never known about the existence of this performance, just listening to it for a few seconds and Karajan is confirmed at the wheel without mistake !! This fine chirp of the orchestra, the emotional handling of every phrase, the impeccable legato, the aggressive fury of the tutti and especially the final few bars...No, this IS Karajan, no mistake and this recording is THE best rendition of this brilliant concerto !! Zimermann here rightfully belongs !!!! I have compared it to most available recordings, the Zimermann'99 including.!!! Nobody even gets close !!! Thank you, Maestro !!
Czapki z głów !!!!!! Świetne wykonanie-pianisty/ jak zwykle/ orkiestra musi jeszcze trochę poćwiczyć by dorównać MISTRZOWI-ZIMERMANOWI GRATULUJĘ !!!!!!!!!!
In Berlin, Karajan will not play this song.Cause in Lucerna. Playing with Giulini in the Los Angeles Philharmonic Orchestra is quite good. The orchestra sings well. Giulini is re-studying Chopin.But 1999 is very best.
I think, that this concerto Karajan does not conduct !!!! I looked in Zimmermann discography. Karajan conducts only Schumann and Grieg concertos in performance of Zimmenrmann !!!!!
Цимерман гений!Восхищаюсь его интерпретациями Бетховена,Шуберта, Шопена,Грига,Шумана,Брамса,Листа,Равеля,Рахманинова ... вот уже 30 лет.
Oh man what a dream duo- Karajan and Zimerman!
After 37 years , sounds still beautiful and Zimerman's playing is excellent as always !!
Zimerman is the God of piano!
NOT TRUE! Krystian Zimerman so over-rated pianist! Krystian Zimerman his Brahms piano concerto no 1 with Bernstein is The most dull stiff Mechanical Boring playing ever! Zimerman The first movement coda Brahms piano concerto no 1 with Bernstein is The most Mechanical stiff machine playing ever! The Best greatest Chopin piano concerto no 2 players Are really=1: Grigory Sokolov ( The Best beutiful piano sound! Sokolov The most rhythmic vital beat! Unbeatable vitalness! Sokolov The most Titanic Chopin piano concerto no 2 ever! 2: Artur Rubinstein ( The GOD of Chopin piano concerto no 2 player! Rubinstein The Golden piano tone sound for Chopin piano concerto no 2) 3: Vladimir Ashkenazy ( The most colorful volcanic piano sound Ever for Chopin piano concerto no 2! Ashkenazy a class of his own playing Chopin piano concerto no 2)
Piękno muzyki Fryderyka Chopina to fenomen graniczący z cudem.
Divine performance ,bravo .
Karajan the best of the best.
One of the best versions of Chopin's Piano Concerto No. 2
Raed Al-Sabbab No, the best version is Zimerman's 1999 recording (together with the frist piano concerto) with the Polnish Festival Orchestra and Zimerman himself conducting!
+MusikPiratCH 1999 NO.2 is not best. too much old style performace...
Brian Schmit For me it is! There is NO better performance on any recording! :D
@@MusikPiratCH ruclips.net/video/QdpDXM78NT0/видео.html
Definitely, this is the best
@@cookieoreo713 Your opinion not mine! ;)
Quite simply the best performance ever of this wonderful concerto . HvK and Zimerman made up a fine partnership
Zimerman is a dull Robot with colorless piano sound! The Best Chopin piano concerto no 2 players are Really=Artur Rubinstein Vladimir Ashkenazy Grigory Sokolov! Rubinstein the golden tone! Ashkenazy had volcano colorful sound! Sokolov had the Best piano sound! Sokolov his rhythmic vitalness is unbeatable! Sokolov the most Titanic Chopin no 2!!
It's really satisfying performance !
Legendary class
First time I heard.
Surprised about this discover !
Thank you!!
I am surprised DG never issued this when Karajan died as he never recorded it commercially and he conducts it very well; Zimerman is superb; so fresh...
la perfection....
super koncerto !!!! karajan chopin?? really? wow .sound is perfect karajan.
For sure Karajan conduct these concert, took place in Lucerne in 1980. If you have a look at the Karajan-Institut, you could see, the they repeat it in Salzburg at the same year. They made no recording because Zimerman redcorded it with Giulini.
Simply: Greatest!!!!!!
The Best Chopin piano concerto no 2 players really Are Artur Rubinstein Grigory Sokolov ( The Best piano sound The most Titanic version Ever) Vladimir Ashkenazy recording from 1963 Ashkenazy his piano sound Second to none The Best! The greatest pianists of All Time Are really Artur Rubinstein Grigory Sokolov Emil Gilels Radu Lupu Mikhail Pletnev Sviatoslav Richter Maurizio Pollini Vladimir Ashkenazy Alexei Lubimov Stanislav Igolinsky ( better than Lipatti) Solomon Cutner Maria Grinberg Natalia Trull! Zimerman his Brahms piano concerto no 1 with Bernstein is The most dullard dull Boring stiff machine playing ever! The first mvt coda is so mechanical Boring stiff dull machine playing ever!!
Zimerman a dull Boring stiff machine player! Zimerman so over-rated pianist!!
It is the first time Chopin Karajan and Zimmerman of listening which is perfect like Rubinstein performance
Wonderful!
i play somtime keybord when is alon ,chopin.my spirit is well and
positive thinking .
karajan conduct very nice.
Grandiose!.
amazing!!!
I would like to thank the uploader for this jewel. Superb concerto!
Preziosa testimonianza sonora!
🎼📻Volume honorè🎶
great!
I mean, even if you have never known about the existence of this performance, just listening to it for a few seconds and Karajan is confirmed at the wheel without mistake !! This fine chirp of the orchestra, the emotional handling of every phrase, the impeccable legato, the aggressive fury of the tutti and especially the final few bars...No, this IS Karajan, no mistake and this recording is THE best rendition of this brilliant concerto !! Zimermann here rightfully belongs !!!!
I have compared it to most available recordings, the Zimermann'99 including.!!! Nobody even gets close !!!
Thank you, Maestro !!
I agree completely!
A nasterpiece must have passion plus cool reasoning plus a young at heart truly a cup of vintage champagn
Fréderic Chopin:2.f-moll Zongoraverseny op.21
Krystian Zimerman-zongora
Berlini Filharmonikus Zenekar
Vezényel:Herbert von Karajan
Luzern 1980
*
One old one yoyng perfect match
Iconic
Thank you for uploading! I love the photo - does anyone know who was the photographer?
beautiful
thanks for posting
i am interested if you have rare vdos or audio recs.
thanks
this is some good shit
????????
Czapki z głów !!!!!!
Świetne wykonanie-pianisty/ jak zwykle/
orkiestra musi jeszcze trochę poćwiczyć by dorównać MISTRZOWI-ZIMERMANOWI
GRATULUJĘ !!!!!!!!!!
Twierdzisz, że berlińczycy pod Karajanem muszą trochę "poćwiczyć", przecież to śmieszne
@@mauryq2150 Może i śmieszne ale prawdziwe !!!! Wiem co mówię bo sam też grałem ten koncert :)
It is surprising that Karajan conducts as usual even when he addresses himself to apparently unfamiliar Chopin. Oh, that typical Karajan conclusion!
In Berlin, Karajan will not play this song.Cause in Lucerna. Playing with Giulini in the Los Angeles Philharmonic Orchestra is quite good. The orchestra sings well. Giulini is re-studying Chopin.But 1999 is very best.
This does not mean, in the case of a CD recording. This admission could well be taken from the concert behavior.
August 31?
Or Speptember 1?
still prefering Giulini s version but both recordings are wonderful . Much better than the more recent one
🌬🪞💎
I think, that this concerto Karajan does not conduct !!!! I looked in Zimmermann discography. Karajan conducts only Schumann and Grieg concertos in performance of Zimmenrmann !!!!!
HarpsichordA6 is a live recording, not an official release. look at karajan web site the database of his concerts.
goodmanmusica Thank you !
Impossible to find this recording on cd or dvd ?
I dont think so. Karajan is not a Chopin conductor.
He does. Its live performance.
Karajan was elsewhere with his thoughts, I think. Perhaps dreaming of the symphony he was going to conduct after the intermission?
🌬 Un Sublime Concerto .⭕
Une symphonie en cache souvent une autre 👋