What is the difference between the Poynting XPOL-1 vs XPOL-2 Antennas
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- We often find that customer buy based on price, without thinking about the detail of the antenna. This is clearly the problem with an e-commerce online store.
In this video we present both antennas side by side, and give a quick basic overview on the differences between the antennas and what to be on the lookout for.
The Poynting XPOL-2 is a great antenna for directional higher gain applications, and the Poynting XPOL-1 is a very nice antenna for versatile portable and mobile applications.
Just upgraded from XPOL 1 to a 2 V3 and my download speeds have almost doubled In rural Scotland !! Great Antenna Thanks for the info David !!
That’s awesome!
Great! I'm in rural Scotland and have been living with a xpol a0001 for 4 years. The ee mast near our hill just got upgraded to 5g. Hoping to slash out on xpol2 (great video btw!) just need to know how to work it where to point it!.. But just realised I will also have to upgrade my hub!
@@julianbell9586 4G gives my 190 down and 40 up after BT got involved in EE. Used to get 250 down easy but its still pretty great for a none FTTC area. Just move the new Xpol around till you get Signal Strength: close to 100% ! Took me a couple of weeks to find the best spot for it
All my questions answered David, thanks. I'll place an order for the XPOL-2 tomorrow :)
The versatility of the xpol 1s mounting options, is what it wins it for me. You can install it 3 different ways so it does afford you some flexibility and ability to tinker with the reception.
Just ordered xpol-2. Currently getting an average to poor signal without an antenna which translates to 220Mbps to 300Mbps so pretty excited to see what is possible with better signal
I hope / trust it will work well for you!
Good to see you posting again, Suggestion for video would be mounting the Poynting (permanently) on roof types such as tin roof or tiled roof
Great, thanks. I will work on an example.
Been a bit quiet lately, sorry about that. Have lots of material lined-up 👍🏻
i'm getting 250mbps with my XPOL1 V2. i also found that it still makes a difference which way it's pointing, in spite of it apparently being omnidirectional. i got the SNR from 25db to 29db just by turning it 15 degrees. and signal power went from -81db to -76db. i just dont need XPOL2 as my speed is already very high
Indeed, at 250Mbps it’s going to be hard to justify another antenna
How does the XPOL-2 compare in performance to a conventional log periodic MIMO setup? When would one be suggested over the other?
As a general rule the LPDA setup is more suited for the rural areas as it just has that bit of extra gain, in particular in the lower frequency bands where the lower bands offers additional range / reach. This is a very basic cheat sheet (not overly scientific)...suburbs and outskirts can take XPOL-2's. Rural areas get the LPDA.
Sometimes it's also a mechanical consideration, as the LPDA's are heavier and more bulky, where the XPOL-2 is a kilo and a single package.
@@RFShop Ok, thanks for clearing that up for me!
Just a thought, it would probably make for real good content to make videos comparing different antennas and setups to one another in different environments and scenarios to really show what equipment would work best for each application!
@@journeytowellness7096 that’s a great suggestion. Many thanks for that
Bloody awesome explaination, not obvious from images or blurb.
Let's see if the extra is worth it here in blighty (mid wales really) and with 2 cell towers just on the edge of our house and with a hill between both!.
Fingers crossed.
Thanks…much appreciated!
Hi David, can you tell me what the difference in reception is between the MIMO-3-12 and XPOL-1?
Both are applicable to an RV.
Hi Eric, sorry for the late response (9 days in)...
On face value I can only go by what the datasheets tell us. I am more in favour of the MIMO-3 antenna, because of where you can place it and how it can be mounted (i.e. well clear of any obstructions). The XPOL-1, although an omni, is inevitably placed against a surface or obstruction so would not be pure omni in the way I like an omni to be.
Performance wise, though, they are probably very similar
Great crisp video! Well I just have both here to test because I am very unsure on what I need. XPOL1 as 4x4 and XPOL2 2x2 in the highest building of the city. Very curious on how they will perform on 4G and 5G modems.
My goal is to have highest stability with lowest ping. XPOL2 does 42ms ping in 4G so far... thats why I test the 4x4 omni too.
I have a Netgear LB1120 and am looking at the XPOL-2 versus a MIMO LPDA from Waveform versus the new Amplimax? In a rural area in Texas about 4 miles from the tower, No tress within 500 feet from the house, but depending on how high I can mount the antenna, I might have some tree tops as obstacles ...Any suggestions? Thanks,
Hi J. If it's that remote I would look at the MIMO LPDA as the strongest option. Those antennas are generally a little bit better on gain, in particular on the lower frequencies.
Hi Sir ! Can i use Xpol-2-5G with Teltonika RUTX14?
Hi. Yes, absolutely...they will work really well together
Hi david I've just bought a tp link mr 200 to get better 4g but made no difference, than on my phone so thinking about getting an poynting attenna,we cant no see the mast because of hill,which one would you advice to get.
Hi Joleen, the XPOL-2 is a good option. You still know which way to point even if the hills is in the way. An omni would give you less gain and chance to make a connection
came for antennae info, stayed for the cat
She's indeed crazy
@@RFShop your videos have been hugely helpful, by the way. I just bought a XPOL-1-5G and and an XPOL-2-5G, and it was your videos that made up my mind, so thank you very much!
@@chrisblumarten much appreciated...thank you :)
@@RFShop no, thank YOU
thank you! which router are u using in this video?
Hi!
I use the Teltonika RUT240 for most of my demostrations
Quick question David: the T-Mobile Nokia 5G gateway supports 4x4 MIMO. If I read your video charts properly, the XPOL-1 supports 4x4 but the XPOL-2 does not. Would that suggest (cost aside) that I could, or should, hang two XPOL-2s outside to take advantage of the 4x4 MIMO? If yes, are there guidelines as to how far apart they should be? I love your videos, they have ben very informative. Thanks for your time.
Great question. There is video from Dr. Andre Fourie on this exact topic. Let me quickly find it...I’ll post a link below
ruclips.net/video/IO_KGrrWoAI/видео.html
@@RFShop Thanks David!
👍👍👍
Thx
Hi sir how are today i hope you are ok i just wanna know which poynting best for this router B618s-22d cause i want give me 100% performance to my router is LTE
Sibo, I would consider the XPOL-2
@@RFShop ok sir but i failed to get 100% while am busy testing my wifi even tower next to me about 60meters what must i do to get 100% like i saw some of videos posted via youtube
@@sibonelogift5061 you may be too close. Try moving at least a few 100m's away and try again
Hi David.Another great video.I'm doing some semi remote camping.I see other campers using these antennas.Would you recommend the XPOL-2 for distance ? Thanks
Hi, yes...for reach I would consider the XPOL-2. Trouble is always that the XPOL-2 is directional and will require more setup. An omni antenna will automatically work, but one is likely to be 6dBi lower...sometimes that is indeed a problem.
@@RFShop Thanks
Great informative vid buddy, I have a Netgear M1 which is only 4G can i connect the Poynting XPOL-1 which is 5G? will it be better for signal vs the Poynting 4G-XPOL-A0001 Cross Polarised 4G Omni LTE Antenna
Thanks Mick
Hi Mick. Yes, most certainly. When we refer to 5G it means that's an additional technology added to the antenna. It is backward compatible, and could do (where applicable), 2G, 3G, 4G and now also 5G.
What distance will the omni one reach. My mast is 3 kilometres away and I have not got line of site
Distance is always a very difficult topic, as it actually depends on too many variables...such as frequency and application as well as what the customer expectation is when talking about distance. 3km should be do-able though
Thanks for the video. You sound South African 🤔
Very much so, born in Pretoria :)
That's the reason I changed the banner on my channel just earlier this week...;)
From Middle east thank you (◠‿◕)
:)