China Blocked Elon Musk's India Plan? Jaishankar On Delhi's Role In West's Digital Security Focus
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 май 2024
- External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar, in this exclusive conversation with Hindustan Times, sheds light on reason behind the cancellation of Elon Musk's planned visit to India, followed by his visit to China shortly after. Jaishankar said that Musk's engagement in China is unrelated to his prospective ventures in India, emphasizing Tesla's already established presence in the Chinese market. Additionally, he discussed the significance of India's 'Make in India' initiative and highlighted the pivotal role of semiconductor chip manufacturers in shaping the future balance of power.
Catch the full interview here: • Jaishankar On Congress...
NEWS | INDIA | INTERNATIONAL NEWS | LATEST NEWS | EXCLUSIVE | PAKISTAN | PoK PROTESTS
#JaishankarSpeaksToHT #Jaishankar #JaishankarExclusive
Hindustan Times Videos brings all the News for the Global Indian under one umbrella. We break down news from across the globe from the unique lens of a Rising India. Tune in for Explainers, Opinions, Analysis and a 360 degree view of big events in India and the World which impact your present and future.
Follow the Hindustan Times Channel on WhatsApp for News Alerts, Top Stories and Editor picks. Join Us Today - www.bit.ly/3PQ4kSv
Subscribe to the Hindustan Times YT channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
Visit our website www.hindustantimes.com/
Follow us on Twitter / httweets
Follow us on Facebook / hindustantimes
I do like Jaishankar. I wish Western foreign ministers were more like him. On the one hand, he does represent India's point of view, but he does not really distort reality to convey that view.
Absolutely!
Your comment is purely relevant with respect to this video also!
Be happy always😊🙏🇮🇳
JaiSankar is an himalyan idiot
jaishankar take responsibility for you inefficiency.. stop your blame game.. 😊 yout just lucky that you have many uneducated supporterss to comment your something big.. you r no where near to shashi tharoor..your son is a US citizen and you talk about make in india😂
Europe cannot afford to stay out of China relationship 🙃
Nobody can afford to stay out of China, including India 😂
Only answer to any nation is allow foreign investments not at the cost of nation and people.
Dr. Jai beautifully explained it. Elon Musk is in China to discuss the future of his existing business there, approval for auto-pilot mode etc., Not to discuss 'either India or China' type issues.
jaishankar take responsibility for you inefficiency.. stop your blame game.. 😊 yout just lucky that you have many uneducated supporterss to comment your something big.. you r no where near to shashi tharoor..your son is a US citizen and you talk about make in india😂
I don't understand why this is not easy to understand to many. This is so simple and direct.
@chinmayau those people are easy to get influenced
@@chinmayau^
No Sir, India is now involved in aiding and abetting genocide, Elon Musk, will distance himself from such countries.
*INDIA WILL KEEP RISING* ❤❤❤
Which part? The water? Heat? Or POPULATION???
Bharat Matha Ki Jai ❤❤❤
@YouCantHandleTheTruth. all aspects.....Nature cannot be tamed, will take efforts and we are upto it.
So do scam call centres will keep growing.
Absolutely, but only due to the fortitude of individuals that strive to better themselves. If you notice Indians abroad improve themselves at a faster rate within structure of a truly Free Market Economy.
U r joking, every gud investor will choose China over any country not only India.
No one asked you mulla
Ok katuwe.
wow. A smart man and a big asset to the Government.
Never trust a businessman when it comes to money or profit.. be it musk, bezos, adani or ambani
Indian businessman will ultimately have to listen to Indian government.
They can’t run away. Elon musk proved to be a coward that China can blackmail him
Why should he side with either of the countries other than profits? He doesn't owe us or anyone much anyways. Don't be emotional. We are looking for transactions too just like everyone else.
Yeah we should only trust labour unions and trade unions who have bankrupted the kerala and WB economy. Only in india businessmen are not respected. That's why we are still a developing economy wherein most people think only government jobs means employment.
and never expect anyone to generate jobs either . businessman puts everything at risk to make profit and money , the businessman (or woman) do not do it to lose their wealth. so decide first if you want job generators or you want people like Sonia/Rahul/Priyanka/Robert who are mutli billionaires just by looting the public money or you want people like Musk, Bezos, Adani and Ambani. Today each of these are job generators for at a minimum of 100,000 employees directly or indirectly which means at least 500,000 mouths are feeding.
Indians toh din raat Elon Elon karte rehte hain….wahi Elon Indians ki gaan maarta rehta hain. Koi sef respect hi nahi hai Indians mein.
Very smart and intelligent reply given with a complete perspective without antagonising any of the parties concerned. Hard core diplomat.❤
Never Mind, There is always an alternative to anyone or for that matter any thing. It only indicates that our nation is destined to get a better one.
Musk knows GM and ford failed in india, indians prefer japanese, korean or local brands which are economical as well as reliable, american companies are failing in china also.
charging infrastructure also is very poor in india, musk will loose money if he comes to india.
It is true. Not many will come to India due to complicated system here.
Due to high rates of scam and poor government policies towards foreign investment in India.
Sab kuch theek tha but what the hell was that end music 😮
😂
Tax structure also studied before investment
He talks smoothly when he is talking about topics other than politics.
Superb jaishankar ji
Beautifully and very convincingly explained the capacity of our country as well the vision to grow big and the effort from govt to achive for betterment of Bharat. Great articulation with sincerity.
Tesla's blade batteries are supplied by BYD of china ..
Between BYD is the largest market holder of EV cars ..above Tesla as well.
Unfortunately, India is still stuck in a colonial mind set, having someone else having to choose a path for them in any given situation. Jaishankar takes forever to make a simple point.
Yes, and Make in India was also not a great success... Only defence side of the project has seen some improvement
@@anilv3724 Agreed, most students of Macro Economics understand that protectionist policies hinders expansion and growth.
He's always talk with no action, just like Modi😢
Supply chain and distribution, one of the key area, India must focused for on growing development.
100 % true respect business decision. Business happens like this
This one video sums everything economics.
Nicely explained sir. Thanks for removing the sentiment and drama from a business decision.
Very fair and sensible way to take such matters👌🙏🏼
Why blaming China for our short comings ?? Who comes with these lame captions
India needs to open their market for foreign companies so they can come and setup manufacturing plants and create employment in India 🇮🇳
Superb ❤❤
Why does almost every Indian thinks that whatever India do and if they failed, or if investors don't choose them, or countries that do not choose to or aligned with them, then it ALL MUST be China's fault? Do you know who is the biggest enemy and cause of your failures in life? It is the disease of _excuse_ and _blaming._
No it is china bcoz china think he is the sole guardian of Asia.
@@4EVRLOVE Again, you're still blaming. China has made it clear they are not, but you are imposing your own thoughts and delusions where your lies has become the truth.
@@4EVRLOVE If China looked squarely at India, India would not be so lonely...🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
我们什么时候认为中国是亚洲的守护者？中国只是想实现现代化，实现人民富裕，没有兴趣成为亚洲的守护者。这没有任何意义@@4EVRLOVE
Because of 75% subsidy, how could a 20 Billion project go through WITHOUT ADANI participation ? Anil Aggarwal WILL BE TAUGHT A LESSON.
Excellent analysis
Well India can simply not compete with Chinese productivity. I mean the stats are telling.
Ohh thats why europe & north america(western countries) are thinking about import 😮 duties & tax on chinese ev products 🤭
India is still very much behind China in inflastructure, technology, work attitude. Indians talk big but nothing to show.
@@sreekanths5920 Those taxes are to stop Chinese EV's from dominating the market because the price is much better than overrated western cars. This is why they are imposing duties on Chinese EV's... To say for your brain level, tesla makes profit 8000-12000 USD per car while the BYD makes 2-3K USD per car.
Absolutely wrong, India didnt invest in manufacturing in a large way so the potential is unknown. India produces more quality engineers than any country in the World, go check any sector any reputed company around the World you will find Indians working there. And there reputation of being honest and hardworking are very well known. India even exports young talents and labours around the World, so there are no shortages of either quality engineers or labour force. Today India has just started investing in manufacturing, so tomorrow we will compete with China, a day after we will will be at top.
We Indians were the richest nation of the World and we will reclaim that back.
You Europeans just sit back and talk crap, very soon all your colonial resources will end, then we'll see who talks more.
Stats currently will definitely favour China as you lazy Europeans gave away all manufacturing techs to China only sit back and enjoy, now when China is turning into a monster, you are still playing dirty politics makes me wonder if you are really sane!!!!
@@izajahmed8863 ur not understand fully about my comment 🤭 if i said abt taxes am i dont know why they imposed duties. 😜 think deeply & wisely then u got meaning of the comment
To complex to understand.Nut put in a clear undertandable perspective by genious Minister
Please also think and talk about food and beverages for common people..
and plan for it..
india is not behind, India is already SUPERPOORER IN THE WORLD 🤣🤣 i mean SUPERPOWER 🤣🤣 MORE POWER INDIA #1
India have to follow china and russia to be leader and strong to get the corrabeted amrican and west ,we do not aford again and again west and american sencation we seek of it.
While Jai was very articulate, his body language says a lot that he is tip toeing govts official line here instead of being analytical. But then again as a EAM, it's his job.
Why is satya nadella askng questions to S jaishankar 😂😂😂
He is the guest
Remember guys we need to move forward and not fight each other❤❤🎉🎉thks
Bro knows what he's speaking
As per Elon musk, tesla is not car company😂.... so many layoffs here n market share going down in US as well
Wow, talk about beginning the next question on the wrong foot.
Why ask this question knowing the answer is not in the affirmative.
Musk slap to indian politician
We have our own businessman like adani Ambani Mahindra Tata etc they will do production and even in future if any investment will come with mutual intrest our government will welcome ❤
Mahindra electric vehicles are doing well though.
They're using Chinese parts
@@Sara_Kuster
Not really. You're saying like Chinese using Indian noodles
Crappy
@@Rivan_600 Chinese don't use indian noodles, they're master at noodle making 😂
@@Sara_Kuster
Master of copying. Your most of the Technology are stolen from the west.
Sir ne Raghu Ramarajan aur Rahul Gandhi ko lapet Diya.👏🏻👏🏻
Tsla might have linked EV w/ allowing strlnk. Anyone know more about this?
If china did that, it did a good job to save Elon musk. Made in india would damage the image of Tesla.
How many sents do you get to do negative comment against India in every video related to india?
@@krish2.ogamerz248 Cents? Whats app university keeps your brainless huh?
Not more than that I buy toilet paper for my family in a day is equal to get in one month😂@@krish2.ogamerz248
None if its all fax lol@@krish2.ogamerz248
Removing manufacturing from the economy is like removing legs from a healthy human body. That is the reason we don't have inventions or innovations in India. Modi is trying best to bridge that gap but it is a long run.
Much respect to the EAM
@@andakkakondakariyeah tamilnadu has more manufacturing capablities
Beggars can't be choosers. India needs Telsa but Tesla does not need India. That is the fact. 😏🥱
No, Indians don't need tesla cars
@@anilv3724 Indians are too poor to afford Tesla cars anyway just like Apple's iPhone and that is why there are only 2 Apple Stores in India and 57 Apple stores in China
@@anilv3724 Indian politicians begged for Elon Musk to invest in India on social medias. Indians don't need Tesla? Learn some honesty.
Electric cars are still primitive, still waiting for super technology to come.
@@silvarajoomuniandy4316 If electric cars are "primitive", why is it that every well-known players in the automobile industry, wants to have a piece of EV market share? Not so smart, aren't you?
Who will replace Jai Shankarji when the time comes?🤔🤔🤔 whoever it is will have to fill in big shoe's
Answer suggests back channels are at work 😊
they always are especially where money is involved.
India's main focus needs to be localise manufacturing for India and the world . Once just 250-300 years back India was a manufacturing success story ,then British did deindustralise India to industralise west , so considering India's strength in Ship Building,Textiles, Electrical ,Electronic goods , engineering goods , automobiles , so many opportunities to scale up and skill up .
India's main focus should be on it's own citizens before talk about anything else.
Rajan doesn't want India to become technology giant. He wants us to remain in slavery by doing only service.....Services bubble can burst anytime. Technology (Hardware tech, I mean) will always keep us well grounded for years to come.....
Nice content. But what is that scream in the end of the video!!! So uncomfortable!
Ranjit Singh's Ladakh is Khalsa Sarkar territory. Mining over dispute land part is not allow in UN law . union of India is just a temporary care taker of ladakh.
If China looked squarely at India, India would not be so lonely...🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Well Musk played a good business move by showcasing China as India an alternative thus putting China in pressure to give them many business benefits.
India is still coping even after 1 month later since the meeting.
Indian culture is original culture unlike the Chinese Copycat culture
@@thirulogagunaventhiapkanda3345 _"Indian culture is original culture unlike the Chinese Copycat culture"_
When you say this, the ENTIRE world OUTSIDE of India laughs at you, hence no one takes you seriously that's why people choose others and not you. I'm guessing Bollywood is the original of Hollywood, and the English language (that you are _so_ fond of) is also a copies of everything from you too, right?
@@thirulogagunaventhiapkanda3345 Indian culture is fake.
@@thirulogagunaventhiapkanda3345 Indian culture involves playing and eating delicious cowidungi food during Diwali 🤭🤢
@@thirulogagunaventhiapkanda3345 India has an original common language used by every Indians? Remember English belongs to Britain? 🤭🤣😂
During covid 19 govt failed to capitalise when world interested and wanting things to change their preference, that was the time ,govt should have change the scenario
Tesla not setting up a plant in India is Tesla's lost.
India 🇮🇳 has TATA ev's already.
Someday Video producers will learn about not putting cringe loud music at the start or end of their RUclips videos
Kya karna hai tesla ka
Other than some saavy answers, what has he achieved from being a foreign minister?
Relations with china, maldives, Sri Lanka Bhutan got weakened & someplace bitter .
Tesla not coming to Bharat is probably good for both and even if he comes he will have to face a tough competition and might become another Ford.
jaishankar take responsibility for you inefficiency.. stop your blame game.. 😊 yout just lucky that you have many uneducated supporterss to comment your something big.. you r no where near to shashi tharoor..your son is a US citizen and you talk about make in india😂
Tesla will probably enter the inverter business.
Not sure if it really matters whether Tesla comes to India or not. Yes, there is lot of job at stake, however if they do have to do business here, they gotta adhere to the Government’s policies. Also, unsure if EV’s are the future.
Jaishankar is most unsuitable to ministry of external affairs. Dr Subramanian Swamy would have proved as a good minister of MEA.
I have great respect for Sri Jai Shankar Sir. But, somehow I am not convinced with his reply on Tesla issue.
After announcement of his India visit by Elon Musk, there has been continuous bombardment of negative reports by Global Times of China on poor road infrastructure of India and how Tesla cras are a misfit on Indian roads etc. By preventing Elon Musk from committing any Indian projects,China must be trying to have monopoly over Tesla Products manufacting outside of US. Once Tesla sets up shop in India, their Exports from China is going to be affected and hence China wants to ensure no compromise of their interests.
Mr. Jai Shankar being a seasoned diplomat may not like to comment on this issue publicly.
China may arm twist Tesla for now but the EV business is only a fraction of world auto sales. There is a lot of room to grow and India is a large market also. It is only a matter of time before Elon comes here else he will be overwhelmed by his competition. If we play it to our terms we can also win. The current set of technocrats will most likely ensure that.
You really are like your new master the US everything that fails or goes wrong, blame China.
Have you even read news of what happening at Tesla. They are firing thousands daily even in China. EV demand is falling. Elon Musk cannot sell cars in US with subsidy, how his business will even work? BYD makes EV for half-price now, no American company can compete. It’s better he didn’t come and hire people otherwise they would lose job immediately within month.
I definitely want india to have bigger push for hydrogen than EV. Hydrogen is a better option than EV.
Not sure what makes these people think we are equal to Chinese eco system, in manufacturing. We may get there , have a long way to go.. Need a mindset change of policy, banking and politics and work culture etc. and many more PM Modi like people..
India can do better and come up with better cars - no problem!
No. He's getting scr😆ed by Chini 🦇 competition. Especially by BYD. So right now he Doesn't have the money for expansion.....😂
Obviously Elon Musk knows that poor Indian can’t afford the price of Tesla 😂😂😂
Lol Elon Musk saw that nobody in india can't afford his car, just look at their stats and you will see their buying power lol😊
Real BEGGARS on the Global stage.
1) Begging for 1 trillion dollars climate finance during COP26 in Glasgow dated November 2021.
2) Begging for oxygen tanks and donations during v|9 pandemic. PM Care Funds (beggar funds) were set up to beg for money WORLD WIDE
3) Borrowing money from World Bank to build 110 million toilets for 600 million Indians (Swachh Bharat toilet mission) etc.
4) India also happened to be the largest recipient of foreign aid since independence? Research "India largest recipient of foreign aid since independence?" 🤭
India gave too much importance to Tesla
Don't know why its a big deal..Elon Musk not coming to India is a good thing...we already have a EV ecosystem developing steadily...India should infact ban Chinese EVs...that will help Indian startups to florish in this sector
We are left far behind in manufacturing, because of Rahul Gandhi and Reghuram Rajan. WoW. Didn't think they could be so influential in this government. So I think in the cabinet, they are considering various proposals to develop India as a manufacturing hub for chips and Seminconductors. But then they are like " Hey , we can't do this because Rahul and Rajan will mock us, so we better sit on it😂😂
Why dont we build our own capabilities rather than relying on foreign investments. Billions have already been invested but unemployment remains high.
Most of the youth is unemployable because of our diverse and often irrelevant education system. This is the biggest impediment to foreign investment. Our skill level is really low.
We have a lot of good for nothing people that consume.
Who is this? Excellent representative for a poor developing country. Maybe India should find someone like him to refine and strengthen their court systems. Speedy and efficient law and order systems is the need of the day for many countries like India which are stil following democracy. Wish success
Which country are you taking as a reference to compare?
Geo&Eco =AI
He will realise after a year when BYD destroys Tesla
If I was Musky, I'd sell Tesla inverters and other power backup solutions. Taking advantage of the lousy power grid infrastructure India has.
At least we are talking. We need to walk the talk which modi has capabilities
Elon Musk laughing loudly at that indian tea seller boy all the way from China, Beijing. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Did you get your bag of ata? Looks like you are real happy.
CIA Bot
Musk just couldn't holdl his laughters , bahahahaha bahajahaha bahaha......🤣🤣🤣🤣
Beggars can't be choosers.
If you are a top dog, everyone listens when you bark.
If you are a slum/caste/beggar dog, everyone ignores when you bark.
🤭😏🤥😅🥱
Let China do what they want, Indians are smart and capable people we can make our own things no need to depend on China or any one
Self Sufficient,Self dependence
@user-be6om2oe9g
It's ok time to Delhi to stop this and become self sufficient and self dependant
Law of attraction happens to Honest and Sincere people who Dreams of Making Dreams to Reality.
Everything starts with a Dream
Who really cares ?? see the electric vehicles sales right now and the vehicles sitting in the dealerships.Electic vehicles were a hit a while ago, it doesn't matter at this point of time.India will have our own companies who manufactures conducive vehicles.
ONE EV CAR COST OF TESLA = WE CAN BUY 3 EV CARS OF TATA MOTORS
India can make E.V. at a lesser cost affordable to common man & we do have the capacity here then why going behind Chinese controlled billionaires.Make in
India must be our only mantra & let the world come behind us.
Don't allow Tesla in India 😊
No but what the interviewee tried to insinuate is that China offers better incentives to Tesla to keep expanding there instead of diversifying into India. Jaishankar is so patriotic that he is afraid to admit India's anti-business backwardness. He wants to paint as rosy of a picture as possible yet Tesla is reluctant to invest billions of dollars because India remains inflexible.
After one year Elon Musk will cry in the hand of The most selfish nation China !!We indians support Indian EV TATA & Mahindra !!❤🇮🇳🪷👍🪷🇮🇳
The problem is that China is miles ahead of India in terms of infrastructure. Their cities are clean and beautiful. Yes, India has pockets of great infrastructure but also massive poverty and slums. When Westerners visit India they don't parachute drop into these pockets of developed areas. They drive through slums and poor infrastructure to reach these pockets of great infrastructure. So when they see our slums and poor roads and old buildings, it doesn't fill them with a lot of confidence in our ability to manage their investment in India. So until India doesn't significantly develop its poor infrastructure, the West will always prefer China over India.
India should support its homegrown EV Car market that is well on course.....
Next time Elon shows up in India, the ministers of India shouldnot meet him....
Like he says, no one can blackmail with money, so no one can blackmail India using money or China.
Exactly. Mahindra EV is doing so well and exporting to other countries like around Asia, Africa and parts of Europe as well.
China is far advanced in battery. It is understandable that Elon Musk Chose >China.
In addition, they have good consumer data on self driving technology.
India is atleast 5 years behind it. So just accept the facts-
India does not need Tesla. Get out of colonial mindset. Those who come with mutual respect and equality, are welcome.
I don't like TESLA at all, its not made for indian roads also I support make in India so my EV should be not only manufactured in India but that organisation also should be from India. So best of luck to Elon Musk. We are happy with Tata or Mahindra and so many others.....😅😅😅😅
TESLA IS VERY COSTLY CAR FOR INDIANS...... GOVERNMENT MUST SUPPORT " TATA MOTORS " & OTHERS INDIAN EV CAR MANUFACTURING COMPANIES. WE DON'T WANT " TESLA ".