EP-134 | What Xi Jinping Wants, India-China Border Dispute with Lt. Gen Dr. SL Narasimhan (R)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 май 2024
- Lt. Gen Dr. S.L. Narasimhan (R) was commissioned as an Infantry Officer in 1977. Holding a Ph.D. in India-China relations, he has received four awards from the President of India for his contributions to the Indian Army. A specialist in the Chinese language, he studied China and its history for eighteen years. Additionally, he served as the Defense Attaché at the Indian Embassy in China and held positions as a former member of the National Security Advisory Board and DG of the Centre for Contemporary China Studies.
In the latest ANI Podcast with Smita Prakash, he discusses China's economic growth and Xi Jinping's ambitions for global dominance. He elaborates on Xi Jinping's objectives through the Belt and Road Initiative and its potential implications for India and the world.
Dr. Narasimhan suggests that India must exercise caution in handling border disputes with China, as faceoffs might occur along the Line of Actual Control with Beijing. He also delves into China's interests in the Indian Ocean region and provides insights into China's demographic transition.
#ANIPodcastwithSmitaPrakash #IndiaChina #Podcast
Timestamps
00:00 - Introduction
01:16 - Reality of China's Growth Story
07:23 - Xi Jinping’s ‘China Dream’
10:28 - China’s Demographic Burden
21:05 - Belt and Road Initiative
29:55 - Hu Jintao’s Removal from Congress
41:30 - Functioning of a Chinese Mind
44:44 - Will China Take Over Taiwan?
54:39 - Role of Diplomacy in Volatile Situations
01:03:27 - India’s Need to Bolster Its Military
01:06:31 - Importance of Indian Ocean Region
01:12:57 - Provocative Maps by China and ‘Chip War’
01:20:48 - Life of an Indian Army Officer in China
01:28:49 - Communism or Democracy: Chinese People’s Choice?
01:30:18 - China’s Stand on Dalai Lama
Subscribe now and press the bell icon 🔔 to get new video updates: bit.ly/2UV4ygi
Join ANI's RUclips membership to get access to perks:
/ @aninewsindia
--------------------------------------
ANI is South Asia's leading Multimedia News Agency providing content for every information platform, including TV, Internet, broadband, newspapers, and mobiles.
Subscribe now! Enjoy and stay connected with us!!
☛ Subscribe to ANI News RUclips channel: bit.ly/2UV4ygi
☛ Visit our Official website: www.aninews.in/
☛ Follow ANI: / ani
☛ Like us: / aninews.in
☛ Email to: anicontent@aniin.com, internetani@aniin.com
☛ Copyrights © All Rights Reserved ANI Media Pvt Ltd.
Lt Gen Dr. SL Narasimham (R) is clear like a crystal and it is a joy listening to him. Nonetheless, the questions from Smitha and Ajith have to be par excellence to elicit this type of mature response. Kudos to the team ANI
Listening to Lt. Gen. Narasimhan is an education. He is a level headed man, very fluent speaker without pauses and fillers, with clarity and accuracy.❤ Please invite him again.
Sir 🎉 Sachin and 🎉 Kargil
May the.both sides
Withdraw simultaneously
Peacefully ⭐🎉❤🎉
Why not 🎉use the
Infrastructure in collaboration,?🎉
Mountain 🏔️🌄🏔️ are
Stability props 💯 for the
Revolving 🚨 planet Earth ✴️🌍✴️
Not 🚫 my perception
It's the fact stated in the
Final Scripture
Please question ❓
Dr Zakir Naik
Dr Zakir Naik shall be able to
Give information from
🎉 comparative study of
Religions
As a non Indian but always want to see India a prosperous , peaceful, world leading power for world peace. India should not be alarmed by other countries prosperity like China. Also self pleasuring by criticizing other countries does not give any value. There are many fronts India and China can be ally despite many issues. western countries domination to Asia can be minimize by Indian and Chinese ally. ❤ this show from 🇳🇵
India China alliance is only possible once CCP goes away from power. Until then china cannot be trusted as they dont value any agreement.
How can you justify the continues acts of land Encroachments on our borders by it and who is not ready to settle the border issues at all, means have hegemonic designs and ceaseless increments in it's territorial expansion on all the borders including across it's sea?
Ah 4😂
Laxman, I think you need to account for the fact that China is extremely hostile towards India. It hacks Indian nuclear and port infrastructure, steals its land and surrounds India with hostile political entities who have been bought. It sends nuclear parts and weapons to Pakistan, arms red rebels. It is also ready to steal Indians water supply at any point in time. It will interfere in Indian elections. Only a fool will trust China. They have historically not abided by ANY agreed ruling or action. Geopolitics is NOT for the idealistic or naive. It's a dirty, scary reality. Also if you know Indian history, you already know the views Mao had regarding ownership of India's land. He wanted to annex it quite early. And our foolish Nehru permitted it.
Respect! humble and intelligent man.
Thank you for inviting him.....definitely the best discussion on China, and Sino-Indian relationship dynamics i've heard online in years.......most other podcasts only pander to jingoism.
He sounded like the 0.5 front Bipin Rawatji warned about. To pro C propogandist. They spread lies and he is just bringing it us.
The guest was very very astute and knowledgeable. Very pragmatic and practical, one of the best analysis of China I’ve ever heard. The lady host’s questions are on point. Kudos.👏👏
consider listening to prof. Jeffrey Sachs too🙂
@@jchung52655:58
No she is full of hostility
He was talking bs and a lot of wrong fact about China.
A lot of things he just said without evidence of such.
Did not realize you were doing a performance rating for them. They dont care about your review
Even Tawain claims Arunachal Pradesh is part of China. I wonder why India has agreed to defend Taiwan without pressuring Taiwan to blackout this Chinese claim?
They cannot. It is in the constitution. The parliament is in control of non DPP. they have 67%. Dpp won the presidency with only 33%. But if India wants to be involved, be prepared for Russia joining up in South China Sea. Russia will not be Galwan or Himalaya areas, unless USA or nato joins in.
Taiwan also claims Mongolia ( not inner Mongolia) as a part of China tho the CPC doesn't.
@@defjam137: China and Mongolia have settled their Borders. And Taiwan, by no stretch of Imagination, can claim Mongolia. While India is a different matter. Should we not make Taiwan drop the claim that Arunachal Pradesh is part of China before we militarily even think of helping them?
Because A. Pradesh belong to China and india sent troop to take over and China ask I dia to withdraw. Still waiting
That is why we support it's sovereignty and not one china
Gen. Narasimhan is such a logical, intelligent, level headed person! It is heartening and comforting to see that India has people like him.
He is not representative of India with lot's of ifs and solutions in his talks but India should bow down to China created Chinese as his master, I believe India is on right track what its doing, Chinese had advantage for shutting the mouth when rising and needs to do the same paths, if war comes then what, we Indian's will have to face it, I believe this general is playing double games with India and the government should watch his movements and keep eye's. He has done lot's of damage to Indias interest while in China
He sometimes talks like a Chinese spokesperson justifying their actions.
@@kaptainkc7415 most of his talk is accept defeat from China and we will lose if we fight against China, so vatnam who have challenge Chinese and Chinese keep a distance away in forcing or land crabbing policy has stopped in vatnam.
@@kaptainkc7415 ... You have to realise that 'Watching' a country also affects the Individual Watching them,
Just like you would attach yourselves to a character in a story,
To watch China He will have to Look at Chinese culture and beliefs,
It's not justification, It's Acknowledging Their Thoughts and Looking from a perspective.
Very shady chinese bot. 0.5 inside feont face
Undoubtedly the best level headed discussion on China I have listened to. This is what news should be like. Commend both the interviewers too in elevating the discourse beyond nationalistic stuff
Too pro china for India's good. Shady
The Chinese is pragmatic, its stand never changed, China's stand back from 1962 is: doesn't recognize that the Johnson's line in the west and the McDonald Line in the east as border lines because those lines were drawn randomly and unilaterally by Englishmen, not agreed by both sides back then. But China willing to do a swap, i.e. India takes what currently held in the east, and China takes currently held in the west. From India's stand, India wants both, this what the real problem lies.
Yes definitely the colonial boss created lots of problem around the world included this border issues. China and Indian are old civilizations and they both has respected and shared each wisdoms, cultures for thousands of years before these colonizers were even a country back then. They never fought each other and live in peace side by side with no border issues. I think India should meet China's half way and resolve border issues and become a peaceful brother again.
Since both are indian territories hence how they can exchange one with another?
@@ghanvedsingh8946we China think both belong to China
@@yiquny we only recognize china borders by it's great wall
@@yiqunydon't you have a huge enough country already? So greedy
Chinese started building chips in 2003! I was there! My friend has been living in China since 2000.
LG Dr. SL Naramsimhan is not only knowledgeable but could analyse with such detachment on issues so emotional on both sides. Appreciate his depth and clarity on these issues.
he hasnt added to anything thats not written in the Global times. in india we are happy to have guests like this who like to make the chinese watching this podcast on VPN happy.
Some of the points Mr. Narasimhan brought out provide a deep insight which we never heard from anybody . Fantastic
JAYANT BHANDARI is right again, 1% growth of a mouse and 1% growth of an elephant are not comparable. China and India are two different animals and shouldn't be compared at all.
Excellent interview as always! Lots to learn from the deep and comprehensive knowledge of Lt. Gen Dr. Narasimhan. Kudos also to Smita Prakash and Ajit Dubey for 'spreading' out the context of the interview and covering a lot of ground.
Smita ji please bring Vijay Gokhale retd IFS on podcast. His books on China are phenomenal.
No doubt. He also understand china and how china look at india and I. E not a equal partner.
0.5 front Bipin Rawatji warned about is what this guy sounded like. Too much pro C propoganda
His understanding of china and what is reality is contradictory
very impressed with the new style of added News headlines and videos to show proof. More podcasts need to do this, so people don't believe everything blindly.
it was really very informatic I Pod
thank you ANI and Shri Narashimhan
It is still a mystery that India with its 1.4 billion people has only one-fifth of China's GDP. My belief is if India concentrates on building its economy and does not have too much infighting at home or playing the politics between the US, Australia, and Japan against China, it can improve. If India gets to the same level of the Chinese in the future, they will also have the same treatment as the US has given the Chinese today. The US has a track record of using a "Divide and Conquer" strategy, playing one country against another. Any country that threatens to be a superpower is a threat to the US and India is no different. The West for its years of dominance from the British Empire to American Imperialism will not want to see an Asian power. India should understand that. The sub-continent should try to emulate China's success and provide a strong partnership with China in Asia. Being the world's largest democracy counts for nothing if you cannot put food on the tables for the people. A strong India-China relationship is good for the prosperity and peace of Asia and the world.
china was also pretty much at the bottom in 1970, below india. things are always easier when its an autocratic govt and a lot of USD inflows. in india, land acquisitions are not that easy as peoples rights matter, and environmental laws, lot of human language and cultural diversity etc are there..dont forget china developed rapidly because of inflow american capital and largesse+ authoritarian CCP govt. they were used by US to counter USSR, just like how india is trying to be used by USA to counter china. but india too like china is playing smart and only does whats good for her people. india is not in a race with anyone and it is developing organically and wont collapse even if foreign capital and exports dry up. however i have nothing against chinese people, theyre afterall facing same problems like all of us and if they succeed in life we are happy.
China has an economy based on FRAUD and DEBT - so the stock market in Hong Kong and China has lost several TRILLION dollars of value - mostly due to the housing/real-estate fraud. Chinese internal debt is monumental and the Chinese trains - fancy and all - don't make money in many routes. India has a more "real" economy - though China has been miles ahead because it combines communism (dictatorship) with shrewd capitalism. But it's saddled by bad debt, overcapacity, and real-estimate market fraud - that was over-valued by trillions.
We should never underestimate China
equally important not to over estimate...
@@HK-ih2sv30:05
@@mingmuyiyang861548:51
@@zhengwenping4764 40:05
china will only get bigger, richer & more powerful... from UK.
Why to have snacks on table, if guest don't have time to eat😂😂😂😂😂
They eat during breaks which are not recorded in the video... 😂
Today, the wealthiest newborn in the world is Chinese. Thanks to three generations of the one-child policy, this newborn inherits the wealth of 14 ancestors. They won't need to work for a living; there will always be enough Indians willing to go to China for better wages, just as we go to Europe, America, and the Middle East today. Nepal has already sent Hindu Gorkhas to serve in the Chinese army.
China handles capitalism better than America did in 2008 during the housing crisis. While the American government bailed out banks at the expense of taxpayers, China, as an actual capitalist, is allowing Evergrande to sink and go bankrupt when facing a similar housing problem.
A wealthy man does not need his children to support him in his old age. The newborn is the richest in the world today and can financially afford to retire young.
The Chinese political system is based on MERITOCRACY. This system encourages highly educated Chinese to join the PLA. China has managed to expand its influence worldwide in a civilised manner and has not fired a single bullet across its borders in the last 40 years. India should adopt the Chinese political system and not reinvent the wheel as in the last 40 years, China has solved similar problems that India faces today.
Utter nonsense. If china was so meritocratic within PLA, why did they get a hiding in galwan and later outwitted at kailash range ? I dont see any indian willing to goto china for working..for business yes not at all for employment
Chinese demographics are currently so weak due to the one-child policy that within 20-30 years they will have inadequate numbers for their own industrial capacity. They need to export but other countries like Mexico, Vietnam, and India have more competitive wages - and will become challenges due to recent labor wage hikes and increased cost of logistics (shipping). They have some opportunities to remediate things but also lots of bad debt and excess debt - their official figures do not represent the actual debt due to accounting "tricks" and processes. They are not in a good place in demographics or the numbers of newer consumers coming into their economy.
Lt. Gen Dr. SL Narasimhan Is an absolute through & knowledgeable citizen of influence. Very clear in his analysis & thus his thoughts.
A very informative discussion !
Brilliant mind educating in a realistic and concise manner! Proud nephew 🤘🏽
Smith ji- great podcast and guest, just one feedback- it would have been better if uou had interrupted your guest less and let him speak freely. I understand that you are passionate about the subject, but it helps the audience more if you leave it to the expert to speak his mind.
Outstanding interview.
Lt Gen Narasimhan has cleared the cob web that is settled in the Indian Citizen's mind.
China is far far ahead of what India is today.
We in India have started development path only 10 years now. It will take 15 years more before we match China.
I am a Chinese. I like your discussion. I give you a thumb up.. You are factual and neutral. Unlike another host, Palki, from Vantage, everything about China is negative. Chinese people do want to visit India. But the Indian government doesn’t issue visa to us. We Chinese don’t hate Indian people. You guys can visit China without a problem.
Palki is anti china
But chinese very much hate to Tibetan people. Thousands of people were killing in Tibet by the chinese army. But why? China doesn't have right to choose the next Dalai Lama. The next Dalai Lama will choose by the Tibetan people.
We have seen extreme hostility with Pakistan China axis. China is playing with fire and it's in nobody's interest.
I've also lots of Chinese friend they are good always doin they're work and business don't care much about politics
As we Indians also don’t hate Chinese people
I find Chinese people very nice, honest and hard working
It’s the govt to govt to issue
Wonderful discussion Thank you
The best defence is a strong strategic plan for India’s continuous economic, military and political strengthening. A strong Bharat 🇮🇳
Excellent podcast, should be more of such kind...👍 👍
Thanks for bringing Dr SL Narasimhan to the show this is the first time i watched a show that an indian guest who talkes about facts rather emotions which i've seen in the indian media and talk shows. Whenever they open their mouth they are starting ranting China is bad bad.... i respect this guest very much because he talks based on reasons and facts we need more this kind of indians appearing on the show. China and India need to manage border issues carefully that being said they should not prevent them from coorporating economically so both people can benefit. Chinese and Indians are not enemies they've been each other's neighbours for thousands of years and got along really well. I hope the Indian media should be rational and promoting positively so the two people don't have ANIMOSITY and hostility to each other.
Vijay Gokhale is also a very rational speaker.
nobody in india considers chinese people as enemies. we have chinese people living in india and there are chinese origin people who are indian citizens too. indians love the taiwanese too. the current problem is due to the actions of the mainland chinese govt on the borders of india and supporting terrorist entities like pakistan and antiindia actors in all countries that border india, but we are hopeful that as india makes more economic growth they will behave properly which they did in the past, as they only seem to respect brute strength and leverage. its a sad reality that civilizations have not grown beyond this mindset.
It's not only India, they are always like this with everyone. They are not keen on knowing anyone else except themselves. They feel themselves as superior.
Very pedantic views. He provides little actionable analysis. He is part of the wait n watch paridigm of our previous MEA approach.
What actions do you want to take that will affect China? Actionable analysis is for the Armed forces and political machinery. The public only wants quality analysis.
@@itsover9008 if this is quality analysis for you... your bar is too low.. you can get all these and more info. from reading few articles and watching some free RUclips china watchers channels...
@@itsover9008too much pro china propoganda is what I heard. Band bagana. Bend the knee to the giant. I guess birds of same feathers flock together
Please correct your audio output. Its very difficult to listen from only one speaker from the headphone.
awesome thoughts
Well covered topic and very knowledgeable guest
As usual truly general like. Only sense as a matter of fact in his analysis. It was an absolute pleasure listening to you sir!
Very useful video thanks to Ani News to for these types of podcasts 😊
Amazing
Excellent analysis
Kindly read my comments
Too pro china and seemed too subserviant to the master
He has 23 yrs experience of China. But I don’t think he understands China’s leadership 😊
So true. Very superficial and low self worth person
And jokers like u only pick on ppl n critic and personally a empty vessel making noise 🙄🤷🏽♂️😅
Who the hell are u to say that
He said It himself
Seems you have a lot of opinion, but knowledge is missing
This Lt. Gen sounds like a BABU and was part of the negotiating team!! No wonder no results after 25 round of talks...
He knows the real issue... The border issue is not what the journalist think. Actually China is justify with the border issue.
While India should be cautious of China, the guest has to consider few things:
1. Going back to 2009, in the USA, a good section of knowledgeable and influential people have not believed China’s statistics. Believe it at your own risk.
2. Please, China is not a Developed country. At best you can call it middle income country; consider GDP of $12K compared to $70K in developed countries, so a lower growth for a middle incomes country is significantly different from that of a developed nation.
3. If anything, with the intemperate stance China has taken, China, has its best days behind it rather than ahead of it.
4. China’s exports will grow till it does not. Manufacturing is going back to developed countries in a significant way. The trivial stuff they will build outside, but in another 5 years, USA will see a surge in manufacturing.
?????
China signs MOU with Rahul and he forces India not to by Rafale. Blame Adani and China has prevented Adani from competing against China for ports etc, worldwide.
What are you talking about? How and when did rahul gandhi cancel rafale? UPA2's 126 raffle deal was canceled by Manohar parikkar. Later modi 1 placed a fresh order for 36 raffles. There is low chance of UPA coming to power in 2024. So how will rahul cancel rafale. Don't be a whatsapp expert.
@isacr4063 UPA deal was filled with kickbacks from Anil Ambani to Gandhis. That's why Pappu kept blaming Anil for embezzling 60000 crores. Parrikar deal was Govt to Govt procurement and Gandhis wanted details public so that Pak/China would know everything. Go investigate yourself.
@@shivajighorapade4391 the point was rahul gandhi was not involved in any cancelation as you mentioned. I never said if kickback were there or not. I am not a congressman. I think you should investigate before making statements. You were wrong and now you are making claims about matters I never said anything about to cover up.
@isacr4063 Rahul tried his best with N Ram from Hindu, lying about Parrikar and spreading lies about the Rafale deal. He was forced to apologize by SC. Even today he goes on like a broken record about Rafale. He didn't succeed but not for lack of trying.
@@shivajighorapade4391 this is how politics works. Oppositions always oppose ruling party. That's why you need a majority tor stability. Let me assure at no point did rahul come close to changing anything the government wanted done in past 10 years and even he didnt think he stood a chance. Even china wont believe it. Perhaps only a few people like yourself thought this can happen. If china paid him for rafale, they wasted their money and believe me the chinese are very parsimonious and smart when it comes to money. Don't keep arguing a losing argument just because of your ego.
Smita, why don't you allow the guest to complete his answer before poking your stupid questions?
It’s annoying that she constantly interrupts the guest. She has to control her enthusiasm. Her co host is equally irritating and irrelevant for the interview.
@@bangaloresatish6600 You know, during the PODCAST with our EAM, she asked him why couldn't India violate the border agreement with China if they did the same. Do you expect the EAM to say "Yes lady, our troops are doing the same"?
ANI should employ better editors.
Totally agreed. She is very annoying cutting right in the middle with negative and dumb comments.
Chinese already a world major power! Something is wrong with Indian Analysts about Chinese roads in the world!
Nothing is wrong with Indian analysts... neighbours know their neighbours better than anyone else.
no wonder with minds like Lt. Gen Dr. SL Narasimhan , india is still a very poor undeveloped third world country , chinese iq are just too smart for him
"Chinese already a world major power!" - only in the eyes of Africans they are loaning out blood money. They will seize assets or part of your nationhood in return of these monetary benefits.
China is not quite there but in a "gray zone" in the area of power - their military is not truly at a superpower level (without nuclear weapons being factored in...) despite the size - AND - their economy itself is highly debt-saddled. But POLITICALLY - they have few really powerful friends or alliances - they are nowhere at the level of the US which has NATO and Asian alliances (around 36 countries). They are not really a world power but have the "size" of a world power. But they are nowhere as powerful as either the US or even EU politically speaking.
@@Shiv1971I doubt that, China has Russia as ally, Russia is no joke, it's under sanctions from the entire west, literally fighting Ukraine backed by the entire NATO for years and at the same time fighting proxy wars in Africa using the Wagner mercenary group and still their economy is growing. Russia also literally has the world's second strongest military and a nuclear arsenal that is actually bigger than even US. So the alliance with Russia alone makes China a terrifying force. China + Russia is scary, even to NATO.
Indians who realise the benefits from this speaker is taking the first step in understanding the Chinese, but the biggest impediment is to be judgemental about the Chinese, rather to accept Chinese thinking latches on to its history , a discipline that is foreign to outside the Chinese. One needs a paradigm shift and mustn’t consider it as compromising, rather as acquiring a new tool to interpret a different thought process. Achieving the Results demands the laxity in Time to enable the crystallisation of the many variables, which once clearly assessed, all impediment will be brushed aside. The Chinese are not averse to paying the price for mistakes, but it’s a lesson, that is well learnt. This leaning obviates any resistance to complying to all the Laws of Science, but it doesn’t cope well with the vicissitudes present in human behaviour of other cultures. Chinese are quick learners, and are adaptable; but there is no compromise with their core values, a trait common with all civilised and highly developed societies. China wants its say and if in being able to do so, becomes a Super Power, so be it ; but she doesn’t concentrate
by striving to be one. They are goal orientated , be it health, wealth or harmony-
Simply confounding.
Great and Knowledgeable Discussion on China India relationship past, present & future
❤✍️✍️🤛Super exeleant,elever,, experience person❤❤❤
Analysys is spot on
Lt Gen Dr SL Narasimhan - Thanks for the clarification - but there is AI is coming up on the requirement of labour
As others have pointed out the general accepts Chinese at their word. Like GDP growing at 5.2% , or population only now shrinking now. These are highly questionable.
Sent cover photos of history books in my library
Chinese prosperity was drafted by Deng Xiao Ping. " The Star of Peaceful East" He is to my mind the most intelligent man ever. I hope Chinese people remember him as true father of the nation. He chose successive heads of State even after his death. A greater man has not come to China.
Congress voter above
Nice discussion.
As usual in ANI podcast
Kindly read my comments
Very pro china and propogandist is what he sounded like. No self pride in our progress and almost like bowing to the master attitude in his consistent, persistent praise of CCP. 0.5 front to be aware of. He is forsure a commi
Good briefing of past incidents to help us understand the present ...
Very interesting and informative discussion. Thanks
The question at 21:13 was not really answered .. not sure why Dr Narasimhan was so defensive of the Chinese establishment
Being a septuagenarian(born 1946) Wish this youth icon Kartik Pandian all the best in life & let lord Jagannath continue to bestow blessings both on his role model & mentor NABIN PATNAIK & look forward to meet him in my capacity as one of the founder trustees of DAINIK JAGRAN SRI PURANCHANDRA GUPTA SMARAK TRUST KANPUR to explore how to implement PM MODI ambitious coastal area people women friendly MISHTI Mangrove Initiative Seashore Habitat Tangible Income Scheme:Odisha keluapalli Ganjam Chilika
I enjoy listening to your show, thank you!
The main difference between China🇨🇳 and India🇮🇳 :
Indian leaders are busy with words while Chinese leaders are busy with actions
🇨🇳 : economic super power
🇮🇳 : population super power
Its ok 👍 atleast we think how to defend our country.
India is free country, not boot licker of Winnie the Pooh XI
@@oxy2986Well, seems to me India still want to be a colony of the West
@@rlai2201 believes what you want we don't give f about west we just see our national intrest .
Ccp are more keyboard warriors only can threat west can't attack them .
😂🤡
❤❤❤❤ China and India have been friendly neighbours for thousands of years and there is absolutely no reason why they cannot be good friendly neighbours for thousands more years.
There is a lot of love and respect among the Chinese for the Indian people. In fact they made Lord Buddha whom they regard as a devine Indian teacher their de facto God. The Chinese people and the Indian diaspora have been treating each other as brothers and sisters. You can clearly see this in a place like Malaysia where the Chinese and Indians regard the Buddhist and Indian temples as their own. In fact in Singapore the Chinese voted in an Indian as their President with a huge 74% majority against 2 other Chinese candidates. 75% of Singapore's population are Chinese.
Only Indians in India has a negative view of China mainly because of the persistent negative naratives perpetuated by the Western press for obvious reasons.😢😢😢
This is completely wrong observation
@@milindr7204how is it wrong?
Good to hear from Gen Narasimhan. Have gained knowledge from hearing this podcast
He is not saying nothing new that we have not heard.
He is tpo pro chaina, to be watched carefully. Hope he is not a secret stooge
I think what general Narshiman said was very relevant
Thank you Gen Sir❤
If anyone remembers there was a similar India Japan Economic corridor Delhi Mumbai Economic Corridor...what has happened to that project
At the end of interview , Mr. Narsimhan has conveyed Xi xinping msg to India ..quite clearly..
Not so subtle this gentleman, hope Indian government takes note. 0.5 front!
Namaskara. Jai Bharat 🙏
Many Chinese projects have not done due diligence on the cost benefit analysis or the business case. That means the return on investment on many projects will be sub optimal and sometimes will run at a loss like the port in Sri Lanka
The only job interns (Tambi) have with Smita Parkash in ANI is to clear dishes and tea cups!!
😂
Mr.Narasimhan comes across more as a Diplomat than a General - great clarity of thoughts. India seemed puzzled with Chinese incursions in 2020, I believe that these incursions were a result of abrogation of Article 370, Chinese tried to deny access to patrol points which they believed were theirs. This LAC business is a matter of perception. India should have anticipated this after the abrogation of Article 370.
Understanding China's Actions in Ladakh in April 2020Force Magazine , completely explained it.
His analysis is not as good as Pravin Sawhney's
China propogandist is what I saw. Bend the knee and accept the great giant. Never raise your head etc etc. Not happy with this guy's comments
Thanks
Excellent interview.
Ma'am I love your makeover every time I see you and try to follow 😊
This is what you are learning from this podcast?
Always a pleasure to listen to Gen Narasimhan... Editor please more of them
Sounded like Shady internal enemy
Interesting talk. But too long. It just drags. A crisp short edit would be preferable
Got actually nothinh from discussion he seems to suggest no body has clue about China.
This guy is a classic bureaucrat
The unrest in HK in 2019 was not triggered by the National Security Law. It was triggered by the Extradition Law.
I think China and India should resolve their problems and work together to balance the global power with west.
Interview pavin Sawhney he is smart guy......❤
The only time your podcast makes sense
china never said be only power ... if India want to be next power India are welcome and dont smear bad on China - China and India have the right bring prosperous to its own people thts is duty of all politician/ government of a country ... wht kind of mindset is tht by saying be only power by the modulator luckily the scholar /Gen SL Narasimhan correcting her
Brilliant…. Top end military thinking mind .
Very interesting
Smita ji your question are really great❤👍💐
Okay JI
Crystal clear explanation about China's legacy, policies, actions and how India to perceive, prepare & react without mincing words.. True Chinese Think Tank ..
He is wise smart and competen
Nice post
Very informative.
Recently American ambassador in India said they are prioritising manufacturing in Vietnam and not in India.
Mexico
@@prateek752@prateek752 : You are right. Even Mexico has increased its exports to America, taking advantage of it being part of NAFTA.
listen to Vietnam, saying Vietnam with about a 100 million population, is producing the same output as of a place with more than 1.4 billions population.
@@pardeeptandonMexico is doing the assembly, so where the semi-finished parts come from, think about it.
@@pohkhui: They come from China and not from India because we are incompetent.
The BRI , has many bilateral business deals. Since there are so many business deals there will be failures and successes. The needs and scale of each country also differ depending on the needs. As such I disagree that its scale down is a failure. If you look at the past 10 years there are net successes vis a vis failures. As for the declining demographics there are conflicting reports. China's economy is at a turning point into high tech, AI and robotics which require less but better educated population. An economy and social service that cannot grow fast enough to cope with a growing population is a recipe for disaster.
One of a few wise mind and serious analyst in India
The episode in South Africa is confusing, surprisingly Smitha did not raise this issue with the expert in Chinese affairs.
The whole conversation is revealing facts and ideas of the Chinese mind. On the whole, Chinna is being a communist mindset, and guided by their ancestors traditions and principles, are aggressive and expansionist in every field to progress, and do things that helps their goals. Lots of things to learn, and Indian need to brace themselves to face the future in an effective manner. Thanks, Lt Gen SL. Narasimham garu. Highly educative and open minded ness . Smithaji it’s a good podcast.
My left ear liked this episode
What about Right one...
🌹🇨🇳🇮🇳 There is no hatred between India
and China. Both President Xi and President Modi are not war mongers.
Both of them are capable of settling the India-China border dispute and
MOVE ON TO BUILD UP BRICS.
🙏👍BRICS IS MORE
IMPORTANT AND VERY MUCH BIGGER THAN THE SMALL PIECE OF LAND UNDER DISPUTE AT THE BORDER.
... HARRIS NG YM 💜
🇮🇳🙏🇨🇳. 🇮🇳🇨🇳👍
finally a good guest….. after a few disappointments
Nice Analysis with regards
Kindly read my comments and then tell us if you feel this analysis was nice or propagandist?
@@pardeeptandon0.5 front Bipin Rawat ji warned about, may he RIP. This guy left a bad taste in my mouth after the video.
0.5 front Bipin Rawat ji warned about
China IS a superpower and wants friendly neighbourly relations with India. India should have also an independent and friendly approach to this neighbour. As long as India signs one military treaty with USA (who want to harm China as much as possible) friendly relations between the two asian giants cannot be possible. Indian foreign politics going into direction of becoming USA pawn in Asia is harmful for all asian nations. Once more: China wants good relations with India. Modiji started well with Xi but soon began backstabbing China by signing armytreaties with USA. . Only then the Chinese started the border troubles again.
India has no army treaty with US..US and china both arm a terror state pakistan to create problems with india.
mutual respect and friendship is a two way street-
On your show I saw a tank which shocked me. Why so huge ? It is sitting duck. The general would notice this, The Chinese would be delighted, Hitler made the same mistake