Manfrotto or Nomatic? The Most Popular Camera Bag vs. My Camera Bag
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 июн 2024
- My search for the "perfect camera bag" lead me to the Manfrotto Pro Light Backloader last summer, which is really fantastic- but there are a few areas where it’s not perfect. The Nomatic Peter McKinnon Everyday Camera Backpack is one of the most popular and well-reviewed bags around, so I decided to try it out and see if it outperforms the Manfrotto (spoiler: I ended up returning it).
Alternate title: Camera Bag Quest II: Electric Bagaloo
🎒 Bags & Stuff From This Video:
•Manfrotto Pro Light:
geni.us/ANrqj0 (Amazon)
geni.us/Oa2y (B&H)
•Nomatic Peter McKinnon Everyday Bag:
amzn.to/3j6s3ju (Amazon)
geni.us/BuBu9Mj (B&H)
•Inexpensive Space Bag:
geni.us/spacebag (Amazon)
•Brevite Jumper:
geni.us/TnKDb (Amazon)
geni.us/A60ZVr (B&H)
•Peak Design Capture Clip:
geni.us/w9Cw (Amazon)
bhpho.to/3hGnoVc (B&H)
•Colorful Zipper Pulls:
geni.us/dt9qh (Amazon)
📼 My First Video About Camera Bags:
• Does the Perfect Camer...
💡Learn Something Awesome:
•My Final Cut Pro editing course: learnfinalcutpro.com
•My podcast production course: podcasterplaybook.com
⏱ Chapter Markers:
0:00 - Does The Perfect Camera Bag Actually Exist? No.
0:54 - What Am I Looking For?
2:36 - Nomatic Peter McKinnon Everyday Bag
4:41 - Pricing
6:13 - Manfrotto Pro Light Backloader
9:59 - What I Don’t Like About The Manfrotto
12:19 - The Peak Design Capture Clip
13:35 - Bag vs. Bag: Fit & Comfort
15:32 - Design & Style Differences
17:05 - Build Quality & Durability
18:14 - Side Pockets
20:33 - Zippers & Pockets
24:21 - The Nomatic “Loft” (What I Was Most Excited For)
28:01 - Extra Storage
29:46 - Nomatic Quality Control Issues
32:11 - Ability To Stand Upright
32:44 - Conclusions
35:21 - What Would I Want I The “Perfect” Camera Bag?
37:24 - The Dark Horse- I Mean…Bag
-----------------------
Affiliate links earn a commission from qualifying purchases which helps support my channel at no additional cost to you.
---------- SUPPORT THE CHANNEL ----------
Patreon: / tombuck
Become a Channel Member: geni.us/joinchannel
Buy Me a Coffee: buymeacoffee.com/tombuck
----------- CONNECT -----------
🎯 Subscribe! bit.ly/TEPsub
Instagram & Twitter: @sodarntom
Main Site: himynameistom.com
Podcasts: himynameistom.com/podcasts
----------- MUSIC -----------
•Artlist.io (2 Extra Months Free): geni.us/ArtlistTom
•Epidemic Sound (30 Day Free Trial): share.epidemicsound.com/enthus...
----------- VIDEO GEAR -----------
•Ecamm Live for Streaming: geni.us/ecammtom
•Sony FX3: bhpho.to/3EJuBde (B&H)
•Sony a7SIII: bhpho.to/3f8mMlS (B&H)
•Sony a7IV: bhpho.to/33mOGZo (B&H)
•Sony 24 1.4 (Main Lens): geni.us/sony24 (Amazon)
•Tamron 20-40 2.8: bhpho.to/3sTzIDy (B&H)
•Zeiss 85 1.8: geni.us/zeissbatis (Amazon)
•Sirui Anamorphic Lens: bhpho.to/309H0rV (B&H)
•GoPro Hero 11: geni.us/zXnTsh (Amazon)
•DJI Mini 3 Pro Drone : geni.us/I2e0AB (Amazon)
•ATEM Mini Video Switcher: bhpho.to/2RVGI42 (B&H)
•Elgato CamLink: geni.us/vddHN (Amazon)
•YoloBox for Mobile Streams: bhpho.to/3pc8qHU (B&H)
----------- AUDIO GEAR -----------
•Rodecaster Pro II: bhpho.to/3wCwaqI (B&H)
•Earthworks Ethos: bhpho.to/3CthFs4 (B&H)
•Shure SM7B: geni.us/tepsm7b (Amazon)
•Sennheiser MKH 50: geni.us/mkh50 (Sweetwater)
•Sony Video Mic: bhpho.to/3ztb6Vb (B&H)
•Rode VideoMic NTG: amzn.to/2ZKrHTh (Amazon)
•Sennheiser Profile (USB Mic): bhpho.to/3JDWGrh (B&H)
•Sennheiser Wireless System: bhpho.to/43JgqkL (B&H)
---------- LIGHTS & SUPPORTS ----------
•Nanlite Forza 200 (Key Light): geni.us/9Ofr (Amazon)
•Aputure Light Dome Mini: geni.us/vf5O (B&H)
•Small Nanlite RGB Tube Lights: geni.us/nanlite (Amazon)
•Big Nanlite RGB Tube Lights: geni.us/pavotubes (Amazon)
•Aputure MC RGB Light: geni.us/IuE4 (Amazon)
•Rolling Camera Stand: bhpho.to/3PbJGg3 (B&H)
•Big Tripod: bhpho.to/3lRoTyz (B&H)
•Small Tripod: geni.us/oQOh3Az (Amazon)
•Travel Tripod: geni.us/nlUBm (Amazon)
•Motorized Slider: bhpho.to/3ztKMJA (B&H)
-----------------------
🎥 Check out my full gear list here:himynameistom.com/gear
-----------------------
It's my goal for each video to be interesting/helpful/atleastmildlyentertaining, but I'm an enthusiast and not an expert. You can take a look at my About page to know more about my background, both personally and professionally: himynameistom.com/about
•My channel is open and welcoming to people of all races, ages, genders, and orientations. I’m glad you’re here.
•Read my Ethics Statement about objective reviews, sponsorships, and brand partnerships: himynameistom.com/ethics
-----------------------
Episode 336: The Most Popular Camera Bag vs. My Favorite Camera Bag 
Кино
I sure hope a nearly 40 minute video on camera bags isn't too ridiculous, but I had a ton of fun making it. I don't know why I like them so much, but it's just super satisfying to find something that really works! I think I'll definitely be making a follow up video on the surprise that showed up at the end of this video (if it's possible to "think you'll definitely do something" 🤔).
And after Returning the Nomatic bag, I ended up taking some advice from the comments on the last video and trying the Tenba Fulton 14L all weather bag. It's amazing! I've always loved Tenba bags, but didn't think they had a backpack that suited what I'm looking for. I was also dubious about a roll-top, but it rolled its way right into my heart. The main part of the bag is similar material to the Nomatic, but the top part is similar to the Manfrotto, so it's kind of a perfect hybrid. I've been using that as my "everyday" bag because it's so small and I've been using the Manfrotto as my "big" bag for when I need more gear. A bagtastic duo!
And I watched every minute of it even if I already had a bag I love and own! Finally someone not kissing ass 😂 and I bet Nomatic or PT would like this review too and get feedback, inspiration from it! Love how calm, honest, and personal your videos are - I normally just watch but I’m feeling like to comment today after having 6 stripes of bacon and 3 eggs straight lol
Could you spend a few more minutes fixing the affiliate links?
Finally someone talking about the Manfrotto bag! I LOVE mine it fits soooo much gear, and still feels good on my back. I have the M sized one.
Will Lumix G9 + leica 12-60mm fit it? Is it comfortable when walking in nature?
Can you put macbook pro 16 in it, and can you bring as personal bagage in airplane? Manfrotto
It's not too long Tom, I'd watch it twice and over! You've earned it. Always detailed, fun and informative.
Thank you Leona! This makes me feel a lot better 😁
Manfrotto had amazing designs . You can tell they want functionality with amazing styling . It’s like be be free tripod vs the peak design . The manfrotto kills it at half the price . Loved your vid ✌🏼✌🏼✌🏼
Absolutely love and appreciate this review. Watched the entire thing as I’ve been debating the McKinnon bag since it launched and I’ve never even seen this Manfrotto bag.
I’ve been getting by with a Yeti bag and I hate it.
Thanks Brother, Absolutely helped me into a new bag.
I’m glad you liked that manfrotto. That PM bag, there’s so much you want to love but sometimes it just falls short. Totally agree on that.
Thanks for helping me with info about the PM bag!
I just bought the PMxNomatic bag. I’m getting it tomorrow. Hope I get to configure it and maximize it for my gear. Like you, I plan to put my camera in the top compartment. This was a great extensive review Tom! Loved every second of it.
I hope you like the bag! It really is nice and definitely the most comfortable bag I’ve used overall.
so many reviews, so many videos, but yours was the one that convinced me to buy this backpack. Many reasons why your video was the one that convinced me, but I wanted just to let you know. Great videos, great insights , thanks a lot.
Wow thanks Adam! I hope you really like the bag- mine has held up super well still 👍
Branding wise, I love your combo of creativity, detail, elegance/taste, visuals and music. I like you as a person that explains his EXP to me, but the branding just brings it into: A, possibly S tier. Appreciate you!
"this is me in high school, this is everybody else". so relatable lol
I got the Mckinnon bag for Christmas, Ive been loving it. Such high quality!
Great vid, Tom! I absolutely understand the obsession with finding the perfect camera bag. I've always been drawn to cool backpacks in the past, and now that I'm traveling more for events as media, I've been hunting for the bag that's perfect for my use. I'll have to check out the "medium" Manfrotto one as I like the design of the small one you have but I tend to overpack for everything 😅
So glad to know I'm not alone! I was trying to figure out why bags are easy to obsess over, and I think it comes down to the pure functionality (at least for me anyway). A good bag genuinely enables you to do more and makes things easier, so it's amazing when you find it.
@@tombuck exactly! Thank you for documenting your journey. I'd do the same, but my audience is mostly just interested in PCs. At least I get to relate with other creators 🤜🤛
great video, I went through your very same process: first experiencing frustration with the top zip and ending up buying the peak design clip. So far I really like my Pro Light Backloader S and I can recommend it.
I have one tip: you can make use of the big top handle to slip a light rain jacket through it, roll it up and close it inside its own hood. It doesn't really prevent the access of the top compartment and being on top it doesn't get much dirt with you use the back loader. My wishes for an updated version: 1) better top compartment access, so you can actually store a camera there. 2) One of the shoulder straps should feature a pouch for easy access of small items 3) Target weight 1.5kg (so slight lighter than current S version)
That's an awesome tip, thank you! Nice to hear from someone else who's used the Pro Light.
As always Tom, Super Thorough review...thank you again for making my purchase decision more difficult...I think I am just going to go with the Lowepro...keep on crushing it, my brother...
Lowepro has a pretty stellar reputation. You really can't go wrong with them!
@@tombuck Thanks 🙏🏼
I just got the Lowepro protactic 450 aw ii and I can fit my Sony A7M4 with the Sony ECM-B10 Mic attached on the top compartment(the loft). Super happy with it. I know it's an old bag with a brilliant design but it does everything that a Nomatic or any newer more expensive bags could do!
The 450 is pretty amazing. A bit on the large side for what I need personally, but a great bag nonetheless!
Thank you Tom. I'm also a nut for camera packs & bags!
They're so fun!
Bought two of these (small/medium) based on your last recommendation and they're incredible. I wish the medium had a tiny bit more room, but I tend to overpack. 😀 The Manfrotto's are great - my significant other loves her small bag too.
The Manfrotto is so underrated! I’m really surprised I don’t hear about it more.
Need more room PRO Light Flexloader Backpack Lis plenty big love mine
Not shocked at all with the $23 one being the best. The same happened to me with a €30 one I got for tracking. I ended-up loving it so much that I use it every day. It's simple, has many pockets, works for what I need and it was only €30 😉
It’s super interesting. I mean, the materials aren’t on the same level as the others, but for the price you really can’t complain. It’s also a nifty design- I’ve now been able to take it places and it’s super practical overall.
What's your bag Vlad?
I really like my new Compagnon Adapt 25l backpack. I think it fits nicely between the two in terms of price and features. It can be used as a camera bag as well as an everyday bag, which was very important to me. And when you want to change, you can quickly remove the pouches - just like with the Nomatic.
Awesome video Tom! 🔥🔥🔥
Appreciate it!
Oh, great video and comparizon, I'd sent the Nomatic back as well. I'm an owner of their Travel Bag V2 and it's sturdy and well executed, only I most often find the straps getting in the way when approaching the main opening. Then, when you pointed out that as soon as you really start filling the bag up (the Manfrotto) - the less space you'll get in those outer pockets. This goes for every bag out there, and is a valid statement for my Nomatic bag as well. Jeez how many side pockets that are quite tight, and the materials are dark so it's hard to see where everything is. With the bag full of stuff these pockets are really tight. They do have a great warranty because the zipper for the main compartment broke around one of the corners - the stitching went off and I couldnt run the zipper all the way around. So I wrote them and got a brand new bag within two weeks, international shippping, no questions asked. Although it packs a lot, it's still all those issues with the pockets, straps.. I guess I'm the same when it comes to finding a perfect bag/backpack... for musicians, the search is still on. I kind of lean to a, by me, modified camera bags as a solution, but there are some dedicated products nowadays as well.
Their Everyday non-camera backpack really does seem awesome. If I were still teaching I’d definitely have that as my work bag.
@@tombuck Ehm... dear sir, just received my PGYtech OneMo yesterday and sitting here configuring it for the upcoming trip 🙂 I think it's a tad overpriced but still really really good. They paid for the shipping so OK, and then I got this extra bag inside that can be used separately. Hm, not overpriced after all. But the Nomatic bags has become hefty priced and that's a total overkill when considering price/value. Fine whoever wants to buy it.
Wow. I’m glad you found the perfect bag at the end. Unfortunately it looks a bit juvenile… but that’s why there’s no perfect bag! Great vid and good luck!
That was brave to make such a long YT video, BUT I watched & enjoyed all of it! I also love bags and still can’t find the “perfect one”. I too thought I needed that big $$ dollar PM bag, but I’ve been holding out! Big fan of your stuff!
I’ve now got the Tenba Fulton 14l and it checks almost all the boxes. There’s a bigger version too, and it’s the least expensive of all these 👍
@@tombuck I just looked up the Fulton and it does look cool! I just got the Peak Design Everday backpack 20L. I got it from my work’s corporate gift page. In other words, I didn’t have a choice but it was free lol. It’s too early to tell if I like it or love it. I hope you make some more bag videos! Also, we the people hope to see some more videos on your other channel soon!!
As always, thank you for the great vid! Ordering the Manfrotto and CADen bag ($44, what a great deal). Had the Brevite one and returned it. Looks great but zero protection (kinda a lot of $ for not much of a bag, IMHO). Cheers and mahalo!
Glad it helped! The Manfrotto has really held up super well. I also ended up with a Tenba Fulton that’s a bit smaller and I really like, but the Manfrotto is my “bigger and tougher” bag.
Just bought up the Compagnon Element 11 Sling, I know you don’t like roll tops but it’s pretty top notch for a smaller sling 👌🏻
Thanks for the recommendation Andrew! I'm definitely coming around to roll tops lately.
Happens I'm on the market for an everyday / camera bag and saw you made this 40 minute video. I've watched at least a million videos on the Nomatic, just haven't spent more than a bill on a bag before.
14:26 Also, people don't realize how important comparisons / demonstrations like this are. Am I the only one?
Oh man, I can't tell you how often I've made the mistake of thinking a bag that works on a 6' 3" person will work for me...and it does not.
If you're still in the market for a cheaper option, check out the Tenba Fulton! They have a few different sizes. I ended up getting the 14L and I REALLY love it. The Manfrotto is now my "big" bag for when I need to take a lot of stuff, but the Tenba is my everyday bag. It's also got a roll top that fits a camera with mic 👍
Great video. I did a video on the PM bag when I first got it and one on my replacement PM bag because my original bag already broke within a year!
I saw that video! It was really nice to see how things held up (or didn’t) over a longer period.
I’m telling you man, Wandrd Prvke 21L 😛
I’ve been looking at the Prvke Lite, which looks to be a really great size.
I love wandrd bags I think they're underrated.
I LOVE< LOVE> LOVE my Manfrotto...it has been to some of the worst/best places on earth and it is very practical and durable.
Great video and lighting
Thanks!
Thank you for the ultimate breakdown.
Glad it was helpful!
Hi! Insomnia led me to finding this video (which I stayed up to watch and view the other one on just the Manfrotto) and subscribe to your channel! You are the master of good gab! I wish I had watched this earlier so I could consider the Manfrotto. I purchased a ThinkTank Backstory 15 a couple weeks ago to fit all new full frame Lumix gear in advance of getting the new Panny S5 Mark ii. I've been a longtime ThinkTank user and I think it works similarly and fits as much as the Manfrotto, but with more rigid compartment dividers. It addresses some of the Manfrotto shortcomings you mention (like straps that aren't attached to the back opening flap) and other nooks and crannies to fit stuff. Overall, it's very comparable in a sleek and not photo-centric design. The biggest shortcoming is the base is not big enough for the pack to stand vertically on its own. Thanks again for your vids and I look forward to following you in the future.
Hopefully my video helped cure your insomnia 😉
I've heard great things about the Backstory- ThinkTank really does make great bags. I'm sure you'r super excited for the S5II!
@@tombuck I am very excited. Trading/selling all my Lumix m43 gear to switch. I think it'll be worth it!
I was searching for my camera bag recently and have decided to go with Peak Design 20L V2. I think it fit my gear nicely with a medium size camera cube (sold separately).
I was able to check out a Peak Design in a store and the buckle/latch thing for the top is probably one of the most satisfying things I’ve ever used 😁
Love the Manfrotto. I have one and it does everything I want it to
Seems like their bags are criminally underrated. It's built like a tank and priced really well.
I always come back to my Boundary Errant X-PAC, but the Guru Gear City Commuter is so close to being the perfect bag (they screwed it up with the straps overlapping the rear main zipper and having two fidlock straps covering the rolltop when it should’ve been one).
Great video as always
Thanks Paul! you have the PM bag right? Or am I remembering wrong? I'd be interested to know your long term review if you have it.
@@tombuck my buddy kyle has both PM bags. I use the PGYTECH OneMo (I love the green interior of course) and a Wandrd PRVKE 31L in green of course……I really like the design of that Manfrotto. I like sliding the whole camera in and I can do something similar with the roll top on the Wandrd. Like you I don’t use the side access as much as I thought I would.
Low key, having that periscope mic sticking out would add some cute factor to it lol 😅I’m feeling it
Great for covert operations too 😁
Another great video...wish the Manfrotto bag (and your video) were available so long ago while waiting for the kickstarter bag. It was such a LONG wait for the bag and the nickle and diming every piece on an already expensive bag really took the wind out of the sails on that PMK bag for me. It's a heavy bag on it's own and I always seem to open the main section the wrong way every single time.
I love the interior of the Manfrotto, the red dividers really makes it pop compared to bile brown on the other...LOL. Just a thought on your comment about your camera with mic not fitting in the top section of the Manfrotto. I don't remember which Sony mic you had on there (is it the ECM-B1M?), but what about if there was a more compact mic? Sony ECM-G1 or ECM-B10 or another brand altogether? FYI...the B&H link for the manfrotto bag goes to Amazon.
Thanks Dana! You're right that the B10 is a bit more compact, but it's more of a length thing. It's still just as tall as the B1M. But I did try the Tenba Fulton after someone's recommendation. It has a roll top, so it can adjust to fit a setup of any size. It's pretty amazing honestly, I might need to do a specific video on it (I got the small 14L version, but there's a bigger 21L). It's a perfect "everyday" bag and then the Manfrotto can be used when a lot more gear is needed.
Great video. The top compartment of the Manfrotto looks like it has an antitheft design. It should not be too easy to remove the camera from the top while you have it on your back :)
You know, that’s a good point. I also think they intended it for smaller items like snacks or wallets, so maybe not for a full camera.
In my experience the chest strap that you removed from the Manfotto bag helps to stabilise the Peak Performance capture, I never used it in the past but now I do.
The material of the Mnfrotto is ripstop, it means it doesn’t tare when it is punctured. It will probably outlast the zippers. The tarpaulin material I have mixed experience, my Vaude shoulderbag didn’t last long, it was a dissapointment, my Ortlieb bicycle bags are 20 years old and still going strong.
Yeah, that makes sense. I kind of regret removing it, but it was really annoying with no simple way to keep it out of the way. I might try adding an aftermarket one at some point though 🤔
My friend it appears you’re looking for the Tenba Axis V2 20L or 24L bag. You are welcome.
Tenba yes! I tried the Axis at a camera shop, and while it was pretty awesome, it wasn't quite right for me. BUT, I did find the Tenba Fulton which is absolutely amazing. I ended up getting the 14L all weather version and so far it's the perfect "everyday" bag. The Manfrotto still works for when I need to pack a bit more. Tenba bags really are amazing.
I went with the Manfrotto PRO Light Flexloader Backpack L I carry 2 Canon R3 bodies with extra lens and a 16 MacBook Pro m1 love this backpack it works great I shoot concert festivals and wear my backpack the whole time due to theft highly recommend it
The Flexloader really seems like it can pack a TON of gear from the videos I've seen. Glad you're liking it!
Great video, thank you. Am of the opinion that a selection of bags is required to suit different occasions and trips.
Ultimately, I think you're right. Each one enables you in different ways.
The weeble wobble reference 😂😂
Tom...I'm a little late here (#whoopsie sorry! 😳) But I LOVE the fact that you just don't STOP....you keep on searching! And you STILL find new bags *better* (and cheaper) than the others! Well done! 🤓
Some brands are so over featured (Grovemade, anyone), over “reviewed” (take your pick) on YT that I seem to gravitate toward videos with gear and brands I haven’t heard about before. Or, when leading products go head to head, say Sennheiser v Sontronics. Happy Manfrotto came out on top in this particular review, I’ve still to see a McK bag that excels in functionality or exceeds in quality. And that’s ok, not every product can be #1 ❤
Manfrotto is definitely a bit of a dark horse here, and I love it.
I have the NOMATIC PM every day bag. And I completely agree with the lack of an outside pocket. If it's to be an "every day bag" why does it not have a specific place for writing utensils and possibly a notebook. Yeah I can have it on one of the two zippered pockets on the main compartment, but then I'll have to open the main compartment.
Those zippered compartments should be like on the manfrotto bag. I would have liked the smaller pockets along with the large one at the bottom.
Side note: Nomatic started offering a metal "frame" for their cubes as a free upgrad le to make them sturdy like they were originally designed. Not sure if that was just for the Kickstarter backers or for everyone.
Glad to hear about the metal frame thing, I'm sure that makes a big different.
But yeah, I really don't know why they removed that front pocket. In the few videos I've seen where someone showed it, it looked like it added a ton of flexibility to the bag.
Another great and thorough video Tom thanks. I’ve been waiting and waiting to buy a bag, and I was tempted with the Pete McKinnon bag I’ll be honest but your video has brought be down to earth. Do I really need to spend £400 on a bag when clearly there are cheaper ones available that also do the job. Mmmmmm
Thank Paul! The Nomatic bag is super nice, but it just wan't right for me. The Manfrotto is amazing, but I've also now got the Tenba Fulton, which is a bit more compact and I absolutely love it (they make a 20L version, which is similar in size to the Nomatic if you need a bigger bag). I've been using it alongside the Manfrotto and it's a great combo.
@@tombuck thanks Tom, I’ve gone for the small Manfrotto as I really like it !! Thanks the the brilliant review as always :-) you are my go to guy !! Quick question; have you always done the word play throughout your life? Or just thought it would be unique for your Channel? It must take ages !!!
Best gear videos on RUclips!!😎👍
Thank you very much 🙏
My preferred travel/camera bag costs half of the Nomatic/Peak Design etc… seems to fly way under the radar. Cost me $150 and it’s been around the planet at least 10 times without failure. Traditional “camera bags” are just not going to cut it if you travel a lot. Most suffer from redundant features and excessive padding that add weight and bulk. From what I can see both of the bags in this review would benefit from a trim with a pair of scissors.
I had this problem too. What camera bag to choose? The answer was very very simple. Get a camera insert and a proper back from any good brand. It'll be as modular and the brands you can choose from are endless.
Tl;dr. Get a normal bag and a camera insert/cube
Well done and informative video. I've always had issues with my camera bag choices and reluctantly purchased the PMxNomatic bags(Everyday and Sling)... I think the reason I liked the idea of the Everyday Bag was because of the configurability options. I've always had issues with configuring my bags. They offered the cubes and dividers kit as options so I feel less restricted in coming up with a decent set-up.
Thanks Jay! If I had kept the Nomatic bag, I think I would've also bought the big camera cube at some point. It really is nice to be able to easily swap them out.
In your search, did you take a look at the Lowepro ProTactic 450 AW II? I purchased it a while back and it seems to have a lot of what you're looking for. It does say that it's a 25L which is bigger than you were looking for, but with both of the ones you had being bigger than they claimed, maybe those turned out to be the same size?
As always, love your videos, and love seeing the Aquabats posters in the background!
But also, I more or less use this bag to store my gear in so I want a large back to hold my camera and a majority of my lenses (I remove them if they aren't going to be used).
Yes! I actually ordered it several years ago and ended up returning it just because it was a bit too big for me. It was a REALLY awesome bag though, and super practical. I've looked at the 350 a bit though, which also seems great.
Yes the McKinnon bag does fit an 16” m1 MacBook but barely. I do think the 16” MacBook is a bit smaller than most 16” laptops though
Good to know! Thanks Kyle!
Thanks for verifying that the McKinnon backpack removed the exterior pocket that other RUclipsrs showcased in prototype versions. Not having a quick-access are for storing documents (the laptop slot doesn't count) is a dealbreaker for me.
It's a real bummer because that pocket seemed super useful. I always need to quickly grab and stow small items without opening the whole bag.
Very detail real world concern.
Id really like to see some reviews on the Hazard 4 camera bags, all the reviews out there are so brief you can no information on them, I went ahead an ordered one anyways. Mine come in tomorrow , I went with it because it has a hard shell and my gear is way too expensive to not protect it right.
Oh wow, this look pretty neat! I like how utilitarian they seem, and the price is great too.
Where can I get the attachment loops like you did for the Peter McKinnon side pocket?
I found some on Amazon as accessories for hiking backpacks. Lots of colors/styles available 👍
I got the BIG Peter McKinnon bag, it’s way too big, UNLESS you are heading to a professional job where you gotta take a lot of stuff. I think the big PM bag is perfect for pro jobs. It’s also the highest quality thing I got. It’s like the Arri of pro bags!
That’s pretty much what I’ve heard about it- way too big for everyday but perfect if you’re traveling with clothes AND gear or just need to take a ton of gear.
I'm only considering the Lowepro ProTactic or Tenba Axis...you should take a look
I had a ProTactic for a bit and really liked it, but it was ultimately too big. I have been using the Tenba Fulton for a bit now and I REALLY like it!
Is the loft section (without using the small insert), large enough to fit a gripped Canon R5, with either the RF 24-70 f2.8 lens, or the RF 70-200 attached?
Is there enough room with the R5 with battery grip and another lens in the top load loft section?
Don't have to use insets, or is there enough padding to just use inserts in the main section?
Non-gripped with 24-70, yes. But the grip and/or a bigger lens is probably too much.
I personally don't understand why anyone would pay that massive price for a nomatic backpack, no hate to Peter McKinnon but surely the price of the bag is mostly attributed to the name value of him than the quality of the bag itself kinda like the filters which from what I've seen from actual unbiased reviews, they aren't nearly as good as some RUclipsrs make them look and are extremely overpriced.
The bag is super nice, but it’s definitely overpriced, especially once you add in dividers and stuff. It’s definitely why I was a bit more picky about the build quality and loose threads and stuff.
@@tombuck Ive got my backpack for 150$ (Chrome camera backpack 2.0) and these kind of qc issues weren't a problem at all. Kind of strange how they couldn't figure it out while charging that much for it.
Nomadic isn’t terribly priced until you throw his name on it.
It’s absolutely overpriced. I have one (35L) , when Nomatic had a flash sale and I picked up a returned one for $160 with dividers… at that price it definitely makes more sense… barely. I just can’t see spending 300+ for it bare
@@LionFeldmanagreed, anything with an influencer name attached to it will be expensive just because of it. Way better bags out there for less money.
Agreed about the top access on the Manfrotto. Big miss IMO. Very easily fixed by changing the zipper path or adding a magnetic flap like the Boundary Errant or PD Everyday bag.
I need to check out this Boundary bag!
@@tombuck There’s a Boundary Errant and Errant Pro. The Pro is too much bag for me. The Errant X-PAC would be perfect if it had an internal shelf/divider like the McKinnon (and some other bags). I’d also like to see maybe a 1/2” more depth, but I do like the slim profile (some bags are so deep you look like a turtle carrying them). They do have a cube insert (MK-1 I think) that effectively creates a shelf but it’s not the most efficient solution. I just put my PGYTech shoulder bag (with my drone stuff in it) at the bottom which gives the bag structure and allows it to stand up on its own. My camera sling and tech pouch go on top of that, which make them easily accessible from the top. The magnetic flap is so satisfying and there’s also a zipper for extra security. The bag has held up great over 3+ years and I keep going back to it despite having tried 50+ other bags lol. It just works for me. I also replaced the zipper pulls with the same ones you have (except in orange). I love the orange pulls on a blacked out bag.
Peak Design 45L❗️👌
Hi Tom. Thank you for this review. I still think that paying over 200 dollars for a backpack is a lot. Check out what I decided for. You would love the interior color, and I doubt even a micro SD card will get lost in that vibrant blue 😁. I just bought the A7IV, and the savings😮 from the cheaper backpack will go to lenses and other accessories. Thank you again!
Which bag did you choose? I would never argue with a bright blue interior! 😁
@@tombuck check it out and tell me what you think...
Dulepro Camera Backpack. YT keeps deleting my comment for some reason.
Check the think tank aurban acces 15. It have top compartment that you can unvelcro it and make the top comparment big
I look forward to the blood match video between Pelican and Nanuk.
"Bloody Nanuckles"
yeah bags!!! I'm addicted too ;)
I like you assume you are the only one obsessed with camera bags in reality most of us are we would rather change camera systems than doing a new search for a bag... Currently using the lowepro 350aw and 450aw but after many years the 350aw is getting a zipper issue so i am trying the manfrotto and not looking into trying many bags. Most photo/video people i know probably have tried or own 8 or 9 bags.
I'm very glad to know I'm not alone in this.
Oh, man! I am using the Sony Fx30 with the sony b10 mic, I do hope I can find the camera bag that can take my setups without taking out my mic from the camera!
Take a look at the Tenba Fulton! They have a small 14L and a bigger 20L, but it has a nice roll top that you can fit a camera with mic attached 👍
@@tombuck OMG thank U！！
well done,, BUT I don't understand that there is the same backpack in the Amazon app but it wrote there ( GOMATIC ) instead of ( NOMATIC ) !!!
🤔
I believe they're the same and "Gomatic" is a name Nomatic sometimes uses for their really "on-the-go" type bags.
Maybe version two of those bags will be the one
Maybe! The Manfrotto is so so close, and it still does a lot of things better than any other bag I've tried. I got the Tenba Fulton when I returned the Nomatic, and I've really been loving it. It's also priced much lower.
What’s a good backpack for the RodeCaster?
Oof, that's a tough one. You might want to look into some sort of tech backpack that has room for laptops/tablets. But honestly, the best thing might be to find a hard Pelican-style case with foam that you can customize to fit the RCP along with mics/cables/etc.
My Nomatic has the worst zippers, they are tough to pull, one broke because I had to pull so hard just to get it to zip. The horrible zippers have made me really dislike using the bag.
It’s crazy what a difference zippers make. I remember the first time I saw a review where someone talked about YKK zippers and I was like, “Who cares, it’s a zipper!” Then I learned. 😬
I got peak design everyday backpack, but already dropped my camera and 2 lenses because of not the peak design of origami dividers and side access.
So ordered Nomadic Everyday with 2 small cubes. It's not perfect but seems better than PD in terms of carrying photo gear.
Shame the pockets are kinda lame.
I got Manfrotto before (different model) but it was also not as streamline as other backpacks, and I'm not a big fan of these snake like dividers ...
What about rain? How all those backpacks works under short "shower" or longer low-medium rain? Even if covered with some backpack rain cover/ Do water goes down on back, gets wet inside etc. Any good test of those features? Or low rain for longer or even short "shower" won't affect those bags even without rain covers (those or some other brands)? I see really not much honest real use test. Everything seems like "please review our bag.. but don't scratch it" or some people perhaps order to review and return it back as it has still some badges/labels".
I returned the Nomatic before using it in the rain, but the Manfrotto has held up very well to some pretty intense weather. I also now have a Tenba Fulton backpack that's incredibly weatherproof. So much so that it's almost silly it comes with a rain cover because I can't imagine ever needing it.
Thoughts on the Wandrd Prvk 21?
I've been looking a lot at the Prvk Lite. I really like the size of it and the fact that it doesn't have a black interior. The only real downside is that there's only one side pocket and I do use both of them like 90% of the time. But part of my wants to try it anyway 😬
My Kata Bumblebee 220 still rocks 😉
I looked it up and seems like a nice choice!
@@tombuck Its a shame Kata merged with Manfrotto they ruined their products I've been using this for at least 10 years 5 straight I change it when I'm bored but I keep coming back to it it has so much storage and features
Tom you are so much cooler than Peter McKinnon in my opinion. I have always felt Peter is a try hard. He is that guy in high school that tried way too hard to fit in by being into everything. His information can be great, but he is so cringe to watch. However you are like my homie I want to hang with and go on adventures with. And yes the Manfrotto is way better value and better looking too. 😊
This is really nice to read, thank you! There's a weird one-sided nature to making/sharing things online, but I'm glad it can kind of feel like we're able to hang out and connect.
Yeah, that is weird when I make tattoos I am right there with the client the whole time. But when I make videos I am all alone in my home studio, but imagining I am talking to my friend. I think you taught me that trick awhile back. But you are probably one of the best at making it seem clam and like you aren't all alone.@@tombuck
The McKinnon 25L not having any external quick access pockets is a huge miss.
Yeah, it's a pretty weird choice I think.
I can say this - if you are a working PRO - AVOID THE PM NOMATIC BAG AT ALL COSTS - this was a DISASTER release - the "CUBES" are not supported like they are in all the RUclipsrs videos - they instead send you a metal wire you are surpassed to thread yourself - AFTER SPENDING OVER $300 - AVOID this - INSTEAD - go to amazon and get the Besnfoto $99 backpack - it can fit a 16" laptop - it can offer top storage just like the PM - AND has side storage and you can get 4 of them for the price of the PM Nomatic with CUBES - that you need to BUY Separately - seriously without the cubes it is not a PHOTO bag AT ALL. Avoid PM's over priced nonsense you can usually get something way better for half the price if you look. Just being honest - I was on the kickstarter for this and as soon I got the bag (WITHOUT THE INSERTS I PAID FOR) after waiting almost a YEAR - I IMMEDIATELY returned it - mainly because in the YEAR wait - I bought that Besnfoto and its gReat and it was only $99!!!
Oh man, what a nightmare Kickstarter situation. The Besnfoto really looks like a great deal!
I've watched a lot of reviews you are the first I've seen who mentioned the logo on the back, however I don't find it cool I find it creepy.
Check out the Peak Design.
I have a Manfrotto Flexloader L and I'm very disappointed with the dividers, they don't stick to the bag almost at all, if I don't have all the equipment in the bag, what remains "flies" around. Very disappointed
Really? I think they’re the same dividers as mine, which I love. I wonder the the interiors are different somehow? That’s a bummer to hear.
@@tombuck i think are the same
Seems like you need the "medium" size bag...
I like Manfrotto tripods. But not a fan of Manfrotto bags. Not functional the way I’m wanting.
Tom great video but are you sure you weren't drink while making this video... For I thought you might have been half in the bag!!
Just drive k on my enthusiasm for camera bags 🍻
@@tombuck Seriously Tom, there is one other backpack that I have been eyeing for two years but since I haven't been traveling much I can't justify it... However, when I was traveling alot there were two essential (must have) items any backpack needed to have sternum strap (you mentioned) and hip belt (you didn't mention)... Atlas Adventure Back Pack with their 2-Fold Origami feature seams to offer the most versatility particularly if you need to carry more than just camera gear and a laptop computer... Atlas BackPack have had their Origami Fold feature deployed over a year before PM...All seasoned travelers know (and as my father had taught me since a very early age) a single carry-on backpack is all that is necessary... I have been following that philosophy since the days of AA flying pianos...
couldn't you just tear EVERYTHING out of the manfroto bag and configure it so you could access you camera through the top with microphone attached and then have space at the bottom for misc items...like invert the bag
That's kind of an interesting idea! I wonder if I could take down the top compartment divider and then use the regular dividers to make a little "shelf" that's at the right height 🤔
Nomatic is heavy, too heavy to me.
I think 25L is just a bit too big/heavy for me too, especially when fully loaded. But I thought the Nomatic straps were really comfy.
If it's a delicate and expensive microphone then makes zero sense to keep it attached to the camera when stored.
But it is if getting things quickly is important. Missing something because you're tinkering with a mic is always frustrating 🤦🏻♂️
@@tombuck if it's worth damaging both the microphone and the hotshoe then you'd have the camera out already, how often does that happen that requires perfect audio to quickly get the camera out?
You cut the chest strap. Nooooo.