Jay: "I'd burn down the world for that little guy." Me: "This is gonna be awkward.." Meep: "ALL HAIL MEEP!!!" Jay: "ALL HAIL MEEP!!!" Me: "Oh right. It's Jay. Yeah, this tracks."
It's not in this edited reaction, but they do kind of address Jay's concern about UNIT acting like the Doctor got a new face - based on the reaction to 14 and thinking he's 10, UNIT seems to be trained to not talk to the Doctor about his future selves, which is a cool world-building detail
The Jay/Adam dynamic in it's simplest form: "What colour of starburst do you like the best? I like the pink ones 😊" "I don't like starbursts" "OK, cool"
I think the best compliment I can possibly give this special is that it feels nostalgic without feeling manipulatively nostalgic. David Tennant, Catherine Tate, Russel T Davis, Murray Gold, we're just back in it. And it doesn't feel like it's trying to "sell you back your childhood" like so many other franchises these days do. It feels real, it feels genuine, there's so much love put into it, it's a perfect blend of camp and silliness while still treating itself with its own sense of kinetic movement and urgency. It's just a good old fashioned fun time that we haven't seen out of Doctor Who in a long time.
I like the quantity of call-backs in this special: not only there are references to Donna's first adventure, The Runaway Bride (among them Nerys, Donna missing every alien invasion, and her saying she's "descending" the same way the Racnoss queen did), but the whole Meep storyline is taken from an old comic book adventure starring the fourth doctor. The fact that they pulled a reference so far back that the only people who will get it first probably have kids and a mortgage, astonishes me.
I'm so happy to see you guys doing my facourite show. I didn't realise you were fans! Also, no meep toys. RTD approaced several companies about it and they all turned the idea down
I’m a transwoman who’s loved Doctor Who since I was a child in the 90s. Tom Baker was my first Doctor, watching vhs recordings at my grandparents house. This episode made me bawl my eyes out multiple times. Rose is such a wonderful character. The doctor and Donna were my favourite combo of new who, and this brought back all those feelings. It was incredible.
i didn't like the trans stuff thrown in the episode like some political gag, even though she did a great job in the episode. Nice actress, bad political mess.
@@FizzyWM No it's not, but the way they worded it wasn't the best. Basically, saying a male presenting Doctor can't understand the metacrisis thing properly, and because they were women they could "let it go" it's fine for the overall story mind you but the wording and phrasing was, again not the best. And now I'm seeing people pointing out the fact - how does an alien from another planet entirely know about pronouns on Earth (when Rose pointed out the Doctor using a he for the Meep) and the Meep said the obvious one that it chooses the definite article aka The Meep (which works obviously). It's nitpicky garbage but it is there and it is why so many people complain about things being "woke" these days that it's being forced down their throat. :|
I’m a parent of 2 trans kids. I bawled and bawled….that acceptance of Rose was as natural as breathing and it was not all “trans-angst” but joy. Real joy! I think she will be the one to defeat the toy maker…? @eolsunder..you are a bigot.
So, I had never watched Doctor Who except for a few scenes from some episodes prior to this one. I watched this episode because Ruth Madeley is in it and like her I'm a wheelchair user born with the same disability she has in real life.. Now that being said.....There are weapons built into Shirley Anne's (Ruth's) wheelchair!!!! Give them to me NOW! Okay, maybe not the explosives or darts; how about a taser? I'm kidding - slightly. 😂It's SO cool!
This was a delightful reaction! Ive watched several different channels do this episode, and still found myself grinning from ear to ear watching yall experience it. Thanks for recognizing the joy and sharing it with us!
Jay talking about feeling the need to be ready to fight off babysnatchers was the most relatable damn statement ever. My mind goes to babysnatchers, wolves, and other random threats 😂
Wilf even being mentioned made me cry a little , and im not gonna lie i thought donna was gonna knock four times , at the end , but they might save that for the last episode ,he was the doctor who said "i dont want to go " in contrast to jodies "tag ur it" so its interesting to see him getting closure so he can actually move on , and the hint of jodies positivity , fantastic!😊
Well it makes sense for this Doctor to have a bit more of that positivity because he is no longer burdened by the Time War. At this point that was so long ago. 10 was still dealing with his PTSD from the Time War. And it wasn’t until the 50th anniversary that we really saw the Doctor over come that.
Kate Herron, who directed all of Loki Season 1, will be co-writing an episode of the upcoming Doctor Who season. I don't think the TARDIS would look out of place if it landed at the TVA.
@@MatthewCYN15 Tom delivered that technobabble on the final episode with the confidence and style required. He's too big a name now to want to take the role but he would've made a great Doctor in another universe. Guess we have to settle for him as the MCU's Doctor.
Meep was practically designed to sucker Jay and Adam with that soft fur and big kitty eyes. Moment Meep started talking, I told my kids "I dont trust it!"
Don't forget. It has been almost FIVE BILLION YEARS for the Doctor. And he remembers how his friend Donna takes her coffee...... True friendship, y'all.
It has not. The process to get through that Wall in Heaven Sent took almost 5 Billion Years. The Doctor is not actually 5 Billion years old. He's a few thousand at the most. Remember, he kept dying and returning as a clone.
@@scotthewitt258maybe if you took a moment to listen and not be condescending you will learn something. When the Doctor spent the 4.5 billion years in the Dial, He spent the whole time reliving the same few days in a new body. so by the time he finally escapes the dial for him it only felt like a few days real time, since his final body never experienced the billions of years of the passage of time. The Doctors real age is somewhere around 2,500 years old both in physical and mental age. so in reality the last time he saw donna was roughly 1,600 years prior to the new special. no ones trying to argue... just spreading some knowledgeable information to fellow Doctor Who fans. Have a nice day.
@@scotthewitt258 Not arguing, in this case, correcting. The Doctor is not over 5 billion years old. The process took 5 Billion years over millions, if not billions of copies of a Doctor who was only... a few thousand years old. He really isn't 5 Billion years old.
After watching years of you reacting to American programmes (and LOVING it) as a Brit it was awesome to see you react to a quintessentially British Show - my claim to fame-ish Tom Baker lived near our local supermarket and you could hear his laugh echo through the aisles, and the coat and scarf...his. Love this reaction and looking forward to your reaction to the future episodes. ❤
I desperately need you all to know that this was adapted from a comic from a Who comic in the 70s. And they ended up cutting out a scene where we see a flashback of the Meep's home planet. On the home planet, you see plenty of Meeps dancing around and singing wonderful songs and playing cute games...the topic of these? Murdering as many people as possible and causing loads of graphic destruction. I'm so sad they didn't have time for it because the scene is hilarious lmao
I like some people saying "a little cheesy" or "a little heavy handed". GUYS HAVE YOU WATCHED THIS SHOW IN THE 2000s under RTD? Have you watched RTDs filmography? Have you watched Tennant playing the Doctor before? This is EXACTLY the cheese and the heavy hand this show needed. You thought RTD would retcon/pull back from the inclusivity some call "wokeness"? Because that was clear this wouldn't happen with RTD back in the game. And I loved every second of it. We needed that "effortless fun". I'm very very happy, for one, about this. That's peak "Who revival era" that started with Eccleston.
It's a little frustrating sometimes, because people sometimes act like just because they saw what they are doing in regards to inclusivity at all, that it's "heavy handed". It's a constant tight rope of "ugh so heavy handed" and so subtle it was probably missed by a majority of people. Its alright to just be obvious about it.
@@StarmongooseExactly, trans people right now don't need someone to quietly whisper "trans rights". They need it to be SCREAMED across the nation, and that's exactly what we got and it was amazing.
@@Starmongoose well no it isnt because people watch shows to be engrossed in the shows not have twitter activism blurted out in the middle of them. It always comes across quite nasty aswell tbh. Nothing inclusive about donna and roses last scene with the doctor. It was quite disrespectful to male audiences. The amount of shows these days that put down certain groups to elevate others rather than just tell a nice story is beyond sad
TBH, it was heavy handed, but I loved it all the more for that. It was like RTD went "Well they're gonna call me Woke anyway, lets just fucking go nuts!" Also, men in TV are not a marginalised or downtrodden minority. Piss off with that nonsense.
27:23 So you know, at least from what I've seen, Tenant's 14th Doctor is NOT going to being around until next year. Although, there is also a solo adventure with the 14th Doctor in the comics (The Liberation of the Daleks) which has already been released. The 14th Doctor is ONLY on-screen in these three specials. The last of which is being released on 12/9/2023. It is unknown right now if he will regenerate into Ncuti Gatwa's 15th Doctor at the end on the special on 12/9, but he probably will. The 2023 Christmas Special (The Church on Ruby Road) is scheduled to be released on Christmas Day and is slated to be Gatwa's first full outing as The Doctor. The 15th Doctor's first season is 8 episodes and is set to be released sometime in 2024. They started shooting his second season about a month ago. That will also be 8 episodes and is set to be released in 2025.
The introduction and epilogue are shot in Camden Markets in London, one of the best places in the UK for independent market sellers and funky bespoke fashion - the Cyberdog store in the background is a real store for a clothing brand that sells cyberpunk/rave culture fashion. My wife and I visited it whilst in town for a Dresden Dolls concert 5 years ago on Halloween, so this gave me sincere nostalgia.
Had the pleasure of meeting Mr Dave Gibbons, who drew the comic this episode is based on, at a convention in Birmingham back in 2006. Charming and friendly fellow, chatted with him briefly (about what I can't recall) and he signed a copy of Absolute Watchmen for me, which I then gave away as a gift like an idiot to the brother of my then-girlfriend. Gibbons is best known of course for his work on Watchmen, but also did a lot of other great work in the 80s for DC among others, including classic storylines like For The Man Who Has Everything (the Superman birthday story where Mongul traps him in an illusion of Krypton) and the Green Lantern story Mogo Doesn't Socialise, both of which have since been adapted into cartoon form.
Had so much fun watching you Guys react to this. I’ve been a Doctor Who fan since I was about 5 years old (I’m 57 now) and I was almost at the point of giving up on the show during Jodie Whitaker’s tenure (totally not her fault - I thought she was great, but really let down by the majority of the stories she was given), but this special has given me a reason to watch again - and enjoy it! Your reaction was easy, honest and a joy to watch! I’m duly subscribed, Gentlemen!
That was simply a delight! Very glad you're doing this. Seeing all your joy and hype, being a fan of the franchise, is just fun! I feel like we've all become so analytic about the media we love, similar in reactions, and this year we've had a few movies and now this, that remind us that it can simply be FUN. It was great to have watched the episode, already knowing about the Meep's true intentions, but having had all the same reactions about the adorable-ness. Only to see you go through the same xD
Beep the Meep is sorta-kinda a recurring villain of the Doctor already, we were first introduced to The Most High, in a comic run in Doctor Who Weekly (the original title of Doctor Who Magazine) against the Fourth Doctor, and has appeared in the format a few times since. That first comic run was adapted by Big Finish (with Tom Baker) and adapted again in this very special 60th anniversary special. The Meep also appeared in a DWM special CD audio release, which came with an issue of Doctor Who Magazine (that time facing the Sixth Doctor). Meep Meep!
I first started watching/loving Doctor Who about 10 years ago and I hadn’t watched it in a long time, but after finally seeing Good Omens I really fell back in love with rewatching episodes with David Tennant’s Doctor. This whole episode felt like a giant hug in so many ways and I can’t wait for the next two parts ❤❤ (I’ve also definitely been feverishly searching the house for my sonic screwdrivers lol)
I love when a reaction is done by people who KNOW the show. Your genuine reactions were exactly right. RTD you get an enthusiastic chef’s kiss for this episode. Off to watch it for a 3rd time…bye!
I loved this so much, both the episode and your reaction. You’re totally right that modern Who has been missing so much, for the last few years. I’ve been a Whovian since childhood and seen adventures with every Doctor. But, there’s just so much special magic and camp that RTD brings to the show. There are so many people who work behind the scenes, who he’s also brought back too.👏😀🥲
I already thought this episode was great, but it really does keep getting better with each re-watch. So many easter eggs, or just subtle details that you missed. Looking forward to the next two episodes!
A little over the top but, honestly, the queer community deserves some cheesiness every now and then. My only real critique is that I still don't fully understand the episode title. Was the Meep the Star Beast? That might be more on me than them. Edit: Thanks for the background!
Yes, the Meep is the Star Beast. the title is actually from the Meep's first appearance in Doctor Who Magazine in the 80s, a story called 'Doctor Who and the Star Beast', which this special partially adapts
Unless I’m wrong, there’s supposed to be 3 specials with 14, and the 4th thing coming, the Christmas special later this month is Ncuti Gatwa’s first solo episode as 15.
Absolutely love Doctor Who but never expected you to react to it, figured it was something you'd save to watch and enjoy in your own time, so it was an absolute joy to watch this, thank you so much guys, what a treat! I love watching you guys have fun with a reaction, and this was so lovely I watched it twice, cant wait for future DW reactions!
That episode felt like a legit episode of Doctor Who! Sure, I liked Jodie and her Doctor, but..... it was too serious. It had too many serious topics and wasn´t just as fun as the old Doctor Who episodes...... but THIS.... Holy shit. You could tell that they had fun doing this episode.
I mean, Jodie's run had the same comedic/serious ratio as every other Doctor. Like, they've all had some whacky stuff. I can get some criticisms of Jodie's era, even if I don't agree with them, but she had pretty much the same story tone balance as every other NuWho Doctor. Plus, 13 was debatably the most generally upbeat Doctor, tied with 11.
@@ewanholme1687That's true. I didn't like Jodie's run at all but she was definitely very positive and optimistic, many times to the show's detriment even.
I think this right here is purest reaction to the *feel* of Doctor Who being back in every aspect. If anyone asks how the new RTD era is, I shall direct them here.
I'm posting a second time....forgive me....but I just had to tell you guys how wonderful it was to see your amazing positive and fun reaction to this episode. I loved The Star Beast, and it was a shock when I started to view all these incredibly negative reviews elsewhere on the internet. Thing is, several of them weren't just negative, they were really hateful and vicious, not offering thoughtful critism, but just mean-spirited and (I have to say it) bigoted comments about "woke" this and "woke" that, and a flat out attack of Yasmin Finney. It was very sad to see the kind of hateful posts I saw from Doctor Who fans. If you don't like this episode, no problem, but that kind of bigoted hate? In Doctor Who fans? I was just so happy to find this review. Thankyou again!
In an interview with RTD, he said that the first special would have the feel of a classic style episode, almost self contained. We had a goofy alien and the spisode gave space for Doctor & Donna to reunite ready for the craziness of the next two episodes. Fantastic upgrades for TARDIS and Sonic Screwdriver. A great success ! As much as I wanted a three parter that was packed with cameos, I am very happy with Russell's instinct on Part 1.
So cool that you two are doing Dr Who... This episode was awesome, the best of Tennant's excitable fun mixed with a bigger budget without losing the classic camp-ness of Dr Who
I’ve finally been able to watch this episode - loved it! And now I’m excited to be able to experience your guys’ reactions, especially with Whovian Adam watching his Doctor on screen again.
Jason means Healer or Physician. So Donna named her son Doctor. Then her daughter took the name Rose 🌹. Maybe TARDIS had something to do with that. RTD’s attention to detail is amazing.
Thank you guys for reacting to Doctor Who....finally. My first Doctor was #4 (Tom Baker) but Capaldi did it for me (He made Parliament Funkadelic cannon...Dr. Funkenstein) and Matt Smith was a gem. I watch some of Jodi but I couldn't get through most of it. The fun wasn't there. My nephews heard Meep and thought it was Phineas and Ferb Meap 😂. Jay's look when he realized the twist and how he loves it. Meap will be back. Now, I'm off to eat some Starburst (The Reds).
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
Jay: "I'd burn down the world for that little guy."
Me: "This is gonna be awkward.."
Meep: "ALL HAIL MEEP!!!"
Jay: "ALL HAIL MEEP!!!"
Me: "Oh right. It's Jay. Yeah, this tracks."
It's not in this edited reaction, but they do kind of address Jay's concern about UNIT acting like the Doctor got a new face - based on the reaction to 14 and thinking he's 10, UNIT seems to be trained to not talk to the Doctor about his future selves, which is a cool world-building detail
They couldn't include the clip because it would answer Jay's "insightful observation."
The Jay/Adam dynamic in it's simplest form:
"What colour of starburst do you like the best? I like the pink ones 😊"
"I don't like starbursts"
"OK, cool"
I felt like I got stabbed hearing that. I LOVE Starburst.
@@ChampionAshleyI felt vindicated. I HATE Starburst.
The beep of all the meeps 😭😂😭😂😂
hail to the meep!
@@Luna-zw6te Hail to the most high!
Why the crying emoji? 😂
@@Legendary3Dgamer crying with laughter 😂😭😂
😂
I think the best compliment I can possibly give this special is that it feels nostalgic without feeling manipulatively nostalgic. David Tennant, Catherine Tate, Russel T Davis, Murray Gold, we're just back in it. And it doesn't feel like it's trying to "sell you back your childhood" like so many other franchises these days do. It feels real, it feels genuine, there's so much love put into it, it's a perfect blend of camp and silliness while still treating itself with its own sense of kinetic movement and urgency. It's just a good old fashioned fun time that we haven't seen out of Doctor Who in a long time.
Y'know, I'm starting to doubt Donna's claims that she's the "best temp in Chiswick" with the amount of coffee she spills on electronics 😂
To be fair she said that based on 2008 offices.
@@SorchaSublime I'm pretty sure computers in 2008 were at least as susceptible to coffee damage as computers now 😝
i mean, its chiswick, so shes probably a saint in comparrison
Someone get this woman a Stanley cup, good lord
I like the quantity of call-backs in this special: not only there are references to Donna's first adventure, The Runaway Bride (among them Nerys, Donna missing every alien invasion, and her saying she's "descending" the same way the Racnoss queen did), but the whole Meep storyline is taken from an old comic book adventure starring the fourth doctor. The fact that they pulled a reference so far back that the only people who will get it first probably have kids and a mortgage, astonishes me.
Didn’t think you were Whovians guys, glad to have yous as part of the family 😀😀😀😀
Tom Bakers Doctor said the same thing, "I'm the definite article, "I'm always The Doctor"
How did I know Adam would love adorable meep and Jay would love megalomaniac meep 😂
I'm so happy to see you guys doing my facourite show. I didn't realise you were fans!
Also, no meep toys. RTD approaced several companies about it and they all turned the idea down
I’m a transwoman who’s loved Doctor Who since I was a child in the 90s. Tom Baker was my first Doctor, watching vhs recordings at my grandparents house.
This episode made me bawl my eyes out multiple times. Rose is such a wonderful character. The doctor and Donna were my favourite combo of new who, and this brought back all those feelings. It was incredible.
i didn't like the trans stuff thrown in the episode like some political gag, even though she did a great job in the episode. Nice actress, bad political mess.
@@eolsunder I agree tbh. The actress was fine, most of the rep stuff was too clunky. Didn't fit in naturally.
@@eolsunder Our existence is not political, or a gag.
@@FizzyWM No it's not, but the way they worded it wasn't the best. Basically, saying a male presenting Doctor can't understand the metacrisis thing properly, and because they were women they could "let it go" it's fine for the overall story mind you but the wording and phrasing was, again not the best. And now I'm seeing people pointing out the fact - how does an alien from another planet entirely know about pronouns on Earth (when Rose pointed out the Doctor using a he for the Meep) and the Meep said the obvious one that it chooses the definite article aka The Meep (which works obviously). It's nitpicky garbage but it is there and it is why so many people complain about things being "woke" these days that it's being forced down their throat. :|
I’m a parent of 2 trans kids. I bawled and bawled….that acceptance of Rose was as natural as breathing and it was not all “trans-angst” but joy. Real joy! I think she will be the one to defeat the toy maker…? @eolsunder..you are a bigot.
So, I had never watched Doctor Who except for a few scenes from some episodes prior to this one. I watched this episode because Ruth Madeley is in it and like her I'm a wheelchair user born with the same disability she has in real life.. Now that being said.....There are weapons built into Shirley Anne's (Ruth's) wheelchair!!!! Give them to me NOW! Okay, maybe not the explosives or darts; how about a taser? I'm kidding - slightly. 😂It's SO cool!
I loved this, with all the camp and corny. The best part for me is the TARDIS making Donna a cup of coffee planning for her to spill it.
SO many reactions so far have missed that bit, and Donna going "OH MY GOD WHAT HAVE I DONE NOW" or however she said it lol So good.
I dont care how evil the meep is i still wanna hug it
it will eat you
I would serve his needs
Hail to the meep.@@ennayanne
@@SlendyFLM You mean you'll serve The Meep's needs 😏
The Hearstopper collab then soon, the Sex Educatiion mash-up ❤
Also, Yasmin Finney saying ‘I am alll” and ‘I am finally me’ makes me emotional af
This was a delightful reaction! Ive watched several different channels do this episode, and still found myself grinning from ear to ear watching yall experience it. Thanks for recognizing the joy and sharing it with us!
Jay talking about feeling the need to be ready to fight off babysnatchers was the most relatable damn statement ever. My mind goes to babysnatchers, wolves, and other random threats 😂
beep, beep im a meep. i said beep, beep, im a meep.
I love the TARDIS is now fully wheelchair accessible 😊
It's a small but really nice inclusion isn't it? Of course, it also made the usual crowd mad and that's always a good thing.
@bumsnypha has it upset people? 😂 maybe they should think of it as old fashioned Dalek friendly instead then 🤣
@@ennayanne highlighy doubtful because i react to a ton of doctor who stuff and have not seen anyone mention it
Wilf even being mentioned made me cry a little , and im not gonna lie i thought donna was gonna knock four times , at the end , but they might save that for the last episode ,he was the doctor who said "i dont want to go " in contrast to jodies "tag ur it" so its interesting to see him getting closure so he can actually move on , and the hint of jodies positivity , fantastic!😊
Well it makes sense for this Doctor to have a bit more of that positivity because he is no longer burdened by the Time War. At this point that was so long ago. 10 was still dealing with his PTSD from the Time War. And it wasn’t until the 50th anniversary that we really saw the Doctor over come that.
@@darth_kal-eland then poor 12 had to deal with all the trauma from 11s time spent on Trensalor.
Fun fact: the Meep was voiced by Miriam Margoles, she's basically a national treasure in the UK, and she played professor Sprout in Harry Potter
Hufflepuff for life.
And she's incredible when she's on Grahm Norton's show. And I'm an American :D
Welp you learn something new everyday😅 would never have guessed, very good 👍(ps... I'm not even being sarcastic)
@@HellfireCommstransphobia for life more like.
@@ennayanne If that's your thing, don't let me stop you.
Kate Herron, who directed all of Loki Season 1, will be co-writing an episode of the upcoming Doctor Who season.
I don't think the TARDIS would look out of place if it landed at the TVA.
I thought Loki was the next Doctor? Lol
@@Jimmy_Jones OMG, could you IMAGINE the reaction if Tom Hiddleston was named the 16th Doctor?! 😮🤓🤯😵💫🤩
OH taken the words out of my mouth. Honestly, Loki give MAJOR Time Lord vibes in Season 2. I would be hyped to see him as the Doctor.
@@MatthewCYN15 Tom delivered that technobabble on the final episode with the confidence and style required. He's too big a name now to want to take the role but he would've made a great Doctor in another universe. Guess we have to settle for him as the MCU's Doctor.
@@hanonhold MCU's Doctor indeed 😁 though a small part of us hope Tom gets to be the Doctor 💚💙
i was half expecting the doctor to be like "THE ROUND THINGS!"
Oh… and I just realized… Rose is a Toy Maker. Oh. Oh. That. Yeah. Wondering how that will relate in episode 3.
Hah, nice parallel
"I loved that man" leaves a mark. Not gonna lie.
SO glad to see Doctor Who on the channel!!! Please keep reacting past the specials into Ncuti’s run as 15!! ❤️❤️❤️
Meep was practically designed to sucker Jay and Adam with that soft fur and big kitty eyes. Moment Meep started talking, I told my kids "I dont trust it!"
I absolutely yelled THANK
YOU JAY because I've been saying UNIT headquarters looks like avengers tower 😂
Don't forget. It has been almost FIVE BILLION YEARS for the Doctor. And he remembers how his friend Donna takes her coffee......
True friendship, y'all.
It has not. The process to get through that Wall in Heaven Sent took almost 5 Billion Years. The Doctor is not actually 5 Billion years old. He's a few thousand at the most. Remember, he kept dying and returning as a clone.
@@KojinMacJorn For almost five billion years. But l I know people on the internet gotta argue about everything.
Have a nice day.
@@scotthewitt258maybe if you took a moment to listen and not be condescending you will learn something. When the Doctor spent the 4.5 billion years in the Dial, He spent the whole time reliving the same few days in a new body. so by the time he finally escapes the dial for him it only felt like a few days real time, since his final body never experienced the billions of years of the passage of time. The Doctors real age is somewhere around 2,500 years old both in physical and mental age. so in reality the last time he saw donna was roughly 1,600 years prior to the new special. no ones trying to argue... just spreading some knowledgeable information to fellow Doctor Who fans.
Have a nice day.
@@scotthewitt258Didn't you read their comment? The doctor didn't remember those years
@@scotthewitt258 Not arguing, in this case, correcting. The Doctor is not over 5 billion years old. The process took 5 Billion years over millions, if not billions of copies of a Doctor who was only... a few thousand years old.
He really isn't 5 Billion years old.
youre so right about this episide being effortlessly fun, i was grinning the whole time i was watching this special!
4:50 Being traumatised by Doctor Who as a child is a British rite of passage
After watching years of you reacting to American programmes (and LOVING it) as a Brit it was awesome to see you react to a quintessentially British Show - my claim to fame-ish Tom Baker lived near our local supermarket and you could hear his laugh echo through the aisles, and the coat and scarf...his.
Love this reaction and looking forward to your reaction to the future episodes. ❤
Obviously intentional "accident" was obviously intentional.
And some of us think the TARDIS was "playing along" by adding all the sparks and flames.
Given how she was portrayed when she had a body, I am in that same exact camp as well.
I desperately need you all to know that this was adapted from a comic from a Who comic in the 70s. And they ended up cutting out a scene where we see a flashback of the Meep's home planet.
On the home planet, you see plenty of Meeps dancing around and singing wonderful songs and playing cute games...the topic of these? Murdering as many people as possible and causing loads of graphic destruction. I'm so sad they didn't have time for it because the scene is hilarious lmao
I believe they also had to cut down on the amount of VFX shots sadly
Okay I need to find this comic somewhere
Fraggles ❓
Seeing you this happy makes me as happy as when watching the episode! :o) Thank you so much!
I like some people saying "a little cheesy" or "a little heavy handed".
GUYS HAVE YOU WATCHED THIS SHOW IN THE 2000s under RTD? Have you watched RTDs filmography? Have you watched Tennant playing the Doctor before?
This is EXACTLY the cheese and the heavy hand this show needed. You thought RTD would retcon/pull back from the inclusivity some call "wokeness"? Because that was clear this wouldn't happen with RTD back in the game.
And I loved every second of it. We needed that "effortless fun". I'm very very happy, for one, about this. That's peak "Who revival era" that started with Eccleston.
It's a little frustrating sometimes, because people sometimes act like just because they saw what they are doing in regards to inclusivity at all, that it's "heavy handed". It's a constant tight rope of "ugh so heavy handed" and so subtle it was probably missed by a majority of people. Its alright to just be obvious about it.
@@StarmongooseExactly, trans people right now don't need someone to quietly whisper "trans rights". They need it to be SCREAMED across the nation, and that's exactly what we got and it was amazing.
@@Starmongoose well no it isnt because people watch shows to be engrossed in the shows not have twitter activism blurted out in the middle of them. It always comes across quite nasty aswell tbh. Nothing inclusive about donna and roses last scene with the doctor. It was quite disrespectful to male audiences. The amount of shows these days that put down certain groups to elevate others rather than just tell a nice story is beyond sad
TBH, it was heavy handed, but I loved it all the more for that. It was like RTD went "Well they're gonna call me Woke anyway, lets just fucking go nuts!"
Also, men in TV are not a marginalised or downtrodden minority. Piss off with that nonsense.
@@charg1nmalaz0r51 Cry about it
26:00 "We could end up anywhere in time and space😟!"
As if that's not an average Tuesday for you, Doctor😂😂
Fun fact: the Meep comic this episode is based on came out 2 years *before* E.T.
After having watched this episode, am I walking around constantly saying "Hail to the Meep"?.......... Maybe........
27:23 So you know, at least from what I've seen, Tenant's 14th Doctor is NOT going to being around until next year. Although, there is also a solo adventure with the 14th Doctor in the comics (The Liberation of the Daleks) which has already been released.
The 14th Doctor is ONLY on-screen in these three specials. The last of which is being released on 12/9/2023. It is unknown right now if he will regenerate into Ncuti Gatwa's 15th Doctor at the end on the special on 12/9, but he probably will.
The 2023 Christmas Special (The Church on Ruby Road) is scheduled to be released on Christmas Day and is slated to be Gatwa's first full outing as The Doctor. The 15th Doctor's first season is 8 episodes and is set to be released sometime in 2024. They started shooting his second season about a month ago. That will also be 8 episodes and is set to be released in 2025.
"I ain't mind controlled, I'm just into it."
Same, Jay. Same.
The introduction and epilogue are shot in Camden Markets in London, one of the best places in the UK for independent market sellers and funky bespoke fashion - the Cyberdog store in the background is a real store for a clothing brand that sells cyberpunk/rave culture fashion. My wife and I visited it whilst in town for a Dresden Dolls concert 5 years ago on Halloween, so this gave me sincere nostalgia.
Had the pleasure of meeting Mr Dave Gibbons, who drew the comic this episode is based on, at a convention in Birmingham back in 2006. Charming and friendly fellow, chatted with him briefly (about what I can't recall) and he signed a copy of Absolute Watchmen for me, which I then gave away as a gift like an idiot to the brother of my then-girlfriend. Gibbons is best known of course for his work on Watchmen, but also did a lot of other great work in the 80s for DC among others, including classic storylines like For The Man Who Has Everything (the Superman birthday story where Mongul traps him in an illusion of Krypton) and the Green Lantern story Mogo Doesn't Socialise, both of which have since been adapted into cartoon form.
“effortless kinetic fun” is such a spot-on description of that rtd energy i’ve been missing
Had so much fun watching you Guys react to this. I’ve been a Doctor Who fan since I was about 5 years old (I’m 57 now) and I was almost at the point of giving up on the show during Jodie Whitaker’s tenure (totally not her fault - I thought she was great, but really let down by the majority of the stories she was given), but this special has given me a reason to watch again - and enjoy it! Your reaction was easy, honest and a joy to watch! I’m duly subscribed, Gentlemen!
I am so so happy that you guys have reacted to this!!
"I don't think I've been this happy in a long time" My feelings about the special exactly.
That was simply a delight! Very glad you're doing this. Seeing all your joy and hype, being a fan of the franchise, is just fun! I feel like we've all become so analytic about the media we love, similar in reactions, and this year we've had a few movies and now this, that remind us that it can simply be FUN.
It was great to have watched the episode, already knowing about the Meep's true intentions, but having had all the same reactions about the adorable-ness. Only to see you go through the same xD
The sheer joy of this reaction is everything. Can’t wait for the next episode!
Learning that you guys are Whovians has made my day
Beep the Meep is sorta-kinda a recurring villain of the Doctor already, we were first introduced to The Most High, in a comic run in Doctor Who Weekly (the original title of Doctor Who Magazine) against the Fourth Doctor, and has appeared in the format a few times since.
That first comic run was adapted by Big Finish (with Tom Baker) and adapted again in this very special 60th anniversary special. The Meep also appeared in a DWM special CD audio release, which came with an issue of Doctor Who Magazine (that time facing the Sixth Doctor).
Meep Meep!
I first started watching/loving Doctor Who about 10 years ago and I hadn’t watched it in a long time, but after finally seeing Good Omens I really fell back in love with rewatching episodes with David Tennant’s Doctor. This whole episode felt like a giant hug in so many ways and I can’t wait for the next two parts ❤❤
(I’ve also definitely been feverishly searching the house for my sonic screwdrivers lol)
I love when a reaction is done by people who KNOW the show. Your genuine reactions were exactly right. RTD you get an enthusiastic chef’s kiss for this episode. Off to watch it for a 3rd time…bye!
I loved this so much, both the episode and your reaction. You’re totally right that modern Who has been missing so much, for the last few years. I’ve been a Whovian since childhood and seen adventures with every Doctor. But, there’s just so much special magic and camp that RTD brings to the show. There are so many people who work behind the scenes, who he’s also brought back too.👏😀🥲
I already thought this episode was great, but it really does keep getting better with each re-watch. So many easter eggs, or just subtle details that you missed. Looking forward to the next two episodes!
I have VERY much missed not only Tennant and Tate, but RTD's writing as well. What a fantastic episode.
“Binary… Binary… Binary.” Got me good 😭
👿"Get Meeped!" 😆😆😆
A little over the top but, honestly, the queer community deserves some cheesiness every now and then. My only real critique is that I still don't fully understand the episode title. Was the Meep the Star Beast? That might be more on me than them.
Edit: Thanks for the background!
Yes, the Meep is the Star Beast. the title is actually from the Meep's first appearance in Doctor Who Magazine in the 80s, a story called 'Doctor Who and the Star Beast', which this special partially adapts
If I remember right, that was part of the title of the comic where the Meep made its first appearance
@@SirAdamusGames Ah, ok- thanks for explaining. Never read the comics so that helps.
@@xavierkoide1644 Ah, thank you
@@AlexanderWandering It's named as such because it has the powers of the Psychedelic Sun that it uses to control people.
Glad to see you guys are covering the specials too. Hope you stick around for Nctui's era!
I am so happy you finally posted this on the tubes!
Unless I’m wrong, there’s supposed to be 3 specials with 14, and the 4th thing coming, the Christmas special later this month is Ncuti Gatwa’s first solo episode as 15.
I'm so happy you did this! Ahhh it's so exciting. Love your faces when the Meep revealed it's true colours. :D
Donna has FIERCE mum energy.
SO happy you're reacting to Doctor Who and I hope you continue to the new season next year. You both looked so deliriously happy throughout!
I LOVED this episode so much and you guys had the perfect reactions too! Can't wait to watch next week with you!
Jay looks like he has a new dark patron 🤣❤️
11:47 “You should be running”
Jay, her legs don’t work 🫢
Absolutely love Doctor Who but never expected you to react to it, figured it was something you'd save to watch and enjoy in your own time, so it was an absolute joy to watch this, thank you so much guys, what a treat! I love watching you guys have fun with a reaction, and this was so lovely I watched it twice, cant wait for future DW reactions!
This episode has Para-Demons/Mothmen, dark side Baby Yoda, War-chairs, Mordor in London…and 3 Doctors for T-time.
DOCTOR WHO REACTS?!?!?!!! First jeopardy, now Doctor Who?!?!?!? See, this is why y’all will always be my favorites, MY HEARTS!!!!!
WE'VE GOT THE MEEPS -Interdimensional Arbys-
I didn't realize how much I missed Murray Gold's music until this episode.
This is where the Allons-y begins!
Yay! So happy to have you guys reacting to this! 🎉💙💙🎉
That episode felt like a legit episode of Doctor Who! Sure, I liked Jodie and her Doctor, but..... it was too serious. It had too many serious topics and wasn´t just as fun as the old Doctor Who episodes...... but THIS.... Holy shit. You could tell that they had fun doing this episode.
I mean, Jodie's run had the same comedic/serious ratio as every other Doctor. Like, they've all had some whacky stuff. I can get some criticisms of Jodie's era, even if I don't agree with them, but she had pretty much the same story tone balance as every other NuWho Doctor. Plus, 13 was debatably the most generally upbeat Doctor, tied with 11.
@@ewanholme1687That's true. I didn't like Jodie's run at all but she was definitely very positive and optimistic, many times to the show's detriment even.
Adam summed it up well, it was just a fun time. :)
I think this right here is purest reaction to the *feel* of Doctor Who being back in every aspect. If anyone asks how the new RTD era is, I shall direct them here.
I didn't think you'd do Doctor Who, might have to join the patreon to get the full reaction.
I would sell my soul for a Dr Who/Loki crossover.
(music starts) "I hear the secrets that you keep, when you're talkin' to The Meep..."
Glad you guys are doing these on your main channel!
I'm posting a second time....forgive me....but I just had to tell you guys how wonderful it was to see your amazing positive and fun reaction to this episode. I loved The Star Beast, and it was a shock when I started to view all these incredibly negative reviews elsewhere on the internet. Thing is, several of them weren't just negative, they were really hateful and vicious, not offering thoughtful critism, but just mean-spirited and (I have to say it) bigoted comments about "woke" this and "woke" that, and a flat out attack of Yasmin Finney. It was very sad to see the kind of hateful posts I saw from Doctor Who fans. If you don't like this episode, no problem, but that kind of bigoted hate? In Doctor Who fans? I was just so happy to find this review. Thankyou again!
You have no idea my excitement level for this!! So happy you guys are doing this!!
Solarpsychedelia is an awesome band name.
I thought the exact same thing! 😎✌🏻
This gives me such joy.
In an interview with RTD, he said that the first special would have the feel of a classic style episode, almost self contained. We had a goofy alien and the spisode gave space for Doctor & Donna to reunite ready for the craziness of the next two episodes. Fantastic upgrades for TARDIS and Sonic Screwdriver. A great success ! As much as I wanted a three parter that was packed with cameos, I am very happy with Russell's instinct on Part 1.
My favorite boys reacting to my favorite show. Yippee!
So cool that you two are doing Dr Who... This episode was awesome, the best of Tennant's excitable fun mixed with a bigger budget without losing the classic camp-ness of Dr Who
I’ve finally been able to watch this episode - loved it! And now I’m excited to be able to experience your guys’ reactions, especially with Whovian Adam watching his Doctor on screen again.
Jason means Healer or Physician. So Donna named her son Doctor. Then her daughter took the name Rose 🌹. Maybe TARDIS had something to do with that. RTD’s attention to detail is amazing.
Those cybermen (capaldi era) were call backs to the OG cybermen from the 60s..
Arby's. We have The Meep.
I've been waiting for this day for a long time!!! You guys are reacting to Doctor Who!!! Wooo Wooo Woo! Wooo Wooo
Love seeing Adam so happy, I felt the same exact way. Grinning like an idiot the entire time.
I loved this so much 💙 can’t wait for your reactions to the other episodes! 😁
Too many feels to see Russell T. Davies, have the intro music, be WATCHING DOCTOR WHO AGAIN especially with cha boys. What a DAY.
Can we just take a moment to think about how the wrarth warriors look alot like the grass hoppers from a bugs life when they fly (A disney movie btw)
I'm just SO happy. My Doctors back and it feels like home.💙🤍💙🤍
Russel has returned.
Thank you guys for reacting to Doctor Who....finally. My first Doctor was #4 (Tom Baker) but Capaldi did it for me (He made Parliament Funkadelic cannon...Dr. Funkenstein) and Matt Smith was a gem. I watch some of Jodi but I couldn't get through most of it. The fun wasn't there. My nephews heard Meep and thought it was Phineas and Ferb Meap 😂. Jay's look when he realized the twist and how he loves it. Meap will be back. Now, I'm off to eat some Starburst (The Reds).