OmniDog's Vault: DC Absolutes You Must/Must Not Own Part 3
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 апр 2019
- EDIT! ABSOLUTE DEATH GETS A REPRINT! final part DC Absolutes: Black Mirror, Sandman, Killing Joke, Arkham Asylum, New Frontier, Justice, Swamp Thing, Batman; Year One, Final Crisis, Flashpoint, Promethea, Batman:The Master Race
Кино
Absolute: Killing Joke is the best Absolute Edition I’ve got of anything. It’s a short story, yes, but the Absolute Edition specifically is great! It includes both Bolland’s recoloring and the original, and the recoloring on glossy paper and original on its original paper. PLUS Moore’s FULL script and extra art from Brian Bolland! If you love The Killing Joke and only have the Deluxe Edition or the original, Absolute is a must.
(Coming from a guy who likes short one shot stories and tons of extra content)
that's cool, I'm glad you like it! My issue is with the story itself not being my cup of tea but of course, that's on me.
Omnidog's Vault Of course what I never mentioned was that it’s kind of special to me as it was my first comic when I started collecting. I’m sorry to hear you’ve kind of grown to not like it. That’s perfectly fine, just wanted to give a different perspective for people scrolling through. Also, found this series super helpful btw!
@@bradenhogan2 no worries! I get that totally! It was a huge deal, I remember but my opinion about Alan Moore's work in general has changed. Which has nothing to do with your love for the book! You are absolutely entitled to that, which I think we both agree on. Thank you for the compliment, I'm glad you found the series helpful!!
Absolute Death is scheduled to have a new printing on January 2020 (ISBN 9781401224639), so that’s one less problem off the list.
Loving this little series you're doing, I've never read Alan Moore swamp thing so I'm definitely waiting on that absolute
thanks Darklantern!
I wish I could get the Absolute Saga of the Swamp Thing & read it for the first time again.It’s my favourite run of any comic,I think I’ll just stick with my six Trade Hardbacks though.3 absolutes are a bit too expensive an ask when I’ve got ‘Moore’s run in 6hardback trades already & have read it first trade to last about 20 times(it might actually be more than that)but yeah I’m jealous of anybody reading this for the 1st time but glad a lot more people are going to be exposed to my favourite (From Hell & Watchmen are probably his best most ambitious books that I appreciate his genius in more,I just enjoy this more)comic run ever!
Killing Joke- 100% agree that it hasn’t aged well.
The art work is unforgettable but story wise it does not hold up
Great recommendations! I haven't read Promethea yet so I'm very curious now.
Morning Notification Squaaaaaaaaaaaaaaddddd!!!!!! Another great video!!
Thank you buddy!!!
It's 2020 dog I just watch part 1 & 2 now 3 lovely video really interesting and good advices
glad you enjoyed it!!
Nice channel you have here sir, very helpful.
Thank you for watching!!
Justice is getting reprinted in Deluxe. I'm getting that :), that's the format I got Kingdom Come in too and happy with that.
Justice is one of my all time faves, so I'm happy it's at least getting a deluxe!!
@@OmnidogsVault Yes! Alex Ross definitely deserves to be oversized (or over oversized). Besides World's Greatest Heroes is there another DC book with him doing interiors?
@@freddiealonsonido I can only think of Kingdom Come, Justice and World's Greatest Heroes.
@@OmnidogsVault Just picked up Justice Deluxe, it's beautiful, I would have gotten the Absolute, hope they will reprint! Gonna get myself Kingdom Come and WGH in Absolutes.
hawkdiehard nice!! Great stories and art!!
I have just bought the BYO Absolute (got a 15% discount from my local guy so that's a little lighter on the wallet!). There are 2 books that come with it, book one is the new recoloured edition, and book two is the original untouched classic version. Nice to have both! Cheers
I’m still searching for Justice and New frontier and I will email DC about reprinting them it seems crazy they are Not perpetually in print. I will counter that Flashpoint is worth getting in Absolute. I was skeptical about paying so much for so little. But I bought it on a whim 60% off and love it. Kubert’s art and the tight albeit short story is amazing. I’ve read it over at least twice since buying it a month ago and it’s now one of my most cherished books. Yes DC will probably omnibize (trademarking that word) Flash point but for now it’s perfect. What about absolute Batman INC? I’m thinking just wait for the Morrison omnibus instead. Great video as always, loved this series.
Alan Moore’s “TOP 10” is the best bang for your buck absolute than anything I’ve came across.It’s arguably Alan Moore’s best collection of superhero books(yeah it’s as good as Watchmen,but they are completely different takes on the superhero genre so both are must have Absolutes)The absolute contains TOP 10 vol’1 & 2,Smax,TOP 10 ‘49ers & a one shot story thrown in for good measure.The content is as epic in quality as it is in quantity
socillizt4life I agree with everything you said. Too bad that it’s super OOP!
Glad you feel the same as me about master race, although i would be harsher than calling it middling.
Still haven't read Swamp thing
yes, I remember you were very critical of it lol!!
Hey Jesse great video as usual but you didn't mention the Absolute Blackest Night by Geoff Johns.
excellent point, I don't own it though...
When Absolute Swamp Thing came out I friggin loved it and I loved the recolouring it was like reading it again for the first time! I picked up the swamp Thing Bronze Age omni and very happy with it and can’t wait for the absolute ST volume 2 this year! Plus nobody STILL understands Final Crisis to this day lol 😂
Also I really wish DC would recollect Tom Strong even in hardcover or trade but an omnibus or absolute Tom strong with gorgeous Chris Spiuse artwork I would LOVE!!
I just ordered the first two Swamp Thing absolutes last week. I'm also thinking about rebuying Watchmen and Transmetropolitan in absolute format, beause those are two of my favorite comics ever written, and my old paperback copies are pretty lackluster (dull coloring, cheap paper, smaller format, etc).
I also did the same thing as you and bought the Sandman omnis; I would have liked to have the absolutes, but couldn't justify dropping an extra $150 just for the larger artwork.
yeah the omni's for Sandman work better for me! Good choices on Absolutes!
I wish I had friends that collected Absolutes so I could see the Batman Year One Absolute hands on in person. I’m so conflicted because it’s probably my favorite art in a dc book ever, I’m a massive Mazzucchelli fan. But the cost is way way too much.
yeah I understand completely. If it was by Alex Ross I'd buy it no matter what the cost lol, but we have to factor price into our decisions...
Well, since this video was uploaded DC has reprinted Absolute New Frontier, a 15th Anniversary Edition. It also has all the extras in it now, including the story you mention in this video.
very happy about that!
The Sandman omnibus format is still really nice. I think Death will come back in print eventually; whoever publishes it isn’t leaving money on the table
A little late to the party -- but, I got the absolute Swamp Thing and love the new colors (I didn't grow up with the original comics, just the trades). I didn't understand the big uproar with the recoloring . Did those same people complain about Sandman being recolored?
Wondering what your opinion is.
skrewler i think the difference is that the colors were considered an essential part of the story in Swamp Thing. They contributed to the mood and feeling of the book. That said, while I understand the complaints I don’t mind the recoloring.
For what Utsav worth, a new edition, printing of New Frontier Delux Edition has been announced, pre-orders being taken for it. Even though I have the 15-year anniversary Absolute, I think I'd like to get the new Deluxe of it as well. And, maybe we need a part 4 of your 'DC Absolute' up-loads...
Freddie also asked for that! I'll have to go back and see what I've added since then!!
@@OmnidogsVault Please do, could be fun !
Great video 🖒🖒🖒
Thank you so much!!
Absolute Ronin by Frank Miller. A must, read, must-have favorite.
Remarkable!
Thank you!!
Absolute Flashpoint had I think 100 pages of additional content in it, but I think it might be better as omnibus. I would hope they would include that extra material in an omnibus format.
What about absolute Authority? Thanks for your channel
I think the new one just announced would be a great way to read it.
This was fun to watch, even if it was just to read Cycle's comments. :) I don't see Absolute Identity Crisis on that list.
I addressed Identity Crisis in Part 2 of this, go watch that and steal this idea...
@@OmnidogsVault Ah okay. Well it's only fair I steal this idea since you stole it from Gem Mint first......oh shit, he went there! ;)
@@NearMintCondition I don't steal his ideas, I steal yours!!
@@OmnidogsVault This is true....so what I'm doing is i'm stealing back. :)
Identity crisis was a great read! I like the version of deathstroke in it.
So far, I try to get every Absolute. I like the format and the presentation. I wish they would fill the gap between the Green lantern Absolutes...
I'm guessing they won't because of the 3 volumes of Johns GL Omni but I just wish they'd reprint Absolute Sinestro Corps War
Hmmm. I want to do a Swamp Thing collection. I would like to get the Bronze Age Omnibus and grab the Absolutes. But I'm worried if the omni is worth grabbing or not. I'm also debating if I want the Alan Moore run collected in hardcover or the trades. I haven't read the series. But the reception is so positive that I think it could be a run worth re-reading in the future. I feel that hardcovers have a longer life which is why I like to invest in them.
Thanks for the episode. Hope there's more. This is fun.
I did do a ST Bronze Age omni overview which might help you decide. The Moore run has a high re-reading factor for me because it was so different than what came before!
@@OmnidogsVault i'll watch it again. Thanks Jess.
Hey Omnidog... by any chance do you have the blackest night absolute? If so, by any chance would you be looking to sell? Thanks for the great content!
Sorry, I don't own it! Thanks for watching!
Is Blackest Night not a good read? I didn't see it on any of the videos. The art looks cool. I have the HC but I haven't read it because I'm new to reading comics and I want to buy the entire Geoff Johns omni volumes and read them in order.
I think you can read the Johns GL omnis and the Blackest Night issues in there will be plenty of good reading and in context too. It's in GL omni 1.
The Killing Joke is in a small less than 80 page that is recolored HC from DCBS when I ordered almost a decade ago. New Frontier is in a single tpb w/ the DC Black Label on it. Final Crisis gave me a massive headache. Finally, can you do a DK III spotlight on the art. Please. I stayed away from DK III because of DK Returns. I need the better 50% approval before I'll get it.
New Frontier might be the greatest Absolute of all time. That, or Sandman ;) hahaha. very surprised it's not in print since it's probably as seminal as Watchman imo.
Absolute New Frontier is getting reprinted next week! With extra stories! And I agree, it might be the best one ever!
Damn, that flashpoint looked crisp, can u show ur custom bounds too in a future video?
I did a video with @NearMintCon in 2018 about our custom bound books! Here's the link: ruclips.net/video/Nkm2JkRG1SE/видео.html&lc=Ugzf0B7kVdftieYG-oR4AaABAg
@@OmnidogsVault So f'ng good, thanks a lot man
Black Mirror will also have Francavilla art 👍
Part 4
Flashpoint Absolute is only $46 on Amazon so I think I’m going to buy it. Otherwise I wouldn’t buy it
What about Haunted Knight
Late , but where did you buy your shelves for your books ?
IKEA
Do the skeleton cases stories appear as backup stories as they were originally realesed (detective comics #871-873) or are they presented together after detective comics #873 and before detective comics #874?
they are put together for the black mirror absolute and TPB
@@OmnidogsVault Thank you so much
Hi I like Batman and I want to know which absolute you recommend for me?
It's going to be my first one, thank you.
My first Batman Absolute is the one I'm going to recommend to you: Batman: Hush
Okay Thank you
Arkham asylum and black mirror
do I need to get absolute death or is it good enough to just to get the main story and overture?
you need to get Absolute Death, extremely important/great stories. Getting a reprint this coming /winter
What are your thoughts on absolute batman and robin reborn ?
I think it's fantastic
What about Crisis on Infinite Earths? Deluxe or Absolute?
well, the art is great so I would say Absolute!
Final Crisis. Read it twice. Still literally no idea what's happening.... :/
yep! I'm right there with ya!
DCcomics.com says Absolute Death is available now. The only other place I can find it online is TFAW who say it's due January 2020. Now I"m not sure what to trust lol
I'd trust TFAW, it's due first thing next year
@@OmnidogsVault Good deal, thanks :)
Didn't Absolute New Frontier get a reprint for the 15th anniversary?
Enos666 yes!
Dark Knight 3 is really Holy Terror. Dark Knight 3 is really Dark Knight 4.
Hey Omnidog, you wrote in you infobox that Absolute Death is getting a reprint. Really? The reason why i ask is i just got one of the last copies from amazon but with some huge bumps. Would like to return it but just in cause there is definitly a reprint. Are you sure about that, coulnt find anything about that fact.
David
unless DC cancels it, it has been solicited for January 2020
@@OmnidogsVault Thank you so much.
Killing joke did not age well because Batman does not talk like batman. He speaks like Night-Owl or some other timid bastard.
I feel like the treatment of Barbara in this did not help but that's just my opinion