People who do theories need to keep in mind that yes they're actors but they also have real lives. Therefore, slight hair color differences & weight gain/losses shouldn't be considered clues.
Every thing they change Marlene king has to say yes or no on what they want to change so there for Marlene kijng is all the way control of everything even shay Mitchell said she has to run everything by her
To be honest, I feel really sorry for Charles. He obviously treasures the time he spent with his real family because he keeps all the photos and videos of them in his volt, but for some reason he didn't grow up with the DiLaurentis family, which is pretty sad. The prom is another sad thing for me, I mean he created the prom in his dollhouse that would have been his prom and he obviously wishes that he could have been at this prom, which means he obviously does have feelings and does care, which makes me feel bad for him. Also the Liars and everyone else won't forgive him for everything he put them through, so he will be completely alone.
Ok maybe Jason looked a little "nervous, guilty, etc." because he was accusing his sister of murder and realizing that the person he grew up with and loves could be a psychopath. Just a thought
I honestly think Charles doesn't have any anger problems. Even the director's and Marlene said that we would feel very sad and emotional towards Charles. I believe something very bad must've happened to him with the whole situation. Maybe Andrew is just helping Charles for what they think is deserved. Charles honestly must be lonely, I mean when Spencer and the girls called him to come out from "hiding" during the prom scene he basically listened even though he was gonna come out eventually (maybe), I feel bad for him and I bet when we find out the story everyone will feel some empathy towards him.
Nicole Zerone I know right during that scene when he came out I felt so pitiful for him he's body language was so desperate and tragic I wanted to tell him he's forgiven.
Nicole Zerone I feel extremely sorry for him too, whatever his story is or his reason behind torturing the girls (with whoever else) has a reason behind it, and whatever that reason is i fell will have everyone like 'awwww' or something.
Yeah and I think that maybe Charles dies or someone he really cares about does.I mean how can it be heartbreaking, and full of agony. Unless like others have said , maybe Jason was the one who was trying to drown Alison and their dad came upstairs and saw Charles and Jason. Only Jason was the one who tried to drown Alison. Charles is then put in Radley and Jason is free to wreak havoc and torture everyone. Just a thought and I read more about it. I can't stand it . Maybe it's Ian, Eddie Lamb, Wilden, Holbrook, Holden, Hell "Big Rhonda!" Where is she at? Loved her...😋
when "Charles" came face to face with Spencer, he had the same head shape from this Jason (from the back) -_- and listen carefully to the words of the song starting at 2:59
Jason did tell the truth about Ali not being there all day on thanksgiving we saw Ali's flashback. Jason changing his story I put on Mr. D. He seems majorly in denial of anything that involves Ali looking bad. And there is 7 years difference so Jason's gotta be 25 if Ali is 18. I need to do a serious rewatch marathon lol
The mom in the photo with the baby & 2 boys is Mary Drake (you can tell Mrs. D and Mary apart by their hair. Mary's hair is always parted from the left & Jessicas is parted from the right.... When Mary is pretending to be Jessica, the hair is pulled back).
I was now thinking that A is harassing the girls, blackmailed Melissa into wearing the black swan costume, playing with Toby and his quest to find his mom, working with Mona. How many others were harassed or blackmailed by A? Lucas definatly(he said it was Mona), If Jason isn't CHarles then he was probably harassed by A as well as Maya who was getting texts. She was said to have been hiding from her stalker, but could it have been a different stalker than she thought? Yes, this one guy, I forget his name was stalking her, but alot of people are saying that they don't think that it was him who killed Maya and he never said he did. Either it was Charles or someone else who killed her, or Maya is not dead. I also think it's an important clue when Spencer sees a blonde in the window when Maya was living in ALi's house.
Maybe Mrs. D only showed enough love to two certain kids, causing one of them to feel neglect and hurt, if they are twins that is, if they are like cousins then that would make more sense.
also when he was watching the video of mona being attacked he said "could be my sister" paused then said "could be Alison" like he was talking about two different people. His sister (bethany?) and Alison
Off topic kind of. One of the producers said in an interview that Andrew, Mona and Spencer were linked. Andrew may not have bad intentions, but he is not who he says he is. I had a thought last night, I actually theorize while falling asleep. Anyways, The police force in Rosewood is so incompetent and corrupt. I think Tanner does not trust the police, this is pretty clear with Toby, although I know Toby is on my suspect list, that there are leaks and she wanted to investigate without letting some of the others in. I think , although I don't know the reason yet, but it is important, that Holbrooks reaction when he was removed from the case. His whole reaction was a put on. That it was a show, because Toby revealed to Tanner Holbrook's involvement with Ali. I believe that was staged. back to Andrew, Could tanner have hired Andrew? Is he working as her informant, getting close to the girls? If he's not Andrew, or that's an alias, he looks young, he could pass at least for 18, but what if he's actually older? I know that there is an age difference, but he might be in his early 20's undercover in highschool. The reason I think this is his involvement with the Dilaurentis family, and his friendships with Spencer and Mona and now Aria. He is so smart because he already passed highschool. Or if he's an informant as a fellow classmate and is their age. I think that A texted Mike saying it was Mona and lead him to the pathfinders camp. I also think that the dollhouse is near the varjack cabin. The old cambell farm sounds like it was a abandoned farm. Ithink that's where there was a fire that Ali saved Emily. I was thinking could this be when A's face was disfigured? During the Jenna thing or the lodge fire, my guess is the lodge fire. That's when they found the red coat, and black widow came to be.
The reason I think that Holbrooks dramatic exit was staged, was all part of the bigger picture of the kidnapping and catching A, for Tanner. Maybe there was an Andrew Cambell but he did like G_xoxo said that one of the little boys was Charles and he died, that would make it possible for someone to assume the identity of someone who actually existed. She was right the vault room looked like a shrine to someone lost.I think there was a baby doll in the crib in the vault room.
Imagine that after they find A and they are happily living with there lives and 30 years later they have teenage daughters and then the liars and there daughters receive a message at the same time that says " now it's my turn bitches and I love the new addition to your little family. Can't wait to take you all out one by one -B"
@taylor john It makes sense if Charles hit Alison with a rock and he have to go to radley. Maybe he met Bethany there, because i think bethany has problems. And maybe wrote miss D i can't protect you anymore... to charles?
I profoundly think that Jason killed his own mother, and guys do you remember when Ali received a text from A that said "I burried your mother, just like I watched her bury you", now it only means one thing to me he's the one who tried to kill Ali that night, and he's the one who's been tormenting her ever since, I'd say he's the inside man, the one we see, and Charles is his partner in crime... However I don't know their motives yet :( And also it seems like Charles is obsessed with Alison and I wonder what made him this way.. Plus Ezra is still shady af.. like I don't buy that story about him writing a "novel".. Bullshit! You don't monitor underage girls on a daily basis just to write an effing "novel"!!
After the elevetor accident, Jason doesn't care about his sister anymore (min 1:00) because Jason might be dead and now Jason is someone else. But then, at the police 6:00 he seems like he cares about Ali? I'm confused... Could you explain please? BTW, great theory and video!
What if the vault isn't of Charles's most personal items? What if it was a room he built for Jason? Maybe A kidnapped Jason after the elevator incident and kept him there?
People saying things like Mrs. D had 4 children and a previous marriage, etc are pushing it too far. Bethany probably isn't a 4th child, and is either an Ali/Cece like character who manipulates people OR is just Charles' other personality or he is transgender or something and goes by the name Bethany. Having 4 children but 2 disappearing? That would not go unnoticed in Rosewood.
BlueHeartXXX TRUTH. seriously i thought i was the only one who was thinking that it just doesn't sound right. I love everybody's theories cause there very entertaining, but do you guys really think the PLL producers/Creators would make it that easy for us to figure out A?
That blonde girl who took Mona when Jason said "that could be my sister" could technically be Sarah Harvey (Bethany) and still be Jason's sister .. plus she wouldn't need an alibi because she was down in the "doll house the entire time"
Maybe they aren't identical twins but fraternal twins instead. It makes sense, and it would have to be Ali if it's Jason and Charles because of the ages of Melissa and Jason. Also Ali because it was Mrs.D.
When he was saying about the mona video and he said "it could be my sister, it could be Allison" he could be talking about two seperate people. One his full sister (who we dont know about) and Allison his half sister
I'm not sure if someone already said it.. but in the video of Mrs. D and the boys.. she sais "do you want to say goodnight to your little sister, give her a little kiss?" to the ONE boy. Then he gives her that little kiss and she sais "what a good boy you are".. then the other one pets her and Mrs. D sais "all good boys".. I don't really see why they would be twins or even siblings. The other boy could be a friend they brought with them.
In the pic of the boys one boy is taller with spiked up hair (meaning 1 or 2 years older) I think that one is charles, the other boy has shaggy hair, kind of like Jason's used to be.
Squid Bear no i have twin sibilings and one of them is taller than the other by like an inch or two its normal for twins. I'm not saying there twins but the looked the same age.
The picture at the beginning of Mrs Dilaurentis & children looks like the building where Emily got locked into with the car when Alison apparently got her out.
Anyone remember Andrew acting weird? My theory is him being the half brother of Charles and Bethany, besides the video of Mrs. D with a baby girl and two boys was taken at the 'Campbell' Farm aka Andrew's last name. Charles wanted someone to get close to the liars and succeeded.
Maybe Charles was a family friend who liked the Dilaurentis family more than her/his own. They called shim Charles Dilaurentis as a joke, but Charles began to believe it was true, and attempted to get with Alison to join the family. Maybe they played house or something when Ali was too and Charles hit her? Idk, I'm not even sure if I believe that theory myself.
i think the baby is spencer and shes mrs D child but she gave her up to her daddy cuz shes crazy so shes non identical twin to ali.. thats why mrs D hates her and affraid of her most of the time :D
Don't know if this is accurate because I can't keep up with all the details but I read somewhere that Supposedly Jason is 7 years older than Ali and Bethany is 2 years older than Ali..again, read it somewhere not sure if that's right but if so unless they expect us to believe one of those boys is 7 years old than that baby cannot be Ali but could be Bethany....
that circular decoration is the same just like at the place the police found the cameras aka charles' lair(whatever you want to call it) am i the only one??
I think Jason died in the elevator and Charles is impersonating him. I noticed something huge in a picture of Charles and Spencer in the vault. You could see Jason's colored hair peeking out the back of Charles' mask!
GUYS! i don't know what the story is but i know that the Jason from season 1 is way different from the Jason of the others! You can re-watch season 1 or you can search Pretty Little Liars Jason season 1 and look for the photo with the big V in the middle. The picture will show you a picture of Jason from season 1 with brown hair ( like Charles ) and another picture on the other side of Jason from all the other seasons! Marlene King states that Charles was not in the first episode but is defiantly in the first season! Jason from season 1 isn't in episode one but is in season 1! Guys i have no idea about the story of this but all i know is that there are two different Jasons and one of them has something to do with Charles or is Charles! if you have any ideas about the story of this put it down below! I ASURE YOU THAT THEY HAVE SOMETHING TO DO WITH IT BECAUSE WHY WOULD THEY JUST RANDOMLY CHANGE JASONS JUST BECAUSE! EVERYTHING IS DONE FOR A REASON! THERE ARE NO COINCIDENCES IN ROSEWOOD.
The thing is though, Marlene actually never said that big A wasn't in the pilot. I saw the tweet. Someone asked her "Is A someone we know since season 1?" Marlene replied saying " I said Original A Was in the pilot. But that doesn't mean Big A wasn't in Pilot." Just wanted to clarify.
I don't think Charles is a girl because we do see a boy in the video. I think he's Jason's brother and Bethany is Alison's twin and Sarah is actually Bethany, Charles is A and he attacked his two sisters.
DawnDawn190 I dont believe Charles is transgender. One reason is because if he was, why did Charles reveal himself dressed as a male to the girls in the dollhouse and respond to being crowned Prom King? If Charles identifies as a female, wouldnt he reveal himself dressed as a female? The writers/producers would have to answer as to why they did that with a good explanation, because I will be very confused. The second reason is because there is an interview with one of the writers (Bryan Holdman maybe?) and he revealed that the transgender theory would be too crazy for the Rosewood they have created. He said there are some things that get TOO crazy for the show. He said some stuff in the PLL books read well but don't translate to the world of Rosewood they've created. In the books, he says, that Aria finds out Noel's dad is a crossdresser and that was too far out there for the show. I would think they would feel the same way about the transgender end of it. I obviously don't know for sure, but I dont feel they will.
Really? Scrolling through old comments just so you can say you were right or you won? 😂😂 CONGRATULATIONS. I just put down my opinion, knowing there was a good chance it could be wrong. I liked the story. Did I think it felt a little rushed at times in how the storyline was presented, yes. But overall I enjoyed it. I have already watched it multiple times. Have a good time going around telling the world how right you were and how wrong they were, just because everyone has there own opinions. Enjoy ☺😉
My Theory...... I read an interview Keegan Allen (Toby) did and he said A has been in almost every episode since the first season. Sasha Pierterse(Ali) agreed with this and she said the big reveal of A when it is finally out is sad and twisted... I think Charles did something to Jason and has been perpetrating as Jason ever since.....there has been clues......1.)his dark room with all the pictures of Aria....and at the end of the episode A is in a dark room developing pictures ....... 2.) Aria stabbed a person with a screw driver/large nail.. while locked in the box on the Ghost Train episode and in the next episode at the end Mona comes out of Jason house lifts up his shirt and he has a screw driver/ large nail like puncture on the side of his stomach............3.) and we see Jason back turned seems like he is texting during Truth Up Weekend and mysteriously Aria has a text come through from A....Jason was helping Mrs Hastings mentor the Truth Up Class same class Aria was in.... There are many more clues as well... I think when Jason/Charles left to go back to Georgia to remodel his Grandma house he didn't ...instead he went to go build that underground creepy doll house the girls ended up being locked in during Season 5 Finale. He dressed up as Ali beat up and kidnapped Mona ...then made it look like he killed her.... When he visited his sister in jail he tells her straight up "I know you did not kill Mona" Just my theory Why I think Jason/Charles are the same person.
That is actually a great theory, that Charles "became" Jason after the whole elevator incident. Maybe Jason died and Charles took his place, escaping Radley? Hmm.
omg, do you guys remember those GIRL twins that were shown, well mabey those twins are actually charles and jason..... mabey thats a clue .... who knows
I've watched the summer finale (The A reveal that CeCe/Charles/Charlotte is A) and when Jason got showed the video, he said Alison. But if you don't remember CeCe, She was basically a version of Ali. Maybe Jason knew it was CeCe since they were dating. But as soon as I watched the recap doesn't Ali have longer hair?. But Ali wasn't with them. But of course it was not Ali because A had them in the dollhouse. And Mona was pretending to be Ali. (A's order). If this doesn't make sense I don't know 😂. I have a very weird thought process.
There have been two actors playing Jason... Maybe the recasting was actually a planned part of the story. The Jason that went to "Ali's funeral" isn't the same Jason that we've seen the rest of the show.
okay there goes my theory (sorry for my english, i'm spanish) i think Cece is not A, i think big A is Jason. Jason and Charles are twins /brothers it doesn't really matter. Okay, so one of them, Charles was crazy and evil and was sent to Radley. But he got out of there somehow and he killed Jason just to pretend to be him and Jessica knew so she always tried to protect his son. That's why Charles is buried. He met Bethany in Radley, and they are working together, she is red coat. They had to kill Jessica because she is the only one who knows everything. Jason/Charles is obsessed with Alison and the girls so this makes sense
while some of this could very well be true and is interesting, I think the fact that you pointed out the difference in looks in Jason after the accident and before is a little ridiculous. He looks different because of the way Drew has changed his look. (such as his hairstyle or color or if he lost or gained weight.)
What if Charles and Bethany are the same person? Maybe some people think the same, but I think both of them are the same person. I think that Charles is a trangender and he changed his gender when he was 16 (when he 'died' and Bethany Young was alive) Thats why Miss D bought both dresses and stuff.
Are you people forgetting about the black widow? I don't think that charles and bethany are the same person. I think that Charles and Bethany could be working together though. Bethany could be the black widow, which marlene did say that we get to learn who she is as well as charles.
I was just thinking when I looked at the picture, that we know Jason used to have longer hair...coincidence? Maybe he had it as a kid. So maybe the boy with the longer hair is Jason and the one with the shorter is Charlie.. the "imaginary" brother/friend. But then at the same time in the promo for 6x04 Charlie is dead? Now that I have to figure out but yeah thats my opinion!
When he said "could of been my sister. Could have been Alison" when he said sister maybe he was referring to Charles if Charles is transgender. I believe that Charles is transgender because in the book it says that A is Alison's twin sister and remember when Mrs. Draw bought two dresses? I think that one of them was for Charles, Ali's twin sister.
Do u remember in s1 e3 they did that tribute to alison jason looked completely different then after that he looks like he does now so maby that was his twin maby he is Charles
What Jason said at the police station made me a bit curious... To me it feels like he wants to say 'it could be my sister OR it could be Alison'. If it was Jason and he talks about his sister Alison everybody would Know he means her by only saying 'my sister'... so maybe it was Charles at the police station and he talks about his sister (Bethany??) and Alison
Well if u didn't know Charles wanted to a girl that's y mrs d bought two yellow dresses on of them was Ali and the other one is for Charles. So maybe Charles is Bethany Young
my theory Holbrook is Charles he disapeard and he was not with his dad maybe he was at the dollhouse with Mona and then came back and got fired we havin´t seen much of him in the last few episodes after he got fired he could be at the dollhouse maybe I mean he could be Charles it would make a lot of sence I said MAYBE and this is just a theory when I found this theory I just had to post it.
I think that Charles is transgender and his family didn't support him except for Mr's. D so he decided to get back at them. He/she came up with A. He started with Ali's closest friends Spencer, Emily, Aria, and Hanna. He then got mad at the 4 liars for trying to bring him/her down so he started to go after there family too. It all makes sense to me and I have heard plenty of other theories about this too and I agree. My second theory is that Mona is still A or she is working with Charles. Just think about it. Mona was collecting her blood and she probably got a human dummy and put blood on it when the liars saw it in the trunk. Mona faked her death and got Charles to help her. Mona had Charles help her set up the dollhouse. Mona is a mastermind she always was and she always will be. Please reply on what you think because I love these theories so ooze much!
But A now is mimicking mona and taking away what was hers and expanding it on a greater level, I think mona has nothing to do with the final A and that mona was just a mask to hide everything. Also I think that Charles is Jason's brother which was in radley as in the books the roles are reversed and Ali has the twin sister in radley xxx just my thought but I'm so excited now so many people know about A xx I'm starting to think there was only one BIG A all along xxx
Sara Greenough Wouldn't that be too easy if Charles was Jason's brother? And that thing that you said about A mimicking Mona what I think about it is Mona used to be the big A but then someone else over powered her and Mona used to treat them like crap so now Mona is no longer Big A.
People who do theories need to keep in mind that yes they're actors but they also have real lives. Therefore, slight hair color differences & weight gain/losses shouldn't be considered clues.
Tailor Foreman PREACH
Every thing they change Marlene king has to say yes or no on what they want to change so there for Marlene kijng is all the way control of everything even shay Mitchell said she has to run everything by her
Preach girl Preach
Tiffany Wellz Well yeah, that goes for hair color and stuff. But weight loss/gain? I think that just happens...
Say it again i dont think they here u preach it again
To be honest, I feel really sorry for Charles. He obviously treasures the time he spent with his real family because he keeps all the photos and videos of them in his volt, but for some reason he didn't grow up with the DiLaurentis family, which is pretty sad. The prom is another sad thing for me, I mean he created the prom in his dollhouse that would have been his prom and he obviously wishes that he could have been at this prom, which means he obviously does have feelings and does care, which makes me feel bad for him. Also the Liars and everyone else won't forgive him for everything he put them through, so he will be completely alone.
This is so true, there's no actual villain in the show. But everyone sticks to what they believe
Marlene has said we will feel sorry for -A when we find out the story I think it's just heartbreak in his past
Amy Perry yeah, he actually has a soul - mona & emily
Just because they don't look like twins doesn't mean they aren't, they could be non identical twins
Ok maybe Jason looked a little "nervous, guilty, etc." because he was accusing his sister of murder and realizing that the person he grew up with and loves could be a psychopath. Just a thought
Too many kids.
- Alison
- Jason
- Charles
- Bethany
- Spencer
-Melissa
Charles&Bethany are the same person
Hope Vines We don't know if Charles or Bethany is related,
Hope Vines NOOOOOOOOOOO BETHANY IS CHARLEESSSSS - CHARLES IS BETHANYYY = TRANSGENDER
It can't be Bethany's dead
Bethany is Charles idiot
I honestly think Charles doesn't have any anger problems. Even the director's and Marlene said that we would feel very sad and emotional towards Charles. I believe something very bad must've happened to him with the whole situation. Maybe Andrew is just helping Charles for what they think is deserved. Charles honestly must be lonely, I mean when Spencer and the girls called him to come out from "hiding" during the prom scene he basically listened even though he was gonna come out eventually (maybe), I feel bad for him and I bet when we find out the story everyone will feel some empathy towards him.
Nicole Zerone I know right during that scene when he came out I felt so pitiful for him he's body language was so desperate and tragic I wanted to tell him he's forgiven.
Nicole Zerone I feel extremely sorry for him too, whatever his story is or his reason behind torturing the girls (with whoever else) has a reason behind it, and whatever that reason is i fell will have everyone like 'awwww' or something.
Yeah and I think that maybe Charles dies or someone he really cares about does.I mean how can it be heartbreaking, and full of agony. Unless like others have said , maybe Jason was the one who was trying to drown Alison and their dad came upstairs and saw Charles and Jason. Only Jason was the one who tried to drown Alison. Charles is then put in Radley and Jason is free to wreak havoc and torture everyone. Just a thought and I read more about it. I can't stand it . Maybe it's Ian, Eddie Lamb, Wilden, Holbrook, Holden, Hell "Big Rhonda!" Where is she at? Loved her...😋
when "Charles" came face to face with Spencer, he had the same head shape from this Jason (from the back)
-_- and listen carefully to the words of the song starting at 2:59
this actually makes so much sense
Jason did tell the truth about Ali not being there all day on thanksgiving we saw Ali's flashback. Jason changing his story I put on Mr. D. He seems majorly in denial of anything that involves Ali looking bad. And there is 7 years difference so Jason's gotta be 25 if Ali is 18. I need to do a serious rewatch marathon lol
Alison wasn't with her dad and brother for the entire day of Thanksgiving. She's admitted it on a few different occasions....
That's what I said...
I LOVE THE MUSIC IN THE FIRST PART
The mom in the photo with the baby & 2 boys is Mary Drake (you can tell Mrs. D and Mary apart by their hair. Mary's hair is always parted from the left & Jessicas is parted from the right.... When Mary is pretending to be Jessica, the hair is pulled back).
I was now thinking that A is harassing the girls, blackmailed Melissa into wearing the black swan costume, playing with Toby and his quest to find his mom, working with Mona. How many others were harassed or blackmailed by A? Lucas definatly(he said it was Mona), If Jason isn't CHarles then he was probably harassed by A as well as Maya who was getting texts. She was said to have been hiding from her stalker, but could it have been a different stalker than she thought? Yes, this one guy, I forget his name was stalking her, but alot of people are saying that they don't think that it was him who killed Maya and he never said he did. Either it was Charles or someone else who killed her, or Maya is not dead. I also think it's an important clue when Spencer sees a blonde in the window when Maya was living in ALi's house.
I love this theory so much...very elaborate! Looking forward to Part 2🎉
The thing I always thought weird about this?
If they are brothers or twins.. Why does Mrs. D only say to one kid say goodnight to your sister
Maybe Mrs. D only showed enough love to two certain kids, causing one of them to feel neglect and hurt, if they are twins that is, if they are like cousins then that would make more sense.
I love the Jason/Charles theory, it does make sense.
also when he was watching the video of mona being attacked he said "could be my sister" paused then said "could be Alison" like he was talking about two different people. His sister (bethany?) and Alison
Off topic kind of. One of the producers said in an interview that Andrew, Mona and Spencer were linked. Andrew may not have bad intentions, but he is not who he says he is. I had a thought last night, I actually theorize while falling asleep. Anyways, The police force in Rosewood is so incompetent and corrupt. I think Tanner does not trust the police, this is pretty clear with Toby, although I know Toby is on my suspect list, that there are leaks and she wanted to investigate without letting some of the others in. I think , although I don't know the reason yet, but it is important, that Holbrooks reaction when he was removed from the case. His whole reaction was a put on. That it was a show, because Toby revealed to Tanner Holbrook's involvement with Ali. I believe that was staged. back to Andrew, Could tanner have hired Andrew? Is he working as her informant, getting close to the girls? If he's not Andrew, or that's an alias, he looks young, he could pass at least for 18, but what if he's actually older? I know that there is an age difference, but he might be in his early 20's undercover in highschool. The reason I think this is his involvement with the Dilaurentis family, and his friendships with Spencer and Mona and now Aria. He is so smart because he already passed highschool. Or if he's an informant as a fellow classmate and is their age. I think that A texted Mike saying it was Mona and lead him to the pathfinders camp. I also think that the dollhouse is near the varjack cabin. The old cambell farm sounds like it was a abandoned farm. Ithink that's where there was a fire that Ali saved Emily. I was thinking could this be when A's face was disfigured? During the Jenna thing or the lodge fire, my guess is the lodge fire. That's when they found the red coat, and black widow came to be.
The reason I think that Holbrooks dramatic exit was staged, was all part of the bigger picture of the kidnapping and catching A, for Tanner. Maybe there was an Andrew Cambell but he did like G_xoxo said that one of the little boys was Charles and he died, that would make it possible for someone to assume the identity of someone who actually existed. She was right the vault room looked like a shrine to someone lost.I think there was a baby doll in the crib in the vault room.
ellieluvable i really like this!
Thanks!
Like i said tobys new partner is someone to watch!!
Imagine that after they find A and they are happily living with there lives and 30 years later they have teenage daughters and then the liars and there daughters receive a message at the same time that says
" now it's my turn bitches and I love the new addition to your little family. Can't wait to take you all out one by one
-B"
@taylor john
It makes sense if Charles hit Alison with a rock and he have to go to radley.
Maybe he met Bethany there, because i think bethany has problems.
And maybe wrote miss D i can't protect you anymore... to charles?
I profoundly think that Jason killed his own mother, and guys do you remember when Ali received a text from A that said "I burried your mother, just like I watched her bury you", now it only means one thing to me he's the one who tried to kill Ali that night, and he's the one who's been tormenting her ever since, I'd say he's the inside man, the one we see, and Charles is his partner in crime... However I don't know their motives yet :( And also it seems like Charles is obsessed with Alison and I wonder what made him this way.. Plus Ezra is still shady af.. like I don't buy that story about him writing a "novel".. Bullshit! You don't monitor underage girls on a daily basis just to write an effing "novel"!!
After the elevetor accident, Jason doesn't care about his sister anymore (min 1:00) because Jason might be dead and now Jason is someone else. But then, at the police 6:00 he seems like he cares about Ali? I'm confused... Could you explain please? BTW, great theory and video!
This is one of the best, I see whe you are coming from!
What if the vault isn't of Charles's most personal items? What if it was a room he built for Jason? Maybe A kidnapped Jason after the elevator incident and kept him there?
Anyone else notice how Spencer's mum winks at Spencer's dad when she says "no more secrets" at 3.30 ????
People saying things like Mrs. D had 4 children and a previous marriage, etc are pushing it too far. Bethany probably isn't a 4th child, and is either an Ali/Cece like character who manipulates people OR is just Charles' other personality or he is transgender or something and goes by the name Bethany. Having 4 children but 2 disappearing? That would not go unnoticed in Rosewood.
BlueHeartXXX TRUTH. seriously i thought i was the only one who was thinking that it just doesn't sound right. I love everybody's theories cause there very entertaining, but do you guys really think the PLL producers/Creators would make it that easy for us to figure out A?
Awwe look at Jason in the left side when he was a little kid ((:
LILProdigy Navarro jason is adorable everywhere :))
For the next videos you could turn down the volume of the music, it's too loud and the voices from the scenes sound very low. Tks
has everyone forgotten that fraternal twins exist
This is great!
That blonde girl who took Mona when Jason said "that could be my sister" could technically be Sarah Harvey (Bethany) and still be Jason's sister .. plus she wouldn't need an alibi because she was down in the "doll house the entire time"
Maybe they aren't identical twins but fraternal twins instead. It makes sense, and it would have to be Ali if it's Jason and Charles because of the ages of Melissa and Jason. Also Ali because it was Mrs.D.
When he was saying about the mona video and he said "it could be my sister, it could be Allison" he could be talking about two seperate people. One his full sister (who we dont know about) and Allison his half sister
What if we just wait until season 6 to see the real Answers....
this is genius
I'm not sure if someone already said it.. but in the video of Mrs. D and the boys..
she sais "do you want to say goodnight to your little sister, give her a little kiss?" to the ONE boy.
Then he gives her that little kiss and she sais "what a good boy you are".. then the other one pets her and Mrs. D sais "all good boys"..
I don't really see why they would be twins or even siblings. The other boy could be a friend they brought with them.
In the pic of the boys one boy is taller with spiked up hair (meaning 1 or 2 years older) I think that one is charles, the other boy has shaggy hair, kind of like Jason's used to be.
Squid Bear no i have twin sibilings and one of them is taller than the other by like an inch or two its normal for twins. I'm not saying there twins but the looked the same age.
3:03 mrs.D didnt give birth to melissa or spencer veronica did so they are full sisters jason is the only half sibling except maybe charles
This theory is so cool
this is amazing when will part 2 come?? it make me think of more stuff now
The picture at the beginning of Mrs Dilaurentis & children looks like the building where Emily got locked into with the car when Alison apparently got her out.
Anyone remember Andrew acting weird? My theory is him being the half brother of Charles and Bethany, besides the video of Mrs. D with a baby girl and two boys was taken at the 'Campbell' Farm aka Andrew's last name. Charles wanted someone to get close to the liars and succeeded.
I think Charles is the one who threw a rock at Ali so that's why he was sent to Radley
Maybe Charles was a family friend who liked the Dilaurentis family more than her/his own. They called shim Charles Dilaurentis as a joke, but Charles began to believe it was true, and attempted to get with Alison to join the family. Maybe they played house or something when Ali was too and Charles hit her? Idk, I'm not even sure if I believe that theory myself.
i think the baby is spencer and shes mrs D child but she gave her up to her daddy cuz shes crazy so shes non identical twin to ali.. thats why mrs D hates her and affraid of her most of the time :D
Amber Mood I like that.. tht would be a good story ..
Wait hold what about Melissa
cant be melissa is older than jason
I agree. notice that both Alison and Spencer have cleft chins
I agree. notice that both Alison and Spencer have cleft chins
Also Jason's eye color changed his eyes a dark blue in season almost looking brown, and they're a light blue in season 3
04:50 "HE A" "RUN" on the Emily'Tshirt!!! OMG!!! maybe JASON is A!!!
What's the song playing in 3:55
I like this show
I think is real person was Alison twins
OMG THE THING THAT THEY WERE TWINS AND CHARLES PRETENDED TO BE JASON WAS MEH THEORY TO
Don't know if this is accurate because I can't keep up with all the details but I read somewhere that Supposedly Jason is 7 years older than Ali and Bethany is 2 years older than Ali..again, read it somewhere not sure if that's right but if so unless they expect us to believe one of those boys is 7 years old than that baby cannot be Ali but could be Bethany....
that circular decoration is the same just like at the place the police found the cameras aka charles' lair(whatever you want to call it) am i the only one??
In the first one spencer talked to him and told him some evidence that's the only reason he didn't care about her
I think Jason died in the elevator and Charles is impersonating him. I noticed something huge in a picture of Charles and Spencer in the vault. You could see Jason's colored hair peeking out the back of Charles' mask!
Pretty good Theory's
So interesting, when is part 2 coming!
GUYS! i don't know what the story is but i know that the Jason from season 1 is way different from the Jason of the others! You can re-watch season 1 or you can search Pretty Little Liars Jason season 1 and look for the photo with the big V in the middle. The picture will show you a picture of Jason from season 1 with brown hair ( like Charles ) and another picture on the other side of Jason from all the other seasons! Marlene King states that Charles was not in the first episode but is defiantly in the first season! Jason from season 1 isn't in episode one but is in season 1! Guys i have no idea about the story of this but all i know is that there are two different Jasons and one of them has something to do with Charles or is Charles! if you have any ideas about the story of this put it down below! I ASURE YOU THAT THEY HAVE SOMETHING TO DO WITH IT BECAUSE WHY WOULD THEY JUST RANDOMLY CHANGE JASONS JUST BECAUSE! EVERYTHING IS DONE FOR A REASON! THERE ARE NO COINCIDENCES IN ROSEWOOD.
The thing is though, Marlene actually never said that big A wasn't in the pilot. I saw the tweet. Someone asked her "Is A someone we know since season 1?"
Marlene replied saying " I said Original A Was in the pilot. But that doesn't mean Big A wasn't in Pilot."
Just wanted to clarify.
Does anyone know good forums for theories and alternate endings for PLL ? I have some that I'd like to share.
I don't think Charles is a girl because we do see a boy in the video. I think he's Jason's brother and Bethany is Alison's twin and Sarah is actually Bethany, Charles is A and he attacked his two sisters.
queeneva3 charles is transgender
DawnDawn190 I dont believe Charles is transgender. One reason is because if he was, why did Charles reveal himself dressed as a male to the girls in the dollhouse and respond to being crowned Prom King? If Charles identifies as a female, wouldnt he reveal himself dressed as a female? The writers/producers would have to answer as to why they did that with a good explanation, because I will be very confused. The second reason is because there is an interview with one of the writers (Bryan Holdman maybe?) and he revealed that the transgender theory would be too crazy for the Rosewood they have created.
He said there are some things that get TOO crazy for the show. He said some stuff in the PLL books read well but don't translate to the world of Rosewood they've created. In the books, he says, that Aria finds out Noel's dad is a crossdresser and that was too far out there for the show. I would think they would feel the same way about the transgender end of it. I obviously don't know for sure, but I dont feel they will.
i know this is old comment))) but I won)) Charles actually is transgender)) and let's call HER Charlotte))
Really? Scrolling through old comments just so you can say you were right or you won? 😂😂 CONGRATULATIONS. I just put down my opinion, knowing there was a good chance it could be wrong. I liked the story. Did I think it felt a little rushed at times in how the storyline was presented, yes. But overall I enjoyed it. I have already watched it multiple times. Have a good time going around telling the world how right you were and how wrong they were, just because everyone has there own opinions. Enjoy ☺😉
i'm sorry :((
My Theory......
I read an interview Keegan Allen (Toby) did and he said A has been in almost every episode since the first season. Sasha Pierterse(Ali) agreed with this and she said the big reveal of A when it is finally out is sad and twisted...
I think Charles did something to Jason and has been perpetrating as Jason ever since.....there has been clues......1.)his dark room with all the pictures of Aria....and at the end of the episode A is in a dark room developing pictures .......
2.) Aria stabbed a person with a screw driver/large nail.. while locked in the box on the Ghost Train episode and in the next episode at the end Mona comes out of Jason house lifts up his shirt and he has a screw driver/ large nail like puncture on the side of his stomach............3.) and we see Jason back turned seems like he is texting during Truth Up Weekend and mysteriously Aria has a text come through from A....Jason was helping Mrs Hastings mentor the Truth Up Class same class Aria was in....
There are many more clues as well... I think when Jason/Charles left to go back to Georgia to remodel his Grandma house he didn't ...instead he went to go build that underground creepy doll house the girls ended up being locked in during Season 5 Finale.
He dressed up as Ali beat up and kidnapped Mona ...then made it look like he killed her....
When he visited his sister in jail he tells her straight up "I know you did not kill Mona"
Just my theory Why I think Jason/Charles are the same person.
That is actually a great theory, that Charles "became" Jason after the whole elevator incident. Maybe Jason died and Charles took his place, escaping Radley? Hmm.
The baby could be Spencer because she is their sister to, although Mrs.Dilaurentis isn't her mom... Unless she is
All your secret is out there in the open can't wait to see tonight episode of pretty little liars lol lol ladys
omg, do you guys remember those GIRL twins that were shown, well mabey those twins are actually charles and jason..... mabey thats a clue .... who knows
You can tell that the baby is a doll
I've watched the summer finale (The A reveal that CeCe/Charles/Charlotte is A) and when Jason got showed the video, he said Alison. But if you don't remember CeCe, She was basically a version of Ali. Maybe Jason knew it was CeCe since they were dating. But as soon as I watched the recap doesn't Ali have longer hair?. But Ali wasn't with them. But of course it was not Ali because A had them in the dollhouse. And Mona was pretending to be Ali. (A's order). If this doesn't make sense I don't know 😂. I have a very weird thought process.
There have been two actors playing Jason... Maybe the recasting was actually a planned part of the story. The Jason that went to "Ali's funeral" isn't the same Jason that we've seen the rest of the show.
I'm wondering if Jason and Charles are one and the same. I think A is Jason.
When's part 2 amazing theory btw x
okay there goes my theory (sorry for my english, i'm spanish) i think Cece is not A, i think big A is Jason. Jason and Charles are twins /brothers it doesn't really matter. Okay, so one of them, Charles was crazy and evil and was sent to Radley. But he got out of there somehow and he killed Jason just to pretend to be him and Jessica knew so she always tried to protect his son. That's why Charles is buried. He met Bethany in Radley, and they are working together, she is red coat. They had to kill Jessica because she is the only one who knows everything. Jason/Charles is obsessed with Alison and the girls so this makes sense
I'm a little confused because where does Aria fall into place. Remember what the doctor said "the "AIR" around that girl."
while some of this could very well be true and is interesting, I think the fact that you pointed out the difference in looks in Jason after the accident and before is a little ridiculous. He looks different because of the way Drew has changed his look. (such as his hairstyle or color or if he lost or gained weight.)
Jason is so cute and hadsom😘😘😊😊
Btw what is the song name frm yhur theory o like yhur theory too and the song
Also Jenna and Garrett kept saying "The Jason Thing" ....." Glad Nobody Knows about the Jason Thing"........did they know about his sibling Charles?
What if Charles and Bethany are the same person? Maybe some people think the same, but I think both of them are the same person. I think that Charles is a trangender and he changed his gender when he was 16 (when he 'died' and Bethany Young was alive) Thats why Miss D bought both dresses and stuff.
where's part 2?? I really liked these theories!
I think that andrew is charles jasons twin
Are you people forgetting about the black widow? I don't think that charles and bethany are the same person. I think that Charles and Bethany could be working together though. Bethany could be the black widow, which marlene did say that we get to learn who she is as well as charles.
Did anyone notices how Jason says "could be my sister. Could be Allison." Could he be referring to Bethany as his sister and Ali as Allison?
whats the nameof the song that keeps playing in the theories?! doll faces??
I was just thinking when I looked at the picture, that we know Jason used to have longer hair...coincidence? Maybe he had it as a kid. So maybe the boy with the longer hair is Jason and the one with the shorter is Charlie.. the "imaginary" brother/friend.
But then at the same time in the promo for 6x04 Charlie is dead? Now that I have to figure out but yeah thats my opinion!
Just realize Spencer was first to know Mona was A and now Charles / hope this is not all her crazy imagination in she has always been in Radley
When he said "could of been my sister. Could have been Alison" when he said sister maybe he was referring to Charles if Charles is transgender. I believe that Charles is transgender because in the book it says that A is Alison's twin sister and remember when Mrs. Draw bought two dresses? I think that one of them was for Charles, Ali's twin sister.
Do u remember in s1 e3 they did that tribute to alison jason looked completely different then after that he looks like he does now so maby that was his twin maby he is Charles
What Jason said at the police station made me a bit curious... To me it feels like he wants to say 'it could be my sister OR it could be Alison'. If it was Jason and he talks about his sister Alison everybody would Know he means her by only saying 'my sister'... so maybe it was Charles at the police station and he talks about his sister (Bethany??) and Alison
Well if u didn't know Charles wanted to a girl that's y mrs d bought two yellow dresses on of them was Ali and the other one is for Charles. So maybe Charles is Bethany Young
i agree with this theory.
i think next epiesode there going to tell as who is a
I think, that Sarah is the blonde girl who "killed" Mona and that Charles forced her to that.
Wat is the first songs name
I have been thinking about the twin theory and I am thinking that neither Jason or Alison have a twin but I think Spencer is the one with the twin.
Just a quick thought, but what if the person filming it is A, and he felt left out in his family?
my theory Holbrook is Charles he disapeard and he was not with his dad maybe he was at the dollhouse with Mona and then came back and got fired we havin´t seen much of him in the last few episodes after he got fired he could be at the dollhouse maybe I mean he could be Charles it would make a lot of sence
I said MAYBE and this is just a theory when I found this theory I just had to post it.
What if Spencer is Mrs D's kid? I'm not sure about that but what if the other dress was for Spencer and she doesn't want mr D finding out?
Great video. Look at Emily shirt on 4.49 'HeA Free'. Coincidence?
the girl who said she was really good friends with mona, and was looking for things in mona's room,,,, I thought she was mona... ??
I think that Charles is transgender and his family didn't support him except for Mr's. D so he decided to get back at them. He/she came up with A. He started with Ali's closest friends Spencer, Emily, Aria, and Hanna. He then got mad at the 4 liars for trying to bring him/her down so he started to go after there family too. It all makes sense to me and I have heard plenty of other theories about this too and I agree. My second theory is that Mona is still A or she is working with Charles. Just think about it. Mona was collecting her blood and she probably got a human dummy and put blood on it when the liars saw it in the trunk. Mona faked her death and got Charles to help her. Mona had Charles help her set up the dollhouse. Mona is a mastermind she always was and she always will be. Please reply on what you think because I love these theories so ooze much!
Yes i feel the exact same about mona! In an earlier series you see her playing with them as dolls in a dollhouse, i definately still don't trust her!
But A now is mimicking mona and taking away what was hers and expanding it on a greater level, I think mona has nothing to do with the final A and that mona was just a mask to hide everything. Also I think that Charles is Jason's brother which was in radley as in the books the roles are reversed and Ali has the twin sister in radley xxx just my thought but I'm so excited now so many people know about A xx I'm starting to think there was only one BIG A all along xxx
Sara Greenough Wouldn't that be too easy if Charles was Jason's brother? And that thing that you said about A mimicking Mona what I think about it is Mona used to be the big A but then someone else over powered her and Mona used to treat them like crap so now Mona is no longer Big A.
Whats the doll song called?
just so u know twins don't have to be identical and they can have different heights etc...