I wish they'd included the whole Bethany thing, and I kind of wish they'd made it so that Alex had been there from season 1, and not just sort of thrown in after the time jump:/
Brendan Brown not to mention the others got the first A.D text after hanna was kidnapped. So, there's no way that was a dream because hanna never knew about A.D and had to referred to the stalker by "A-moji" right before she was taken. Plus, the way "Spencer" said "you told THEM the truth" then looks surprised when she hears hanna say she wished she had. Plus, now that we know Spencer is Charlotte's sister it would make sense that Spencer's twin(also Charlotte's sister) would want to find out who killed her sister.
Anyone else notice how in the hallucination with Spencer, she asked "You told them the truth right?" implying that she doesn't know the plan and she also says A.D. but at this point Hanna doesn't even know who A.D is.
Also how when Hannah said "I'm glad we don't know who actually killed Charlotte, because if I did, I'd spill" something like that, Spencer-- or A.D--seemed surprised, and then basically hinted her to help her get out, and she sang a lullaby which the DiLaurentes' family always does.
Anyone notice in episode where its Aryas and Ezras wedding when Spencer asks to hold the baby she walks to mirror and its like her personality shifts and she pats babies hair and says " you have your daddies eyes" but they dont know who the father of those girls was ???
Clue that Spencer was mary's daughter was also clear when Mary said in 7x01 "I have never been the one to turn down caffeine" and we all know Spencer's addiction with caffeine.
Something I wish i'd added to this theory - young Bethany looked a lot like young Spencer (as in Maddie Ziegler, who played young Spencer in the dancing girl in Radley dream Spencer had in 'She's No Angel' in season 5). The dance young Spencer performed in the dream looked to me like a dance-representation of Spencer's story, even Mary was in it if you watch the dance, taking every move literally. (Thanks for all the support on this video:))
I think it was Spencer's twin in the 'dream'. I think Spencer's twin pretended it was a dream because she wanted Hannah to admit who killed Charlotte. She then helped her escape because Hannah obviously didn't know, and would have told if she did. Twin does run in the family! Plus, maybe Spencer's twin sings the song to her because HER mother Mary always sung it to her.
I watched the dance now and I honestly don't see how that is Spencer's story including Mary. The dance looks like it's gonna represent excrutiating pain.. Can you tell me what moves make you think it's Spencer's life story???
I think this a great theory. Plot twist though. ; Spencer's twin is the one who is pretending to be her 1. Spencer would never date her friends ex 2. Her haircut was an outrageous choice. 3. WHen hanna was abducted she had a dream spencer came. Maybe it was the real spencer telling her to find a way out. Why would the twin try help hanna? Also has anyone noticed that spencer has been acting really dumb in season 7. Also aint it a coincidence that spencer and CALEB unexpetcly meet. When spencer talks to hanna in hanna dream read between the lines and see what she says
fhfhfkfgkr was just thinking about it .haha same idea .maybe the spancer we've seen is her twin .and the real spancer being A ,bcoz shes angry that her friend can't differentiate or tell that the spancer they are with is not the real spancer .If that make sense
This is an amazing theory. Though if the current spencer is AD then how did she manage to kidnap Jenna? Is that person not AD? I literally think it would be amazing to have a twist like this.
+Claire Gregson OMG I got it maybe the real Spencer www switched by the twin and she's the one that got shot! You can't see the bangs when she's laying down! I think the real Spencer is the one in Hannah's dream and the evil one is the one pretending to be her dating Caleb and everything then in the house in the last episode a.d somehow put the real Spencer in her place? It sounds crazy and probably doesn't make since but it's a thought
This was brilliant- pll is full of mysteries so we never know what will come next- you have to be very cleaver to even see the things other people don't- good job!
Shay La Yeah,true but Toby was the first to leave the show. On there snapchat they were all saying goodbye to him and there's pictures on there Instagram about Toby leaving. He could possible be dead,hopefully we would miss him.
I seem to find a lot in common between Mona and Spencer also..Both smart and nerdy girls, both spent time at Radley..idk. there has to be some connection there between these two girls.
this theory is actually a really good analyzed theory. I feel like any other theories I've seen have just pulled things randomly and are basically just guesses with nonsense to back it up, but this was well thought out. some of it turned out to be wrong, but most of it was right. I'm very impressed with this one. great job!
Did anyone notice Jenna being pulled out of the way by someone before the liars came in? Isnt that creepy? Who pulled her away? Non of the liars were busy with moving jenna cuz they thought their friend was dying so I dunno!
I think it's weird how they missed that person and Jenna, because that was the same second they came up the stairs. How could they not see A.D. dragging Jenna through the corridor??? I think that person is Mona tho, for some reason. The same clothes she used and Charlotte continued to use.. The gloves that are big on Mona's small hands.. The way she holds the hoodie..
Also in the promo for the next episode, you see that Jenna is back so clearly she is working with A.D and Mona and Jenna made "that deal" in the elevator. Why else would Mona let Jenna get away with everything if it was'nt because she thought she needed Jennas help for taking down the liars? :D just a thought
Margaret Furtado it can't be Mary as she was with Spencer right when the liars came in. She'd have to have super hero speed to move to her side that fast! At least, that's what I think
Wow! that's the best theory I've watched!!!! Especially the part of old "Spencer" being dead and the "always" part... I think that's brilliant!!! Wow.. that's amazing! Breathtaking .. .my mind just blowed!
Good video...the only thing that I still have doubts about is Hanna's "dream". I don't think that is Spencer's twin. I think that it was Mary in a Spencer mask because 1) her hair style is EXACTLY like the "Spencer" in this scene and I believe that masks of all of the girls were made when they were on those morgue tables in the Dollhouse; 2) she was part of the Amoji team and was working to find out who killed Charlotte so that's why she asked Hanna if she told them the truth; she also mentioned AD to Hanna when Hanna hadn't even heard the alias AD yet; 3) the way she was stroking Hanna's hair/face, cradling her head, and singing a lullaby was done in a very maternal way so I don't think it would have been someone younger who doesn't have a child (also, Mary sang the same song to Spencer when she got shot at the end of 7A); and 4) she told Hanna to think of a way to escape and then she was the person who "found" Hanna on a deserted road...what are the chances of that happening?! LOL
Spencer asking Hanna "You told them the truth,right?" was very odd.I think it is proof that,that girl is not Spencer.Hope they don't do something with the masks again
I really hope she has a twin, mostly because Troian would be so damn good at it! Idk about it being Bethany though, cause who was the body that Melissa buried then or how did the twin get out? But the blonde wig doesn't make sense since Charlotte has blonde hair anyway? Though I think sometimes Sara used it? Ahhh. So many questions haha.
Yeah Troian would be so good at it!! Yeah, ugh there's always something not quite right with the whole story:( and I can't believe we have to wait so long to find out! (Also I love your channel:))
Also!!! the song "Spencer" is singing to Hannah is the same song that Mary Drake sings to Spencer when Spencer gets shot in the latest episode!!!!!! It could be because Mary Drake has sung it before to her other twin daughter (spencer's twin) and thats why "Spencer" (Spencer's twin) is singing it to Hannah!!!!
except??? if bethany was spencer's identical twin sister, what about the guy at the horse riding place who was talking to spencer and emily about bethany's visit with jessica - don't you think he would have mentioned that the girl he was talking about was IDENTICAL to the girl standing right in front of him lmao???
Your theory makes me think spencer does not have a twin. She has a split personality. The part with Hannah when watching it now really does not look like she was dreaming. That Spenser or her other personality was really there. Maybe thats why they let her go because Hannah told her she does not know who killed Charlotte. Than at the end with the song just like Mary sang to Spencer. And i remember when i first saw that scene i thought how strange from all the girls it was Spencer who came to her dreams the friend who is going out with her ex that Hannah is still in love with.
I some how agree with you, I think she has a split personality, also I think it was Mary who wore a mask as Spenser, that's why the same song with both girls, Mary did want to no who killed her son/daughter, also when hanna ran away, it was Mary who came driving by.
Also I somehow feel that Ali has a twin and Bethany is the twin, cause the twin story told by Ali could be her story, where she might have not killed the sister but for sure gone to radley, and Bethany was angry with Jessica, cause she was her mom but wanted to be called aunt jessi that is y he painting and thought of Jessica being evil,
LelaFG I always thought Aria would be the one with a SPD because she had the perfect life up until she found about her dad and then what happened to Ally. In a way she rebelled by going out with Ezra in the beginning.
OMFG! The Spencer visiting Hanna scene hit me like a bus! I knew it seemed too real. And it did remind me of how Alison used to visit them. Wow, this new season better explain everything!! I have so many questions...*sigh*
Everyone, including myself, feels pretty stupid now, for not seeing the lullaby part ourselves. So thank you for enlightening us :D Great theory by the way, so cool you have relevant arguments for your theory!
giiirl you slayed! good job! I also got that Spencer had a twin after the Hanna dream scene. I knew that wasn't a dream. First the bangs, then why would Hanna dream about Spencer from aaaall the other girls? But yea, you did a great job, even if I didn't like the way they put it together as in, the reason, and the finale episode (too boring and many things unexplained).
I'm really happy for you... This was your very first theory video and you were right!!! Personaly, I didn't love it, but after an entire day I'm starting to accept it haha
I love this theory, only one thing though. You said that Spencer with the fringe is AD, so you're implying that the Spencer in Hanna's dream was actually Spencer? That does not make sense. I feel like that is actually her twin, like wearing her old clothes and still have the same hairstyle. The conversation gave off a 'investigation' vibe even though it's supposed to be a dream to help comfort Hanna
I'm sorry I hate to sound snobby. It's a great video and I love the theory!!! But the song is actually called Sail. I am just one of those people that correct people who mess up song lyrics and titles. It is some pretty bad ocd.
I didn't take it as you were saying that's the name of the song. I took it as you were saying that the part of the song that played during that scene was " Blame it on my A.D.D" like talking about the lyrics not the actual song name.
I believe that Lucas Is A.D and we know that A.D kept Arias file and threw Noel Kahn file in the trash. So Lucas and Aria are probably the twins related to Allison. I think Mary Drake might be claiming that Spencer is her daughter to cover up who her real kids are to protect them. The guy with the British accent is not A.D it is Wren, and he wants Allison dead and he has some connection to Wilden.I believe Wren was trying to get Archer Dunhill to kill Allison by making him think that Allison killed Charlotte. He knew Archer was in love with Charlotte and would Kill Allison if he thought she had killed Charlotte. Wren figured he would get Archer to get rid of her so he wouldn't have to. Wren is the one that was staying in the cabin and had all those pictures of Wilden. Wren has some sort of connection to Wilden and he wanted to make the police and the girls think that Archer was A.D. Lucas reappeared in season 6. He let Hannah stay at his condo, use his car, he is the mysterious person with the limo. He admitted to Hannah that he bought a factory, and one of the text messages came from a factory. He was upset when he thought Allison died and he destroyed the statue. Emily told the girls that she believes Lucas wanted the box that belonged to Allison. The girls found out Lucas was visiting Radley. He claims it was to see Mona, but if he is A.D and related to Allison than he didn't go to Radley to see Mona it was to see Charlotte. The girls didn't start getting text from A.D until Lucas reemerged in Rosewood. In the beginning Lucas had feelings for Hannah that is why he agreed to be her Allibi, and let her use his car and condo. He was doing this to spy on the girls with cameras and to be one step ahead of them. He knows Hannah didn't kill Charlotte, but he was using her by kidnapping her, because he figured one of the other girls knew who killed Charlotte.
0:25 hold on he said 2 baby's maybe Spencer and Melissa are Marrys children and they got taken away from her and adopted by Peter and Veronica Hastings but Melissa has to be Marrys daughter because in season 7 Marry said that she is Spencer's mom and Melissa and Spencer look too much alike not to be related
That clip was the perfect way to start this video! So sad it's over but As Told By GiGi did some awesome reviews she now does Riverdale reviews which are awesome
Andrea Jingleheimer Schmidt The actress of Spencer confirmed in an interview that Spencer was originally supposed to be A in season one. However, because she was a likable character they scrapped the idea. I read about this a long time but if u search it up, I'm sure u can find it :).
Lord Voldemort Alison's twin according to the book alison has a twin, the night she disappeared alison is wearing a necklace some of it is not, and she has different types of hair that night (straight and curly). There are three girls came out of the grave. First (2x24) no one help her/him, second (3x13) someone help her/him by someone who's wearing red cloth that night, third (4x12) Mrs. Grundwald helping Alison. I think the two girls are Bethany and Sara? Maybe one of her friends hit her and Avery see that she came out of the grave that's why she thinks that she's alive, or she's the one who hit her. And she also have the same clothes, maybe cece (coz she's also red coat) help her out or spencer because she's wearing a red cloth. That's why she became a decoy of red coat coz she owe Cece for saving her.
I really love this theory and I think it has a lot of sense! there was a lot of Bethany- Spencer connections and they never really showed us Bethany's face when she was 17! also we don't know anything about her... and AD could stand for the fact "her body" was in the grave named "Alison DiLaurentis" ! I really hope this theory would be the truth I think Spence is the most important out of the liars for this show and Bethany deserves a lot better than what they gave her until now!
OMG WHO IS A.D.!!!! I wanna know soo bad. First everyone says Aria is A.D. or they say Spencer or Spencer's twin, And then they say that Sara is Hanna's sister, or they say Wren is Spencer's brother and he's A.D. which that would be gross Eww. And then they say Ali or her twin. Or that Bethany is alive and is Ali's twin. Could be Charlotte, Spencer, and Wren are siblings. I just don't know. THIS IS SO CONFUSING!!!
yall are clearly not understanding. there are hints that spencer with a fringe is the twin (A.D.) and spencer without a fringe is the real spencer. spencer just happened to not have a fringe in hanna's "dream" and that's either a figment of her imagination (which makes less sense bc hello... just a coincidence that she didnt have a fringe in hanna's "dream"? I don't think so) OR... spencer is being held captive while her twin is pretending to be her, OR: spencer is dead.
Beck no, I hate this, the show screwed up after the CECE reveal that I don't waste time on paying attention, I used so much time looking at how ali one time had a curly hair and straight hair in the same day but then it was just a editing mistake.
So real Spencer is dead or she never came back to Rosewood? If you're right about Hanna's dream, i guess something happened to the real Spencer that would be creepy And i have a theory about this ''Spencer'' has something against Hanna? because first we saw Hanna trapped and we know ''Spencer'' was the girlfriend of Caleb and almost when Hanna and all the liars arrived to Rosewood A.D trap Hanna and maybe because Spencer thought that if Hanna returned that means that probably Hanna and Caleb will get reconciled. I know it sounds stupid but it could be.......
I don't think that's stupid at all. Because it is so odd/random to me that Caleb & Spencer dating became a significant storyline. Like it's weird. I never would've expected them together. And then it's interesting too how in one of the last episodes Spencer kisses Toby good bye and then Toby is killed with his fiance. Like it was so strange to me how Spencer warns them to get out of Rosewood and ironic that as they're leaving they get killed. It could have been so vindictive/revenge. There are no "accidental deaths" on pll. In previous seasons Toby and Spencer were targeted, A trying to break them up. And A tried to kill Toby too, early on in like season 1 or 2 when Toby is working construction. I wonder if Spencer's twin is jealous or just angry at Spencer, getting revenge.
Very good. But only one thing: at 7:30 the song is called "Sail" not "Blame it on my A.D.D.". Other than that, I like it. And i totally agree about the scene with Hannah, it seemed a bit out of place for her to be dreaming Spencer. Good work
I wish they'd included the whole Bethany thing, and I kind of wish they'd made it so that Alex had been there from season 1, and not just sort of thrown in after the time jump:/
vintage flower girl I hate that people were saying its Bethany she's dead!!!!!!
Ikr!
WAIT so maybe Melissa knew she was killing/burying Spencer's twin! Maybe she knows all about this.
LizziesAnswers that's what I thought bc Melissa was 'protecting' Spencer
LizziesAnswers yeah I agree
ok this sounds very weird and isn't well thought out but what if melissa would be spencer's "twin" ?
Smiley Freak who is a and is ali still alive
LizziesAnswers in the current episode.. Spencer's mom says that Melissa has no idea
omg that scene with spencer visiting Hanna in a "dream" it makes senseeee
Brendan Brown not to mention the others got the first A.D text after hanna was kidnapped. So, there's no way that was a dream because hanna never knew about A.D and had to referred to the stalker by "A-moji" right before she was taken.
Plus, the way "Spencer" said "you told THEM the truth" then looks surprised when she hears hanna say she wished she had.
Plus, now that we know Spencer is Charlotte's sister it would make sense that Spencer's twin(also Charlotte's sister) would want to find out who killed her sister.
And "dream Spencer" doesn't have bangs like Spencer really did at that point
Brendan Brown thats when hannah was kidnapped. she HALLUCINATED the whole thing
Anyone else notice how in the hallucination with Spencer, she asked "You told them the truth right?" implying that she doesn't know the plan and she also says A.D. but at this point Hanna doesn't even know who A.D is.
wow yeh ! never noticed that! #mindblown
Also how when Hannah said "I'm glad we don't know who actually killed Charlotte, because if I did, I'd spill" something like that, Spencer-- or A.D--seemed surprised, and then basically hinted her to help her get out, and she sang a lullaby which the DiLaurentes' family always does.
Oh I didn't even realize the person who posted the video made the lullaby connection, i hadn't gotten to that part yet.
What hallucination
Anyone notice in episode where its Aryas and Ezras wedding when Spencer asks to hold the baby she walks to mirror and its like her personality shifts and she pats babies hair and says " you have your daddies eyes" but they dont know who the father of those girls was ???
Clue that Spencer was mary's daughter was also clear when Mary said in 7x01 "I have never been the one to turn down caffeine" and we all know Spencer's addiction with caffeine.
at 2:48 when Mary said "You and your sister look so much alike" she may not have been talking about Melissa maybe Alex
Something I wish i'd added to this theory - young Bethany looked a lot like young Spencer (as in Maddie Ziegler, who played young Spencer in the dancing girl in Radley dream Spencer had in 'She's No Angel' in season 5). The dance young Spencer performed in the dream looked to me like a dance-representation of Spencer's story, even Mary was in it if you watch the dance, taking every move literally. (Thanks for all the support on this video:))
vintage flower girl eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee eeeeeeeeeeeeeceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeceeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeceeeeeeeeceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeereeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeereeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeereeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeereereeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeereeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeereeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeereeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeereeeeeeeeerreeeeereeeeerreeerrreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerreeeeerreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerreeeeeerreeeerrrreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerreeerreeeeetreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeetrretreereeeeetreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeedeeeeeeeeeeweeeeeeeeeeereesedeeweewweweeweeeteweeeweeeeweeeeereeeewweeeeeeeeeeeeaweeesweweeeeeerewwwwwwqqqqqqqeqqqqqftfffffeerft
I think it was Spencer's twin in the 'dream'. I think Spencer's twin pretended it was a dream because she wanted Hannah to admit who killed Charlotte. She then helped her escape because Hannah obviously didn't know, and would have told if she did. Twin does run in the family! Plus, maybe Spencer's twin sings the song to her because HER mother Mary always sung it to her.
Beth Barnes yes thats what i thought while watching this. makes sense
vintage flower girl
I watched the dance now and I honestly don't see how that is Spencer's story including Mary. The dance looks like it's gonna represent excrutiating pain.. Can you tell me what moves make you think it's Spencer's life story???
I think this a great theory. Plot twist though. ; Spencer's twin is the one who is pretending to be her 1. Spencer would never date her friends ex 2. Her haircut was an outrageous choice. 3. WHen hanna was abducted she had a dream spencer came. Maybe it was the real spencer telling her to find a way out. Why would the twin try help hanna? Also has anyone noticed that spencer has been acting really dumb in season 7. Also aint it a coincidence that spencer and CALEB unexpetcly meet. When spencer talks to hanna in hanna dream read between the lines and see what she says
fhfhfkfgkr was just thinking about it .haha same idea .maybe the spancer we've seen is her twin .and the real spancer being A ,bcoz shes angry that her friend can't differentiate or tell that the spancer they are with is not the real spancer .If that make sense
Nope. I think the current Spencer is A.d. If the real Spencer was A.d why would she try to help Hanna?
This is an amazing theory. Though if the current spencer is AD then how did she manage to kidnap Jenna? Is that person not AD? I literally think it would be amazing to have a twist like this.
Well Maybe spencer took Jenna to stop her from hurting her sister
+Claire Gregson OMG I got it maybe the real Spencer www switched by the twin and she's the one that got shot! You can't see the bangs when she's laying down! I think the real Spencer is the one in Hannah's dream and the evil one is the one pretending to be her dating Caleb and everything then in the house in the last episode a.d somehow put the real Spencer in her place? It sounds crazy and probably doesn't make since but it's a thought
This was brilliant- pll is full of mysteries so we never know what will come next- you have to be very cleaver to even see the things other people don't- good job!
yeah it definitely is! And thank you:)
pll will never be the same without Toby. (A.K.A spoby)😑
Shay La Yeah,true but Toby was the first to leave the show. On there snapchat they were all saying goodbye to him and there's pictures on there Instagram about Toby leaving. He could possible be dead,hopefully we would miss him.
Angel Hayes Toby is still alive
Kayla Darigan i don't think so...😫
Kayla Darigan how du you know? Are you sure
Angel Hayes to be fair in the books it would be better this way
OMG GIRL AFTER THE FINALE IM SHOOOOOKKKKKKKK
ItzzPriyanna same
I seem to find a lot in common between Mona and Spencer also..Both smart and nerdy girls, both spent time at Radley..idk. there has to be some connection there between these two girls.
K both been on the A team before.
K it would be so good if Mona and Spencer are twins
K - I believe it a bit
Twins with an extreme height difference?
I LOVE HOW THIS THEORY WAS ACTUALLY RIGHT GIRL. EVERYONE SAW IT AND THEY JUST OVER LOOKED IT BUT IT WAS ACTUALLY RIGHT I CANT EVEN GOOD JOB!! ♥️♥️
Well congrats, after 9 months it's confirmed you're correct!😂👏🏼
How does it feel to be right? 😉
xitsbiancaa yasss
GREAT
Wow. You predicted this months ago, great job!
AND YOU WERE RIGHT !!!
this theory is actually a really good analyzed theory. I feel like any other theories I've seen have just pulled things randomly and are basically just guesses with nonsense to back it up, but this was well thought out. some of it turned out to be wrong, but most of it was right. I'm very impressed with this one. great job!
Did anyone notice Jenna being pulled out of the way by someone before the liars came in? Isnt that creepy? Who pulled her away? Non of the liars were busy with moving jenna cuz they thought their friend was dying so I dunno!
I think it's weird how they missed that person and Jenna, because that was the same second they came up the stairs. How could they not see A.D. dragging Jenna through the corridor??? I think that person is Mona tho, for some reason. The same clothes she used and Charlotte continued to use.. The gloves that are big on Mona's small hands.. The way she holds the hoodie..
Also in the promo for the next episode, you see that Jenna is back so clearly she is working with A.D and Mona and Jenna made "that deal" in the elevator. Why else would Mona let Jenna get away with everything if it was'nt because she thought she needed Jennas help for taking down the liars? :D just a thought
It can't be Noel isn't he dead? Pretty sure is head got chopped off D:
It was Mary
Margaret Furtado it can't be Mary as she was with Spencer right when the liars came in. She'd have to have super hero speed to move to her side that fast! At least, that's what I think
Wow! that's the best theory I've watched!!!! Especially the part of old "Spencer" being dead and the "always" part... I think that's brilliant!!! Wow.. that's amazing! Breathtaking .. .my mind just blowed!
Its funny to watch this now while we know that spencers twin is ad
I'm so impressed that you actually figured it out! annnnd 8 months before the finally! great job!
Good video...the only thing that I still have doubts about is Hanna's "dream". I don't think that is Spencer's twin. I think that it was Mary in a Spencer mask because 1) her hair style is EXACTLY like the "Spencer" in this scene and I believe that masks of all of the girls were made when they were on those morgue tables in the Dollhouse; 2) she was part of the Amoji team and was working to find out who killed Charlotte so that's why she asked Hanna if she told them the truth; she also mentioned AD to Hanna when Hanna hadn't even heard the alias AD yet; 3) the way she was stroking Hanna's hair/face, cradling her head, and singing a lullaby was done in a very maternal way so I don't think it would have been someone younger who doesn't have a child (also, Mary sang the same song to Spencer when she got shot at the end of 7A); and 4) she told Hanna to think of a way to escape and then she was the person who "found" Hanna on a deserted road...what are the chances of that happening?! LOL
Dolphin517 could be true but the voice sounded the same but they did before used voice thingys
Dolphin517 this is all overwhelming
Dolphin517 turns out it really was her twin
When "Spencer" was with Hanna while she was being held captive spencer didn't have bangs.
This is so brillant and well thought out!!!! Are you excited about the final ten episodes?
Thankyou:) And yes I am soo excited I can't believe we have to wait so long!!!!!
totaly thrilled i LOVE pll
Honestly, after watching this I agree with you so much! This is such a clever theory. Good job!
or A.D.D as in Attention Deflect Disorder
Attention Deficit Disorder...
Spencer asking Hanna "You told them the truth,right?" was very odd.I think it is proof that,that girl is not Spencer.Hope they don't do something with the masks again
This was amazing and captivating
thankyou:)
I really hope she has a twin, mostly because Troian would be so damn good at it! Idk about it being Bethany though, cause who was the body that Melissa buried then or how did the twin get out? But the blonde wig doesn't make sense since Charlotte has blonde hair anyway? Though I think sometimes Sara used it? Ahhh. So many questions haha.
Yeah Troian would be so good at it!! Yeah, ugh there's always something not quite right with the whole story:( and I can't believe we have to wait so long to find out! (Also I love your channel:))
NoPlaceLikeStoryBrooke also twins are not always identical
:)
NoPlaceLikeStoryBrooke haven't you ever asked yourself why Bethany's face was never revealed? That arises suspicions that she's somebody's twin.
Julieta Fernandez It's always been said Bethany was two years older than the liars, how the hell can she be someone's twin?
congrats!! you were right!!
Also!!! the song "Spencer" is singing to Hannah is the same song that Mary Drake sings to Spencer when Spencer gets shot in the latest episode!!!!!! It could be because Mary Drake has sung it before to her other twin daughter (spencer's twin) and thats why "Spencer" (Spencer's twin) is singing it to Hannah!!!!
*guess what? YOU WERE RIGHT!!!*
except??? if bethany was spencer's identical twin sister, what about the guy at the horse riding place who was talking to spencer and emily about bethany's visit with jessica - don't you think he would have mentioned that the girl he was talking about was IDENTICAL to the girl standing right in front of him lmao???
Erica Adelaide maybe they are not identical twins
MC&MP Studios and the face?
it's really interesting, thanks for the vidoe, made me think alot xD keep it up
thanks:)
Good theory. I really hope Spencer isn't a twin too. The whole fake deaths, and twin thing is getting annoying.
Wth. If Bethany is her twin how can she be A wen shes dead???
Exactly.
***** Garrett hahahaha :D
+Sireen Star. Yeah but we no Bethany deffo is shes the one tht got buried instead of ali duhhh
+Lily Red. Yh and wilden haha 😂
doesn't mean she is dead no one stays dead Ive noticed lol
YOU WERE SO ACCURATE! 💯 I followed your instincts because you made me open my eyes to scenes that I didn't notice. Your theory was correct! 💯
Oh my fucking god you were right woooow congrats
You guessed correctly! Scary accuracy. Especially the scene with Spencer (actually Alex or AD) holding Hanna when she was kidnapped. BRAVO!
Love it! Especially the last part!
douching
Same 😂
I didn't mean to put '😂'
I can't say I agree but you do have many great facts to hold your theory and I just think that's awesome. I love it!
Your theory makes me think spencer does not have a twin. She has a split personality.
The part with Hannah when watching it now really does not look like she was dreaming. That Spenser or her other personality was really there.
Maybe thats why they let her go because Hannah told her she does not know who killed Charlotte.
Than at the end with the song just like Mary sang to Spencer.
And i remember when i first saw that scene i thought how strange from all the girls it was Spencer who came to her dreams the friend who is going out with her ex that Hannah is still in love with.
I some how agree with you, I think she has a split personality, also I think it was Mary who wore a mask as Spenser, that's why the same song with both girls, Mary did want to no who killed her son/daughter, also when hanna ran away, it was Mary who came driving by.
Also I somehow feel that Ali has a twin and Bethany is the twin, cause the twin story told by Ali could be her story, where she might have not killed the sister but for sure gone to radley, and Bethany was angry with Jessica, cause she was her mom but wanted to be called aunt jessi that is y he painting and thought of Jessica being evil,
LelaFG spencer may not have a twin but she has a sister ( cece drake ) because Mary drake is her biological mother
LelaFG I always thought Aria would be the one with a SPD because she had the perfect life up until she found about her dad and then what happened to Ally. In a way she rebelled by going out with Ezra in the beginning.
LelaFG yeah
oh wow. the lullaby!!! I didn't connect this part ! so awesome 🙈 good job !!
Why did this give me chills...I'm honestly a little scared to know now! lol
Omg I'm convinced now. This is insane but it makes so much sense!!! Great job!!!
Omg I hope she has a twin!! It would be so good!!
OMFG! The Spencer visiting Hanna scene hit me like a bus! I knew it seemed too real. And it did remind me of how Alison used to visit them. Wow, this new season better explain everything!! I have so many questions...*sigh*
Loved it you should make more!
Rebecca Gomez me too this was great!!!
Spencer is always my favorite character, aside from Ali.. nice video!
I just cant believe its fucking true dude u opened my eyes, its spencer's twin! I cant wait for season 8 and see this is true
OmegaMax where did you watch season 7?
+J'myra Fields in seriesbang
OmegaMax there is no season 8
you mean april cause its stil season 7 and its the last one and going to be in april 2017 ... thats bad 😢😢💔
Oh well, then i mean i cant wait for the final episodes of season 7. Thanks :D
who else i here from after watching the s7 finale
this is so good, shit got me thinking
Everyone, including myself, feels pretty stupid now, for not seeing the lullaby part ourselves. So thank you for enlightening us :D Great theory by the way, so cool you have relevant arguments for your theory!
I really like this theory, and considering Spencer's biological mother (Mary drake) is a twin, it is very possible she has a twin sibling too
giiirl you slayed! good job! I also got that Spencer had a twin after the Hanna dream scene. I knew that wasn't a dream. First the bangs, then why would Hanna dream about Spencer from aaaall the other girls? But yea, you did a great job, even if I didn't like the way they put it together as in, the reason, and the finale episode (too boring and many things unexplained).
Who else came here after the series finale?? you were right 😀
I'm really happy for you... This was your very first theory video and you were right!!! Personaly, I didn't love it, but after an entire day I'm starting to accept it haha
I love this theory, only one thing though. You said that Spencer with the fringe is AD, so you're implying that the Spencer in Hanna's dream was actually Spencer? That does not make sense. I feel like that is actually her twin, like wearing her old clothes and still have the same hairstyle. The conversation gave off a 'investigation' vibe even though it's supposed to be a dream to help comfort Hanna
Khanh Nguyen you got it mixed up. the video was saying that spencer in the dream was A.D. not spencer.
omg this is sooo good! well done! 👍
Damn, you were spot on with the mary and mr.h affair
YOU WERE RIGHT THE ENTIRE TIME . Omg u deserve an award
I'm sorry I hate to sound snobby. It's a great video and I love the theory!!! But the song is actually called Sail. I am just one of those people that correct people who mess up song lyrics and titles. It is some pretty bad ocd.
haha that's ok it was my mistake, and thanks:)
haha ikr! i love this song
I didn't take it as you were saying that's the name of the song. I took it as you were saying that the part of the song that played during that scene was " Blame it on my A.D.D" like talking about the lyrics not the actual song name.
Although most of the connections and 'evidence' you found for your theory didn't pan out, I'm very impressed this was a theory you had back in 2016!
I believe that Lucas Is A.D and we know that A.D kept Arias file and threw Noel Kahn file in the trash. So Lucas and Aria are probably the twins related to Allison. I think Mary Drake might be claiming that Spencer is her daughter to cover up who her real kids are to protect them. The guy with the British accent is not A.D it is Wren, and he wants Allison dead and he has some connection to Wilden.I believe Wren was trying to get Archer Dunhill to kill Allison by making him think that Allison killed Charlotte. He knew Archer was in love with Charlotte and would Kill Allison if he thought she had killed Charlotte. Wren figured he would get Archer to get rid of her so he wouldn't have to. Wren is the one that was staying in the cabin and had all those pictures of Wilden. Wren has some sort of connection to Wilden and he wanted to make the police and the girls think that Archer was A.D. Lucas reappeared in season 6. He let Hannah stay at his condo, use his car, he is the mysterious person with the limo. He admitted to Hannah that he bought a factory, and one of the text messages came from a factory. He was upset when he thought Allison died and he destroyed the statue. Emily told the girls that she believes Lucas wanted the box that belonged to Allison. The girls found out Lucas was visiting Radley. He claims it was to see Mona, but if he is A.D and related to Allison than he didn't go to Radley to see Mona it was to see Charlotte. The girls didn't start getting text from A.D until Lucas reemerged in Rosewood. In the beginning Lucas had feelings for Hannah that is why he agreed to be her Allibi, and let her use his car and condo. He was doing this to spy on the girls with cameras and to be one step ahead of them. He knows Hannah didn't kill Charlotte, but he was using her by kidnapping her, because he figured one of the other girls knew who killed Charlotte.
OMG you're a genius! Loved the theory, i think it could be true. Maybe not all of it but most parts make a huge sence to me now! Soooo.. We'll see:-)
0:25 hold on he said 2 baby's maybe Spencer and Melissa are Marrys children and they got taken away from her and adopted by Peter and Veronica Hastings but Melissa has to be Marrys daughter because in season 7 Marry said that she is Spencer's mom and Melissa and Spencer look too much alike not to be related
Hannah Layton Peter Hastings is a dog remember..he could still be daddy
Shannon Adams maybe but I feel like many they are both adopted
That clip was the perfect way to start this video! So sad it's over but As Told By GiGi did some awesome reviews she now does Riverdale reviews which are awesome
I really Hope Toby isn't dead. I prefer Spoby More than Caleb. If either Spencer or Toby turn out to be dead I'm gonna stop watching.
Caterina Quaak Toby isnt dead
Der Reinscheißer Ep no shut
Well done. You were right(apart from the bit about Bethany) it also showed this second to last scene as a part where A.D replaced spencer
also! "mommas gonna buy you a mocking bird" MOCKING BIRD as in twins?
great video, i really loved the points you made because i really does make sense to me
Well Spencer was originally supposed to be A. It'd be cool if Spencer was AD
Can you explain this please? :)
Andrea Jingleheimer Schmidt The actress of Spencer confirmed in an interview that Spencer was originally supposed to be A in season one. However, because she was a likable character they scrapped the idea. I read about this a long time but if u search it up, I'm sure u can find it :).
This was the first spencer has a twin theory I have watched and you were right!!
buuut then who is in Alis grave?
Disturbed Bunny bethany young is in her grave
Beauty Vlogs theres two bethanys?
Lord Voldemort Alison's twin according to the book alison has a twin, the night she disappeared alison is wearing a necklace some of it is not, and she has different types of hair that night (straight and curly). There are three girls came out of the grave. First (2x24) no one help her/him, second (3x13) someone help her/him by someone who's wearing red cloth that night, third (4x12) Mrs. Grundwald helping Alison. I think the two girls are Bethany and Sara? Maybe one of her friends hit her and Avery see that she came out of the grave that's why she thinks that she's alive, or she's the one who hit her. And she also have the same clothes, maybe cece (coz she's also red coat) help her out or spencer because she's wearing a red cloth. That's why she became a decoy of red coat coz she owe Cece for saving her.
I really love this theory and I think it has a lot of sense! there was a lot of Bethany- Spencer connections and they never really showed us Bethany's face when she was 17! also we don't know anything about her... and AD could stand for the fact "her body" was in the grave named "Alison DiLaurentis" ! I really hope this theory would be the truth I think Spence is the most important out of the liars for this show and Bethany deserves a lot better than what they gave her until now!
What song is no 0:30?
Jeancarlo Arqque C. same here i wanna know the song
Hamza Nafty Hands of time - Rachel Diggs
i just finished watching the finale...dayuumm girl you got it right
the name of the song is 'Sail" lol
Yes but it says in the lyrics "blame it on my a.d.d
This actually sounds very accurate. And this video makes good points and alot of sense
Um this is very interesting... Perhaps it may be right? We never know...
bhshd
the spanna scene gives me feels I love them
OMG WHO IS A.D.!!!! I wanna know soo bad. First everyone says Aria is A.D. or they say Spencer or Spencer's twin, And then they say that Sara is Hanna's sister, or they say Wren is Spencer's brother and he's A.D. which that would be gross Eww. And then they say Ali or her twin. Or that Bethany is alive and is Ali's twin. Could be Charlotte, Spencer, and Wren are siblings. I just don't know. THIS IS SO CONFUSING!!!
Amazing theory I never really thought about it before but this makes so much sense! Can't wait until the new episodes come out 😝😝😝😝
BETHANY IS DEAD, SHE CAN'T BE AD BECAUSE SHE'S DEAD !!
Sad that there will be no new theories but happy because your theory is right!
why would a.d want to help hannah tho .... ?
baby mac doll because they want Hanna to escape MK plot holes
Because she was trying to get her to spill, and when she realized she didn't know anything, she basically helped her escape
Kaxx Spencer helped Hannah. Theory says Bethany is the "Spencer with the wigs."
yall are clearly not understanding. there are hints that spencer with a fringe is the twin (A.D.) and spencer without a fringe is the real spencer.
spencer just happened to not have a fringe in hanna's "dream" and that's either a figment of her imagination (which makes less sense bc hello... just a coincidence that she didnt have a fringe in hanna's "dream"? I don't think so) OR... spencer is being held captive while her twin is pretending to be her, OR: spencer is dead.
Beck no, I hate this, the show screwed up after the CECE reveal that I don't waste time on paying attention, I used so much time looking at how ali one time had a curly hair and straight hair in the same day but then it was just a editing mistake.
After watching the last episode I came back for this video lmao
So real Spencer is dead or she never came back to Rosewood?
If you're right about Hanna's dream, i guess something happened to the real Spencer that would be creepy
And i have a theory about this ''Spencer'' has something against Hanna? because first we saw Hanna trapped and we know ''Spencer'' was the girlfriend of Caleb and almost when Hanna and all the liars arrived to Rosewood A.D trap Hanna and maybe because Spencer thought that if Hanna returned that means that probably Hanna and Caleb will get reconciled.
I know it sounds stupid but it could be.......
I don't think that's stupid at all. Because it is so odd/random to me that Caleb & Spencer dating became a significant storyline. Like it's weird. I never would've expected them together. And then it's interesting too how in one of the last episodes Spencer kisses Toby good bye and then Toby is killed with his fiance. Like it was so strange to me how Spencer warns them to get out of Rosewood and ironic that as they're leaving they get killed. It could have been so vindictive/revenge. There are no "accidental deaths" on pll. In previous seasons Toby and Spencer were targeted, A trying to break them up. And A tried to kill Toby too, early on in like season 1 or 2 when Toby is working construction. I wonder if Spencer's twin is jealous or just angry at Spencer, getting revenge.
LizziesAnswers Marline said that A. D. was not responsible for Toby's crash, it just shows that nobody can get out of Rosewood.
Very good. But only one thing: at 7:30 the song is called "Sail" not "Blame it on my A.D.D.".
Other than that, I like it. And i totally agree about the scene with Hannah, it seemed a bit out of place for her to be dreaming Spencer.
Good work
The top in season four doesn't have the holes in the sleves
Wow you did a great job on this theory!
Well..
the song at 7:28 is called sail by awolnation
Love this theory well detailed.. also the ending of the episodes after credits is a picture of twins giggling
This is a good theory and last scene was actually very intriguing for me too
OMGGGG U WERE RIGHT!!! CAN'T BELIEVE IT !!! 😱😱
you didn't do ok, you did more than ok. Its aweome, i love it you're a genious.
Woow after all, your theory was correct all along, Bravo 👏🏾
Loved your theory. cant wait for the new season!