Beside what is described, I would also add most of the times R sounds quite soft. You barely touch your mouth with the tongue. Then only you will get this flowy beautiful Russian speech.
Anastasia. Thank you. I learned french as my second language at age 4. I'm 36 now and living in Russian speaking country for 2 years. I finally can make the non throat r. Struggled with this for decades. Including with speaking Spanish which has similar tongue mechanics.
I'm a half Russian who never could make a soft r roll (mine was way to gross) and after 2 minutes of your video I finally understood how to sound softer, thank you a lot!
Thank you so much! You're the first video to actually show what the proper placement looks like INSIDE the mouth, rather than some diagram. I feel like I understand the rolled r much better, I think I'll get it down after this!
extremely good explanation! I've seen around 40 to 50 videos about the rolling r (mostly in Spanish) and this one is definitely one of the best! :) as a long time struggler I'd advice anybody with difficulties to train your tongue with a speech therapist (and you'll get instant feedback as well!).
agree, this one has some very unique insights and methods, straight to the point, very well made video. literally 10/10 video on this topic. the video made me realize i cant even smile properly lol.
This was super helpful! I found that placing my tongue near that part of the roof of my mouth near my teeth and then just exhaling/breathing out (or like the quick "sneeze" you mentioned) helped a lot! Could you please make a video on how to properly do exercises for "ы"? I've seen other videos that have helped a bit, but I haven't quite nailed it yet, and it's so frustrating 🥺😭😖
Thank you so much for providing these detailed and vivid examples! I've been practicing the Russian "P" for so long and I'm always curious about where to place my tone and how does the vibration of the tone looks like. Now I've got clearer direction of practicing!
Omg i’ve watched many tutorial videos to pronounce russian ‘R’ but still couldn’t do it. But now, after find your video, finally i figure out how to do it! I’m not 100% good at doing it yet. (Like, it doesn’t go well when i try to short Rrrrrrr) But at least i can do long Rrrrrr now! I got to practice more right now. Thank you so much!!! Love your video from S.Korea :)
THANK YOU! It may seem odd for graphs and diagrams of where the proper tongue placement is to not work for comprehension but I was not getting it at all and wasted about a day of studying and training my throat. However seeing where it should go so nonchalantly has helped me a ton in a matter of minutes. Although the Horse and Mushroom exercises have helped tremendously too. Thank you thank you THANK YOU 😁
Hi, I really enjoyed the way you explained the roll of the R. It was very clear, and concise. I don’t know if you are still active, but maybe you could make a video on pronouncing ‘р’ (русский) when it is preceded (or even followed) by ‘т’ и ‘п’ и ‘д’ и ‘в’ или ш / щ? I have the hardest time when it follows the above letters, and if it lies at the end of certain words like ‘вечер’ или ‘повар’ Words like здравствуйте или привет и русский are fairly easy, although with the latter two, it is hard to get them consistent. я учу русский язык с месяца, но это ужасна. кириллица - это легко, говорить нет. 😆 Спасибо большое!
What helped me the most with consistently making the same sound (like forming the muscle memory of where to put my tongue/how to relax but keep the correct position to produce the correct sound) was thinking about it like sliding a French R from the very back all the way to the front while maintaining the sound bcuz it's really very similar it's just a trill made farther back in the mouth almost the exact same method to make both really ((this was quite simple for me but I had been making the weird ass clicking sound from the predator films as a stim since I was in like 7th grade so jumping from Alien Cricket Noise to French R was like breathing for me))
The difficulty comes if you mentally associate the Russian "Р" with the sound an English "R" at all. Abandon this thinking all together. Completely different letter. Reprogram yourself to associate it with the sound of a quickly rolled "D", and it becomes very easy.
Thank you for making a wonderful video to explain how to make this sound. I can make this sound at least few times after watched your video. By the way, My mother language is Chinese.
@@anastasiakorol368 Не за что)) п.с. Если уж придираться формально-точно, то соответствие неточное, но это довольно похоже. Достаточно для того что бы научить. =)
im russian pronouncing half of the words correctly the other half with french variant 😄was going to logopedist in my childhood but didnt work) maybe your video will help me) but honestly, russian people say that they like my wrong r, but ive started to learning Spanish recently, and it became a problem 😒
Any tips on how to get one's tongue to relax? I can get my tongue into the right position but when I try the strong exhalation, it only seems to hit the back/middle of my tongue, and the tip remains still. It's still producing a rolling sound but I can tell it's not quite right.
I’m Haitian with French as part of my native language. At the age of 7 I moved to Canada and been speaking Canadian English for 19 years. I lost the ability to speak my native language during my early years in Canada. During this whole time I never gained the ability to roll my R’s. I’m in the process of teaching myself a few new languages and beatboxing which all require me to have the ability to roll my R’s. This is my first time your channel. I think this video might help me, but how do I relax my tongue enough for it to vibrate like yours when exhaling enough air? I can feel how tense it is and air is just going right through it. Plz help. Do you have any tips for me on relaxing the stubborn tense tongue of mine haha?
It’s funny you mentioned learning English that your tongue was sore. I watched the movie Moscow in the Hudson with Robin Williams and he plays a Russian learning English, and he said his tongue was sore. I didn’t know that was a true thing. Apparently it is true. Funny that it’s the other way around too because my tongue is getting tired.
I am a native Russian speaker but I moved to a different country in Europe when I was four. So I never really learned and internalized the proper r-sound. It's a huge mess now because there is so much one can do wrong about it...
My tounge won’t vibrate, I try relaxing it but nothing seems to happen and the closest I can get to the sound is when my tongue moves away from the spot and use saliva to bubble up and it won’t sound close enough to the P to bypass it
Hello ! Thanks to this video I'm already much closer to a trilled R than ever so thank you so much ! one of the major things I have trouble with is the frequency of the trill, mine is quite slow and it makes the sound ugly :( i can't make it vibrate fast enough for it to be really be trilled also because of this I can't do long trills, they are even uglier and sound like uh a slow machine gun or something idk x) does it come with practice or is there a specific problem ? I can provide a recording if someone wants to help :o
@@anastasiakorol368 Is there a technique that makes the relaxation of the tongue easier? For some reason I have a huge issue with this part, and it seems to be the only thing preventing me from pronouncing this rolled R properly. Somehow my brain tenses the tongue significantly, and I can't turn this thing off for some reason
The vibrating is not in 'R' but more to 'tr'. And not able to voice out while vibrating. The vibrating on and off lolz sometimes vibrating works all the tries sometimes no... how to improve further? Thanks...
Hi there, I can produce the Russian rolling R sound but most of the time it sounds like something starting with the H consonant (Hrrrr). I can do Trrrr and Drrrr to some extent. However the authentic Russian R sounds like Lrrrr, which I can't do at all. May I ask how you combine the L consonant with the rrrr sound naturally? Mine always sounds like A-Hrrrr-L.
what you do at 1:25 i can do very well but as soon as i have to make a noise like at 1:39 i absolutely don't know how to do it i sound extremely strange. Someone has tips for me ?
I need some help I’m new to learning Russian and I’m struggling with rolling Rs. My first and only fluent language is English. When I roll a R I make noise even if there’s no air. It’s much deeper, and like repeated Rs. It works but doesn’t sound right. I’ve watched multiple videos and I need advice. (+ my tongue is in the right place )
idk if anyone will see my comment since its been over a year, but whenever I press my tongue to my alveleor ridge as soon as I exhale my tongue moves away from it, and if I try to move it back its not relaxed anymore. Any tips on how to fix that? also great vid :)
Well, I still cannot make the alveolar trill, despite it being in my native language. After going to the speech therapist it turned out that almost everything I do with my mouth and tongue is wrong, even the swallowing process. So it is true that many people will not be able to learn this sound by themselves, but not because they physiologically cannot pronounce it (save for a tiny minority of people, like those with a short bridle). So, unless those incorrect vocal apparatus habits are corrected, those people will not be able to learn the pronounciation of a trilled r, like myself. At least not without a help from a speech therapist, it is unlikely to find out that almost all of your vocal apparatus habits are wrong without an expert noticing it.
Absolutely agree. Many Russian speakers can't pronounce the R sound too. But it doesn't stop them from expressing their ideas. Neither it should stop Russian learners.
@@anastasiakorol368 May I ask one more questions? Whenever I manage to make some vibration, it is quite harsh with a low frequency, and every hit sounds like a d sound. I'm not actively hitting my tongue like when making the repeated quick d d d d d sound of course. Still, I cannot make this vibration more gentle and delicate for more than a month now, zero progress during that time. Have you ever encountered a similar case, and/or do you know what might be the case, how it can be corrected? I hope I'm not too brazen here, if I do I'm sorry
It turns out in a clashing noise. I’m not sure if it’s because I’m putting to much air into it and the best I can do is a French roll. So rolling in the back of the tongue instead of the front. Can you help?
I can get my tongue relaxed and in the right place and everything, but I just can’t it to vibrate???? I don’t even know what I’m doing wrong at this point, I just can’t do it😭
Hi , whenever I try the R sound it always comes with a 'grrr' sound from my throat whenever I do the exhaling. Therefore I can't incorporate the thrill R into my speech. How do I fix this?
Unfortunately, this didn’t produce any sound besides a slightly muffled harsh exhale. My tongue doesn’t vibrate, shake, wiggle or move even though it’s relaxed up there
I'm Mexican and speak Spanish, I was never able to pronounce it, and now that I have tons of Russians friends and I teach them Spanish, it's so annoying, really trying my best!!! I'm 33 yo, let's see! Thanks for the video!!!
У меня французский вариант... и только знакомый логопед это замечает ))) Я русский... так что можно проканать за нейтива с неправильным произношением :D за картавого нейтива Еще встречал упражнения на отработку именно мягкого Рь - у некоторый бывают проблемы что все Р в речи получаются твердые. You can search pronunciation exercises in russian youtube by request "Исправление звука Р"
I ve watched every single video on this but it still comes out wrong. I can easilyt vibrate my tongue using air, but when i add voice it doesnt sound like a rolled r at all. It sounds more like a machine gun
great observation. it means that your tongue is relaxed only when your head is back. memorise this feeling and move your head in a normal position slowly. try to notice the moment when a good R gets broken.
![How to roll Russian sound [R].](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yl3oRtsFUjA/mqdefault.jpg)
![The best trilled [r] video yet!](/img/1.gif)
It's 3 am and I sound like a leaking balloon
😂
4am but same
Beside what is described, I would also add most of the times R sounds quite soft. You barely touch your mouth with the tongue. Then only you will get this flowy beautiful Russian speech.
Thank you for explaining the differences in the “wrong” sounds! I definitely will be using these techniques and practicing!
Anastasia. Thank you. I learned french as my second language at age 4. I'm 36 now and living in Russian speaking country for 2 years.
I finally can make the non throat r.
Struggled with this for decades. Including with speaking Spanish which has similar tongue mechanics.
I'm a half Russian who never could make a soft r roll (mine was way to gross) and after 2 minutes of your video I finally understood how to sound softer, thank you a lot!
Wow!!!!!!!!!! My congratulations!!!
Thank you so much! You're the first video to actually show what the proper placement looks like INSIDE the mouth, rather than some diagram. I feel like I understand the rolled r much better, I think I'll get it down after this!
Out of every video I have watched on this sound, yours has had the only explanation that I understood.
extremely good explanation! I've seen around 40 to 50 videos about the rolling r (mostly in Spanish) and this one is definitely one of the best! :) as a long time struggler I'd advice anybody with difficulties to train your tongue with a speech therapist (and you'll get instant feedback as well!).
agree, this one has some very unique insights and methods, straight to the point, very well made video. literally 10/10 video on this topic.
the video made me realize i cant even smile properly lol.
the best teacher for Roll R Therapy
After watching this video and using the techniques, I managed to make the sound finally, thanks so much for this video ^^
Glad I could help!
Help me please
Why did I start looking up when practicing? 🤣🤣🤣 I won't stop watching your video until I sound like Галустян! Thanks for the tips!
I leaned back my head and it just worked, finally!
This was super helpful! I found that placing my tongue near that part of the roof of my mouth near my teeth and then just exhaling/breathing out (or like the quick "sneeze" you mentioned) helped a lot!
Could you please make a video on how to properly do exercises for "ы"? I've seen other videos that have helped a bit, but I haven't quite nailed it yet, and it's so frustrating 🥺😭😖
Glad it helped!
Thank you so much for providing these detailed and vivid examples! I've been practicing the Russian "P" for so long and I'm always curious about where to place my tone and how does the vibration of the tone looks like. Now I've got clearer direction of practicing!
Really good video. I will practice these techniques. I can do a short roll, but i cannot sustain it. Mine just sounds like a buzzing noise
The best and most thorough tutorial on the subject that I've seen. Thanks VERY much!
This is the better explanation I saw about how to make this sound.
I was watching Spanish r rolling techniques before this one and they kinda help as a warm up.
Watched almost every video on this topic. This is the by far the best one
Omg i’ve watched many tutorial videos to pronounce russian ‘R’ but still couldn’t do it. But now, after find your video, finally i figure out how to do it! I’m not 100% good at doing it yet. (Like, it doesn’t go well when i try to short Rrrrrrr) But at least i can do long Rrrrrr now! I got to practice more right now. Thank you so much!!! Love your video from S.Korea :)
Useful exercises.
Thanks!
Thank you sooo much!! I was always told to “vibrate my tongue” but never knew how, I can’t thank you enough, this worked :)
I'm not much help because was just trying one day and I figured it out. I have a hard time with short Rs. Still need to practice.
Nice video. It's the first video I've seen that actually shows a vibrating tongue.
After watch more that 20 videos, this one is the most effective to learn and reproduce the russian Р 😊
This is one of the best videos Ive found ❤ The car noises actually worked for me lol Thanks!
This explanation is one of the best I've found! Though I must admit, that relaxing the tongue is much harder to do than it seems at first 😂
ive been trying to figured out how to do it for 5 minutes 😭
@@ronanxiety I can't relax my tongue at all it seems. . .
Может научусь всё-таки...
I did it! Finally!! Thank you so much!
Fantastic! My congratulations!!!
Very good demonstration. Thank you!
THANK YOU! It may seem odd for graphs and diagrams of where the proper tongue placement is to not work for comprehension but I was not getting it at all and wasted about a day of studying and training my throat. However seeing where it should go so nonchalantly has helped me a ton in a matter of minutes. Although the Horse and Mushroom exercises have helped tremendously too. Thank you thank you THANK YOU 😁
This is a wonderful video! Best of this year!
omg , i can do it now once i watched once of it , its a very helpful video , thank you so much
Hi,
I really enjoyed the way you explained the roll of the R. It was very clear, and concise.
I don’t know if you are still active, but maybe you could make a video on pronouncing ‘р’ (русский) when it is preceded (or even followed) by ‘т’ и ‘п’ и ‘д’ и ‘в’ или ш / щ?
I have the hardest time when it follows the above letters, and if it lies at the end of certain words like ‘вечер’ или ‘повар’
Words like здравствуйте или привет и русский are fairly easy, although with the latter two, it is hard to get them consistent.
я учу русский язык с месяца, но это ужасна. кириллица - это легко, говорить нет. 😆
Спасибо большое!
Very detailed and helpful explanation! Спасибо Анастасия!
I’m English and it’s really hard for me to do this but I’m not giving up cause Russian is really fun I love learning Russian
What helped me the most with consistently making the same sound (like forming the muscle memory of where to put my tongue/how to relax but keep the correct position to produce the correct sound) was thinking about it like sliding a French R from the very back all the way to the front while maintaining the sound bcuz it's really very similar it's just a trill made farther back in the mouth almost the exact same method to make both really ((this was quite simple for me but I had been making the weird ass clicking sound from the predator films as a stim since I was in like 7th grade so jumping from Alien Cricket Noise to French R was like breathing for me))
Superb demonstration!
the best explanation ever! Thank you!
The difficulty comes if you mentally associate the Russian "Р" with the sound an English "R" at all. Abandon this thinking all together. Completely different letter. Reprogram yourself to associate it with the sound of a quickly rolled "D", and it becomes very easy.
Your comment might just make this work
Great idea! I can go from a 'd' to 'r' quite easily!
I will try this again.
Interesting explanation
Great informative video. Best one I seen explaining and teaching how to pronounce Russian ‘R’s!
Thank you for making a wonderful video to explain how to make this sound. I can make this sound at least few times after watched your video. By the way, My mother language is Chinese.
really cool video and nice exercices, thank you so much !
i went from nothing to being able to make the silent viberating noise from this video :)
Who else is trapped in chewbacca's body? 😭😭
Спасибо, Ася.
Anastasia! You've been found!
Amazing video thank you very much ❤️
That worked danke im very happy
Americans often pronounce 'Flap T' very similarly to the Russian sound 'эР' (of course, not at those moments when it becomes too similar to 'd').
"body" звучит часто как "бари".
Но бывает, конечно, звучит и как "бади" и даже "ба[д/р]и". Но тут нужно найти просто удачный пример.
Thank you! I didn't know that! No I've got +1 way to explain Russian P to Americans.
@@anastasiakorol368 Не за что))
п.с. Если уж придираться формально-точно, то соответствие неточное, но это довольно похоже. Достаточно для того что бы научить.
=)
@@YaShoom Это точно. Я иногда готова жертвовать научной точностью, если это делает объяснение более понятным.
i wasnt sure what to expect @1:25, but i wasnt disappointed
thank you anastasia! this helped me very well :)
Thank you for the
1:32 and 1:43 its so funny the way you just stare at the camera 😭😭❤❤
Thanks!
This was the most useful video I’ve seen about this!
im russian pronouncing half of the words correctly the other half with french variant 😄was going to logopedist in my childhood but didnt work) maybe your video will help me) but honestly, russian people say that they like my wrong r, but ive started to learning Spanish recently, and it became a problem 😒
I can seem to make it by using the back of my throat. My tongue wouldn’t move but I can get a sound similar
Any tips on how to get one's tongue to relax? I can get my tongue into the right position but when I try the strong exhalation, it only seems to hit the back/middle of my tongue, and the tip remains still. It's still producing a rolling sound but I can tell it's not quite right.
I can never do a r for more than a second any tips for extending the sound
Very helpful and funny
I’m Haitian with French as part of my native language. At the age of 7 I moved to Canada and been speaking Canadian English for 19 years. I lost the ability to speak my native language during my early years in Canada. During this whole time I never gained the ability to roll my R’s. I’m in the process of teaching myself a few new languages and beatboxing which all require me to have the ability to roll my R’s. This is my first time your channel. I think this video might help me, but how do I relax my tongue enough for it to vibrate like yours when exhaling enough air? I can feel how tense it is and air is just going right through it. Plz help. Do you have any tips for me on relaxing the stubborn tense tongue of mine haha?
It’s funny you mentioned learning English that your tongue was sore. I watched the movie Moscow in the Hudson with Robin Williams and he plays a Russian learning English, and he said his tongue was sore. I didn’t know that was a true thing. Apparently it is true. Funny that it’s the other way around too because my tongue is getting tired.
By the way, your video is the best! Thank you! God bless!!!
By the way, Porsche is not pronounced like Porsh. It is pronounced like Por-Shuh. Porsche.
I am a native Russian speaker but I moved to a different country in Europe when I was four. So I never really learned and internalized the proper r-sound. It's a huge mess now because there is so much one can do wrong about it...
My tounge won’t vibrate, I try relaxing it but nothing seems to happen and the closest I can get to the sound is when my tongue moves away from the spot and use saliva to bubble up and it won’t sound close enough to the P to bypass it
Hello ! Thanks to this video I'm already much closer to a trilled R than ever so thank you so much !
one of the major things I have trouble with is the frequency of the trill, mine is quite slow and it makes the sound ugly :( i can't make it vibrate fast enough for it to be really be trilled
also because of this I can't do long trills, they are even uglier and sound like uh a slow machine gun or something idk x)
does it come with practice or is there a specific problem ? I can provide a recording if someone wants to help :o
1. try to relax the tip of your tongue a bit more 2. in fast speech you won't need a long RRRR. Say привет, for instance. The R there is short.
@@anastasiakorol368 Is there a technique that makes the relaxation of the tongue easier? For some reason I have a huge issue with this part, and it seems to be the only thing preventing me from pronouncing this rolled R properly. Somehow my brain tenses the tongue significantly, and I can't turn this thing off for some reason
@@janboreczek3045 I'll comeuppance with a video with some more exercises
so what am i ment do to when the air escapes the open parts of my mounts
The vibrating is not in 'R' but more to 'tr'. And not able to voice out while vibrating. The vibrating on and off lolz sometimes vibrating works all the tries sometimes no... how to improve further? Thanks...
Keep on practicing. First deal with the "mechanics" after that add voice. You can do this!
Hi there, I can produce the Russian rolling R sound but most of the time it sounds like something starting with the H consonant (Hrrrr). I can do Trrrr and Drrrr to some extent. However the authentic Russian R sounds like Lrrrr, which I can't do at all. May I ask how you combine the L consonant with the rrrr sound naturally? Mine always sounds like A-Hrrrr-L.
It sounds like I'm going diddle diddle diddle.
I just made a weird "KHHHZZZZZZHHHHHH" sound
haha same
But for me khhzzzzzzddddhzzzzz
what you do at 1:25 i can do very well but as soon as i have to make a noise like at 1:39 i absolutely don't know how to do it i sound extremely strange. Someone has tips for me ?
I can sometimes get the rolling r sound but i can't maintain it for more than a second like in this video..
You might not need it, as in Russian we don't use long RRRRRRR. We don't say pRRRRivet. We say it shortly. Privet.
So I am able to make the R sound but it sounds too hard or like д but trilled
I could never roll my R until earlier today it clicked, now it's too harsh though. I haven't been able to plug it into Russian words yet
Omg so hard :(((
I need some help I’m new to learning Russian and I’m struggling with rolling Rs. My first and only fluent language is English. When I roll a R I make noise even if there’s no air. It’s much deeper, and like repeated Rs. It works but doesn’t sound right. I’ve watched multiple videos and I need advice. (+ my tongue is in the right place )
idk if anyone will see my comment since its been over a year, but whenever I press my tongue to my alveleor ridge as soon as I exhale my tongue moves away from it, and if I try to move it back its not relaxed anymore. Any tips on how to fix that?
also great vid :)
I'm having the same problem, so if anyone has any tips it would be very useful!
I see you) I think I'll need a separate video with some additional exercises.
Well, I still cannot make the alveolar trill, despite it being in my native language. After going to the speech therapist it turned out that almost everything I do with my mouth and tongue is wrong, even the swallowing process. So it is true that many people will not be able to learn this sound by themselves, but not because they physiologically cannot pronounce it (save for a tiny minority of people, like those with a short bridle). So, unless those incorrect vocal apparatus habits are corrected, those people will not be able to learn the pronounciation of a trilled r, like myself. At least not without a help from a speech therapist, it is unlikely to find out that almost all of your vocal apparatus habits are wrong without an expert noticing it.
Absolutely agree. Many Russian speakers can't pronounce the R sound too. But it doesn't stop them from expressing their ideas. Neither it should stop Russian learners.
@@anastasiakorol368 May I ask one more questions? Whenever I manage to make some vibration, it is quite harsh with a low frequency, and every hit sounds like a d sound. I'm not actively hitting my tongue like when making the repeated quick d d d d d sound of course. Still, I cannot make this vibration more gentle and delicate for more than a month now, zero progress during that time. Have you ever encountered a similar case, and/or do you know what might be the case, how it can be corrected? I hope I'm not too brazen here, if I do I'm sorry
@@janboreczek3045 I have the exact same problem. Was the speech therapist unable to help you with this? Did you find a fix
When following these tips I find myself making a tttttt or ddddd roll, it doesn't quite sound like an r one, does anyone have a solution?
Yeah, treat is as a preparatory, transitional exercise. Try to relax the tip of your tongue.
How about Turkish R is it similar .
I ask because foreign Turkish learners ask me questions and i can't answer properly .
It turns out in a clashing noise. I’m not sure if it’s because I’m putting to much air into it and the best I can do is a French roll. So rolling in the back of the tongue instead of the front. Can you help?
I can pronounce the rolled r but can't combine it with any letters
Good question. There's a common problem, I think I'll make another video on the spot.
I can get my tongue relaxed and in the right place and everything, but I just can’t it to vibrate???? I don’t even know what I’m doing wrong at this point, I just can’t do it😭
Hi , whenever I try the R sound it always comes with a 'grrr' sound from my throat whenever I do the exhaling. Therefore I can't incorporate the thrill R into my speech. How do I fix this?
By the way, out of curiosity - how do you manage any kind of vibration with your mouth open so wide? :O
I’ve been practicing in the car, shower, while watching tv. My family wants to expel me and my bad rolling tongue. 😅
I Have my tongue vibrating but I can't get the right sound It always has a d or a t before the r sound. Any tips to help that?
this is a very high pitched R but when i try its a *deeper clearing throat* type R how to fix it 😭
Unfortunately, this didn’t produce any sound besides a slightly muffled harsh exhale. My tongue doesn’t vibrate, shake, wiggle or move even though it’s relaxed up there
I'm Mexican and speak Spanish, I was never able to pronounce it, and now that I have tons of Russians friends and I teach them Spanish, it's so annoying, really trying my best!!! I'm 33 yo, let's see!
Thanks for the video!!!
I hear that the Russian r is different than the Spanish r. But i would like to see a comparison
I don't hear such a difference 🤔
I struggle to apply the russiam r in words.. Any tips
Can you pronounce this sound separately?
@@anastasiakorol368 yep just not in words
@@nicnac9147 A few exercises could help. I'll make a video about that soon.
@@anastasiakorol368 thank you so much
i’m american and i want to learn russian, and my tongue is sore after trying to pronounce the russian r, but i think i will eventually do it.
Of course you will! Russian phonetics is a bit tricky sometimes, but definitely not the hardest one.
@@anastasiakorol368 after the time of 5 days i actually learned how to do it, i want to say thank you because you helped me a lot pronouncing the r.
@@movedaccounts1221 my congratulations!!!!
У меня французский вариант... и только знакомый логопед это замечает ))) Я русский... так что можно проканать за нейтива с неправильным произношением :D за картавого нейтива
Еще встречал упражнения на отработку именно мягкого Рь - у некоторый бывают проблемы что все Р в речи получаются твердые.
You can search pronunciation exercises in russian youtube by request "Исправление звука Р"
I
ve watched every single video on this but it still comes out wrong. I can easilyt vibrate my tongue using air, but when i add voice it doesnt sound like a rolled r at all. It sounds more like a machine gun
Okay I have a dilemma. Turns out I can roll my R, but only when I tilt my head back like you did in the video. What does this mean??
great observation. it means that your tongue is relaxed only when your head is back. memorise this feeling and move your head in a normal position slowly. try to notice the moment when a good R gets broken.
@@anastasiakorol368 thank you. I will keep trying, but right now my neck hurts 😂
@@jessicaqu be careful!))
I keep doing mine at the back of my tongue but I can’t get it to go to the front
и как расслабить язык?
I learned in 3 months 😂