The Surprisingly Different Moral Perspectives of our Favourite Clone Commanders [Pt.2]
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 июл 2024
- All my homies hate Faie
Join Geetsly's Clone Army Now & Get Access to Exclusive Perks! 💥
/ @geetslys
Check out some of the music we use in our videos!🎶
•bit.ly/RelaxJackYT
Become a Geetsly's 41st Elite Clone Trooper Today🎮:
• / discord
#geetsly #starwars #clonewars
For business inquiries and to learn about our team check out our website🌐:
frontiermediaco.com/
Chapters
0:00 Intro
0:38 Captain Rex
3:06 Commander Faie
6:02 Commander Neyo
7:58 Outro 
Кино
![The Surprisingly Different Moral Perspectives of our Favourite Clone Commanders [Pt.3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/izB1AwId5-0/mqdefault.jpg)
![The Surprisingly Different Moral Perspectives of our Favourite Clone Commanders [Pt.3]](/img/tr.png)
![How our Favourite Clone Commanders Moral Perspectives on War Differed so Drastically [Pt.1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JOso9LpRV4Q/mqdefault.jpg)
![Finesse2Tymes - Pretty Ricky [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xIoP_mhYRT0/mqdefault.jpg)
Rex: It’s wrong, they’re innocent
Neo: It’s an order, even though they’re innocent.
Faye: If they can talk, they get the Glock
But not my glock
Short way to sum up this whole video 😂
Meanwhile my personal clonetrooper
Striker: I AM DEATH
I laughed harder than I should have
Padawan or Master, they get the blaster.
Neo: what's the difference between a smashing a baby and a watermelon?
Rex: this entire village is dead Neo not the time
"not the time" 😂
Faye: if it's an order there is no difference
Rex: The Jedi are our friends, these orders are wrong!
Neyo: I missed the part where that’s my problem
Faie: All suspects are guilty, otherwise they wouldn’t be suspects
Hahaha
Very faithful representation of Faie
You got me with neyo.
I see what you did there with Faie. Nice fan-vid reference! :)
Not going into more detail about Bacara and Neyo was the Clone Wars biggest missed opportunity. They contradict the brotherhood mentality of the clones and would have been a great episode to see both Neyo and Bacara eating alone away from their brothers
Would have been cool to see a group of Clones so different from the men of either the 501st, the 212th, or the 104th, who didn't like their Jedi or had too much free will and thought, the conversations the two different groups could have would have been interesting to see.
Bacara was the Clone equivalent of Sgt. Hartman from Full Metal Jacket. Extremely strict, harsh, ruthless, and uncompromising.
Neyo on the other hand was like Vicious from Cowboy Bebop. He was an amoral psychopath who viewed his brothers as tools.
It was a total missed opportunity to see them and how they treat their troops.
The clone wars did an excellent job depicting the true nature of most clones, but you are exactly right, and this is hopefully something we could see in the future!
@@geetslys I know TCW is done but I would love to see a “clone wars” serious where we get a few episodes that show different clones perspectives, would be a great way to build on characters and introduce new ones
Bacara: *_(BRUTALLY_* executes a traitor in front of their family)
Neyo: “So… gonna eat that?”
Captain Rex: The Jedi are our friends, brothers in arms, and have strong morals
Commander Faie: Either the Jedi die or these innocent Wookiees will!
Commander Neyo: Well, I don't entirely agree, but an orders an order so let's do this. Leave it for the big wigs to figure out later.
Neyo: the order was given for a reason.
I love how TCW truly explains what clones are. They are basically different individuals who shares the same DNA. That's scientifically what clones are.
Most would've expected clones being the exact replica of the host, including personality, ideas, memories etc.
makes me wonder how a batch of clones would act, say if Jango's memories were "falsely" implanted from birth.
Isn't it just so...cosmic? It is really fascinating.
They're basically super-twins. Yeah
Like the boys over at Generation Tech say, no matter how much indoctrination and genetic modification one does, it's impossible to completely wipe out someone's individuality because life finds a way.
@@zexalbrony4799 This annoys me the most when people claim "chips are bad", since they go "but they use the chancellor's name as a warcry!"
... mate, Christian crusaders probably used the Pope's name as a warcry. They still ended up rebelling agains Vatican over being allowed to divorce.
Rex: knows right and wrong; cares
Neo: knows right and wrong; doesn’t care
Faye: the teachers slave
Fey is the epitamy of "good soldiers follow orders."
If you know, you know.
Rex: We served with these Jedi for years! We can't just shoot them.
Faie: Splish splash, Jedi go flash! (All others glare at this boi)
Neyo: Too bad. They told me to kill 'em, so I killed 'em.
Gree: The orders said he was a traitor! I had to do it! I had enough of traitors!
Cody: Ah, he was gonna die sooner or later anyway, might as well have been me who pulled the trigger.
Bacara: Nothing is more important than the mission.
I can feel that something in Cody died that day.
I have a feeling something was separated from commander gree as well
@@marseldagistani1989, apparently, Cody felt the same way, if what we saw in the Bad Batch is anything to go by.
I’d love to see Bly, Blackout and Wolffe in the next one
Thanks for the recommendation!
I don’t think blackout has enough background
Bly and Wolffe yes. But I'm not sure if we have enough material on Blackout. Or Jet from the 2nd Battle of Geonosis. Maybe Fox would be the better input if you ask me.
I just realized that Rex and Ahsoka have matching color schemes, with white and blue in similar shades on his armor and her montrals. I wonder if that was an intentional design decision, meant to highlight how Anakin's support characters had similar mindsets.
true
Rex: We can’t shoot them, they are our friends.
Faie: So anyway I started blasting.
This just made me love Rex even more.
I feel like the morals of a Jedi Knight is what a true hero (in literature) are.
Rex: is friendly and approachable
Neyo: is cold but is effective
Faie: will rip you to shreds
Rex- It's ok you're out of ice tea...here take this tip.
Neo- They're always out of tea, who cares.
Faie- No tea? Burn this restaurant down.
Rex: “What the fuck, Faie?!?”
Neyo: “Yeah, I like this place!”
@@zsu-23-4shilka2 please may you continue with this epic Star Wars Story?
7:16 sounds like Neyo and Sev would get along on that front, that and they both like the colour red it seems
Neyo and Sev talking with each other would make the clone army be cancelled in no time
they would have the edgiest time ever
We need to see more clone commanders or clone captains in the Clone wars or in a bad batch
I'd love to see a series or something on this! Very fascinating
Every Clone was an unique individual who had different types of morals and ideology, but they were still brothers that were force to fight in a war that they didn’t truly understand.
Rex,Faie,Neyo.
What a odd bunch of Clone Commanders in one room😂
Please make this a series. This video was cool!
Commanders I’m intrigued by:
Bly
Wolfe
Ponds
Oddball
Gree
Cody
Or any of those navy admirals :)
Gree & Cody were discussed in pt 1.
Captain Rex: You can't just slot all the natives of the planet that you're invading, it makes our bothers and the Republic look bad!
Commander Neyo: Why would give a frack about any of that when I have a job to do? Besides do you want to let the Separatists to win the war? That's the soft-hearted Jedi logic that got a lot of our boys killed during the First Battle of Geonosis. They should stick to being peacekeepers instead of playing generals. Wasn't it a Jedi that got a lot of your guys killed on Umbara?
Captain Rex: First, Pong Krell was the exception not the rule. Second, not all the Jedi are total washouts when it comes to being leaders.
Commander Keller: Remind me why I decided to hang out with you two again?
Rex: Krell was a traitor, so he doesn’t count. Plus I’ e seen renegade troopers doing way more damages than he did.
@@florians9949 Oh yeah, Slick nearly cost them the Battle of Chriptosis
@reaperking7748 please turn this into a Story and please continue it ?
Keller: wow Rex that must have been crazy I’ll be going now I got to practice my Jedi hunting skills
Hope we get to see some of these Commanders/Captains in the Bad Batch during the early Imperial era
What up Geets
Neyo shot down Stass Allie because she kept trying to talk to him and it annoyed him
These were interesting. The description of Neyo's personality reminds me of both Sev from Republic Commando and myself when I do a neutral/anti-hero playthrough in rpgs. XD
My comparisons:
Rex: Renegade/Rogue.
Faie/Faye: Death Korps of Krieg guardsman.
Neyo: The Quiet Kid.
Also, I noticed that some images used for Faie/Faye were actually of Commander Kellar. Just a weird observation.
Not that weird of an observation, he used images of Commander Vill when talking about Commander Appo.
Faie: *exited gas mask noises*
@@stormdragon7500 where is your Trench shovel Commander?
@@marseldagistani1989 Deeply stuck inside the enemy battle droids chest cavity, sir!
I think part of the reason why Rex's motives, philosophy, and general growth came from Anakin's passion. The Jedi saw passion as a source of evil and corruption as seen in their code; however, like many other things, there are always 2 sides of the story. Anakin's passion and dedication to saving lives and doing the right thing (along with a "little" bit of being unorthodox) shaped Rex's point of view, combined with his own discipline as a soldier. Other Jedi and commanders were rigid and had a "by-the-book" philosophy so they just progressed to soldiers and generals, save Quilan Vos who was more like a maverick
Rex values and beliefes seem to match surprisingly well with those of Mace Windu: "Jedi do not fight for peace. That's only a slogan, and is as misleading as slogans always are. Jedi fight for civilization, because only civilization creates peace. We fight for justice because justice is the fundamental bedrock of civilization: an unjust civilization is built upon sand. It does not long survive a storm." Quote from the excellent RotS novelization xD both Rex and Windu champion justice and civilization out of a genuine belief of it being the best for the citizens of the republic and the galaxy.
I think comparing commanders Thorn and Fox would be awesome, to show the great differences of the two most prominent officers of the Republic Shock Troopers Corps.
Tbh do we have any idea what thorns views were like?
All we saw was him doing his job and fighting to the bitter end like a badass
But that doesn’t mean he wouldn’t have had a similar view to fox
Rex is the one guy I want beside me in the foxhole/trench when stuff goes down.
Rex seems to be, in D&D terms, Lawful Good. Which is both pleasing and makes sense when he grappled against Order 66. Lawful Nuetral and true Nuetral seem to fit the other two.
Neyo's armor is coolest Clone War era armor in my opinion.
is it weird that faie is my favorite kind of clone? and he kinda makes sense too. a decade of programming and harsh training to basically worship the republic and its orders. and when/why did they decide to teach the war clones right from wrong?
I always enjoy the good leaders and cold commanders. Bacara, Faie, Keller, Neyo, Fox (yes, Fox). They are all good clone commanders and are dangerous because they are efficient and excellent at their job.
Therapist: Phase one Neyo isn’t real and he can’t hurt you.
Phase one Neyo: 7:38
You gotta do more!!! Bly, Thire & Appo (only other clones I can think on the top of my head lol. I guess maybe Fox or Thorn)
Keep up the amazing work!!! My favorite clone trooper is definitely Bly and I think Bly is SOOO UNDERRATED
Neo has a cool armour design, and I havent heard a lot about the SIMP
And then Rex
If Geetsly doesn’t see this or is already making Part 3, then I atleast hope I can predict the future.
For Part 3, the clones that would be awesome to see would be:
Commander Bly: A clone who cared deeply for his Jedi General and had one of the strongest relationships among Jedi and Clone. He was compassionate but fiercely loyal to the Republic. But even with his chip active, he showed mercy to Aayla, wanting her death to be quick and painless.
Commander Keller: Keller is among on of the coolest and most interesting clones out there. Keller was basically Bacara’s second in command and took his job seriously. His 7th Arctic Legion was efficient and dangerous, and they would glass a planet if they had to. Keller was willing to put an entire town under marshal law to find a Jedi. He would stop at nothing to complete his mission.
Commander Fox: Fox was, obviously, fiercely loyal to the Republic and the Chancellor. He would not question an order and was extremely by the book when it came to procedures. While he is hated for it, he was a model clone commander. He was an excellent coordinator and commander, and did whatever it took to carry out the orders of the Chancellor, which, is the reason he is hated, but is also what most (if not all clones) would drop everything to serve the Chancellor.
Personally, I wouldn't mind listening to more of these, with how many clone commanders existed, we could have at least an hour long thing just summarizing each one like this!
Wow, I can't believe Lucasfilm modeled Neyo's personality around my own
Is nice
~Heavy weapons guy
You didn't mention how Neyo would make all his officers wear the exact same armor as him so the enemy would not know which one he is, basically decoys.
Yes I’d like to see you continue with this series of Clone commanders and their morality or lack there of!
I like how the SW: Republic writers made Faie a form of symbolism of the Empire's future Stormtroopers.
*sees description* ...Oh, no. *Him.*
Oh, and fellow commenters, it's Neyo, not the guy from The Matrix.
1:13: If anyone is wondering, the woman Jedi on the left is Callista Ming from the Callista duology/trilogy.
(Honestly, why are some of the comic splashes blank, while others aren't?)
Neyo does have a point when it comes to picking the choice with the better outcome, regardless of the moral quandaries.
Well, one of the next three better be Alpha-17, the real anti-Rex.
This video makes me love Rex more. He didn't just fight for institutions like Gree or Windu, and he also didn't fight to protect certain people like Anakin. He fought for the institution of the Republic because he believed (perhaps wrongly) that the Republic saved the most lives.
Everytime I think of how it cannot get darker it does the more u think about it how the clone Wars ended and our favorite clones are tossed aside and forgotten these troopers that fought for the rebuilic and forgotten and the bonds they had with their generals which ended as well as the last season where they are buried and look at those helmets and believe thats how it ended 🥺🥺
This series is one of the best I have ever seen! Great job! It really helps me to see each of the different personalities of these awesome characters.
We need some kind of mini series (like 7-10 episodes), in each episode of which we will observe one clone-commander personality, behaviour, fighting skills, etc. We would see how different each of them. For example, series could show us how Wolf took a bit of Jedi philosophy under Plo Koon’s command; how Gree had genuine interest in other species’ culture and his effort to broaden his horizons of knowledge; how Fox was ruthless in executing orders and his behaviour to prisoners; show us Neo’s “cold-bastard-genius” personality and action in fight. Rex would be excluded because we already saw much of him, instead we need Cody.
I really like how you share your perspective and explore humanity instead of just lore dumping! These videos are always great.
You should make this a series! I'd love to see more of these type of videos
I totally enjoyed this particular segment and I would like to see more videos on more clones and their different personalities.
I'm sorry every time I see Commander Neyo I think of him raiding some Separatist base while singing
"MY NAME IS 8826 AND I AM HERE TO SAY, WITH THE POWER OF NEYO I STAND IN YOUR WAY-"
Excellent writing today. Very impressed. Somebody there spent a ton of time in school.
I would like to learn about the morals of the clone commander from the star wars the clone wars episode "supply lines". The one that stood with Jedi general Di on Ryloth until the very end.
Also it really does seem that most clone's morals and personality is represented or expressed in some way by their Jedi commander. At least that is what I understood from watching star wars the clone wars. If that presumption is true then you must wonder how amoral was oppo rancisis to create such a clone commander as Fae
Captain Keeli?
3:05 I swear I almost cracked to tears hearing that
This was great! I really enjoyed seeing the perspective of the different clone commanders! I'd love to see Ponds, Fox and Appo next!
I love these videos on the commander’s personalities
Yes please more videos please maybe Clone Commandos Commanders .
3:26 In the new canon Oppo Rancisis is alive.
Thumbnail be like
Neyo: yo- you *hic* you drank my godamn pink tea dint ya?!
Rex: what the hell neyo it's right there!
Faye: *why am I stuck with these idiots?*
Rex: “Who are you to talk? You follow orders *_BECAUSE_* they’re immoral!”
Faie: “No, you fucking idiot; I follow them because they work. Also, that pink tea in the break room slaps…”
Neyo: “The wha- *_YOU MOTHERFU-“_* (shoots Faie in the dick)
7:37 This is the kind of clone that appears in nightmares.
Loved this! More please :) would love a commanders compass of sorts displaying the morals on a line?
I appreciate the great videos you put out👏🏼👏🏼
personality speaking neyo is by far my favorite
Yeah, i think the Neyo that's been described in the vido is my spirit animal
I think The Clone Wars really missed an opportunity to explore both Faie and Neyo. Just imagine an episode where Rex comes to blows with Faie over the morality of following orders.
Oh, God; now I can’t stop imagining Rex & Faie arguing about something while Neyo is just sitting in the back with his space popcorn, watching the show & making inappropriate jokes.
@@zsu-23-4shilka2please continue on this ?
I would love to see a video with Commander jet, howzer and doom. If this hasn't been made already
I still crave to watch some of the clone commanders get offed at some point during the next season(s) of the Bad Batch, especially Bacara and Cody.
Idk why you'd want Cody to die, but Bacara would be interesting, he'd 100% go down fighting even unarmed and having to fist fight Wrecker
Hey geetsly just wanted to ask if you know anything about the fates of clone commanders Jet and Stone?
We honestly need to know more about Commander Neyo. Would love to see him in action
Man this is so awesome to here
In the words of Ben swolo “MOOORRRREEE!!!”
Keep this series going!
*thumbnail*
Captain Rex hanging out with his brothers for lunch.
Read on Wookiepedia that Rex is the most like Jango Fett. The writers hinted at it with Rex's use of dual blasters.
This is a great serries! More please.
Rex could’ve been a Jedi holy crap
Our mans back wit more good content 👑🔥
More of the same please, really enjoying these.
I hope you do Fordo eventually, along with Alpha and Able.
Wish these were explored deeper somewhere
Great video, I really enjoyed it. One thing I would like to say is, that Rex's morality is fairly warped if you think too hard about it. Although what you said is true, the 501st was committing some quite dishonourable, and at points out right cruel war crimes. Yes, the Jedi's use of war crimes is a bit of a meme now, but Rex kills an unarmed Kerkoidian commander during the Battle of Christophsis, most likely in cold blood, as Whorm Loathsom had been captured by Kenobi already. Also, Torrent Company kills a lot of the unarmed droid crew during missions, including surrendering ones, which leads me to believe that Rex doesn't really consider droids as near sentient at all.
Well they aren’t sentient
It’s a droid
If it actually had a choice it wouldn’t surrender if given a weapon
As they aren’t programmed to fight hand to hand
And also there is no point in taking them prisoner as they know nothing and will reveal nothing If they do know something
And it is a detriment to ignore the unarmed ones as they will most likely pick up a weapon and start blasting
@@luigimrlgaming9484 Droids are sentient, it is a definitive fact in Legends and in Canon, and no idiotic theories can prove otherwise.
@@tk-6967 then judging by how the B1s get treated in the clone wars they would’ve already risen up and answered the question
They aren’t alive but they do have personality matrixes idk why you think they are
Quote a source
@@luigimrlgaming9484 They have inhibitors as well. It is a legal requirement for droids
@@tk-6967 yeah their called restraining bolts
But the real inhibitor is who programmed them
You see any B1s have restraining bolts?
If they were sentient then they would take to their self preservation more seriously
And general grievous would be already dead
Neyo is a badass who had his second in command get the same face tattoos as him so it's harder to recognize him.
Excellent. Moar!
Han gets killed by Kylo Ren-
Neyo: He should have shot first!
Chewbacca: Graaaaaawaaaaaaahhhrrr!
Faie was a evil glitch in a Star Wars video game his blindness to follow orders is just damming to me.
I would love to hear more about Clone Commanders that were like Rex and more independent, like Wolffee. Or a Commander who should have gotten more screen time, like Doom. Or just another dick Commander so we can explain why they suck, like Fox or Vill.
Fox wasn‘t a dick, but ok. People are still sore bc he eliminated Fives, who was deemed a traitor…
@@Gojo1911 Oh Fox's a dick alright. he's the kinda guy who's your friend until his superiors say otherwise, & he'd sooner shoot you if that's his orders than to even bother thinking about asking his superiors questions. he's basically Bacara, but just much friendlier & far less severe... come to think of it, that makes him something like Cody, just minus the psychological trauma accumulating in later years leading up to depression.
I dint see neyo cracking jokes at all. I can definitely see him saying something along the lines of "everyone dies get over it." During a funeral though
Keep it coming man
You should talk about clones other than commanders next, such as fives, echo, Gregor, etc.
Do more clone commanders pls
Neyo will always be my favorite clone trooper
*sees Commander Faie* SIMP! WE HAVE A SIMP HERE!
Any info on Foxx and Thorne would be hella dope. The Guard get such a bad rap but I swear when I was younger I saw them do hella bad ass stuff in comics but I can’t find any proof as if I have been mandela’d
Well there was also the Star Wars Clone Wars cartoon, the one which was before this clone wars. There was this really cool arc trooper in it called Fordo. Maybe you mean him? There was also another clone during the assault on Coruscant, who destroyed a bunch of droids.
these thumbnails are brilliant
I agree
I would love to see more
That phase 1 Neyo is cursed
Commander salvo from dark times would be interesting too
Dont forger faie litterly killed his own men during order 66 , if it meant vos was dead his fellow clones were just collateral damage to him , Faie n krell “you and i are not so different “