About 16 years ago I learnt this piece, and I feel that I felt it very similarly as you do. It's hard to find someone who plays it as you do. It's a piece that's very easy to start sounding 'mechanical' (for a lack of a better word). This is the closest I've found it to be played as I perceived it and how I believe it should be played. Very beautiful piece. Great job!
Thank you for putting the sheet music up top! You helped me realize i made a mistake at the 31st measure. I played 2 c#'s on the first beat instead of an e and a c#
Curious question, is this the original composition? I learned this song from sheet music that is slightly different. For example, at 2:33, the beginning of bar 39 on your sheet music calls for an E sharp and C sharp, but an E and C sharp are played instead. The version I learned calls for 2 C sharps at the beginning of the run. This is the first song I've learned to play all the way through (I don't like learning boring songs,) so I'm curious how we know if the compositions that we find are true to the originals or not.
This is a very beautiful piece! I'm currently learning this and I'll be playing this on a performance in a month. I hope I'm able to finish learning it by then, but this video is really helping me with playing it in a better way ❤
Oh! This is played so very well. I am truly inspired to push on in my practice in the hope that one day, I may achieve a level of playing somewhere near this. Thank you so very much for this gift.
@@rebeccatabaranza5457 they're referring to a certain chord that is supposed to be a f# minor chord but it looks to be an a major chord just in this edition
a little to slow but works and youve got the tempo but sometimes you take to much time on pauses plus let your left hand ring out more and then it'll be perfect but overall nice playing!
The swaying motion of the left hand is hauntingly beautiful.
Thank you so much!!
Oh thank you so much….just what I needed. I’m trying to get back at piano in my 80’s😁. Now I will slow down. Rosie🌹
Have fun!❤😊
Keep practicing! Have fun
About 16 years ago I learnt this piece, and I feel that I felt it very similarly as you do. It's hard to find someone who plays it as you do. It's a piece that's very easy to start sounding 'mechanical' (for a lack of a better word). This is the closest I've found it to be played as I perceived it and how I believe it should be played. Very beautiful piece. Great job!
Bottom note in right hand on the down beat of mm 39 should be a C#, not an E. The music here has a typo, I think.
Yes that’s true I’m learning this piece right now and the music proves you right
Very well played - its often played far too fast and doesn't really work - this is excellent!
Thanks!
Thanks ! I'm glad you appreciate my talent
Just the kind of interpretation I was looking for, thank you very much!
Glad you liked it! Thanks for watching!
Stunning performed. Absolut beautiful
Thanks ! I love reading comments like this on my videos.
Thank you so much for this, I was having trouble playing it and realized my mistakes after just watching a few seconds.
You're very welcome!
Beautifully done. I cannot play it this well. And for all the critics, try video taping a piece perfectly yourself. I have. Not so easy. Thrrtttt
Hauntingly beautiful. So delicate yet powerful
Thanks for listening!
what a beautiful piece
Thanks for watching!
Thank you for putting the sheet music up top! You helped me realize i made a mistake at the 31st measure. I played 2 c#'s on the first beat instead of an e and a c#
Glad to help. Keep practicing!
I've learned it like this too - and I checked my music sheet and it's two c# there, I guess there are different ways to play it
@@fancyfence yes! I looked back at my sheet music as well and it had the same thing. There's probably just different versions
Curious question, is this the original composition? I learned this song from sheet music that is slightly different. For example, at 2:33, the beginning of bar 39 on your sheet music calls for an E sharp and C sharp, but an E and C sharp are played instead. The version I learned calls for 2 C sharps at the beginning of the run. This is the first song I've learned to play all the way through (I don't like learning boring songs,) so I'm curious how we know if the compositions that we find are true to the originals or not.
All of our submissions are the original versions of the pieces, thanks for watching
@@RoadToVirtuosity the version in the video is wrong in several places
I just finished Tarantella and Fur Elise and now I’m playing Avalanche and This song! 🎶 😊
This is a very beautiful piece! I'm currently learning this and I'll be playing this on a performance in a month. I hope I'm able to finish learning it by then, but this video is really helping me with playing it in a better way ❤
You can get it, keep practicing!! One measure at a time
Great playing
Oh! This is played so very well. I am truly inspired to push on in my practice in the hope that one day, I may achieve a level of playing somewhere near this. Thank you so very much for this gift.
Thank's!
I very like this song that I hear every day
Stunning performance, I love it!
Thank you!
Very well played! This is a beautiful piece!
Thanks!
thanks glad you liked it! Subscribe so you don't miss more videos
Very beautiful. Thank you!
Thank's!
thanks glad you liked it! Subscribe so you don't miss more videos
thank you for your help !!
Beautiful!
Thank's!
Thanks for the beautiful performance. In measures 45 & 49, please check whether the chord should be an F sharp minor instead of the A major?
Thanks! Yes, you are right
I can confirm this, as I'm currently learning it.
A major? It's f minor.
@@rebeccatabaranza5457 they're referring to a certain chord that is supposed to be a f# minor chord but it looks to be an a major chord just in this edition
This is so good!
Thanks, I enjoy reading your comments!
I would love to dance with this music, but I don't really know how to count it... any help please ?
You can count it like that "2 beats separated in 3, every bar has two waltz rythmes in it"
Por que en el minuto 3:00 tocas C natural en vez de C#? en la mano derecha cuando haces el acorde
Where did you notice that? In both hands c sharp
Beautiful soulful piece expressing joys and sadness of life..... Song without words, thank you.
Beautiful voicing :D
Thank's!
Excellent
Thank's!
Nebylo by vhodné klavír před nahráváním naladit 🤔
amazing! but would u do a tutorial for this song? trying to learn it for my rectial.:(
No time to record a tutorial, but you can try decrease the velocity of the video and see it by parts, keep practicing you can get it.
@@RoadToVirtuosity thank you for the advice but I have the recital next week and I'm a very slow piano learner. Thank you nevertheless
Great jon❤❤
Thank you!
Beautiful! But... Isn't it a little different from the Urtext edition?
Sorry, maybe I have the wrong version. At 1:40 I thought there was a C with another C intead of a C whith an E.
Please confirm whether in measure 39, right hand should start with C# octave?
thanks glad you liked it! art doesn't have to be identical sometimes you can improvise ;)
a little to slow but works and youve got the tempo but sometimes you take to much time on pauses plus let your left hand ring out more and then it'll be perfect but overall nice playing!
Thanks for the tips!
on 2:48 i'm pretty sure it's a c#
Which measure do you refer?
very well played...however your B from the right hand is out of tune...
Came here after Once musical 🥰
Thanks for watching!
멘델스죤 무언가
Tune your piano bro
Thanks for pointing that out
Not lining up the downbeat melody with the bass is an inappropriate interpretation.
Just say you don't like it maybe? Its not unequivocal.
Ouch. Get your piano tuned.
That's right friend