Jim Green One Year Review - The Best Cheap Work Boots Ever

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 янв 2025
  • ХоббиХобби

Комментарии •

  • @CarlMurawski
    @CarlMurawski  Год назад +5

    BUY HERE: bit.ly/3pJrAHc

  • @JimGreenFootwearOfficial
    @JimGreenFootwearOfficial 4 года назад +378

    The pioneer of Jim Green USA and here we are a year later with our own depot and a second bulk order currently in production to head that way.
    Thanks again for the kind words and we feel you’ve hit the nail on the head with the reference to the watch collection. Hopefully we will continue to be added to many boot collections and become a go to option for most.
    All the best Carl

    • @splashpit
      @splashpit 4 года назад +3

      Are they true to size ?
      Say if I wear an 9 RM Williams will an 9 Jim Green be the same ?
      Cheers

    • @nickmagma7745
      @nickmagma7745 4 года назад +7

      Come to Belgium!

    • @tlove9125
      @tlove9125 4 года назад +4

      Will the waterproof Monster boot be coming to America?

    • @domenkavas1325
      @domenkavas1325 4 года назад +3

      Hi, will you sell those in Europe?

    • @brgulker
      @brgulker 4 года назад +3

      Just checked the website - do you have any sizing advice? I’d like to purchase.

  • @moosa9850
    @moosa9850 2 года назад +79

    Still wearing mine, 20 years later, just resoled it 4 years ago. Brilliant products.

    • @felixmarihessenauer3158
      @felixmarihessenauer3158 2 года назад +14

      20 years!? Holy cow then I will definetely get these

    • @reamus9102
      @reamus9102 Год назад +1

      Wow!

    • @inderjit3125
      @inderjit3125 2 месяца назад

      Fake

    • @moosa9850
      @moosa9850 2 месяца назад +1

      @@inderjit3125 I am actually South African so I know what I'm talking about

  • @IdeaStudioBKK
    @IdeaStudioBKK 4 года назад +105

    Long term reviews really do allow us as the audience to get a better idea of what a product can do and how it will hold up. Thanks

    • @KR-jg7gc
      @KR-jg7gc 3 года назад +2

      I've seen heavy men have jim greens for well over 5 years.
      I'm a very light guy, 60kg ..
      I'm talking about men in the 80-90 kg range.

    • @taargustaargus3139
      @taargustaargus3139 2 года назад +1

      @@KR-jg7gc 80-90 kg is heavy? That's like average weight for 6' 1 guy, give or take. (then again im saying this as an American.... so..... we are 'larger' than most)

    • @kosta2177
      @kosta2177 2 года назад

      I’m 6.1 and I’m 100 kilos (220 pounds) lol And there are no fat at all. So I don’t know, should I consider myself a heavy 😅

  • @heinrichstoltz1356
    @heinrichstoltz1356 3 года назад +34

    Jim Green’s are legendary in Southern Africa. Game Rangers, Farmers (Ranchers), Miners and Forestry Workers love them. Know of plenty Jim Green’s that have been resoled multiple times. The Razorback Steelcap is my default work boot.

  • @wiggieellenberger9198
    @wiggieellenberger9198 2 года назад +6

    I live in South Africa and have been wearing Jim Green Razorback boots for over 20 years!
    I wear nothing else.
    Awesome boots!

  • @gnarl12
    @gnarl12 2 года назад +16

    I got some and love them. Not so expensive that you mind beating them uo but not so cheap that they're flimsy or poor quality. I replaced their insert with a red wing leather and foam one and they gave me a bit more cushion while still keeping my foot on leather. The boots have enough room that you can also pop in a hiking boot insole like a Super feet or similar. Great boots with nice thick leather.

    • @JimGreenFootwearOfficial
      @JimGreenFootwearOfficial 2 года назад +2

      Thanks for the support, much appreciated. Keep us up to date on how they go

    • @shannonandsheila1403
      @shannonandsheila1403 Год назад +2

      @JimGreenFootwearOfficial Please dont do like our American boot companies and cheap out and sell out to justin or some other garbage company. Redwing and Chippewa used to be some solid boots, but they sold out and now won't last a walk around the block.

  • @IGmeanwell
    @IGmeanwell 3 года назад +16

    Coming into this summer I needed a nee pair of works boots. I tried everything from Carhartts (the most comfortable out of the box but questionable quality), Timberland Pros and Keens. I would be using them mostly for landscaping my storage properties primarily. However after watching your video as well as Rose Anvil’s; I decided to try the razorbacks. The quality stood out immediately, on first try they felt sturdy (I have bad ankles and knees this is a must), but pliable. After mulling it over, then replacing the leather insole with my own they felt amazing but needed a little breaking in. Well after three weeks they are really getting almost as comfortable as my Blundstones but much more confident in stability. I could see myself going back packing in these, or using these as my hiking boots when photographing elopements (get quite a few of those in the ADK). They remind me of Danner Mountain Lites but I don’t mine beating the crap out of these. Tomorrow I plan on cleaning the dirt off my Jim Greens and giving it a nice coat of conditioner. Can’t wait for these to really break in.

  • @kennethwilson2343
    @kennethwilson2343 Год назад +2

    Wore these for close on twenty years. When I loved to NZ from SA forgot to buy a pair before I left. Friends are bringing a pair of Rangers over to me this year. Can't wait. Gareth, my wife said to tell Peter that Marcia from Fligtt Centre says hello..

    • @JimGreenFootwearOfficial
      @JimGreenFootwearOfficial Год назад

      This is awesome to read and see🙌 my early days at the factory i did liaise with Marcia on many occasions. Looking forward to you trying out the African Ranger soon.
      Thanks for the comment and reaching out

  • @jimoconnor7491
    @jimoconnor7491 Год назад +3

    Thanks for the review, I just ordered a pair for $90 on Amazon (Black Friday deal). I couldn't pass them up!

  • @edrichlouw1790
    @edrichlouw1790 Год назад +2

    I just did a bush hike with these in the Vredefort area SA. Best boots I’ve ever owned.

  • @franko3227
    @franko3227 4 года назад +6

    Got a pr for Christmas and they were very comfortable right out of the box. Look very well made and should hold up well.

  • @tonyquats9146
    @tonyquats9146 4 года назад +25

    I got myself a pair after your first video of them. I highly value your two cents. I purchased Naked & Famous and enjoy rockin my Diesel Grant Stones as well. Keep it up

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад

      Well that's very flattering man!!! I hope I haven't let you down, but it sounds like you've made some very good purchases.

  • @ocean911
    @ocean911 Год назад +1

    I don't mind the thin insole of my vellies. That just gives me an option to choose many (probably in the hundreds) of after market insoles I can buy and get the right amount of support I want. I can easily replace when they wear out. Jim Green offers the solid base/foundation to build ur grail boot and customize it to your tastes.

  • @drzaius844
    @drzaius844 4 года назад +4

    “That ski-boot feel” LOLOL I know exactly what you mean. I have some double-sole Carminas (80184) that are like that. I know they’ll last forever, and I could kick through a wall, but it’s got that unbending feel just like a ski boot without the ski. Great video, thanks man!

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад

      YES! C-Clunk, C-Clunk! Thats what it feels like. I know you cant have everything- Hard core build quality AND flexibility, but holy hell they can be hard to wear at first.

  • @davidrivera8634
    @davidrivera8634 4 года назад +3

    I'm going to Oregon for Thanksgiving which is being turned into a Camping Thanksgiving. We're gonna be hiking quite a bit around Crater Lake. I'm not a fan of synthetic material hiking boots. Don't get me wrong, they do their job very well, but I would use it for the trip and they would be stored (got hunting boots already), cause wouldn't need them much in the flat lands and concrete jungle of Houston, TX. Saw your video on cheap boots, along with about 10 other videos on a binge, and said "hey, I can break them in at work, wear them in Oregon, and put them in my work boot rotation after I get back...if not I'll give them away around xmas. Well, ordered the brown ones on Amazon, arrived in 2 days, it's been about 1.5 months with them and they are like a glove. Stiff 1st two days, after a week I could wear them all day, after a month they are as comfortable as my LEGENDARY Redwing Irish Setter 83606 which needed no break in at all. You should really check out those Irish Setters, they have a non-aluminum toe too.
    I did change out the insole for an Easyfeet insole on amazon. After day 1 I used Saphir Renovateur leather conditioner to speed up the break in. Even though I love the laces, I did change them out for DELELE Wave Shape Non Slip Heavy Duty Laces in dark green and coffee. The green laces are eye catching, but slick and the boot's lace rings don't offer friction, so if you like to tie your boots snug or tight forget about it. The Delele laces are slightly wavy...or bumpy, and they give you just enough slip resistance to give you that snug fit, plus the color is a perfect fit with that bit of green in honor of the original laces.
    I'm a 9.5EE to 10EE in most boots. The 9.5D in these are just right, even after changing the insole. NOTE: The included insole is so thin that just about any other insole you swap it for will reduce the amount of room in the shoe...but there is a lot of room.
    These are going to sever me well for years to come I believe. I'm even looking at some of their other boot styles by Jim Green, we'll see. I am going to have to waterproof these for my trip, so some oil, snowseal, or something. Followed by a water based waterproofer. Any recomendations?
    Thanks for introducing me to these boots Carl. Keep up the good work...review some laces, no-tie laces like lock laces are cool, as well as Xpand laces. Not 100% slip on with 6" or higher boots, but I can literally take my boot's on and off in about 8 seconds, and they never untie.

  • @TheMediatorOfChaos
    @TheMediatorOfChaos 3 года назад +2

    Got my pair on right now. I love the way Timberlands look, but they just don’t last anymore. The price is right like you said, I’m definitely converted now.

  • @GMC2001
    @GMC2001 2 года назад +2

    I bought some Vellies on your recommendation. Thanks Carl. Amazing. I love them

  • @yousefgeorge3060
    @yousefgeorge3060 4 года назад +5

    Long term review ARE SO MUCH BETTER THAN 1 day ones!!!

  • @Sturnburn772
    @Sturnburn772 Год назад +1

    Good analogy with the timex. I think a G shock is also an appropriate comparison in a collection of expensive watches

  • @colesymons2660
    @colesymons2660 4 года назад +2

    I got the Silverado ones from that video but I’ve moved onto a pair of builder pros after seeing your videos never been happier

    • @gregoriojuarez1579
      @gregoriojuarez1579 4 года назад

      Were those boots worth it?

    • @colesymons2660
      @colesymons2660 4 года назад

      @@gregoriojuarez1579 both pairs have easily payed for themselves in the comfort and stability, the nicks is by far better for obvious reasons

  • @chrishelm4371
    @chrishelm4371 4 года назад +6

    I've added a few Jim Green boots to my daily wear assortment. They are great for the price, from the Vellies to the Stockman and the Razorback I'm a fan.

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад

      Totally agreed! I love brands like this, and even though they're not marquee brands they deliver a solid value for sure.

    • @Jason-zw2dg
      @Jason-zw2dg 4 года назад

      Do you use them for work or fashion?

    • @chrishelm4682
      @chrishelm4682 4 года назад +1

      @@Jason-zw2dg work around the property and lots of walking. I have a tree farm.

  • @tucobakunin8250
    @tucobakunin8250 8 месяцев назад

    I love my Razorbacks. I wear them daily for work (I'm a mostly rural Amazon delivery driver). Super duper comfortable for all-day wear. Even running stairs on the occasions I get stuck doing apartments all day. And, they look so damn good ( my opinion ) I find myself wearing them when not at work even over "nicer" boots. They are some of my favorite boots, period.

  • @nationalheritagenaturepark6651
    @nationalheritagenaturepark6651 2 года назад +1

    I work, trek, and go to town in only one pair of boots, my Razorback by Jim Green. Living in the cooler high Drakensberg, whilst managing a farm, my feet experience every conceivable range of conditions you can think of. Spring with new veld grass wet with recent rain, rushing streams, stables, towing stuck cars from the deep mud on the un-serviced district road, ( When will this service ever happen?), and workshop with oil and grease. High summer, maintaining roads and hiking trails, mowing, gardening, general concrete construction, forestry, and fencing, you name it, it is probably on my list of tasks. Autumn, burning firebreaks and preparing the property for winter, with its cold frost and occasional snow, dry veld fighting runaway fires. then in the same boots after a lick and polish, I go to town once in a while, (one has to, unfortunately) I am happy to walk around, proud to be a countryman in my Razorbacks. The only times I don't wear my Razorbacks are when I shower, and in bed, for obvious reasons, I think. All in all, I wear them because I don't have to think about them. They just become a natural part of me and who I am.
    Now here is the thing. Right from the go, I will in the future replace the inner sole with a custom sole. My feet and rough lifestyle wear out the factory-fitted fiber sole very quickly. and secondly, I will wear gumboots on the district road in the future. Give these Razorbacks by Jim Green of South Africa a go. I have never been disappointed with them. And another thing, perhaps I will buy two pairs next time round, one for all the hard work, and the other as my "going out" pair, but I will wear my work pair when I have to meet my bank manager. It will show him I'm still strong and hard-working.

    • @chrisdelaplante5515
      @chrisdelaplante5515 5 месяцев назад

      No, when you go to meet your bank manager, don't wear the work pair but the going out, he will thing that now you don't need to do hard work anymore coz you are now the manager who give orders to others.

  • @SugarMapleForge
    @SugarMapleForge 4 года назад +6

    I'm about to put a pair of razorbacks through some serious abuse! Everything from landscaping, lawn care, snow removal, even concrete work. Curious to see how they hold up! Excited as well.

    • @mwirth187
      @mwirth187 3 года назад +2

      Post a video :)

    • @DanielTAGyota
      @DanielTAGyota Год назад +1

      How have they held up after 2 years past from this comment?

    • @SugarMapleForge
      @SugarMapleForge Год назад +1

      @@DanielTAGyota I got a good year out of them. That's with everyday wear. I now have alico summits that I wear everyday and I like them better but they are getting hard to find.

    • @DanielTAGyota
      @DanielTAGyota Год назад

      @@SugarMapleForge 👍

  • @luisg6404
    @luisg6404 3 года назад +1

    I bought them love. them. I got their vellies and town and country too. all excellent shoes. thanks for the excellent review!!

  • @cowboycody8094
    @cowboycody8094 4 года назад +5

    Those boots have patinaded nicely and I like the pull tab on the back.

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад +2

      I do too, and its not useless like so many other boots.

  • @snake_eyes_garage
    @snake_eyes_garage 4 года назад +4

    I find these boots to be almost too wide for me, and I have a wide foot. I agree on the insole. I will be getting inserts to take up the slack as they feel a half size too big. These will be for thick socks only. Which means here in Texas only a winter boot.

    • @gnarl12
      @gnarl12 2 года назад

      A hiking boot insole and thinner socks and you're set. For thicker socks a thin red wing leather insole is what you need

  • @robertlarsen6516
    @robertlarsen6516 4 года назад +5

    Great review on a lesser known boot. Although more a hiker than a true work boot, add an after market insole and BAM! Two birds, one stone.
    And a big thanks to whatever international trade rules allow this product to be priced so well...

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад +6

      Absolutely! Another thing that I like about Jim Green is that they pay 100% of the wage rate to their employees. In a country where a lot of companies gouge their workers, Jim Green seems to be doing it right.

    • @michaelgilmore3567
      @michaelgilmore3567 4 года назад +2

      South African workers have much better worker rights than than either China or the US ......

  • @jasesteel1
    @jasesteel1 Год назад

    Wearing a weekender right now for that very reason you mentioned!

  • @edf2953
    @edf2953 4 года назад +10

    I had no idea that one could buy a good quality work boot for $139. Thanks for enlightening me. I must have missed your original review on the Jim Green boot. Glad I caught this video. Very informative and interesting video Carl. Another fine production! Keep up the good work and i hope that all is well with you and the family...Ed.

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад

      Glad to help! These are really a stellar boot for their price. If you had asked me what a good work boot under $150 was a year ago I'm not sure I could give a good answer, but these are fantastic.

    • @kosta2177
      @kosta2177 2 года назад

      @@CarlMurawski what about RedBack boots? They are Australian made, so they can keep their prices lower, while being extremely comfortable

    • @adamdover3868
      @adamdover3868 2 месяца назад

      @@kosta2177i know this is a really late comment but ive been rocking them for the last year and a half just currently looking for a new pair cause i’ve worn them out. great boots man not one stitching has fallen out and i’ve put them through hell. they actually fixed my plantar fasciitis to

    • @kosta2177
      @kosta2177 2 месяца назад

      @@adamdover3868 thanks for the feedback!

  • @jbasauri6129
    @jbasauri6129 4 года назад +4

    Hey Carl, after watching this video I decided to go ahead and get a pair, it was not easy but my boots are on the way to Cancun, Mexico. Let's see if they can stand the hard wear and tropical weather. Cheers!

  • @koryleach9660
    @koryleach9660 6 месяцев назад

    I’m a footwear guy. My oldest boy is working as a window cleaner for the summer while attending school for electrical engineering. He needed a pair of boots for hiking and work. I pressured him into a pair of these with the wedge sole. He loves them.
    I have a pair of African Rangers buffalo. While they are nowhere near as good as some of my nicer boots/ shoes they are a tremendous value for the money.

  • @CrimsunChin
    @CrimsunChin Год назад +2

    Thank you for the great info about these boots! I see that Jim green offers customizable boots. If you had to customize these razorbacks to make them even better work boots, what would you do differently? Or would you choose a different platform?

  • @thepug991
    @thepug991 2 года назад +1

    Video was the catalyst to me buying these

  • @wrbwn
    @wrbwn 4 года назад +2

    Great review as usual. I might take a look at these.

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад

      Much appreciated! They’re well worth your time

  • @umbertosmith7014
    @umbertosmith7014 6 месяцев назад

    Jim Green Last is fabulous...comfortable no toe pinch, lighter and more comfortable than Nicks...A better boot for hiking. Taking wildland firefighting boots is great if you need that tool...
    For most of us green horns or civilians we can get along with a boot like Jim Green. The dark lugged sole seems every bit as rigid and tough as a vibram.
    Its a nice boot and on the feet comfy.

  • @chinatownboy7482
    @chinatownboy7482 2 месяца назад +1

    I live in The City. Most of my wear is urban.
    I have the regular, and the steel toe. Both are heavy. 2 layers of leather are thick and stiff. Your break in will be harsh. Once broken in to your feet, these are very comfortable.
    The lug soles are rigid. In my use, walking on city sidewalks, they have good traction. Offroad, dirt, sand, mud, earth..... I haven't slipped yet going to the beach, park, or hikes. I have felt surefooted on bar room floors, and marble lobbies.
    The leather is locally sourced from a South African tannery. I know nothing about how to grade leather. It cleans up well with saddle soap. This leather seems to really like mink oil. The John Lincoln Company makes a shoe polish which seems to rub right in and effectively creates a barrier against moisture. The leather is thick enough to withstand a lot of abuse. Regular cleaning and oiling will prevent it from drying and cracking.
    The footbed inserts are nothing special. They are leather, on top of foam, which is nicer than just foam. It doesn't appear to be anything that is orthopedic, nor built for support. You may want to use your own.
    Jim Green describes the insole lasting board and midsole as "poly woven fibreboard". I have no complaints with the way it feels under the foot or the durability. The fibreboard does flex and break in easier. They should last as long as the lifetime of the shoe.
    The soles are simply glued to the midsole. Unless you are in an environment with harsh chemical solvents, the glue should hold until a cobbler peels the sole off. As seen in the Jim Green videos, resoles are easily accomplished by peeling off the old sole, and gluing on a new sole. Jim Green sells replacement soles on their website. No resole service is offered in The USA.
    When you wear through the upper layers of leather, or the stitching holding the vamp to the midsole breaks, you should buy another pair of boots. It would be cheaper than to find an artisan cobbler to recraft the shoe.

  • @MaineMan2023
    @MaineMan2023 2 месяца назад

    Just got my Stockmsn chesleas! Amazing!

  • @aconsideredmoment
    @aconsideredmoment 2 года назад

    Thanks. Appreciate the long term review.

  • @barryrahn5957
    @barryrahn5957 4 года назад +3

    Hey Carl, I got a pair of Razorbacks this past July after seeing your original video. I've worn them a number of times and have stopped wearing them because the toe box is too low. I think if they heightened the toe box it's be killer. Widthwise the toe box is wide enough and the construction is good. I commented on another video about them and the Jim Green rep e mailed me with a few suggestions about my concerns. Maybe I just got an odd man out, although it took three pairs of return until I got a pair that felt ok. But I'm not ready to call it quits yet. Maybe I'll try a pair of Monsters - it looks like they have a higher toe box.Or maybe I'll fly down to SA and get a pair custom made a the factory. More important, I liked your update video. Why not make an end of the line video when they finally do wear out.

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад +2

      That's a really cool idea! End of the line for these may take some time, but I'll get there.
      I'm intrigued by your toe box situation. It's definitely a little lower than typical but I didn't find them uncomfortable at all. I'm glad the good folks over there got you hooked up though!

    • @barryrahn5957
      @barryrahn5957 4 года назад

      @@CarlMurawski I have a fairly high arch, so I think my instep is higher than usual. Even before I bought 'em I thought the toe box looked a little low. But I'm m to see JG starting to make inroads in the US market. Happy Monday.

  • @splashpit
    @splashpit 4 года назад +3

    Carl as you own so many brand boots could you do a video with audience help compiling a chart that helps with boot size across brands , ordering online is so hit and miss as some brands you have to order larger or smaller .
    RM Williams 9
    Redback 9 1/2
    Yuketen 10
    Corcoran 9
    Last & Loom 9 1/2
    Belmore 9 1/2
    LL Bean 9
    Cheers

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад

      Thats an interesting idea, but I think it may be hard to figure out exactly what the sizes are. Maybe like you suggested, I can create a shared document where people can add their experience? I can certainly add to this and then make a video on the findings.

  • @TheProHunting
    @TheProHunting 3 года назад +4

    Really and trully a great boot!

  • @Saw_Squatch
    @Saw_Squatch 4 года назад +1

    I'd love to be able to try these my only problem is that I need a safety toe for work and I would kind of like waterproof if I could get it maybe one day I'll be able to get Jim Green's that fit my job site requirements

    • @maddacheeb808
      @maddacheeb808 4 года назад +1

      If you look at the international site for Jim Green they have steel toes available.

  • @ruthy8ruthy
    @ruthy8ruthy 4 года назад +2

    I think this is one of your best videos Carl. It's useful that you mentioned the width of the boot. Something that surprisingly often gets left out.
    I wanted to ask you, do your feet sweat more in these than in boots made with better materials?

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад +1

      Thank you!
      Sizing is something I dont mention often because I feel that my experience might be misleading to some since everyones feet are different. I didnt notice any issues with sweat, and in fact these breathe pretty well - much better than my synthetic "waterproof" boots. Plus they're used in their homeland of South Africa where it gets much hotter than New England I'd bet.

  • @carlshapiro9208
    @carlshapiro9208 4 года назад +9

    They also do custom boot production; maybe you could do a limited Carl Murawski edition with the couple design changes you'd like to make and take pre orders? Might be a fun project for you and us viewers.

    • @barryrahn5957
      @barryrahn5957 2 года назад

      That would be cool. I got a pair of Rose anvil/ Nick's Collab boots and it'd be neat to have pair of Carl Murawski/ Jim Green boots. Carl? JG? Whaddya think?

  • @MIIIB
    @MIIIB 4 года назад +4

    They look and are very affordable thanks for the commerce import benefits they get.
    I will like to try them but honestly a boot without leather midsole is not for me ...
    I'm so comfort with the good quality than I can't let basic 877 RW aside for Joe Green.
    If they only apply more quality, definitely I will buy them.

    • @robertphillips93
      @robertphillips93 4 года назад

      Instead of a replacement insole, I use a pair of Birkenstock arches designed for boots with a little heel height. The seamless upper is something I haven't enjoyed on a boot since my Pivettas from way back when.

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад

      Fair enough!

  • @satan500
    @satan500 2 года назад

    Have you looked at all the great boots coming out of Italy? DIOTTO for woods. FRACAP for street or mountains. Also CENTURIAN ARMY BOOTS made in Italy?

  • @petersilecchio4417
    @petersilecchio4417 2 года назад +1

    Great Year Review.

  • @Jay-rd6fe
    @Jay-rd6fe 3 года назад +3

    would be nice to see jim green vs steel blue since steel blues are great australian made boots for working and hella cheap aswell

    • @Beardman56
      @Beardman56 Год назад

      Lol might be cheap in Australia but hella expensive in the US. Somehow more expensive than the redbacks that I normally buy

    • @Jay-rd6fe
      @Jay-rd6fe Год назад

      @@Beardman56 red backs arent really safe for heavy work tho their just thin phoam sole with a plastic toe

    • @Beardman56
      @Beardman56 Год назад

      @@Jay-rd6fe they're designed for different things. I stand in a factory all day and they're the best for that also they're steel toed

  • @ElectroG33k
    @ElectroG33k 2 года назад

    Hey so I just got a pair and it looks like they did update them with a yellow leather insole now. It's sewn in.

  • @shotbytim9624
    @shotbytim9624 2 года назад +1

    I've been looking at Jim Green boots but noticed they only come in one width. You've mentioned before that you have a wide foot, as do I. (I also have fallen arches) Since you rave about the comfort of the Jim Greens, is it safe to assume that they have a roomy toebox?

  • @BROVERLANDER
    @BROVERLANDER 2 года назад +1

    “A jack of all trades is a master of none, but oftentimes better than a master of one.”

  • @soopooritsrich1966
    @soopooritsrich1966 3 месяца назад

    Hello everyone, I’m new to the boot scene and just recently bought a pair of Razorbacks. Love the boots but the low toe box is snug at the top of the toes, will this go away in time as I break them in?

  • @adrienm3687
    @adrienm3687 4 года назад +5

    Just picked up a pair directly from them for $250 CAD after shipping, fees, extra leather insoles, and some leather product.
    Excited to get them. More than the quality..I love the look..nothing else really looks like them.
    I’m sure the price will start to go up once they find better NA distribution.

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад +3

      I agree, they look like nothing else really. I hope they keep their prices in the same ballpark though, since they're really such a great entry level option.

    • @adrienm3687
      @adrienm3687 4 года назад

      @@CarlMurawski I’m excited to use them for camping and fishing next summer, and dog walks here in Canada when there is not a foot of snow on the ground.
      Nice to have a pair of beater boots. You compared it to the Weekender, but I think they will serve more as a g-shock. I am more into watches than boots, so excuse the nerdiness.

  • @jairocatalan4974
    @jairocatalan4974 4 года назад +2

    I’m about to be 3 months in with these boots working mon-fri and they are starting to feel flimsy. Maybe I will upload a video on how mine have worn

    • @dubester1982
      @dubester1982 3 года назад

      Could be. Boots definitely break down faster worn daily, they never really dry out, and basically start to rot Do you use a boot dryer at all? Rotating in another pair would make a huge difference

    • @jairocatalan4974
      @jairocatalan4974 3 года назад

      @@dubester1982 no I don’t have a boot dryer haha I use them everyday mon-fri and I don’t take extra care of them at all.

    • @JimGreenFootwearOfficial
      @JimGreenFootwearOfficial 3 года назад

      Now +-6 months in of what sounds like some harsh wear and testing, how they doing?

    • @jairocatalan4974
      @jairocatalan4974 3 года назад +1

      @@JimGreenFootwearOfficial I bought another pair cause I got a hole in the toe

    • @JimGreenFootwearOfficial
      @JimGreenFootwearOfficial 3 года назад

      @@jairocatalan4974 A bit of love, care and rest for the uppers they should last a lot longer. Thanks for the support of the second pair, much appreciated and we always an email away if you need any assistance.

  • @derPaul76
    @derPaul76 3 месяца назад

    So I will buy a pair - allways believe the electrician ;-) thanks for the review

  • @picnicsinspace198
    @picnicsinspace198 2 года назад

    I just bought the chelsea Jim Green boots for work because I wanted a slip on...But I'm wondering if I f'd up. Should I have gotten the Razorback? I feel like I can just put my insoles in them, and work, but maybe I'm wrong. I guess I could have them re-soled and have cristy soles and a leather midsole maybe put on.

  • @dshanley7
    @dshanley7 4 года назад +3

    Between this review and Rose Anvil cutting them in half I might need to get a pair now

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад

      Totally worth it man! There are a couple color options now too.

  • @piche090391
    @piche090391 2 года назад

    Has anybody used the JG boots for inside work only? E.g a warehouse, where it’s mostly concrete or tile flooring?

  • @ernestschutte6065
    @ernestschutte6065 Год назад

    Im a farmer and have a pair of Jim Greens and they can take abuse from drowning them in water and mud and into the cow pens to planters and fertiliser they can take it. I just put in memory foam insoles

  • @president6645
    @president6645 Год назад

    I Think the Jim Green bushcat boot is a better work boot. Exactly the same as a razorback but lower cut around the ankle for more flexible movement. Especially for those bending down. Razorback is more of a hiker.

  • @johnwen8810
    @johnwen8810 4 года назад

    Good review! Very informative

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад

      Glad it was helpful! I think the extended reviews are especially useful with items like these.

  • @JD-tl7ld
    @JD-tl7ld 4 года назад +5

    I consider most all insoles as being cheap throw away items. They are mostly garbage that get replaced before the boot is even worn.

  • @jovanyortega4200
    @jovanyortega4200 3 года назад

    Hi Carl, great channel, you should try ALTBERG BOOTS, they make military boots and have others styles.

  • @taylanlowe120
    @taylanlowe120 Год назад

    What brands can you compare to? Carolinas,wolverines..?

  • @quinnlane7257
    @quinnlane7257 2 месяца назад

    How much room is there in the toe box ? Height wise?

  • @pat557
    @pat557 3 года назад +1

    I heard the new shipments will have leather midsole at same price. Any truth to this?

    • @NitroMonkey91
      @NitroMonkey91 3 года назад +2

      I literally just got a pair today off amazon. Its true. They do come with the leather insole.

  • @brianc9374
    @brianc9374 3 года назад

    Been trying to break in my razorback. Very comfortable, except I get rubbing on the outside of my right heel.

  • @NombreHombre
    @NombreHombre 4 года назад +5

    Hi! I know that you normally cover workwear, but do you have any style advice for a male teacher? I can't find anything definitive, and most of my coworkers dress like they don't care. I've also been looking for some decent leather bags and planners, but haven't found anything great. I've also been wondering about what your advice would be on boots. I have to stand on hard ground for most of the day, and I have to wear footwear with a decent heel, since I was injured during my time in the military.
    All the best,
    Matt

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад +4

      Hi Matt, first off thank you for your service both in the military and in teaching as well. When it comes to boots on hard surfaces, I'm expecting that you're standing on tile which is on concrete slab floors. In my experience a wedge sole is best for these applications since they tend to spread out the pressure across your entire foot. Luckily there are a lot of options in this category, including a collaboration I'll be doing with Nicks (top secret).
      Please feel free to email me at: info@carlmurawski.com if you'd like to discuss further, I'd be happy to help.

    • @tatwood93
      @tatwood93 3 года назад

      Wedge sole chukka boot with goodyear welt

  • @infamous_z
    @infamous_z 3 года назад +1

    Would these be good for doing yard work, for example cutting grass or moving large logs?

  • @raffthy5709
    @raffthy5709 4 года назад +1

    Hi Carl, what can I do to protect leather boots such as these if my work involves a lot of puddles of nasty water mixed with cement and concrete sludge and mud. I do have a pair of PVC Wellingtons which I use when the puddles are extra deep and when I have to stand in them for a while, but I just do not enjoy wearing PVC Wellingtons all day for driving and stuff. So I'm thinking of getting something like the razorbacks but I worry that the cement might destroy the leather. I currently wear a slip on which is made of fake leather and is non welted. The waterproofness has already been compromised from being wet with cement and dried many many times. Will something like obenhaufs do the trick? Thanks

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад +2

      Obenaufs LP is great, but you may be best serves with something a bit more hardcore like Sno Seal. LP is really good, but I feel like its best in roughout since it gets under the nap of the fibers. Of course, it also depends on how often you reapply. Sno Seal is pretty tough stuff and I've used it on leather gloves with pretty good success.

    • @raffthy5709
      @raffthy5709 4 года назад

      @@CarlMurawski Thank you for your suggestion. Do you think that leather can take that kind of abuse (with proper cleaning and maintenance)? What would you choose if you were in my situation? Just found out that my fake leather slip ons already has a tear in the uppers and it hasn't even been a year yet.

  • @Leon-xi9cu
    @Leon-xi9cu 2 года назад

    Looking at some boots for casual wear and another pair for work. Really looking to replace my Irish Setter Marshall soft toe cowboy boots. I work in the fast food industry and am up on my feet up from 8 to sometimes 10 hours a day, would these be the right boot for that or would it be worth the money going for the Thorogood Moctoe or even the White's Perry Moctoe?

  • @barryrahn5957
    @barryrahn5957 3 года назад

    Is that Midnight Oil playing in the closing moments of this video?

  • @bradmondrush4501
    @bradmondrush4501 3 года назад

    Anyone know anything about the stockman boots by them I'm looking at getting some but there are like 0 reviews of them out there.

  • @gatriemacleinn1976
    @gatriemacleinn1976 4 года назад +1

    CARL! please help. i need a GOOD pair of STEEL TOE boots for a factory job. i only have $150 to spend. do you have any recommendations?

    • @Anomaly188
      @Anomaly188 4 года назад +1

      I'm not Carl, but here's a suggestion: www.amazon.com/KEEN-Utility-Milwaukee-6-Inch-Steel/dp/B007KA7D6W?ref_=ast_sto_dp&th=1&psc=1

  • @KR-jg7gc
    @KR-jg7gc 3 года назад

    I'm shopping for boots that will last forever.. lol with my weight they will.
    I'm South African.
    So the issue is comfort? This is clearly visiting even by looking at these vs Caterpillars (which are currently on sale but still 3 - 6 hundred rand more than JG).
    If this is the case I think I should go for them and get inners with 🤔, which they sell as well. Along with oil, and jts still cheaper than Caterpillars

  • @barryrahn5957
    @barryrahn5957 3 года назад

    The music at the end - is it Midnight Oil?

  • @darktimbercustomknives6248
    @darktimbercustomknives6248 7 месяцев назад

    Do these run true to size??

  • @aight365
    @aight365 3 года назад +1

    Glad i found your channel! subbed! Question: i seriously wonder how these Jim Green compare to Thursday - Commander. is it worth spending more for Thursday Commander?

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  3 года назад

      I think it depends how you'll wear them. The Jim Greens are probably tougher, but I'd bet they're somewhat bulky for casual wear.

  • @Sondre_Friis_Nyberg
    @Sondre_Friis_Nyberg 4 года назад

    When the Spring arrives again, I'm going to buy my first pair of non-winter boots. I'm in between the RW Iron Ranger and the Belstaff MARSHALL. I haven't really found many reviews on the Belstaff's, so I was wondering if you (or anyone of your viewers) have any experience with them. They look really good, but the 'Designer' mark on the website makes me a bit sceptical. Any help would be appreciated.
    Love the videos!

  • @tockingwatches2377
    @tockingwatches2377 4 года назад

    Funny that you mentioned watch collecting. I’ve been considering a pair of Nick’s Boots but after hearing some of your thoughts, I’m wondering if sticking with my Zamberlans is best. I live in the North Carolina mountains where winters are harsh (heavy winds, lots of snow) and summers moderate (mid 70s most of the time). Perhaps a west coast boot isn’t the right choice.

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад +1

      Yeah, that really depends. The Nicks/Whites boots use thick leather, but leather isnt a great insulator. I've found past the socks I wear with those boots, they're not great in the cold. Zamberlain looks like a really interesting company, I need to check them out.

    • @tockingwatches2377
      @tockingwatches2377 4 года назад

      @@CarlMurawski The Zamberlans started as a search for a robust cold weather work boot that provided good ankle stability while on slopes. I’ve had them for two seasons and have been impressed overall. It took a month or two until they were completely broken in.

  • @seantaylor4683
    @seantaylor4683 3 года назад

    Did you find that they run bigger, smaller, or true to size?

  • @devonpeters9458
    @devonpeters9458 3 года назад

    Two things I’m curious on:
    Your thoughts on the lighter brown color vs dark brown?
    These as a hiking book and not just a work boot?
    Thanks!

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  3 года назад +1

      I have both, and I like the darker brown personally. It's just a little more subdued and doesnt look like a Timberland. As to your next question, you CAN hike in them but I wouldnt buy them specifically for that purpose. There isnt much side traction, and I think the Jim Green Monster is more suited to that role.

    • @devonpeters9458
      @devonpeters9458 3 года назад +1

      @@CarlMurawski thank you for the quick feedback. That makes sense and I appreciate it (as I do your channel)! I’ll take a look at the Monster.

  • @aaronlouviere5797
    @aaronlouviere5797 4 года назад

    In the "Cheap but Great Work boots" video you also mentioned Silverado Boots.
    Anybody out there try those yet? They look pretty nice.

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад +1

      Yes indeed! Those are okay... but the one thing that bothers me is how far apart the eyelets are. They kind of put pressure on your foot in a weird way, and if they come unlaced they just open right up. I keep mine in my car in case I need a change of footwear.

    • @aaronlouviere5797
      @aaronlouviere5797 4 года назад

      @@CarlMurawski thanks for the heads-up!

  • @lrlevy
    @lrlevy 4 года назад +2

    A great review. Nothing theoretical, all practical.

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад

      Thank you! In theory these will last me a good many more years.... oops.

  • @bricks312100
    @bricks312100 3 года назад +4

    Now your 139 boots are 189 with the 50 dollar insoles

    • @JimGreenFootwearOfficial
      @JimGreenFootwearOfficial 2 года назад +6

      Thanks for getting in touch and interest in Jim Green Footwear, below clears up your concerns on the price jump. World wide products have just got more expensive too but we continue to offer the best boot in the market for the price.
      Below is a few factors:
      - We have had 2 wage increases since our first batch of boots arrived in the US
      - The US Dollar has then depreciated by 20% to the South African Rand making exports more expensive
      - The cost of shipping has tripled
      - We have had raw material increases and also now using better quality leather more suitable for wet/snow conditions.
      - We have also added in a new and improved insert/footbed into our boots (although still old stock in the US with the older option)
      - and finally when we launched we had our boots priced at a special price, sort of a early bird special
      All this being said if you can show us a boot that is like like more affordable than us we will match that price

    • @flabiger
      @flabiger Год назад +2

      ​@@JimGreenFootwearOfficialThank you for the explanation, most companies would have been opaque about their reasoning.

  • @conductorcammon
    @conductorcammon 2 года назад +3

    They are $200 now. Still a great boot though.

  • @SauceE.428
    @SauceE.428 4 года назад

    How do you compare them to the Silverado's??

  • @mromo98
    @mromo98 3 года назад

    How log did these take to break in?

  • @cooter-in6kf
    @cooter-in6kf 4 года назад

    Did you like the Silverado boot and how was sizing on it

  • @golfmc78
    @golfmc78 4 года назад

    Would these be a good everyday boot?

  • @indianastarkjones1535
    @indianastarkjones1535 Год назад

    Just bought my first pair of Jim Green Tan Razorback boots and their version of the Chukka boots Chocolate.

    • @Artemis-v8i
      @Artemis-v8i Год назад

      How is it

    • @indianastarkjones1535
      @indianastarkjones1535 Год назад

      @@Artemis-v8i had to return both pairs. Too tight. I don't blame Jim Green. My foot shape is awkward.Size 14 in some brands,in others 14.5 and 15 . My feet are extremely flat and my left foot has been broken 4 times and healed in bad I'm sure if I had normal feet or if Jim Green makes a size 15 wide. They'd fit just fine. There 14 isn't the American sized. I think we have bigger feet than any other country.

  • @jonesdaevilone
    @jonesdaevilone Год назад

    So glad I'm not the only one scuffing the heck out of the front of my boots 😅

    • @jonesdaevilone
      @jonesdaevilone 3 месяца назад

      Mine only lasted a year and they were covered in deep cuts and holes and the sole started coming off on one. Considering the punishment I gave them at work they are brilliant

  • @WayneBruce26
    @WayneBruce26 Год назад

    Is that a sexy Casio Duro on your wrist?

  • @ShiftersAndLifters
    @ShiftersAndLifters 3 года назад +1

    That’s a bad coffee mug. Anyone know where to find one?

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  3 года назад +1

      I think I left a link in the description bro!

    • @ShiftersAndLifters
      @ShiftersAndLifters 3 года назад

      @@CarlMurawski thanks i realized it in a later video. New watcher love the videos!

  • @barrymantelli8011
    @barrymantelli8011 2 года назад +1

    2yrs on, and my Jim Green boots get more comfortable with each wear.

  • @poekz228
    @poekz228 4 года назад

    Have you heard of the new brand QLTY work boots?

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  4 года назад

      I haven't! Do they look any good?

    • @Anomaly188
      @Anomaly188 4 года назад

      @@CarlMurawski Do you like Moc Toes? Cause that's what they make. I think all Moc Toes look ugly.

  • @stephennaumann8922
    @stephennaumann8922 4 года назад +9

    Rose anvil has a great video deconstructing these boots

  • @kevinhudsonsmith2323
    @kevinhudsonsmith2323 2 года назад

    I’ve checked their website and Amazon both sites list these boots at $189.00 not $139.00

    • @CarlMurawski
      @CarlMurawski  2 года назад +1

      Yes, their prices have increased since this video.

    • @kevinhudsonsmith2323
      @kevinhudsonsmith2323 2 года назад

      I am still planning on purchasing a pair. I like the look and believe they are worth the cost.