Can France still call itself the land of Liberté? | Focus on Europe
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 сен 2023
- France is imposing tight border controls on neighboring Italy to make them turn away refugees. For a long time, the EU has been working toward opening its internal borders, but the refugee crisis has made that goal more difficult to achieve.
Subscribe: ruclips.net/user/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#France #EU #Migration
France is « the country of liberty ». Liberté, égalité, fraternité applies to its citizens on it soil, not to the whole 9 billion humans on earth,
It’s ridiculous that some random African dude can say I want to go to France,or I want to go to Italy. Like the whole of Europe is just free real estate.
Not so long ago many random French dudes went to half of Africa “as if it was free real estate”, lived there, stole there, killed there, destroyed the environment there, insisted that half of Africa was actually part of France, forced everyone to learn French and the French culture, and brought back many people. These are the consequences. Unfortunately, we can’t hide away from our past. Our European past towards Africa was awful. And all actions have consequences.
@@karelkieslich6772 if you want to live the rest of your life in guilt and repatriations for the faults of some other generation that’s your choice. The rest of us will not sit by and see our countries get destroyed.
Africa had white slaves, remember that woke one. Yep, I second: if you want to live the rest of your life in guilt and repatriations for the faults of some other generation that’s your choice. The rest of us will not sit by and see our countries get destroyed.
@@karelkieslich6772
Crazy, right? like when Europeans said ' I want to go to India, Burma, Algeria, Senegal, etc etc and take land/resource for ourselves. Like the whole world was just free real estate.
As a European, I do the same. Like I want to travel everywhere and want to work from example Spain, Portugal, Sweden...
So, basically the French have to take in all these persons to be considered free, thereby making the lives of their citizens difficult?
More like to make sure that the pension system won’t collapse in the too near future.
Not to say it's perfectly innocent, far from that, but maybe just like Sweden, France is getting wary of all the trouble associated with immigration. It cannot host the entire misery of the world, no country can do.
Even more when this phenomenon is being weaponized. Search Belarus / Poland issue on that matter
Exactly, enough is enough. It takes many years to integrate foreigners no matter how they arrive. Like other countries, they don't want to be over run by outsiders. Setting absolute limits is okay.
Then help Italy defend its waters instead, why work against each other when we could control the Mediterranean together?
Exactly. Sweden have understood that the limit is reached, even though it took way too long. It seems like France and Germany is starting to do this aswell. Hopefully Italy is next.
@@ad_astra468
Yes, this is a huge part of the problem. The least the rest of Europe can do is to stop trying to guilt Italy into not doing what needs to be done. But we should obviously help more than this, even though Italy needs to take the main responsibility in guarding *their* borders.
Borderless EU was always going to be a problem, but was meant for EU citizens to move freely within Europe, NOT for the rest of the world. Borders need to be reinforced everywhere imo.
How do you think it would be possible to check people crossing the borders at every point for example between France and Germany etc?? Take a look at the map and think how much money you would need to block every road accross the border and what it would do to trade inside the EU if trucks would need to stop at every border to wait to be checked. It's not going to happen and only the outer borders of EU should be secured.
Makes no sense. If there are no borders for EU nationals there can’t be for non-EU. How would someone know if it is EU or non EU?!? You either abolish borders or check everybody
It's not so much a matter of checking everyone who passes through, but there should be stricter punishments for those who are caught illegally within a nations borders. @@cyberfunk3793
@@erictonyes Like fines, prison or deportation? They can't pay any fines anyway, housing them in prison is expensive and so is deporting them. Kind of hard to solve after they are in EU already, they arent stopping just because of harsher penalties.
@@user-ll2je4kc4fEconomy wasn't what it's today hundreds of years ago, now countries are much dependent on trade and those border controls were expensive then also. Again simply look at the map and see how many places you would need to block and man to have internal border controls in Europe.
Why do DW you always show immigration in a positive light? How about you made a documentary about the victims of immigration?
Because it is unless you make it negative like France exells at
I won’t be surprised if DW is owned by Blackrock
Because ..... of certain events in Germany, the home of DW, from 1933 to 1945.
german conscience
@@onlyahuman493yea keep it up in Germany and the AFD will be the most popular party and not just the second like it is now.
That old volunteer is crazy to say "all immigrants have the RIGHT to come to Europe"
Africa is 1.3 BILLION people, can we welcome them all or do we have to say at some point STOP, ENOUGH!?!
The EXTREME right-wing parties will rule all of Europe in the next 5-10 years because people will be fed up with all this madness that is happening especially in Western Europe!
As soon as a right wing government is in the European parliament, Europe will just become more left-wing as popular right wing policies are implemented removing reasons to support the right wing.
Nah, they will do exactly what they would be elected to do
Yep. Until France stops interfering with Africa, expect this to continue. You want this to stop, treat the cancerous root cause that is France and its colonialist policies.
@@asekuvena No it will even out EU politics, as at the moment the simple left wing parties of the EU actually share more in common with extremist left wing groups than just simple liberals, and the rise of the same caliber groups rising on the right wing will result in the left wing groups having to change their goals to more centrist values to gain support.
Every generation for ages now is too liberal for their parents and way, way too conservative for their kids.
There is no real balance 🚫⚖, the centre has just been getting more and more liberal.
@@entireglxy4338
If E.U. keeps this up. no land in here will be free. :)
this gives you joy ? you have a good idea ? no ? then be quite. halfassed observations is part of the problem. people like you. try again champ. you are welcome
Yet another hit piece by DW, distorting France just because France has chosen to adopt a common sense approach to a long lasting problem that has affected France for many decades....
Well said
Lol
True
Frances problems for decades stems from their african colonies!
Yeah, this time they even have a hippy saying its "their right" to come, wtf
There is no such thing as a "right"
to invade other people's property.
@@user-bo8ry9gu8z Then YOU shouldn't be allowed to have any property.
Come take mine and watch what happens
Same goes when “westerners” leave their countries to invade countries in Africa, Asia or the Middle East. You reap what you sow.
@@user-bo8ry9gu8zAnd you're free to cry about it.
@@user-bo8ry9gu8z Let me move to your house then.
So what was the right when our ancestors took europe? (I'm german)
No. Because Islamists wanting to import their restrictive medieval cultures in France 🇫🇷
This entire argument is pointless. From the birth of the idea, it was never Liberté for all, it was always Liberté for the French citizens.
nope , unfortunately the roots of the french republic is UNIVERSALISM
When people can't admit they're being invaded lmao
Yes, of course they come heavily armed. Has your country ever been attacked? Guess you're from the USA 🇺🇸
Its shocking how blind white people are to the irony here, especially in France
- Haiti and their enslaved ancestors who they forced to pay reparations for no longer being their slaves
- what Congo where they helped murder Patrice Lumumba and installed Sese Seko who bankrupted the country with mass corruption
- How about Francafrique leaders who are wildly corrupt authoritarians who did France's bidding and impoverished their nation but were kept in power by doing Frances bidding
- the 1.5 Million Algerians who they killed
Yet, Europeans think they stand for liberty and freedom and fight for democracy. You are being propagandized and lied to
they are been invaded for what they invade in the past.
this shouldn’t happen, say goodby to Europe cause it won’t stop.
I wonder why
By whom
Which countries
Are they linked to France terrible history or eu or nato history ?
If yes ...share the ill gotten gains and they won't come
@@mkodyChallengesYOu do you really want an explanation or is just a sarcastic question?
Tourists ❓ In Italy they say they want to go to France In France they say they want to go to the UK or Germany.
About time France closed its borders
About time France pissed off.
🤣@@presidenteden6498
Filippo “bleeding heart” Lombardo has the exact mentality which leads to this crisis. Compassion is an irrational approach to problem-solving. This situation needs cold hard mathematical logic.
It is a human problem. I love math but human peoblems often require comapssion and the ability to put yourself in somebody elses shoes. Then do the math
Cold hard full metal jackets work better
James Hetfield said it best... "Just like the curse, just like the stray... you feed it once and now it stays."
Cold hard xenophobia
@@dazza2350 kinda like how the Ukrainians are xenophobic against Russians or how Palestinians are xenophobic against Israeli settlers.
Poverty is not a sufficient reason to applying for asylium!!!
they are not poor , they are LAZY
😂😂 whoever drafted the title of the documentary has a good sense of humor.
Haha, I thought the same thing, but I'm not so sure that was there intention. Either way, they'll be made fully aware soon enough.
Europe should reevaluate their policies toward Africa to minimise migration
Yes, but only if you mean individual European nations and not the EU as a whole.
As Italian prime minister said France is still engaging in neocolonialism in its former colonies and gets surprised when most of the youth there migrate to France in search of a better life.
It really should stop with the moral 😇 fanaticism wars and try and embrace peace 🕊☮ for once.
@@asekuvenathe only way to achieve that is to chip everyone and increase control. Considering the way tech is going it can be a plausible outcome.
But in the meantime if the west doesn't want immigrants then they need to do more to help the countries of origins.
Have you tried the much less expensive method of just not picking fights? 🤨
Like, you know you don't have to kill people right?
@
I regret It's not "Fortress Europe". The EU is way too lenient on illegal immigration. A good start would be to restrict access to social rights and allowances in all EU countries to EU citizens only. There would be less candidates to cross the Mediterranean or the Greek border. And applicants to political asylum shoud apply outside our EU borders.
Deliberate policy on the part of the WEF. The EU is just it's puppet.
the problem is THE LEGAL IMMIGRATION , since it's the way the EU use to solve illegal immigration
@@REMPLACEMENT-TV There not trying to "solve" the immigration problem. That's the problem. It's all a big misdirection to allow the WEF to destroy Europes standard of living, as part of a wider global strategy to keep the masses enslaved. It's such a shame that Europeans have no idea what their nations have succumb too.
4:08 “France should be ashamed “
No man, it’s your government that should be ashamed.
What he meant was France should be ashamed for have enough common sense to take in some of these burdens that we want to offloaded on them 😂
Noone has the right to come to my home without invitation.
Noone has the right to migrate to a country without permission.
What do you do with persons breaking into your house? What do you do to stop people from breaking into your house?
Every action has equal and opposite reactions. It's the bad karma of the previous generation of French people . French people looted and exploited Africa , now france is crying 😂.
The only thing I dont get about this VERY complex issue is why the traffickers (and their accounts and assets) are not being targeted? This smells like someone in the side of Europe is being protected.
They also use social media and basically have full fledged commercials. This easily and justified is my can be shut down. After all tens of thousands die yearly worldwide being smuggled.
Bingo. In fact, a LOT of people inside of Europe are being protected.
This problem needs a permanent solution because, without one, it is a problem without an ending.
If not, then year-on-year things are going to get worse - much, much worse.
It's a little late in the day, but perhaps it is time to adopt Japan's approach to migration.
There are fewer illegal immigrants in Japan than in Europe and the US, but the government and businesses have taken in large numbers of cheap laborers in recent years, and crimes by them have increased significantly.
The problem won't be resolved until Western countries stop working together to plunder Africa. It will happen eventually, but if Europe waits too long, it will be the immigrant majority in Europe that will end the plundering and at that point it is too late.
Japan is loosening it’s migratory politics because in a few decades there won’t be enough Japanese people to make it a viable economy. Get informed.
Countries are national communities for their citizens/nationals. With some exceptions most people are born in a country that becomes ‘theirs’ abstractly at least. Most can swap countries legally if they try in their lifetimes but the effort/reward for doing so varies dramatically. The member of national communities should have direct input on how/when people can join and then it should be done in a safe manner.
Here we have a strange twilight world where big business and it’s interest uses countries legally and the concept of borders for profit and taxation benefit much of the time, but disregards it for the rest of the time. Housing is a chief interest related to this-lower salaries in construction, higher sales prices at time of sale or higher rental fees.
So sad that this weird and xenophobic argument wasn't used during colonization times or in immigration waves, for example of Germans, Japanese, Italians, Polishes, Russians, Spaniards to South America...
This is largely because the colonizers built up the places that they colonized.
@@gomes2151
@@gomes2151you’ve not put in the time or effort to understand these topics. You’re too judgmental and oriented in terms of us vs. them thinking.
Often nations are divided between Nation states. Like Papua New Guinea and Indonesia (West Papua).
Then stop sitting on the high horse about human rights whenever we deal with non white countries
@@gomes2151ironically, your comment implies mass migration is bad and a threat to the native Europeans. Germans, Italians and the likes migrated to the "New World", ie land that was conquered at the expense of the native populations of South America. Why would contemporary Europeans want to end up like them?
France just let's them go to England
You mean France no longer a Free For All?
What a pity Europe isnt surrounded by hundreds of miles of sea like Australia or New Zealand
People need to stay in there own country and fight for their lands!
Get out of their country. Change the law on foreign policy
Italy should secure their borders. Italians making a problem for EU
This report seems to be pro illegal immigration, and critical of the idea of protecting borders, framing it in the guise of double standards in France. Who benefits from this absolutely naive and deluded stance?
If three people can eat at one table, five or six can too, but not a million.
For who want open borders…your home no need fences too.
Europeans voted for this, welcome to your future..
Do know what vote it was and when. I'm curious.
nobody voted for that
Push them out onto the Channel as fast as possible. Help them get on the dinghies. Collect millions from the UK gov.
Troll. "This channel doesn't have any content".
Perhaps DW are overly dramatising going between Italy and France.
buy a hiking map,
Don't think any of the routes through the mountains are particularly secret.
those 2 old ladies saying its "inhuman" "no one wants them" well no one called the middle east and africa from europe and said HEY EVERYBODY COME HERE! they obviously have no idea what's going on in for example sweden today, and of course france etc. we need to close our borders and only let EU citizens travel and be able to travel safely.
does anybody tell the story of the people who stay? Who remains? Who carries on?
No country can. Germany also.
If it's a fortress it's really a bad one since it has already been overrun
Thanks for spending the time to create and share this content awareness
Problem is people from africa... or middle east
Great man the contractor.Thank you!!!!
Voltaire " Men are Born everywhere but in CHAIN ! "
France has enough problems with outsiders and their descendants, so they are doing what any sane people would do and keep the riffraffs out. The rest of Europe should follow their example instead of complaining how unfair it for them to do what is good for their country and society
@@presidenteden6498
Go to UN website and look up how have been planning to go flood Europe with over 100 millions non Europeans. They aren’t even bother hiding it.
Look at all the young men!!
Aanndd russian bots started dumping their datatrash into this forum...
If African leaders knew what they were doing...nobody will leave Africa to any other country,,,,.....sad
Hey Germany? Instead of trying to give us a lesson, what about you open your border?
The EU / EC should build desalinization plants like the ones in southern Spain in North Africa and the Horn of Africa . . . . think.
France is done anyway 😂😂😂😂😂
"Liberté" is a recurrent and time-honoured motif of an alternative France. In all other respects repression and intolerance are as French as tarte aux pommes.
I dont understand how people believe countries have unlimited housing, land, welfare, medical, education and jobs.. why dont they fight to make their countries great.
They will keep coming until the whole of Africa empties out to Europe. Now deal with it since Germany took in 3 million and opened the door, the message reached back home.
Interesting that none of the volunteers were immigrants. From among the recent immigrants that is - not the guy who 'identified' as an immigrant because he had a mother...
God bles you guys for all your help❤❤❤
that old man is delusional
Are you joking? You can’t even choose your clothes in land of liberté, what kind of freedom you’re talking about
“The Strange Death of Europe” by Douglas Murray
I don’t think anybody has the right to go to another country and think I have the right to be here if that so what the point to be a citizen or having a country ..
That's pretty rich considering what most EU countries did to Africa.
@@Dstinctthis is the modern day, things that happened centuries ago aren’t relevant, it is not acceptable now
Why should anyone care to enter a country legally anymore?
Yall are gonna wish you had the 2nd amendment soon, mark my words
Maybe you guys should wake up and ask yourself why only Europe, the top half of North America and Australia are required to be diverse 🤨
This problem can not be solved inside the EU alone and only marginaly at its borders. The only viable solution is to help stabalize the nations they come from and by that them not having reasons anymore to leave their nations.
European tax payers have no obligation to help no one except their own citizens, remember that most African countries have ceased to be colonies since 60's during all this time that they're free living standards have fallen...no matter what help Europe has send, why a European has to pay for an African while his own father and mother were unaware for a birth control in a first place???
Yes, but only en Francais.
No wonder Patton wanted to go into Russia!!!
first of all this is not an european country anymore and that concept is generally associated with european type civilization
If you take in 10k you send the message to 10m that the path is clear.
France is part of the African Union now thanks to Liberté 🤣🤣🤣🤣
goes around comes around
Only question is when it will stop. Ever?
Now with libya flood
Morocco earthquaqe and so on
Why is this report so ducking naive and only shows a very one side of the story DW news? Appalling piece of "journalism".
10:10 Well educated fleeing is a bad sign.
europe chose your citizens first or lose your culture and people.
DW eine Abkürzung für Durchwahl nach US
zum Glück, hoffentlich, Rock n roll und icecream. wie heisst diese geile russische BAnd ?? genau.....+chirp+chirp
Aber nein, es ist die Abkürzung für Dachgeschädigte Weichspühler
The French fought hard and bloodily to create a zone of liberty for their people in their country. Nobody helped and supported. France has no obligation to provide liberty for any number of random individuals from around the world.
Those people need to fight for the same, for themselves, and their people, in their countries
When I was Hungry you gave me to eat, now enter into the home of my Father.
Liberté, Egalité, AFRICANITÉ 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
France does what 😮
At least France has cheaper energy
Nobody in Paris speaks French anymore.
yeap show my channel to the whole world
The proficiency in native languages in the amurika has been dwindling as well. Funny how nobody complains for example about nobody speaking arabic in Dubai, where the natives represent a tiny minority of the total population.
Most of these immigrants come from French speaking Africa and only speak French, that’s why they choose France. Language is not the issue. Clash of culture (which is way more than just speaking French) and values are…
You are lying that would mean they only teach french in a nation that france left 70 years ago. You should feel deep personal shame and self hatred for lying, but your soulless nature will allow this vast transgression to roll of your lizard skin @@sans_hw187
Definitely not
Liberte egalite fraternite…tranquilite!!??
FFS When is Europe going to wake up? Its actually likely far far too late to save Europe.
Muamar Gaddafi warn Europe this would happen if Lybia would be destroyed. Did they and my American government listen? No. They wanted to extracate Lybia's wealth at all costs.
the EU plan has always been to bring millions of african , it's written on their official program
Earlier tension was for expansion of territories and soon it will be for 'Not my territory'.
- Shut down Human rights NGOs for few months and the operations in African countries. Except critical health, put every one on a ship by Force to transport back to other side.
-Open NGOs and close the borders then with Forces deployed. Start job, service generation activity in Africa.
- Work with the NGOs for proper allocation and distribution of individuals back in organised way.
*Be a Napoleon to unite Africa while solving problem at home. But, today they can only unite Pride march*
If the West could give up on trying to force democracy down African nations' throats, we wouldn't be in this mess in the first place.
Doing that is not in the West's nature. 🤷
Glad to see the people in this comment section are awake. Pray to the Lord that the governments' of Europe will listen.
the EU project is actually to invade europe with africans
The comments are not even worth looking below
First they came for
Wow
Kind people, God bless them with enough healthy and prosperous life.
Some say that France is the land of colonialists but I dont agree.
This one from Sudan with so good English why don't go to USA, Australia, Canada?
We don't want those human refuse either.
Stop it. USA can't solve all your problems.
Australia doesn't allow this insanity. Strict border control . Off shore processing , etc.
Of course, it can. How else do you make a lie stand as truth? Simple, keep repeating it eleven times.
Smugglers also use social media and basically have full fledged commercials. This easily and justified is my can be shut down. Tens of thousands die yearly worldwide being smuggled.
I don't understand,why Europe iz not setting up manufacturing factories in some African countries,where they have influence....
resource iz available there,cheap labours....it will benefit African countries & benefit europe economically....then they will not migrate to any country....
simple solution
because African countries are corrupt, so if Europe give them money to build something they won't do anything and the money will disappear
1. They are too busy promoting humanitarianism and democracy through extremely aggressive cold ❄🥶 wars there.
2. Europe can't even handle developing its own infrastructure these days with its laziness problem.
No one in their right mind would invest that sort of money in Africa. For instance, there was a big plan to build a massive solar farm in NA, but no one would put up the money for it. Africa is pretty much one failed or failing state after another, with the few that are being well run the exception.
@asekuvena That is such rubbish; most of Europe has fantastic infrastructure, world-leading in most cases. Name a region that does better
Only the ones previous generations built.
This generation is only in power through national nepotism. It is utterly useless at doing anything meaningful itself.
@@knightsnight5929
france has set free from africa, because sinfighting in "helping" west style of democracy forget colonials and solidarity
Regardless of what French citizens think, don't make decisions based on short-term interests. you are still a great power
For white french people it is...
europeans entered africa illegally. now it's payback time.
the problem is not europe but the big problem is european that's true