What Makes a Race? with Dr. Nathaniel Jeanson | Traced: Episode 4
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 апр 2022
- In this fourth part of the series "DNA's Big Surprise," we learn about the origin of "races." Ken Ham discusses what we can discover from human DNA and how it relates to race in the new book "Traced" with the author, Dr. Nathaniel Jeanson.
It’s groundbreaking scientific research that rewrites everything you thought you knew about “race,” ethnicity, and even human history. And it’s only possible because the researcher, Harvard-trained Dr. Jeanson, starts with the history and the timeline God has given us in his Word.
See the full playlist of Traced episodes here: • Traced: DNA's Big Surp...
Learn more:
answersingenesis.org/store/pr...
Visit Answers.tv: All Answers in Genesis videos, livestreaming, and much more-all in one place.
Please help us continue to share the gospel around the world: AnswersinGenesis.org/give
This is the most important science of our day! bravo dr.jeanson,bravo!
At about the 24 minute mark, I started wondering whether it wouldn't be possible for two branches to merge back together, but then I realized that that's the beauty of specifically tracing the male genome. It can only ever come from 1 ancestral line, with no merges along the way whatsoever, and therefore hardly any contamination of the data for thousands of years. Such an exciting concept!
Wrong gender. The mitochondrial DNA is in the female line. And the whole Earth was populated by 3 sons without wives! Noah's grandchildren were left to drown!! Doesn't sound like a God who is Love.
@@douglaidlaw740 Sorry sir, you are wrong on both counts. It's the male line, because the Y chromosome can only come from a male, and therefore descends from a 100% paternal line, while the X chromosome is mixed.
Genesis 7:7
And Noah and his sons and his wife and his sons' wives with him went into the ark to escape the waters of the flood.
I love that you show how quickly the appearance of a "race" can change. Peet Monzingo is a RUclipsr with an excellent example of this. He's a 6-ft-something ginger with pale-skinned dwarves for parents. About a hundred years ago, one of his great great grandfathers was a KKK member. But his first American ancestor was an African princess(!!!) brought over on a slave galley. (I may have gotten some of this wrong, but that's about the long and short of it. Absolutely fascinating)
Some of the biggest lies of the modern age: that race is binary and gender is a spectrum...
The truth is that gender is binary and what we call 'race' is a spectrum of superficial differences. We place way too much emphasis on race!
من افضل العلماء الحمض النووي في العالم
بالمرصاد على أحفاد أبو لؤلؤ المجوسي وكيانيون الزردشت طهران أعداء البشرية في العالم
And IMO, the only Americans with a right to hyphenate are those with dual citizenship.
Answers In Genesis, I think that you need to make a playlist for all these videos with Dr. Jeanson.
They have made the playlist now. It's available on their channel right now.
I was introduced to genetics in 6th grade and have been hooked about it since then now age 67. This makes total sense. I'm ordering the book and will send my dna immediately. Haven't been happy wit Ancestory etc.
no. it doesnt make any sense. If it had made sense it would have been published in a scientific paper...
@@matswessling6600whether it’s published in a paper or not has nothing to do with it making sense.
@@HarryHafsak yes. it does. articles published in peer-reviewed scientific journals must follow some rules that makes them open to scrutiny. They are also controlled before being published. If other scientists find them lacking it can be withdrawn.
so yes: being published in a well known peer-revied scientific journal do ensure a certain level.
Thank you and thank God for these videos, Nathaniel Jeanson and Ken Ham.
There is no place in the Bible where we will ever find our Maker separating humanity by using the word 'race' to describe people. We find these words instead...'nations, tribes and tongues! Revelation 7:9-17. Apostle Paul was thought to be an Egyptian! Acts 21: 38
They know. They've written entire books on that. They use the word 'race' because everybody understands it. They know that we are one human race. Jeanson even said "so-called race" in his talk.
What a fascinating series! I watched the entire Traced series and plan to rewatch again until Jesus returns for His people. 🙏🏼
As a devout Christian I could never except the science that contradicted what I already knew to be true without evidence simply because it was in the Bible. Now Dr Jeanson has helped ease my anxiety about being wrong. Thanks Ken!
How wonderful our Creator has given us the answers through the gifting s you are sharing. Thank you!!
Can't say it enough -- we are all one race --
Human.
Amazing to think that the concept of "race" is much more fluid than what we once thought
That was really well done guys 👍
Wow so fascinating very informative and sooooo cool
It’s cool and frustrating at the same time because I just ordered the book but it’s back ordered to July 2022 which means I have to wait but also that many people are wanting to read it and that is good news!👍☺️
Awesome Video! Very informative
I just finished watching the whole first series from 2 years ago and I am now binging this one. My mind is blown. I was already of the Young Earth Theory, but this still changes how I see everyone.
It doesn't matter when son of Noah you come from. You still come from Noah and God wants us all to repent and come to him.
Oh but it does matter. We of true Ysrael did all the hard work so you could repent and be saved. Yet we were treated the worst as the part of the script Christians selectively claim is done away with predicted has happened.
I am reading his book now, l also read his cv and his PhD from Harvard very impressive.
Outstanding
How do we order a y chromosome dna test? What is the best company to get this test?
Awesome
Interesting 👍
Is r1a and r1b split, im sorry i dont know the right word, become a and b, is it Jacob and Esau, or ephraihm and manessah or doesnt it work like this??
Thats impressive research
Read your book. True gift . Thank you. I ordered two extra to give away.
This is all the best thing i have seen In a long time thankyou so much. I love Ken Ham now, I see his innocence as a man and how shocked he still is. He genuinely thaught he already knew white men are japeth and his glow to find he is R1b semetic is beautiful
The son could have all the shades. I wish I had all our families pictures. My Grandma could pass for white. My Grandfather was just a bit like the dad.
My Grandparents had 4 children male looked of “Jewish” origin with gray eyes, female looked Native American with brown eyes and mixed African American hair, female was light with black features and sandy brown hair with blue/gray eye, freckles and African American textured hair, last was male blonde hair and blue eyes with white skin. And yes, they’re all full blood brothers and sisters.
Greenlanders/Inuit from Greenland, Canada, Alaska and Siberia are originally from East Asia. We look completly like Asians, especially chinese. From the other of the world to another side of the side.
Just got my copy of TRACED today from AIG.
21:20 Many concepts require learning about both paternal and maternal lineages.
Is it possible to get the Y chromosome dna test from someone’s ashes?
I ask because it’s now occurred to me that my wife doesn’t have any living male relatives on her fathers side.
It’s also a tragedy to realize that his Y chromosome line has died off…he had a brother, who’s also dead, and both of them only had daughters
Depends on what race it is. 100m, 4x4 relay, 110m hurdles, marathon, etc..
What would you say about the many artifacts and archeological sites that are dating back 10-12k years ago?
Carbon dating is only accurate to 6000 years. The rest are typically suppositions based on how deep something is buried in soil. The problem with that approach is upheavals such as floods and earthquakes, the sinking and rising of land and water mass confuses the issues. Scientists look at a layered rock face and make declaration of "time" periods. I take a look at the same rock face and ask questions about the location and whether it was in an area where a crazy mixed up mass of living creatures remains would have settled out with different soil compositions in layers as the great flood waters dried up or receded leaving hundreds of feet of mud behind for later scientists to try to make sense of the chaos. What they don't tell you is that some of "science" consists of arbitrarily assigning a number or a state of being to a theoretical item they want to test and then test from that until they force their theory onto the evidence, rather than testing the evidence first and revising what they think when new evidence may contradict initial opinions created by less information. Science is a process of inquiry. Nothing more. Even math has unsolvable equations. What happens when you use one of those unsolvables to base your entire theory on which is then disproved? Double down, or say, wow we have better answers and they bring us back to traditional knowledge after all?
@@marywells9340Utter non sence.. Can you give any scientific proofs that carbon dating is limited to 6000 years?
@@ajishmathew007
I’d refer you to the same scientific research paper that states vaccines stop the spread and contracting Covid 19 😂
Tbh though, I’ve heard that claim before, read up on it, years ago but I’ll admit I don’t remember where I read it. So, I usually won’t bother bringing it up.
My point of bringing up Covid or even replying to you is I’d hope by now you’re smart enough to not just blindly believe what “science” claims to be fact.
I could have just turned it on you and asked what scientific research makes you believe carbon dating can date something 10 or 100 thousand years old? Cause some who desperately refuses to admit intelligent design, because that would require them to one day stand judgement for the things they have done in this life, both good and bad, told you?
Seems to me, these scientists are constantly trying to 1 up each other. Probably trying to secure funds.
This guy claims to find some bone or whatever claims it’s 10k years old. Next guys says oh hey I just found a bone 15k years old 😂 ah, carbon dating and science!!
No clue if you are younger or older than me, but the older I get the less I “believe” anything anyone says. Especially on something as important as this.
I mean, we really aren’t arguing about how old something is, we are talking about if what the Bible says it fact or not.
Which has much larger implications than what you do on Sundays, but what you will be doing for all eternity. Wouldn’t you agree we both should take that very serious? And probably not just go off what “scientists” tell us?
I’d recommend going to the source. Get yourself a KJV Bible and spend some time just reading it for yourself. And pray, pray, pray about it.
Eternity is forever. Why would anyone just trust what some scientists say?
Dr. Jeanson, I’m curious if your professors at Harvard University knew that you are a creationist during your doctorial studies? If so, did you ever feel that your doctorate was in jeopardy because of your beliefs. If not, did you feel it necessary to conceal your beliefs from them?
I've looked him up but couldn't find any such information on him.
@@markuse3472 Several sources show he's a creationists hack author
Hey Doc! recommend a testing company for me please.
What do you mean by Arab? Because the word Arab or a rav descend from the word hibraiquer Wich means ( vrahim means v father Ra him loved) a rav means Ra father
💖💕
Is Y-chromosome DNA the sthey the same as mitochondrial dna why? Is one the male lineage and the other by a female lineage?? Would you share a little on that please ? Thank you.
I hope this helps answer some of your questions! answersingenesis.org/genetics/supplemental-material-traced/
Thank you
The mitochondria of all human cells come from the mother line.
@@stephenschaubroeck6010 They are different. Y chromosome is passed from father to son. Females don't have a Y chromosome. Everyone has mitochondrial DNA, but it is only passed down by mother to child.
This is such basic biology and I know you know this but I include it here for the rare reader who may not:
Gender DNA is either:
Male = X and Y (XY)
or
Female = X and X (XX)
making gender non-transitionable.
Interesting my haplogroup is L... Shem. Interesting most likely explains my undefined features. Those three brothers came from a father and mother that had same physical appearance.
The missing tribes are R&Q following the Assyrian captivity
Hi I am Guatemalan and would like to participate in the DNA.
Please do a podcast on haplogroup T1.
Is T1 Jewish or Israeli from the Diaspora?
Isn't it incredible that God tells us that life is in the blood? This research kind of adds a new meaning to that in a way. You can actually see the history of life by studying blood DNA lol
There’s a RUclipsr with red hair very fair white skin with ancestry of Africans. His last name is a variation of the original
Not starting anything, just thinking about possible controversy of Prince William and family. Not to worry.
Both sides of my family came to the US from Germany - Pomerania. Late 1800.
Most truth I've heard about ancestry. Also mirrors my own family lineage in the Americas Africa Asia and Europe. WOW mind blown rn. I'm Mozambican, Cherokee, and European. Now looks like Asian! That explains the "scalp Lock" worn by my native ancestors. It was introduced during the Hun migration. That's what I suspected. The Huns were made to wear the haircut as a way to segregate them from the ruling Manchurian dynasty that had just took power. All the best Shaw Bros Kung Fu films are based in this 300AD history. That makes sense. Just wow
Okay I have watched mostly all you parts of traced and I am glad you discover something new for yourself and other people, however people of color have known this truth for a long time by word of mouth from our ancestors. I am of Africa, Native America and European, I knew this all my life. My study in history in school goes further back than your time for I am older. Before World History, I learned Ancient History. Every country that was conquer by another people naturally their history would be lost and replace by the new people for control. However I watched your study to see and learn more than what I already had learn years ago. Some books I found in the basement of a rich neighborhood library that was very old had history of people coming from Africa to America before Columbus, just as the Lief Erickson had done. But the latter was in Canada and the Africans were with the Mayan people. Later I learn that Africa had went to Thailand as well. But yet I kept waiting for you to mention this and you chose not to show but only wanted to find the original people known to you by what you think what was original people of a certain area. not really scientific in my opinion. Yet you did show that the Anglo Saxon has no proof of being European but Asia. Studying an old study done in Europe of the Black Europeans of Germany of Black Emperors I wanted to know that history and the study was done in the early 1900's so your data did back this study. Now just a thought, I wonder if you collected data from Albinos Y chromosomes to see where their ancestry had mostly reside at during BC times. I hope that when you get the data that you are only searching for that you will enter all peoples data, just maybe they had different starting points that may not have your theory or may bring new information. However as a whole it was a interesting study. I was just wondering just how well can we trust science DNA.
My dad's y dna is G and my maternal grandfather's y dna is A and he and his grandsons have the similar eyes as the Koison woman.
My husband's is R
Then why does The Vedas have history going back 10 to 15,000 years ago
If the years from NOAH to now are 6,000 YEARS, can you tell through DNA analysis how many years and generations there were from ADAM & EVE out of AFRICA to NOAH?
Austronesians include the natives of Madagascar and Indonesia. So it's not a far stretch to believe that Africans and East-Asians are related.
Race invented 400 years ago as a term, based on start of slavery raids in Africa.
Again, as I've stated before, one must use the generational timeline of the ancient sources such as the Septuagint, the Dead Sea Scrolls, Samaritan Pentateuch and writings of Josephus to actually be reasonably accurate, because the timeline given in modern day translations and their versions are based on the corrupted timelines of the Old Testament in the Masoretic Text. There are more than 16 centuries of generational time missing from the much later and tampered-with Masoretic Text, and therefore our modern translations. This was done on purpose with an agenda, but that is another story that needs to be looked at and understood, and correcting this would also clear up a ton of discrepancies in the timelines of the Bible and secular history, but scholars do not want to deal with this problem. In my opinion, they are not good scholars.
Very interesting. The Australian Aboriginals have over 300 different languages. This would indicate a variety of origin, as you have said.
A Rabbi from Jerusalem said that East-Asians are from Ham - the forefather of African peoples.
Ham is the forefather of the Hamites; Hamites and Shemites (descendants of Shem) co-exist in Africa. Stop the lies.
So Noah had a black, Asian and white grand kid?
Considering the Exodus involved Joseph's two son's (Manesseh and Ephraim), bringing out their Egyptian mother's DNA, that new mitochondrian DNA coding was infused into the Israelites.
E1b1A is not Ham, It is Shem
Can you please explain to laypersons like me how these dna results can pinpoint geographically where ancestry can be traced back to? I might even need a separate video for this explanation 🙈😅 Thank you for this very fascinating presentation ❤️
There was another series from the 'replacing Darwin's book which should still be available on RUclips. He explains there over about 20 episodes how the data is collated and how the information is derived. It will help you understand how mutations and y chromosome data backs the biblical account.
You should look into The Human Genome Project. They mapped the entire Human Genome and much more. It's firmly rooted in science so if science scares you it's not going to be for you. Several animals have the entire Genome mapped now and EVERYTHING supports Evolution
@@remainhumble6432 20 utube episodes and still no Scientific Paper? So it's just someone's opinion without supporting evidence as I expected
@@imafeltersnatch7634 He has published many things if you care to look into it. If I were you I would try the red pill and try to use that brain of yours. How you can swallow some of the research these days? I have realised that a lot of 'scientists' seem to be favouring fairy tales rather than truth and again it's not what you think.
@@imafeltersnatch7634 What you are saying is clearly the current narrative. But perhaps you should look into why the whole thing does not make sense to some. This is only for those who are getting sick of idiotic narratives and seeking truth.
In Biblical times, it was common for men to have more than one wife. Do we KNOW that Shem, Ham, and Japeth had only one wife each?
Yes. Because it specifically says 8 people were on the ark.
Some of his ideas are right, some wrong. Clearly there were peoples other than the 8 Ark survivors after the Deluge who visited this world and interbred with the children of Adam.
When will the lies and mis--directions end regarding current day descendants of Ham, Shem & Japheth? Genesis 10 tells the lands assigned to them by the most high, and their descendants.
Shem & Ham descendants have always lived in Africa.
It may be a surprise to you but a lot of “black” people forced into that least strata of privilege already knew this.
I don't get it, seeing that all of humanity can be traced back to Noah's 3 sons, where did all the different races and skin colors came from? Aren't Noah's sons are of the same genetic race or are they of different races? A blend of White and Black will result in a mixture of brown or even light or dark color, so where does these 2 or more races came from? Some of what you are saying does not add up.
Olives are green dark brown or black.
Arab means very dark in Eberu.
Do not forget Egypt is in Africa. Egyptians/Mytsra are related to the Tsarians or Tyre. Black peoples. And my tribe JOSEPH is part Egyptian/Black. Read the script more closely.
Mr Jeanson,
Instead of making statements such as, "The Americas are filled with Central Asians . . ." it would more accurate to state, "America today, is filled with people who used to live in what we today identify as, Central Asia.". You're making the mistake of attributing "nationalities" (Meaning a People.) to geography.
Most of us have a history of ĺight skinned blacks during slavery and thru 1800 because of plantations
18:00
N + O + Q
We are a lot older than 4000BCE - that’s a fact .
Check out Sterkfontein caves in S.A. at lower end of the great African Rift Valley .
Clearly. He disagrees with your 'fact'. The question therefore is how is your 'fact' not his 'fact' based on the actual facts.
I dare Jeanson to publish his research and allow it to get peer reviewed.....He won't - He won't because he knows that it will get utterly destroyed and proved false. His work is not intended for the educated but rather for the Christian "layman" to simply reenforce their faith.
He wrote two books traced is the layman's book the technical book for serious scientists.
@@alansegger6199 Thank you but You're missing my point. If Jeanson was "serious" about convincing other Scientists then he would publish his work for peer review. Sadly though he will never do this - because he knows he's wrong and will get called out on it. Jeanson manipulates protocols such as Phylogeny branches to make the data to fit his narrative. He's already been debunked by legitimate Scientists who've reviewed his work on You Tube videos. Can you image what the world Scientific community would do if they got a hold of his "Hypothesis"....He's only debated one other Scientist that I know of (Dr Dan) - and Jeanson was rude and talked over Dr Dan's points in a clever strategy of deflection. Jeanson's work is targeted at Christians that are not knowledgeable to know any better & to just reaffirm their faith. Finally, if Jeanson was correct, he would receive a Nobel - You'd think he'd publish for that alone, lol....
Being peer tested as we speak so we have to wait and see.
King tut was r1b as were the paracas mummies and the tarim mummies and also the British king and prince's will I am Arthur and red and hairy
Can it be that you are not taking into account the information given to us in the extra biblical books of Enoch, one and two where God has said to of cursed Ham with dark skin and enlarged facial features.
The Book of Enoch is non-canonical, therefore unvetted and not reliable.
Thank you for sharing this. I knew the book of Enoch must be false, because it isn’t in the Bible. But now because you shared this, I know it’s not true. Sounds kinda racist, like black folks are curst or something? Is that what you are implying?
What girls were available to Shem, Ham and Japheth? Please don't tell me that they bred with their sisters!
The Bible says they boarded the ark with their wives 🥰
"And you shall choose three from the daughters of men to be wives for your sons.
And Noah took the three daughters of Eliakim, son of Methuselah, as wives for his sons, as the LORD
had commanded." - book of Jasher ch.6 (a Jewish history book with details not in Genesis)
Noah was married to Naamah, a daughter of Enoch.
First cousins
The laws that say you can't marry in your own familiy didn't come until the times of Moses.
Noah's wife was, I think, his great aunt.
Um... skin color is not all there is to race, and appearance is not solely determined by environment. A number of times you assume the skin color of ancient peoples with absolutely no data given to support your assumption. There are fundamental flaws in your methodology. I love your work but you need to rework this one.
Geological record earth is 4 billion years old, homo sapien 300,000 years. Dna shows neanderthal appears in 4 percent lineage of europeans. Explain that. Neanderthal went extinct 28,000 years ago. Science.
This DNA evidence is probably better than the old assumption filled, radiocarbon dating, circular reasoning, geologic strata, guestimates....
We've been lied to bud
Noahs ark landed in the caucus mountains... his whole family was white or caucasian. This is where the egyptians, hebrews, samarians all originated from.
But who is Noah a descendant of? Adam and Eve in Mesopotamia, were somewhere around modern Iraq between the tigeris and the Euphrates. Bagdad! Babylon! Look at a map 🙂
Also, the Caucus mountains are in North East Turkey...
Ham has no idea what he's talking about in regards to critical race theory. It was simply an academic study by law professors to determine the effects of racism systemically within our government. That's all it was. And given the history of this country, and how its foundations were laid it's a just cause. It has nothing to do with making Whites feel inferior. It has nothing to do with making them feel racist when they aren't. You, Mr. Ham, though I respect you and your work.. have a major blind spot and insensitivities in some areas.
Yes, that's how it started. But the theory has grown and morphed over the years. It is now used by racists to blame everything on people of certain 'races.'
@@bbgun061 Yes, it's used by some racists. A lot of legitimate beliefs are used by degenerates. Fact remains. Critical Race Theory isn't what Ham says it is. It's not what right wing media says it is.
@Adri Mills The problem with what you communicated is this.. While laws and statutes were being established, our country still didn't recognize Blacks as actual people. Institutions were also being founded under this climate. Inherent within these governing bodies is a bias. We can see it within the disparity of sentencing for similar crimes committed by Whites and Blacks. Blacks not being allowed to buy property in certain areas.. Blacks being dispossessed of legally obtained property. Blacks, not being allowed to learn how to read or write. KKK members being imported into Los Angeles and making up a significant percentage of law enforcement. Which led to all manner of injustice. CIA, funneling drugs into Black communities to Bloods and Crips. Do we cover all of this in grade school? Should we? Would teenagers have a better understanding of why some neighborhoods are in despair, and poverty written? Would those same teenagers enter adulthood with a more nuanced view of social, and economic conditions? I believe so. I also take issue with this head in the sand approach you've conveyed. I think you mean well, but it's not cool at all. "Teaching something irreversible/pointless". Yet you probably have no issue with American History being taught correct? Everything I highlighted is woven into that history. Truth shouldn't be so offensive, nor is it anything we as Christians should be attempting to mask or conceal.
@Adri Mills I appreciate your civility.. thank you. With that being said, there's a fundamental error in how you see this.. the logic is off. With all due respect. Essentially, hide or omit truth, because of what it might cause. Our Lord and Savior certainly wouldn't be on board with concealing truth. " the resentment or victim mentality that this may cause in young minds." That is a fallacious stance. You say this as if you can't teach kids about the depraved acts of others throughout history while at the same time teaching them that their actions individually define them. That character is assessed based on individual behavior, not the history of others who share ethnicity. "Not sure how reminding students on a daily about their horrible/terrible ancestors".. This is another really odd thing you said. It doesn't make any sense. You go to class, you are taught about a specific event, how to contextualize it, and then you're on to the next topic. It seems to me you're manufacturing all sorts of excuses as to why truth should be hidden. And no we aren't what we think.. I'm sure Hitler thought he was just in his actions. I'm sure those who push filth in our entertainment industries also think they're just. They aren't.
@Adri Mills I didn't read the entirety of your response because it's nonsense. You don't get to redefine what a thing is to invalidate it. I'm done talking to you about this. God bless..
Ok .. were did white people get their light complexion?
This is not the way to learn about the history of religion. Read the Sumerian texts Abraham tells where he came from in Genesis Ur was Abrahams home it was in Sumer that make him a Sumerian. There was a world flood and every culture around the world tells of the flood and how people survived it Noah's family was not the only people to survive there were survivors all around the world. Tell me how Noah's DNA can be in every person if the world has other people who survived. Try checking the facts before claiming you have the answers.
Where do you get this information that other people survived the flood?
If you're a Christian, the bible clearly says there were eight souls saved. Genisis 7: 13 and 21 and 23, 1 Peter 3:20 KJB
So interesting.
Th a no y o u. fo r. S ha r I no t h is ev I d e nce