Kant’s Noumenal and Phenomenal Realms
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- Is it possible to prove whether God exists, or is that question left unanswerable because we are bound to the physical world? In this brief clip, R.C. Sproul shows how Immanuel Kant’s response to this question has influenced the thinking of many agnostics today.
Watch the full message: www.ligonier.o...
Noumenal (rational, analytic) is dual to phenomenal (empirical, synthetic) -- Immanuel Kant.
Concepts are dual to percepts -- the mind duality of Immanuel Kant.
"Always two there are" -- Yoda.
Duality creates reality.
Among the fathers of western philosophy, there’s Yoda
@@user-hu3iy9gz5j "Philosophy is dead" -- Stephen Hawking.
Isn't metaphysics just bad grammar?
Why are there always random comments that have absolutely nothing to do with the video lol
How is that funny?
@@terminat1 because it’s dumb. That’s why
I know, right? Are they all bots, or... I'm not sure. But shoutout to Sproul.
New to RUclips?
Justified states by Neville Goddard might wake you.
Certainly the nominal is indemonstrable by sense. If it's so, how does our understanding come to belief?
God is omniscient omnipotent and omnipresent
They are stuck In the phenomenal world with all the power... They say it's the best. They have to develop an ideology of why there's a noumena world and some guys to the side.
Is this the same as substance and accidents?
oops i didn't watch the whole video
This sure is one approach to the split
That’s too bad … R.C. Is not yet done with this explanation … Where is the session where he talks about it more extensively? … because there is one where he covers this topic …
Thank you for your question. You can watch Dr. Sproul's lectures on Kant here: www.ligonier.org/learn/series/consequences-of-ideas/kant-part-1
finite man cannot define the Infinite
Of course not - show me something infinite!
@@smnwbb JESUS CHRIST
First, the name Melchizedek means “king of righteousness”; then also, “king of Salem” means “king of peace.” Without father or mother, without genealogy, without beginning of days or end of life, resembling the Son of God, he remains a priest forever.
We can define it but never know or understand it
I can’t deny what I see
Got no choice but to believe
My doubts ( ?)burned like ashes in the wind….
Forever free I am not the same
I thank the master
I thank the saviour
I thank God
Amen
Maverick city
In Salvation- God’s love and eternal life
In Judgement- His righteousness and justice
In His faithfulness - His immutability and veracity
In His plan and will- His omniscience and sovereignty
In His revelation- His veracity love and omniscience
Amen.
Amen and Amen
I am amazed at the influence that anti-Christ, anti-Bible narcissists have presenting the same ancient lies in sophisticated and academic terminology.
it obviously seems like you disagree with the phenomenon/noumenon distinction. why is that
I'm no fan of Kant, but he was a Christian.
Why?
Is it possible for one to know the noumenon with out knowing the phenomenon?
@@emmanuelbelleh2758 The Bible declares “no”. The Bible teaches that God made people with ability to reason on a very basic level, and to know right from wrong. Romans chapter 1. Selective or subjective reasoning is actually lying when the topic is objective truth in the mind of God. In other words, God Almighty is not hiding His existence. He puts the evidence in the face of every human. Fallen man decides whether to agree with God or not. And that is what He calls rebellious, militant lying.
This is wrong.
how so
@@theemptychamber1616 he don't know