moscardo efrafa yeah and the fact that it was all for nothing because John ends up dying makes it even more sad if you look at Arthur’s reason for saving John and playing the epilogue
Same here. Best game Rockstar has ever made, it's way better than GTA. This has emotion, and truly amazing characters. I know GTA has great characters but nothing can beat John Marston.
+NoSelfEsteem i wish taht the next rdr is gonna be a very good presequel, with bill, dutch, javier and john as robbers in there gang :) that were be awsome
Don't worry John is in the 2nd one if you've watched the trailer you'll notice there is A grieving mother and A child that get's threatened by Arthur Morgan the new protagonist. Mark my words the child is John Marston.
mexican mexicano al 100% there is not a comparison point, red dead had a true story, really good characters, and gta v, well, it's just about bank robberies, i'm one of those who think gta iv is much better
Aldo Ramirez, Despite not being mentioned in RDR directly by John, He does kind of Hint at Arthur as a part of his Youth and Outlaw Past. They most likely just took the Same Coat Jack and John wore and tailored them to Arthur having worn em first in RDR2. It's not like it wasn't an Uncommon thing back then, Duster Coats/Rawhide Leather Vests etc.
@@Jean.05 Still better than Arthur leaving his son and coming back after he DIED, LMAO. At least John left them with good hands taking care of them, Arthur left him and his mother completely alone thinking it would work out. My god, the amount of kids that never played RDR1, yet talk about John as they knew sh*t about his character amaze me. You aren't real RDR fans.
it may seem stupid but I cried when John died. Have all the adventure with him, he finally found his family, his happiness, and he is caught up by his past ... Really, john and a great hero, a good character game, I will never forget, Rest in peace John. (excuse my English, I'm French).
I've had RDR1 for about 8-9 years, and during all of my playthroughs I've never been able to play John as Low Honor. How hard he worked to make a better life for himself and his family, knowing all he ever did was wrong, and trying to make amends for it, I could never bring myself to make him act dishonorably. He fought hard for his redemption and earned it far more than any other character I've ever seen.
This song relates to the entire red dead franchise if you think about it, red Harlow was the first protagonist to carry his deceased father's pistol, then John Marston to Jack, as well as Arthur Morgan's weapons technically passed down to John, happens in all 3 games, all playable characters receive dead men's guns
I haven’t played the game in years. Listening to this song now, I’m still in rage that he died. When I played the game, I took my time to enjoy the game until he died. After that, I was so pissed, I tried to get it over as quickly as possible to get revenge.
At first i just thought it was a random montage of key moments in the game but when i relized it was his life flashing before his eyes i burst out crying
November 2018, already ended rdr 2 but even thinking that arthur morgan is my favourite rockstar games character and one of the best in all videogames, I still miss john even with him appearing on this new game.
In my opinion red dead redemption is one of the best games in history. The story is amazing, music is perfect graphics are so realistic. I give this game 5 1/2 stars
Not saying the graphics are bad but hearing that 6 years ago these graphics was perfect just puts on smile on my face, gaming has evolved (and devolved in some parts) so much
This is so well made from 10 years ago. Better than most modern rdr2 music videos tbh. I think the style just reminds me of the credits in the second game.
I know its only a game, and i've never been upset over a game... but this made me cry D: He was such a good character! R.I.P. John Marson You will NEVER be forgotten!
Yeah, because at that point in RDR2 Arthur is basically a dead man. However, he still has the will to live because he has a reason to fight to save John.
@@airgerald1055 It's about picking up a dead man's gun to carry out the last reason that's keeping your life worth living. It sort of fits with Arthur but not quite.
Red Dead Redemption was just absolutely brilliant. It told an extremely touching story of redemption, in a way that only a video game can. One of the best uses of the medium as a platform for story-telling ever.
its really sad that Jack had to become what his father didnt want him to be, an outlaw. i cried when John died but i cried more knowing his son became what John feared
i remember playing warzone. it was the second last circle and my squad was boutta be wiped stuck in a building and i said "ill hold em off for yall get to the circle" the enemy squad chased me down while my team pushed for circle and high ground. as soon as i got killed i played this song in the mic.
Live by the gun, die by the gun. John knew this day would come...every gunfighter knows his day will soon come. Because people never forget and least forgive. All I was glad in the end, sort of bittersweet, is he managed to rescue what he worked so hard and even died for: his family. No man can't die with such joy as knowing his family will survive him. Every family man knows such a zeal...I hope.
Never been so emotionally attached to a video game story like the red dead redemption series. Theres been sad moments in games throughout the years but nothing punched me in the chest and caused tears to spew out like these games.
I found this game back in 2k12, and holy shit was it a thriller. Thank you, Rockstar for a great game and making me have hope for the future of the gaming industry.
you know... you play this game for hours and hours... getting to know and love the lead character... you're with them thru all sorts of adversity... push thru all the hardship to victory... then they kill them like this... I'm a grown ass man and I feel like I lost a family member after they killed John Marston. The most depressing game ending ever! Damn you Rockstar!
I've never play Red Dead Redemption (1) but this is a very sad scene. I like better than Arthur's in the sense that it's more of a "Let's remember the good things we did and the good times we had" song instead of Arthur's which is more like "I'm dying. I've learned the rights and wrongs. Now it's time to go home" Arthur's is more emotional in the sense that the day is done and it's time to go home. While John is more of a reminisce on his life as an outlaw, you know?
It is just a video game but when he died It really touched me I have been thinking about since July 2015 you go on a adventure and you get so attached to him then he just dies,it is just like one big movie
Same here bro! It's weird how you can get attached to a video game character so much! It just shows how well this game was written and how much of a badass that John Marston character really was R.I.P. John Marston
Beautiful, A Good Farewell to a Bad Ass Cowboy, Arthur didn't deliver as much of an Emotional Departure he just sorta. . . Well Pulled an Old Man at his Deathbed situation on us. Marston went down in a guts n glory way.
One of the best game game ever made. Everything was perfect, musics, storyline, an epic and sad ending. That was an experience to live, thanks Rockstar for this masterpiece, and farewell John......we miss you :'(
its 2016 and i still cant get over the end i cant wait for PS4 version to come out so it will be like a whole new game and we'll get to experience it again and just how special the story really was. );
Red dead is the best rockstar game ever made hands down to bad the way arther and John die but they died with honor I shed a tear because this is a amazing story
I was literally depressed for a week when I watched him die. I watched it on RUclips so I never had to see it while playing, I'm just never gonna finish the game because I can't. I seriously can't.
i have saves on when John was at the ranch n happy, n I have saves for Arthur happy at horseshoe overlook, just because it gives me false hope that they’re gonna be okay
I feel I can relate to John Marston he just seems like the type of guy I would want to meet. He kind of reminds me of my father and I really like that about him and he died protecting his family like my dad protect us. My father was a army man not exactly an outlaw but he fought for our country in the Iraq war.
Rockstar games did this game damn good. so many people loved john marston's character and thats enough said. not only game play but the story line was what we all got hooked on to. it kept our attention and in the end we cared about this character so much that it actually upset many when he was killed. -but hear this. "he went out like a champ (not a coward) and in the end his boy got his on that piece of shit law man. (i shot his deputy in the face and five others in dead eye before they unloaded on john)
One of the last things John says to his family is “dont look back” One of the last things Arthur ever says to John is “dont look back” but both John and Jack did not listen to those words and ultimately one of which lead to John’s demise
I have never cried over a game character...EVER, but John Marston's death made me cry like a baby...I cried over him for 2 days on and off, and then I decided to make a character where I would stop progressing at 2 missions before he ends up on the farm. I've kept him alive, and I complete events and experience things with him every day. I jus cannot bring myself to let him die.. THAT'S the way games should be.
This is a never ending cycle... Arthur told John to run and not look back, which he did, and inevitably caused his death... and then his son, avenged him while he told them to go... the cycle continues..
You know, as a grown up you must understand that he sacrificed just for his family. If he hadn't suicide they will keep chasing him, him and his family so he just choosed to die. a pure ending
Rest easy old friend.
But he's with you now, isn't he, Morgan?
You to arthur😔
Hows it going with dutch and jack
Rest easy Morgan.
Your old friend is coming home.
I mean see if this was real life Arthur died 122 years ago
1899: you gotta run an don’t look back
1911: keep riding and don’t look back
FIRST JOHN THEN ARTHUR I JUST CAN'T
moscardo efrafa yeah and the fact that it was all for nothing because John ends up dying makes it even more sad if you look at Arthur’s reason for saving John and playing the epilogue
:c
Luis Z he's a outlaw saved his saved his wife and his kid lived another 10 years I think it was completely worth it
thanks for the spoiler fella
Mike Hunt a good man for sure
This game will stand the test of time in my book. Rockstar are truly amazing developers, I cannot wait to see a new Red Dead game on next-gen.
Same here. Best game Rockstar has ever made, it's way better than GTA. This has emotion, and truly amazing characters. I know GTA has great characters but nothing can beat John Marston.
this made me cry. so many great memories of playing as john marston coming back. thank u so much
+Vycrance It's going to be HARD to top John.
+NoSelfEsteem i wish taht the next rdr is gonna be a very good presequel, with bill, dutch, javier and john as robbers in there gang :) that were be awsome
Don't worry John is in the 2nd one if you've watched the trailer you'll notice there is A grieving mother and A child that get's threatened by Arthur Morgan the new protagonist. Mark my words the child is John Marston.
i think rdr was much better than gtav tbh
mexican mexicano al 100% there is not a comparison point, red dead had a true story, really good characters, and gta v, well, it's just about bank robberies, i'm one of those who think gta iv is much better
Vato Loco To be fair they’re very different games.
Yup
Yeye Rdrgz in terms of gameplay
no
in terms of story
100%
And RDR2 is better than both. Arthur was so human, i prefer him above John...
The jacket that's wearing Jack seems like Arthur's original yellow jacket
Aldo Ramirez, Despite not being mentioned in RDR directly by John, He does kind of Hint at Arthur as a part of his Youth and Outlaw Past.
They most likely just took the Same Coat Jack and John wore and tailored them to Arthur having worn em first in RDR2.
It's not like it wasn't an Uncommon thing back then, Duster Coats/Rawhide Leather Vests etc.
@Lynx _76 iT iSnT cHaNgE mY mInD
@Lynx _76 get over yourself he doesn't need to change your mind it's his opinion douche
Aldo Ramirez fuck you now I’m crying in genetics don’t need this right now man
Aldo Ramirez NA the other one that John wears is Arthur’s coat cause it looks like it has stains on it
I still crying,after 6 years...
Sulfur, are you still crying after 9 years?
@@notajtag4568 It's not to cry but really, is emotional.
And I'm crying after 12 years
@@notajtag4568 yes... always...
I'm here after 12 years
R.I.P John Marston a family man he protected his family
.
But he fucking ran off for a year LMFAO
@@Jean.05 screw you Arthur says run and don't ever look back so he did it to not waste Arthur's sacrifice for them
@@Leigh4444 You obviously don't fucking know the story XDDDDDDDDDDDD
@@Jean.05 Still better than Arthur leaving his son and coming back after he DIED, LMAO. At least John left them with good hands taking care of them, Arthur left him and his mother completely alone thinking it would work out.
My god, the amount of kids that never played RDR1, yet talk about John as they knew sh*t about his character amaze me.
You aren't real RDR fans.
it may seem stupid but I cried when John died.
Have all the adventure with him, he finally found his family, his happiness, and he is caught up by his past ... Really, john and a great hero, a good character game, I will never forget, Rest in peace John.
(excuse my English, I'm French).
No, you typed it all just right. I completely agree with you. :)
Thanck you :)
It's “thank“ but that's okay. :) And you're welcome. :)
Oh sorry
It's okay. :)
Lets be onest, who didn't cry? (I did) :'(
I didn't... I seen what was going to happen.
@@andreapitre1978 I almost cry
Bram I cried to both of them
I think I was too shocked to cry.
Rdr2 -rdr is the only game-movie that make me cry
Saddest game ending ever
R.I.P. Uncle,John,Abigail
Rdr2 :,(
Bruhh
What about rdr2
Bro this comment is 9 years old rdr2 didnt exist back then
@@konkeshtgaming7293 the comment is like a long ass time before rdr2, learn to read smh
@@lennygosheesh man ig i was a retard back then
I've had RDR1 for about 8-9 years, and during all of my playthroughs I've never been able to play John as Low Honor. How hard he worked to make a better life for himself and his family, knowing all he ever did was wrong, and trying to make amends for it, I could never bring myself to make him act dishonorably. He fought hard for his redemption and earned it far more than any other character I've ever seen.
As I've played both the characters I've got attached to them and always cry when they die
I swear, same
Same ... Arthur and John are legends
This song relates to the entire red dead franchise if you think about it, red Harlow was the first protagonist to carry his deceased father's pistol, then John Marston to Jack, as well as Arthur Morgan's weapons technically passed down to John, happens in all 3 games, all playable characters receive dead men's guns
This game was.. Is and always will be the best game ever !
Until Red dead redemption 2
@@Fea_240 I don't know. Both are awesome 🤔
@@Fea_240 No, both are equally masterpieces
Still play both myself
@@Fea_240 rdr1 still better imo
I haven’t played the game in years. Listening to this song now, I’m still in rage that he died. When I played the game, I took my time to enjoy the game until he died. After that, I was so pissed, I tried to get it over as quickly as possible to get revenge.
They've given you a reason to fight.
At first i just thought it was a random montage of key moments in the game but when i relized it was his life flashing before his eyes i burst out crying
November 2018, already ended rdr 2 but even thinking that arthur morgan is my favourite rockstar games character and one of the best in all videogames, I still miss john even with him appearing on this new game.
In my opinion red dead redemption is one of the best games in history. The story is amazing, music is perfect graphics are so realistic. I give this game 5 1/2 stars
Not saying the graphics are bad but hearing that 6 years ago these graphics was perfect just puts on smile on my face, gaming has evolved (and devolved in some parts) so much
How tf is it 5 1/2 I give it a 9/10
@@LilBiscuit1 5 stars mate not out of 10
This is so well made from 10 years ago. Better than most modern rdr2 music videos tbh. I think the style just reminds me of the credits in the second game.
I know its only a game, and i've never been upset over a game... but this made me cry D: He was such a good character!
R.I.P. John Marson
You will NEVER be forgotten!
"Our time has passed, John"
Dutch van Der Linde in 1911
listened to this as the clock striked 12 to play Read Dead Redemption 2. Not gonna forget this
Oh, the tears I shed.
This song fits really well with Arthurs last ride back to camp before the gang broke apart
Yeah, because at that point in RDR2 Arthur is basically a dead man. However, he still has the will to live because he has a reason to fight to save John.
EXACTLY WHAT I WAS THINKING
@TheLee both ways, it still fits John and his situation with Ross and the Bureau.
@@airgerald1055 It's about picking up a dead man's gun to carry out the last reason that's keeping your life worth living. It sort of fits with Arthur but not quite.
@@themadtitan7603 it’s fits mostly with Jack, it would be cool if when you were riding near agent Ross before you kill him this song would play.
John was an good guy when I saw that at the ending I cried
This game had such an impact on me. Certainly one of the most unforgettable games I've ever played.
Red Dead Redemption was just absolutely brilliant. It told an extremely touching story of redemption, in a way that only a video game can. One of the best uses of the medium as a platform for story-telling ever.
its really sad that Jack had to become what his father didnt want him to be, an outlaw. i cried when John died but i cried more knowing his son became what John feared
backstabberz108 Jack is smart though, but live by the gun, die by the gun.
Best game I’ve ever played this is my childhood and anyone who didn’t have this missed out
This is so depressing. But, these help you understand how much empathy you have for them.
Rest in peace John
John is a...Good man😭😭
I’m from the future, and no one will see this, but RDR2 adds so much more meaning to this game, more than there already was.
Red dead will always be in my heart it reminds all my memories with my mom and me when I played Red Dead
i remember playing warzone. it was the second last circle and my squad was boutta be wiped stuck in a building and i said "ill hold em off for yall get to the circle" the enemy squad chased me down while my team pushed for circle and high ground. as soon as i got killed i played this song in the mic.
When the credits hit I just sat there and stared into space listening to this. Amazing game.
I played red dead 2 first so this hit me in the feels
Completed this game today...jesus christ, never cried so much at a game in my life. So emotional, best game I've ever played
You're not gonna let them take your will live to live... R.I.P. John..still missed.
C'est à la fin du jeu que tu te rends compte à quel point tu aimais cet homme...
I've played the story mode 5 times and i still love this game
This still needs to be made into a movie that is true to itself. I played this game as a man and by the end cried like a boy.
John Marston was such a great character!
not going to cry not going to cry
Live by the gun, die by the gun. John knew this day would come...every gunfighter knows his day will soon come. Because people never forget and least forgive.
All I was glad in the end, sort of bittersweet, is he managed to rescue what he worked so hard and even died for: his family. No man can't die with such joy as knowing his family will survive him. Every family man knows such a zeal...I hope.
Never been so emotionally attached to a video game story like the red dead redemption series. Theres been sad moments in games throughout the years but nothing punched me in the chest and caused tears to spew out like these games.
I found this game back in 2k12, and holy shit was it a thriller. Thank you, Rockstar for a great game and making me have hope for the future of the gaming industry.
you know... you play this game for hours and hours... getting to know and love the lead character... you're with them thru all sorts of adversity... push thru all the hardship to victory... then they kill them like this... I'm a grown ass man and I feel like I lost a family member after they killed John Marston. The most depressing game ending ever! Damn you Rockstar!
John Marston💐
Arthur Morgan 💐
I miss Red Dead Redemption ❤
I've never play Red Dead Redemption (1) but this is a very sad scene. I like better than Arthur's in the sense that it's more of a "Let's remember the good things we did and the good times we had" song instead of Arthur's which is more like "I'm dying. I've learned the rights and wrongs. Now it's time to go home" Arthur's is more emotional in the sense that the day is done and it's time to go home. While John is more of a reminisce on his life as an outlaw, you know?
It is just a video game but when he died It really touched me I have been thinking about since July 2015 you go on a adventure and you get so attached to him then he just dies,it is just like one big movie
Same here bro! It's weird how you can get attached to a video game character so much! It just shows how well this game was written and how much of a badass that John Marston character really was
R.I.P. John Marston
Iv been thinking about it for 6 years and it just makes me sad Af
Shout out to all the players who never bothered to change John's attire throughout the entire game 😂👍
The poncho distracted me and decided to keep it as his default outfit until Chapter 4 in Beecher's Hope
ur right man hes a legend and we wont forget him
John... one of my best partners of gaming... RIP #cantstopcrying
Beautiful, A Good Farewell to a Bad Ass Cowboy, Arthur didn't deliver as much of an Emotional Departure he just sorta. . . Well Pulled an Old Man at his Deathbed situation on us. Marston went down in a guts n glory way.
Ivan Salcedo Agreed. Overall I think John is the better protagonist and it’s stupid how much the writers watered down his character in RDR2.
"Keep riding and don't look back." sounds familiar...
One of the best game game ever made. Everything was perfect, musics, storyline, an epic and sad ending. That was an experience to live, thanks Rockstar for this masterpiece, and farewell John......we miss you :'(
hard to watch this and not shed a tear
I come here often and feel lonely
its 2016 and i still cant get over the end i cant wait for PS4 version to come out so it will be like a whole new game and we'll get to experience it again and just how special the story really was. );
Bro had a vision 💀
It still hurts :( damn it john... we miss you partner..
Red dead is the best rockstar game ever made hands down to bad the way arther and John die but they died with honor I shed a tear because this is a amazing story
A really awesome ending. Really sad, but awesome. And the fact that, in the end, you avenge John's death is really good.
I cried to death and burst in to tears
I was literally depressed for a week when I watched him die. I watched it on RUclips so I never had to see it while playing, I'm just never gonna finish the game because I can't. I seriously can't.
me @ arthur
i have saves on when John was at the ranch n happy, n I have saves for Arthur happy at horseshoe overlook, just because it gives me false hope that they’re gonna be okay
Callie if this left you depressed for a week then you should never watch Arthur’s death
same
the best campaign i ve ever played...its emotional too :')
I love the song.
John avenged Arthur and Jack avenged John
I feel I can relate to John Marston he just seems like the type of guy I would want to meet. He kind of reminds me of my father and I really like that about him and he died protecting his family like my dad protect us. My father was a army man not exactly an outlaw but he fought for our country in the Iraq war.
Arthur Morgan 🤠😪
What was he marines, Air Force, navy?
@@nadja9055 Another Arthur dickrider.
He wasn't even an idea when RDR1 was made, face it.
@@nadja9055
Nah.
This is one of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard. RIP John, your a true legend. :*)
I agree, it's impossible not to feel a knot on your throat at least.
Such a great song from a great game. Nice cut on the video. What a sad ending.....
You bond with the people you play as, as if they are a friend. You spend more time with them, as Pavro said.
By far an amazing video
Life is never fair, even in a video game...but he faced it with valiant
This was the best videos I've seen it was very creative I loved it good job. Plus this was the only game I almost cried to at the end rip John
Rockstar games did this game damn good. so many people loved john marston's character and thats enough said. not only game play but the story line was what we all got hooked on to. it kept our attention and in the end we cared about this character so much that it actually upset many when he was killed. -but hear this. "he went out like a champ (not a coward)
and in the end his boy got his on that piece of shit law man. (i shot his deputy in the face and five others in dead eye before they unloaded on john)
RIP John. This song is beautiful. Has anyone heard the new Ashtar Command CD, American Sunshine? It's sounds a lot like this and it's really good
How Could Anyone Dislike This, Best Game Ever
Until RDR2
@@darrenh55755
Nope, RDR1 is still better.
this...was like the Terminator saying goodbye to john Conner....but more heart wrenching...
Red Dead Depression 😔
One of the last things John says to his family is “dont look back”
One of the last things Arthur ever says to John is “dont look back” but both John and Jack did not listen to those words and ultimately one of which lead to John’s demise
Read Dead Redemption is the best game in the world
remember, john died 100 times during your walkthrough
Until we ride again... Mr Marston.
well said i dont think a game could ever have a sadder ending
1:17 "This is a fine spot"
One of the best games i ever played in my life.
I have never cried over a game character...EVER, but John Marston's death made me cry like a baby...I cried over him for 2 days on and off, and then I decided to make a character where I would stop progressing at 2 missions before he ends up on the farm. I've kept him alive, and I complete events and experience things with him every day. I jus cannot bring myself to let him die..
THAT'S the way games should be.
One of the best games I've played in my life .. really excellent..
This game best ever
Until Red dead redemption 2 came out
Stoppp you’re gonna make me cry
this is the song that i will always remember and think of when i play red dead redemption it sums the game up perfectly
Hey pal u still alive ?
When John Got shot I stood up and yelled YOU SONS OF BITCHES!!! I never got so Mad or so Sad at a game
This is a never ending cycle... Arthur told John to run and not look back, which he did, and inevitably caused his death... and then his son, avenged him while he told them to go... the cycle continues..
His death was already inevitable from the start. People don't forget and nothing gets forgiven
You know, as a grown up you must understand that he sacrificed just for his family.
If he hadn't suicide they will keep chasing him, him and his family so he just choosed to die.
a pure ending
And fyi, when John peeks out from behind that tombstone, I laughed so much...not sure why, just the way he bends forward...