Johns death was sudden and brutal. Died within the span of 1 mission, being denied the life he fought for and rightfully earned Arthurs death was slow and painful. Lasting an entire chapter, while he watched everything he stood for crumble. Rdr story is on another level
John's death wasn't exactly sudden if you look at it closely. John knew from the get-go that they would kill everyone from the gang, which is why he walked into Fort Mercer going against Bill without any plans at all and drawing his revolver so fucking slow; he wasn't planning to stay alive. Bonnie saving him and looking at her ranch made him think of a better future but unfortunately he already knew they would still kill everyone from the gang once he confronted Dutch. Which is why the last parts of RDR1 are mostly John teaching Jack skills, because he knew he wouldn't be with them any longer. It was already a huge foreshadowing that John will die with how the last missions of teaching Jack is really drawn out for a longer time it should be.
I feel like Hosea’s death was the most tragic in the grand scheme of things, since him not being there to keep Dutch somewhat sane was arguably the final nail in the gang’s coffin, but Arthur screaming when Lenny got shot hit me so hard
He got the opposite, not what he wanted but what he deserved. "Face me to the west so I can watch the setting sun and remember all the fine times we had that way." In the end, he faced east and watched the sun rise, not remembering all the "fine" times but just knowing he had won, allowing John to survive.
@@whatinthegoddamn890What do you mean half insane at that point? He was insane after Hosea’s death. This was proven when he took the fight to the army.
John’s death was totally unfair. He did what Ross has told him to do. Ross promised to let him live the rest of his life with his family if he captures the rest of his gang. But at the end, Ross killed him anyways for his own pride.
He killed hundreds of innocent people though. Red Dead Redemption meaning they are beyond redemption. But they still seek it because they are morally full of guilt for what they've done
Ross saw what happened to Agent Milton when he tried to be resolve things in a civil manner. Milton gave the gang every chance possible and in the end, died for it. I think Ross learned from his mistakes and decided that pure brutality was the only way to handle John Marston, deal or not.
You only think that because the game is from his perspective. These guys are murderers and thieves and even though Ross is clearly not a good person he is just trying to take down a gang of murderers. He certainly did not kill John for his own pride.
@@masonaltaira5084 doesn't matter because if it was Ross not John, Ross would have wiped out the entire natives before Dutch realized about it including women and children
It hurt me that no one helped her, she died alone watching the gang disintegrate and how the Pikertons came to destroy everything they had achieved over the years, Charles at least buried her in a place where she could rest and watch over everyone like she did in the camp.
It’s interesting that there’s only like 6 or 7 members of the Gang who didn’t die from being shot. Although Arthur is dependent on his honour & Javier is dependent on if you shoot or lasso him. The ones who did get shot were: Davey & Mac Callander (the former succumbed to his injuries & the latter was put down by Agent Milton after interrogation), Jenny Kirk (succumbed to her injuries), Sean, Hosea, Lenny, Molly, Grimshaw, Cleet (Optional- potentially shot by Sadie), Micah, Bill, Uncle & John. Javier (optional) & Low Honour Arthur if he helps John. Whilst those who weren’t shot were: Kieran (tortured & decapitated by Colm), Low Honour Arthur if he returns for the money (stabbed by Micah), High Honour Arthur (succumbs to Tuberculosis), Strauss (died in custody), Cleet (Optional - hung by John, Sadie & Charles), Karen (unknown- possibly Alcohol), Javier (Optional: if captured alive by John and handed into Archer & Ross… he’ll probably be executed by the government), Dutch (Suicide by Gravity), Abigail (unknown, probably an unknown illness) Survivors: Trelawney (probably with his family in Saint Denis), Mary-Beth (author), Tilly (a married mother in Saint Denis), Pearson (married and shop owner in Rhodes), Sadie (bounty hunter & potentially a security guard in Mexico or South America), Charles (potentially a family man in Canada with the Wapiti tribe), Jack Marston (author/ rancher & lonely outlaw)
Karen is confirmed, I can't remember who said it but he/she said Karen died with a bottle in her hand. I think it was Mary Beth when John finds her in Valentine's train station.
It would be nice if they re-made RDR With updated graphics to match RDR2 so the story flows a bit better, or upgrade both to today's standard and sale as a package deal.
It was planned for Rockstar to make a remaster of the game but due to the poor quality of GTA Trilogy Definitive Edition they cancelled it and sadly I think it's better to leave RDR1 on the PS3 era
@@roorsworch5998 🥲 But there's so much that can be done with today's graphics and honestly most games Today lack a story and kinda suck "in my opinion" If they were to bring those 2 games into 1 and maybe add a 3rd part or just expand the first 2 parts Red Dead Redemption would hit number 1 in sales I bet. Many people like me didn't even find the game until years later and that base has steadily grown. just my opinion of course
@@mrc8534 nah brother, all of what you said is completely right and I fully agree with you, it would be amazing if Rockstar bother to do so, maybe after GTA 6 who knows but I'm afraid it will not be until 2030...
publishers believe that they did not earn enough in part 2. do you think they will make a remake of part 1? even online stopped updating because of this in part 2
The two members I hated as much as Micah were Dutch and Bill. Dutch because the gangs downfall was all his fault including the deaths of Lenny, Mac, Hosea, Davy, and Eagle Flies. Bill because his stupidity got Sean killed and he didn’t show any regret or remorse.
I want an rd3 that takes place before rdr2 and ends with the event in black water I feel like that would finish off the series perfectly and I just feel like it’d be fun to place as a younger Arthur
The saddest one is John and Arthur.. I got sad more at John probably cried Bc I played as John the first character.. in my whole life on my old console
Susans’s death was sooo random and unjustified, if someone were to shoot in that standoff, most probably everything would go off. She was hard on a lot of ppl but she also deeply cared about them
Micah didn't work with them til after they got back from guarma. As Milton said. Picked him up when you boys got back from the Caribbean, he's been a good boy ever since
Grimshaw was a gangster. She shot Molly with 0 remorse whatsoever. Her death was unfair. Micah shot her and Dutch, who she’d been loyal to for over 20 years, joins sides with her killer.
Hosea and lennys death were in my opinion sadest hosea was like the grandfather of the cam teacheing the player how to hut and set up a temporary camp And lenny was just a kid he never deserved to die
I never thought I was going to get RDR2 so I watched shorts of it. I only knew about Arthur’s Death and his TB. I knew Micah also died. I didn’t even know Hosea was a character. When he died I audibly gasped and then in almost quick fire, Lenny met the same fate. That was my least favourite mission. I do love it a-lot though.
Note that, considering his age, Jack probably was sent to Europe at the end of WW1. Considering he was the last member of the gang, that's probably where he died.
Sean's death was the most surprising for me. I was expecting a shoot out, but for it to kick off like that? Damn. Rockstar knew what they were doing with this series.
Everyone complaining of Micah but Edgar Ross is just trash made John kill his old brothers and Killed John like a rat with 20 mens and made fun of all members death, im proud of Jack
Susan Grimshaws death was the saddest. Yeah it was a lazy kill. But she was there since near the start of the gang. She died on the floor with no comfort.
I had got to the part where John got his family and was just enjoying free roam and was happy playing the game. My little brother saw and was like “you didn’t finish the game😐” “Yes I did! I got his family back!😄” “You didn’t finish the game ☹️” “Huh? 😲”… I found out a couple hours later
This game has epic the Hosea death scene gave that type of gamer rage I haven’t had since megaman x 1 where zero gave his life to destroy viles invincible ride armor As Arthur I shot them all so quick had the best aim i normally never had
@@Walter-The-Catbut the question is, which is sadder, and Arthur got betrayed by his family and he had to get beaten while with TB which means he was dying on that day and then getting beating which mean a small punch would probably feel like a bullet.
One thing that I can’t help but think « this is weird even for Dutch at that time » is when Micah kill Miss Grimshaw Miss Grimshaw has always been this « ruthlessly by the book » entity for the gang And Micah sucker kill her and he didn’t even blink or say a goddamn word to Micah ? That also means ( in my book ) how the hell micah was afraid of Miss Grimshaw I am not on the team that think that Dutch got mad, I think he was madman from the start with charisma and silver tongue to paraphrase mr milton Miss Grimshaw feels like the most « avoideable / unenessary deaths » for me You goddamn fool dutch
@@bakerzane3055 totally, it would have been a great « reason » to create more « confusion » in Dutch But perhaps, probably, it is made to made us realize how Dutch has lost his way. Because even in that heated moment, she is just speaking against Micah specifically, that’s all. The more the years passes since I finished the game, the more… « angry » I feel towards Dutch I just think he was a sociopath with a god complex or something loving to have this « guru » role more than anything , probably even more than money
I totally agree with you. There’s even a random event in camp where Susan even threatens Micah with her shotgun for trying to charm her with his disgusting manners In the final mission, he immediately saw the opportunity to get rid of a great danger as she was accidentally distracted by Javier She’s one of my favorite characters 💔 and I’m so angry towards Dutch for ignoring it and all what he did to Arthur and the others
Johns death was sudden and brutal. Died within the span of 1 mission, being denied the life he fought for and rightfully earned
Arthurs death was slow and painful. Lasting an entire chapter, while he watched everything he stood for crumble. Rdr story is on another level
And how about the epilogue of both of them
@@vanillaboy-rr8dvrdr1 epilogue is one mission.
@@yoshpeters3079 I did not clarify what I was saying what I was saying was. And what did you feel after doing both of the epliogues?
John's death wasn't exactly sudden if you look at it closely. John knew from the get-go that they would kill everyone from the gang, which is why he walked into Fort Mercer going against Bill without any plans at all and drawing his revolver so fucking slow; he wasn't planning to stay alive. Bonnie saving him and looking at her ranch made him think of a better future but unfortunately he already knew they would still kill everyone from the gang once he confronted Dutch. Which is why the last parts of RDR1 are mostly John teaching Jack skills, because he knew he wouldn't be with them any longer. It was already a huge foreshadowing that John will die with how the last missions of teaching Jack is really drawn out for a longer time it should be.
Out of all the deaths who arent the main protagonist, Hosea's death hit me the hardest
I feel like Hosea’s death was the most tragic in the grand scheme of things, since him not being there to keep Dutch somewhat sane was arguably the final nail in the gang’s coffin, but Arthur screaming when Lenny got shot hit me so hard
Aruthers death was 😢 very sad
For me it was Lenny and Hosea
Mine was easily Mac Callender. Favourite character by far. (Please don't take that literally. My favourite character is either Jack Swift or Trelawny)
Hosea didn’t deserve that kind of end at all.
You know how Arthur said that he wanted to die watching the sunset to remember all the times him and his gang had together, he got exactly that…
No if he got low honor
He got the opposite, not what he wanted but what he deserved. "Face me to the west so I can watch the setting sun and remember all the fine times we had that way." In the end, he faced east and watched the sun rise, not remembering all the "fine" times but just knowing he had won, allowing John to survive.
So Dutch just sees Micah kill miss Grimshaw, who he’s been riding with for years and still decides to choose his side?
Yes
The biggest "WTF" moment for me lol
He didn't know if she was a rat or not. The same goes with Arthur.
Dutch was half insane at this point
@@whatinthegoddamn890What do you mean half insane at that point? He was insane after Hosea’s death. This was proven when he took the fight to the army.
Sean, Kieran and Dutch’s deaths were the only ones i was surprised by because they were the only ones that wasnt spoiled
Dutch shouldve let arthur kill micah, exactly why i hate both of them.
@@Gragagayagabut micah was about to kill both john and dutch
@@Notgerma yeah but arthur had the perfect chance but dutch stopped him.
@@Gragagayaga yeah but at least john got his revenge
@@Notgermawhich then lead to johns death
John’s death was totally unfair. He did what Ross has told him to do. Ross promised to let him live the rest of his life with his family if he captures the rest of his gang. But at the end, Ross killed him anyways for his own pride.
He killed hundreds of innocent people though. Red Dead Redemption meaning they are beyond redemption. But they still seek it because they are morally full of guilt for what they've done
Ross saw what happened to Agent Milton when he tried to be resolve things in a civil manner. Milton gave the gang every chance possible and in the end, died for it. I think Ross learned from his mistakes and decided that pure brutality was the only way to handle John Marston, deal or not.
as dutch said they will just find another monster to justify their payroll.
You only think that because the game is from his perspective. These guys are murderers and thieves and even though Ross is clearly not a good person he is just trying to take down a gang of murderers. He certainly did not kill John for his own pride.
@@masonaltaira5084 doesn't matter because if it was Ross not John, Ross would have wiped out the entire natives before Dutch realized about it including women and children
2:24 Im not even joking as soon as i saw Hosea get killed i wanted to give Agent Milton the worst death ever possible😊
I swear that smile at the end is giving me te he vibes
Same😊
Yeah. Milton proved he was no better than they were. Maybe worse. Killed Hosea in cold blood.
And people say "Milton is that bad" lmfao.
Micah really tried to walk it of lmao
His body was still trying to process getting shot which was why he walked off. It’s common for people to try and walk away after getting shot
mf was like "Anyway i guess i'll die 🤷🏻♂️" 🤣🤣
My big brother did this mission and shot him in the head 7 times and said walk it off
Micah and his act reminded me of The Nature Boy Ric Flair
Arthur’s reactions to all his people dying is so emotional, you can just see the toil it took on him losing he’s family.
I cried when Arthur say thanks to his dying horse.
Not buell 😪
PROTECT THE HORSES
I almost cried when lenny died he wanted to be buried next to his Freinds but they left him😭
Bro they buried him with hosea
Why did he die like that? He’s just a kid!
They went back for the body. Stole it out of the morgue when they nabbed Hosea's corpse.
I yelled out "NO" when he died
@@Etrilandme too man…
I cried the most when John died when I was younger! Seeing him kiss his wife and then die like that was heartbreaking for me.
Let’s be real, if uncle didn’t have lumbago he would solo everyone at the ranch
😂
Hosea and Lenny dying during the same mission destroyed me
Arthur death music hits hard😭😢
The parallels to arthurs last ride and johns ending :(
The saddest one was Kieran
Imagine being tortured, knowing that no one came looking for you thinking that you betrayed or left the gang.
In my opinion John’s death, he was just trying to start a family 😢😭😭😭
Trying*
Fr it’s really depressing
R* kill john for nothing. John can run or throw some molotov too pinkertons on the upside window
John never died
Well in red dead 2
Ross approached Jack for the first time on the riverbank and Jack approached Ross for the last time on the riverbank
And Ross’s first words to Jack were “enjoy your fishing kid, while you still can” and Ross died while fishing
You forgot herr strauss, he died in prission while the pinkerton torture him, he never talk about the last gang members ubications
When??
well there isn't any cutscene of him dying
@@AidenSantos-vx6nq It's in the epilogue. Charles tells it to John when they meet again in Saint Denis, there is no cutscene of Strauss though
He didn't have a cutscene
@@AidenSantos-vx6nqCharles tells John in the bare knuckle friendships mission
Not susan she didn’t deserve it she was the only one on Arthur other than john
Ikr
Yes bro
It hurt me that no one helped her, she died alone watching the gang disintegrate and how the Pikertons came to destroy everything they had achieved over the years, Charles at least buried her in a place where she could rest and watch over everyone like she did in the camp.
@@JORGEPT384me to but if Arthur helped her he would have got shot and he was the only one that would so it makes sense sad but I understand
John survived for over a minute with 12 bullets in him
Not entirely fictional. Emmet Dalton (a real Western outlaw) survived after getting 23 gunshots in his body.
The way arthur stops breathing as he looks at the sunrise as if there's instant relief
I cried so hard when arthur died I was crying way before cause I knew it was coming but yeah 😭
When Hosea died and it went back to gameplay I literally shouted 'where's Milton and where are my explosive arrows'
It’s interesting that there’s only like 6 or 7 members of the Gang who didn’t die from being shot. Although Arthur is dependent on his honour & Javier is dependent on if you shoot or lasso him.
The ones who did get shot were: Davey & Mac Callander (the former succumbed to his injuries & the latter was put down by Agent Milton after interrogation), Jenny Kirk (succumbed to her injuries), Sean, Hosea, Lenny, Molly, Grimshaw, Cleet (Optional- potentially shot by Sadie), Micah, Bill, Uncle & John. Javier (optional) & Low Honour Arthur if he helps John.
Whilst those who weren’t shot were: Kieran (tortured & decapitated by Colm), Low Honour Arthur if he returns for the money (stabbed by Micah), High Honour Arthur (succumbs to Tuberculosis), Strauss (died in custody), Cleet (Optional - hung by John, Sadie & Charles), Karen (unknown- possibly Alcohol), Javier (Optional: if captured alive by John and handed into Archer & Ross… he’ll probably be executed by the government), Dutch (Suicide by Gravity), Abigail (unknown, probably an unknown illness)
Survivors: Trelawney (probably with his family in Saint Denis), Mary-Beth (author), Tilly (a married mother in Saint Denis), Pearson (married and shop owner in Rhodes), Sadie (bounty hunter & potentially a security guard in Mexico or South America), Charles (potentially a family man in Canada with the Wapiti tribe), Jack Marston (author/ rancher & lonely outlaw)
And let’s add the death’s with no cutscene :
1- jenny
2- Davey callendar
3- mac callendar
4- herr Strauss
5- karen ( unconfirmed )
6- Abegail Roberts
Wait actually davey had a cutscene in the beginning of the game 🗿🗿
It was Abigail Marston at that time
Karen is confirmed, I can't remember who said it but he/she said Karen died with a bottle in her hand. I think it was Mary Beth when John finds her in Valentine's train station.
@@RogueSeraphNope, not there. Mary only talks about her being a writer and gives a copy of her book to John.
It would be nice if they re-made RDR With updated graphics to match RDR2 so the story flows a bit better, or upgrade both to today's standard and sale as a package deal.
Too expensive and the first game would require heavy refitting of most things, especially the game engine
It was planned for Rockstar to make a remaster of the game but due to the poor quality of GTA Trilogy Definitive Edition they cancelled it and sadly I think it's better to leave RDR1 on the PS3 era
@@roorsworch5998 🥲 But there's so much that can be done with today's graphics and honestly most games Today lack a story and kinda suck "in my opinion" If they were to bring those 2 games into 1 and maybe add a 3rd part or just expand the first 2 parts Red Dead Redemption would hit number 1 in sales I bet. Many people like me didn't even find the game until years later and that base has steadily grown. just my opinion of course
@@mrc8534 nah brother, all of what you said is completely right and I fully agree with you, it would be amazing if Rockstar bother to do so, maybe after GTA 6 who knows but I'm afraid it will not be until 2030...
publishers believe that they did not earn enough in part 2. do you think they will make a remake of part 1? even online stopped updating because of this in part 2
Arthur dies of turbiculosis not being shot
I loved Arthur and John’s characters
5:27 Every man cried at this moment😢
15:44 Check out Uncle's hand when Abigail is examining him.....
Bro I saw it move
@@paulinegillespie4589Bro faked his death.
Uncle survived lumbago, few bullets can't kill him
Also why Uncle's grave is not next to Abigail and John's
Maybe death twitches
Yeah Arthurs death is the saddest yet best death
Disagree, too overdramatic
I agree
@@hoya1178who’s is your favourite
Arthur Morgan.
"Got hit. Couldn't shake it."
The two members I hated as much as Micah were Dutch and Bill. Dutch because the gangs downfall was all his fault including the deaths of Lenny, Mac, Hosea, Davy, and Eagle Flies. Bill because his stupidity got Sean killed and he didn’t show any regret or remorse.
You forgot Abigal. There is no cutscene, but her grave is next to John's grave when you play as Jack Marston.
Dutch always had a plan, even in the end..
I want an rd3 that takes place before rdr2 and ends with the event in black water I feel like that would finish off the series perfectly and I just feel like it’d be fun to place as a younger Arthur
Molly got 200 pumped
Dude Lenny got me bro…I was so shocked and sad when it happened..
RIP. Arthur Morgan
He's not real bro
The saddest one is John and Arthur..
I got sad more at John probably cried Bc I played as John the first character.. in my whole life on my old console
Susans’s death was sooo random and unjustified, if someone were to shoot in that standoff, most probably everything would go off. She was hard on a lot of ppl but she also deeply cared about them
Once u played the 2 it’s crazy how everything make more sense and 10 time more sad with the 1
May I stand unshaken
Amid, amidst the crash of the world...
1:40 dutch: someone must be squealed me: it's micah
Micah didn't work with them til after they got back from guarma. As Milton said. Picked him up when you boys got back from the Caribbean, he's been a good boy ever since
@@Tristan_SingsJazz i know that
I literally cried at every death, except Susan. I even cried when my horse died
Yea I didn’t cry either I felt bad tho cus she always stuck with the gang even when everyone started leaving and died from a rat.
I actually don’t think I cried for anyone except for Hosea Arthur and my horse in rdr2
I actually was so surprised when Sean died cause I wasn’t expecting him to
Grimshaw was a gangster. She shot Molly with 0 remorse whatsoever. Her death was unfair. Micah shot her and Dutch, who she’d been loyal to for over 20 years, joins sides with her killer.
Hosea and lennys death were in my opinion sadest hosea was like the grandfather of the cam teacheing the player how to hut and set up a temporary camp
And lenny was just a kid he never deserved to die
Khabib champion
15:22 Looks like that lumbago finally did him in.
I never thought I was going to get RDR2 so I watched shorts of it. I only knew about Arthur’s Death and his TB. I knew Micah also died. I didn’t even know Hosea was a character. When he died I audibly gasped and then in almost quick fire, Lenny met the same fate. That was my least favourite mission. I do love it a-lot though.
I almost cried when they killed Hosea and Lenny. And cried, after Arthur died 😢
During that last moment John knew he couldn’t run, he had to face it. He accepted his fate and knew he couldn’t escape.
Dutch and John's death hit me the hardest.
It's also interesting Ross tells child jack "enjoy fishing while you can" since adult Jack kills Ross whilst he's fishing
Note that, considering his age, Jack probably was sent to Europe at the end of WW1. Considering he was the last member of the gang, that's probably where he died.
Sean's death was the most surprising for me. I was expecting a shoot out, but for it to kick off like that? Damn. Rockstar knew what they were doing with this series.
Love how Micah walks off like he's alive
I was very sad how Arthur died, I felt sorry for Dutch and John
Uncle's last request being that John save Jack and Abigail is really awesome since he's the one that introduced Abigail to the gang
Everyone complaining of Micah but Edgar Ross is just trash made John kill his old brothers and Killed John like a rat with 20 mens and made fun of all members death, im proud of Jack
You beat Micah up so much that you broke his nose.
i subscribed bur its good
Susan Grimshaws death was the saddest. Yeah it was a lazy kill. But she was there since near the start of the gang. She died on the floor with no comfort.
His blood is red now he’s dead jack wants redemption
0:07 I hit the like button too hard, poor Sean
"I gave u all i had. I did"😢
*AHEM*, MICAH? THE RAT? HE IS NOT VAN DER LIN
I always get sad when I see Arthurs death😢
Abigail Marston is died
(1877-1914)
Club penguin is kil
Sean… May the fiery young Irish bastard rest in peace.
"I gave you all I had" Arthur Morgan
This guy forgot that one of the woman died of alchohol poisoning
The fact, that all members died not like:
-u r dying
-no I will live in your heart
They all died like:
-You sure?
-No!
-Then I shot you or other.
-No!
9:46 listen to what john says...isnt it familiar?
4:16
plants vs zombies ahh sound
lol XD
Missed Abigail, though technically she left the gang by this point, but just a flash of her grave probably would have been good.
That last mission felt so nice
Poor Davey got no recognition.
When Hosea died, Dutch became insane.
Hi friend, can I make a video using your script idea?
Yo
Arthur’s death hit me really hard because i am still on Arthur in red dead
If the little boy said “uncle” isn’t that Arthur🤯
"I've got a plan, John"
I had got to the part where John got his family and was just enjoying free roam and was happy playing the game. My little brother saw and was like “you didn’t finish the game😐”
“Yes I did! I got his family back!😄”
“You didn’t finish the game ☹️”
“Huh? 😲”… I found out a couple hours later
dutch tells john the same he tells the army when him and arthur jump to the river in Rdr2
nah, dutch changed up quick, he was all big and bad in the cave, now he was crying (or it looks like) and sadly talking, he knows he’s dead
This game has epic the Hosea death scene gave that type of gamer rage I haven’t had since megaman x 1 where zero gave his life to destroy viles invincible ride armor
As Arthur I shot them all so quick had the best aim i normally never had
If yall really think about it Uncle is the only other Rockstar character to go out like old Smokey.
Susan had been waiting years to do that to Molly😂
People say bad parenting is sad they should see high honor ending 1
This Game shouldnt be called Red dead Redemption
*It should be called Red dead depression* 💀💀💀💀
😢😂
The storyline is just perfect and understanding ❤
I’m sorry but the way Dutch fell and hit the ground, I couldn’t help myself but laugh 😂
Arthur,Jhon,Hosea,Lenny and Dutch...😢
Arthur and john😢
Which one was sadder? Arthur? Or john?
Arthur….:(
@@imsocool1000 arthur didnt feel 20 bullets in him before he died so id go with john
😢😢
@@Walter-The-Catbut the question is, which is sadder, and Arthur got betrayed by his family and he had to get beaten while with TB which means he was dying on that day and then getting beating which mean a small punch would probably feel like a bullet.
2:37 why the mission doesen’t fail 😊
8:16 is my favorite
Agree
One thing that I can’t help but think « this is weird even for Dutch at that time » is when Micah kill Miss Grimshaw
Miss Grimshaw has always been this « ruthlessly by the book » entity for the gang
And Micah sucker kill her and he didn’t even blink or say a goddamn word to Micah ?
That also means ( in my book ) how the hell micah was afraid of Miss Grimshaw
I am not on the team that think that Dutch got mad, I think he was madman from the start with charisma and silver tongue to paraphrase mr milton
Miss Grimshaw feels like the most « avoideable / unenessary deaths » for me
You goddamn fool dutch
Same, she really was the backbone of the gang aside from Dutch, Hosea, and Arthur
To have her death be done like that was a bit underwhelming
@@bakerzane3055 totally, it would have been a great « reason » to create more « confusion » in Dutch
But perhaps, probably, it is made to made us realize how Dutch has lost his way.
Because even in that heated moment, she is just speaking against Micah specifically, that’s all.
The more the years passes since I finished the game, the more… « angry » I feel towards Dutch
I just think he was a sociopath with a god complex or something loving to have this « guru » role more than anything , probably even more than money
I totally agree with you. There’s even a random event in camp where Susan even threatens Micah with her shotgun for trying to charm her with his disgusting manners
In the final mission, he immediately saw the opportunity to get rid of a great danger as she was accidentally distracted by Javier
She’s one of my favorite characters 💔 and I’m so angry towards Dutch for ignoring it and all what he did to Arthur and the others