INFINITE always have standart for Live VOICE in Live Performance.... KINGFINITE is one of the Best LIVE SINGING in KPOP industry until today... 2nd Generation KPOP trully GEM❤
For those who doubted bigbang singing live, just listen to TOP's adlibs, and their shouts. Bigbangs interaction with the fans during a performance is superb.
infinite♡♡ which made me to become kpop fan and yeah!!! they are live singing king♡ and cd eaters!! the only group that i like every each and one of their songs!!
Now day just battle dance 😅😅😅 with loud music, I think because of that everyone still hearing they're song still, even I'm still back to old kpop song, and yeah I'm Old
You can distinguish what they say either. Back then we easily know what they said since their voice is louder than the music. And same, i stuck with first and 2nd generation kpop... Ballad... Trot. I don't even know what's popular since 2017 let alone this new generation or those viral stuffs. Too busy rewatching old kpop mv and jamming on my days off🤣🤣
Toxic fans rise nowdays because delusional kids who had to spending money without received the correct service from the artists. Follow trendy without knowing what it's. The empty body without soul who's not know what they need. Body full of greed. Living in an acquisitive society 😢
As a fan from the same era, I would like to congratulate and say "You've worked hard, guys" to all my 2nd gen groups❤ Also, I agreed with your statement on 3:25 > Hand mic barely or not even used now as lipsynch is common already. Another thing, as I remember, most of 2nd gen idols are always "competing" in making adlibs or singing high note when they performed. That's why there's exist a battle in high note in shows before. Not a battle in lipsynch. Edited: I'm crying and felt overwhelmed because you include B.A.P in this video😭 They're talented but the company was shitty on them.
You included all of my favorites! Beast/Highlight, Block B, Infinite, Shinee, and Big Bang! The other groups also have songs that I love! I really miss 2nd gen. The new gen is all about performance and making this impressive dance/stage which is great in a way but I listen to music because I love music and I want to hear live vocals. It is just so different and I really miss the performances that the live vocals brought us, the different mixes or the surprise ad-libs that we hadn't heard before. Ugh, it was so good.
Thank you for introducing some new groups like Block B (I like Zico as solo artist), B.A.P... I knew most 2nd gen groups, just never grew into them. I think 2PM reminds me of Rain. 🤔 Even though all the groups were amazing, somehow only Bigbang’s live performance stood out and with a different exciting vibe. 😂 T.O.P also spiced things up. 😉 Still waiting for your In-depth guide to BIGBANG series!
Bigbang is a King of Live performance, the Facial Expression the Gesture and the Emotions of the song that they Singging tells the story about... 👑👑👑👑👑💛💛💛💛💛
wow again another pure nostalgia trip from you. And as BBC, special thank you for including Block B. They are my second favorite right after BIGBANG and it always makes me sad to see them excluded even tho they had multiple hits through the years just because they are more recognized locally not much globally. ^~^
Yes, because the popular groups nowadays are not setting the right standards their overrated popularity is actually detrimental to the quality of kpop tasteless bandwagoners are lapping whatever comes out of this side of the world just because it's trending. The title should be more like, why *** is not the best and their fans should stop setting them up on a high pedestal because it's embarrassing. I said what I said.
i feel like i wanted answers from these hugely popular idols who in terms of talent is obviously lacking. aren't they embarrass esp if their fans glorified them and they can't even deliver?
Finally! Someone who thinks like me! 2nd gen is really the best! I don't understand the point of having lipsynch! I understand they are overworked but too frequent is not a good think! One reason I'm a yg stan open mics!
😅 This is really nostalgic, i remember infinite (and also maybe Vixx) was the best for synchronized dance at the beginning of that decade (2010s), then Exo came with even better dance, and after that all the groups became more concerned with dance than vocal... I don't know from when, for sure the groups of that generation still have good quality live vocals... indeed, from the beginning lipsync was always there, but it's not as bad as now...
Even when they are mostly bashed for their voice at first but we see they progressing and improve each comeback. Also 2nd generation kpop having so many concepts and didn't stuck with same melody for their songs like nowdays the songs from some groups just sounds the same with their other songs too. We got ballad specialist group too like the seeya and 2AM which is rare or maybe already extinct now. And back then we don't take it too hard over our idols talking to other groups with different gender.
I’m enough with the excuse “their dance are so hard that to sing is too much” 2nd gen dances is not that easy either I think. So rather that giving excuses and lip-syncing just to look good, better they show what they’re best at.. 😄 I don’t think 2nd gen are the best or flawless, but they’re not faking their performance and give their best.. that’s why I love them 😍
That excuse contradict so much with the pride kpop fans used to have in saying "Kpop idols can dance hard and still sing very well" when comparing Kpop idols to other (mostly American and English) artists' live vocals and performances. What happened to that? Now it's all about "idols don't need to be good at singing. Visuals and dance are where it at" Being able to sing live and having stable live vocals were still important during 2nd gen. I think the over editing and processing the Korean music shows love to do excessively on live singings now doesn't help either. And I think a lot of idols and producers or whoever making the decisions seem to forget that adlibs, the background harmony, just random shouting and hyping each other (which can't be done with the mics off) are what makes the live performances different from just listening to stereo versions. And endearing to the audiences.
Could you do a video about Bigbang idol interactions? I miss 2nd gen so much, and while I've seen clips of BB together with other 2nd gen artists before, the videos aren't easy to find, so it would be nice to have a compilation! It's also always cute seeing 3rd gen artists fanboying/girling over them.
In my opinion bigbang live performance is more interesting than their MV, and I think a lot of VIP have the same though as me. that's why bigbang never win if its about a MV views 🤣🤣
Kpop groups should give excellent vocals, and performance that the audience will injoy. Coz thats what the fans paid for, and they deserve it. So far, 2nd gen is slay and worth it to watch.
Ur video makes me realized why i never into kpop, when i was teenager, i prefered ballad n hip hop eg jo sungmo n dj doc, i mean i was there since beginning, i remember in my school days, Kangta was very popular in my country mostly becoz of his good look, similar with TVXQ, esp jaejoong...eventho they have great vocal n amazing choreos, but i felt they were boring.....their vocals mostly have similar tones n styles, while the music not interesting at all... they didn't evoke any emotions from me....until i saw bigbang...i felt in love at the 1st sight while watching their documentary in 2006...till now only bigbang can give so much emotions with their music n talents, they maybe not the best vocalists or dancers but definitely the best performers 👑👑👑👑👑
I miss 2nd gen vibe when they have more songs that also more focus on vocal not like just edm/hiphop music that louder than their vocal and you can see 2nd gen they are more passionate when perform also don't forget they know how to make stage alive 😂
Gen 2 adalah grup2 yg patut diapresiasi dan kompetisi mereka saat itu kuat dan fair karena memang yg jual suara jauh lebih dihargai dari yg cuman jual tampang, dan bukankah mereka penyanyi ya yg dijual ya suaralah jangan beralasan ini itu klo mo battle dance ya jadi dancer aja klo mo battle visual ya jadi model aja 😅
zaman now alias 2017 ke atas VOCAL belakangan, Lihat dulu apa cakep , bisa dance keren apalagi kalau bisa ngerap cepat.. vocal standar dan sering lipsing pun tidak masalah...
I wish we can have one concert by 2nd gen groups for the 2nd gen fans but this is practically impossible.. not to mention the missing members in some of the groups now🥲 No matter how popular kpop is now, these 2nd gen groups are still the best in my heart.
I screamed when Beast/Highlight appeared... Their music & live vocals always a blessing to my ears. Proud being a Beast /Highlight long time fan. 2nd Gen era definitely remains superior.
back when kpop fans werent angry psychos, and the kpop was actually korean POP. they had more fun on stage! i was able to meet a bunch after live stages back then
Wait I’m confused. I completely agree that idols sung live more often back then. But some of the stages seem to still be lip synced that you showed. It’s sometimes hard for me to tell what is lip synced and what isn’t nowadays😅 Regardless, I’m glad you’re introducing these groups to more people.
I noticed that 2gen don't pretend to sing when they took break and the backtrack is playing, they just keep dancing and back to singing when they're comfortable with
Now I'm going to have to dig out all my Block B stuff and listen to it all again. Mind you, it is a bit mean to say that everyone mimes these days. Many of the good ones do massive tours and all sing live.
I think it deserves mention that SHINee always sang live (still does) while doing very difficult and complex choreography. Thanks also to SHINee for starting the trend of posting dance practice videos. And their dance practice vids were real dance practices, not the perfected "let's pretend we're practicing" videos of today. I love many groups across all generations, but it's sad that the companies today rely so heavily on the mechanical rather than the organic.
Hand held mic do still exist and this gen 3 group is known for using hand held mic. Only 2 of their comeback they ditched it to prove that they absolutely can dance, it's their clap back to all the haters who's leaving very negative critics. All the members from this gen 3 group are all-rounder. The only thing that they failed miserably... It's the one and only Mamamoo...
If any newer gen fans take this as offense, call me conservative, go ahead: as idols, their main selling point is a song. They sell albums and concerts, which core product is a song. I regard the dance and performance, but they are first and foremost, a singer. A singer sings. They could take a break during a song, personally I appreciate a missed note or funny strained voice (we still support them anyway) rather a "perfect" robotic lipsynced live performance. It takes away the "live" meaning 😔
considering all of b1a4 were literally ALL teenagers when they debut with ok gurr neoegeman yesseuman mwodeunjii da haejeulgeeeee. their vocals were insane for teens 🥰
Where's Super Junior though? This list feels illegal if they're not included here in the 2nd gen vocals club 😂 Specially KRY, their vocals are just chef's kiss
taeil from block b did not belt very very good for three and the half times for the current gen to be lipsyncing. 2nd gen is truly the era where u can hear the actual vocals from continents away 😂
![Megan Thee Stallion - Mamushi (Remix) [feat. TWICE] [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5c0_u9PsrsQ/mqdefault.jpg)
As expected from INFINITE👑👑
Infinite in the thumbnail so I clicked fast ❤
7:41✨ INFINITE
INFINITE VOCAL KINGS
thank you for bringing my men Infinite
INFINITE always have standart for Live VOICE in Live Performance.... KINGFINITE is one of the Best LIVE SINGING in KPOP industry until today... 2nd Generation KPOP trully GEM❤
For those who doubted bigbang singing live, just listen to TOP's adlibs, and their shouts. Bigbangs interaction with the fans during a performance is superb.
infinite♡♡ which made me to become kpop fan and yeah!!! they are live singing king♡ and cd eaters!! the only group that i like every each and one of their songs!!
Pleasure to see you my fellow inspirit 🎉
Now day just battle dance 😅😅😅 with loud music, I think because of that everyone still hearing they're song still, even I'm still back to old kpop song, and yeah I'm Old
You can distinguish what they say either. Back then we easily know what they said since their voice is louder than the music.
And same, i stuck with first and 2nd generation kpop... Ballad... Trot.
I don't even know what's popular since 2017 let alone this new generation or those viral stuffs. Too busy rewatching old kpop mv and jamming on my days off🤣🤣
this video without Super Junior, the kings of vocal, is not full
thank you for including B2ST / HIGHLIGHT. they are KINGS of vocal indeed.
INFINITE 💛 FIGHTING
my King ...always King real king ..called BIGBANG
They are the definition of live performance
Minus Seungri
OT4 GIRLIE FOREVER💕
NO UGLY MONSTERS😍💖
Toxic fans rise nowdays because delusional kids who had to spending money without received the correct service from the artists. Follow trendy without knowing what it's. The empty body without soul who's not know what they need. Body full of greed. Living in an acquisitive society 😢
2nd gen the best ❤
Most of the outfit of the 2nd gen from the live performancr originated from G-Dragon, even the mannerism.😄
no wonder, he's the trendsetter back then
As a fan from the same era, I would like to congratulate and say "You've worked hard, guys" to all my 2nd gen groups❤
Also, I agreed with your statement on 3:25 > Hand mic barely or not even used now as lipsynch is common already. Another thing, as I remember, most of 2nd gen idols are always "competing" in making adlibs or singing high note when they performed. That's why there's exist a battle in high note in shows before. Not a battle in lipsynch.
Edited: I'm crying and felt overwhelmed because you include B.A.P in this video😭 They're talented but the company was shitty on them.
You included all of my favorites! Beast/Highlight, Block B, Infinite, Shinee, and Big Bang! The other groups also have songs that I love! I really miss 2nd gen. The new gen is all about performance and making this impressive dance/stage which is great in a way but I listen to music because I love music and I want to hear live vocals. It is just so different and I really miss the performances that the live vocals brought us, the different mixes or the surprise ad-libs that we hadn't heard before. Ugh, it was so good.
Thank you for introducing some new groups like Block B (I like Zico as solo artist), B.A.P... I knew most 2nd gen groups, just never grew into them. I think 2PM reminds me of Rain. 🤔
Even though all the groups were amazing, somehow only Bigbang’s live performance stood out and with a different exciting vibe. 😂 T.O.P also spiced things up. 😉
Still waiting for your In-depth guide to BIGBANG series!
Thanks 🙏 working hard on it 💪🏼
Bigbang is a King of Live performance, the Facial Expression the Gesture and the Emotions of the song that they Singging tells the story about... 👑👑👑👑👑💛💛💛💛💛
wow again another pure nostalgia trip from you. And as BBC, special thank you for including Block B. They are my second favorite right after BIGBANG and it always makes me sad to see them excluded even tho they had multiple hits through the years just because they are more recognized locally not much globally. ^~^
Yes, because the popular groups nowadays are not setting the right standards their overrated popularity is actually detrimental to the quality of kpop tasteless bandwagoners are lapping whatever comes out of this side of the world just because it's trending.
The title should be more like, why *** is not the best and their fans should stop setting them up on a high pedestal because it's embarrassing. I said what I said.
👏👏👏
Agreed 💯 😎🔥
i feel like i wanted answers from these hugely popular idols who in terms of talent is obviously lacking. aren't they embarrass esp if their fans glorified them and they can't even deliver?
@@jammooolaaah well, they're here for the money, not for the craft
Finally! Someone who thinks like me! 2nd gen is really the best! I don't understand the point of having lipsynch! I understand they are overworked but too frequent is not a good think! One reason I'm a yg stan open mics!
Big Bang 👑
Bigbang's live perfomance are just insane.indeeded Kings of kpop.
They just slay 🔥.
What a great compilation of 2nd gen live, Thanks a lot for this video, love it. I really miss Bigbang's live stages.
😅 This is really nostalgic, i remember infinite (and also maybe Vixx) was the best for synchronized dance at the beginning of that decade (2010s), then Exo came with even better dance, and after that all the groups became more concerned with dance than vocal...
I don't know from when, for sure the groups of that generation still have good quality live vocals...
indeed, from the beginning lipsync was always there, but it's not as bad as now...
INFINITE 💛💛💛💛💛💛
That's why I say 2nd gen groups, no matter bg or gg, are in their own element. People can argue with the wall.
Infinite 💛
Even when they are mostly bashed for their voice at first but we see they progressing and improve each comeback.
Also 2nd generation kpop having so many concepts and didn't stuck with same melody for their songs like nowdays the songs from some groups just sounds the same with their other songs too.
We got ballad specialist group too like the seeya and 2AM which is rare or maybe already extinct now.
And back then we don't take it too hard over our idols talking to other groups with different gender.
I’m enough with the excuse “their dance are so hard that to sing is too much”
2nd gen dances is not that easy either I think.
So rather that giving excuses and lip-syncing just to look good, better they show what they’re best at.. 😄
I don’t think 2nd gen are the best or flawless, but they’re not faking their performance and give their best.. that’s why I love them 😍
Totally agree with you girl
That excuse contradict so much with the pride kpop fans used to have in saying "Kpop idols can dance hard and still sing very well" when comparing Kpop idols to other (mostly American and English) artists' live vocals and performances. What happened to that? Now it's all about "idols don't need to be good at singing. Visuals and dance are where it at"
Being able to sing live and having stable live vocals were still important during 2nd gen. I think the over editing and processing the Korean music shows love to do excessively on live singings now doesn't help either.
And I think a lot of idols and producers or whoever making the decisions seem to forget that adlibs, the background harmony, just random shouting and hyping each other (which can't be done with the mics off) are what makes the live performances different from just listening to stereo versions. And endearing to the audiences.
Could you do a video about Bigbang idol interactions? I miss 2nd gen so much, and while I've seen clips of BB together with other 2nd gen artists before, the videos aren't easy to find, so it would be nice to have a compilation! It's also always cute seeing 3rd gen artists fanboying/girling over them.
In my opinion bigbang live performance is more interesting than their MV, and I think a lot of VIP have the same though as me. that's why bigbang never win if its about a MV views 🤣🤣
Golden Era 🔥🔥🔥
Infinite❤
La presentación de the eye de infinite hubiera sido perfecta para este video 🥰
2nd gen just SLAY✨
They have it all
even the fans are fantastic
most of the idols are friends
I miss all my 2nd gen groups ❤
Kpop groups should give excellent vocals, and performance that the audience will injoy. Coz thats what the fans paid for, and they deserve it. So far, 2nd gen is slay and worth it to watch.
Ur video makes me realized why i never into kpop, when i was teenager, i prefered ballad n hip hop eg jo sungmo n dj doc, i mean i was there since beginning, i remember in my school days, Kangta was very popular in my country mostly becoz of his good look, similar with TVXQ, esp jaejoong...eventho they have great vocal n amazing choreos, but i felt they were boring.....their vocals mostly have similar tones n styles, while the music not interesting at all... they didn't evoke any emotions from me....until i saw bigbang...i felt in love at the 1st sight while watching their documentary in 2006...till now only bigbang can give so much emotions with their music n talents, they maybe not the best vocalists or dancers but definitely the best performers 👑👑👑👑👑
Wow 2nd gen.. miss a lot old kpop
Thank you for mentioned Block B, I'm happy their company still apply the journey of Block B to their trainee or junior like Ateez.
I miss 2nd gen vibe when they have more songs that also more focus on vocal not like just edm/hiphop music that louder than their vocal and you can see 2nd gen they are more passionate when perform also don't forget they know how to make stage alive 😂
love the thumbnail 💛💛💛
Seungri beat boxing 🖤🖤🖤
Feel sory for Block B and BAP. They are true warriors
I feel bad for B.A.P 😢 their agency is the worst.
Gen 2 adalah grup2 yg patut diapresiasi dan kompetisi mereka saat itu kuat dan fair karena memang yg jual suara jauh lebih dihargai dari yg cuman jual tampang, dan bukankah mereka penyanyi ya yg dijual ya suaralah jangan beralasan ini itu klo mo battle dance ya jadi dancer aja klo mo battle visual ya jadi model aja 😅
zaman now alias 2017 ke atas VOCAL belakangan, Lihat dulu apa cakep , bisa dance keren apalagi kalau bisa ngerap cepat.. vocal standar dan sering lipsing pun tidak masalah...
I believe that I got used to the real talents of the 2nd Gen.. Hope the new ones will prove they worth the title too..
B2NEBANG!! MY FAVE GROUP!! 2NE1, BEAST, BIGBANG!!B
bigbang king of kpop
I wish we can have one concert by 2nd gen groups for the 2nd gen fans but this is practically impossible.. not to mention the missing members in some of the groups now🥲 No matter how popular kpop is now, these 2nd gen groups are still the best in my heart.
My only Infinite is the best always🙏🇺🇲🇵🇭
How can you speak about vocal LIVES without Super Junior when they have KRY.
There only one Super, Ultimate Live singing group and that is LEGENDARY, KING INFINITE.
😀😃😄😁❤❤❤❤👍👏👏👏👏👏 Beast/Highlight jjang! Forever fighting. Thank you for this acknowledgement to their awesomeness
I screamed when Beast/Highlight appeared... Their music & live vocals always a blessing to my ears. Proud being a Beast /Highlight long time fan.
2nd Gen era definitely remains superior.
back when kpop fans werent angry psychos, and the kpop was actually korean POP. they had more fun on stage! i was able to meet a bunch after live stages back then
This is a super feels trip somehow haha
gen 2 the best era of kpop... 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Infinite all is always the best love them 😖😍🇺🇲🇵🇭😘🥰😍
Wait I’m confused. I completely agree that idols sung live more often back then. But some of the stages seem to still be lip synced that you showed. It’s sometimes hard for me to tell what is lip synced and what isn’t nowadays😅 Regardless, I’m glad you’re introducing these groups to more people.
Bodoh nye die nie.
The best live performance ever are bigbang!
I noticed that 2gen don't pretend to sing when they took break and the backtrack is playing, they just keep dancing and back to singing when they're comfortable with
It was the golden era and I'm glad I was part of it
yesss b.a.p 😍😍😍 best absolute perfect performance!!
I forgot just how good yang yoseob vocal is, he's really one of the best 2nd gen vocalists.
2nd gen best gen
I see BIGBANG I click
The group that "created" synchronized dance were Super Junior, "U" was the first kpop song with a coreo like that.
Yeahhh New Video 🎉
second gen will always be the best, doesnt matter how many new generations pop out. ✌🏻
Infinite the best
Now I'm going to have to dig out all my Block B stuff and listen to it all again. Mind you, it is a bit mean to say that everyone mimes these days. Many of the good ones do massive tours and all sing live.
I think it deserves mention that SHINee always sang live (still does) while doing very difficult and complex choreography. Thanks also to SHINee for starting the trend of posting dance practice videos. And their dance practice vids were real dance practices, not the perfected "let's pretend we're practicing" videos of today. I love many groups across all generations, but it's sad that the companies today rely so heavily on the mechanical rather than the organic.
Totally agree
2nd gen slay.
Many idols name Sandeul as one of the best 2nd gen singers
Miss when they all sing live on stage...
Practice breath singing while choreograph
Hand held mic do still exist and this gen 3 group is known for using hand held mic. Only 2 of their comeback they ditched it to prove that they absolutely can dance, it's their clap back to all the haters who's leaving very negative critics. All the members from this gen 3 group are all-rounder. The only thing that they failed miserably...
It's the one and only Mamamoo...
If any newer gen fans take this as offense, call me conservative, go ahead: as idols, their main selling point is a song. They sell albums and concerts, which core product is a song. I regard the dance and performance, but they are first and foremost, a singer. A singer sings. They could take a break during a song, personally I appreciate a missed note or funny strained voice (we still support them anyway) rather a "perfect" robotic lipsynced live performance. It takes away the "live" meaning 😔
Beast😍😍😍😍😍
For me it's Bigbang and B2st HIghlight
2ND GENE K-POP IDOLS ARE THE BEST!! SUPERB!! & THE KINGS OF K-POP WORLD!! MY FAV 2ND GENE!! Among them is our "The King Of K-pop : BIGBANG" 🌟
Bcs basically BB are the KINGS of K-POP! Nobody even can be close to their aura🥹
Uve got real great quality content. Love love love and keep at it (づ￣ ³￣)づ
Yesss Big bang❤
hope youll show ukiss someday. OG ukiss.
considering all of b1a4 were literally ALL teenagers when they debut with ok gurr neoegeman yesseuman mwodeunjii da haejeulgeeeee.
their vocals were insane for teens 🥰
Where's Super Junior though? This list feels illegal if they're not included here in the 2nd gen vocals club 😂 Specially KRY, their vocals are just chef's kiss
taeil from block b did not belt very very good for three and the half times for the current gen to be lipsyncing. 2nd gen is truly the era where u can hear the actual vocals from continents away 😂
7:41 INFINITE 💛😌
i was expecting some clips of current generation lipsync ing
INFINITES ❤️🔥
Infinite 💙
i saw infinite live, too. 2013.
Bigbang tus patrones
ps: im a huuge SHAWOL.
Infinite 💛💛♾️♾️♾️
what genre are you talking about shinee they created???????
Make a girlgroup version