This is a clip from The Pat McAfee Show presented by Westwood One. MERCH: store.patmcafe... Use Promo Code "PayTheBills" and get $20 off your first SeatGeek purchase.
Eli Manning Trading Card Stats: + Immunity to “Patriots” + 100% increase in performance during Playoffs + Guarantees one amazing throw in a Super Bowl - 0.500 Record - Will lead the league in interceptions 3 times - Inherent derp face
The 2011 NFC Championship Game explains all of Eli's career in one game. The hits, the throws, the 4th quarter comeback, the OT win, and even the memes. Will always love that man.
EtherealMind he was good. Not incredible. I’d say he is a HOF but I don’t agree with being first ballot. Him beating TB12 two times in SB’s is good enough for me tbh.
Renaissance Man crazy since he’s achieved more in his career than you have your entire life but we’ll leave that be because I don’t want to risk sounding as salty as you do right now lmao.
papageorgio419 wym The Mario Manningham throw was easily a top 3 perfect passes in anyone’s Top 3 it fell in his hands in double coverage in the super bowl in the giants final drive down 3 points
As of today, I don't think he'll get in first ballot. The last 6 seasons are too fresh in people's minds. In 5 years, I don't think that will have faded enough for the HOF voters to overlook and vote him in first ballot. Year 2 or 3 will be my guess.
Being a jets fan I always liked to rag on eli manning,but he won 2 super bowls and played for a long time even if he wasn't always consistent so I gotta give it to him
Says you!!! There is plenty of doubt about the quality of his average at best career. Unless, by you mean by “joining”. Eli is required to buy a ticket to see his brothers bust like the rest of us.
Renaissance Man he stopped Tom Brady and the pats from having 8 super bowl wins plus he’s in the top ten for passing yards and touchdowns he’ll get in first ballet
It’s gonna be interesting because he’s got a strong argument both for and against him going into the HOF. I believe he’ll get in, but Deion Sanders made a good point when he was asked about Eli getting into the HOF
Gravivector 😂😂🤦♂️🤦♂️ Jim doesn’t even have 200 tds my guy he threw more ints in his career and in Eli second Super Bowl run had something like 4900 yards if he wins 2 more games that year probably mvp 16 tds in the 4qter of those games that year too he has more wins than Jim so no Jim shouldn’t be in....so I answer your questions answer mine should Marino be in even tho he has 0 championships I think farve is in he’s the all time int leader and only 1 championship
Gravivector just because your Jim guy threw more picks than tds for his career doesn’t mean u can put the era in on it terry bradshaw was in that same era and had 60 more tds if anyone from those raiders teams should be in it’s the coach Flores and yeah Eli had a bad completion% but for more then half his career the offense was made to run the football and take deep shots plus our wr and tons of option routes so they and Eli had to be on the same page and he couldn’t scramble lmaoooo he’s a pocket qb did Payton ever have 50 rushing yards in a game no so idk what to tell u bud but I definitely know my football and don’t just watch highlights I know this and besides eli was a back up for what 6 games Jim was a backup half his career so forget about your boy Jim he’s 🗑 pick a different qb
Justin Vela now you are comparing eras??? They didn’t nearly thi was much in the 70-80’s. Eli numbers are a joke in the passing era. Wait till he is eligible for the Hall. He won’t even be in the top 10. He isn’t the best QB in his draft class. Not even the second best. The fact you have to argue he is Hall worthy means HE ISNT!!!!
This is the reason that makes me come and check every single day. Yeah, Eli has been through some shitty years, but maaaaan, he used to be impeccable. Thanks Pat, you are also a class act.
Thank you Pat Mcafee so much finally listening to a broadcaster who have nothing but positive things to say about Eli Manning yesterday it was so hard listening to the negativity! A quarterback who I'm going to miss playing dearly. I can't wait to his nephew plays I hope he comes to the Giants
Imagine a world where the Pats have 2 more SBs and a perfect record to go with it. The only man to do a (slightly) bigger service to the world was Stanislav Petrov who saved the world from a nuclear holocaust in 1983.
How many years did Eli have a great offensive line? Really? He ended up with shell shock with in the middle of his career...what Eli did is absolutely amazing!!! I always said when all giants fans were coming down on him that..."you'll miss him when he's gone"...I promise!!!
Realistically it was the defense that won them the 2 championships. Manning contributed, but neither he nor Brady were that great in either game. Rewatch the last drive of the first SB. He should have been intercepted at least twice and had to rely on someone catching the ball against their head.
It’s probably the most underrated ability for a WR. The instinctual awareness to know when/how to get down and avoid kill shots. I’ve seen great WRs in college who could and couldn’t. The difference in their careers was huge when it came to availability and playing at as close to 100% healthy as possible.
People that say Eli was never a top 5 QB ever in his career must have missed 2011. The man was a beast in 2011. Top 5 no doubt that year. The same year he said he was an elite QB and everybody laughed at him. Well it turned out he was an elite QB that season. He basically willed the team to the playoffs that year and finally got some help from the defense during the playoffs. Played his ass off that year during the regular season and the playoffs. Plus he beat Tom Brady and the Patriots that year in Super Bowl 46 with a masterful throw to Mario Manningham in the clutch.
Manning has been a victim of the Giants organization being terrible at football. Every single year he would carry a sorry ass team to the playoffs and somehow manage to win because he had that clutch gene. The man had more 4th quarter comebacks every year than some quarterbacks called "elite" have in their career. Sure the last leg of his career made him look bad, and he'll always live in the shadow of his brother Peyton, but Eli carved a very nice career out for himself up there in that awful NY team. I'm a Patriots fan but I have mad respect for the lad.
Azure Kite what are you talking about dude his defense held possibly the best offense in NFL history to 14 points in the super bowl and you wanna say Eli Carried them😂😂 jesus
felipe borre He did carry them to the win, he had to lead the final drive to get the lead, the Giants also had a longer time of possession in that game.
@@felipeborre6698 well apparently you can't read properly. I said he carried the team to the playoffs. I said his defense decided to show up in the playoffs. The defense was bottom 5 in the league during the regular season. They would have been an 5 or 6 win team if it wasn't for Eli's 4th quarter heroics that season. Read before commenting please.
Renaissance Man I know Eli is in top 10 for TDS, yards, has 2 super bowl MVPs and was an Ironman for over 200 games. He has more wins, yards, and TDS than joe Montana who’s a y’all of famer. If joes in Eli is. If the people who are already in the hall set the bar, Eli at least meets it, if not exceeds it.
TheDayman They say he is not Hall of Famer because he ended his career with a .500 record, which is a shitty argument considering that there are quarterbacks in the Hall of Fame with losing records and he is top 10 all time in passing yards and touchdown passes and unless if I am mistaken, and quarterback that is top 10 all time in both of those categories will definitely get in.
Joh Mine ummm no? His second super bowl run he was definitely a top 5 QB. Also he played in a league with Brees, Rodgers, Peyton, and Tom Brady. That’s top 4 spots taken right off the bat. Get the everliving fuck out of here. Also Big Ben how could I forget
TheDayman it’s laughable to think he is lol he’s not better than his brother, brees, Brady, Big Ben, Rodgers. Eli got carried by a hot D twice in the playoffs. Dude is a turnover machine I’d be shocked to see him in the hall
My mans is top 8 of all time passing yards, is two time Super Bowl MVP, 4 time pro bowler and 2 time first team all pro. and people have the audacity to say he’s not first ballot
QB of my childhood will always have massive respect for this man Moms a pats fan so u can imagine how,excited i was as a kid to see him topple the pats not once but twice 😁
@@ArchWolfVegasEditor Because they pick on him about the fact that he was a .500 quarterback, but it's a baseless argument, considering that there are quarterbacks in the Hall of Fame with a losing record and quarterbacks that are top 10 all time in both passing yards and touchdown passes, like he is will never not make it to the Hall of Fame.
I think Eli definitely deserves to be in the Hall of Fame. He definitely had some downsides but he was a very important figure in the league for years. 2-0 Super Bowl record is better than 99% of the league.
Last year everyone was saying aaron rodgers was regressing, this year they built an actual team around him and he nearly reaches the super bowl. Imagine what woulda happened if they built a team around Eli like they did earlier in his career. He's been statistically good over the last couple years despite having no o-line for like 5 years ina row
Yes, Marino would want a SB. But that doesn’t take away from him being a Hall of Famer. He was league MVP. Lead every major QB category when he retired. Was the best QB of his era. All without a ring. Eli isn’t that. Not even close to that. SB are a team trophy. Not individual. Eli was never close to the best QB of his era even while winning 2 rings. The Hall is for individual achievements.
@@renaissancemen1 Marino is a worthy hall of famer and a world of talent. But get out of town, I'll take Joe Montana any day. Winners win when it counts and that only shows up in the rings.
Slade Wilson stop!! Dumbest comment ever. Winners win. Is that on your bedroom wall above the computer you play fortnite at??? Montana was surrounded by hall of famers. Marino made average players good.
The year before Joe Namath won that Superbowl, he was the first quarterback to throw for 4000 yards. And that was in less games. Joe was the best player for 2 years. Eli was never the best quarterback or even top 3 even during his best years.
This dude scared me for years. No matter if the team was stacked or not.. Eli would show up during games against my 49ers. He was a monster against us. I feel he's pulling the trigger to soon, there's plenty of teams that could use him. Damn I'm getting old.. The mannings no longer play football..
Coming from a Giants fan, I’m sad to see him go but also glad. He’s done a lot for my team and I’m grateful we had him but it’s time for him to go. We need to overhaul our whole team though, Barkley can’t run us into the Super Bowl.. we need a good coach, a good offensive line and especially a better defense
He absolutely deserves the first round ballot. I’ve heard multiple arguments today for why he shouldn’t be invited and why he should, this has been the best argument in favor of him so far.
The people of NY are not in the "what have you done for me lately" mindset. Eli manning is beloved in NYC and NYS. Him beating the undefeated pats is one of the greatest days of my life. I live that man
Eli had three great receivers whose careers were cut short because of injuries Nicks(2 great years),Cruz(3 great years) and Steve Smith(2 great years).He had only 2 Top Ten Defenses(Roethslisberger had 7)and they failed to keep top quality runners and linemen for most of his career.
as a huge giants fan, I will never forget Eli! He was a great QB and I wouldnt of wanted anyone else during the time he played. I got his Jersey when I was around 10 my first jersey and I still refuse to wear it. I have it framed and waiting for the day he signs it lol. WONT HAPPEN but its a dream
i believe the 117-117 does not include his post season game wins so technically he is above .500... and those super bowl runs were amazing and he was a comeback clutch king for many 4th Quarter come back games...and an iron man never missing a start..i think the joe namath example is great...eli did have ALOT MORE of those special moments...he will get into the HOF
Tbh him getting a .500 in his career record is a W. For him being a city and a franchise icon he didn’t get treated like the others in the nfl I’ve seen and tbh some of their biggest wins in their franchise while he was there was because he made some big play to either keep them in the game or win them the game. His last few years will always be a reason on why he shouldn’t be in but he didn’t have his long time head coach and offensive coordinator but I think he should get in because of how he’s won and boy for a QB who was a little inconsistent in games he definitely won and played well at the biggest and most important times. A lot of young QBs nowadays don’t have that
After going through the comments, the only common things are... 1: Most think Eli is a hall of famer (to which I agree) 2: There's a person going by "Renaissance Man" that seems to reply to every single positive comment about Eli trying his best to hate on both the fans and Eli's career. Such a sad sad person to go to such lengths. I at least got a chuckle out of it.
*Eli was already a HOF by 2016* If he had retired in 2016, his stats would have been across the board better than Troy Aikman and Warren Moon, for example. His win/loss % would have been 20 games above 500.
Check out Terry Bradshaw’s stats, I didn’t believe them until I checked them myself: 212 TD 210 INT 166.6 y/g 51.9% Cmp% 70.9 QB Rating 4 Super Bowls lol
To be fair with Eli. He had a 78-57 record. He already won two super bowls with that record. He had one more good year in 2016 but the giants didn’t really help him. The past three years is when his record really started to dip.
Imagine sitting at the bar and chatting with a stranger that just happens to be the dad to the Manning brothers and commenting that your son just got a promotion to assistant manager in a CPA firm? A father with 2 sons having won Super Bowls is just insane.
Man.. I'm a Cowboys fan, and it hurt ME a lil for you to say he wasn't successful because of his record.. If he had the coaching and a good team around him his whole career, like Brady, he'd be wearing 5 rings.. That's hard for me to say, but come on, to say a 2x SB MVP wasn't successful? Wtf
Look at Eli's last playoff series. He was on another level and his WRs let him down. A bad GM and a poorly constructed team only allowed him to play in the playoffs once since his last Superbowl win. Like Pat said, the wins don't tell the full story. Eli in the playoffs was a showtime talent. He's a role model QB that deserved to be in the hall of fame
![FNAF vs TF2 - Episode 2 [SFM]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/z5b3V2-VLb0/mqdefault.jpg)
The Giants also didn’t do him any favors. Didn’t he have a bad line, and the quality of coaches? Cause I remember Eli Manning taking hit after hit.
Chef 2K was league leader in times sacked like 3 times i think 😂
He’s not mobile obviously but you have a point, he was like Andrew Luck but for 16 years
He had a horrible offensive line for the latter half of his career. They completely wasted his talent.
He never had a line, or a top RB or WR till Saquon and OBJ.
That defense absolutely did him lots of favors
Eli Manning Trading Card Stats:
+ Immunity to “Patriots”
+ 100% increase in performance during Playoffs
+ Guarantees one amazing throw in a Super Bowl
- 0.500 Record
- Will lead the league in interceptions 3 times
- Inherent derp face
-The tyree catch
-the manningham catch
-the Odell catch
I am patriots fan and I know Eli had our number. (Hurts me to say this)
Lol derp face smacking around the GOAT.
I would take that on my team for 16 years. Also never missed a game due to injury ever
@@ChillHandle12 What about 15-1 packers learn the game Holla
The 2011 NFC Championship Game explains all of Eli's career in one game. The hits, the throws, the 4th quarter comeback, the OT win, and even the memes. Will always love that man.
ELI MANNING MOST UNDERAPPRECIATED ATHLETE IN NY SPORTS HISTORY
WHAT HE DO NEXT GAME GREATEST THROW IN SUPERBOWL HISTORY WITH CHAMPIONSHIP AT STAKE
Just to add he built a big add on in Mississippi’s children’s hospital
Got a drone job coming up where we are going to video the new construction. It’s awesome
Wow. Cant believe he would use a children’s hospital for advertisement. despicable
@@nickjohnbrodeur where u live I'm interested never seen someone with my last name on here
KingEnvy SquadUp new jersey
@@nickjohnbrodeur ahh I'm from Mass so we only 3 hrs away from where I'm at lol
And keep in mind he would be ahead of Philip Rivers for most consecutive starts by a qb if Ben Mcadoo hadn’t benched him for a game in 2017
Poor Eli, getting his record broken by some shitty head coach. For Geno Smith nonetheless
McAdoo was correct for his decision. Manning has been horrible for 8 years. Oh! And showing up to do your job should get you a trophy.
@@renaissancemen1 it got him 2 Lombardi's, and a delayed future bust in Canton. All hail your derp take.
eddie bear yes. That’s about all he did. Was show up.
Renaissance Man showing up doesn’t get you a super bowl.
“Can’t say successful”
>goes on to give examples of how successful he was...
2 Super Bowls is enough Success Eli is good & other Pro Athletes will never accomplish that
Guess football is not a team sport because Eli had .500 record. This guy is an idiot so I stopped watching after five minutes.
Pat said award winning so basically Eli had a fall from grace
The defense also is largely responsible for those SB wins!
The Mannings are football royalty and Eli truly seems like a good dude...sure he’s going in!! Best Wishes moving forward #10
agreed
@EtherealMind apparently being top 10 in completions, passing yards, and touchdowns all time means his stats suck
EtherealMind he was good. Not incredible. I’d say he is a HOF but I don’t agree with being first ballot. Him beating TB12 two times in SB’s is good enough for me tbh.
I liked how eli announced that he was gonna announce his retirement in Friday.
Friday can’t come soon enough. Dude has been irrelevant for 8 years.
Michael Eli is the most mediocre qb to be considered for the first round hof
Michael had a career built on 2 wins. Eli was washed ever since his 2nd super bowl
Michael I was never benched for Geno Smith. Or a over drafted rookie.
Renaissance Man crazy since he’s achieved more in his career than you have your entire life but we’ll leave that be because I don’t want to risk sounding as salty as you do right now lmao.
First Antonio Gates, then Luke Kuechly, and now Eli? What a year!
Jack Shipman don’t forget about Andrew Luck
And Darren sproles
@@maxlockett6732 Noooo!!
@@maxlockett6732 not Hof but great player
And Marshawn... again
Manningham was one of the best passes I’ve ever seen , Eli’s a HOF
The Hall of Fame has really been watered down so yeah...why not.
papageorgio419 wym The Mario Manningham throw was easily a top 3 perfect passes in anyone’s Top 3 it fell in his hands in double coverage in the super bowl in the giants final drive down 3 points
Manning is a Hall of Famer in spite of the Giants.
This.
No way the HOF keeps Eli out. Gotta have all the Mannings in there. They're already designing the Manning Family section in the hall.
As of today, I don't think he'll get in first ballot. The last 6 seasons are too fresh in people's minds. In 5 years, I don't think that will have faded enough for the HOF voters to overlook and vote him in first ballot. Year 2 or 3 will be my guess.
@@tohrazul definitely 2nd or 3rd but he'll get there if Strahan took two tries it should take Eli the same
Ryan great point. Every Manning should get in. Cooper and even Mario.
Being a jets fan I always liked to rag on eli manning,but he won 2 super bowls and played for a long time even if he wasn't always consistent so I gotta give it to him
Eli Manning was true professional
DEFINITION OF FRANCHISE QB FOR A DECADE AND A HALF
He will join his brother in the HOF no doubt
Says you!!! There is plenty of doubt about the quality of his average at best career. Unless, by you mean by “joining”. Eli is required to buy a ticket to see his brothers bust like the rest of us.
Renaissance Man he stopped Tom Brady and the pats from having 8 super bowl wins plus he’s in the top ten for passing yards and touchdowns he’ll get in first ballet
Renaissance Man even though the argument against him is very strong he is pretty much a lock for the hall of fame based of the other stuff.
It’s gonna be interesting because he’s got a strong argument both for and against him going into the HOF. I believe he’ll get in, but Deion Sanders made a good point when he was asked about Eli getting into the HOF
@@123blakes8 only cuz he played for so long...longevity should not mean anything if you weren't elite. Eli was never top 5 in his era
Eli is a stud. The guy who threw the pass of some of the most memorable receptions in History.
Number 7 all time in passing yards and tds too
Gravivector and he deserves to be in the hall of fame
Gravivector no he doesn’t he never won a championship does Marino deserve to be in even tho he didn’t win anything or who’s your QB
Gravivector 😂😂🤦♂️🤦♂️ Jim doesn’t even have 200 tds my guy he threw more ints in his career and in Eli second Super Bowl run had something like 4900 yards if he wins 2 more games that year probably mvp 16 tds in the 4qter of those games that year too he has more wins than Jim so no Jim shouldn’t be in....so I answer your questions answer mine should Marino be in even tho he has 0 championships I think farve is in he’s the all time int leader and only 1 championship
Gravivector just because your Jim guy threw more picks than tds for his career doesn’t mean u can put the era in on it terry bradshaw was in that same era and had 60 more tds if anyone from those raiders teams should be in it’s the coach Flores and yeah Eli had a bad completion% but for more then half his career the offense was made to run the football and take deep shots plus our wr and tons of option routes so they and Eli had to be on the same page and he couldn’t scramble lmaoooo he’s a pocket qb did Payton ever have 50 rushing yards in a game no so idk what to tell u bud but I definitely know my football and don’t just watch highlights I know this and besides eli was a back up for what 6 games Jim was a backup half his career so forget about your boy Jim he’s 🗑 pick a different qb
Justin Vela now you are comparing eras??? They didn’t nearly thi was much in the 70-80’s. Eli numbers are a joke in the passing era. Wait till he is eligible for the Hall. He won’t even be in the top 10. He isn’t the best QB in his draft class. Not even the second best. The fact you have to argue he is Hall worthy means HE ISNT!!!!
This is the reason that makes me come and check every single day.
Yeah, Eli has been through some shitty years, but maaaaan, he used to be impeccable.
Thanks Pat, you are also a class act.
Thank you Pat Mcafee so much finally listening to a broadcaster who have nothing but positive things to say about Eli Manning yesterday it was so hard listening to the negativity! A quarterback who I'm going to miss playing dearly. I can't wait to his nephew plays I hope he comes to the Giants
Imagine a world where the Pats have 2 more SBs and a perfect record to go with it. The only man to do a (slightly) bigger service to the world was Stanislav Petrov who saved the world from a nuclear holocaust in 1983.
How many years did Eli have a great offensive line? Really? He ended up with shell shock with in the middle of his career...what Eli did is absolutely amazing!!! I always said when all giants fans were coming down on him that..."you'll miss him when he's gone"...I promise!!!
“Can’t say he was successful, he batted .500” ~Pat McAfee
Noah Stern obviously doesnt understand baseball that well lol
Noah Stern yea thatd be the GOAT of baseball
@@henrycavillsrealmustache3553 By a WIDE margin...
Brian White yea thatd be if Mike trout just played in a highschool travel team
lol
He forgot to mention the stop of the undefeated season
Nick Bellomo he said he stopped Tom Brady from 2 Super Bowls?
Realistically it was the defense that won them the 2 championships. Manning contributed, but neither he nor Brady were that great in either game. Rewatch the last drive of the first SB. He should have been intercepted at least twice and had to rely on someone catching the ball against their head.
It’s probably the most underrated ability for a WR. The instinctual awareness to know when/how to get down and avoid kill shots. I’ve seen great WRs in college who could and couldn’t. The difference in their careers was huge when it came to availability and playing at as close to 100% healthy as possible.
Pat McAfee for the HOF !
People that say Eli was never a top 5 QB ever in his career must have missed 2011. The man was a beast in 2011. Top 5 no doubt that year. The same year he said he was an elite QB and everybody laughed at him. Well it turned out he was an elite QB that season. He basically willed the team to the playoffs that year and finally got some help from the defense during the playoffs. Played his ass off that year during the regular season and the playoffs. Plus he beat Tom Brady and the Patriots that year in Super Bowl 46 with a masterful throw to Mario Manningham in the clutch.
Manning has been a victim of the Giants organization being terrible at football. Every single year he would carry a sorry ass team to the playoffs and somehow manage to win because he had that clutch gene. The man had more 4th quarter comebacks every year than some quarterbacks called "elite" have in their career. Sure the last leg of his career made him look bad, and he'll always live in the shadow of his brother Peyton, but Eli carved a very nice career out for himself up there in that awful NY team.
I'm a Patriots fan but I have mad respect for the lad.
Bruh He was Miles behind Brees/ Brady/ Rodgers and even Stafford that season
Azure Kite what are you talking about dude his defense held possibly the best offense in NFL history to 14 points in the super bowl and you wanna say Eli Carried them😂😂 jesus
felipe borre He did carry them to the win, he had to lead the final drive to get the lead, the Giants also had a longer time of possession in that game.
@@felipeborre6698 well apparently you can't read properly. I said he carried the team to the playoffs. I said his defense decided to show up in the playoffs. The defense was bottom 5 in the league during the regular season. They would have been an 5 or 6 win team if it wasn't for Eli's 4th quarter heroics that season. Read before commenting please.
We want Pat in the hall of Fame
Thanks Pat, that is the nicest thing I ever heard about Eli.
Totally agree..I am very appreciative that ELI beat Brady twice.
Really loving Pat McAfee joining my rotation of First Take and Undisputed on YT, he's great
Thank you Pat for saying manning is a first ballot hall of famer. He’s amazing imma miss him
Have you watched football the last 8 years???
Renaissance Man I know Eli is in top 10 for TDS, yards, has 2 super bowl MVPs and was an Ironman for over 200 games. He has more wins, yards, and TDS than joe Montana who’s a y’all of famer. If joes in Eli is. If the people who are already in the hall set the bar, Eli at least meets it, if not exceeds it.
Its laughable how people think he isn't a hall of famer
TheDayman They say he is not Hall of Famer because he ended his career with a .500 record, which is a shitty argument considering that there are quarterbacks in the Hall of Fame with losing records and he is top 10 all time in passing yards and touchdown passes and unless if I am mistaken, and quarterback that is top 10 all time in both of those categories will definitely get in.
not once in his career was he a top 5 qb, let alone top ten coming from a giants fan who watched the giants fall short to the ravens in 01
Joh Mine ummm no? His second super bowl run he was definitely a top 5 QB. Also he played in a league with Brees, Rodgers, Peyton, and Tom Brady. That’s top 4 spots taken right off the bat. Get the everliving fuck out of here.
Also Big Ben how could I forget
@@michaelmartin6389 You mean...the Giants that were quarterbacked by Kerry Collins? What does that have to do with anything?
TheDayman it’s laughable to think he is lol he’s not better than his brother, brees, Brady, Big Ben, Rodgers. Eli got carried by a hot D twice in the playoffs. Dude is a turnover machine I’d be shocked to see him in the hall
Never missed a game in 16 seasons due to injury ..man was tough as nails ..
THATS AMAZING BY ITSELF THE 2 SUPERBOWLS WERE ICING ON THE CAKE
Hey the greatest ever is 0-2 against him. Funny how shit happens.
0/2 in super bowls
@@MineMosh3Jnl No, I meant one on one sexual conquest.
@D D Not against TB.
@D D Oh. Of course. Silly me.
thanks for reacting to it, love the show
Eli was fantastic. He played so well for so long with so few weapons, and such bad teams.
My mans is top 8 of all time passing yards, is two time Super Bowl MVP, 4 time pro bowler and 2 time first team all pro. and people have the audacity to say he’s not first ballot
he's never been an all pro, first or second team, he is probably not first ballot but a for sure hall of famer
@@BitchenMarsRockstar Look at his competition for All-Pro honors: Brady, Brees, Roethlisberger, Rodgers, his brother; you can't hold that against him.
He's not
Tied for 8th all-time in winning percentage in the playoffs with 10 games or over, when it’s supposed to count the most, 8-4, .667
I love Eli, but he was never a 2x 1st team All-Pro. He did win the Walter Payton Man of the Year,(co-winner), and Bart Starr Award though.
QB of my childhood will always have massive respect for this man
Moms a pats fan so u can imagine how,excited i was as a kid to see him topple the pats not once but twice
😁
Eli is not a first ballot, but definitely in the Hall of Fame.
He’s first ballot he’s literally top 8 in passing yards of all time why are people so delusional
Also top 12 in interceptions
@@ArchWolfVegasEditor Because they pick on him about the fact that he was a .500 quarterback, but it's a baseless argument, considering that there are quarterbacks in the Hall of Fame with a losing record and quarterbacks that are top 10 all time in both passing yards and touchdown passes, like he is will never not make it to the Hall of Fame.
@@PeterParkerwon and 6 of those 12 guys who have MORE interceptions than Eli are in the Hall of Fame. What is your point?
Benjamin that just means he played for a long time. Adds to his case if anything
Why do I always feel like pats studio is always changing
You missed two biggest accomplishments
2x Super Bowl MVP 1 of 5 guys to do so
16 years and never missed a game
Pat McAfee can really introduce Eli Manning into Naismith Hall of Fame 🏈
He should get in just because of that performance during super bowl 42. He made so many big plays that day, including the David Tyree catch.
Eli Manning and the Road Warriors. Two of the hardest Superbowl runs in history.
Mcadoo went to the same PA college as me so i was pumped when i saw he got a head coaching job.... lol... RIP IUP :'(
Lol same here IUP IUP but he gave us all a bad name
ShadowTH555 yeah he really did that was probably our only shot to look good in the big lights lol.... at least he can prob do a nice keg stand 🤷🏻♂️
@@Cainb23 yeah you're right but actually the guy that invented RUclips went to IUP lol so we have that XD
The SNL text message courtroom sketch Eli starred in was incredible.
the "hello there" cartwheel with the gut hanging out is amazing
I think Eli definitely deserves to be in the Hall of Fame. He definitely had some downsides but he was a very important figure in the league for years. 2-0 Super Bowl record is better than 99% of the league.
The one and only season I rooted for the Patriots was the year they were undefeated , Eli jacked it up . Thanks Eli .
Anyone hear pat say "He was playing flip cup in a west virginia bar in jersey?"
Pat is clueless about what he says
It was posted on IG eli and daniel jones were playing flip cup in a bar surrounded by their teammates
Green Rock Tap & Grill in Hoboken that has a bunch of WVU flags hanging up and holds watch parties for WVU football games
@@maxmurphy2083 Appreciate the context. This is probably the only scenario where a WV bar in Jersey actually makes sense haha
"West VirginiaN bar in NJ" makes perfect sense
beat the best of all time twice for Super Bowl victories i mean anything else he accomplished is gravy. definite hall of fame.
Last year everyone was saying aaron rodgers was regressing, this year they built an actual team around him and he nearly reaches the super bowl. Imagine what woulda happened if they built a team around Eli like they did earlier in his career. He's been statistically good over the last couple years despite having no o-line for like 5 years ina row
I don't think Dan Marino would describe 2 super bowl rings as "batting .500"
Yes, Marino would want a SB. But that doesn’t take away from him being a Hall of Famer. He was league MVP. Lead every major QB category when he retired. Was the best QB of his era. All without a ring. Eli isn’t that. Not even close to that. SB are a team trophy. Not individual. Eli was never close to the best QB of his era even while winning 2 rings. The Hall is for individual achievements.
@@renaissancemen1 Marino is a worthy hall of famer and a world of talent. But get out of town, I'll take Joe Montana any day. Winners win when it counts and that only shows up in the rings.
he won 117 lost 117 thats why he said that lol
Slade Wilson stop!! Dumbest comment ever. Winners win. Is that on your bedroom wall above the computer you play fortnite at??? Montana was surrounded by hall of famers. Marino made average players good.
@@renaissancemen1 if joe namath made it. eli can
eli is top 10 all time in passing yards, passing touchdowns, and completions. that is a lock for the hall of fame
Amen brother!
Thank u for saying he is good because literally everyone I know bully’s needs about saying Eli is a hofer
Eli was sufficient. But that doesn’t mean he should be in the Hall.
He will make it in the Hall of Fame...but hes not a hall of fame quality quarterback.
The year before Joe Namath won that Superbowl, he was the first quarterback to throw for 4000 yards. And that was in less games. Joe was the best player for 2 years. Eli was never the best quarterback or even top 3 even during his best years.
Renaissance Man Bri I’ve gone to 3 comment strait and you pop up just trying to disagree with everything everyone’s saying. Have some morals.
Tbf Eli is pretty good in pressure situations and he is top ten in passing yards and tds
i would love to see Pat on the Joe Rogan Podcast
*BRO* if he isn’t in the HOF I’m gonna be Pissed
Be pissed. He isn’t getting in. See Jim Plunkett.
This dude scared me for years. No matter if the team was stacked or not.. Eli would show up during games against my 49ers. He was a monster against us. I feel he's pulling the trigger to soon, there's plenty of teams that could use him.
Damn I'm getting old.. The mannings no longer play football..
Coming from a Giants fan, I’m sad to see him go but also glad. He’s done a lot for my team and I’m grateful we had him but it’s time for him to go. We need to overhaul our whole team though, Barkley can’t run us into the Super Bowl.. we need a good coach, a good offensive line and especially a better defense
Well said Pat! 😀👍🏻🥳😎
Eli is one of only 5 players to have multiple Super Bowl MVPs.
Interesting fact: During Eli's iron man streak, he never once saw Polamalu in the C gap.
👀👀👀
The day may come where I find the Polamalu C gap jokes annoying and overused.... but today is not the day
We need to see him in the booth
I always hate it when media members talk about a single player going x-x. Eli didn't go 117-117. The giants went 117-117.
He absolutely deserves the first round ballot. I’ve heard multiple arguments today for why he shouldn’t be invited and why he should, this has been the best argument in favor of him so far.
The people of NY are not in the "what have you done for me lately" mindset. Eli manning is beloved in NYC and NYS. Him beating the undefeated pats is one of the greatest days of my life. I live that man
Eli had three great receivers whose careers were cut short because of injuries Nicks(2 great years),Cruz(3 great years) and Steve Smith(2 great years).He had only 2 Top Ten Defenses(Roethslisberger had 7)and they failed to keep top quality runners and linemen for most of his career.
As a giants season ticket holder, it’s gonna be weird going to the stadium and not seeing 10 lining up under center
If pat was on Eli’s team he would’ve had to retire a few years early
Tyler Spencer he also woulda had a ring soooo
Pat has a ring and Eli Manning is a great qb so get outta here
Cody Ecoffey where did he get a ring?
Holy shit the Indianapolis Colts dude wtf
Beat the bears would have had two but the saints beat us the very next year
as a huge giants fan, I will never forget Eli! He was a great QB and I wouldnt of wanted anyone else during the time he played. I got his Jersey when I was around 10 my first jersey and I still refuse to wear it. I have it framed and waiting for the day he signs it lol. WONT HAPPEN but its a dream
i believe the 117-117 does not include his post season game wins so technically he is above .500... and those super bowl runs were amazing and he was a comeback clutch king for many 4th Quarter come back games...and an iron man never missing a start..i think the joe namath example is great...eli did have ALOT MORE of those special moments...he will get into the HOF
Tbh him getting a .500 in his career record is a W. For him being a city and a franchise icon he didn’t get treated like the others in the nfl I’ve seen and tbh some of their biggest wins in their franchise while he was there was because he made some big play to either keep them in the game or win them the game. His last few years will always be a reason on why he shouldn’t be in but he didn’t have his long time head coach and offensive coordinator but I think he should get in because of how he’s won and boy for a QB who was a little inconsistent in games he definitely won and played well at the biggest and most important times. A lot of young QBs nowadays don’t have that
Love your show.... but if you are “batting” .500 that’s off the charts amazing... maybe use a different analogy 😂
Compare Pats desk from before to now. Wow.
No mater what he still lead one of the most amazing drives of all time against the patriots in the superbowl
Are people forgetting his wrs were also around the leagues leaders in drops?..... Many leading to ints....
After going through the comments, the only common things are...
1: Most think Eli is a hall of famer (to which I agree)
2: There's a person going by "Renaissance Man" that seems to reply to every single positive comment about Eli trying his best to hate on both the fans and Eli's career. Such a sad sad person to go to such lengths. I at least got a chuckle out of it.
First ballot not a doubt or question.
Thanks Pat...recognizing a HOFer.
Brady having 8 rings would be like a human being living in Who Ville.
You and David Dobrik have the best SeatGeek promotions lmaoooo
Can't spell Elite without Eli. See you in Canton, Number 10. You earned it
NFL is definitely changing. All the OGs are retiring. Whose left now? Big Ben, Brees, Rivers, Brady...
*Eli was already a HOF by 2016* If he had retired in 2016, his stats would have been across the board better than Troy Aikman and Warren Moon, for example. His win/loss % would have been 20 games above 500.
Thank god someone finally said it. I’m a giants fan and Eli gets slept on WAY to much
PLEASE. If he wasn’t in NY he wouldn’t even be talked about. Want proof. Look up Jim Plunkett.
Renaissance Man that’s a stupid argument
Check out Terry Bradshaw’s stats, I didn’t believe them until I checked them myself:
212 TD
210 INT
166.6 y/g
51.9% Cmp%
70.9 QB Rating
4 Super Bowls lol
To be fair with Eli. He had a 78-57 record. He already won two super bowls with that record. He had one more good year in 2016 but the giants didn’t really help him. The past three years is when his record really started to dip.
Wins/losses are not a QB stat. Might explain why Namath and Jorgensen are in.
Eli Manning the man who stop the 2007 Patriots 18-1 , I may not like him but he has my upmost respect I wish him well
Does McAfee have multiple studios
I feel like that Aaron Rodgers picture above the 'Pat McAfee show' sign wasn't there before...
1:10 in New York City? 😂 They played in New Jersey
Imagine sitting at the bar and chatting with a stranger that just happens to be the dad to the Manning brothers and commenting that your son just got a promotion to assistant manager in a CPA firm? A father with 2 sons having won Super Bowls is just insane.
That dog is such a good boy. All the yelling and not even bothered...
He was more clutch than his brother in big moments.
Thank you. At least someone who’s talking on shows about football knows wtf they’re talking about
He gave us 18-1. That alone should let him into the Hall.
Man.. I'm a Cowboys fan, and it hurt ME a lil for you to say he wasn't successful because of his record.. If he had the coaching and a good team around him his whole career, like Brady, he'd be wearing 5 rings.. That's hard for me to say, but come on, to say a 2x SB MVP wasn't successful? Wtf
Very cool.
Look at Eli's last playoff series. He was on another level and his WRs let him down. A bad GM and a poorly constructed team only allowed him to play in the playoffs once since his last Superbowl win. Like Pat said, the wins don't tell the full story. Eli in the playoffs was a showtime talent. He's a role model QB that deserved to be in the hall of fame
HOF for Eli no doubt about it.