The judge nailed it when she said they were horrible people. If she brought roaches in there would be more than one to video in the days she was there or even when she left. That was a lie.
I don’t think they ever had any intention of letting her live there. I think they didn’t have enough money to pay there own rent so they scammed her. They should be ashamed of themselves.
How can you determine if somebody’s clean after three days while they are still in the process of unpacking? These guys seem like scammers and probably have done it to countless people in the past
Guy in the hallway at the end, "the judge called you horrible people". Defendants, "that's her opinion." Well it's mine too! Horrible people with no empathy - moving is always chaotic - they should have given her a week to get settled, then say something if it bothered them.
bad verdict . the plaintiff should have received at least one thousand and im a painter and the cost to fix two holes and paint a wall is usually 250 .
@@marleonetti7 Well, had they done what proper landlords do and got actual estimates or fixed it and brought the receipt to show the cost of repair they might've gotten a larger judgment. Editing to add: that's why it's called "rough" justice.
They didn't want to give her the week. that's why they put in the 'three days notice' clause, their son was thinking of moving in but if that fell through then they had her as a back up plan, but son does get to move in, so she's out and they just keep her money as a tip for the discomfort of having to get her to move out! Judge was right, they are horrible people!
True, but I think they freaked out over the roach. There is never ever one lone roach. When there is one, there are hundreds, if not thousands. And once your home is infested with roaches, they are almost impossible to get rid of....unless you get a family of possums. There for a few days & already her room looked like a hoarder's room, plus her junk was scattered all over their home. They said "She took over the house". I think they expected a sweet, soft-spoken, quiet young lady to rent a room, and what they got was a gross, messy hoarder who spread her clutter everywhere & was infesting their home with nasty roaches. I think every one of the commenters being all judgy about the defendants would have done the exact same thing in their shoes. (EDIT: They should not have kept all of that money. Yes, they were wrong to do that.)
I feel for her too. She had to give her dog away and that part where she said she was happy her dog had friends to play with. Wow to move into a place and then have to move out so quickly. She didn't have time to ever get settled. Those guys don't need to be anybody's landlord.
@@mikivanduyn9630 that is so true but she seems like the light doesn't go all the way up to the top of the stairs...or maybe she is going thru something mentally. I feel bad for her I could never give up my pet. 🐕
@@mikivanduyn9630 so you expect her to live on the streets ?????? Maybe she has some character and dosent want to live off the tax payers .. Ever thought about that ???
@@stonew1927 what does that have to do with keeping all her money. They’re thieves. 3 days is not enough to determine if someone is clean or not. They never gave her a chance or even communicated their issues w her. They’re scammers after her money! They kicked her out so the son could move in.
Wait hold on-- we are calling her “messy” because she has a messy room after ONE full 24 hour day of unpacking? My house stayed messed up for a week before you could see the house because of all my sh- was piled up. That’s not legit there’s no way I buy she’s messy
Thats true! Atleast with a house, you have space to organize. She literally had ONE room to put her whole life into. So of course it's gonna be messy for a bit.
After kicking her out while she was still in the process of moving in and then moving their kid in? Seems like this was planned. They knew they were going to kick her out in three days before she even stepped through that door with her things. Those horrible defendants wanted to get some money and didn't care who they hurt.
what nasty men they are.... she had only just moved in of course the room was a mess!!.... and then to try and keep her money damn!! I hope karma bites them hard on there arse
You can’t judge someone’s room while they are in the process of moving. For all we know she was going to go out to get a dresser or containers for her items, but never had the chance to. Not to mention, them going into her room and recording it is sketch. Why didn’t he also include videos of the kitchen? That she apparently made sooo messy only after 2 days of moving in. What a joke. She also didn’t breach the lease if they were the ones that gave her three days notice. I wish he would have said that in front of the judge. And also son?? They almost look identical. I thought they were brothers 🤣
Oh my gosh, the defendants said "that's the judge's opinion of them." Yes, yes it was and every single person watching this episode that's all our opinions too. They were awful people. They threw her out and kept all of her money, I can't even say what I think of them. I guess just to say that they were horrible, no good, awful people.
This wasn't the first person they've done it to, I'd wager this is a nice little scam they are running. Why would you video tape someone's room 2 days into moving in? Obviously it's going to be messy while moving in.
Sheesh! They were a tough crowd! I think they got the news that their kid was returning just as she was moving in and then did what they had to to make her leave. Although the 3 days notice makes me believe that they always knew it was a possibility. & keeping her money was just crazy!
Wow! Judge M really screwed the pooch on this case! I don’t care if the poor girl signed a lease she didn’t quite understand, JM most definitely should have given the Plaintiff much, much more than what she did! How would she like it if someone did that to her kid? Those plaintiffs are rotten, rotten people to do that to that poor girl! They knew dang well what they were pulling on that poor girl. They are very lucky this girl was the one they screwed over because something tells me they most definitely would not have put up with that had that happen to them with a new Landlord!
I'm literally not a dog person but my heart sank when she said she had to give her dog away. Also the cute pic of the puppies Playing together aww, why'd they do this to her 😢
I would say their son wasn't sure if he would be moving in so they deliberately put 3 days on the lease so they could kick her out straight away if they needed to. After she moved in the son decided he wanted to move in so they came up with excuses to kick her out.
Yup Make a Quick Buck and Toss The Source ! Their Both Scumbags Plain and Simple. i'm happy She Won and it's Well Deserved.. She Should of Gotten The Whole Amount Tho.
I literally just wrote the same exact thing I feel these scum bags had this planned out from the start, they posted a "fake 🤥" move in ad on craigslist and had it in their mind to come up 💰 off of a vulnerable person that was in need of a place to stay you can tell they would never wanted a roommate just the money it's the greed for me I feel so bad for this young woman I really do and I pray that she has somewhere safe and is happy now
In my state it would be unenforceable as an illegal provision. I bet most states have laws against this in their landlord tenant acts. I think the judge got it wrong.
@@markwinterstein9398 you are correct. I was surprised that the judge in this case seemed unaware of that. You can not have tenants sign away their rights and their rights are what the law says. If 30 day notice is required by law, then it doen't matter what the lease says.
If there had been a roach he would have taken a picture of it after he killed it. Anyone with a brain would do that if they are trying to make her look bad. yeah the room is messy but she JUST moved in. They should have given her a bit more time to unpack and put things away, even in the kitchen. Moving in is hard to get organized. I think they just realized that the son... was able to come live with them and needed excuses to get her out. It's a bit creepy that they are videoing her room at all. She rented it and it should have been her private place.
@@emo72387 True. they would have to prove it came from her. If there was a photo of it the judge might go with the "more likely than not" angle. but bottom line is, they did not even give her time to umpack and organize. Poor roach didnt' get to setle in either!
A lease with a 3 day notice has got to be a scam they are pulling to get money out of people. How many people have they kicked out quickly and tried to keep the money? I think they found out their kid needed a place to stay and used that lease to their advantage. Trash I tell you.. TRASH
Awesome name QUEENS straight up disgusting 🤢 I wonder who is that kid who moving in is !!! Can’t really say wht I want to b c u tube will bk me but u get my thinking 🤔 unbelievable disgusting 🤢 think about it smh
@@J23-o7u They said it's their son. I don't have a problem with them being gay. Just how they treat others. People of all sexualities can be awful. I think you're implying they're pedophiles. That's a big assumption to make based on a tenant dispute.
The defendants seem very messy over the top and in everyone's business and don't know the do's and don'ts of being a landlord . They took advantage of this young lady and hope nobody ever rents from them.
Yes...what about their rude,crude, 'messy' cheating behaviour(devouring the whole deposit? & slimy 3-day clause) with a young woman...to evict her suddenly without a thought for her safety?
They already had plans for who was going to live there. As you can see, it's someone they know lol they just used her for her money and kicked her out. This case actually pissed me off so much I had to come and write a comment. Leaving someone homeless is not a joke and they take it so lightly. Definitely spoiled kids who have never been through anything. Entitled too. Like she literally PAID MONEY to stay there. It's obvious they wrote the lease the way they wrote it because the whole time they intended to kick her out. Wish she had caught on sooner. Eww.
I absolutely LOVE Judge Milian… her compassion and fairness makes her my all time favorite judge on television. (Keeping in mind I interned for Judge Mathis back in the day) 😂😂😂 #RoughJustice 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾
I don’t have anything juicy 🤷🏾♀️😂 Judge Mathis was super laid back & chill, back then. He always seemed to have a joke or something funny to say when he saw you. 😂🥰 I interned for his show in the early 2000’s. He wasn’t as nearly “uptight” as he seems now. 😩 I usual saw him between tapings. I screened calls, because back then there was an 800# people could call and we’d actually answer the phone - but only when the show was airing in Chicago. On those calls I took ticket requests. I also did transcripts of calls when people left messages for a possible case. And then there was other random stuff. I liked it when they let me sit in the control room during tapings with the executive producer Bo and the shows attorney Gretchen.
I am an owner of 3 houses , and do realise how difficult it is for someone with a dog or cat to get a house to rent . I would never turn a tenant away if they had pets . I love dogs , and understand that they become part of your family once you have them .
I felt for her the whole time but when she had to give the dog up that hit home for me because I was in the same situation where I didn’t know my next move and and my family wasn’t big on the dog and I lived with the dog spot to spot and in my car but I knew I couldn’t keep up with it so I had to give him up
Surely many friends may have wanted not a stranger It us def an expense i hope someday soon to be able to incur but not yet Hope things are better now ?
I saw on Judy Justice (Judge Judy's new show) where she gave back the person everything and used term I've not heard which meant if the judge finds the actions despictable as well as the agreement, then the judge can throw out a signed agreement. I wish this was done here cause she should have gotten more back for that cause she was duped big time.
There are things a court has to look at in order for it to determine it is indeed an unconscionable contract. There are elements that the contract has to have, such as a surprise, bargaining power, dealing with someone of lesser intelligence and so on.
This is why I will never live with someone. I have been living alone since 2018. It is absolutely the best. Peace, cleanliness, order, independence. I can’t go back to having roommates unless I had to and there was absolutely no other way, like facing homelessness. I’d rather live alone and struggle a bit, than to struggle with another human being in the same house. NO WAY
Sounds like a bunch of BS to me, they more than likely had this planned from the get go and it wouldn't surprise me one bit to hear they've done it before. There's no way in hell after 2 or 3 days could you tell everything that they were claiming. Their son is in her room now, that don't even sound right. I know one thing for sure, she needs to start speaking up, stop letting people walk all over her and thinking things are a "typo" or life is gonna be a real struggle. To the wanna be scammin landlords, you reap what you sew, remember that. Think karma.
The defendants were lying i dont believe there was a roach it was just an excuse not to give her,her money back,well at least she had some of her money back
@@WVnurseJo The problem is... she signed a contract that stated a 3 day notification and that over rides any other normal time frames on other leases. The judge cant rule on what most leases are, only on what that lease was. Saying she thought it was a typo... she should have clarified that before signing it. I feel bad for her but she did willingly sign that contract.
In my state, the minimum is 10 days. I lived in my last apartment 17 yrs, I was 17 when I moved in. My landlord sold the building to some very horrible people, I gave those disgusting jerks 10 days, they went up on my rent higher than anyone else in the building after I found them searching through my locked mailbox, I lived there 3x longer than any other person. I found a beautiful condo with cathedral ceilings on the same street, rent was cheaper too.
She's -maybe!- a messy person or a hoarder. Both my parents passed in 2020 and bless her- I am at least one of those too. It drives me mad, but I can't throw my parents' antiques and linens away. Try and keep a corridor- a walkway though sweetheart. But- she never had a chance to settle in, either! The defendants schemed and Judge Milian was not impressed with that. Ahhh, life is messy at times. God bless all you young ones setting out, out there. Especially those starting out with burdens on your backs- you get me? I love you all.🙏🕊🌻☮️🐕🦺🐈🌏
A decent person would have told her to clean up her mess, organize all her stuff, give her one week to do so. Then by that week if she hasn't cleaned it up then start the eviction process. Since the Defendant says his son or their son lives there now, I'm thinking maybe that's why they kicked her out so fast. 🤷♀️
In all honesty, the roach was probably there before she was! I unfortunately lived in a apartment complex that was full of them (only in the summer lol) but usually they're already in the home. They're obviously lying to try to give themselves some room to say that was a valid reason for kicking her out, which it wasn't. Love your comment! Very thoughtful!
I don’t know what state this is in, but in my state the 3 days to leave is an illegal provision and is unenforceable even if they both signed it. The judge needs to do her homework.
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 OMG! The judge’s ruling was ridiculous. Shows she doesn’t know or understand the law. Looks like she needs a basic refresher. Time to hit the books again! Most states have laws to protect from predatory, unlawful contracts such as this. This one is extreme and violates the actual law, how any judge would uphold this contract raises more questions about them and their ability to interpret,l and discern the law as well as their ability to rule and make legally sound judgments than anything else. The fact that she enforced it is laughable. What is she thinking? This is insane. Someone check her credentials
I love the judge, but I wish she would stop making Douglass say the term “rough justice”… He sounds bored and annoyed when she does that now. The man isn’t a puppet.
Craigs List: Theres your problem!😂Karma will be ready and waiting with bells on, for these 2 jokers!! Hopefully, she's stable now and happy with her new residence 😊🙏💯
That room is despicable, even for just moving in, but that's complete trash taking that much money from someone then asking them to leave that quickly. The defendants are clearly rental scammers
I don't believe there are any good stories that come from a roommate cohabitation type of situation. Folks just live completely different lives for people to live together.
@@deborahsunflower939 lol you probably got some good stories... I've rented rooms from people I _know_ and had it go sideways real quick, living with strangers? Fuggetdaboooout it!!! 😆
I get a kick out of Harvey, he asks 16 year old girls questions that he knows the legal answer to, expecting them to know it as well. Check out what he says and his demeanor after he asks the young lady about bringing a roach into court, as if she would know that.
Defendants are mean spirited, uptight people. But I can understand they being upset with her given how utterly messy she was and then the damage she caused while moving out. Still, it's totally unfair to keep all her money and kick anyone out with only a three day notice. They just shouldn't lease to anyone, period.
Personally, the judge should have asked, what were they doing in her room taking photographs? That's trespassing, it may be their home, yet she was renting a room in their house and, it's her space.
Yeah I'm inclined to believe these men scammed her. IMO I think they were looking for quick payment for rent and pulled this, probably with other people as well. Any of the things they said could all have been remedied with time and talking but instead they went to move her out asap AND kept all of her money on top of it. Some people are just unbelievable in their nasty ways. Agree with the judge in her opinion all the way.
The audacity of society of those who believe they can get away with what they got away with. It’s just a small example of what’s going out in the world now. It’s so sad
It makes me wonder how many other renters these Defendants did this to. Let them move in, give them a 3 day notice to leave because they hadn't unpacked and put everything away in 24 hours, then kept every penny they were given. They were absolute pieces of garbage.
Wow Judge M strikes again for the landlord!!! $400 for a repair considering her opinion was they were terrible human beings. They were chickenshits who held into this girls money. I was hoping Judge M would rough justice more in favor of the poor girl - after all it’s rough justice! However again Judge M let the landlords trump! Makes me so sad
When you’re renting a room in someone’s house it’s like you have to be there without appearing to be there. People are very territorial of their home and things. I just think overall renting a room is a bad idea.
Something was wrong there, sounds like they scammed her! I absolutely agree with the judge, how could they treat another human being that way!!! I felt so sorry for her, what an awful position to be in!
This is horrible how can you put that type of stress & anxiety on a person. What horrible disgusting behaviour. I feel so awful for this woman . I wish her name @ was available I would most definitely donate to her . If anyone comes across her @ plz tag me .
Lord, they too advantage of this girl. They probably already spent her money & just didn’t wanna give her the funds back. I would’ve never signed that lease. I learned to read & question EVERYTHING when it comes to landlords.
I learned to ask for copies of the lease and any accompanying documents related the residency before I complete the rental application that way I don’t waste my time or money
Man, if this was one of my son's getting kicked out after 3 days. Paying for a place, paying for moving and moving truck. And had to get more boxes. And pets what a nightmare. Wow. But why did she sign that? Her parents should've helped her with her first apt. If it was her first
JM doesn't listen! Plaintiff said in the very beginning she paid a pet deposit and then JM says you had a dog no JM she had a alien, wth yes she had a dog! 🙄
Her room had a lot of stuff in she just moved in... I want to cry 3 days she is expected to clean her room perfectly? I don't get it yes too many stuff = messy but it wasn't impossible. This is horrible
The judge nailed it when she said they were horrible people. If she brought roaches in there would be more than one to video in the days she was there or even when she left. That was a lie.
Exactly
yes indeed
If either one of defendants were put in the situation they put her in you could bet they would be screaming some kind of
“ ism “
That was some bs. They just wanted to talk shit thinking it would help them.
Plus they would have a bill from an exterminator
I don’t think they ever had any intention of letting her live there. I think they didn’t have enough money to pay there own rent so they scammed her. They should be ashamed of themselves.
Nailed it!
Bingo !!!
Judge got it right. They were cruel and heartless. It's too bad she couldn't get every penny back!
I thought the exact same thing. No shame no shame.... I wished the plaintiff would’ve lied and said she gave them more than she actually did.
How can you determine if somebody’s clean after three days while they are still in the process of unpacking? These guys seem like scammers and probably have done it to countless people in the past
Did you see her room ?
Exactly my thoughts, her room did look like a tornado ran through it but it's only been 3 days. That's crazy
This is true but unpacking is one thing that video of her room was ... Another thing bro
I deff would of gave her at least 2 or 3 weeks to get settled and clean it
First thing I thought was scammers. Especially after they mentioned their son getting the room.
Guy in the hallway at the end, "the judge called you horrible people". Defendants, "that's her opinion." Well it's mine too! Horrible people with no empathy - moving is always chaotic - they should have given her a week to get settled, then say something if it bothered them.
bad verdict . the plaintiff should have received at least one thousand and im a painter and the cost to fix two holes and paint a wall is usually 250 .
i wouldn't be friends with them.
@@marleonetti7 Well, had they done what proper landlords do and got actual estimates or fixed it and brought the receipt to show the cost of repair they might've gotten a larger judgment.
Editing to add: that's why it's called "rough" justice.
They didn't want to give her the week. that's why they put in the 'three days notice' clause, their son was thinking of moving in but if that fell through then they had her as a back up plan, but son does get to move in, so she's out and they just keep her money as a tip for the discomfort of having to get her to move out! Judge was right, they are horrible people!
@@annereidy7981 I thought that too - that it had something to do with the son moving in - and you're right - that 3 day notice was no accident!
A decent human being would've told her to clean it up, and if she didn't, THEN give her the warning. They should feel ashamed
a decent human being wouldn't be recording her bedroom 3 days after her moving in
True, but I think they freaked out over the roach. There is never ever one lone roach. When there is one, there are hundreds, if not thousands.
And once your home is infested with roaches, they are almost impossible to get rid of....unless you get a family of possums.
There for a few days & already her room looked like a hoarder's room, plus her junk was scattered all over their home. They said "She took over the house".
I think they expected a sweet, soft-spoken, quiet young lady to rent a room, and what they got was a gross, messy hoarder who spread her clutter everywhere & was infesting their home with nasty roaches.
I think every one of the commenters being all judgy about the defendants would have done the exact same thing in their shoes.
(EDIT: They should not have kept all of that money. Yes, they were wrong to do that.)
In 3 days I'm barely unpacked. I wouldn't have dumped out all.the boxes but they're awful!
@@deborahsunflower939 she may have been looking for something and couldn’t remember where she put it
That’s what they are supposed to do seems like when she moved in they had someone else in mind and gave her the boot
My heart goes out to that poor woman!
I feel for her too. She had to give her dog away and that part where she said she was happy her dog had friends to play with. Wow to move into a place and then have to move out so quickly. She didn't have time to ever get settled. Those guys don't need to be anybody's landlord.
@@davidtaylor8787 she didnt have to give her dog away....
lots off homeless people who take verry goed care of there pets...
@@mikivanduyn9630 that is so true but she seems like the light doesn't go all the way up to the top of the stairs...or maybe she is going thru something mentally. I feel bad for her I could never give up my pet. 🐕
@@mikivanduyn9630 so you expect her to live on the streets ??????
Maybe she has some character and dosent want to live off the tax payers ..
Ever thought about that ???
Yes I really wish her the best and I also hope she will be able to get her dog back.
Defendants want rent income, but don’t really want someone else in their house.
Greed!
Exactly 💯
ABSOLUTELY 💯
Or maybe someone who's a bit tidier and cleaner.
@@stonew1927 no they wanted their 16 ur old son in there instead
@@stonew1927 what does that have to do with keeping all her money. They’re thieves. 3 days is not enough to determine if someone is clean or not. They never gave her a chance or even communicated their issues w her. They’re scammers after her money! They kicked her out so the son could move in.
Wait hold on-- we are calling her “messy” because she has a messy room after ONE full 24 hour day of unpacking? My house stayed messed up for a week before you could see the house because of all my sh- was piled up. That’s not legit there’s no way I buy she’s messy
The only people i know who unpack in 1 day rent rooms and dont have furniture or dishes etc.
When I moved my place was a mess for monthsssss..
lol i moved a week ago and its insane. this thread is making me feel much better about myself lol
Thats true! Atleast with a house, you have space to organize. She literally had ONE room to put her whole life into. So of course it's gonna be messy for a bit.
She’s not. I agree
She didn’t breach the lease, you asked her to leave w/notice. Two vastly different things.
After kicking her out while she was still in the process of moving in and then moving their kid in? Seems like this was planned. They knew they were going to kick her out in three days before she even stepped through that door with her things. Those horrible defendants wanted to get some money and didn't care who they hurt.
Where were they planning on their son to live. Yep this was planned.
what nasty men they are.... she had only just moved in of course the room was a mess!!.... and then to try and keep her money damn!! I hope karma bites them hard on there arse
That's What Scumbags Do.
Men? Where?
One fat guy screwing another fat guy.... karma literally bites them in their fat behinds every night.
You can’t judge someone’s room while they are in the process of moving. For all we know she was going to go out to get a dresser or containers for her items, but never had the chance to. Not to mention, them going into her room and recording it is sketch. Why didn’t he also include videos of the kitchen? That she apparently made sooo messy only after 2 days of moving in. What a joke. She also didn’t breach the lease if they were the ones that gave her three days notice. I wish he would have said that in front of the judge. And also son?? They almost look identical. I thought they were brothers 🤣
They look like twins
@@bethehype5339 i was CERTAIN they were brothers.
I sure hope not. They look identical
They really did look identical! It’s crazy 😂
Peter puffers
Oh my gosh, the defendants said "that's the judge's opinion of them." Yes, yes it was and every single person watching this episode that's all our opinions too. They were awful people. They threw her out and kept all of her money, I can't even say what I think of them. I guess just to say that they were horrible, no good, awful people.
Not mine 🤷🏻♂️ unpopular opinion
This wasn't the first person they've done it to, I'd wager this is a nice little scam they are running. Why would you video tape someone's room 2 days into moving in? Obviously it's going to be messy while moving in.
Sheesh! They were a tough crowd! I think they got the news that their kid was returning just as she was moving in and then did what they had to to make her leave. Although the 3 days notice makes me believe that they always knew it was a possibility. & keeping her money was just crazy!
I’m feeling the same thing. They made an obligation to her and then found out so yeah
Agree. Kid was coming home so they kicked her out and were evil to keep her money.
@@lollylove1107 aaaawwwsew
ww
Wow! Judge M really screwed the pooch on this case! I don’t care if the poor girl signed a lease she didn’t quite understand, JM most definitely should have given the Plaintiff much, much more than what she did! How would she like it if someone did that to her kid? Those plaintiffs are rotten, rotten people to do that to that poor girl! They knew dang well what they were pulling on that poor girl. They are very lucky this girl was the one they screwed over because something tells me they most definitely would not have put up with that had that happen to them with a new Landlord!
They seem like some immature roommates, literally has a problem with everything so quickly
They're human trash
Scammers.
never move in with a couple it's too much and I think it's weird for landlords to go into their tenant's bedrooms without prior notice/ nonemergencies
I'm literally not a dog person but my heart sank when she said she had to give her dog away. Also the cute pic of the puppies Playing together aww, why'd they do this to her 😢
Same here. I felt really bad for her. They turned her world upside down.
I felt so bad, and she looked like she was gonna cry too but she kept it together. This was such a horrible situation to be in.
I have a feeling this was a scam for the start. Either way the defendants are despicable
I would say their son wasn't sure if he would be moving in so they deliberately put 3 days on the lease so they could kick her out straight away if they needed to. After she moved in the son decided he wanted to move in so they came up with excuses to kick her out.
I have a feeling they done that to other people before
That's my thoughts exactly
I thought the same thing!!!
Absolutely
@@Nevaeh1 I wouldn't be surprised at all. And unfortunately people sign those leases without really thinking about it.
Given the circumstances of the "eviction," that 3-day notice thing almost looks like part of a plan.
Yup Make a Quick Buck and Toss The Source !
Their Both Scumbags Plain and Simple. i'm happy She Won and it's Well Deserved.. She Should of Gotten The Whole Amount Tho.
I literally just wrote the same exact thing I feel these scum bags had this planned out from the start, they posted a "fake 🤥" move in ad on craigslist and had it in their mind to come up 💰 off of a vulnerable person that was in need of a place to stay you can tell they would never wanted a roommate just the money it's the greed for me I feel so bad for this young woman I really do and I pray that she has somewhere safe and is happy now
this is why we need stronger tenancy laws. you can't sign/enforce a contract with a 3 days notice clause if it's unlawful.
In my state it would be unenforceable as an illegal provision. I bet most states have laws against this in their landlord tenant acts. I think the judge got it wrong.
@@markwinterstein9398 you are correct. I was surprised that the judge in this case seemed unaware of that. You can not have tenants sign away their rights and their rights are what the law says. If 30 day notice is required by law, then it doen't matter what the lease says.
No you don't, the law already exists, this judge seemed unaware of it.
What awful people!!! She's a sweetheart!! Shame on them
If there had been a roach he would have taken a picture of it after he killed it. Anyone with a brain would do that if they are trying to make her look bad. yeah the room is messy but she JUST moved in. They should have given her a bit more time to unpack and put things away, even in the kitchen. Moving in is hard to get organized. I think they just realized that the son... was able to come live with them and needed excuses to get her out. It's a bit creepy that they are videoing her room at all. She rented it and it should have been her private place.
Even if there were a roach,, what proof do they have that she was the one that brought the roach?
@@emo72387 True. they would have to prove it came from her. If there was a photo of it the judge might go with the "more likely than not" angle. but bottom line is, they did not even give her time to umpack and organize. Poor roach didnt' get to setle in either!
@@ebonypegasus9864 a photo still wouldn’t prove it
@@emo72387 I agree I was just making a joke of it.
@@emo72387 I watch peoples court a lot. In small claims they dont have to prove things. it just has to be more likely than not.
I think this whole thing was a scam I really wonder if they did it to anyone else .
Definitely!
Right and luckily for them a desperate, vulnerable female fell right for it
A lease with a 3 day notice has got to be a scam they are pulling to get money out of people. How many people have they kicked out quickly and tried to keep the money? I think they found out their kid needed a place to stay and used that lease to their advantage. Trash I tell you.. TRASH
They didn't want a roommate they wanted the money.
I am so sad for her having to give her dog away. Those guys are so awful for not even bothering to give her a second to unpack and settle in.
The defendants seem like horrible people, kinda catty too
Three days notice is callous and hateful. I wish those two queens would try to move in 3 days and see how well it works for them.
Awesome name QUEENS straight up disgusting 🤢 I wonder who is that kid who moving in is !!! Can’t really say wht I want to b c u tube will bk me but u get my thinking 🤔 unbelievable disgusting 🤢 think about it smh
@@J23-o7u They said it's their son. I don't have a problem with them being gay. Just how they treat others. People of all sexualities can be awful. I think you're implying they're pedophiles. That's a big assumption to make based on a tenant dispute.
I think one was a woman and maybe they changed over 16 years?
@@gan-ban6083 I suspect they're both women
The defendants seem very messy over the top and in everyone's business and don't know the do's and don'ts of being a landlord . They took advantage of this young lady and hope nobody ever rents from them.
You said it!! They don't need to be anybody's landlord!
Yes...what about their rude,crude, 'messy' cheating behaviour(devouring the whole deposit? & slimy 3-day clause) with a young woman...to evict her suddenly without a thought for her safety?
What a pair of jerks! They really screwed her over.... aweful people. I feel sorry for their son.
They already had plans for who was going to live there. As you can see, it's someone they know lol they just used her for her money and kicked her out. This case actually pissed me off so much I had to come and write a comment. Leaving someone homeless is not a joke and they take it so lightly. Definitely spoiled kids who have never been through anything. Entitled too. Like she literally PAID MONEY to stay there. It's obvious they wrote the lease the way they wrote it because the whole time they intended to kick her out. Wish she had caught on sooner. Eww.
Absolutely agree!
I love that the judge gave them the lectures ... what a bunch of scammers ...
They literally have her no time to get her things put away after moving in.
I’m ordering the defendants to pray for a soul👩🏿⚖️
I absolutely LOVE Judge Milian… her compassion and fairness makes her my all time favorite judge on television. (Keeping in mind I interned for Judge Mathis back in the day) 😂😂😂
#RoughJustice 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾
Wow 😯 yea that says a lot 😂
These days Judge Mathis is so moody you never know how he'sgoing rule on a case😂🤣😅😆..I can imagine how he was back in the day.
I don’t have anything juicy 🤷🏾♀️😂 Judge Mathis was super laid back & chill, back then. He always seemed to have a joke or something funny to say when he saw you. 😂🥰 I interned for his show in the early 2000’s. He wasn’t as nearly “uptight” as he seems now. 😩 I usual saw him between tapings.
I screened calls, because back then there was an 800# people could call and we’d actually answer the phone - but only when the show was airing in Chicago. On those calls I took ticket requests. I also did transcripts of calls when people left messages for a possible case. And then there was other random stuff.
I liked it when they let me sit in the control room during tapings with the executive producer Bo and the shows attorney Gretchen.
Very cool pbg
Judge Milan is prejudice. That's why she spoke so ugly to those two men..
“Karma is the most patient gangsta ever!” -unknown
lol i think its so funny how westerners think that karma is some sort of mechanism of vengance. that is not at all what karma truly means
I am an owner of 3 houses , and do realise how difficult it is for someone with a dog or cat to get a house to rent . I would never turn a tenant away if they had pets . I love dogs , and understand that they become part of your family once you have them .
You sound awesome! Thanks for being a good landlord l.
She just moved in! What do they expect
I felt for her the whole time but when she had to give the dog up that hit home for me because I was in the same situation where I didn’t know my next move and and my family wasn’t big on the dog and I lived with the dog spot to spot and in my car but I knew I couldn’t keep up with it so I had to give him up
Surely many friends may have wanted not a stranger
It us def an expense i hope someday soon to be able to incur but not yet
Hope things are better now ?
I saw on Judy Justice (Judge Judy's new show) where she gave back the person everything and used term I've not heard which meant if the judge finds the actions despictable as well as the agreement, then the judge can throw out a signed agreement. I wish this was done here cause she should have gotten more back for that cause she was duped big time.
Unconscionable contract
There are things a court has to look at in order for it to determine it is indeed an unconscionable contract. There are elements that the contract has to have, such as a surprise, bargaining power, dealing with someone of lesser intelligence and so on.
I wish that was done here too. 3 days to move out shortly after moving in is insane.
Oh no, NEVER move in with overly picky queens! And crooked ones with a son! LAWD 🤮
Nevermind the greed...
the *misogyny* is strong w these 2
read the lease carefully! stop signing things when you question them. These guys are evil and just cruel.
This is why I will never live with someone. I have been living alone since 2018. It is absolutely the best. Peace, cleanliness, order, independence. I can’t go back to having roommates unless I had to and there was absolutely no other way, like facing homelessness. I’d rather live alone and struggle a bit, than to struggle with another human being in the same house. NO WAY
Yeah better to not rent with anyone if you are like them....😂
These men are scammers! 3 days notice!!!!! Kept her money!
I really feel for the plaintiff, those defendants were heartless!
The sugar twins are a mess 👯♂️
😂😂
😂😂😂
Very juicy. Indeed.
🤣🤣🤣
Sounds like a bunch of BS to me, they more than likely had this planned from the get go and it wouldn't surprise me one bit to hear they've done it before. There's no way in hell after 2 or 3 days could you tell everything that they were claiming. Their son is in her room now, that don't even sound right. I know one thing for sure, she needs to start speaking up, stop letting people walk all over her and thinking things are a "typo" or life is gonna be a real struggle. To the wanna be scammin landlords, you reap what you sew, remember that. Think karma.
They violated her privacy by video taping her room. What have them the right to do that?
EXACTLY!
This is humanity I want no part of. Just look at the audacity of how they look at what they did.
"That's not a small hole, baby cakes."
THIS WOMAN, LMFAO. I LOVE HER-
The defendants were lying i dont believe there was a roach it was just an excuse not to give her,her money back,well at least she had some of her money back
Just because it’s in a lease it doesn’t make it legal & binding. Is 2 days notice legal? 🤷♀️
Apparently it is!
No it's not, most leases are required to give 30 days notice
@@WVnurseJo The problem is... she signed a contract that stated a 3 day notification and that over rides any other normal time frames on other leases. The judge cant rule on what most leases are, only on what that lease was. Saying she thought it was a typo... she should have clarified that before signing it. I feel bad for her but she did willingly sign that contract.
@@ebonypegasus9864 Yeah I know what she signed, I was just stating that most places require 30 days to leave
In my state, the minimum is 10 days. I lived in my last apartment 17 yrs, I was 17 when I moved in. My landlord sold the building to some very horrible people, I gave those disgusting jerks 10 days, they went up on my rent higher than anyone else in the building after I found them searching through my locked mailbox, I lived there 3x longer than any other person. I found a beautiful condo with cathedral ceilings on the same street, rent was cheaper too.
They planned that and scammed her.
She's -maybe!- a messy person or a hoarder. Both my parents passed in 2020 and bless her- I am at least one of those too. It drives me mad, but I can't throw my parents' antiques and linens away. Try and keep a corridor- a walkway though sweetheart. But- she never had a chance to settle in, either!
The defendants schemed and Judge Milian was not impressed with that.
Ahhh, life is messy at times. God bless all you young ones setting out, out there. Especially those starting out with burdens on your backs- you get me? I love you all.🙏🕊🌻☮️🐕🦺🐈🌏
A decent person would have told her to clean up her mess, organize all her stuff, give her one week to do so. Then by that week if she hasn't cleaned it up then start the eviction process. Since the Defendant says his son or their son lives there now, I'm thinking maybe that's why they kicked her out so fast. 🤷♀️
In all honesty, the roach was probably there before she was! I unfortunately lived in a apartment complex that was full of them (only in the summer lol) but usually they're already in the home. They're obviously lying to try to give themselves some room to say that was a valid reason for kicking her out, which it wasn't. Love your comment! Very thoughtful!
I don’t know what state this is in, but in my state the 3 days to leave is an illegal provision and is unenforceable even if they both signed it. The judge needs to do her homework.
In some states they can give a three day notice though.
I bet it is for unpaid rent, not because the landlord doesn’t want them there anymore.
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 OMG! The judge’s ruling was ridiculous. Shows she doesn’t know or understand the law. Looks like she needs a basic refresher. Time to hit the books again! Most states have laws to protect from predatory, unlawful contracts such as this. This one is extreme and violates the actual law, how any judge would uphold this contract raises more questions about them and their ability to interpret,l and discern the law as well as their ability to rule and make legally sound judgments than anything else. The fact that she enforced it is laughable. What is she thinking? This is insane. Someone check her credentials
I love the judge, but I wish she would stop making Douglass say the term “rough justice”…
He sounds bored and annoyed when she does that now. The man isn’t a puppet.
Craigs List: Theres your problem!😂Karma will be ready and waiting with bells on, for these 2 jokers!! Hopefully, she's stable now and happy with her new residence 😊🙏💯
That room is despicable, even for just moving in, but that's complete trash taking that much money from someone then asking them to leave that quickly.
The defendants are clearly rental scammers
I don't believe there are any good stories that come from a roommate cohabitation type of situation. Folks just live completely different lives for people to live together.
Ugh so true! I had many Craigslist room mates in the past.
@@deborahsunflower939 lol you probably got some good stories... I've rented rooms from people I _know_ and had it go sideways real quick, living with strangers? Fuggetdaboooout it!!! 😆
I had one super great roommate.
on the second day? like the day she was actually moving in? these two are petty, I almost wish she would have gotten all of it.
I think they were scamming her. She was unpacking. Lord when I come back from a trip my luggage unpack is explosive.
I get a kick out of Harvey, he asks 16 year old girls questions that he knows the legal answer to, expecting them to know it as well. Check out what he says and his demeanor after he asks the young lady about bringing a roach into court, as if she would know that.
Wow!!!! JM hammered those guys......and she was correct, imo.
What despicable human beings! I wish this young lady every good thing.
That's so sad about her dog
Defendants are mean spirited, uptight people. But I can understand they being upset with her given how utterly messy she was and then the damage she caused while moving out. Still, it's totally unfair to keep all her money and kick anyone out with only a three day notice. They just shouldn't lease to anyone, period.
She just had moved in....
Do you get that? 😅
Her room looks like she just moved in - the two guys are terrible
Personally, the judge should have asked, what were they doing in her room taking photographs? That's trespassing, it may be their home, yet she was renting a room in their house and, it's her space.
3 days can't show how clean you are .
Yeah I'm inclined to believe these men scammed her. IMO I think they were looking for quick payment for rent and pulled this, probably with other people as well. Any of the things they said could all have been remedied with time and talking but instead they went to move her out asap AND kept all of her money on top of it. Some people are just unbelievable in their nasty ways. Agree with the judge in her opinion all the way.
That poor sweet young lady, I feel so bad for her. And those two "men" are the worst ever! I hope this comes back onto them 10 fold!
Alexis is there something you want to get off your chest? That “men” in quotes seemed a little loaded
No one would be good enough for them I’m sure. I can’t believe they kept all her money. Unbelievable . They really are horrible people. Have a ❤.
She was still unpacking after 3 days. They were being petty. They clearly were mad she moved in late
You could tell how they walked in,that they was petty af🤣
I just wonder how many these two pulled this scam on others, with their 3 day notice, spying, and keeping ALL the cash!
The audacity of society of those who believe they can get away with what they got away with. It’s just a small example of what’s going out in the world now. It’s so sad
agreed
Anytime people who holler that they're so "clean" WATCH OUT!!! They're some of the nastiest people around.
That defendant's lover, to his left, has the biggest unibrow I have ever seen!! hehe!!
It makes me wonder how many other renters these Defendants did this to. Let them move in, give them a 3 day notice to leave because they hadn't unpacked and put everything away in 24 hours, then kept every penny they were given. They were absolute pieces of garbage.
They realize they didn't want no fish living there
Wow Judge M strikes again for the landlord!!! $400 for a repair considering her opinion was they were terrible human beings. They were chickenshits who held into this girls money. I was hoping Judge M would rough justice more in favor of the poor girl - after all it’s rough justice! However again Judge M let the landlords trump! Makes me so sad
Not true at all........
it’s a contracts issue. she signed a BAD contract but she signed it 🤷🏽♀️
They scammed her. Needed an excuse to scam some money out of someone before letting their son move in. Disgusting people.
Hope she's doing well now. She's probably better off away from these Divas
When you’re renting a room in someone’s house it’s like you have to be there without appearing to be there. People are very territorial of their home and things. I just think overall renting a room is a bad idea.
Defendant are "petty and extraaaaa"
I love the plaintiffs hair. Whoever colored it did great!
I feel so sad for her dog I hope she gets the dog back omg
I'm happy that the comment section is full of people who also think this is a scam.
They were scamming her! Just a way to get some money.
Something was wrong there, sounds like they scammed her! I absolutely agree with the judge, how could they treat another human being that way!!! I felt so sorry for her, what an awful position to be in!
I'd rather live in a cardboard box than live with either one of the duche bags! I wouldn't give the defendants a penny!!!
This is horrible how can you put that type of stress & anxiety on a person. What horrible disgusting behaviour. I feel so awful for this woman . I wish her name @ was available I would most definitely donate to her . If anyone comes across her @ plz tag me .
The “um” is killing me :(
I'm glad the world now knows these two guys are horrible human beings. Shame on them.
Lord, they too advantage of this girl. They probably already spent her money & just didn’t wanna give her the funds back. I would’ve never signed that lease. I learned to read & question EVERYTHING when it comes to landlords.
I learned to ask for copies of the lease and any accompanying documents related the residency before I complete the rental application that way I don’t waste my time or money
Man, if this was one of my son's getting kicked out after 3 days. Paying for a place, paying for moving and moving truck. And had to get more boxes. And pets what a nightmare. Wow. But why did she sign that? Her parents should've helped her with her first apt. If it was her first
JM doesn't listen! Plaintiff said in the very beginning she paid a pet deposit and then JM says you had a dog no JM she had a alien, wth yes she had a dog! 🙄
could have been a cat 🤷🏽♀️
@@MoNehNeh17 what u said went over your head! 🤷🏾♀️
Her room had a lot of stuff in she just moved in... I want to cry 3 days she is expected to clean her room perfectly? I don't get it yes too many stuff = messy but it wasn't impossible. This is horrible