Idaho Murder Mystery: An in-depth look at murders of 4 students | Special Report
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024
- Three weeks ago, the unthinkable happened in Moscow, Idaho, when four university students were brutally killed. Kaylee Goncalves, 21, Madison Mogen, 21, Xana Kernodle, 20 and Ethan Chapin, 20, were stabbed to death in a rental home near the University of Idaho campus.
With a killer still on the loose, families wait for answers and a community remains on edge. Here's
National correspondent Brian Entin hosts “Special Report: Idaho Murder Mystery."
#Idahomurders #UniversityofIdaho
NewsNation is your source for fact-based, unbiased news for all America.
More from NewsNation: www.newsnation...
Get our app: trib.al/TBXgYpp
Find us on cable: trib.al/YDOpGyG
How to watch on TV or streaming: trib.al/Vu0Ikij
That sister seems incredibly strong. Consoling her mom and dad. I hope she has time to grieve when this is over.
whats the ig tho
No, she's pissed. She skipped sad and she's incredibly angry. She's directed her pain to whoever did it.
@@rob4804 piss off
@@hailsatan5414 but can you blame her? Plus she’s holding her parents together while she’s pregnant. My heart breaks for all these families
@@unknown-lf6zx yes!! Exactly and there are steps to grief and maybe she is in the pissed/angry stage but eventually she be in the sadness stage and she has to go through them all to fully cope with this. And I hope someone is there for her when she does.
The fact that she was killed right before she was leaving is too strange. It was definitely someone who knew she was about to move.
@@panda-wy5mk Kaylee was moving to Texas very soon.
@@panda-wy5mk kaylee was set to graduate early and had moved out of the house. She was there for the weekend to show off her new car to Maddie. Had a new job in Texas
Didn't she already move out & was back for a weekend with Maddie.
She was moving Away from someone that couldn't let go...!
I’ve said this from the beginning and I’ll say it again, IMO, Jack did not want her to move to Texas, and they had just broken things off. He killed her!
I have a friend who’s daughter was murdered. The police located a suspect, but did not share the info to my friend. This was to ensure that their investigation was not jeopardized. They charged the man who shot her daughter and he is now in jail. I pray for the families and hope they find the murderer.
My sister was murdered and they had a person of interest/suspect right out the gate but wouldn’t share with our family. Eleven months later, he was finally arrested and it was a close family friend of ours who was my dads best friend since college. We were outraged at the police because in those eleven months, he was around us and comforting us, even coming to our Thanksgiving and Christmas. He took my dad and uncle on a fishing trip to take their minds of things. We all felt like goddamn fools after that and to this day curse the detectives who let us prance around almost a year like morons. All the while, they immediately suspected him and refused to mention a thing while they “built their case”. They were able to quietly serve a warrant for his house and technology devices and we had no idea. He was able to keep that a secret also and hide his stress, he acted totally normal and like a good friend. This came from messages on her phone to a fake profile he was running. They found plenty of evidence from his laptop and cell phone, as well as her phone, in the first three weeks and didn’t charge him or tell us. In some situations, I understand. But the cops knew he was a suspect and let him sit in on interviews with us where he was the “comforting friend, like an uncle.” The cops played us for goddamn fools. I’ll never get over that.
@@Bravo-Too-Much I’m so sorry for your loss and your bad experience with the police. 11 months is a long time and no one should be at large that long when the police knew he was a murderer.
@@Bravo-Too-Much ù
@@Bravo-Too-Much you never hear the family did of the story like this. I’m sorry for your loss. And how horrible I would be livid, having him around while he knew he was guilty. Scum. I hope things get easier for you and your family.
sorry to hear about your Friend's daughter and glad that in her situation the tactic of keeping the family out of the loop worked but your friend is the minority who has had this experience , Too many people or murderers gets away because the cops do this . Atleast give the information to the families they do not need to make it public. this case for example it is clear the parents of the kids have nothing to do with this but give the people some peace of mind by telling them what is going on. it is not fair to the parents of those kids to be left in the dark like they are being. that is when people start making their own theories up and takes the law in their own hands due to frustration and anger , then that innocent person who just wanted answers or updates regarding their kids brutal murder end up in prison!! so no I feel your friend bless her was just a small percent that had a positive result
Brian Entin is an incredible reporter. He puts his heart into his reporting and you can tell he cares. Thank you Brian Entin.
I always trust a guy with white hair in his 20s
i have always like him. he's an awesome reporter. he seems to be a very compassionate person.
Yeah he cares about furthering his career like every journalist
Brian does a wonderful job talking with the families and not making it feel like an interview.
Yes he does. He did the Gabby Petito case too and he did a good job on that one too.
Brian is the best breaking news & hard news reporter I’ve ever seen on tv. He gets the facts straight but also conveys empathy, I’ve never seen a tv news reporter do that.
I'm sure that's it's all from the heart? Are You serious? These news people do all they can to turn tráfico crap like this into Entertainment!!!?? People just crawl all over it? It's Pathetic!!!!
Don't be SO gulable, small minded, wake up!!!!!!! Disgusting Jerry Springer BS.
@@brycemcqueen2235 Yes. Citizens have the right to be informed and get news information. When a reporter is working his best to add empathy with professionalism it helps viewers maintain value in what is life affirming and wholesome. My weightlifting partner actually won the Fat Man competition on the Springer Show in the early 90s. It blew my mind. I hope your family's doing well Bryce McQueen.
@@JLizard Oh I see they're informing and protecting the people? C'mon??? You really believe this? I wish I was small minded and gulable enough to believe that?
Puré fantasy!
This is horribly tragic. Much love and many, many prayers to the families of the victims
Incredible job, Brian. You shared the facts in a way that was respectful to both the families and the victims. Thanks you!
Incredible job rehashing rumors and hearsay.
@@lisaann3840 Really? Ok, what did he say that are rumors and hearsay? At least according to you? And I am thinking that if he did bring them up, it was most likely to dispel them so viewers of this video and those who have been following the case can gain new perspectives on it and separate its facts from the fiction or at least the insinuations and innuendo flowing around in the social media sphere and court of public opinion. So please tell, what are the rumors and hearsay? What are the facts? According to you.
As always, an incredible job. You ALWAYS dig deep and share in such a way that is relatable and revealing. Great job showing these families dignity and honor to the victims!!!
Very Incredible
@@lisaann3840 , sea
Thank you, Brian. You do such an amazing job at being objective and respectful.
Kaylee’s parents stated it wasn’t unusual for kaylee to call her ex that much when it was regarding her dog. Considering that the dog wasn’t anywhere near her at the time of the murder, and was apparently found confined in another room- makes me think she was calling him to see if he knew where her dog was. This also makes me think the killer knew to confine the dog in another room
Or I was thinking maybe the ex had a new gf who did not like her?
I instantly thought what you just said I feel for thinking that but that timeline of her not calling the cops until noon almost just is weird also she could’ve helped set it up an got scared when it all actually happened
If you call a dog, he will bark and wants his owner. She didn't call him for a dof, 1 door away.
Lol!! Oh man.. that would make her the most simple woman to ever exist if she was calling her ex bf, across town, at 4am because she couldn't find her dog in the bedroom, right next to hers, in the same house, on the same floor! 😂🤦🏼♀️ Give her a little credit, damn. She's deceased. She wasn't that stupid...she was just drunk dialing Jack. Haven't you ever been drunk at 4am and called your ex?! And why do you think Bryan would consider the dog a threat, but still be able to confine it in another room? If you have a dog that's a threat to an intruder it's not going to let said intruder put it in a room. It's going to attack them until it's dead or called away by the owner. It would be unmanageable for the intruder...
@@Janellabelle I commented this BEFORE Bryan was arrested / BEFORE information was released that the dog was in Kaylee’s bedroom.
More info has now made it apparent that Kaylee knew where her dog was.
However, 4 weeks ago when I made this comment, it was not clear where the dog was in the house/ if the dog was placed in the house after the murders took place.
Try not to get all frazzled before checking the date of an actual comment.
This is so unbelievable to me. Someone did this horrific crime and just walked away undetected. Smh.
After seeing the whole Delphi debacle play out, I'm sure the police have the killer right in front of them and are dropping the ball
@@Newjerseyblows I think same. But maybe they don’t have enough evidence so don’t want to bring attention to him
Yeah no blood outside of the house? Foot print? New here?
Also i wondering why she called the ex? Not call.911?
@@honeya3183 she called him before going to sleep, they were killed in there sleep. So would be just a drunk girl calling an ex. The roommates however called 2 friends before calling 911. And when calling 911 called it in as there friend just passed out and is unresponsive. Not a murder. Unless they left the lights off idk why they don't see blood tho
I just love Brian Entin. He explains things so intelligently and yet easy for the public to understand. His voice is perfect for reporting. He comes across as believable and a man of integrity. You can tell he gives 110% of himself when working on a story The families are lucky he is covering this case bc he will hold authority's feet to the fire if necessary..
Agree. Brian is boots on the ground…‼️
Totally agree. Brian E. is an asset to professional journalism.
he is the murderer
Couldn't have said it better! I never seen a reporter better than him!
Yeah he's a real professional and too bad more of some of the so-called reporters and journalists who are really unprofessional can't wipe the smile off their faces ; that GLIB SMIRK and attitude as they describe these murders is MORE DISGUSTING , I feel , than the murders themselves ... in some ways .
... look around here on the tube and you will see what I'm talking about ; you WILL be ANGERED
Who ever killed the four students been inside that house before,( DEFINITELY)
This case is so disturbing, and it’s heart wrenching to see all their beautiful faces knowing they’re gone forever.
People only care when it's white people, no one cares when us minorities get stabbed in our own neighborhoods everyday.
@@limyize Why do you feel compelled to appropriate someone else’s tragedy and make it about yourself? If you’re going to be disrespectful kick rocks. No one wants to hear you whine about how oppressed you are.
It is a tragedy beyond belief. I know the school well and can tell you no one would ever have expected this to happen.
That I know is a statement used way too often but it really is an unbelievable and senseless tragedy.
This is still a parents worst nightmare. When we finally think our children have made it and are going to start such wonderful lives and something like this happens.
I absolutely can not imagine what the parents are going through other then some of what they said. My mind would be so messed up.
I truly feel for these families and hope they eventually get justice.
He's Jewish. These people are insatiable
@@kevinsaunders8787 What a senseless mean comment.
It hurts my heart to see and hear these parents going through this. Praying for all of them. Hugs to these parents.
Yes, the whole family. I just recently lost my little sister (22). Not in this brutal of a manner, but I relate to the pure emptiness and pain I see in the big sisters face. And the complete devastation and shock in the mothers voice sounds just like my mom. My heart completely shatters for all of them. No one should have to bury their child.
Me too but to know this is happening to Black Women Every Day in almost every city but never gets the same coverage is the real sad story #justice4missingBlackWomen
These kids were out drinking alcohol they deserved it
@@jamjam6431 here we go... Can't it just be a horrible crime?? I know I'm about to get slaughtered by my comment, but I promise I wasn't the only "eye roller" out there. I'm not an insensitive white woman either.
My soulmate the love of my life, a person I would lay my life down for, is a black woman. Whom has taught me throughout the last 10 yrs the behind the scenes struggles is white individuals never see.
HOWEVER, THIS IS NOT THE TIME/PLACE FOR YOU TO PUT YOUR PLATFORM OUT THERE.
Create your own little podcast, TikTok and have at it.
This is about 4 families that are hurting and are not going to see their loved ones at Christmas this year. It has hurt my heart watching these 4 on the brink of seeing all the hard work and studying come into fruition.
God Bless you 4, and God bless all those who have had to experience these senseless acts, even the ones out society doesn't tell us about, because they're out there too.
The shit is just not fair.
@@mandytrulove269 I don't even have to read your comment to know your are racist and privileged
Thanks for the update on the case I will keep on looking for the rest of this video on the channel. My condolences to the family members of this case.And please let the people do what they need to do in the case. Don't listen to everything you hear from people on Facebook...cases take time.I have faith that it will get solved.
There was a case a few years ago in the US where a mother and daughter were attacked with machetes while they were sleeping. The mother died, daughter miraculously survived. Someone broke into their home (while dad was on business) and came into their bedroom and started hacking away at them. There were immediately concerns of the father being responsible. Because again: there has to be a motive. In the end, turned out that a group of teens were responsible and that they picked the house randomly. They didn't know the victims. They told police that they wanted to find out how it felt to murder someone.
Wow insightful. Any more cases at random
@House Exactly 💯 it is very possible it could be some random person(s). The tunnel vision & other division people are coming up with is disturbing.
@@RealLifeLiz Yes, I can think of a quite a few home invasion mass murders that were random. A case where three women and girls of a family were murdered. Only the father survived, pushing some to suspect him of being involved. Turned out that the killers were two petty thugs who by chance came across the mother of the household while she was out shopping. They followed her back home and then came back later that night to do their horrific crime. They didn't know each other at all. If the killers hadn't been caught, a lot of people would still be suspecting the father. It's very hard to believe crimes like these can happen at random. Another infamous case is one from Japan, where an entire family of 4 were stabbed to death by a night time intruder. The killer has never been caught, but the circumstance of crime suggests that the killing was entirely random (the killer lingered around the home hours after the murder, eating the victims' food and showing in their bathroom). Personally, I just can't imagine that there is a motive that would make sense for us. If there is something like a motive, there might as well not be one. I'm thinking of an unstable person who was slighted (or bullied) by the girls. Something like that. The amount of violence and the peculiarities of the case makes me believe that a motive will be very hard to find.
So very sick & evil motivated!😮
Even Ted bundy which this reminds me of was random. Ted Bundy saw a girl at the bar and followed her and ended up murdering almost everyone in a sorority house.
The pain you feel when you go through trauma is like a tsunami. It hits you bit by bit and all at once with such a force. I feel so heartbroken with their parents. So much has been taken from them. The person who did this has no soul
I think it's someone that has no soul 😈 Something tells me it's a woman and a very Jealous woman!
@@annmoore8696 you’re joking, right? A woman would never have the necessary stamina to repeatedly stab multiple victims who in at least one case for sure (Ethan) fought back which is a normal reaction when being attacked.
@@susanbowman3865 Susan what makes you think it's only a man? I just watched on True stories a woman took out her best friend!
@@susanbowman3865 , never say never
@@annmoore8696 FOUR PEOPLE were stabbed to death NUMEROUS times EACH. The M.O. in this case is of a serial killer is indicative of a MAN. A very pissed off and having a psychotic break man who had the stamina as well as brut force necessary to carry out these murders. Edit: statistically serial killers are men. To kill some one with a knife takes time until the victim bleeds out. Not to mention that their bodies, chests in particular, where most of the fatal wounds were likely to be, contain strong bones. Their rib cages.
Brian, you are incredible. Thank you for your dedicated news. Stay safe
Great job on this special report, Mr. Entin! Glad you are on the case and will keep the public updated as best possible.
My heart breaks for the families. The moms having their children who they appear to have raised with so much love, care and protection, snuffed out when they leave home and go into the world to live their lives… Their pain is one of the saddest things I’ve ever seen.
So well said. 😔
Make me hope there really is a hell
College campuses are the devil’s trap
This is one of the most disturbing cases I ever encounter in my lifetime. My heart is with the victim's families.
Have you seen anything from dahmer, bundy, gacy? Not saying this isn’t bad of course, but there’s been way worse
@@rsafree1139 dude stop it it’s not a popularity contest
Far worse before for sure
Wow you must live in a cave in the middle of nowhere and have no access to the outside world or TV or internet because there has been a hell of a lot of way more disturbing cases than this one.
Have you never heard of serial killer's before.
There are thousands upon thousands of far worse cases.
I can’t even imagine how the remaining two triplets feel losing their brother… like this.
When I was in college, I locked myself out of my 2nd floor apartment. My neighbor climbed partially up the stairs, climbed onto the balcony from the stairs, and had my LOCKED sliding glass door open in seconds. From then on I always use a piece a wood to keep the door from sliding open…even when I’m on vacation.
@@_h_r_1_ but every house has a sliding door. And what traditional door would be wide enough to replace sliding glass?
Yeah, my grandmother always used a broomstick that had the broom part sawed off. Worked. Somebody actually did try to get into her house once and couldn't because of that.
@@_h_r_1_ Sliding glass doors are ones many serial killers have used to break into homes--like the Golden State killer, the Night Stalker killer, etc.
We always use a piece of wood or steel and lay it in the tracks of any patio door
@@linastarot-oracle people are trying to break into your home often? Scary
I think it is strange that 4 people can be stabbed to death with two others in the house who didn't hear a thing.
Ashley & Brian have a very nice, respectful, easy professional relationship. A great pairing. Trusting. And together they are deeply compassionate. Appreciate them.
Yes they are professional reporters/ presenters who are compassionate and sincere.
Kaylee could have received more significant injuries due to maybe fighting back. Unless they slept with a night light, or with the lights on, it would probably have been difficult to differentiate between Kaylee and Madison on the same floor. Kaylee and Madison were found on the same bed. If the attacker started hacking and slashing at one girl, the other would have woken up immediately and taken a more defensive stance.
good point
You make an excellent point.
Yes, the question is; was the “more significant damage” caused by defensive wounds, or not??
dealing with two targets especially who r asleep if u know what u’re doin, first victim u attack in such a way that they’re not cappable of fighting back (cut throat) the victim will make noises, but cant fight back, the other victim wakes up just in time to b stabbed but can put up a fight that will account for defensive wounds.. i’ve seen some information out there ( dont know how accurate) that Kaylee was decapitated, wchich could have been done after 2nd victim was killed, if she indeed was the one who was targeted, and the info is accurate… i’m a combat vet so not sayin i’m sn expert but i have been trained in a certain way and i’ve seen all sorts of “action” down range.. from the info thats out there it just makes sense,
👏👏👏👏 that’s exactly how I was thinking!!
My deepest condolences to these families ❤
Excellent segment regarding this tragic event. Retired from LE-related work, I have lots of thoughts as we all do but am hopeful that the professionals on this extremely horrific case will piece together this puzzling event. Let's hope that no stone is left unturned.
It might take years to solve this case.
It’s unbearably sad. Poor kids.
Kaylees Dad is about to lose it. The killer better hope the FBI finds him before the Dad finds him.
If his dad kills him. I am all for it. This killer doesn’t deserve a trial.
@@nancygatto6571 I'm just so heartbroken for him. I support him and I sympathize with him I'd feel exactly the same as he does.
I hope kaylees dad gets him first! This monster ought to have the families at him
@@kristentrep5038 I agree
@@audibjornsson6107 yes
How did someone kill 4 people in the same house with a knife and no one heared a thing? Someone skilled and trained with a knife or they were all so hammered and passed out?
Just really scary to think about how brutal it was and how easily someone can be killed.
That’s the question I keep asking. You don’t hear people screaming for their lives? BOTH of them go deaf? It’s so suspicious
The purpose of using a knife is that it is silent.
There is no way that supposedly no one knows anything. Someone has to know something. I hope someone comes forward.. this is just evil. Whoever did this probably won't come forward but Whoever knows should how can that person(s) live with themselves. These poor kids and their families need justice. This is completely heartbreaking 💔.
Hard to believe the other two roomates in the house didnt hear any sound of a massacre going on upstairs ,in the middle of the night when I'm guessing it was pretty quite. Did nobody yell or scream ?
I believe the killers family have suspicions about him being involved but is afraid of him. The person who did this has to be mentally deranged.
I bet it's Jermey Reagan watch dude gives me goosebumps!!!!
It reminds me of something similar of what the serial killer Ted Bundy did. He killed almost everyone in a sorority house.
@@kristylee8079I agree but also think the two surviving roommates (at least one of them) are connected. There’s no way that they aren’t
Brian, you are my favorite reporter because you stick to the facts and handle the cases you cover with so much care and respect for the victims’ families. I really hope that these four college students receive the justice that they deserve and that their families and loved ones receive the answers and closure that they are so desperately seeking. My thoughts and prayers are with the families and loved ones of these four college students that had their lives so brutally taken from them far too soon.
News Nation should be ashamed just click🐎
I don’t recall ever being so emotionally impacted by a story to where I can’t even talk about it or bring it up. I think it’s just how real it becomes when you can see the victims lives on social media, etc. Mindbogglingly sad.
Well you're managing to talk about it in this comment.
She would have more injuries if she woke up and tried to fight the attacker. Such a horrific loss. My heart goes out to all the family and friends affected by this senseless act.
I would think that's more obvious of a scenario then her being targeted. Her friend was stabbed in her sleep first. She woke up to the noise tried to defend herself maybe even hitting the attacker making him more angry or just the fact she was moving and the attacker had to do more. I really think that's what happened.
@@johnslater6216 I absolutely believe that’s the most logical scenario as well. Either way I pray they find the person(s) responsible sooner rather than later.
You’d be surprised how many people go into freeze mode
@gribblenibble it was an incel dude who's been arrested. He hates attractive women like all incels do. Weird psychology.☹️
@@gribblenibble you’re so incredibly wrong. This is why we shouldn’t assume.
This family needs to understand that it is an open investigation and if all the information they want is public, the killer would know that information too. It’s sad but just stop.
I agree. I believe the police know way more and this family is talking way too much.
Says the rando on the internet.
I don’t get that though, the killer already knows what they did and if the cops told the family more in confidence they would be less likely to get frustrated and go to the media
True. And The 'Confirmation' of more injuries likely *ONLY* without input from Ethan Chapin or Xana Kernodle family. Seems likely this is only based on discussion between Goncalves & Mogen family discussion.
@@scottanonymous798 likely that police want that info private as they will then have little left to rule out the crazy that may eventually say he did it...when he didn't. and/or that some details would be used to trap any true confession by messing them up during interrogation. -just a thought
If they don't share someone's alibi, might mean they have not actually cleared it and looking further into it. They absolutely check people's alibis multiple times to look at inconsistency in them. So don't lose hope on the police just yet, please. I can't even begin to imagine what the families are going thru and would absolutely be demanding all the info and details as they come if it were me. Don't lose hope over info. It's always changing
I think its important to note that the locks were changed? as the mom noted; could it be someone from one of the girls workplace that got access to her keys, since it appears there was no forced entry. A disgruntled coworker could have a very strong motive. Very sobering to see that blood drain from the floor, must have been brutal. My heart goes out to everyone affected by this case. Hoping for answers soon.
The bloodstains seeping from the wall and floor is from the room of Zanna and her boyfriend Ethan. It must have been a blood bath, never have u seen actual blood going through the walls and concrete in a fresh homicide.
This seems killer(s) who're going to violently murder again. When the police find them they need to make certain they're put away for life, thereby saving other lives in the future. IMHO.
Not everybody in the house was murdered. 2 female students slept soundly through the whole incident. Spared by the killer or not, investigators cannot tell!
@@infinitewisdom4557 probably because their bedroom doors were locked,at least they said that
@@tripadvizer4879 I thought they were on the 2nd floor?
I can’t imagine having a baby, raising them, getting them through high school and finally college. Then this happens. I would be devastated beyond belief. If my baby died by such brutal, ugly hands and it such a manner…. I can’t imagine the thoughts in my head.
I was thinking the same. My son is 6 weeks old. Unfathomable.
Same, I have a 3 month old daughter and it breaks my heart thinking about it.
I was thinking the same. Not too long ago these kids were in college, living at home, still being taken care of by their parents. So sick and selfish for someone to do this with someone else lives
Agreed. A whole other level of intense heartache at the hands of a evil, weasel coward.
My kids are the same age. My heart breaks for them and their families. May justice be made and many prayers for the families.
Excellent documentary Brian, thank you for your compassionate coverage of these sad stories that need to be told.💖
I missed your special last night, so I'm so glad you posted it today. Great job on covering this sad, tragic story. Thank you for what you do, you & NN are the best! Prayers for their families, friends and the community.
Does any one know why there is so much focus on the blonde girls as opposed to the other two?
It is extremely troubling that there is an individual out there so disturbed that they would commit such a horrible crime. Until the police name, and/or arrest a suspect, people should lay off the neighbor. You may be guilty of slandering or accusing an innocent person. That home should never be rented out again, it is a place where an extremely evil act took place, and in my opinion, no person in their right mind would want to live there. After all evidence is collected, it should be burned to the ground or something. Pray for the families and justice for the victims.
I completely agree , but knowing this day && age they will most likely turn that shit into a bed & breakfast 😅😅😩
@@sarahjay9220 yup it’s all about business and money these days regardless of what people went through.
You can buy this house and burn it to the ground. Not everybody is as rich as you are to ruin their property.
There's alot of homeless that would be glad of warm shelter just because not all would live in it there's also alot on the other side of the scale who would.
It’s extremely troubling that this is still national news a month later. This happens every day in this country. 4 people that aren’t attractive and not popular, this is forgotten in a day. Pathetic
These 2 girls beautiful life long friendship, and what they endured together breaks my heart. They looked so happy together. A rare, once in a lifetime type of friendship. And from what everyone says, Ethan & Xana had a beautiful kind of love too. This is just so horrid
totally agree. I just want justice for them so badly
@Mister Google please go away.
@@ranadared5339 this ain't fantasy land. Get real. We don't know.
@Mister Google even if they were, what about it?
@Mister Google they were friends since they were 6
One thing that is bugging me is the fact the surviving roommates thought someone was unconscious even though now they had been stabbed, there must of been evidence of blood etc and did they actually see the person or was it through a door they couldn’t get access too? Because if they did actually see the person then I’m sorry but you’d be able to tell if they were breathing or not
apparently the unconscious person wwas the roommate who passed out when finding the bodies
I’m only halfway through of this devastating case. But I do want to acknowledge this incredible reporting. Well done Brian, not a lot of people like you left in the industry I feel like so I commend you
You hit the nail on the head!
@@md9971
You hit the head on the nail. Hard, too.
Brian Anton is a great reporter 👍❤️I really think he's one of the last TRUE REPORTERS! He's all about reporting facts and trys to eliminate lies. I don't envy his job, it's got ro be a rough job reporting on such case's 😢This one for sure. The Gabby Petito case was also extremely heartbreaking 💔 THANK YOU BRIAN ANTON, KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK ❤
Brian …what an awesome reporting. It gave us an inkling on this horrific tragedy which has to be solved. The background of these four and their family is so heart wrenching. So scary to think one individual could have so much anger in them to do this to four young people who had everything going for them.
Yep. Everything. Money and privilege.... same as the killer/s most likely.
The best overall summary yet! Thank you! The influence of media is so important in keeping this terrible crime at the forefront.
HOW CAN YOU NOT HEAR SOMEONE FIGHTING OFF BEING STABBED TO DEATH.
HAVE THE STUDENTS BEEN TESTED TO SEE IF THEY WERE DRUGGED BEFORE THEY WENT TO SLEEP.
IT HAS TO BE SOMEONE THAT KNOWS THEM.
THIS IS HEART BREAKING. I HOPE THEY CATCH THE PERSON WHO DID THIS.
I agree because they had a dog and the dog stayed clam and didn’t bark at all I assume because the dog would have woke then up right ?
agreed totally bizarre. and even if you were asleep wouldnt you wake up and make some loud noises during which
@@shalondawells1388 if the dog was use to many people coming in and out probably would not bark
They could definitely hear you typing from a mile away
Thank you for putting it on RUclips
Greatly appreciative for all your hard work Brian.🦋🙏🥰
Its hard to believe that 3 weeks have already past since this horrendous crime was committed. Praying the evil monster get caught soon.
With all the stupid and irresponsible rumors and speculation, this case may take even longer for police to solve it. The amount of crime scene evidence is massive, and the forensic labs are probably overwhelmed and under tremendous stress. None of that makes solving this case quickly an easy thing to do.
Monster’s, there were two killers
This is a wild case. In 2022 it’s scary to know that someone had the ability to brutality murder four people and not be caught or leave clues to be caught already. So many people have security cameras now, cameras are literally everywhere now.
I'll tell you what wouldn't of reassured me while being in college during a situation like this is the 60 year old male dean saying "I'm scared too". That's not how you lead, junior.
I definitely understand where you’re coming from. I also think if he acted like he wasn’t in the least bit fearful it would just be so obvious he’s lying, it still wouldn’t be very comforting. Just my opinion. I have zero idea what the “right” way to handle this would be. It’s so sad.
I totally agree with and understand what you are saying. But we really need to recognize, understand and endure the times and the social atmosphere or environment we all are currently living in (which is one of childish Wokeness which has a grip on the world at-large in varying degrees) and just bide the time that the said atmosphere or environment is here (present) at this time and say to ourselves at least quietly "this too shall pass, this too shall pass" and it will eventually pass but not because of any magic or incantations or anything else like that but rather that this trying time will either naturally fade away or it will finally be forced away and actual sanity will return to the human race/species. We just have to remain vigilant and be patient. Anyway as I understand it, one of the tenets of Wokeism states something like "in order to lead effectively, you need to be just like your followers. So, for example, if your followers are weak and scared then you, their leader, need to be weak and scared too to effectively lead them (weak ->😩 Scared ->😨) but don't be strong." It's something like. And it seems like that.that 60yo dean was and is spreading the Wokeists' ideology and agenda, the former being what the Wokeists believe, push, thrust upon society as a whole, etc. as to what they actually believe in and do; and the latter being what is pushed, et. al. through the social sphere, work sphere, political and government sphere/s, sports and our extremely broad, worldwide entertainment industry and related sub industries for example, but not specifically limited to arts, parks, zoos, music, dance, etc. , etc., etc. Even the sports or sporting industry (shout out to whomever deserves it). So, you know, you have to be careful what you say, 😉! Just warning ya'! 😉!
No one should be "cleared" until the case is solved.
It was cleared because they knew it was a target by a hitman. Xana and Maddie were targets. Kahlee and Ethan were collateral damage. Xana and Maddie s moms did naughty drug things and this was a message to them.
now that a killer has been identified, I hope all the armchair detectives who accused the neighbor will publicly apologize to him for the HELL they put him through. STFU and let the police do their job instead of making it more difficult for them.
The killer has NOT been identified, only a suspect.
Thank you Brian for posting this on RUclips for us!!
I thought he would never leave the Gabby Case! Hum
I watched my parents lose two sons on two different occasions, and watching the sister comfort her mom, her parents, is so very touching. I can't imagine what this does to a family. Ky heart breaks for them.
I'm so sorry to hear about your Moms loss! I couldn't imagine Dear! 💔🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️😢🙏
So, sorry for your loss. Praying for thee 🙏 MAY GOD BLESS YOU 🙏
Thank you so much. And to clarify, one was an accident and one an illness, so when I say "I couldn't imagine" I am talking about them being taken from this world at the hands of another And their daughter's love and care for them touches me deeply
U can imagine it happen to u twice sorry u had to go thru that
We never hear from the surviving roommates I hope they’re okay and getting the support they need. 🙏🏽
I'm from Costa Rica and I live in the USA currently. This case resonates lot to me since in January 2017, exactly the same situation happened in there and the person who committed the crime was the house owner's nephew who was obsessed with one of the girls who rented the house during that time. He lived close to the house and he knew the house very well and the students movements which worked on his favor to act in the right moment.
Do you have a link to this 2017 murder?
Wow! Hopefully the cops have considered the possibility of something similar w/ this case and investigated any possible connections there
😲 😱
Interesting perspective, Daniela. I'm thinking it could be someone who worked in the home, especially for awhile. For example, an electrician rewiring a house; a cable guy; someone on a renovation crew, etc. They would be there for awhile and could be very familiar with the layout of the house and the tenants if the worker(s) were there for awhile.
In the very same house?
I know its probably unfathomably hard and frustrating with the investigation, but there is a HUGE REASON why authorities DO NOT release very much information ESPECIALLY when the killer is still on the loose...
Why?
@@beremartinez2658the killer in hiding would benefit immensely if they know all of the evidence against him
Brian Your a great interview er WE LOVE YOUR SKILLS
i haven't been able to get this incident out of my mind. i hope everything comes out to light soon so that the victims' families can have some peace of mind. can't imagine what the community of moscow are feeling. may they rest in peace and justice be served🙏🏼
Kaylee’s poor mother can barely speak I just want to hug her and comfort her.
You can hear her voice is weary from crying and emotions.
I think the doctor may have given the mum something to calm her. She looks like she’s just about holding it together. My heart breaks for her 💔
Brian is a awesome investigative reporter ❤!! He has so much class & empathy. I noticed him first at the Gabby P madness. Thank you Brian !! 🙏
I heard differently about the original 911 call. The unconscious body was the roommate who fainted outside and a passerby said unconscious person. The other roommate was hysterical .
That's pretty much what I heard too!
I read the same story a few days after this crime occured...The story sounded pretty legit the way it was written but it's unknown if it is in fact what actually happened
@@jeffc.4828
It makes more sense than what Ashley is reporting tho!
@@vegasgirl7O2 It definitely does make a lot more sense and so I agree with you..I just would have no idea if it is in fact what happened, but I will say the story I read was absolutely believable!
It is possible he was already in the house waiting. This case is just so disturbing and horribly sad.
Possible. Or maybe at least one of the residents was comfortable enough to let him in the House? That means the Killer knew at least one or two of the residents of the house.
Or maybe the roommates let him in.
Anyone of the kids could’ve let this monster in!
I think he could have totally been hiding inside. With room doors locked and missing timeline for X & E, could they have already been murdered?? Downstairs RM asleep already but killer heard M/K arrive so went upstairs???
@@joasok3642 One of the roommates is transgender. Not saying anything bad about anyone here, it's horrible. But one of the "roommates" on the 1st floor is very strong.
So glad Brian you did this. Thanks you are the best!
This is so heartbreaking. I can't stop thinking about it. I hope it gets solved.
Unpopular opinion: I cannot imagine what this family is going through, but this father should really not leak information like this. I feel like he is jeopardizing the case and the police know way more.
I agree! I was thinking the same thing.
@@bambooprincess3495 it helps avoid a few useless comments. Clearly not all of them.
Perhaps he believes that the more info the public has the more likely the suspect will be identified and caught
I agree. They seem desperate for info though! Hope they find the killer !
I agree.
High risk life style? That made me roll my eyes. What a gross comment.
To us old folks this is high risk living
Imho I would call it too relaxed/ trusting and some pretty bad decisions like the open door policy and little to no security features
losing a loved one at the hands of another person is the most helpless feeling in the world. i hope all the families find peace someday and i pray the person responsible faces justice.
NewsNation just keeps on milking.
Glad to see you on this, sad about the situation. Brian Entin. You always do a good job.
As a bartender I keep wandering why theres no footage from the bar
@Bamboo Princess No its not. Maybe in Bumfuck nowhere but not in the city.
Everywhere has cameras now. For these reasons. They probably served underage kids
I found NewsNation and Brian Entin during the Gabbie Petitto case, and I can say you guys offer the most detailed and fact-based reporting in these mysterious crime cases. I really appreciate it. Great job!
It could be another STUDENT that did this.
Thank you, Brian, I trust you to give us the truth. This is a nightmare that no parent can comprehend. Except for these parents...so very sad and useless.
I PRAY THAT THIS MONSTER IS CAUGHT SOON, THE THOUGHT THIS PERSON IS STILL OUT THERE & OTHERS ARE AT RISK IS JUST TERRIFYING.
KEEP SAFE GUYS.
🙏🏼 🙏🏼 🙏🏼 🙏🏼 🙏🏼
I don't think this guy was angry. Now that he's caught it seems like an unemotional psychopath.
My husband committed suicide in 1989 and I remember everyone, family, friends, coworkers, everyone talking nonstop about it for a couple of months... When tragedy happens, you can't even think about much else or talk about much else.. Investigative instincts take over
I am sorry for your loss, Linda.
I’m sorry Linda I can’t imagine what that must feel like. You’re very strong
I am so sorry for your loss and unfortunately it is human nature to talk about tragedy especially within certain cultures like America and what not where our culture is pretty boring, very systemic everyone is kept at "arms reach", so to speak...
So while they will tell you that they are sorry for your loss to your face, they will talk about it to anyone and everyone behind your back while asking those people and each other "I wonder how she gets through it" ... While never asking you this? I'm so sorry... I KNW this has to be tough as I suffered loss and a similar Experience...
I hope you have Healed since then...and I knw that it sounds clichè but they have TRULY made us stronger!
Love 🖤👽💚
So, sorry for your loss. Praying for thee. MAY GOD BLESS YOU 🙏
Dear Linda
I'm so sorry for your loss.🙏
No… Here’s what you’re missing… Ethan and Xana were in the room at BACK of house, the bedroom door can be seen from the back glass doors at bottom of stairs. This makes sense because if one of them woke up to see who was coming down stairs the perpetrator would have run straight into them. They may have ended up collateral damage.
This is what i think. The targets were the two girls. The boyfriend and gf were just innthe way. They need to look into the person who took them home that night. They said they toon am uber home.
Well done sherlock ,why don't the PD hire you?
Exactly
@@nancygatto6571 They have the Uber driver was cleared
False and false. Please stop. Ethan and Xana were at the front of the house in the southeast bedroom. You absolutely cannot see EITHER of the 2nd floor bedroom doors from the 1st floor front door to the house.
If you are refering to the back door slider in the kitchen, that is nowhere near Xana's bedroom. You'd have to walk through the kitchen make a left and step down into the living room through there make another left and go down the hall past the bathroom to Xana's bedroom.
The whole country is becoming a crime scene.
* the whole *world* .
These poor neighbors and family that want to help by taking multiple interviews with media is a mistake. They have demonstrated exactly why authorities don’t share too many details.
@@CreatureCargaux It was 20 degrees, why would the snow on the outside of his clothing melt? I have a different opinion. I saw precipitation falling and Brian's breath over his left shoulder with the darkness in the background and his breath over the front of his coat.
@@CreatureCargauxhe walked right up the hill lol and he lost connection in his microphone, did you watch the interview?
Personally, I feel this was a targeted attack and planned out. It’s so sad to imagine how mentally disturbed someone could be and that they had so much rage to do such a horrific thing multiple times. This was a permanent choice for a temporary feeling. Ugh 😣 the poor families! I hope they get the answers and peace they deserve. The truth will come out.
I believe Bryan Kohberger planned this for a long time.
@@opulententryIt makes wonder how does this bastard know them? They need to give him the death sentence.
Wow we're ok people Sherlock Holmes is on the case repeating what everyone else has said.
Okay but I don't go on those social media accounts & I still don't trust the news. 😂
Kaylee's sister seems to be so strong for her family. I don't think I've seen her cry once in the many interviews she's done. I'm sure she's devastated and is dealing with the trauma in her own way. She probably hasn't even processed it fully yet, and is staying focused on catching the murderer, then once that's done, she'll allow herself to grieve. So sad.
She’s a sister on a mission, they are probably very angry. Like you hurt my baby sister now I’m gonna kill you!!
Some people may go through the anger process before they break down and cry.
Maybe they are a hardworking tough family. They seemed very tightly knit.
Y’all should keep your mouths shut. They are going through it. They’re real people. I’m sure you wouldn’t want to be scrutinized if something this awful happened to your family.
She was the one that helped found the footage of her sister being at the food truck that night. It's not odd. She's focused and staying strong her parents on air. Sounds like she went straight to work on helping to figure out as much as she could. She will probably grieve more once time goes on. Right now she seems to be in fight mode
I don’t cry in front of people, I barely cry in front of my husband. In times of trauma or tragedy I go into manager mode. My brother says I would have made a good ER nurse. I compartmentalize, I cry in the shower when I’m alone, probably not healthy, but it’s the only way I know how to function.
@@InBuffalo well Said 💗
I understand everyone grieves and mourns differently, but I really hate how nonchalant the sister is about the whole situation…
Excellent reporting Brian.. thank you 🙏 ❤❤❤
This is so heartbreaking and such an odd case, it really does seem like it was someone they knew and I hope whoever did this gets caught and the families get some Justice.
there was a press conference and someone got charged for murder. i belobe there are more involved because he asked if there were others who got arrested, but that's still unsure.
Yes, an odd Case indeed. I think because Bryan is accused of being brilliant. Unfortunately, I'm sure the ending will be filled with more questions. New laws will be discussed. Pray strength for the families 🙏
I'm leaning towards the ex boyfriend of Kaylee because her wounds are said to be very significantly more than any other. From what I've heard and seen she was the target and it was brutal like in revenge? jilted lover? and the perpetrator I believe targeted Kaylee like a jilted lover. The other 3 were collateral damage I believe he had murder Maddie because she was in the same room then I believe as he was leaving going back down to the second floor to go out the back door Ethan heard something and came out open the door seen him and could ID him so he had to kill them too. That's my theory until I see different. There was a video from the candle light vigil where Jack comes out as the family was finishing their speech Kayle's mother goes around the father to greet Jack and as he is hugging the mother he looks the father dead in the eye and the father gave him a cold stare and walked away. That's very telling. Plus the dog was not killed or hurt and that tells me the dog didn't bark ? because the dog new the killer? which I think is something to consider.
I am with you mostly on this, I do wonder, you know, alcohol can make one a very sound sleeper, I also wonder if any jealousy was involved just with the fact that the two girls were in bed together.
Nice ASSumption
Agreed.
Nonsense.
leaning towards food truck guy
that kind of rage…could it have to do with neighborhood conflict over noise? I know partying sounds late into the night can be extremely triggering
Excellent coverage as always Brian. Sending love and support to the families and the community. ❤️
I admire you, Brian for your professionalism and respect to the families. The hard work you put in to bring us the facts as soon as they come out doesn’t go unnoticed. News Nation wouldn’t be News Nation without you. Appreciate your work and hope you catch up on rest soon! 🤍
It's never who you want to think. My mom was murdered. Her boyfriend did it, hard to believe. I liked him alot. He had never been in trouble , had his own business. But love and crimes of passion , add drinking its toxic. Apparently he was very jealous, his kids were there. So there was no question who did it. Though he lied alot about it and I new he was sry. He did it. They were forty years old and had went to high school together. You just never know. It's usually someone they know and you wouldn't have expected. Don't let your grief blind you.
So sorry about this. I cannot imagine the devastation
I agree.
So sorry for your loss. Thank you for your incredible insight. 🙏
Just a thought- if the killer was laying in wait for them, he could have been hiding in the upstairs bedroom before anyone got home, and then attacked the people on the first floor before leaving.
May justice be served STAT. Such a heart wrenching thing for the families and loved ones of these people to go through. Bless these beautiful souls - May their love and light be ever present on earth and May their souls rest in love and peace ❤
What very thoughtful comments. My heart goes out to these poor victims and my condolences to their loved ones.🌺❤
I feel horrible for these victims and their families I also feel horrible for that homeowner. I'm sure they rent that home as extra income and it's going to be difficult for them to rent it in the future. Not to mention as that home is held up in an investigation that homeowner still has to make mortgage payments if they have a mortgage. Whoever did this is absolutely disgusting.
I'm sure the home owner already got their money for the semester.
@@Chowe795 Maybe so..but the homeowner may still have a monthly mortgage payment. They also have property taxes, and continued utility payments. It's a big house. It can't remain totally unheated throughout a long, cold Idaho winter. So, this homeowner stands to lose a lot of money. The house may also be very difficult to sell now.
@@Chowe795 who’s going to want to live there after knowing the horror that took place … no one . They won’t be able to sell it either . Unspeakable evil leaves it’s impressions ….
@@cavatinasophia5343 it is truly sad all the way around whoever did this messed up so many lives.
@@janetritchie7499 exactly they may have gotten the money for the semester but we don't know college kids could have been paying monthly. If they have a mortgage sadly but mortgage company it's still going to expect the money plus they are still responsible for property taxes. Not to mention all the lights have been on in that house for three straight weeks.
Thank you for this, and for your work. Keep us posted.
Killer has been caught
So, you are ready to execute him, without a trial?
Our Hearts are Broken for the families of this horrible crime. May God be with them and comfort them all.