Hearing TOOL H. for the first time!!!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 авг 2024
- VIN AND SORI GEAR
www.teespring.com/stores/the-village-market
PAYPAL vinandsorimerch@gmail.com
Patreon / vinandsori
MAIL US SOMETHING AT
Vin and Sori
P.O. Box 7024
Lewiston, Maine 04243
EMAIL US vinandsori@gmail.com
MIDDLE AMERICA WITH VIN AND SORI
/ @middleamericawithvina...
Facebook / vinandsori
Twitter / vinandsori
Instagram / vinsoriseven
Website vinandsori.com
Facebook / vinandsori
Patreon / vinandsori
Twitter / vinandsori
Instagram / vinsoriseven
![Eminem - Somebody Save Me (feat. Jelly Roll) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Vwa0HenQMi4/mqdefault.jpg)
Vin nailed this. It’s about him being afraid to change into a father figure.
I am kind of shocked how easily he picks these out on the first listen. Great Job Vin, well done.
Juice's Ghost #skepticalhippoeyes
ourworlds atwar they sometimes do but clearly they didn’t on this one
It’s about heroine you idiot
@@ddriveddrive4986 No it is not, It's about his son Devo H. Keenan. Here is what Maynard said about it. During the 1997 Lollapooloza tour Maynard said " This next song is about having children, do any of you have kids? It is amazing how much they change your life isn't it?" They then began to play H.
H. Is Maynard’s son, the snake is the inner anger he feels from his passed abuse. His fear is that this anger will arise against his son. But the more his son touches and changes him, the snake is drowned. When that part of his past dies, that’s why he says it’s alright. That the killing of that part of him was considerate.
This is a gem, kind of overlooked unfortunately.
thechayot Who overlooks this song?
Not by me, one of my favorites off the album
Best Tool song in my opinion. Very smart lyrics.
I get your comment. 46&2, Stinkfist, Aenema, Pushit, and Third Eye get so many mentions but this song barely gets any but is so good. I guess that’s why Tool is best listened to as an album. Songs like this are just as good as others but often overlooked.
My favorite tool song
Possibly my favorite Tool song. Gets me every time. Beautiful.
It's hard to judge a favourite tool song as they are all epic pieces of art. But at a push I'd be inclined to agree with you.
Hard agree. Favorite Tool song. Jambi second.
This song completely changed for me after I became a father.
"And as the walls come down and
As I look in your eyes
My fear begins to fade
Recalling all of the times
I have died
And will die.
It's all right.
I don't mind"
Have felt this for FOUR years now, but I don't mind, I don't mind...
Fucking tears man. Tears.
Wow. Pretty damn good guess. Just looked it up. He is trying not to inflict the same abuse on his child and wife that was inflicted on him. He is dealing with the struggle to break the cycle of abuse.
What "abuse" did he suffer?
Don’t believe everything you read. Think for yourself
Ian Scottt because I’m not looking for my interpretation of the lyrics. I’m looking for MJKs
Adam Gilmore Everyone has had some form of trauma. So yes In a way it’s true but there was no abuse. This whole album is him trying to fix what’s broke.
It kinda defeats the purpose of Tool if you try to find Maynard's meaning of the songs, not saying you can't, if you want to then go ahead, but to me I'd rather not know what his meaning is and Interpret the music the way I feel/hear it.
I've heard that in 1997 while playing at Lollapalooza, Maynard referenced this song "This next song is about having children, do any of you have kids? It is amazing how much they change your life isn't it?". I'm sure there's some deeper meaning to the song about just how exactly children change your life, but at least we know from The writer's lips what the song is about!
Todd Staten Yes his son is the driving force of the change he’s going through. Very good comment. To understand the deeper meaning, start the album from the beginning try and understand that this is all going on in his head. dealing with his emotions, fears,and Traumas.
That was my first concert. Lollapalooza '97 in Charlotte, NC. Tool changed my life that day. Ive been a drummer ever since.
Its about the birth of his son Devo H. Keenan. And how it forced him to change and allow who he was in the past to die. His son is consideratly killing who he used to be...
Exactly.
Exactly what this song is about
So powerful!
No it's not.. it's about heroin
Just shows you how deep the writing is. The music is amazing and the writing is a whole different level. That’s what’s makes Tool so good and deep.
"H." is a song by the American rock band Tool. The song was released as the second single from their second album, Ænima on March 19, 1997. "H." reached number 23 on the US Mainstream Rock Tracks chart.[1]
The working title for the song was "Half Empty", and thus "H." most likely stands for that or "Half Full".[2] During several tours, the lead singer of Tool, Maynard James Keenan, has referenced his son, whose middle name is H, just before performances of this song.
However, on several occasions, specifically on November 23, 1996[3] during a show at the Electric Factory in Philadelphia, Maynard James Keenan does grant some insight into another meaning of the song. Speaking to the audience he says, "So, any of you ever watched those Warner Bros. cartoons? Sometimes there's that one where that guy is having a tough time trying to make a decision. He's got an angel on one shoulder and the devil on the other. Seems pretty obvious, right? Usually it's the angel who is kind of the one trying to give him the good advice while the devil is trying to get him to do what's bad for him. It's not always that simple though. Most times they're not really angels or devils. They're just friends giving you advice, looking out for your best interest but not really understanding what's going to be best for you. So it kind of comes down to you. You have to make the decision yourself... This song is called H."
You know, usually I’m all team-Sori but i think I have to break faith a bit today.
Firstly, from my knowledge, Vin’s interpretation absolutely knocks it out of the park. In fact, it’s so spot-on I have to suspend a bit of disbelief. This was written around the time of Maynard’s first-born (his son). I don’t think the proper subject would be easy to nail down on a first listen. Most others, myself included, would have initially been more inclined to agree with Sori.
The second big break is on this point of “darkness” - it’s one of the things Tool is loved for, and it kind of shocks me that someone wouldn’t pick up on it. In fact, it’s something that sometimes turns people off of Tool - especially their older content.
I could see how dissecting Lateralus early on could throw someone off the scent though. Although it has its own moments of darkness, it’s generally far more uplifting than the rest of Tool’s discography. And while I’d say that most of Tool’s music has a generally positive/healthy message, most of the sonic paths they create to get there are completely built around confronting and moving through the darkness of the human experience.
It’s one of the reasons fans find their work so cathartic; a lot of it centers around being self-reflective and confronting the darkness that can otherwise consume your life. Even if you just reflect on the songs you’ve already heard so far, you can see it. “Jambi” does this. “Wings for Marie (10,000 Days pt. 2)” does this. “Jimmy” does this. “Pushit” does this. “The Patient” does this. “Schism” does this.
I think the biggest irony here might be that Ænima is hailed almost universally as their darkest album. So much so that many fans who enjoy them for that dark edge actually enjoy it more than Lateralus, which would otherwise generally be considered their magnum opus.
Don’t fight it Sori...succumb to the power of the dark side!!
The first time I heard it, I thought it was about drug addiction. If you listen to it with that in mind, you can defiantly see it being interpreted that way. Especially if that's something you have witnessed or been through. Of course I've known for a while what the songs true meaning is because I have been a fan for a long time but that is great thing about TOOL. They want you to interpret the songs the way you see them. The way you connect with them. Let them be that "tool" for you.
@@musicmademejester Yeah, I generally agree with that. I think, especially with Tool, although Maynard probably always writes with a particular thing in mind (in this case, having his first child), I think he purposefully affects a balance between the specific and the general. In that way, it can be specifically therapeutic for him, in the particular, when performing, but can also be therapeutic for the listeners, generally, when listening and going through whatever roughly-related issues they may be facing in their own lives.
In fact, one of the cool things I've noticed in particular about Tool's music, having been a fan for quite a long time, is that the personal meaning of songs can really move and shift with your own life over time. And it can shift without you changing your mind regarding what the song may have been specifically written about originally. For instance, I think there's very few songs off this album that I personally experience in the same way as I did in 1996-1997. Or even in 2002-2003. Or 2010-2011. It's always been just general enough to shift along with my perspective. And that's pretty cool.
@@crossofcrimson Yeah, I totally agree with all that.
There are websites where the meaning of this song is discussed. I think Vin is a smart guy, but I highly doubt he could decipher the meaning behind this song on the first listen. I'm sure he does research beforehand. He tends to get his interpretation of Tool songs a little too spot on a little too often. I could be wrong though.
STAR 420 I actually sympathize with that sentiment. Vin is a very smart guy, but there are moments in some of these interpretations (especially of Tool songs, but other songs as well) where my surprise borders on suspicion. This one triggered that feeling for sure. Another one was the “Forty-Six & 2” interpretation - specifically the chromosomal insight. Even with knowledgeable people, the immediacy of that guess would be a bit beyond reach, particularly because “Forty-Six & 2” describes the (supposed/metaphoric) evolved state (a total of 48 chromosomes), whereas actually existing humans have forty-four and 2 (sex) chromosomes. I’m not saying it’s impossible to land on the reference, especially if you have a biology background or something. But to immediately forward that guess minutes after hearing/seeing the lyrics? Well, it’s definitely a bit of a stretch.
The thing that’s been getting to me more is that I get the feeling this song-by-song breakdown was actually recorded before the live-listen, as they (oddly) seem surprised in both versions, but more genuinely surprised in the song breakdowns. It didn’t feel that way at all for Lateralus. I know they were leaving town to go to NAMM, and had pre-recorded quite a bit before to give themselves a buffer. I can’t help but feel like these were all recorded before the live-listen, and it just wasn’t said.
Now, I wouldn’t be upset if the first listen was song-by-song, and the live album-listen came second. But the thought of them being dishonest about it is a bit disturbing. Maybe I’m wrong. I like them quite a bit, so I’m willing to give them the benefit of the doubt. But I can’t say these thoughts haven’t passed my mind.
Wow Vin, you nailed that interpretation. Also this song grew on me so first time listen I would give it max 8/10 too but now it is my second favorite tool song.
Great discussion my friends. Much love from New Orleans!!!
You guys should check out the Opiate ep by Tool. How can you see their growth if you don’t listen to their early stuff?
Jay Money I agree, all his songs are in order.
Its hard for me to not question Vin's amazing ability to decipher not only tools lyrics but 95 % of the artists they react to lyrics correctly practically every time. That's a true and rare gift and hosting a reaction channel on utube wouldn't be his career path. I'm positive a talent like that would be highly sought after and would demand a generous salary. He does his homework, guaranteed
God this song is just TOO FRIGGIN GOOD. Tool is just... The best I swear.
They aren't a band that just speaks out loud "this is a song about drugs!" It's all so beautifully wrapped in the lyrics, and the music is just powerful and punches you repeatedly. Fuck, this is the first time listening while reading the lyrics and now that I know it's about his son, I'm almost in tears writing this.
Call me weak, but god damn tool are masters. I grew up with them, they are my favorite band, and I'm just so friggin pumped for the next album
Complete my RUclips existence, Vin and Sori
Portal - Curtain
!!!!!!
GOD WILLS IT.
Crowded House, Dont Dream Its Over!! You need to do it . Very important song that musicians like Mic Fleetwood and Dave Mustaine have spoke about and love. Crowded House Dont Dream Its Over!!
You’re a genius vin. You almost always nail the lyrics
This song is amazing and highly underrated as far as TOOL songs are concerned. Vin was spot on Maynard wrote this song about his sons birth and the changes he will have to make in his own life for his son. Again brilliant song and obviously the lyrical content. 👍
Novembers Doom - Autumn Reflection
6 full months over 365!
Iron Maiden - Phantom of the Opera (or something off of their first two albums with their original lead singer - Di'Anno)
Yes! I've watched a ton of yalls videos over the years. Good stuff! Nice to see my favorite Tool song!
This song... 🔥🔥🔥
What do you mean hearing for the first time? Didnt you guys listen to the whole album a few days ago?
Favorite tool song without a doubt. The kid makes him Half empty because he has to give up some things yet Half full because it makes him open up his Heart again.
Sori, not every song is about a "boyfriend + girlfriend" type of relationship......
All of cannibal corpse's songs are. Why wouldn't tool's be too?
@@matthewgodding777 lol, she does always go straight for a romantic relationship.
Limited mind, she can't help it...
It’s a look into her perception of her own marriage
@@baartbman2390 oh come on. I wouldn't say she has a limited mind at all... it might just be naturally oriented to seek that out. she might just have grown up listening mostly to music like that. but saying she has a limited mind is way too harsh. I think she's smart.
This song is sooo underrated. I was hypnotized first time I heard it!
The great thing about music as you can make your own interpretation and make it personal to yourself. There are no "right" answers.
This is probably my favorite song off of this album! It’s so good and a bit overlooked By people I feel like
I Won't See You Tonight Part 2 by Avenged Sevenfold
Anathema- Internal Landscapes
Anathema- Dreaming Light official video with the two girls
Anathema- Untouchable live from Bulgaria
Anathema- Flying live from Bulgaria
An Amazing band that needs to done.
Not at all a metal fan but tool is my favorite band and love me some anathema too. First time I see them mentioned on in the comment section
Still just chillin waiting for “Say Hello to Heaven”
Awesome reaction to an awesome song! First time watching you guys react. Will be watching more. Great tool shirt btw! I have the exact same one
Vin, it's Chris Beckerle one of your OG Tool subscribers, if you got the meaning of this song with no research, damn man, salute, you are even better at this then I thought.
Reaction
Tool - Vicarious
Just want to give a quick shout out to Adam Jones, drummer of Tool. Dude is phenomenal!!!!
nope.. that would be danny carey. but I'm glad to see you know the name of someone in the band other than maynard. adam is one of the guitarists, you could say hes the lead.
3 more days til TOOL and my brothers birthday celebration. It will be our 11th time seeing TOOL, only 3rd time together. We’re headed to see them after his small family wedding party. 🎈 🎉❤ Good Christian family.
It amazes me that if you send an instrumental track to someone & this is what that person feels shares & voices.
Your pretty on it dude! I love you dude..your tuned into this!
I love your channel a lot. You're very great.
Beautiful mind Vin👌👍got that spot on
5:39 Sori's reaction and body posture is spot on!!!
Still my favorite Tool album.
Granted, I was 14 it hit me at the right time...but it's a GREAT album!!!!!
the bridge that starts at 4:16 is my favorite moment on the entire AEnima album
Vin, I am impressed by your whits. If you really have never heard about the meaning of this song that is. Well done!!‘ love ya guys.
Love watching you both try to nail this down..This is exactly what MJK wanted,
I think..anyway..the guy is truly an enigma, yet an open book.
mesmerizing reaction wow.. it gets you dont u.. i would love for u to do Godsmack Touche live in Vegas..
Thanks for all the Tool reactions. Watching you crazy kids react. Sori just rocks! She wants you to feel this song. Peace. Stephen
Type O Negative - Creepy Green Light
Unfortunately, I don't think they like ToN and their most recent ToN vid has a lot of dislikes so they're probably done.
I always took the "my blood" line as being a reference to self injury. A reminder that love and openness is the path to healing from the kind of pain that makes that kind of outlet necessary.
This song is about struggling having a kid after having a bad childhood
Great to see other Reaction Channels doing Tool 2018 Tool Army member here
It's about his kid and how he pushed Maynard's transformation
The song is called H. H is a common street name for heroin. This song has always been interpreted as getting over heroin addiction to me.
Cool you would review this song today i’ve been listening to it and vibing off it today
Helloween ☆ Keeper of the seven keys 🎃
Def one of my fav ones. That and judith
The songs about his son Devo H Keenan.
H. Is the name given to the main character in the CS Lewis novel “A Grief Observed”. Where he battled with God and grieved over the passing of his wife. He fought and challenged God to justify the enormous loss in his life. Jeopardizing his faith, challenging his belief system, because of the closeness he had with his wife for such a long time. But wouldn’t submit and reject his faith, regardless of his faith. He submits to God on this situation. CS’ wife’s name was Helen Joy Davidson. And he penned the book under another name using the main characters name as H (the person being grieved over). Picture a person alone after losing the love of their life and having an argument with God about justifying this loss. And God justifying it to the point you submit to His will. He knew the anger was wrong, vs God for the loss. But he couldn’t help it. Ultimately he accepts it and try’s to move on. Maynards lyrics on multiple songs are comparable to the works of CS Lewis.
Wow with this and many Tool songs I actually start shedding tears at some point into the song. Maynard hits me so hard.
Reminds me of the movie White Men Can’t Jump. Something about listening to Jimi Hendrix. You can’t just hear Jimi. You have to listen to him. TOOL is the same way. You have to listen and not just hear it to get a full appreciation of the music and lyrics
Interesting fact that the working title for this song was called "Half Empty." But as usual Vin is mostly right, but like most Tool songs you can interpret the song anyway you want.
I agree but there's no way this was the first time they ever listened to the song. Tool songs are confusing sometimes and I just can't see him listening to once and understanding every line in this song that way. Probably did a lot of research on this song before they did this video
The nice thing about tool songs is that it means whatever you need it to mean.
The song is about choices and people who mean good by helping you with these choices, but end up being poison for you. so you have to sometimes only listen to yourself.
I'm always so impressed with how Vin can pick up on these themes so quickly.
The power of having several Personal Computers in the room, to Google Search info on the fly...
Prior planning
@@sfjarhead4062 Are you & Defensive Wounds insinuating that Vin is disingenuous? lol
Defensive Wounds they don’t research
SFjarhead they don’t research
Thank you for making me revisit this song. The first time I heard it I was a teenager and English is not my native language, so I didn't fully understand Tool songs, but now that I am adult and with your knowledge, I can totally enjoy Tool.
My take on the song is its about his son and his son's mother, and his life as a rock star, always on the road and the temptations. The abuse angle works too though. H and 46 & 2 are my favorite songs on this album.
This is about how the birth of his son has changed his life for the better
Love these 2 what an awesome couple Vin was spot on on this
Im too glad watching this ♡
Hugs from argentina
Vin hit the nail on the head!
I used to warm up for practice with this song when I first started learning bass guitar. And then seeing Tool for the first time at Lollapalooza 97. So many great memories.
Can’t help but always having a Toolgasm when listening to that intro, Tool makes me take extra long trips to the store.
Wow, Vin, you sure interpret songs so very very well!
Been waiting for this one
Damn, Vin smoked this one. A lot of meanings from different people on this song but the most recognized one is exactly what Vin is mentioning
Vin is completely right.
U guys r so great
It s about his son's birth changing him
There is something to be said about intelligently written lyrics, through poetry and music, tristes and analogues that explain one thing as the forefront, but ask to be internalized, and made the reader/listener's own. I love Tool and System in equal, but, whereas system is a band that is almost always expressing how they want their message interpreted, tool, and especially Maynard asks you to self reflect on the lyrics and the music, to find your own meaning. We want to feel close to the artists we revile in, and we find ourselves in the best of it/them. That is what art does when art is done best... We find meaning for ourselves because we can, because we need it, nd it helps to fill the gaps that our static construct of reality can't do without exterior context. I look, and the horizon is... so I choose the road less travelled...
Love how you guys head bobbed the entire song!
Holy fuck I can’t believe Vin got the meaning immediately. Every single bit of it. So impressive. You sure you didn’t cheat?
its funny how on point Vin is, and how completely off Sori is and how much she's arguing the point lol, its entertaining
So these reaction videos from the Aenima album were recorded "before" the live listening video you uploaded 5 days ago..????..
Yea, they are out of town at NAAM, so these were recorded awhile ago.
Have you been informed that it's about his son yet? LOL
Basically what Vin is saying....
I interpret it as: His son is taking away the pain of his past and giving him hope for the future. But at the same time he is making him a "softer" and more vulnerable man (considerately killing me).
My favorite Tool song.
It's about Maynard going through his life change. How deep you wanna dig is up to you.
You guys really should read his book. I think it would give you some insight to his way of thinking. It's a good read.
Always thought it was about being abused and trying to break the cycle of abuse.... Which ever form.
Spot on Vin. It's about him not wanting to act like his father figures did to him to his son Devo H Keenan
I thinks it's basically about the residue of the effect adults behaviour have on children, good or bad. And the desperate need to sever those feelings/ties to be whole. And the fear that it's not possible to break that cycle. Sometimes even the best intentions by adults can negatively impact a child into adulthood.
I also think all songs are subjective and usually interpretations relate in some way to the interpreter. I've noticed that how it relates to you can change as you grow older and your perspective changes too. You could really only know by asking the writer and Maynard has said he likes to leave it to the listener, it's part of the art of music to him. 4 people listen to a song and you get 4 different ideas and some you never anticipated. It's kinda magical when good music does that, in my opinion.
Play this song while looking at HR GIGER'S ART WORK. IT'S THAT otherworldly
Btw. His son's middle initial is H. And he was born in 1995, a year before the release date of Aenima. On his son's reddit AMA he sort of avoided questions about his middle initial. I don't think this is a coincidence. Definitely about becoming a father.
Dammit Vin your phone keeps going off and always think it's mine.
This is the song that made me fall in love with tool. Maynards versatility in full display.
Still my favourite Tool-Album. Memories, oh sweet memories.
Nice reaction V&S...Over coming addiction for his son/Loved one... Well thats what I thought anyways. First reaction woohoo
Dream Theater - A Change of Seasons
Dream Theater - The Count of Tuscany
Dream Theater - The Spirit Carries On (live)
Dream Theater - The Dance of Eternity (live)
guys you both are right, there is even the theory that marks this song is about Heroin, another theory says this song is about the cruel past of maynard's infancy and nevertheless the song is about "relationships" father-son, lovers, drugs, and everything all you can make a relation with, no matter the object.