This song took on a whole different meaning to me after I lived through a co-dependent relationship with a girl with borderline personality disorder. There’s this weird dynamic where you want to do everything you can to protect the other from pain and so you don’t want to harm them by acknowledging the pain they are inflicting. When you don’t acknowledge it you find yourself becoming distant and resentful. You get the idea that you can endure it long enough for them to heal and you don’t believe they harm you intentionally. But your permitting it is inflicting damage on them as well. The realization that you are as responsible for the abuse as they are is really challenging. You realize that you are choking this beautiful and pure thing that you love by denying it has failed. Think about the lyrics. Place your trigger on my finger. Basically saying we are cooperating in destroying ourselves. Choking this infant here before me. That’s when you find yourself lashing out in self preservation and feel extreme guilt in harming the other person that you still see as pure and innocent. The whole claw your throat out line really hits me because it’s exactly how I experienced it. I didn’t want to hurt her by leaving and I knew it would be deeply painful because she would never end the relationship and the dynamic would never improve. We would always be hurting each other long term. In the end the only way she left was the most painful “hateful” way. I didn’t want to do it but I had to be “cruel” for us each to heal and become well. It killed me inside but as they said there’s no love in fear. Pushit is a perfect name because they fear you will leave them and they try to get proof that you won’t by doing terrible things to scare you off. They push you away. They view the exchange, the argument, the reconciliation as proof of love. The lyrics line up so perfectly. “I saw the gap again today” is the realization that they aren’t truly close, there’s a fissure. She begs him to stay and he’s struggling to push her and himself apart for both of there Health.
My favourite part of this song is when they did this song live in 1997 and a stranger decided to climb up on stage and Maynard not knowing how to react he decides through him down and put him in a chokehold, while maynard still continues to sing and do his screams simultaneously. ruclips.net/video/dS41ost0pM8/видео.html
Lyrical correction: He doesn't say "Push it in me, pushit on me". He says "but you didn't need to pushit on me". Pretty significant difference in meaning lol.
@@Qliphirot Actually Maynard has released the official song lyrics he had written done before recording. There's an entire website that basically he has given those to (although I'm not sure he ever released the lyrics for 10,000 Days). Looking at them, there are variances in a ton of the lyrics he provided, and what made it to the record. Because Maynard while recording would feel out his writing and change things on the fly. Tools concert's on most songs have some to a lot of variations from the album releases. Both musically and vocally.
@@BoWeava The way Tool "fans" treat the band on their facebook page I really hope it is an april fools joke. I want Tool fans to suffer until they finally give up hope and move on. Or die.
I'm honestly REALLY looking forward to you guys doing Lost Keys & Rosetta Stoned!!! (The two play into each other similarly to Parabol & Parabola) 😊 You guys would get the biggest kick out of it omg please
For all the people saying they are tired of all the tool reactions on this channel i got 3 things for ya 1 this is their channel not yours 2 they just did a album reaction so they breaking thing from the channel And 3 ITS FUCKING TOOL HOW DO YOU NOT LOVE THEM
"Is he talking about himself or the other person?" answer; yes! It's about the relationship between his lower and higher being, and the ego trapped in the middle. Third Eye follows along the same theme, but at a different point in the spiritual journey. I'm glad you mentioned Peterson, I have reservations regarding his political opinions, but he has done some good talks on the same Jungian ideas of the shadow self, and of descending the Abyss (the gap) and confronting the Beast, that inspire this song. Peterson even describes the relationship we have with our demons as being like toxic worldly relationships..
This song is clearly about jujitsu, think about it every line basically relates to rolling with someone, basically "trying to kill" them but at then afterwards resuming friendship (still love me). "Bang my head upon the faultline" = the little gap between mats. "slipping back into the gap again" = getting past someone's guard. "put me somewhere i dont wanna be" = opponent turning the tables on you and now you're on defensive. "minimize my movement anyway / i must persuade you another way" = basically the thought process during a match. Essentially every line can relate to jujitsu if you look at it, also iirc Maynard practices jujitsu so yeah.
Favorite Song. Not just tool, in general. Been waiting for you guys to get here, even though you listened to the salival version, that one doesnt have that grimy guitar in the middle of the instrumentals while Maynard is dropping the one liners to start it and then it just comes through full force. one of my favorite interludes that comes back hard with Maynards voice so clean in those high notes. 9 months now I dont know what to complain about, but am still happy. Finish the album and I will start pushing for undertow.
You guys - wonderful to watch. Rewinding over your reactions, remind me of how I used to utterly lose it back in the day, listening to this. Please keep them coming - you guys are great!
It means that complaining about something that won't change is stupid though. They said they'd do the whole album. Don't like it? Go watch something you like and come back when it's done
Ethan Peterson - Certain Lyrics “I saw the gap again today... You didn’t need to shit on me (women sometimes shit during childbirth). You minimize my movement anyway. Choke this infant here before me. You’re pushing and shoving me (pushing during child labor) .... “ At first I thought he was using the childbirth experience/mother and child relationship as a metaphor
Ethan Peterson - One of my favorites is when Maynard uses the inner workings of a coffee pot in The Pot: “ Rob the crave to snow the cradle then burn the evidence down “. “Eyeballs deep in muddy waters (under the influence of caffeine?).”
"Choke this infant here before me. What is this but my reflection? Who am i to judge or strike u down?" I believe he is saying she is acting like an infant but perhaps he is as well.
I look at this similarly. Except I don't see a girl at all. I think he is talking about his own ego. Maynard has a reputation of being an asshole (I don't necessarily agree), and this song may have been a form of self reflection. He's looking at himself in the mirror, and has nobody to blame but himself. Striking yourself down or judging yourself, will only put you into a deeper hole. Look at the lyrics on the next verse: "Rest your trigger on my finger Bang my head upon the fault line You better take care not to make me enter 'Cause if I do, we both may disappear" I think "we" is his own physical self, and his ego. He loves himself, but he didn't show it in his actions, and kept pushing himself to a low point. If you look at Maynard now vs then, he's a pretty respectful person. Worked on himself a lot. This is just my opinion, I can see both sides though.
I love watching first reactions to TooL songs. But once you heard your first TooL song and you we’re like oh snap this is shizznit. 😆 wasn’t it impossible not to hear the rest of that album
@@BittersweetDuality He thought that they were going in the studio in March, but they actually started two/three months later, hence why they didnt release it in fall. (They only release in fall/Spring, so that's why it's coming this spring).
Lucifer Brahma you aren’t required to pay them. It gives you a higher chance of you join a patreon alliance but it’s not mandatory; Patience is though.
The beginning of this song, with the orchestral bee type sounds. Like a Hornet's nest being stirred up. Overlooked element. The studio version of this song is vastly different than the Salival live versions. Almost like two completely different songs. The live version has a completely different beginning. Has tabla drums implemented and then slowly builds up to the studio version at the end.
Many songs on this record and Undertow (This song being one of them) are about the horrible sexual abuse Maynard endured as a child. He has talked about it many times in the past...
Danny Carey is everywhere, many of tool songs start with Danny doing the drums and the rest of the band follows him, the way he plays is called polyrithmic, he does 2 rythms or 3 rithms at the same time.
Vin/Sori not sure if you will read this but I know how much Vin loves KoRn and Jonathan Davis loves Pink Floyd. They did an AMAZING rendition of Another Brick in the Wall Parts 1,2,3 and Goodbye Cruel World. They did a studio and live. I think it would be a perfect combo vid for you guys. Consider it.
Sori, Orion has brought you a very beautiful glow today. Yeah when this started I remembered that you had done the Salival version before. Great review as usual and still looking forward to Aenima review which does reference Ron L Hubbard. Have a great day and I hope your return trip home was good.
ah, yea you're right, sorry nvm me... my new theory it they didn't write the title, it was someone else they have to help and they didn't know about the previous listen (but they should've)
You guys should react to the band He is Legend! They are so underrated, but have truly been one of best rock bands for the last 15 years! I'd start with the song stranger danger
Hey guys I love your shit, and this album review has been awesome. I just subscribed to your patreon account and I don't mind because your REM reviews were cool . But While Tool was cool I think an album re action / review of Pearl Jam's 3rd album "Vitalogy" Might just blow your minds
vicarious, Vicarious, VICARIOUS, VICARIOUS!! vicarious. Have you thought about Vicarious? Vicarious might be a good song to check out next. Something to consider might be Vicarious. A song like Pushit, at least in my humble, seems to be a song someone might get into if there a devoted Tool fan. Unlike a lot of other Tools longer songs Pushit has many twists & turns. There's an awful lot there, traveling through space & all that. It's not an intro song, and although you guys have listened to a lot of Tool I believe a song like Pushit cannot be fully appreciated in the short run. Over time it might become your mantra. There's only way response when listening to Pushit for the first time..."whoa".
I'm confused. You guys listened to the entire Aenima album last week but you're reviewing songs from it this week. The title says " first time listen".
This might come as a shocker...but recordings are things that happened in the past. They take time to edit and clean up, render and upload. You might have seen the livestream and more then likely what’s making its way into these videos came from that live session. There’s a near 100% chance that these guys have rendered and uploaded their entire album review already at this point and have the episodes set to scheduled release day by day. Don’t get so tied up in the chronology of your personal experience
@@ReignSurvives the live stream was in their BED you dipshit, why don't YOU check it before getting out of control angry at internet comments you think are wrong? ruclips.net/video/TEJgZ7lU3d0/видео.html its an entirely different setting than the one in these reviews, so the question here is 100% LEGIT.
Crowded House, Dont Dream Its Over!! You need to do it . Very important song that musicians like Mic Fleetwood and Dave Mustaine have spoke about and love. Crowded House Dont Dream Its Over!!
Vin and Sori. I wouldn’t be so quick to just plug this song into a man/woman relationship. Think of a child being molested and/or abused by an adult and listen to the song again. By the way, there are hidden tracks during the creepy/melodic part. In the beginning you can hear “you make me do it” and toward the end you can here “in the end, we’ll be alright”. One last thing, some of the lyrics were wrong.
This is one of the most literal songs maynard has written. This is exactly what it is. Hes unhappy w his relationship and theyve just had a baby. What do i do?
I know lol i feel like im taking crazy pills. How can you be a die hard and have never gotten to these songs yet? Who doesn't binge these when theyre discovering them? So what, are we just watching people listen to songs we like?
As someone told me in the comment session in another video, they apparently recorded a few reaction videos to aenima songs "before" and recorded the live listening session "afterwards"...but they uploaded the latter before the others... But i might be wrong.. (or rather that person might be wrong). And yes of course they did the reaction video to the Salival version last year..
His lyrics go MUCH deeper than that. There's a ton of mathematics and theories that go into his writing. Check out 46&2 for example. This is a good explanation for the song. ruclips.net/video/OufK0647p1U/видео.html
Hello Guys! Here we go again ! Time for my daily nagging ;-) to wish that you do something completely different. It would be interesting if you widen your views to do something so really stand out? In Norway there is a singer who is referred to as nature, fairy, haunting or angel. There are a few artists who are in the same spirit but this is a class of its own. Her whole being is like an emotional bomb. Her name is Aurora. This song Murder song 5,4,3,2,1 is not her most beautiful but perhaps the most interesting to discuss. I really hope you dare to take this song. :-) AURORA - Murder Song (5, 4, 3, 2, 1) [Live at Nidarosdomen]
my first time hearing Pushit, ironically, was the Salival live "reimagining" of it. It literally blew me away and still does whenever I listen to it. compared to it, this one is garbage. it's still good, don't get me wrong, but omg that live version is mindblowing
As someone told me in the comment session in another video, they apparently recorded a few reaction videos to aenima songs "before" and recorded the live listening session "afterwards"...but they uploaded the latter before the others...
@@briancarroll6803 Dude they said they heard Pushit Salival (live album) version.. But goddamn it, they released the Full Aenima reaction, and after a few days reaction to Pushit, for the first time, I mean come on, shouldn't they release their videos chronologically? Because this is confusing.
@@lopolik I see now what you're saying. There's dissonance between the record dates and what they wanted to accomplish in the way of production and presentation. It's like noticing a glass is filled (or emptied) to different levels across camera cuts haha.. If I understand correctly, they record these reactions first, so they'll be genuine. Then, record the full album listen, usually with a live chat, to release as a precursor and to this reaction "series". What's funny is you and I have put this much energy into discussing the video title.. Obviously my work day has me starved for entertainment today haha. Good catch by the way
Yeah, Misfortune Cookies would be nice : D Cool drum mix in this one and yeah Vin, that bass is nasty! Do check the bass tone on Atheist's album Elements, with Frank Zappa's sound engineer. Sori, when you headbang, your hair's supposed to move up and down too : D : D
Youre talking about syncopations (2 things in different times at once). Polyrhythms are rhythms that dont sound like the time theyre actually in kinda. Meshuggah songs are mostly all 4/4 for example but they never sound like it, thats polyrhythm
You already have done Halloween by Helloween and that was a great reaction and topic, when you both get a chance could you check out the second song in the Trilogy, keeper of the 7 keys? It continues the fight between good and evil. Here is the link to the song on youtube. ruclips.net/video/ZUzpf3mMsxA/видео.html Enjoy the rest of your week and thank you both for being there and doing what you are doing.
Wondering why Peter Steele gets vilified with toxic masculinity yet the same message comes thru in “claw your fucking throat away” and..... is it just because Peter was less eloquent? 😇
This song took on a whole different meaning to me after I lived through a co-dependent relationship with a girl with borderline personality disorder.
There’s this weird dynamic where you want to do everything you can to protect the other from pain and so you don’t want to harm them by acknowledging the pain they are inflicting. When you don’t acknowledge it you find yourself becoming distant and resentful. You get the idea that you can endure it long enough for them to heal and you don’t believe they harm you intentionally.
But your permitting it is inflicting damage on them as well. The realization that you are as responsible for the abuse as they are is really challenging. You realize that you are choking this beautiful and pure thing that you love by denying it has failed.
Think about the lyrics. Place your trigger on my finger. Basically saying we are cooperating in destroying ourselves. Choking this infant here before me. That’s when you find yourself lashing out in self preservation and feel extreme guilt in harming the other person that you still see as pure and innocent.
The whole claw your throat out line really hits me because it’s exactly how I experienced it. I didn’t want to hurt her by leaving and I knew it would be deeply painful because she would never end the relationship and the dynamic would never improve. We would always be hurting each other long term. In the end the only way she left was the most painful “hateful” way. I didn’t want to do it but I had to be “cruel” for us each to heal and become well. It killed me inside but as they said there’s no love in fear.
Pushit is a perfect name because they fear you will leave them and they try to get proof that you won’t by doing terrible things to scare you off. They push you away. They view the exchange, the argument, the reconciliation as proof of love.
The lyrics line up so perfectly. “I saw the gap again today” is the realization that they aren’t truly close, there’s a fissure. She begs him to stay and he’s struggling to push her and himself apart for both of there Health.
My favourite part of this song is when they did this song live in 1997 and a stranger decided to climb up on stage and Maynard not knowing how to react he decides through him down and put him in a chokehold, while maynard still continues to sing and do his screams simultaneously.
ruclips.net/video/dS41ost0pM8/видео.html
What?
Lyrical correction: He doesn't say "Push it in me, pushit on me". He says "but you didn't need to pushit on me". Pretty significant difference in meaning lol.
kurtrussell most of the tool lyric videos I've seen, have at least a couple mistakes, smh. It detracts from the lyrics significantly...
@Skankshot Yeah the person who did these lyrics videos that they're using for this album did a pretty poor job
That's why i hate when bands do not provide the lyrics.
@@Qliphirot Actually Maynard has released the official song lyrics he had written done before recording. There's an entire website that basically he has given those to (although I'm not sure he ever released the lyrics for 10,000 Days).
Looking at them, there are variances in a ton of the lyrics he provided, and what made it to the record. Because Maynard while recording would feel out his writing and change things on the fly.
Tools concert's on most songs have some to a lot of variations from the album releases. Both musically and vocally.
Literally official lyrics say otherwise. These ones appear to be correct for the most part (few minor errors elsewhere)
"If when I say I might fade like a sigh if I stayed." That is an incredible powerful lyric that resonates in so many souls.
Here supporting the Aenima album review and break downs! Can't wait to watch each one!
Tool drummer Danny Carey has revealed when the new Tool album will come out, i saw the video of him today saying in April hope its true.🎸
Yeah dude April 1 confirmed.
Tool won't release the new album until all current Tool fans are dead or deaf. Those fans are the scourge of the earth.
Yea ya never know, could be an April fools joke, hopefully not.
@@BoWeava The way Tool "fans" treat the band on their facebook page I really hope it is an april fools joke. I want Tool fans to suffer until they finally give up hope and move on. Or die.
scizyr 😂 slow down there big fella! Lol jk. I don't troll their FB page so I wouldn't know, but I have a pretty good idea of what you mean.
He said mid April. Not April 1.
This is easily one of the best songs ever written.
A Perfect Circle - *THE NOOSE*
But I'm more than just a little curious how you're planning to go about making your amends to the dead.
I'm honestly REALLY looking forward to you guys doing Lost Keys & Rosetta Stoned!!! (The two play into each other similarly to Parabol & Parabola) 😊 You guys would get the biggest kick out of it omg please
These pieces have to be the essence of this band. There's not much of a tool song which is more "toolesque".
Maybe disgustipated.
Würgermeister H. Couldn’t agree more. Disgustipated is quite the hidden gem honestly 💎
For all the people saying they are tired of all the tool reactions on this channel i got 3 things for ya
1 this is their channel not yours
2 they just did a album reaction so they breaking thing from the channel
And 3 ITS FUCKING TOOL HOW DO YOU NOT LOVE THEM
Novembers Doom - Autumn Reflection
6 months over 370
Double-nailed it.
Opiate live-listen someday? You'll hear Maynard at his angriest and it's under 30 minutes.
Yes so much power
"Is he talking about himself or the other person?" answer; yes! It's about the relationship between his lower and higher being, and the ego trapped in the middle. Third Eye follows along the same theme, but at a different point in the spiritual journey.
I'm glad you mentioned Peterson, I have reservations regarding his political opinions, but he has done some good talks on the same Jungian ideas of the shadow self, and of descending the Abyss (the gap) and confronting the Beast, that inspire this song. Peterson even describes the relationship we have with our demons as being like toxic worldly relationships..
Reaction
Tool - vicarious
I've noticed ever since you two started listening to Tool you're spirituality has grown drastically God bless tool!!!!!!@!!
This song is clearly about jujitsu, think about it every line basically relates to rolling with someone, basically "trying to kill" them but at then afterwards resuming friendship (still love me). "Bang my head upon the faultline" = the little gap between mats. "slipping back into the gap again" = getting past someone's guard. "put me somewhere i dont wanna be" = opponent turning the tables on you and now you're on defensive. "minimize my movement anyway / i must persuade you another way" = basically the thought process during a match.
Essentially every line can relate to jujitsu if you look at it, also iirc Maynard practices jujitsu so yeah.
Interesting take on the song. It does make sense that way....
See people are saying to much TOOL..... there can never be too much Tool...they, musically and lyrically speaking are one of the greatest bands ever!!
Favorite Song. Not just tool, in general. Been waiting for you guys to get here, even though you listened to the salival version, that one doesnt have that grimy guitar in the middle of the instrumentals while Maynard is dropping the one liners to start it and then it just comes through full force. one of my favorite interludes that comes back hard with Maynards voice so clean in those high notes. 9 months now I dont know what to complain about, but am still happy. Finish the album and I will start pushing for undertow.
You guys - wonderful to watch. Rewinding over your reactions, remind me of how I used to utterly lose it back in the day, listening to this.
Please keep them coming - you guys are great!
I actually think this song may also be about sexual abuse.
Man, this song... #Relationshipgoals
Vin and Sori, all Tool all the time. Unofficial Tool reaction channel.
VoyagerAbove no kidding tool 24/7 lol if they like it more power to em. How about a full iron maiden album listen?
Bored of it now to be honest
They said they were gonna review the whole album. Do you have comprehension problems?
Peste Noire is nightcore for nazis change my mind doesnt mean we gotta like it numbnuts
It means that complaining about something that won't change is stupid though. They said they'd do the whole album. Don't like it? Go watch something you like and come back when it's done
The lyrics are wrong in the video y'all had.
"You didn't need to shit on me" is what it says
r3wturb0x / Is this song about child birth?
@@danielwade1978 what? how in the fuck? well i guess music is open to all interpretation
Ethan Peterson - Certain Lyrics “I saw the gap again today... You didn’t need to shit on me (women sometimes shit during childbirth). You minimize my movement anyway. Choke this infant here before me. You’re pushing and shoving me (pushing during child labor) .... “ At first I thought he was using the childbirth experience/mother and child relationship as a metaphor
Ethan Peterson - One of my favorites is when Maynard uses the inner workings of a coffee pot in The Pot: “ Rob the crave to snow the cradle then burn the evidence down “. “Eyeballs deep in muddy waters (under the influence of caffeine?).”
"Choke this infant here before me.
What is this but my reflection?
Who am i to judge or strike u down?"
I believe he is saying she is acting like an infant but perhaps he is as well.
I look at this similarly. Except I don't see a girl at all. I think he is talking about his own ego.
Maynard has a reputation of being an asshole (I don't necessarily agree), and this song may have been a form of self reflection. He's looking at himself in the mirror, and has nobody to blame but himself. Striking yourself down or judging yourself, will only put you into a deeper hole.
Look at the lyrics on the next verse:
"Rest your trigger on my finger
Bang my head upon the fault line
You better take care not to make me enter
'Cause if I do, we both may disappear"
I think "we" is his own physical self, and his ego.
He loves himself, but he didn't show it in his actions, and kept pushing himself to a low point. If you look at Maynard now vs then, he's a pretty respectful person. Worked on himself a lot. This is just my opinion, I can see both sides though.
I love watching first reactions to TooL songs. But once you heard your first TooL song and you we’re like oh snap this is shizznit. 😆 wasn’t it impossible not to hear the rest of that album
TesseracT - Exile
I know you guys and your viewers will love it.
I come for the tool reviews. Keep it up. Also I distinctly remember you listened to this song already
NEW TOOL IN APRIL!
(Unless Danny is wrong/joking)
April Fools they been saying that for the passed three years.
@@BittersweetDuality He thought that they were going in the studio in March, but they actually started two/three months later, hence why they didnt release it in fall. (They only release in fall/Spring, so that's why it's coming this spring).
@@heisenberg1898 yeah but they haven't had a new album recorded for three years they do now.
Didn't say what year....
Not April but August!!!!
Bury me in smoke please I've requested alot🙄
Second that!
Requesting isn't good enough, you need to pay them.
yeah you need to pay
Well I ain't gonna pay them for nothing
Lucifer Brahma you aren’t required to pay them. It gives you a higher chance of you join a patreon alliance but it’s not mandatory; Patience is though.
Yay! I know the breakdown of the lyrics is so important but I often think "they didn't mention the music!" The whole band is so amazing!
The beginning of this song, with the orchestral bee type sounds. Like a Hornet's nest being stirred up. Overlooked element.
The studio version of this song is vastly different than the Salival live versions. Almost like two completely different songs. The live version has a completely different beginning. Has tabla drums implemented and then slowly builds up to the studio version at the end.
Many songs on this record and Undertow (This song being one of them) are about the horrible sexual abuse Maynard endured as a child. He has talked about it many times in the past...
And opiate
Neil Periet, Rush drummer, was a big fan of Danys, what a huge compliment
Opiate
FYI.
The Album is pronounced, "Ah-ni-muh"
VICARIOUS
New tool will be great.... hope I live long enough to hear it
Check out puscifer the humbling river, Maynard's other band. Beautiful song
Danny Carey is everywhere, many of tool songs start with Danny doing the drums and the rest of the band follows him, the way he plays is called polyrithmic, he does 2 rythms or 3 rithms at the same time.
It was Funny watching you break this song down a second time.... I watched those two reactions back to back
Vin/Sori not sure if you will read this but I know how much Vin loves KoRn and Jonathan Davis loves Pink Floyd. They did an AMAZING rendition of Another Brick in the Wall Parts 1,2,3 and Goodbye Cruel World. They did a studio and live. I think it would be a perfect combo vid for you guys. Consider it.
Moonspell - Night Eternal
THE OFFSPRING - YOU'RE GONNA GO FAR KID
Bolt Thrower - The IVth Crusade
All in favour of an Old School Death Metal week say aye
k0bra 3eak AYE
Great song and always good to hear this track and anything from Aenima! Also, I am a fan of Sori and her choker! MORE TOOL!
She is beautiful😍 and tool again
Old school Tool...The only way to go. Allman Brothers-Soulshine
Sori, Orion has brought you a very beautiful glow today. Yeah when this started I remembered that you had done the Salival version before. Great review as usual and still looking forward to Aenima review which does reference Ron L Hubbard. Have a great day and I hope your return trip home was good.
I cant wait for the third eye review
Lost Keys - Rosetta Stoned would be very interesting. I love that song.
Anthrax - In My World, In the End, Indians, Inside Out and What Doesn't Die
Did you write "first time listen" because you *did* listen to it before? ;)
I think they recorded all these videos before the live session, and are uploading them now to keep us all entertained while they take a break
@@blahuhm6782 But they heard the Salival version before :P
10:25
ah, yea you're right, sorry nvm me... my new theory it they didn't write the title, it was someone else they have to help and they didn't know about the previous listen (but they should've)
First time listening to the *studio* version. It seems.
You guys should react to the band He is Legend! They are so underrated, but have truly been one of best rock bands for the last 15 years! I'd start with the song stranger danger
Vin and Sori have already listened to the live version of this from Salival..
I always hear "You still love me cause you didn't mean to shit on me".
Hey guys I love your shit, and this album review has been awesome. I just subscribed to your patreon account and I don't mind because your REM reviews were cool . But While Tool was cool I think an album re action / review of Pearl Jam's 3rd album "Vitalogy" Might just blow your minds
vicarious, Vicarious, VICARIOUS, VICARIOUS!! vicarious. Have you thought about Vicarious? Vicarious might be a good song to check out next. Something to consider might be Vicarious.
A song like Pushit, at least in my humble, seems to be a song someone might get into if there a devoted Tool fan. Unlike a lot of other Tools longer songs Pushit has many twists & turns. There's an awful lot there, traveling through space & all that. It's not an intro song, and although you guys have listened to a lot of Tool I believe a song like Pushit cannot be fully appreciated in the short run. Over time it might become your mantra. There's only way response when listening to Pushit for the first time..."whoa".
When are you gonna re-listen to Iron Maiden Fear Of The Dark-LIVE..?
Tool is so cool, I heard someone said Tool is like the Pink Floyd of our times
And now for something completely different, Hawkwind, Steppenwolf.
You should listen to "Prison Sex" by Tool It's a disturbingly sad song but a great one
Didn't they do this song but the salival version?
Btw the salival version is far superior IMO.
Disagree. This version is possibly Tool's best song.
Jinjer - Who Is Gonna Be The One (live)
I'm confused. You guys listened to the entire Aenima album last week but you're reviewing songs from it this week. The title says " first time listen".
This might come as a shocker...but recordings are things that happened in the past.
They take time to edit and clean up, render and upload. You might have seen the livestream and more then likely what’s making its way into these videos came from that live session. There’s a near 100% chance that these guys have rendered and uploaded their entire album review already at this point and have the episodes set to scheduled release day by day. Don’t get so tied up in the chronology of your personal experience
@@ReignSurvives the live stream was in their BED you dipshit, why don't YOU check it before getting out of control angry at internet comments you think are wrong? ruclips.net/video/TEJgZ7lU3d0/видео.html
its an entirely different setting than the one in these reviews, so the question here is 100% LEGIT.
ktopaz “our of control angry” lol. Look in the mirror buddy
@@ReignSurvives I'm not your buddy, Guy! ;)
@@ktopaz chill buddy
Yall didnt do Ions or Third Eye by Tool??
Vin doing a decent job at hiding his annoyance for the named gadgets in this one. 😉
Hey awesome. My fav tool song...It's said like Ah Ni Ma (aenima). It means both a male can have female counterparts & vice versa. Keep the vids coming
GWAR!!!
It’s so much angrier and faster than the salival version... the studio is way better.
Crowded House, Dont Dream Its Over!! You need to do it . Very important song that musicians like Mic Fleetwood and Dave Mustaine have spoke about and love. Crowded House Dont Dream Its Over!!
Danny, master of polyrhythms
Okay that's a lie. Tomas Haake, master of polyrhythms
Did you skip Jimmy?
They did it before
I think you guys will really like "Stars Are Projectors" by Modest Mouse.
Vin and Sori. I wouldn’t be so quick to just plug this song into a man/woman relationship. Think of a child being molested and/or abused by an adult and listen to the song again.
By the way, there are hidden tracks during the creepy/melodic part. In the beginning you can hear “you make me do it” and toward the end you can here “in the end, we’ll be alright”.
One last thing, some of the lyrics were wrong.
The best song ever.
...
GOJIRAAAAAAAAAA - OF BLOOD AND SALT
I don’t know what this song is about, I didn’t write it. But I love it.
You guys need to listen to Tool - Pushit (Salival) Live version. Amazing
They already did.
This is one of the most literal songs maynard has written. This is exactly what it is. Hes unhappy w his relationship and theyve just had a baby. What do i do?
I think 'My God' by Jethro Tull and 'Stray Cat Blues' by the Rolling Stones would give you good discussions afterwards.
How is it the first listen? You've heard it twice already. This is the third time this song is on your channel.
I know lol i feel like im taking crazy pills. How can you be a die hard and have never gotten to these songs yet? Who doesn't binge these when theyre discovering them? So what, are we just watching people listen to songs we like?
Now I want to watch their commentary back to back on the videos
As someone told me in the comment session in another video, they apparently recorded a few reaction videos to aenima songs "before" and recorded the live listening session "afterwards"...but they uploaded the latter before the others... But i might be wrong.. (or rather that person might be wrong). And yes of course they did the reaction video to the Salival version last year..
10:25
@@briancarroll6803 yeah they acknowledge having listened to "pushit salival (live) version", we already knew that, duh.
Best song on the album
His lyrics go MUCH deeper than that. There's a ton of mathematics and theories that go into his writing. Check out 46&2 for example. This is a good explanation for the song. ruclips.net/video/OufK0647p1U/видео.html
Danny Carey has odd time signatures, like superman behind the kit.
Polyrhythms!! Signature Danny Carey.
Hello Guys! Here we go again ! Time for my daily nagging ;-) to wish that you do something completely different. It would be interesting if you widen your views to do something so really stand out? In Norway there is a singer who is referred to as nature, fairy, haunting or angel. There are a few artists who are in the same spirit but this is a class of its own. Her whole being is like an emotional bomb. Her name is Aurora. This song Murder song 5,4,3,2,1 is not her most beautiful but perhaps the most interesting to discuss. I really hope you dare to take this song. :-) AURORA - Murder Song (5, 4, 3, 2, 1) [Live at Nidarosdomen]
my first time hearing Pushit, ironically, was the Salival live "reimagining" of it. It literally blew me away and still does whenever I listen to it. compared to it, this one is garbage. it's still good, don't get me wrong, but omg that live version is mindblowing
Second Time listen. Do you remember you listened to the whole Aenima album? ok you forgot, but you did.
Lol what is going on
As someone told me in the comment session in another video, they apparently recorded a few reaction videos to aenima songs "before" and recorded the live listening session "afterwards"...but they uploaded the latter before the others...
10:25
@@briancarroll6803 Dude they said they heard Pushit Salival (live album) version.. But goddamn it, they released the Full Aenima reaction, and after a few days reaction to Pushit, for the first time, I mean come on, shouldn't they release their videos chronologically? Because this is confusing.
@@lopolik I see now what you're saying. There's dissonance between the record dates and what they wanted to accomplish in the way of production and presentation. It's like noticing a glass is filled (or emptied) to different levels across camera cuts haha..
If I understand correctly, they record these reactions first, so they'll be genuine. Then, record the full album listen, usually with a live chat, to release as a precursor and to this reaction "series".
What's funny is you and I have put this much energy into discussing the video title.. Obviously my work day has me starved for entertainment today haha.
Good catch by the way
Yeah, Misfortune Cookies would be nice : D
Cool drum mix in this one and yeah Vin, that bass is nasty! Do check the bass tone on Atheist's album Elements, with Frank Zappa's sound engineer.
Sori, when you headbang, your hair's supposed to move up and down too : D : D
Youre talking about syncopations (2 things in different times at once). Polyrhythms are rhythms that dont sound like the time theyre actually in kinda. Meshuggah songs are mostly all 4/4 for example but they never sound like it, thats polyrhythm
The Piper Never Dies - Edguy
Pink Floyd - The Wall
Jimmy should have been next in the tracklist. Pushit comes after Jimmy.
3 inches of blood- Deadly Sinners
Architects - Gone With The Wind, about the struggle to manage terminal cancer.
Love your channel
Your insights are great 👍👍👍
You already have done Halloween by Helloween and that was a great reaction and topic, when you both get a chance could you check out the second song in the Trilogy, keeper of the 7 keys? It continues the fight between good and evil. Here is the link to the song on youtube. ruclips.net/video/ZUzpf3mMsxA/видео.html Enjoy the rest of your week and thank you both for being there and doing what you are doing.
She didn't need to shit on me
What about JIMMY?
Wondering why Peter Steele gets vilified with toxic masculinity yet the same message comes thru in “claw your fucking throat away” and..... is it just because Peter was less eloquent? 😇