Maple Vs Roasted Maple - Guitar Tone Comparison!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 дек 2024

Комментарии • 97

  • @furaishots
    @furaishots 6 лет назад +9

    Roasted maple = Rosewood --> More air and high harmonics freq. specialy after 3k and 4k Hz. Maple is more hot in the mids and a little more bassy, Thats why we dont see mahoganys Gibson Lp with all maple necks and thats why we see ash bodies with maple necks and fingerboards. People confuse mids and the high mids with the trebles bite and high freq. Mids are about 250,500 - 2k, meanwhile the edge and high frequencies are in 3,4K to 10, where is the Air. The more hardness has a material, the more high freq. are reflected, less dampened by the material, which make it more rich and wide, open. A lot people prefer maple boards for single coils, and rosewwod for humbuckers, specially if they are direct mounted.

  • @cocochops6492
    @cocochops6492 5 лет назад +12

    1:20 he's using the Bridge pickup on the regular maple, Neck pickup on Roasted maple

    • @leftymadrid
      @leftymadrid 5 лет назад

      Yeah I noticed that too...

  • @SattickDas2001
    @SattickDas2001 Год назад +2

    The roasted sounds somewhat more sharper, while the normal maple has a more rounder "brown" tone.

  • @Clayphish
    @Clayphish 5 лет назад +20

    Pretty bad comparison honestly. Not only is the volume quieter during the first roasted maple neck samples, on the first distorted clips the guitar is on different pick ups settings.

    • @hamercalif
      @hamercalif 5 лет назад

      Do you really think that one shift to the bridge p/up position during distorted clip spoiled you the whole picture to compare tonal characteristics of the necks? And because of those minor elements as volume and pickup switch, you name the comparison Pretty bad? Come on.....

    • @buckeyeburl0162
      @buckeyeburl0162 4 года назад +1

      @@hamercalif well...

    • @ЕжиКкоторыйлюбитбенды
      @ЕжиКкоторыйлюбитбенды 3 года назад

      @@hamercalif Pickup setting is more valuable only look at pickup switch-naming on Gibson-style guitars

  • @stas-683
    @stas-683 3 года назад

    Очуметь разница! Спасибо, что заморочились с перестановкой грифов🙏🙏🙏

  • @daw162
    @daw162 6 лет назад +1

    like the sound of the unroasted neck better, but it's not something EQ can't fix and no guarantee that it isn't the wood itself differing between the two necks vs. the roasting vs. not roasting.

  • @vicibanzio
    @vicibanzio 2 года назад

    what is the song on *02:05* ???

  • @sallen6949
    @sallen6949 7 лет назад +1

    I was looking for a video like this! Well done, my friend. While the traditional natural maple is warmer, I love the added presence and articulation of the roasted maple. Especially when you kick in the dirt...the roasted maple had a sparky quality that's pretty happening.

  • @timperry2375
    @timperry2375 Месяц назад +1

    2:04 vs 2:21

  • @Feodorchik
    @Feodorchik 4 года назад

    Дмитрий спасибо)
    а вам какой вариант по душе?

  • @STEALMAN83
    @STEALMAN83 3 года назад +1

    I notice you keep switching pickups throughout the video, so no wonder things sound so different

  • @andrewharacidi
    @andrewharacidi 4 года назад

    На перегрузе - просто звук двух разных звукоснимателей. Что сравниваем-то?)

  • @marcblum5348
    @marcblum5348 6 лет назад +1

    Overdriven it makes a bigger difference. That's interesting. Would love to hear an in-the-mix comparison.

    • @TheEchelon
      @TheEchelon 5 лет назад

      Because he used different pickups with the overdriven parts...

  • @phillipwelcker4927
    @phillipwelcker4927 7 лет назад

    Nice work, great comparison.

  • @TheJeffcurran
    @TheJeffcurran 7 лет назад

    Cerwin-Vega in the background. I had a pair those for many years. Ran them until the surrounds rotted. Great speakers.

  • @Makhach
    @Makhach 6 лет назад +1

    The comparison is not 100% fair. Reverb/delay pedals matter. Also, the mic position matters.

  • @tapilaha
    @tapilaha 6 лет назад

    what wood is the body made of? mahogany with maple on top?

  • @pleximanic
    @pleximanic 7 лет назад

    Great Comparison!

  • @Dogsrule777
    @Dogsrule777 4 года назад +3

    Roasted all the way! 🎧🏆

  • @CodyWolfeVevo
    @CodyWolfeVevo 5 лет назад

    Funny didn't even see the diezel sitting there, but I heard it right away and knew it was a diezel. Great freaking amps

  • @rbenm
    @rbenm 6 лет назад +3

    I liked the roasted maple better, lookes great too on that body

  • @nandoholgado3050
    @nandoholgado3050 7 лет назад +2

    The roasted one has much more definition, the not roasted maybe could sound warmer here, but that is an EQ issue. After the roast procces the wood is not normal wood anymore, so, like any different wood, needs different EQ.

  • @deadinside0586
    @deadinside0586 7 лет назад

    Beautiful tone! What's the pickups?

    • @dmitry_andrianov
      @dmitry_andrianov  7 лет назад +1

      Bridge - Lindy Fralin High outputs humb,Neck - ft-pickups.ru/content/guitar/full/12/

    • @ЕжиКкоторыйлюбитбенды
      @ЕжиКкоторыйлюбитбенды 3 года назад

      @@dmitry_andrianov Здравствуйте, а что лучше для наших многоэтажек в плане стабильности, печёный, если разница в цене гитар не критичная?

    • @dmitry_andrianov
      @dmitry_andrianov  3 года назад

      @@ЕжиКкоторыйлюбитбенды стабильность грифа от многих факторов зависит,так что не вижу смысла гоняться за печеным

    • @ЕжиКкоторыйлюбитбенды
      @ЕжиКкоторыйлюбитбенды 3 года назад

      @@dmitry_andrianov понятно, спасибо!

  • @donarmando916
    @donarmando916 5 лет назад

    I love the roasted maple and there is a tone difference, but the difference is more noticable in clean or crunch mode.

  • @shanebratton8339
    @shanebratton8339 7 лет назад +4

    Is that the wiki leaks guy?

    • @IronLordFitness
      @IronLordFitness 6 лет назад

      No he's not Julian Assange XD But I had the same thought haha

    • @hamercalif
      @hamercalif 5 лет назад

      @@IronLordFitness *-)))))))))))))) I'll tell you true - he is!

  • @arielista
    @arielista 6 лет назад +13

    I thought I would like roasted better but no, regular maple for me.

    • @F-MK96
      @F-MK96 5 лет назад

      same but i love the look of roasted maple :D

    • @LJN71
      @LJN71 5 лет назад

      Ariel Lopez It doesn’t seem to have any noticeable impact on sound, but for me who lives in a climate where humidity changes greatly between summer and winter the promised increased stability does appeal.

  • @helixworld
    @helixworld 8 лет назад +9

    The standard pale maple has warmer tone. I like it better in this demo, as your guitar is bright enough already. Thanks very much for showing this.

    • @gscgold
      @gscgold 7 лет назад

      only because the pickups are different , wood type has nothing to do with it.

    • @ValentinTeodorTamas
      @ValentinTeodorTamas 7 лет назад +1

      gscgold The neck is aftermarket. Same exact electronics.

    • @dynamicdissonance4016
      @dynamicdissonance4016 7 лет назад +5

      actually the roasted maple sounds way more smooth and less bright than the normal maple.

    • @helixworld
      @helixworld 7 лет назад +2

      A lot of guitarists who hear a tone with boosted mids will say its brighter. To me they are different things, and the roasted neck has more top end brightness.

  • @terryharris6851
    @terryharris6851 6 лет назад

    I hope you used new strings on each demo...

  • @pfalso4
    @pfalso4 6 лет назад

    Graph tech nut too though

  • @TruthSurge
    @TruthSurge 6 лет назад +6

    but... but.... wood doesn't matter!!! wahhhhhhh! I'm going to tell my daddy on YOU!
    Well, woods matter. everything matters. I liked both. That more focused sound of the roasted can work. The warmer tone can also work. Just goes to prove that whatever the strings vibrate UPON, can audibly affect the tone. thx.

    • @JohnnyTsak316
      @JohnnyTsak316 6 лет назад

      I liked the non roasted but hety - it;s ok if you or anyone likes the roasted more it's a prsonal taste thing however exactly everything eaffects the tone on the instrument wood included ha ha ha

    • @sebbo1496
      @sebbo1496 5 лет назад

      @Graham Rathbone
      yea man.
      a real test would be taking the same neck and roast it and compare before and after. and the rule of thumb should be, imho, if that's as far as you have to go, it doesn't matter. i think making sure bridge and nut let the strings vibrate without dampening is the most important. because then you can probably get more frequencies to start with. anything else is pickups or tone knob and ofc amp.
      ofc, imho, the neck and the wood defo matter when it comes to different species and stuff. but only one of many factors.

  • @damianrjames
    @damianrjames 6 лет назад

    zdorovo! thnx!!

  • @frantisca
    @frantisca 6 лет назад +2

    Roasted= more nasal and low mids. Question of taste and if you need more stability due to climate issues... Personnally, I like Mahogany+Rosewood. To each his own ;-)

  • @mymixture965
    @mymixture965 6 лет назад +1

    So wood does not matter, show this the anti tone wood people. I like the regular maple better.

  • @shysingh
    @shysingh 6 лет назад +2

    Standard Maple sound BIGGER

  • @karjafru9389
    @karjafru9389 6 лет назад

    Doesn't make sense when you're compairing them using different pickups

    • @daw162
      @daw162 6 лет назад +1

      Look closely at the figure on the guitar. It is the same body and electronics.
      There is no guarantee even that the next roasted maple neck might not be brighter than the unroasted neck, though - two different pieces of wood may have bigger differences themselves than anything that roasting does (and roasting does actually change the wood if done at a high enough temperature - it's been used in building materials - "high temperature drying" for decades to make up for the decline in lumber quality.

  • @ko1om8o
    @ko1om8o 8 лет назад

    Жареный клен классно звучит

  • @donarmando916
    @donarmando916 7 лет назад

    There is really a hearable difference between the two. In my opinion the roasted neck has some tones that are coming out really much nicer and warmer than the standard neck but it's not across the board. The neck is just part of the overall sound. Body, pickups and the amp also matters.

  • @joeabstractjoe
    @joeabstractjoe 5 лет назад

    🎵👍🎵

  • @sigurdfyllingkarstad2694
    @sigurdfyllingkarstad2694 6 лет назад +3

    The roasted one had a mid boost in it. I liked the roasted one the most :)

  • @niknek7013
    @niknek7013 8 лет назад

    Чистый клён звучит ярче, "жареный" скрадывает звук, ощущение приглушённости.

  • @KwonCW84
    @KwonCW84 7 лет назад +2

    The roasted maple has more treble than the plain one.

  • @jannatinkarlen8702
    @jannatinkarlen8702 4 года назад +2

    roasted maple seems to sound more brittle

  • @RomaHere
    @RomaHere 8 лет назад

    Жареный на перегрузе вкуснее, чем сырой)

  • @liquidSpin
    @liquidSpin 6 лет назад

    Sorry, but I can't trust this comparison. The video was shot using 2 cameras which can definitely alter the sound a bit. If the guitars are both exactly the same except for the baked and none baked wood and running through the same amp then at least shoot the video with one camera.

    • @alexdattel2757
      @alexdattel2757 6 лет назад

      He most likely doesn't even use camera sound.

  • @KOTinROLL
    @KOTinROLL 8 лет назад

    По мне так, тот кого пожарили в печке , не много мягче звучит.

  • @huss03
    @huss03 6 лет назад +5

    Roasted better. More serious and grown up tone. More authentic.There's more "air" around the sound, and it's more musical and compelling in the way it carries the chord progressions.

    • @zonakmahanta
      @zonakmahanta 6 лет назад

      Huxxy yes....more air around the sound...totally makes sense...

    • @fretbuzz59
      @fretbuzz59 5 лет назад +1

      Man, that's some serious marketing mumbo-jumbo.

    • @sebbo1496
      @sebbo1496 5 лет назад

      anyone else hear some strawberry with a like an earthy almost mossy touch in there?
      for real though...
      sounds different but not more frequencies on one or something. nothing you can't reproduce with the tone knob...so...who cares...

  • @johnsimms3957
    @johnsimms3957 7 лет назад +8

    The plain maple sounds better.

    • @sergeibarbul8208
      @sergeibarbul8208 Год назад +1

      That's right, it sounds better, but only for you.

  • @godsgifttotheinternet4538
    @godsgifttotheinternet4538 6 лет назад +3

    I think I'm supposed to pretend that they sound different right?

    • @rollipollirock
      @rollipollirock 6 лет назад +1

      God's Gift To the Internet listeners must have bad ears here on RUclips

  • @zextremist
    @zextremist 8 лет назад

    Первый жирней звучит, второй ярче, но суше (ха-ха). Правильней было бы первый гриф поджарить и сравнить :)

  • @fursov01
    @fursov01 7 лет назад +1

    У roasted по гармоникам беднее. Очень плоский звук! Не понравился... Я за обычный!

  • @Daantjer
    @Daantjer 6 лет назад +3

    Gotta love how people swear the wood makes a difference...
    It absolutely does on acoustic guitars but it absolutely doesn't on electric guitars. The small differences you're all hearing are probably the pickups, 2 guitars, pickups gonna be a little different.
    Not to mention you're judging the sounds coming out of an AMP, picked up by the MIC of a CAMERA, and then coming out of your SPEAKERS.
    The regular maple could sound warmer to you in this one, grab 2 other electric guitars and it could be the other way around.

    • @rollipollirock
      @rollipollirock 6 лет назад +1

      MarryJewana pickups for the most part are machine wound, this guy is even using the same tuners. Cheers ... go tell Brian May that neck wood used does not matter.

    • @Daantjer
      @Daantjer 6 лет назад

      @@rollipollirock machine wound and the exact same amount of winds doesnt mean there are no differences in the pickups. You also know that tuners don't matter either right?

    • @markturton7805
      @markturton7805 6 лет назад +1

      Are you aware your points are totally moot. He's using the same guitar, same tuners, same amp, same mic, same recording software under the same conditions and it's all coming out of YOUR speakers comparatively so the only variables here are the necks and your ears. To my ears the roasted maple out of the two necks has a darker tone but that's not to say another roasted maple neck couldn't sound brighter.

    • @Daantjer
      @Daantjer 6 лет назад

      @@markturton7805 "To my ears the roasted maple out of the two necks has a darker tone but that's not to say another roasted maple neck couldn't sound brighter."
      The difference is so small to begin with that it could be literally anything or a combination of things.
      You could also say that the pickups on one sound brighter than the other, that the pickups might be slightly closer to the strings on one than the other, that the neck is screwed to the body a little tighter on one than the other, which makes for better contact to the body. Needlesly to say that he's human and can't play exactly the same twice.
      You literally go to yourself "if I have to hear any difference it would be that ....blablabla *start fooling yourself*

    • @TheApsodist
      @TheApsodist 2 года назад +1

      @@Daantjer the difference is small to some people and large to other people. People have different ears. Those who can hear know what they are hearing.

  • @СергейЕршов-ю7э
    @СергейЕршов-ю7э 8 лет назад

    жареный круче

  • @antonnotna5919
    @antonnotna5919 5 лет назад

    Unroasted

  • @fredcolameo3095
    @fredcolameo3095 5 лет назад

    Very poor comparison. Less Vodka is announced.....so you would not forget technical specs before 5 minutes....or even which pick up position...LOL

  • @sharonlee4773
    @sharonlee4773 Год назад

    I couldn't hear the difference!

  • @Patbwoy
    @Patbwoy 5 лет назад +1

    I'm getting tired of these wood comparison, that don't prove ANYTHING, because EVERY piece of wood will sound different.

    • @daemon4321
      @daemon4321 4 года назад

      It's a shit, all of it.
      Acrylic guitars sound very WOOODY. Steve Vai prove it.
      And "That don't prove anything", because we need to play on a guitar. MORE. Not a comparising wood, maple tops, guitar color or something. This proves all.

  • @SvyatoSky
    @SvyatoSky 7 лет назад +1

    хммм интересно даже, прожаренный клен звучит по чище и по стекляннее обычного.

  • @itprintsco
    @itprintsco 8 лет назад

    жареный вообще бедно как-то звучит!

  • @evgenykarkan6939
    @evgenykarkan6939 8 лет назад +1

    Жаренный не очень богато звучит

  • @MrTorriann
    @MrTorriann 7 лет назад

    Народ, вы тут так обсуждаете и не стыдно. Это две разные гитары, если ставить этот гриф на одно и то же, ничего (100% доказано) ничего не изменится.

  • @nsc217
    @nsc217 4 года назад

    The roasted maple here sounds brighter and overall shittier